Glad i created controversy over this... even 2 years after I posted that comment... yes i know how hard it is to be an actor/actress... I've done it before... the memorizing of the lines... the singing... the long dawn-out rehearsals... pain in the butt but worth it at the end.... and for all that told me to "shut the fuck up" i did say nice things... i just expanded on the negatives... get used to it... its what critics do and what the real world is like... Have a nice life... btw nice job guy.
and also, i have the script of it, as i am playing it, and the lyrics are 'if i were a rich man, daidle, deedle, daidle, digguh, digguh, deedle, daidle dum' it was only 'yubby dibby dibby dibby dibby dum' with topols version. i dont know if you have actually seen how many differences there are in the show with the film. lay off him please
i for one think you did a fantastic job. i don't understand y this guy thinks you should be the exact replica of topol. thats not what you do with the part, or any part. u make it your own, and this is what you did, and very well. i am playin tevye is july of this year, and i'm tryin 2 make it not like topol, i dont want people to see topol on stage, but i want them 2 see me. well done anyway
I'm sorry, but I must say something. Cshoes, have you ever played Tevye in a show? I am currently playing the role, without a week to go before we open. And honestly, it is one of the hardest roles in broadway for a male. So before you criticize, realize that its up to the actor to do whatever they want to bring out the character.
1st of all...is not if i were a rich man idle didle deedle didle dum...it is if i were a rich man yubby dibby dibby dubby dibby dum...plz get that right! that bugged the crap out of me...2nd of all tevye in the film was alot less ya know...dramatic?
he acted like what he was oh so terrible...
but tevye in the film was acting like...
i dunno that if he was rich that it would alot better..but no he looked at how poor he was instead..
3rd of all he couldnt the stomping and shaking his arms right either he was waving them like a child..ur supposed to keep ur hands in 1 place... and just shake ur arms..and he couldnt keep a beat he was off like 1 beat...but his accent was great!
and singing was awesome 2! besides the negative above..i think he did an awesome job!!!!
@cshoes277 It would be best for you (or good for you) to get a group together and do your own version of 'Fiddler' and you be the director. Then you can have your very own ideas on stage and not be disgruntled.
1st of all, if you read the score, it does say: "idle didle deedle didle dum" or something similar, "dibby dibby dubby dibby dum" is just the film version.
2nd of all, the guy who originated tevye on broadway is none other than zero mostel, who would usually play for laughs, whearas topol's interpretation is more toned down, so there you go!
He's one of the best renditions of Tevye I have ever seen! *and I've seen alot of Fiddler on the roof* I agree with chengloki,he deserves to be on Broadway! This is by far the best High school plays ever,and many high school plays are *ugh* 5 stars and 5 Stars for the guy playing Tevye!
he's one of the best i've seen. it's true that he wasn't very great in some places, but it's a high school play and it's a hard character. in the context, it was amazingg. :]
gonna have to agree with RamonaSolares on this one. truejudgement was absoloutely shite. not saying this version is PERFECT, but it does beat truejudgement's performance hands down.
Ha I liked your little irish slips during the opening monologue! 'Not really complaining' and 'but it's no great honor either' were REALLY Irish. It was good, but seemed a little forced physically. But don't let that get you down. You did well, and its such a hard character!
Here we go. TrueJudgment is being a hater again, just because his version of Tevye sucked. This Tevye was excellent and TrueJudgment is eaten up with jealousy.
Yah... bad arms...I was tevye a little while ago. But you got a great voice pretty good accent but you lost it a couple of times. and the "choreographed stuff" seemed forced and like you were telling yourself what to do. Other than that I commend you for a great performance of a VERY difficult character. GREAT job!
however some things were a little too much, i mean he was over the top as it is, and that was good, but some things were too much here. and i bet i could give you a run for your money on the arm motions. i thought you werent even gonna do it and i was disappointed until i saw the end.
not bad up until about 3:08, then you/he were/was off-key from then on pretty much. you did however have a better than accent than I had (having played Tevye myself), but our school didn't really work on the accents. you were also truer to the movie. i'll give you that.
Some things i thought were over done around and after 3:30 but don't worry it was so fun to watch it didn't matter! Excelent singing ability, though if I'd have to critique it if you were doing it for an audition song, I'd say keep to the musicality of the piece, you were doing fine up until you started changing rests and notes at certain places. I did that for South Pacific and ended up regreting the improv later >.<
Well done
JEMCO2008 1 year ago
ehh not good. he was always behind the piano, would studder and not begin phrases well, and very pitchy
FITZFACTOR 1 year ago
Glad i created controversy over this... even 2 years after I posted that comment... yes i know how hard it is to be an actor/actress... I've done it before... the memorizing of the lines... the singing... the long dawn-out rehearsals... pain in the butt but worth it at the end.... and for all that told me to "shut the fuck up" i did say nice things... i just expanded on the negatives... get used to it... its what critics do and what the real world is like... Have a nice life... btw nice job guy.
cshoes277 1 year ago
He did a fantastic job!! he was a perfect tevye! :]
sowa6 1 year ago
fuck the diddle deedles. he does a great job of playing teyve. he sounds like a russian jew from a shtel
Lotrfan99 2 years ago
Well I think this guy does a GREAT job! Especially for a high schooler!
ultimatekokiri 2 years ago
Great Tevy impression. Especially from a High Schooler.
OMalleysAnatomy26 3 years ago 3
Yea. But the beginning was just all wrong.
Saru786 3 years ago
and also, i have the script of it, as i am playing it, and the lyrics are 'if i were a rich man, daidle, deedle, daidle, digguh, digguh, deedle, daidle dum' it was only 'yubby dibby dibby dibby dibby dum' with topols version. i dont know if you have actually seen how many differences there are in the show with the film. lay off him please
Danny064 3 years ago
i for one think you did a fantastic job. i don't understand y this guy thinks you should be the exact replica of topol. thats not what you do with the part, or any part. u make it your own, and this is what you did, and very well. i am playin tevye is july of this year, and i'm tryin 2 make it not like topol, i dont want people to see topol on stage, but i want them 2 see me. well done anyway
Danny064 3 years ago
this has been the best "IF I Were a Rich Man" GREAT JOB:)
jpchapdelaine99 3 years ago
How do the hell do you make those noises you have so much guts u rule
Buzaglod 3 years ago 2
I'm sorry, but I must say something. Cshoes, have you ever played Tevye in a show? I am currently playing the role, without a week to go before we open. And honestly, it is one of the hardest roles in broadway for a male. So before you criticize, realize that its up to the actor to do whatever they want to bring out the character.
Outlaw45329 3 years ago 2
Exact same position
Buzaglod 3 years ago
I am very sorry for all of this critisam...
1st of all...is not if i were a rich man idle didle deedle didle dum...it is if i were a rich man yubby dibby dibby dubby dibby dum...plz get that right! that bugged the crap out of me...2nd of all tevye in the film was alot less ya know...dramatic?
he acted like what he was oh so terrible...
but tevye in the film was acting like...
i dunno that if he was rich that it would alot better..but no he looked at how poor he was instead..
cshoes277 4 years ago
3rd of all he couldnt the stomping and shaking his arms right either he was waving them like a child..ur supposed to keep ur hands in 1 place... and just shake ur arms..and he couldnt keep a beat he was off like 1 beat...but his accent was great!
and singing was awesome 2! besides the negative above..i think he did an awesome job!!!!
cshoes277 4 years ago
can you shut the fuck up
Buzaglod 4 years ago 3
@cshoes277 It would be best for you (or good for you) to get a group together and do your own version of 'Fiddler' and you be the director. Then you can have your very own ideas on stage and not be disgruntled.
doug18020 1 year ago
1st of all, if you read the score, it does say: "idle didle deedle didle dum" or something similar, "dibby dibby dubby dibby dum" is just the film version.
2nd of all, the guy who originated tevye on broadway is none other than zero mostel, who would usually play for laughs, whearas topol's interpretation is more toned down, so there you go!
countfudgekula 4 years ago
wow this guy sounds good
iLuvMovies16 4 years ago
He's one of the best renditions of Tevye I have ever seen! *and I've seen alot of Fiddler on the roof* I agree with chengloki,he deserves to be on Broadway! This is by far the best High school plays ever,and many high school plays are *ugh* 5 stars and 5 Stars for the guy playing Tevye!
anadentone 4 years ago
High school? This ACTOR belongs on Broadway!! Now. =Stefan=
chengloki 4 years ago 3
My highschool is putting on this play on Friday November 16 2007 ill put on the clips tell me how you guys like it
moviemake123 4 years ago
what is with the echo?
KingOystar 4 years ago
he's one of the best i've seen. it's true that he wasn't very great in some places, but it's a high school play and it's a hard character. in the context, it was amazingg. :]
lisaaxox 4 years ago
This version is amazing! It is such a hard character and he did a excellent job!
theatrecrazy07 4 years ago
gonna have to agree with RamonaSolares on this one. truejudgement was absoloutely shite. not saying this version is PERFECT, but it does beat truejudgement's performance hands down.
countfudgekula 4 years ago
omg! my school just started to do this play and I am what ever the girls name is! the eldest daughter!
((I just got my line thing today so I forgot, I will go look later))
MileyMusic33 4 years ago
the choreography is utter shit
daniecolange 4 years ago
Everything descends into complete shit after 3:11
poor.
Frigenam 4 years ago
Ha I liked your little irish slips during the opening monologue! 'Not really complaining' and 'but it's no great honor either' were REALLY Irish. It was good, but seemed a little forced physically. But don't let that get you down. You did well, and its such a hard character!
DirtyRottenScoundrel 4 years ago
There is good timing between the music and his lines. :]
samrarhuasa 4 years ago
And FYI, TrueJudgment, here's a newsflash: Tevye is SUPPOSED to be "over the top"!! Have you seen the movie?!?!
RamonaSolares 4 years ago
Here we go. TrueJudgment is being a hater again, just because his version of Tevye sucked. This Tevye was excellent and TrueJudgment is eaten up with jealousy.
RamonaSolares 4 years ago
good show my friends dad is on the broadway good job though!
kleno 4 years ago
haha my 7/8th grade clas is doin this play....it rocks!!!! im lazar wolf!!!
xamus123 4 years ago
That was absolutely amazing!
nicoleLOVESrent 4 years ago
Yah... bad arms...I was tevye a little while ago. But you got a great voice pretty good accent but you lost it a couple of times. and the "choreographed stuff" seemed forced and like you were telling yourself what to do. Other than that I commend you for a great performance of a VERY difficult character. GREAT job!
dagr13 4 years ago
however some things were a little too much, i mean he was over the top as it is, and that was good, but some things were too much here. and i bet i could give you a run for your money on the arm motions. i thought you werent even gonna do it and i was disappointed until i saw the end.
TrueJudgment 4 years ago
not bad up until about 3:08, then you/he were/was off-key from then on pretty much. you did however have a better than accent than I had (having played Tevye myself), but our school didn't really work on the accents. you were also truer to the movie. i'll give you that.
TrueJudgment 4 years ago
Some things i thought were over done around and after 3:30 but don't worry it was so fun to watch it didn't matter! Excelent singing ability, though if I'd have to critique it if you were doing it for an audition song, I'd say keep to the musicality of the piece, you were doing fine up until you started changing rests and notes at certain places. I did that for South Pacific and ended up regreting the improv later >.<
2snipe1 4 years ago
it was alright until the part that required any singing skill. then it was horrible.
sonofashrub 4 years ago
Excellent job. Good voice. Not just like the movie though. Topol was brilliant :D
ShawDAMAN 4 years ago
good voice
interesting interpretation tevye
rigid of blocking-lack of fluidity
somethings too forced
skynyrd331 4 years ago
this guy sounds exactly like the guy from the movie.
AMAZING.
malcunes 4 years ago
Topol. ya mean Topol!
countfudgekula 4 years ago
Not brilliant singing ability, but perfect acting. He played it wonderfully.
darthzach 4 years ago
WOW THAT WAS GREAT! :D Best Tevye impression ever!
shoppingchickk 5 years ago
I love the Tevye Dance. I love the twist you (or he) brang to it.
darthzach 5 years ago
dude! we did this play at my skewl!! it was awesome!!!this one was really good!!
angelofevil14 5 years ago
We watched this at school once, the rest of the day everyone was impersonating Tevye in this song!! Especially the hyper kids!! XD
pengukodmo8 5 years ago
Wow, im very ipressed.. just like the real thing
dashvault 5 years ago
Excellent performance! He sounded just like the real Tevye! He should move on to real movies, he has the talent! L'Chaim!
zSTiLLFLYz 5 years ago
Excellent singing and accent. More of that little dance we all love would make it more visually interesting.
lieberlady59 5 years ago
That is one of the best Tevye impressions
bohica31812 5 years ago
haha hilarious.
i was wondering when he was going to do his little "dance"
almost thought he wasn;t going to do it til the end
GOOD JOB!
pohaikealoha 5 years ago