I saw NIN on the Downward Spiral tour in 1994, and was treated to an AMAZING show. It even had one of those moments where Trent Reznor flipped out and started beating the equipment with instruments. His dog had died that day.
just saw devin townsend play a small venue it sounded so bad all I was thinking about was how its possible to make a small venue sound good and make your epic music come across the exact way its supposed to. All I was thinking about was this. Thanks so much for putting this on the internet. NIN has the greatest fanbase of any artist.
No matter how old Trent got, or how far removed he was from his early life as an addict, this eye of the storm part of Mr. Self Destruct, when its live it always seems to take him back to a certain place.
This song has such dynamic energy whether its blowing your ear drums or leaving you in a beat-less limbo, its like a black hole.
HOW CAN YOU FUCKING STAND THERE WITH YOUR FUCKING PHONE IN THE AIR?? ARE THOSE FUCKING FAGGOTS EVEN LISTENING TO THE FUCKING MUSIC???? Holy fucking shit that pisses me off sooooo fucking much...
the banging sound in the beginning is from a sci-fi movie from the 80's set in a future dis-topia where in all people are grown and forced to take sedatives in order to maintain productivity and control, policed by MACHINES. underground.
Great performance of an awesome song. This is a quality recording and I really appreciate all of the work that went into putting this together. Though, I still can't help but feel a little depressed knowing that there really aren't any live recordings of this song that sound much better than this :(
Wow amazing this sounds so close to the 90's NIN live!! Trent still got it! I hope Trent changes his mind about quit touring. And I hope he starts touring in a couple of years. And I hope in the next NIN record (if possible) Trent brings the this 90's Industrial metal sound back because it beats the drum and bass electronica new wave pop rock sound anytime! We really need it because of today's fucked up times!
Though a bit loath to comment on YouTube, I feel this necessitates complimenting an absolutely amazing effort! Wishing I could have been there, yet this is a stunning alternative. Very well done and enjoyable to watch. I am happy that NIN isn't simply great, but has great (and talented) fans.
i am the needle in the vein i am the high you can't sustain i am the pusher im a whore i am the need in you for more i am the bullet in the gun i am the truth from which you run i am a silencing machine i am the end of all your dreams i take you where you want to go i give you all you need to know i drag you down i use you up MR SELF DESTRUCT thank you TOIOU!!
How the F did you put this out so quick in way better quality and sound than all your trailers in a week and you can't get the damn project you've worked on for a year out? Losers.
@tribestros Don't you know the guy who did TDS:Live also worked on AVOTT ? He did half of Vegas and one quarter of The Gift... Did it ever come to your mind that it may be slightly *more complex than that ?
Hey, tribestros you are calling them Losers, this is the best stuff put on You Tube ever, the shit takes some time, they want to make it right, Dumb Ass!!!!!
@tribestros I kind of agree in a way. I have been waiting much too long for the project, however. Take this into account. They are taking videos, doing a little editing and uploading. Done. The TOIOU project is filming 4 seperate concerts, editing them, doing the soundwork and shit. THEN making the packaging, THEN burning all the discs. THEN sending them to MANY different parts of the world. Thats just the simplified version. Think nextime fuckstick.
The only album i dont own is Ghosts I-IV, i want to buy it but i dont have enough money,lol, but i have to say that Year Zero is the best one so far, i love that album!!!
Fuckin' A !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NIN Rulesss !!!! Just like always !
They have kept changing or better say adapting to their surroundings in the best way ever ! Starting from their first album right to the last one ,they all give me exact feeling of ups n downs we experience throughout our lives !
This is a good thing. Now we don't have to endure another 2 albums worth of manure like we did with Year Zero and The Slip. Hopefully Trent grows his testicles back and comes out with another metal-ish album. That garage rock/alt shit NEEDS TO GO!!!
I'll throw you a bone for The Slip not being to your taste (though Head Down is an awesome song) ...but seriously: Year Zero? I mean, if you don't like the album, that's your prerogative (I tie it with The Fragile as my favourite) but other than The Beginning Of The End, NONE of it sounds "garage rock" at all. I suggest listening to both albums a few more times. The first time I heard The Slip, I hated it but now I find it fairly fucking awesome
I would have payed out the ass to see The Downward Spiral in entirety. Seen NIN too many times to count and they truly were ALWAYS the best shows ever! Every last 1 of them. No one in my lifetime will come close to what Trent and crew pulled off on-stage.
Thanks to all the fans who were there at this concert at Webster Hall to record this for all of NIN fans to see in its entirety. Nine Inch Nails along with TOOL and Meshuggah will always remain my favorite hard rock/alternative band of all-time!!!
Wow. Exceptional video quality and editing. Thanks to everyone who filmed the show, for submitting their videos, for the people responsible for putting all of this together... My favorite album, live, and for the whole world to see, ha ha. Amazing.
So, there really is a god after all... Thanks a million to the people who put all of this together. Didn't go to the show, but at least I can see it in one form or another. People like you make the world a better place. Seriously.
what hides inside every human, and what the whole humanity fight against
SrQuasar 2 weeks ago
I saw NIN on the Downward Spiral tour in 1994, and was treated to an AMAZING show. It even had one of those moments where Trent Reznor flipped out and started beating the equipment with instruments. His dog had died that day.
DPLaVay 1 month ago
just saw devin townsend play a small venue it sounded so bad all I was thinking about was how its possible to make a small venue sound good and make your epic music come across the exact way its supposed to. All I was thinking about was this. Thanks so much for putting this on the internet. NIN has the greatest fanbase of any artist.
jasondesante 1 month ago in playlist The Downward Spiral : Live
Goosebumps at the bridge.
Bostonian91 3 months ago
I'll take you where you wanna go!
steven8807 4 months ago
JUST WOW!!!!
nimatek667 4 months ago in playlist The Downward Spiral : Live
@ynattirbelise no, you should go back in time to the self destruct tour
clarkreznor 5 months ago
The break in the middle of this version is incredible, better than the studio version IMO
Staphylin 8 months ago 5
I am the needle in your vein.
I am the high you can't sustain.
I am a pusher, I'm a whore.
2:26
No matter how old Trent got, or how far removed he was from his early life as an addict, this eye of the storm part of Mr. Self Destruct, when its live it always seems to take him back to a certain place.
This song has such dynamic energy whether its blowing your ear drums or leaving you in a beat-less limbo, its like a black hole.
prod1gy3000 8 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@wbonfig
how about the youtube downloader?
Wuselwatz 8 months ago
lol at the beginning GOD DAMNIT
KyleThomasShultz 8 months ago 5
@KyleThomasShultz
alwys cracks me up aye
HarryGnutz 8 months ago in playlist Nine Inch Nails
I want to get this whole concert on mp3. Any ideas?
wbonfig 8 months ago
@wbonfig
how about the youtube downloader ?
Wuselwatz 8 months ago
@wbonfig how about the youtube downloader ?
Wuselwatz 8 months ago
@wbonfig aTubeCatcher is the way ;D
0oZuntAo0 6 months ago
Comment removed
steven8807 5 months ago
HOW CAN YOU FUCKING STAND THERE WITH YOUR FUCKING PHONE IN THE AIR?? ARE THOSE FUCKING FAGGOTS EVEN LISTENING TO THE FUCKING MUSIC???? Holy fucking shit that pisses me off sooooo fucking much...
Robergine 9 months ago
this record is awesome. i particularly love HERESY when he goes "YOUR GOD IS DEAD!!!!!"
OralAgreement69 9 months ago
FFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUU- still amazing to this day, and they only manage to outdo themselves.
Squidpus 10 months ago
the banging sound in the beginning is from a sci-fi movie from the 80's set in a future dis-topia where in all people are grown and forced to take sedatives in order to maintain productivity and control, policed by MACHINES. underground.
SeanOhReally 11 months ago
@SeanOhReally THX 1138, if anyone is curious.
KradProductions 11 months ago
Yes. God yes, I let you do this to me.
syztym 1 year ago
who is this nine inch nail?
angie4josh 1 year ago
Love these guys and this song ...but does anyone else think the vocals actually drown out the music too much here?
I've seen them live a lot and they usually kick ass
TomFromJersey 1 year ago
@TomFromJersey Yes
joydivided23 1 year ago
Warning: Too Much Musical Awesomeness, Self Destruct Sequence In.....5..4..3..2..1...........NIN FUCKING BLOODY RULEZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!
filth69ify1 1 year ago
Great performance of an awesome song. This is a quality recording and I really appreciate all of the work that went into putting this together. Though, I still can't help but feel a little depressed knowing that there really aren't any live recordings of this song that sound much better than this :(
thepenguin55 1 year ago
@thepenguin55 look at jessicasarahs youtube page of nin live in sacramento and portland during the lights in the sky tour
TunerLegend17 1 year ago
@ynattirbelise No I was Watching GOD ON MY COMPUTER AND I MISSED THE LIKE BUTTEN OH TRENT UR AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
CaptainBBS 1 year ago 4
gay
tehbombson 1 year ago
beep beep
mortcasinomort 1 year ago
@ynattirbelise ME TOO!!!!!!!!!!! he is awsome
TheSprince84 1 year ago
awsome he is so good in concert
TheSprince84 1 year ago
@ynattirbelise I am the hand you chopped down... And I control you (8)(8)
Zelig687 1 year ago
fucking awesome
Xetrez 1 year ago
this song is like thrash its awesome
slaytallicdethrax 1 year ago
so god like at 220 so good live wish I could see perfect drug fav song
25onelove 1 year ago
TY to all the makers of this, it's a lot like being there, at least the most like being there I've seen on youtube.
mawhar 1 year ago 2
This live version is so much better than the original song, LOVE IT. Does anyone know where i could get the mp3 of this?
OOTB 1 year ago
Im sooo sad I missed this.... I love how much heavier it sounds live.
lolbaitfershiz 1 year ago
Wow amazing this sounds so close to the 90's NIN live!! Trent still got it! I hope Trent changes his mind about quit touring. And I hope he starts touring in a couple of years. And I hope in the next NIN record (if possible) Trent brings the this 90's Industrial metal sound back because it beats the drum and bass electronica new wave pop rock sound anytime! We really need it because of today's fucked up times!
RussX5Z 1 year ago 4
Man... the drums are INSANE on this song... most of it didn't seem to be programmed.
Kueck10893 1 year ago 4
Goddamn it!!!
owahahah 1 year ago 2
uh...yes...yes...yes...yes...yes...YES
uvter 1 year ago
Though a bit loath to comment on YouTube, I feel this necessitates complimenting an absolutely amazing effort! Wishing I could have been there, yet this is a stunning alternative. Very well done and enjoyable to watch. I am happy that NIN isn't simply great, but has great (and talented) fans.
mordeo 1 year ago 4
Trent takes me where I want to go
random63089 1 year ago 21
Wow! To think I played that stage last October.
chrispnotenbooger 2 years ago
damn its wont work for me (the video ) i feel deprived of some human right :(
lhowl 2 years ago
why is it ever time i watch this i have to headbang? FUCKING GREAT!
gctones 2 years ago 8
fucking great quality video as it must be, thank you very much NIN rocks!
Buuhster 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing! MUCH LOVE :)
UKHoboso 2 years ago
great job and a big thanks. just a hugh gift to nin fans. nin rules
jslatter 2 years ago 6
sixtimesover 2 years ago 11
I think this is the best way to see NIN's live concerts. You can feel the energy! the moving camera makes you feel you're right in the crowd
marcoslhernandez 2 years ago
the best way to see NIN's live concerts on youtube maybe. nothing can compare to actually being there.
tomfromabove1979 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How the F did you put this out so quick in way better quality and sound than all your trailers in a week and you can't get the damn project you've worked on for a year out? Losers.
tribestros 2 years ago
@tribestros Don't you know the guy who did TDS:Live also worked on AVOTT ? He did half of Vegas and one quarter of The Gift... Did it ever come to your mind that it may be slightly *more complex than that ?
ThisOneIsOnUs 2 years ago 3
Hey, tribestros you are calling them Losers, this is the best stuff put on You Tube ever, the shit takes some time, they want to make it right, Dumb Ass!!!!!
ny5280 2 years ago 9
@tribestros I kind of agree in a way. I have been waiting much too long for the project, however. Take this into account. They are taking videos, doing a little editing and uploading. Done. The TOIOU project is filming 4 seperate concerts, editing them, doing the soundwork and shit. THEN making the packaging, THEN burning all the discs. THEN sending them to MANY different parts of the world. Thats just the simplified version. Think nextime fuckstick.
SinnesterSorrow 1 year ago
@tribestros prick.
therealpsp1mp 1 year ago
@therealpsp1mp fuck u
tribestros 1 year ago
@tribestros umad?
therealpsp1mp 1 year ago
just to mention that Ghosts I-IV is one of the best album by nin, along with the fragile and downward spiral, but all the albums are really great
flurubis 2 years ago 3
The only album i dont own is Ghosts I-IV, i want to buy it but i dont have enough money,lol, but i have to say that Year Zero is the best one so far, i love that album!!!
ny5280 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no, 'no junk no soul'. Your Fragile/Antichrist years are what will remain "Still"
al3ksandros 2 years ago
got to love the NIN community!! thanks guyss! and girls!!!
gundambob646 2 years ago 5
Fantastic...thanks much for posting!!!
goforwake 2 years ago
Gear list used to make this video please?
jnnx 2 years ago
Comment removed
al3ksandros 2 years ago
Great vid. Great band
coreygott90 2 years ago 2
Pretty Hate Machine to The Slip and EVERYTHING in between = Awesome Fucking Music
As a true fan, if the band evolves like Nine Inch Nails did, you evolve with them.
14murh 2 years ago 101
yesssss
666Hellsing 2 years ago
Fuckin' A !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NIN Rulesss !!!! Just like always !
They have kept changing or better say adapting to their surroundings in the best way ever ! Starting from their first album right to the last one ,they all give me exact feeling of ups n downs we experience throughout our lives !
MinaLiberta 2 years ago
EPIC
faketree 2 years ago
right away....goddamnit!
sgf1989 2 years ago
nIn Rocks!!!!
Please, come to Brazil!!!!
ThiagoCPBarbosa 2 years ago
NIN's not going to come to Brazil anytime soon.
They are done touring for an indefinite period of time.
pulsedemon 2 years ago 3
I died on the inside a little when it was announced that nin was done touring for this patch of time, I never saw them live and I've always wanted to
sgf1989 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a good thing. Now we don't have to endure another 2 albums worth of manure like we did with Year Zero and The Slip. Hopefully Trent grows his testicles back and comes out with another metal-ish album. That garage rock/alt shit NEEDS TO GO!!!
gatesoftanhauser 2 years ago
I'll throw you a bone for The Slip not being to your taste (though Head Down is an awesome song) ...but seriously: Year Zero? I mean, if you don't like the album, that's your prerogative (I tie it with The Fragile as my favourite) but other than The Beginning Of The End, NONE of it sounds "garage rock" at all. I suggest listening to both albums a few more times. The first time I heard The Slip, I hated it but now I find it fairly fucking awesome
pulsedemon 2 years ago 4
when bands evolve and change (like the good ones do), theres bound to be people who dont like it. personally i love it all
smokelakes 2 years ago 5
garage rock/alt? what are you on?
NappyHeadedHorse 2 years ago
jaaaaaaaaaahhhhh!!!!! you let me do this to you
spijtig 2 years ago
I teared up upon seeing/hearing this. Much love to Nine Inch Nails and to the souls who captured this.
DaveyJones1111 2 years ago 2
I'm amazed that trent would go back to one of his darkest times.. simply awesome.
godman1234567890 2 years ago
thefirst time i saw this setlist i was like holy shit!! thats the whole album!
ballsoffury6969 2 years ago
I fucking LOVE LOVE LOVE this! That was the show I was supposed to see on my b-day, too.
absolutstar 2 years ago
just found out about this, holy shit.
someguy8383 2 years ago
Andrew?
Patriot16100 2 years ago
Great stuff, and incredibly steady and patient hands for NIN fans... No doubt we'll (hopefully) see a bigger collaboration in the future.
CGFilmTV 2 years ago
I would have payed out the ass to see The Downward Spiral in entirety. Seen NIN too many times to count and they truly were ALWAYS the best shows ever! Every last 1 of them. No one in my lifetime will come close to what Trent and crew pulled off on-stage.
orangeguy7 2 years ago
this is already on my iphone! its fuckin amazing!!!
pantherleal 2 years ago
fucking amazing!!!!!
ragehuelika 2 years ago
when i saw this, the intro lasted about a minute and a half. The build up had the whole crowd falling over each other.
totter2 2 years ago
Wow, pure awesomeness!
Serapel 2 years ago
without a doubt nin does everything perfect...this is great tank u all
legionofwarriors 2 years ago
I would kill to be there. :O:O
thebadge666 2 years ago 3
yay! Great!!
RezinAngel 2 years ago
Burnt this video to DVD. Its SOOOO good!!
Lordgout 2 years ago
Thanks so much for posting!
Amouthfulofsin220 2 years ago
AWESOME !
AnimeForumX 2 years ago
love it!
violetgrr 2 years ago 3
Fucking awesome!
I want it back too...
Majdaily 2 years ago 2
What was that song at the very beginning of the video?
BrewHa002 2 years ago
Mr-Self-Destruct , its part of the song
MephProduction 2 years ago
Ladyhawke: Paris is Burning
Narckarella 2 years ago
It's part of the song, but the sound that you hear is actually a sample that was taken from the movie, THX 1138
PrivateBuckwheat 2 years ago
grali tak ./.jakby im się spać chciało>>>:(
mariofromnl 2 years ago
and this is all shot by fans?
FFFFUUUUUUUUUU.......
just plain awesome.
well done.
raspatism 2 years ago
i want NIN back :(
vikinglordSF 2 years ago 4
Amazing! Terrific energy and vocals throughout the entire playlist!
Better than their show in my home town (halo_22)
Great job shooting this!
WheelChairZombie 2 years ago
this is fucking great!!
delicojeje 2 years ago 2
so awesome, thank you to all those involved! btw anyone know the song playing right before they kick into MSD?
southpaw7 2 years ago
I think it's "Paris is Burning" by Ladyhawke.
Uriel77 2 years ago
WOW.... HOLY SHIT!
gokawi03 2 years ago
legend.
gonzo73 2 years ago
Amazing footage!!! Thanks so much for providing this!
technochica 2 years ago
this is so fucking cool!
petrimental 2 years ago
bad.
TheBehelit 2 years ago
Thank you :)
ibizaelia 2 years ago
Comment removed
KybernetikKollektiv 2 years ago
aka, the best crap.
hkpolitik 2 years ago
Woah! That is so cool, i might burn this onto a dvd soon, hopefully. Thanks.
xKruspeFanx 2 years ago
3.24 - does that guy on the right have a hearing aid? D:
magicmuffins7 2 years ago
moulded ear plugs.
from an audiologist.
the shizz.
krudboy 2 years ago
THANKS! I was sooo bummed I missed it so thank you to all involved and of course to Trent who always thinks of his fans first!
z3rosum 2 years ago
*drool* amazing
ckliar 2 years ago
THANK U
dtc5793 2 years ago
I was there.
DigitalVirus 2 years ago
NIИ always kicks ass live. That's what help propel them to stardom in the early 90's!!!
Redzombie13
Hallandale Beach, Florida Monday, October 26, 2009
3:25 PM (EST)
Redzombie13 2 years ago
Thank you!! hey, a question - if i burn this onto a dvd does that mean I can play it on my tv?
BeadyEyedChloe 2 years ago
yes - it is what they made it for. :D
CertainLyte 2 years ago
Thanks so much to everyone that was involved in the production of this. It's amazing.
Erajia 2 years ago
A big thank you to everyone involved in this project!! This is epic! NIN fans are amazing. Thanks, just, wow!!!
unibludger 2 years ago
NIИ kicks so much ass!! I wish I could have been there, thanks a bunch guys for posting this!
trevoreriksmoen 2 years ago
the goddammnit says it all :D
Livenation...You obviously are only in it to make the almighty dollar
Thanks to those who filmed and are sharing this with the world.
zincink 2 years ago 2
hell yeah! \m/
w1090 2 years ago
thank you! thank you! thank you! This is so fucking sweet! you made my shitty day into a great one! Thank you for this!
gctones 2 years ago
Thanks to all the fans who were there at this concert at Webster Hall to record this for all of NIN fans to see in its entirety. Nine Inch Nails along with TOOL and Meshuggah will always remain my favorite hard rock/alternative band of all-time!!!
Redzombie13
Hallandale beach, Florida
Saturday, October 24, 2009
8:12 PM (EST)
Redzombie13 2 years ago 5
you're SO right about these 3 bands!! They're some out of my favorites as well!!
jool777 2 years ago
listening on my mackie hr824s and the sound is incredible for a fanshot
djruinerdotcom 2 years ago
Great job!! What kind of tools did you use?
AliceDamnation 2 years ago
Effing awesome! The sound is unbelievable!
the8thsynn 2 years ago
Beautiful in some many ways....
eddeetoy 2 years ago
BEAUTIFUL!!!
smorzandlilone 2 years ago
fantastic job - well done all.
LuKeNuKuM 2 years ago
is there an mp3 rip of this?
Roderik46 2 years ago
well fn done
aonello 2 years ago
Awesome...
fatandrewrockz 2 years ago
The video is pretty good quality. But what really blows my mind is the audio. I've never heard a concert sound this good from fanshot video.
y2kbug77 2 years ago
NIN fans are just as awesome at NIN themselves. THANK YOU!!!!
LadyPNIN 2 years ago
About FUCKING TIME he played this live again! Killer performance and excellent editing. This will be treasured for years to come.
FLCLboy 2 years ago
Not my cup of tea music-wise, but superb editing.
maidbloke 2 years ago
Why are you watchin g this then?
Disturbedone1954 2 years ago
is there an mp3 rip of this?
shaun1239 2 years ago
Superb, very well done....
zx6rman 2 years ago
The fans are the most crucial & involved part of NIN other than Trent. I applaud this every NIN fan for the dedication over the years ,
especially This One Is On Us!
markmccool 2 years ago
Wow. Exceptional video quality and editing. Thanks to everyone who filmed the show, for submitting their videos, for the people responsible for putting all of this together... My favorite album, live, and for the whole world to see, ha ha. Amazing.
KriztofferSwank 2 years ago
Thanks to all dudes who recorded it...it´s fucking awesome!!
Deadsong100 2 years ago
This is fucking sweet..Thanks to all of you who helped make this happen! You guys rule!!
SuckOnMyTubeBitches 2 years ago
el aporte del año, gracias desde chile!!
doctorkien 2 years ago
thanx a lot guys, this one is really great, you just made a great gift for everyone...
Really Thanx...
dongardu 2 years ago
Thank you! You've made a lot of people very happy. Good job. :)
dizzyballerina 2 years ago
this is awesome to see this because I got kicked out before witnessing the last nin tour because of getting kicked out of the venue for smoking weed
defx7 2 years ago
Thanks so much to those that put this together!! This is amazing and so awesome that you shared it with all of us for no fee!
DangerSwanson 2 years ago
this is really well done!
jumblejunkiemusic 2 years ago
incredibly edited, incredibly filmed. this is outstanding piece of work, totally the best NIN movies ever.
robinfink 2 years ago 2
wow. just...wow.
michaeltgrace 2 years ago
thanks a lot for the hard work u all put in these videos!!!
johnkael 2 years ago
So, there really is a god after all... Thanks a million to the people who put all of this together. Didn't go to the show, but at least I can see it in one form or another. People like you make the world a better place. Seriously.
brejo57 2 years ago 5
It has so exceeded my expectations. Really. I owe you.
kp2718 2 years ago
I am so glad to be able to see this, I was so disappointed I couldnt get tickets to it
ThoBrian 2 years ago
This is the coolest shit ever. Thank you all so, so, so much.
KradProductions 2 years ago
that did the trick, nice one!!!
ivanrlynn 2 years ago
epic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
drchango2010 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
download youtube videos as mp3 google
ELLTUBE
i3l1nd 2 years ago
fucking awesome!
clistere2 2 years ago
Very nicely done! Thanks so much for posting this, I sadly couldn't make it. Awesome open camera policy...
darkanticrista 2 years ago
Also, the look of the performance reminds me of the electric factory in 2005
darkanticrista 2 years ago
Very nicely done. Thanks for this.
vigintiduo 2 years ago