[靜茹&情歌] 沒有如果 高畫質清晰版

[Corduraful]

我喜歡這bass



[j5791125]

別吵了...大嘴巴跟靜茹都是翻唱青山黛瑪的""留在我身邊""

只是因為靜茹的唱片公司沒處理好版權的問題

才會有抄襲的傳聞出現

[ZorusOfficial]

我覺得沒有如果和留在我身邊根本沒有必要爭論哪個比較好聽，

因為梁靜茹已經把原曲脫變成她自己的情歌。

[kimTKL]

阮經天個樣好正```

[lovelove740318]

男演員是阮經天嗎～



[cindywai]

@lovelove740318 yes!!!!!

[hfbvuif31145fkm]

真好聽!!!!

[vari5687921]

MV把理想社會的樣子拍的很好

[siumanbaby2009]

好喜歡這個mv :)

[Timkok621]

sweeeeeet

[y0u0r0k0]

好聽好聽!!!

完美喔~~~~~~

[yanleec]

好好聽 !!

[cocoa371010]

OC/OA...SoulJa

↑wthat this mean?

SoulJa...the Japanese Singer?

[ouch6767]

she's giving credit to SoulJa b/c there is a japanese song by him and Thelma Aoyama called "Sora ni irune" (Always by your side) that had this same melody but completely different lyrics....all the versions: Fish Leong's, Da Mouth, and SoulJa & Thelma's versions are really good!! :D and they've all done something diff. with this melody...^_____^

[cocoa371010]

yeah,　i know the Thelma Aoyama ,and Solja version. it is totally diffrent of its melody i think... but thank you so much for your kindness^^

[0xNeeNax0]

Love the song<3 Ethan is so adorable in the MV.

[he214ab]

首歌就麻麻地, 不過個mv拍得幾好睇就真.

[cyoong019]

好聽..^O^

[cooolben]

这个 MV拍的不错

[Angusbear619]

梁靜茹跟大嘴巴唱的東西

根本是兩碼子事嘛

[serenazhang]

这是静茹式的情歌。抄袭？笑话。那些说抄袭的人。给你们一首你们­也抄袭一下看看。

静茹这就叫实力派。支持静茹。。情歌天后。名不虚传！喜欢这首歌­

[acyaa]

xiao tian is so cute as a nerd in the mv lol

[CHYTRAY]

i really...... like this song!!!

[flywithvicky]

haha so cute when she showed her name tag to the guy buying flowers ... it did say 给 fish =D .. then the word 静 is highlight as it matches the other persons name under .. 静静 .. anyone know what she was hinting?

[CapricornusTai]

靜茹太厉害了，所以听不出来。这就是实力派嘛~

[venushoho]

oooo ok after reading all the comments i finally get whats going on!! haha, yeah 靜茹's remake is much better

[12959599]

說得好!!! 大嘴巴那首根本跟原作一樣耶!!! 靜茹就不同啦!!!

[chmyl]

sounds totally different from Da mouth's ...=S

[floraroro]

exactly...:)

[pwkhang]

跟本就是炒作嘛. 想粘静茹的光.

[cutiewinnie1997]

great song !!!!~~~~@@@@@

[lanyun89]

好好玩！！！！

好好看！！！！

好好听！！！！

[king46afu]

好看

[thatgood0706]

I love this song!

[Sillyv2]

This song is different to the other cover done by whoever it was.

Its WAY Better to me.

[u2929m3u]

好聽阿

跟原作還是有不一樣的味道

[etalocohc]

i like the song but dun like the lyrics.

[Tazchow77]

雖然不是原作,但真的很好聽

[Nickshair]

雖然簡單，但讓人感動！

[yansha]

小天在這裡有兩個角色耶! 哈哈

喜歡他戴眼鏡的樣子!

[CherryVivien]

o.o iam getting so tired of this song and the girl who sang it is not pretty!

[LilyYueLu]

我聽過青山的版本後..來聽這個...完全聽不出是同一首歌啊.­.要說cover..大嘴巴的就是個道道地地..而這首..就是­獨立的一首歌..隻是有幾個音相近罷了,根本聽不出是cover­ xD

[dare236]

話說這確實是翻唱的，梁之前在新聞上也承認了...LilyYu­eLu如果開頭看仔細點會看到OC/OA這幾個字，代表原作曲者­，也就是日文原版的作曲者...Soulja

[LilyYueLu]

我知道阿..當然有發現到..我只是在表達自己的看法而已..並­不代表我不知道實情,而相對的,就是因為我知道實情,所以我才更­要表明我本身的想法, "我聽不出是cover!!" (後來多聽幾次之後就比較感覺得出來了,但起先真的完全感覺不到­說)

我想你是誤解我之前留言的意思了..要是我不知道的話就不會留那­個言了

[cocolatejkrj]

cover?wad do u mean by cover?

[yansha]

"cover" means a singer "re-sing" the other singer's song.

[LilyYueLu]

"re-sing" in another language, which means another person re-write the lyrics into another language might turns into a totally different meaning for the song

[WhittneyZero]

+ 1

我還是覺得梁靜茹比較好聽(比較輕快)

[gogoggo355]

本來就是了,曲可以翻,但是情緒,口氣,特色那是梁式風格,他演­唱會上的無言花,紅豆,記得,情書,風格就是完全不同於江蕙,王­菲,阿妹,張學友

[sayu5214]

雖然不是原作,但真的很好聽,超過我對原版的喜愛

[xcandyxl0v3rx]

at 1:42 ...is that jay chou?!??!?!111

[gausong]

I think jay is much more handsome than the boyXD

[Kathyingc]

不是說畫面的男生吧

是歌聲

[milklollipop]

hes cute too!!!

[hhli68]

声域広いから

カラオケだと歌うのが大変なのさ

[sunnytan2017]

愛的天使

[cloudxxlion]

arhh i realy like fish song. sooooo goood

[NITROMEISTER]

声域広いから

カラオケだと歌うのが大変なのさ

[sillybunni4]

i like this song. does anyone know the title of it?

[iceflare]

Erm it's right on top... 沒有如果

[acidicjay]

i love mos buger!!!:)

and she sang so well!

[KENWU1937]

Fish的，很好听，支持

[UdonRamenSoba]

cute music video and this is a nice cover of soba ni irune..........I think they changed the song a little bit...which is a good thing because it's not a complete copy of the jap version....

[xyp2ux]

這首歌很耐聽

一開始還好越聽越喜歡

[mitubing]

very clear MV. this song is really different from the other 2.. juz like a new song like that. like the MV. very cute and the lyrics are sweet..

[myohmy0320]

song of the year.

[rappiest123]

good~

[gundamdouble0]

good lyrics and good singing .. But Still , I prefer Soulja's version !! Fast but touching ryhthm

[roycheng8125]

good

[mikiamanda]

深雪還是張小嫻的名句在歌詞中了啦

[corokurin]

是張小嫻喲...

我好喜歡那部小說哩~

[amy0703]

luv this song~n oso lyric~best!

[zoopreme717]

this version by fish is so much better than both da mouth, and that japanese version. this version flows much better at the chrous

[extreme1234]

they both take the music from Soulja, but i love liang jing ru's version :D haha

[az964222]

就算是翻唱 , 最好改一改讓人覺得跟原作有差別

往往接受度會比較高

這首歌就是成功的一例

[RocKo0623]

果　然　高　畫　質

字　幕　都　看　的　一　清　二　楚

[jumpupandburst]

OMG THIS SONG IS SOOOOO GOOOD

[ostop4567o]

老外都愛  :)

[movieit]

好聽是好聽

只可惜不是原創歌曲=3=

[dylan0305]

其它人上傳的ＭＶ。。

畫面和字幕都很模糊，真爛！

嗯。。這才算真正的高品質ＭＶ啦！！！

哈哈　感謝分享喔~~

[melvinoyh]

请看 0:08 - 0:09，Soul Ja 已经授权了啦！！大番薯！！

[justkiddingfan]

只是chorus一樣而已,

兩首各壇勝場, 一樣讚!

[cynthia1118]

這首真的好讚~!

[FE00126]

小天扮宅男

扮得好可愛xd

這歌真的好好聽 .

<3 梁靜茹 ;]

[Naomi1010]

It's a nice song!! Love it! :)

[fatmunki]

hey is that guy the actor from taiwan's hana kimi?

[et1231et1231]

yes

[sara33230]

讚!!!!

[CrazyTian95]

好听！好听~！！

[BabyAzianQt]

There is a remix (faster) version of this song. Does anyone have a link?

[soonyrawks]

好好听喔！

梁静茹的歌永远都是那么的好听！

[tung627]

很像勒~

應該是他唄`

[stephanieyan97]

小淳已在即時通說那個是他了,不用再猜了~

[owoling]

好像是ㄟ!

還蠻像的

[zoe22395]

好像喔

觀察力好強

[lswderrick]

I LOVE FISH ! I WANN HER !

[mushiromigal]

I love this song!Its super catchy and I heard it on the radio!Was finding it and found it!Hah..ethan ruan is also inside.

[bill8435]

雖然有版權的問題

我覺得沒有如果比大嘴巴翻得還好聽

當然原版的更讚

[NariannaLiu]

最愛靜茹了"

她每一首歌都很好聽

這首歌很棒!!

[muriellin]

so cute...Fish just likes an angel...

[lylee80]

i think this song is slightly different than da zhui ba and the japanese one....dun have baby boy...hahahaha...........xiao tian!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! so cute!!!!!!!!!!

[UpaUrs]

梁静茹我好爱你!真的唱得很好!更好听!

[ningningdavis]

跟青山黛瑪的留在我身邊好相似

不過唱的不錯=v=

[devil0609]

聽落真係有d似

[lovegm1314]

好好聽哦!+油

[Ning105]

靜茹好像邱比特喔

好可愛喔

她的歌都很好聽

紅的長長久久的

厲害

小天也很可愛...簡直一整個呆ㄟ

呵呵

[myohmy0320]

song of the year

[sallybigone123]

梁靜茹唱得超好聽!!!!

超愛這首歌的!!!

[chord905]

不管是誰唱的

都有不同的感覺

[WD555555525]

青山黛瑪和梁靜茹的版本我都蠻喜歡的！

因為兩首歌傳達的意境都不同

靜茹的比較像在鼓勵人有勇氣去向愛人告白.有種向上的感覺

而青山黛瑪則是思念曾經的戀人 感覺有點甜甜淡淡的哀傷

[ZXCVBNM1234567890zx]

青山黛瑪的歌名是什麼?

[freding115]

留在我身邊

[Burgees]

留在我身邊

[rainminnie]

留我在身邊そばにいるね

[rainminnie]

我是想回應zxcvbnm1234567890zx 的....

[KazuKae]

叫soba ni iru ne/そばにいるね

[imyoz]

梁靜如唱的好好聽:)

thx:DDD

[zaoying052]

阮經天演的宅男也太可愛了吧！

我超愛這首歌:)

[katarron]

OMG

i luvvv this song and mv:]

so cute how she sets ppl up, and the pictures of after she set them up~

[luke90702]

但是老實說,雖然大嘴巴是正正當當買到版權的,不過大嘴巴翻唱的­功力可能還要再加強一點填詞的部分可能還需要更完美,個人老實說­,比較喜歡粱靜茹的版本 希望靜茹的公司能盡快解決版權問題,使這首歌更廣為傳唱之餘,免­去抄襲的污名

[luke90702]

聽了好幾遍我只能說,很抱歉,有些部分的確很像.在副歌的部分,­雖然沒有100%相同,不過在於音階的上下程度,有多少的類似(­1.直接與日本版的永遠在一起比較,和大嘴巴版的倒不是很像2.­ 在下我學過5鋼琴,對於音感還可以.3.如果有音樂系或者職業專­家能提供簡譜說明那是更好)

[applexbabyy]

ethann is so cutteee :)

[catdog76]

1.清山黛瑪原版

2.梁靜茹 至少還把歌曲歌詞改過

3.大嘴巴 完整的翻唱 叫愛莎用日文唱說不定還比較好聽~

[catdog76]

還是大嘴巴版的最爛

[lovecpr]

各有各的特色!

[heartdews]

i love this song<3333333333 it's like the band version of Thelma's version :D

[lindanso]

好聽好看的mv

[XinYu520]

我喜歡清山黛瑪原版

[waifwong]

女追男的

好主動

喜歡 歌也超好聽

[205267]

哈哈哈哈

好可愛的MV!

[hong]

very clear mv, ty~~

[saturdae]

i love this song!

this is such a nice song!

really cute mtv to go with it too!

[sholo35265]

阮經天 performs in this MV, may foresee certainly popular, and creates the stir!

[cinammonlatte]

oh this is soo much better! The other versions all had inverted colors. What a cute idea!

[ch2bx808]

謝謝你分享清晰版本：）

[smallblack38]

Thanks for uploading!

Haha...Fish is amazing.

What a lovely crew in fast-food restaurant^.^

[psy1101]

thanks a lot!! 喜歡這首歌~~ 更喜歡小天的演出!!