Kinect vs Move - IGN Debate

[FaultierBeast9]

psn move is a fucking rip off of the wii what dont you guys haha im over here laughing at you fools just because sony was losing the fight of this gen they came up with some stupid shit the last time i saw move sold 8 million and kinect sold 20 million

[garlicpancake42]

When the court case is over, the Wii Motion Plus comes flying into the room, and shoots the Xbox and Playstation3 in the knee with an ebony arrow because you can't play Skyrim on the Wii. But really, the Xbox Kinect is awesome, and the Xbox itself is awesome. The PS3 can go curl up into a ball and slowly die.

[FreakTheMedia]

no one in this world can prove that ps move is better than kinect look how much money it cost for a game the controller and the navagator $100 but kinect is cheap and u only need 1 camra i used to have the move and i thought it was rubbish sure you have good games but have u considered that when ur playing crysis with it it start moving all over the place your gonna have to exit your game and calibrTe it but with kinect they spent time and money on the camera so its more accurate.

[no3023]

Kinect wins

but

Ps3 wins Xbox

[no3023]

Kinect is for families

Move has more fun games and should be used with older people

I agree that the kinect wins but the ps3 wins the shit box

[AleXy86]

the kinect dude got pwned by the dude representing the move.

[wreden1]

The Red Dislike bar is Kinect and the green one is Move... sooo i think Kinect is the winner :)

[TEAMNHL]

I like the move better because the cintrol thing lights up and makes it look awesome. :d

[oOFlowzillaOo]

Red Dislike Bar is Move

[oOFlowzillaOo]

Green Like Bar is Kinect

[Zectro15Tero]

Wii Motion Plus is better but after I played all three I have to say that they are all great but one point about the move that is true, there are no hardcore games for it, and what's with the pictures? I don't want my dam picture taken.

[miztrandersin]

you don't here people talking about the wii or ps move any more do you?

[Zectro15Tero]

@miztrandersin Correction, you don't hear about it.

[atza20]

they both suck wii was the only one that worked

[andrey2793dec]

@atza20 wii is for pussies like you

[atza20]

@andrey2793dec haha people like you make me laugh

[andrey2793dec]

@atza20 i m glad :))

[Zectro15Tero]

@andrey2793dec Name me 30 games that didn't originate from Nintendo then you can bitch about it.

[andrey2793dec]

@Zectro15Tero ha ha what a fag did i hurt you nintendo faggy

[onyxnegro]

Haha easy way for men who love playstation. All see why he love PS Move ^_^ He probably doesn't like move hehe. Men You are too fat then why u like PS. You only like "move" Your hands but True is one - You are fat and maybe go dance using buttons ^_^. Kinect is new all will be in future to play pff using body... not how You..only fingers... GL FAT PIG and remmember - kinect can make hand controler hehe

[teddybruscie]

So basically Wiimote Wins!!!

YAY!!!

Swag

[XjInterceptoR]

Innovation. Except with with about 5 seconds of lag. No one likes lag. Fuck kinect, I was bored of it after a week. Move ftw, the fight lights out and sports champions is amazing.

[ericmarshall19]

both suck. just give me a fucking controller so i can sit on my ass, i play games to relax not to exercise...

[MrFriedPie]

all that dislikes come from people who have an ps3 and they seeing just ps3 there ass get kicked by an xbox so ps3 don't cry it's just a game

[n3n3b3n3]

@EatReviewSleep and one kincet is all you need for multiple people to play kinect wins

[JaisonMax5]

pues quedo convencido con el ps3 por mas tecnologuia y aparte por su blu rey

y pues este video ayuda a saver cual t gusta

P;D buen video

[RoyBlox8]

PS Move = Similar to WiiMote

Kinect = EyeToy :D

[cody43390]

fkin dumb ass! have u ever herd of star wars kinect!??!!?!?!?!

[EatReviewSleep]

You can get the eye for $20. I just got 4 controllers on amazon for $120. Thats about the price of a kinect but LESS. MOVE WINS.

[KMA7171]

I find move better because if you are playing a car game you don't have a steering to steer with,do they?no you drive it with your bare hands,or if you are playing something like Call of duty you don't have a gun to shoot with,or even table tennis,while on the other hand Move you can turn that into a gun,a table tennis racket,and also it looks more fun.

[KMA7171]

and one more thing i don't think there is something in kinect called war games?please tell me if they do

[Gatorsurfer1887]

Ign starting flame wars since whenever the fuck

[pidosilencio]

Playing with things in your hands? it is the past, in the future we don't need controls. :P

[Shayd93]

They forgot to mention Kinect is a rip off EyeToy which PS had in 2002

[MrAnkitrox]

WHATS UP WITH TIS GAY COURT SESSION BULLSHIT!?

[1legomaster]

I'm not on any side but... IGN sucks. They always go with Xbox 360. I am a fan of both, but my God give the PS3 a chance. IGN is always giving 360 games a 7 out of ten or higher. Where as PS3, your lucky to even get an 8. Like I said I'ma fan of both and I'm not on either side, but respect both consoles. One is not better then the other. IGN= Idiot Gamer Nerds.

[AsiaAssassinAssocian]

this video speaks the truth

[loganlaromar]

Wii > Both .. Haha kidding, but really, Move is just an HD Wii while the Kinect will hardly get any great games. It seems like a lot of money to buy a Move just to add some gun firing motion controls for COD. The Kinect is basically a whole new system because it's doubtful that the 3 games the 360 has will use it.. COD on Kinect? That'd be far too difficult. So they're both kinda redundant unless you're younger and want to dance on Kinect.

[DiegoElect]

move is the shit

[DiegoElect]

kinect is the best

[Precisionz24]

/watch?v=w0puP8nrIU8 <-- my answer

[TheReviewSquare]

i would like to point out that if you like playing online and you have an Xbox you need to pay and on ps3 you don't i personally have both consoles but we all know that kinect is better then PlayStation move

[MrDavidTV]

Xbox and PS3 are both great consoles, why do people get so frustrated when someone prefers one over the other? Overall if you can afford it buy both if not pick witch one suits you best! SiMPLE!

[crazyrobot10]

Psmove is better, in 2011 we've seen crappy games like all the licensed ones. It feels retarted not using a light saber to play star wars. Move is for hardcore. ONE STATMENT DOSENT WIN IT D:-

[MrBuckysaurus]

@crazyrobot10

Did you just refer to a dildo being hardcore.......lol

[MegaTech81]

anything that has to do with the xbox is and always will be the best. it brings you the best games, futureistic gadgets and you still have great fun. lets not forget that it kicks stinky and hairy PS3 ass!!

[Coelacanthp]

Kinect wins but ps3 still kicks xbox ass

[TheSuperHudi]

KINECT WYMIATA I TYLE BEZ DWÓCH ZDAŃ!!!!

[mpinks97]

the kinect is good if you like danicng or like looking like a retard. move is good if you don't want to buy a wii

[pidosilencio]

@mpinks97 so playing move makes u look intelligent?

[veganlroy]

@pidosilencio So true!

[skiller2002]

move better so what there talking about people support move not kinect

[M3TR01DFANBOY]

they left wii motion plus out of this because ps move and kinect are fighting each other for second place

[GTA4fanatic118]

@M3TR01DFANBOY xbox and ps3 are just jumping on a motion control banwagon cuz they want money wii made it a part of there systems day to day features 5 years later and xbox and ps3 have only just made their stuff when wii had it for 5 years so yes i agree with you

[scottydog771]

@M3TR01DFANBOY wii motion plus shouldn't exist the controls should be that good without it, that's what it's meant to be like originally

[TheBadBuffalo]

@M3TR01DFANBOY yeah, the wii motion plus is the best, especially in skyward sword ,it's incredibly accurate

[dunnoahago]

@M3TR01DFANBOY Or maybe they left the Wii out because the wii is for 11 year old girls and his the HD quality of a carrot -_-

[M3TR01DFANBOY]

@dunnoahago im 17and have hd component cables for wii. both of you arguments are rendered moot

[dunnoahago]

@M3TR01DFANBOY Cool story Bro, needs more Dragons.

[HariRedBoyz8808]

THE HARDCORE NEEDS HARDCORE!!!!!!!!!!!!

[catholicgamer99]

I personally hate the Move. I love using Kinect for playing Dance Central, but that's about it.

[awesome696969696]

I have both.... I have to say that everybody says that the Move is like the Wii. But what NOBODY says is that the Kinect is A Playstation Eye in HD.

[catholicgamer99]

@awesome696969696 Yeah, that's what I thought when they were both announced.

[GamerAnalysis]

Those r my 3 favorite ign guys

[Ghostbustr7]

i dont care what company move or kinect was made from but i have a lot more fun with friends with family when i play the kinect. its bringing something new to the table. No offence to any hardcore gamer but cmon get up excercise. (im not saying all gamers are low life fat ppl)

[MichaganGirl]

i have a wii right wanting a kinect. i like the kinect because you are the controller but with my wii i keep losing the remotes and thats why i love kinect i will not lose anything

[Carter242dun]

why would anyone want to move away from the concept of game controllers it takes away from the genuineness of whats considered video gaming.Move gets my vote here

[ryanmuszak5109811]

im a kinect fan and honeslty i think there the same, move has better games but kinect is cooler and newer

[BHawksFan01]

wiimote>>>kinect>>>>>>>>>>>ps move

[iamDeadSilence]

Sony fan here. PlayStation Move has similiar features to the Wii but so does Kinect but the fat truth is, The Move is so much more better. Idk who would want to give up the touch and feel of an Assault Rifle controller, getting head shots, that The Move offers you, for frankly an invisible whatever you invisibly hold on Kinect. Plus Kinect still doesnt have anywhere as near big games like The Move does. Zumba?Kinectimals? Come on? Try Resistance 3,Killzone 3, Resident Evil 5 for The Move

[teenyweeny222]

cough gunstringer cough

[yoyoguysss]

Kinect IMPROVED version of Eyetoy Move Improved Version of Wii Now Stop Fighting

stupid fan boys

[yoyoguysss]

ok First of all Kinect is nothing like ps2 eye Toy Microsoft stole Sonys idea But

THEY MADE IMPROVED VERSION OF EYE Kinect has microphone and more graphics and

and accuracy than ps2 eye toy.......ok fine isnt Move a copy of the Wii So even Move isnt anything new BOTH MOVE AND KINECT ARE GOOD!!

[NickiM1738]

kinect sucks

first of all kinect just copyed sony and sony came up with no controller for the ps2 eye toy so apparently the kinect is just the eye toy but for a diffrent system, company, and has better games

ps move is not like the wii

the wii u have a sensor, and a controller not an eye

so you can do more things on the move than on the wii like everybody dance, create your own moves and take pics

that is why microsoft is copied sony which apparently means SONY IS THE BEST

not microsoft

:D

[mike43167]

@NickiM1738 it dosent matter who copied who it matters which has better games,quality,family fun.apparently move sucks and gets boring becuse obviously family member dont want to play and plus for move you have to but another controller for 2 player which is more wasted money.kinect has the better games,graphics,family fun and less money wasted becuase on some games 1 kinect is 4 players and obviously other people would love to play it=more fun and more time no bored=xbox,kin better

[mike43167]

@NickiM1738 now suck my salty ballzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzz go xbox and kinecttttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt­ttttttttttt.

[The3nnn]

kinect sucks!!! it is not precise, play station move could be a copy of the wii, but is 100.000 better with the games and all the things you can enjoy with it. i don't like kinect, playing ping-pong with the hands?! what the hell is that, and it takes like 1 hpur calibrating that thing, and kinect has a bulky desing. IT'S BETTER PS3, WITH PS3 MOVE YOU CAN DO ENYTHING

[NickiM1738]

@The3nnn SONY :D

[nodenaatti]

@The3nnn Everything? Are you sure?

[infamousfreack1]

ps3 is the best and all you xbox fans know that whos with me ps3 rules ps3 ps3 ps3!!!!!!!!

[sirbean123]

I'm all for the kinect. And Xbox in general... ADD MEH [aardvark menace]

[thedrakethebest007]

ok future games for kinect..............

Ghost Recon Future Soldier is some crazy shit it reminds me of the movie GAMER

[thelittleroxtar]

@thedrakethebest007 Yeah i am waiting for it...Amazing

[Exilon0193]

Kincet Haters=Fatass no-life gamers

[Simplecompexity]

Move=wii with glowey ball on the end

[XXEpicSauseZZ]

Ok so kinect is good for exersic and little kids and people who dont like shootin games and move is good for the games that require accesories like cod requires guns to be a shootin game and gladiators requires a sword and sheild so they are both ment for different things

[cloudcally]

LOL LMAO IGN said Kinect is better but there are a lot more dislikes for the video.

[IS0Pod]

@RCNINJAKINECTFREAK Why not?

[MrLuizilla]

Choosing between the Move and the Kinect?

F*ck this, I prefer the WiiMote.

[SteelGoronNidoking]

wii is best.....

ok tad fan boyish but for kinect and move to be better they need more games.

So far the move is the best of the two as it has the best games, although i would love to see much bigger games using move as at times it even beats wii motion plus.

[drAWSOME51]

god people why are there so much arguing and crap of people saying if i wanna move i will go outside. But there talking about kinect and move NOT the outdoors. And plus people are insulting them on what they think is better? My god it is just someones OPINION!!! its like a mario fan saying he hates sonic and all that. BOTH of those games are equally fun! same goes with kinect and move.

[msonic98]

i love how many playstation fanboys cant except the truth

[brasskickass]

BULLSHIT

[alexander2310703806]

Kinect Is Better Is Something new... Let's Face that !

[wwerulzs64]

@alexander2310703806 its not new look up Playstation eye toy kinect is a bullshit rotten copy

[alexander2310703806]

@wwerulzs64 There is nothing in common I believe that PSmove is a copy, and it's a copy of Wii!

[NickiM1738]

@alexander2310703806 KINECT AIN'T NEW PS2 EYE TOY IS JUST LIKE THE KINECT BUT KINECT HAS BETTER GAMES SONY THOUGHT OF NO CONTROLLER GAMES

[SgtNatino]

@alexander2310703806 Ever heard of eyetoy for PS2?

Face it, both are carbon copies of other products.

[Savin97]

Both are crap! if i wanna play moving i would go outside!

[911alldown]

@Savin97 what will you do if it's raining outside ??

[DaGoN1532]

@Savin97 yeah but you dont =)

[fayyah101]

@1997jesus the PlayStation eye in move was invented way before kinect and Wii.

[1997jesus]

kinect all day man we wanna play the future listen up noobs move is the sequel of wii

[Dragodemon000]

So...IGN supports Kinect because of it's POTENTIAL?

What about what it can offer right now? IGN can not see the future, so arguing something's worth based on potential is an infantile point. The PS Move is offering decent (granted, not brilliant) and operational services for it's system right now, across numerous demographics.

Kinect is catering to a small number of people and everyone should agree that, while innovative, there's not a lot to it RIGHT NOW.

[Robertico951]

xbox



[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 stop trolling, bye, i have to go to bed 4 school tom.

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 obviously this is a dead arguement...

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 are you angry?

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 COOL STORY WANNA BE GANSTER LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO­LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 COOL STORY BRO

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 who was your English teacher by the way? Any whose bye!!!!

[IS0Pod]

@RealityEyes01 You're tired of FPS and you go to the gym, what was the point of buying an xbox dumbass?

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 You know what, what the hell. I've debated with so many people today, it is just not worth it. If it means that much to you, sure, I'm a loser, and you're the coolest irl and online cause you go to the gym, enjoy being the coolest ever.

[TSMxNation]

@RealityEyes01 look, pls stop saying your cool online, that just makes you look like a loser irl

[giovank1]

winner kinect !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[IS0Pod]

@RealityEyes01 LOL If you're so tried of FPS, then get off the xbox 360 and the kinect. There's a thing called going out and exercising by going to the gym. You should try it after you watch your dad's gay porn collection.

[TheTryHardNOOB]

dayum lost of pissed fan boys here :/

[proctor4883jay]

hahahaha 1683 ps3 fanboys are mad because kinect won!

[ShortCreeper]

@proctor4883jay kinect won? hahahahaha

[IS0Pod]

@RealityEyes01 Lazy? lol You're saying kinect will keep you fit? it's just better to go outside to lose some weight. move is meant for gaming. ever heard of sharpshooters?

[get8p]

Both things r good. It is best pple to choose which1 of it is most handy 4 them, not what recommended/promoted best.

[ronvnkl232]

both are not worth your money the ps move is a wii rip off and its not nearly as accurate as motion plus is kinect is annoying its a rip off of the ps2 eye toy its way better though but still you just cant make hardcore games with kinect btw killzone 3 sucks with move the ps eye isnt fast enough for motion gaming with a controller like the sensor bar of the wii basiclly this arguement is for second place if you want great motion controls go with wii motion plus its defently the best

[jamesdebee88]

Go figure. That is all I have to say.

[ryan4697]

i had the playstation move for a while... then my mom got a job :)

[Jodie7068]

i have seen something like the kinect the playstation 2 eye toy

[1997jesus]

kinect rocks systems r mostly about video games but u can also use ur voice on movies and games And on 11-25-11 bye bye ps3 kinect will change everything with kinect by youtube bing voice support live tv

[Ammar0Atta0Khan]

Kinect may be better than ps move but I do know this that 90% of kinect games suck. Atleast with the move you get quality titles like resistance or Killzone.

[DiegoElect]

kinect this is betther

[PinkerRanger]

yeah kinect is betther

[kztar621]

Well, I gotta give props to Microsoft for not making it so painfully obvious that they stole the idea from Nintendo. I mean, Sony, you even copied the fucking advertising! (With a stupid blue ball on top)

[TNAenigma2161]

kinect forever

[AGentertainment]

Both suck.

[FreshGotTheJuice]

Cant Spell (ign)orant Without Ign .

[elmaestromultijugado]

kinect is cool kinect rules yeahh \m/

[TheMichaelm1997]

I like both . But I like the move a little better. Sure,Kinect has your body playing, but it is difficult to set up. Both games are sensitive but if you play the move you will have fun

[IS0Pod]

kinect sucks. if people don't want a controller, might as well go outside

[wallygrim]

@IS0Pod Then don't buy Kinect if you want to go outside and play in the sun... It's not our problem if that's what you want... But it doesn't mean it sucks... And i'm still getting the Kinect! =D

[IS0Pod]

@wallygrim lol at you. haha

[CRAZYKILLER996]

kinect kinect kinect kinect last time kineeeeeeeeeeeeeect yeeeeaaaaah

[gamerdude22314]

kinect wins



[YingYangDude888]

move won from the beggining but the move guy's argument was much better

[antony9721]

you cant even compare them! but you can compare the wii and move. Also kinect is a copy of playstations eyetoy so essentially wii and playstation one this 

[antony9721]

you cant even compare them! but you can compare the wii and move

[omariobros]

amo los videojuegos pero ellos son unos frikis sin vida

[lokdog4]

kinect wins!

[Ironjagg]

innovation no breathing..

[OfficialGrammarNazi]

Nobody said the ps move would be anything but an hd wii.

I would rather have an old concept done extremely well than have a new concept done terribley.

[anzsai]

Kinda agree with the whole hardcore first person shooter game....

[playmauricio]

ps3 kick ass

[MrWatchmen759]

fuck ign

[SexyGothicBoi]

I kinda don't like what games are for the kinect... I like the move cause I can shoot things with it :D Seriously, have you tried out the sharpshooter? Dude it's so cool!

[TheSleepyGene]

The kinect is okay... Its been hyped for what like a year and a half or more. Its not really precise and its opening game kinect adventures made me rather play my wii. The move is much more precise and a little bit more hardcore but isnt really friend friendly. How about microsoft and sony partner together! Everything would be fixed.

[Anniede123]

Xbox Kinect is not fun without space

[TheLMan101]

So... these guys are all 360 fanboys or something? I mean, the quote "No-one is excited about the Move" just makes it seem they already decided a winner. At least other people will keep an open mind about it.

[AymanzooR]

if microsoft gets a navigation controller for kinect games to remove the rails move will lose no offense move is awesome 2