A Message to Sami Yusuf, Yusuf Islam, Ahmed Bukhatir, Zain Bhikha & other "Nasheed Singers"

[aliturkish]

MashAllah at last some one speaks the truth about nasheeds .tell them brother ,tell them ......

[SuperMaryam16]

so it is bad listening to them? I want to know more. I am confused now.....

[MilkShaykh01]

@SuperMaryam16 Very bad. Please read the description i hope the websites can help you

[Mr1Fox9]

very well said (alhamduliLLAH).

[M76pa]

Cant believe how much I love this brother.

[yousef98765]

salam, from what i know Ahmed Bukhatir and No Beats Necessary, do not use instruments, the others you mentioned do use music sometimes, but i dont think those i mentioned use music, the ustadah didnt even know the singers to mention them and say that they do use music and he even mentioned that he was given a list by a brother, so i dont think u should of mentioned some of those people without clear evidence! sami yusuf is clear and everyone knows what he does and ALLAH knows best

[MilkShaykh01]

@yousef98765 Walakum salam. Again please listen to what the speaker said carefully, a Muslim can NOT have a career as a singer or musician, he can NOT have a fan site, he can NOT give dawah through singing. One of the ulemas even called it a Bid'ah. No sahabi would do this! Its imitating the kuffar as well.

[MuslimVlogGuy]

Some young dude like this shouldnt be speaking..

[MilkShaykh01]

@MuslimVlogGuy Why not? He speaks from Quran and Sunnah so whats the problem? Hes the only guy that delivers talks in English in Jeddah, the rest are in Arabic, so what about the people who don't understand Arabic? whose going to give the dawah? This guy is a student of knowledge as well as a teacher, hes not like you, who sits around on youtube and records his self on cam spreading knowledge. Before you backbite him read the description and watch the full talk.

[MuslimVlogGuy]

@MilkShaykh01

The problem is that he may not be qualified to speak on such important matters. I don't sit on around on youtube spreading knowledge. If you had watched them, they are simply addressing issues that goes on. I didn't know that calling him a young dude is backbiting. Maybe if you're getting your knowledge from him, I ought to pass from getting knowledge from him.

[MilkShaykh01]

@MuslimVlogGuy Baarak'Allaahu feek, sorry if I came across harsh to you. He is qualified to speak on such matters, and the you called him ''young dude'' is kind of offensive, hes in his mid 20's.

If you want his YouTube channel or email inbox me. Jaazak'Allaahu khayran

[MilkShaykh01]

@MilkShaykh01 He has studied under Fareed Abdullah. He does not issue his own verdicts or fatwas, he gives the fatwas of the scholars. Check his YouTube, you can message him on his inbox if you wish, he does reply :) wwwDOTyoutubeDOTcom/user/OneWa­yToParadise

Btw did you know Imam Bukhari gave his own fatwas at the age of 13..

[MilkShaykh01]

@HiddenDiam0nds There are conditions please watch wwwDOTyoutubeDOTcom/watch?v=oq­pwR8_-pdQ

[AfgGodfather18]

Whose voice was that one with the nasheeds?? Any brother or sister knoes thanx

[Sabriya18]

Sorry to sound discrete but alot of things you said are false and blown out of proportion. For one, Zain Bhikha and No beats Necessary don't use any musical instruments. They use human sounds, a.k.a Beat Boxing. If you truly want to advice and make a difference with what you say, you should atleast address them with the right way of saying their names. "I dont know their names and dont want to" is degrading to them, after all they're Muslims just like yourself. Islam is a religion of ease Akhi.

[sacdevdasi]

subhan allah

[ankurdang]

whats the logic behind music being haram......? i think its just a misinterpretation of scriptures !

[MilkShaykh01]

@ankurdang Check the websites on the description

[nabeelm82]

@ankurdang zakir naik, dr.israr ahmed, yusuf estes, abdur raheem green, khalid yasin, nouman ali khan.....and very senior scholars have said music is haram.....there are authentic sahih bukhari hadith available which says/indicate that music is haram....do some research, may Allah guide us all Ameen

[muhammad8500]

@nabeelm82 Music is haram i accept but Zakir naik etc are not alims but as always Allah Knows Best.

[MilkShaykh01]

@muhammad8500 As much as i love Zakir Naik, i am a big fan of him, but he is not a scholar and has not studied fiqh so he shouldnt speak about something hes not qualifed to

[darklight254]

@ankurdang

The logic is "obey Allah and obey his messenger"

[SaraMuslimahAa1]

who is the first reciter? mashaAllah, what an amazing voice..

i so agree with what this brother says about nasheed and music..

[AlgerianThug]

Advice should be given in secret, it's most likely to bear its fruit when given to a person when he is by himself, for in such a situation the person is less likely to be affected by the thoughts of others. The sincere advisor should not aid the Devil over his brother by publicly rebuking him and letting Shaitaan beguile his brother into not taking the naseehah. This closes the doors of goodness and acceptance, and reduces the chances of the naseehah from being accepted.

And Allah knows best!

[ax1237]

@AlgerianThug If someone writes something that contradicts the pure Sharee'ah, and distributes that material, or if he propagtes that view in the media, it becomes compulsory to refute him and expose the falsehood of what he says. There is noth...ing wrong in mentioning that person's name or in warning people about him if he calls to innovation, shirk, or if he calls people to what Allaah has prohibited or to disobedience.

[zz773]

The prophet Muhammad (pig shit be upon him) was a dirty pedophile who raped 9-year-old Aisha when he was 54.

[libexzz]

very dry lecture, the brother fails to understand these brothers intentions, and name bashing is just ignorence



[MilkShaykh01]

@libexzz Very dry comment, you obviously didn't see what he said about their intentions? You obviously didn't see the dua he made for them? You obviously don't know your deen properly about 'name bashing' open up Imam Nawawi's Riyad Saliheen chapter 256, read the 6 exceptions on backbiting inshaa'Allaah