Added: 5 years ago
From: SemNick90
Views: 289,665
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,274)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Omfg, most be most horrific cover of any Pink Floyd song ever by any band, complete ruin of a classic Pink Floyd song..

  • It was good until they started playing...

  • ow shit!

  • Really horrible, what a mess !! Not worth the time when looking this video !

  • I want MORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Another EPIC KK fail.

    Robert T is such a badass, he must feel like a jukebox to this clown.

  • it make me sick!! aagggghh!!!!

  • Lol you guys swear they practiced this for like 3 months before the show. There just messing around on stage.

  • lmao are they serious

  • Comment removed

  • Metallica should have stayed to their own kind ,,FLOYD IS too wise

  • ahahaha poor Metallica...  just sad..

  • Metallica is not worthy to play Pink Floyd.

  • HORRIBLE.

  • This sounds almost NOTHING like Floyd. The drums are too weak and the only things that suggests it's a cover of the song is the bass-line and the fact the lead guitarist is playing slide! Awful.

  • WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH PINK FLOYD? GO SLAP YOURSELF WITH A FUCKING 2X4 AND COME BACK WHEN YOU'RE THINKING CLEARLY

  • ...embarrassing.

  • leave them alone they're great band and show respect all those great bands and they don't think that the're the best band in the world like slayer or some else they're still fans and it's great about them ! sorry for my english

  • don't cry david gilmour, they're crazy!

  • Sacriledge

  • what the fuck is this shit ????

    

  • very bad =( i love Pink Floyd

  • That was crap.

  • I was excited when I saw the link for this, I love both bands... Sadly, it was really shit. Sorry boys

  • Sheeeesh ,That was horrible

  • Shame you Metallica and let it be.

  • ok first of, rob was spot on with the tempo, and pretty much the entire bass part, so dont give him crap, , what really wuined was hamett's improvising over the bass track, i love metallica, probably my favorite band, but if youre going to even try and play something of pink floyd's at least play it correctly or even try to use it correctyl! IMO its not one of these days unless waters is on bass either, so the pulse dvd's one of these days doesnt count either!

  • love metallica and floyd, but if you're going to play this song infront of thousands of people you need drums, you could tell they were just doing it for the hell of it.

  • Really everyone? Just chill, they're just up on stage having fun, as a band should, no matter how big and popular they have become. Listen to the crowd, they seemed to love it, why does everyone have to slam Metallica because they didn't cover it "perfect"?

  • PINK FLOYD É A MAIOR BANDA QUE JÁ EXISTIU !!!!!

  • gilmour didn't used a slide

    and btw the bassist sucks

  • you suck doing Pink Floyd, Metallica.....

  • Metallica,

    You're nearly a laugh but you're really a cry.

  • pleeeeese where the fu@k is Jason ! \o/

  • worst cover ever

  • That was simply ridiculous.

  • nie umiecie 

  • Holy sweet Moses!!! What the *******. 

  • I think that it pretty bad-ass of them to make the attempt, But...Please, they should listen to the song a few hundred times...get the tempo down, and articulate with a little more care. The tone is damn nice. I believe they could pull this tune off with some practice. Then, give it a go, Metallica! Do it right the next time, or don't make the attempt...please.

  • GEE... I hear you "cueing up" like the floyd; but u forgot to use your Fx pedal to click and sustain the loop! GooD try

  • What a bunch of amateurs, they don't have a clue how to play music. There isn't a single Mettalica piec that I would like to hear. They are the most overrated band in the history of the universe. And yes, that is my opinion.

  • I LOVE Floyd and i LOVE Metallica but this should NEVER have happened

  • wtf? My arse can play it better

  • They should be strung for daring to play this.

  • Mi dispiace per loro ma i Pink sono sempre i Pink!!

  • @RaimondoSereno certo che i Pink sono sempre i Pink :-) , però il fatto che li abbiano "citati" è segno di grande rispetto ed ammirazione

  • @thelamb1964 Mi piacciono moltissimo quando suonano le loro cose e il loro genere forse come hanno detto anche altri ci si aspettava semplicemente un esecuzione migliore da parte loro, comunque massimo rispetto ai Metallica.

  • i was't too against them doing this, but at about 0:55 is when i lost my shit.

  • Complete crap.

  • Pink Floyd=Masters

    Metallica=Puppets

  • fuck you assholes .....son of bitches!!!..you dumb shits are not even close to floyds..

  • WTF!? total bullshit...

  • wow... they really f***** this one up....

  • is there anything metallica can't completely ruin?

  • y para variar nunca faltan los sopencos .... ¬¬ me da náusea este video

  • No. They did NOT just go there. Pink Floyd is my all-time favourite band, and I just.. I died a little inside.

  • @QuakerCakeable Ahh don't take it personally. The pretenders will continue to pretend and Floyd will remain Floyd...awesome, original, unassailable and first in space.

    Me who ica?

  • good job guy's way to go trashing a classic

  • so bad musicians, unbelievable, in each village are 10 better ones

  • This sucks, but i am happy that a great band like Metallica listens to the masters Pink Floyd

  • nice

  • Metallica i love you i really do but...not pink floyd..please not pink floyd

  • @Guatexico78 what the fuck is your problem dude!!! i can almost guarantee if it wasnt for floyd, bands like tallica wouldve never come around, i would choose metallica any day over pink floyd, but i will not say please not pink floyd, because honestly, one of these days by pink floyd is some of the heaviest music you will ever hear, its heavier than enter sandman in my opinion,, you should not be able to call yourself a fan of any music at all, if you disrespect pink floyd!

  • One of these days, these guys will do a better cover INDEED \m/

  • Man Gilmour could use Kirk as a guitar pick...

    I love Metallica and Floyd but this was terrible =/ Megadeth would have done a better cover tho =)

  • AAAAAABBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOO..

  • The most half-assed attempt I've ever seen.

  • sweaty fuckers

  • this suck

  • I don't know if I should laugh or cry

  • embarassing

  • This is embarrassing to watch.

  • They should learn the song first before playing it live!

  • What in fucks name was the guitarist doing?

  • This is stupid, Metallica is just trying to playing a song of a band thay respect but they don't know much about, it is just a way to show respect to a different kind of music... This is not bad, this is just different, you can't expect an exact version of the song.... Metallica is a trash metal band, one of the best metal bands ever... Maybe you should try to hear more trash metal and stop bitching that much....

  • first i looked at the dislike bar and thougt that would be a fake video, but instead it was real and actually terrible! :/

  • thats pretty coool, why does everyone think its sucks so much

  • @MrDanBalls listen to the original then you will see why lol

  • @MrDanBalls

    Go to YouTube brother and search for: Pink Floyd - One of These Days (PULSE),

    then pick the one from the top (7:22). They should be prosecuted and kept on bread and water for a month for this.

  • They should be culled.

  • OMG, did they ever hear the original version? It sounds these guys are playing 2 different songs together. It's only Pink Floyd who can play this, please guys, play your own songs and hands off on Pink Floyd..!!

  • Fcking awful.

  • this is bad damnnnn

  • They didn't even play the it right... what a piece of crap...

  • the bass is the only thing that reminds me of pink floyd here.

  • Now THAT's baaaaad.

  • first off kirk tried to cover it the wrong way. david doesnt use a 6 string to play that song so no wonder it sounded like shit.

  • Is just me who loves both Metallica and Pink Floyd? Why is it so bad?

  • ew?????? absolute disgrace to pink floyd, im gonna go watch the VHS to delicate sound of thunder and wack off.

  • the lead guitarist sucks up totally ...

  • piece of shit

  • How childish! David Gilmour is such a master and makes it look so easy that tricks people in thinking they can imitate him. The result: horrific!!!

  • wtf??

  • PLEASE DON'T EVER DO THIS AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I'm sure Metallica has got stuff going for them, they've been around long enough. But if it's true that they pay homage to other bands by making themselves look bad, then I'm afraid I don't get it at all :\ . This was a bad day for their fans and PF fans as well. Perhaps they could try murdering a song that already pisses people off.....they might gain a few fans........LOL.

  • That is good..... Tom Araya would say.

  • the Fuck?

  • @buckethead It's not mindless bashing, it's mindful. My beef isn't how they executed it, it's that they didn't. It's not a matter of style. Not once did they change key at the same time. I luv Metalica but that lil homage was sad.

  • les falto lo chingon se quedaron cortos uno de estos dias.

  • What a piece of crap. How DARE they......

  • @Electricbaboon Same to u :D

  • @Electricbaboon I agree. It was unrecognizable. SACRILEGIOUS!

  • Comment removed

  • I think the bassist doesn´t know the song. What a terrible ideia, a bad band like Metallica doing a Pink Floyd song!

  • @Semente200 I agree with you that this cover is very bad...but it's a foolishness sayin' that Metallica is a bad band...ok that Pink Floyd is of another planet and inimitable,but Metallica in 30 years did wonderful things

  • Wow metal and slide do not go well together.

  • no les llegan ni a los huevos pinche metallica!!! eso es una falta de respeto

  • This have to be a joke right? wtf?? >.<

  • next!!!!!

  • schlecht

  • No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.

  • wtf???

    

  • Wow the bassist's inability to keep time in unbelievable.

  • @CommunistDancefloor the crowd doesnt know the tempo, rob was actually right on.

  • no tienen ni un poco de la perfeccion que usa Pink Floyd!!!

  • It wasn't that bad, for a quick little medley. I thought it was alright for something made up on the fly...

  • @jerman2003 your wrong, that was absolutely terrible, and i thought there wasnt a bad thing to say about mettalica

  • I love metallica and I LOVE pink floyd but I don't love this. It's awesome to make a nod to pink floyd and put their own spin on it and all, but this just sounds....Unrehearsed, kinda messy.

  • i DIS FUCKIN LIKE

  • LOSERS METALLICA IS A SHIT!

  • Lol, I actually kinda liked it!

  • Sounds like crap. Can't really say much else......

  • I think Floyd fans need to calm down.

    I love Pink Floyd, the best band I ever heard, but this is just Metallica putting their own take on it for their own kind of crowd.

    Enough hate and mindless bashing.

  • This is what happens when a band that were faithfull to their music for only 4 albums try to imitate a real band.:) Sorry guys,Pink Floyd is miles out of your league:).

  • lol nice try Metallica, but you're no David Gilmour..or Roger Waters..or Nick Mason..or Richard Wright(R.I.P)

  • David Gilmour is much better

  • Cmon.. it's not that bad. Its not PF all in all, keep in mind :D

  • I can play better than this, its pathetic

  • O_o

  • fuck it

  • -_____________-

  • stick with heavy, you kick ass there !!!!

  • ok, that's very sloppy kirk, and rob(but I don't like you anyways) :(

    The only member I really like from metallica now a days is James, the heart of metallica.

    Pink Floyd is better for me right now though, even though metallica's in the back of my head as my favourite band always! since I was 9 years old.

  • Nie ta liga

  • It's kind of obvious this wasn't a serious attempt at all. If people would pay a little attention they would know Metallica does this from time to time, playing excerpts from tunes by respectable bands (and Iron Maiden) in an "unskilled" way, kind of like saying "we know we don't know this, but let's have fun with it". For my part, I'm thrilled they would choose this one because it's fucking awesome.

  • Kirk is great....but he is no Gilmour.

  • So Ugly..... !!!!!

    

  • Different.... I like different.....

  • Fuck

  • That bass is WAY off......and not in a way thats its even interesting......leave it to the masters next time!!!

  • Thats just Metallica fucking around...I'm sure they could pull off a decent version if they were bothered enough to learn it....which they obviously aren't!

  • I love Metallica I think they're great but they failed and should be very embarressed of what they did right there. Pink Floyd kicks Metallica's ass any day of the decade.

  • Seriously? RJ is a great bass player but I could do better than that when I was, like, 16... sorry to say.

  • fail! this is my first ever youtube 'dislike' lol

  • fail!

  • This really isn't one of these days. This is metallica playing a piss poor immitation of the bass riff from one of these days while hammet proverbially urinates on a guitar. For a start, it's a clean sound on rob's bass, and not pumped through a $4k echo device. And what's Lars doing on the drums? Mason's drumming is an integral part of the OTD sound and you can barely hear him here.

  • MA COS'E' STA MERDA

  • FUCKIN TERRIBLE! LONG LIVE PINK FLOYD

  • why 841 people dont like?

  • @CHIKO1985de watch "one of these days live pompeii" pink floyd and you will see why 844 dislike this. Be prepared to see how this was really meant to be performed. I like metallica but this is a disgrace to awesomeness!

  • I'm going to cut Metallica into little pieces

  • @wazar591 hahahahahaha

  • @wazar591 ... If you guys don't like Metallica, that's fine... But if you're going to write s**t about one of the best bands of all times, you should go f***k yourselves while you listen to the music you enjoy the most... : )

  • fuck metallica

  • trujillo perfect ,,but ..but,,but,,wtf,, is that,,hammlettttttshit,,boy game,,i hope david gilmour never see this shit like im doing all do way from from mexico city (PINK FLOYD FOREVER,,,

  • Shit, even on slide, Hammett has a horrible vibrato...

  • Truly awful

  • ummmm.... no

  • che schifo!

  • they wanted to cut us into little pieces but i don't even require a bandaid..

  • WTF! this suck.

  • ok so metallica acknowledges Pink Floyd, which most of us do

    and thanks for that, most people should in some way...

    but do butcher a song in the process...and expose a weakness

    not worth it..next time...I say, more practice or pick another song

    ONE OF THESE DAYS (I'M GOING TO CUT YOU INTO LITTLE PIECES)

  • Jesus, these guys suck.

  • korn did a good job with the brick

  • Both Pink Floyd and Metallica are legends. This is obviously just a jam! Why the disrespectful PF fans?! And saying Metallica cannot write song? Really? Even though we have the terrible, untalented "artists" who produce horrible pop songs you guys decide to trash Metallica's music and songwriting? My God.

  • The bass is SOOO wrong. Roger slaps it. and the guitar was overdone but not bad I'd say.

  • very bad.

  • really really bad cover

  • heyheyhey it's two fucking chords

    facepalm.jpg

  • @adognido

    It proofs why PF got there WELL deserved LEGEND status as a group ;)

  • Mmmm. Was it a seque into another tune? Or did James and Lars pop out for a quick piss? Because they shouldn't have bothered really...it's too half-assed.

  • Outrageous...

  • I luv metallica... But thus one us honestly Stupid

  • horrible version of a great song!

  • horrible.

    

  • One of these days & there's no drums

    Fuck

  • i dont know why everybody says it sucks

  • Horrible

  • @tropicalmadness impossible ... it's metallica

  • @ronofontario possible most of their stuff after the black album has literally been a piece of shit