Sharon is better of course, she have a better voice an she is more elegant, and she is more friendly and affectionate, she is a good singer and a good person!
Sharon has a better voice and is better in stage. Amy is a mezzosoprano and Sharon is a SOPRANO!!! Amy can't sing live like in the album, but Sharon sing better in live, she is amazing, had the voice of an Angel
@ceciliagio Sharon is not trained singer, just amateur. But her tessitura says that she's mezzosoprano, not soprano. And Sharon's terrible live, really. She has technically problems, lots of. Amy isn't good live either, but it's cause she jump and run too much around stage.
I think that they both are verry talanted singers, though i prefer Sharon. Amy Lee is not verry good live, but Sharon is amazing! But you can't really comprare them, their sound is verry different.
Love the picture at 0:50. The door, dress, image, the whole this is so cool. It's like the gate into heaven, to me. I like both singers, they're both amazing in their own unique ways!
i love the two singers and bands SO much! both singers are beautiful with amazing voices, u just can't compare them tho, they're COMPLETELY different. also they're styles of music and voices just can't b compared. i do prefer WT and sharon tho, not only cuz im dutch myself(XP) but because i prefer those songs more, some of them are so wise, i just adore them, sharon's an old soul, that's also y i prefer her but i love them both!
Ok let me clear some stuff up. Since I know lots bout music ( ot that you guys don't) Sharon is basically a professional opera singer, so she can nail the high head voice notes perfectly. She was trained that way. Amy has a bit more modern voice so her style is different. But basically they're both amazing
you are so right Amy Lee is higher on the food chain than sharon,,compared the Amy Lee, sharon seems so small , Amy Lee is the Queen of goth/metal and rock.
Amy Le<3 she is the much talented and best voice ,she can also play many diffrent instruments something that does her songs extra good both live and not. I like sharon but she has a too light voice and Amy has always been my IDOL<3 and her songs means so much more than sharons...
The only shame here is you trying to push your opinon on other people, and I hate to break the new to you but , your as dumb as they come, and don't know jack about music, Amy Lee has to much talent, and that just the way it is but try again OK,,we get a kick out of you,,your too funny,
Sharon really does put Amy to shame. Her voice is so much more pure than Amy's. Her voice sounds beautiful singing Ice Queen with high notes and really good with low notes in songs like The Howling and Our Solemn Hour. Amy's long notes and vibrato do not impress me.
Love Amy Lee..so much talent,,,look up top female rock singers and Amy Lee is #3 out of 100,,Sharon was 24 or 25 , cristina was 38 and tarja was not even on this list,,Amy Lee win again,,the world know this already.
Sharon is just more talented. Technically she simply has a better range, more octaves etc. Those lists mean nothing to me as most of these people making these lists haven't heard all the songs to compare properly.
es k no tienen pork comparar, io tengo mi favorita pork la he visto en vivo, pork he escuchado sus notas agudas, y pork simplemente es una de las mejores del género... "SHARON DEN ADEL" ^^
In my opinion, none are better than the other. They're both awsome woman who, to me, are both impossible to compare. An attempt to do so is futile. Keep on rockin you two!
Amy trys too hard in my opinion. She's a good singer in the studio, live..not really. I do like her though
Sharon however looks brilliant and flawless in most of her peformances. She is so beautifull, too. I never knew such beauty could be for real. But it is..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm sorry to dissapoint you but Amy Lee is and always be the best of the two,,it just the ways it is,,you can't stop the Amy Lee train,,she will run you over,,sorry you lose.
Sharon is without a doubt the best singer of those two. both in studio and LIVE. People saying anything else should really get to the doctor and check their hearing.
halambacka ,,LMAO you can't win this,,your a lost child with no where to turn,,is that why your gay? Amy Lee is better and allway been better,,the world know,,oh,,whats her name again,,wooohooo,,your a loserrrrrr
@jctcmc59 yes but my fav singer ohh her name IS TRARJA ASSHOLE CAN SING BETTER THAN YUOR ASSDIG AMY LEE,TELL TOR GAY LOVER AMY LEE TO SING THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA..HEHE SHE CANT...
halambacka ,your a nasty like girl and a foul mouth,,can you say anything without cursing,,and once again you sound retarted,,but keep it up its funny watching you have a meltdown,,Amy Lee wins again,,Amy own you...LOSER
such a lame comment,,but that is expected from you,,you got anything different to say, or is it the same old shit coming out of you mouth stinky little girl,,Amy Lee win again,,FOOL
@jctcmc59 fucker LEE HAS NEVER WIN AND WILL NOT WIN ASSHOLE..ID ASK U AGAIN FUCKERT CUZ UR 2 YEARS OLD.U R FUCKING AMY LEE'S MUM?R U AMY LEE'S BF/OR R U HER PUSSY WHICH IS NOT FUCKED AND U COME CRAZY?ASSHOLE
halambacka ,,would you like some cheese with that whine,,your a cry baby,,grow up or put the bottle back in your mouth and do what you do best and that is SUCK,,,20million sold and. yours?..LMAO not even close,,you lose again,,LOSER
@jctcmc59 fucker if those who sold are good then fucker madonna is better than lee cuz she solds more,and jonas bro and lady gaga..faget pop solds like lee faget..but lee is a whore which cant sing anything hehe loser
LMAO,,you losers couldn't find your ass with a garden rake,,Amy Lee will allways out shine sharon , hell she already does,,in everyway,,you can't and will never win this,,your not smart enough,,your european,,LOL,,I wonder if we took back the car, the light bulb, the airplane, the computer and the internet then what would you europeans do??I know what you have allways done,,walk around with your fingers up your ass
@jctcmc59 FUCKER WE LAUGH WITH U UR SO FUNNY..NO ONE LIKES LEE NOW AND SHE CANT WRITE ANY SONG ALL THE WORK OF FALLEN WAS DONE BY BEN MOODY WHICH SHE LEFT HIM CUZ SHE IS AN IDIOT LIKE YOU DUMBASS...
dude.. i agree whole-heartedly that amy lee is a good singer, but don't put all europeans in the same boat like that. i prefer sharon, and that's not cuz im dutch, i just prefer the music and voice better. if u want to win an argument, do it maturely(and i mean absolutely no offense with that whatsoever) but don't diss a whole group of people just because of one person... that's not cool man=(
I like both of them, but I have to admit I like Sharon a bit more. Sharon's got that angelic voice that sounds fantastic even live, and she's really funny. I used to really like Amy...sadly, until I heard her singing live... I'm sorry, her voice live just doesn't, IMO, match up to Sharon's.
I'm not bashing/glorifying either singer. Just my opinion.
@scarletdoherty amy cannot sing live-.- maby cuz her songs is freaking hard to sing + shes jumping around on the stage? but she now a grown up and her skills are much better than before(:
@evovenon : evanescence songs' hard? not really. i am a classical singer myself and i think WT songs are waaaayyy harder vocally. for sharon to nailed it everytime LIVE is beyond amazing.
but i got ur point.
amy can sing live but not as good as sharon.
aboveall, i am sooo jealous she could play n sing that good.
I would not want these haters as Amy Lee fans,,Amy Lee is better than all of the haters,,they just can't say who they like without disrespecting Amy,,thats why Amy Lee scares them, they know Amy Lee is better than there sing and it pisses them off,,it too funny.
oh and both amy and sharon r HOT AND BEAUTIFUL!! (im a girl just so u know and im straight lol) ^_^ my fav pick of amy is 2:55 she look like goddess w/ her floating hair just like eris of sinbad, 4 example lol XD and my fav pick of sharon is 3:05 love her dress looks like a goddess too...both r awesome dont get me wrong ^_^
at 00:40, is that amy's little sister's grave?...she doesn't look happy at that moment, u can see her face expression... oh poor amy i feel her pain :'(...well, i love u amy i respect u ^_^...plz ppl give her respect too she lost something near and dear 2 her,ok? like i respect sharon even if i don't hear her songs but some of her songs r good and i can't say she sucks bcus i dont know her or i never hear her songs b4 so.....
They're both my idols, but I prefer Amy, even Sharon's voice is amazing, Amy Lee's too and she's more an artist, she's a very very good pianist and it's really hard to both sing and play the piano ! By the way, if Sharon's voice is maybe better in live than Amy Lee's voice, I'd say that Sharon doesn't do what Amy does in lives....... Amy moves so much more!
I like em both equally. Sharon has such a pretty, almost delicate voice that calls you. Amy has a strong, independent voice that also calls you. Both of them have the most amazing voices. Not a lot of singers these days sound so unique. They almost all sound the same... Sharon and Amy are two unique ones. :D
Im a fan of both bands and them! they both rock! i love amy's voice! its so hanuting and mysterious but then again, sharon has that fragil voice that gives you chills down your spine! i vote for both! and i agree with "jctcmc59" they should!! :D
both of them are amazing artists. Though Sharons voice is much more delicate than Amy's, which is obvious. But like, they are completely equal in my book. -nods-
Well, Sharon's voice isn't all that delicate. it's more.... the best word is she sings delicately most of the time. but some of her songs aren't so delicate.
Yeah they're both beautiful and talented but REALLY on their own way. I like more Sharon's voice and WT's music but Ame is still very good (and Evanescence). :)
Even though I love Sharon very much, Amy Lee is touching me more then Sharon. Sharons voice is more open, wich is really beautiful... But I love Amy more... ^^
lets all agree that the girls rock that being said for deep lyrics that touch the soul i like amy for symphonic elegant voice i pick sharon and for hard core mean bitch i pick emilie lets add them up and add in 100s more bands now you got it
I`ve found brilliant live performances from Sharon, Amy, Cristina Scabbia and Simone Simons but no matter how hard i`ve looked i can`t find a good one from Tarja but i`ll keep looking.
Sharon is by far, the best of both, and had such a long and good career before Amy. Sharon and Tarja are probably the best female vocale metal queens ever... but the list is bigger and, to my opinion, does not inlcude Amy.
Tarja spen her career on partying thats why she got kicked out of nightwish i mean at least amy is on a goodpath and is doing her own thing i mean honestly theyare both good but i prefer amy and umm u dnt see many female vocalists like them these days
I guess that's the first time a rock/metal band one get's blamed by a fan 'cause of the party. I like more Sharon's because I find it to be more like goth metal than Amy. If you like to blame Tarja, it's ok, but she has the best goth metal voice ever, as she has a trained voice, and she can hit the tone she wants; and that's a fact, not an opinion. WHen you are a star, you always get mad; few starts have hit so high and haven't made mistakes. Tarja's voice it's the dark angel's voice on Earth.
Both are very interesting singers with unique voices. We don't really see a whole lot of unique singers. Anyone can sing, but few have true talent. Well, at least that's what one manga said. Either way, that statement is probably true. :D
why she scares u?! 4 me she's not scary she's beautiful i just like her style, and most of her pics r not scary like 0:22, 0:31, 0:58, 1:25, 1:43, 2:17, 2:25, 2:56, 3:02, 3:18, 3:47...those r not scary, but i like every pics of hers ...and sharon's pics too ^_^
Amy Lee is younger than Sharon, and a little bit more pretty, but... Sharon is really beautiful and her voice is amazing. In score I give 8/10 to Sharon and 5/10 to Amy.
I love Sharon. Her voice is so pure and angelic. I used to be an Amy Lee fan, but stopped listening to her after she released "Call me when you're sober." I am a huge Seether fan, and turned by back on Amy because she had no right to go out and make Shaun's private problems public. That was a very low thing she did.
This slideshow with the song is great, when I watch it...i feel like the pictures tell a different story along with the song.Great work! Sharon and Amy are fantastic artists btw
I love Amy. She is my role model. She is brilliant and strong and independent. She has such a strong voice. Sharon is good too, and has a beautiful voice, but Amy wins in my book.
I love both, but Amy is so different than Sharon, you can't compare them. Also, for me, Sharon is..closer. She's dutch like me and I saw her live..amy lives on the other side of the ocean. But anyboth, both are GREAT. But very different..
I love both Amy and Sharon...but I love Amy more..I think they are both amazing,have amazing voices and play with amazing bands... but I've loved Amy for years...and I find her to be in a differnt place than Sharon...
I like Sharon better. It seems to me that she looks more natural with this look. On the other hand Amy looks like she's trying too hard to be (or look) goth-ish... she looks better with the rocker chick style, rather than that goth wannabe...
(I like their music and there was no offence intended in my long comment.)
Sharon is better of course, she have a better voice an she is more elegant, and she is more friendly and affectionate, she is a good singer and a good person!
But Amy is also good.
despedidadelaoreja 6 months ago
i did this song in ma choir class ive been lookin for this song all over love it
scarlettrose1991 6 months ago
I really Pefer Amy Lee but Sharon is great too I dont see why People compare them, Their Both Amazing women of Rock!! their for They shall be Equal.
zellytega12 6 months ago
Sharon has a better voice and is better in stage. Amy is a mezzosoprano and Sharon is a SOPRANO!!! Amy can't sing live like in the album, but Sharon sing better in live, she is amazing, had the voice of an Angel
ceciliagio 8 months ago
@ceciliagio Sharon is not trained singer, just amateur. But her tessitura says that she's mezzosoprano, not soprano. And Sharon's terrible live, really. She has technically problems, lots of. Amy isn't good live either, but it's cause she jump and run too much around stage.
GothicAmy4 6 months ago
@GothicAmy4 Sharon is amazing in live, I saw Within Temptation concert and is so good singing live, really amazing.
ceciliagio 6 months ago
Sharon has a resemblance with keira knightly.. isn't it?
cassiecadiz 1 year ago
@cassiecadiz
No, no... no Avatar for this. Though it would fit nicely.
The song is by Adiemus and has been used by Delta Airlines
to underline its philosophy for many years.
040348 7 months ago
I think if these two beautiful did a duet together It'd be sooooo epic!!!!! I mean why don't they?
joxergirl 1 year ago
avatar music for this? wtf?
cheertildeath 1 year ago
2:34 She looks like Mulan a little =)
nightqueen14 1 year ago
Sharon for life :D
H3rvIk 1 year ago
The Victorian RockGirls ......can be a good name for a band
MADRID090 1 year ago
We're lucky to have them both, amazingly talented the pair
lucius1176 1 year ago
I think that they both are verry talanted singers, though i prefer Sharon. Amy Lee is not verry good live, but Sharon is amazing! But you can't really comprare them, their sound is verry different.
TemeraireWT 1 year ago 5
adiemus is the name of the song
lquezada55 1 year ago
what's name this song please ?
faust8866 1 year ago
Amy Lee is the living prove that you don't need to weight 50 kilos to be beutifull.
She is really pretty.
SnieznyAniol 1 year ago 2
Love the picture at 0:50. The door, dress, image, the whole this is so cool. It's like the gate into heaven, to me. I like both singers, they're both amazing in their own unique ways!
archergrl1996 1 year ago 2
You are right , I got caught up in the moment,,eveyone is different, I like Sharon and Amy.
jctcmc59 1 year ago
ilove Sharon And Amy Lee And I Think they are both great singers \m/
ALB072677 1 year ago 2
i love the two singers and bands SO much! both singers are beautiful with amazing voices, u just can't compare them tho, they're COMPLETELY different. also they're styles of music and voices just can't b compared. i do prefer WT and sharon tho, not only cuz im dutch myself(XP) but because i prefer those songs more, some of them are so wise, i just adore them, sharon's an old soul, that's also y i prefer her but i love them both!
abcsinging123 1 year ago
also, yes, Amy Lee is definitely the Goth Queen, but Sharon is still the Victorian Angel
th3rdhal3 1 year ago 3
Ok let me clear some stuff up. Since I know lots bout music ( ot that you guys don't) Sharon is basically a professional opera singer, so she can nail the high head voice notes perfectly. She was trained that way. Amy has a bit more modern voice so her style is different. But basically they're both amazing
th3rdhal3 1 year ago
you are so right Amy Lee is higher on the food chain than sharon,,compared the Amy Lee, sharon seems so small , Amy Lee is the Queen of goth/metal and rock.
jctcmc59 1 year ago
its insulting to sharon to be compared to amy.... amy is nowhere close lol
zarngrime 1 year ago
What song is playing?
And Sharon rules for all eternity!! One day I hope to meet the sweetest, most beautiful angel ever. <333
nightqueen14 1 year ago 3
I thinkt there both really good [although I do prefer Sharon :$]
But to be fair,I dont think they are Victorian what so ever.
PinkLunaStar 1 year ago
I agree evovenon
jctcmc59 2 years ago 2
Amy Le<3 she is the much talented and best voice ,she can also play many diffrent instruments something that does her songs extra good both live and not. I like sharon but she has a too light voice and Amy has always been my IDOL<3 and her songs means so much more than sharons...
evovenon 2 years ago
The only shame here is you trying to push your opinon on other people, and I hate to break the new to you but , your as dumb as they come, and don't know jack about music, Amy Lee has to much talent, and that just the way it is but try again OK,,we get a kick out of you,,your too funny,
jctcmc59 2 years ago
Sharon really does put Amy to shame. Her voice is so much more pure than Amy's. Her voice sounds beautiful singing Ice Queen with high notes and really good with low notes in songs like The Howling and Our Solemn Hour. Amy's long notes and vibrato do not impress me.
pantherz9103 2 years ago 3
Love Amy Lee..so much talent,,,look up top female rock singers and Amy Lee is #3 out of 100,,Sharon was 24 or 25 , cristina was 38 and tarja was not even on this list,,Amy Lee win again,,the world know this already.
jctcmc59 2 years ago
Sharon is just more talented. Technically she simply has a better range, more octaves etc. Those lists mean nothing to me as most of these people making these lists haven't heard all the songs to compare properly.
pantherz9103 2 years ago 4
pork hay musica de ADIEMUS ?? :P
jeje
es k no tienen pork comparar, io tengo mi favorita pork la he visto en vivo, pork he escuchado sus notas agudas, y pork simplemente es una de las mejores del género... "SHARON DEN ADEL" ^^
maririth 2 years ago
In my opinion, none are better than the other. They're both awsome woman who, to me, are both impossible to compare. An attempt to do so is futile. Keep on rockin you two!
zeldagirl1234 2 years ago 18
I do love Sharons voice
jctcmc59 2 years ago
Amy trys too hard in my opinion. She's a good singer in the studio, live..not really. I do like her though
Sharon however looks brilliant and flawless in most of her peformances. She is so beautifull, too. I never knew such beauty could be for real. But it is..
D1FF3R3NC3 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry to dissapoint you but Amy Lee is and always be the best of the two,,it just the ways it is,,you can't stop the Amy Lee train,,she will run you over,,sorry you lose.
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 fucker
halambacka 2 years ago 2
@jctcmc59 I do agree :D Amy is much more talented=D
evovenon 2 years ago
Sharon is without a doubt the best singer of those two. both in studio and LIVE. People saying anything else should really get to the doctor and check their hearing.
hjemme2 2 years ago 4
I love Amy's voice but music from evanescence are so repetitive.
mesatbk 2 years ago 2
maybe sharon is better live
but amy`s song and lyrics and voice is much more better
kaify12 2 years ago
halambacka ,,LMAO you can't win this,,your a lost child with no where to turn,,is that why your gay? Amy Lee is better and allway been better,,the world know,,oh,,whats her name again,,wooohooo,,your a loserrrrrr
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 HEHE ASS DIG U MAKE NO SENSE ASS DIG...FUCKER..
halambacka 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 yes but my fav singer ohh her name IS TRARJA ASSHOLE CAN SING BETTER THAN YUOR ASSDIG AMY LEE,TELL TOR GAY LOVER AMY LEE TO SING THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA..HEHE SHE CANT...
halambacka 2 years ago
amy is better
freakersball7 2 years ago 2
halambacka ,your a nasty like girl and a foul mouth,,can you say anything without cursing,,and once again you sound retarted,,but keep it up its funny watching you have a meltdown,,Amy Lee wins again,,Amy own you...LOSER
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 HEHE FUCKER lee WONT WIN NO ONE CUZ SHE A LOSER LIKE U ASSDIG...
halambacka 2 years ago
such a lame comment,,but that is expected from you,,you got anything different to say, or is it the same old shit coming out of you mouth stinky little girl,,Amy Lee win again,,FOOL
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 fucker LEE HAS NEVER WIN AND WILL NOT WIN ASSHOLE..ID ASK U AGAIN FUCKERT CUZ UR 2 YEARS OLD.U R FUCKING AMY LEE'S MUM?R U AMY LEE'S BF/OR R U HER PUSSY WHICH IS NOT FUCKED AND U COME CRAZY?ASSHOLE
halambacka 2 years ago
halambacka ,,would you like some cheese with that whine,,your a cry baby,,grow up or put the bottle back in your mouth and do what you do best and that is SUCK,,,20million sold and. yours?..LMAO not even close,,you lose again,,LOSER
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 fucker if those who sold are good then fucker madonna is better than lee cuz she solds more,and jonas bro and lady gaga..faget pop solds like lee faget..but lee is a whore which cant sing anything hehe loser
halambacka 2 years ago
LMAO,,you losers couldn't find your ass with a garden rake,,Amy Lee will allways out shine sharon , hell she already does,,in everyway,,you can't and will never win this,,your not smart enough,,your european,,LOL,,I wonder if we took back the car, the light bulb, the airplane, the computer and the internet then what would you europeans do??I know what you have allways done,,walk around with your fingers up your ass
jctcmc59 2 years ago
@jctcmc59 FUCKER WE LAUGH WITH U UR SO FUNNY..NO ONE LIKES LEE NOW AND SHE CANT WRITE ANY SONG ALL THE WORK OF FALLEN WAS DONE BY BEN MOODY WHICH SHE LEFT HIM CUZ SHE IS AN IDIOT LIKE YOU DUMBASS...
halambacka 2 years ago
@jctcmc59
dude.. i agree whole-heartedly that amy lee is a good singer, but don't put all europeans in the same boat like that. i prefer sharon, and that's not cuz im dutch, i just prefer the music and voice better. if u want to win an argument, do it maturely(and i mean absolutely no offense with that whatsoever) but don't diss a whole group of people just because of one person... that's not cool man=(
abcsinging123 1 year ago
Agreed. Sharon's the one with the real voice. Amy is bulls*** compared to Sharon. Only a f***ing idiot would say differently. Hello jct.
TheOmegaAnon 2 years ago
amy lee is fucking annoying she is trying to hard on everything and fails hard at it, she is nutn but a redneck.
while on the otherhand Sharon is a naturally born with a good voice,looks and acts.
EwFreDDe 2 years ago
I like both of them, but I have to admit I like Sharon a bit more. Sharon's got that angelic voice that sounds fantastic even live, and she's really funny. I used to really like Amy...sadly, until I heard her singing live... I'm sorry, her voice live just doesn't, IMO, match up to Sharon's.
I'm not bashing/glorifying either singer. Just my opinion.
Felicity1247 2 years ago
i am a BIG fan of amy lee. and i just recently listen to WT. sharon is beyond amazing. and i love her instantly.
u made good point saying amy can't really sing live. yes, that's true.
but she did great job singing and playing live version of acoustic songs though. it's beautiful.
scarletdoherty 2 years ago 2
@scarletdoherty amy cannot sing live-.- maby cuz her songs is freaking hard to sing + shes jumping around on the stage? but she now a grown up and her skills are much better than before(:
evovenon 2 years ago
@evovenon : evanescence songs' hard? not really. i am a classical singer myself and i think WT songs are waaaayyy harder vocally. for sharon to nailed it everytime LIVE is beyond amazing.
but i got ur point.
amy can sing live but not as good as sharon.
aboveall, i am sooo jealous she could play n sing that good.
super talented :)
scarletdoherty 2 years ago 10
what song is this? :)
brokooooli 2 years ago
I would not want these haters as Amy Lee fans,,Amy Lee is better than all of the haters,,they just can't say who they like without disrespecting Amy,,thats why Amy Lee scares them, they know Amy Lee is better than there sing and it pisses them off,,it too funny.
jctcmc59 2 years ago
oh and both amy and sharon r HOT AND BEAUTIFUL!! (im a girl just so u know and im straight lol) ^_^ my fav pick of amy is 2:55 she look like goddess w/ her floating hair just like eris of sinbad, 4 example lol XD and my fav pick of sharon is 3:05 love her dress looks like a goddess too...both r awesome dont get me wrong ^_^
ZAshleyAngieZ 2 years ago
at 00:40, is that amy's little sister's grave?...she doesn't look happy at that moment, u can see her face expression... oh poor amy i feel her pain :'(...well, i love u amy i respect u ^_^...plz ppl give her respect too she lost something near and dear 2 her,ok? like i respect sharon even if i don't hear her songs but some of her songs r good and i can't say she sucks bcus i dont know her or i never hear her songs b4 so.....
ZAshleyAngieZ 2 years ago
i love both sooo much
Sharon rocks the victorian goth look
and Amy is more of a "love metal" goth
not to mention they're both BEAUTIFUL
TheWeaselLady13 2 years ago
sharon will always be my hero but amys still awsome too. i cant say whos better cause in my mind they're both the same ^.~
zeldagirl1234 2 years ago
They're both my idols, but I prefer Amy, even Sharon's voice is amazing, Amy Lee's too and she's more an artist, she's a very very good pianist and it's really hard to both sing and play the piano ! By the way, if Sharon's voice is maybe better in live than Amy Lee's voice, I'd say that Sharon doesn't do what Amy does in lives....... Amy moves so much more!
They are both great, but Amy wins \o/
MarylinMansonx3 2 years ago 2
These two are my idols. They are so beautiful and have amazing unique voices... I can't choose who is better, they're both amazing.
laahaalaahaa 2 years ago
Same here. Amy is more of my favorite, though, because she's more gothic.
yaoiluvr007 2 years ago 2
Sharon it's the best
amy le only studio
xixorochi 2 years ago
sharon is the best
MAMDOLORES74 2 years ago
Amy Lee For the win! :D most beautiful woman ever! sharon isn't bad either..but I prefer Amy :) <3
TheAmyLite 2 years ago
Adiemus - Adiemus is the song.... found on the First Pure Moods CD.
Draveken 2 years ago
Enya
blizzardsuperfan 2 years ago
I like em both equally. Sharon has such a pretty, almost delicate voice that calls you. Amy has a strong, independent voice that also calls you. Both of them have the most amazing voices. Not a lot of singers these days sound so unique. They almost all sound the same... Sharon and Amy are two unique ones. :D
danielledear1 2 years ago
@danielledear1
Couldn't say it better myself. ^^
PrincessAmayari 2 years ago
what is song??
radd91 2 years ago
Sharon Van den Adel is dutch ^^^^^^
dutchw1ngs 2 years ago
AMY....AMY AMY id have to say AMY!!!!!
69SRHxx 2 years ago
Im a fan of both bands and them! they both rock! i love amy's voice! its so hanuting and mysterious but then again, sharon has that fragil voice that gives you chills down your spine! i vote for both! and i agree with "jctcmc59" they should!! :D
101evfan 2 years ago
both of them are amazing artists. Though Sharons voice is much more delicate than Amy's, which is obvious. But like, they are completely equal in my book. -nods-
stereotypical06 2 years ago
Well, Sharon's voice isn't all that delicate. it's more.... the best word is she sings delicately most of the time. but some of her songs aren't so delicate.
7babyphat7 2 years ago
Amy Lee has an angelic, haunting voice, and lyrics that are off the charts and people connect with her, just the facts of the matter.
jctcmc59 2 years ago 4
i agree. i connect with every single one of her songs i've listened to....
If Amy Lee was the only person in the world besides me, i wouldn't miss Sharon that much.. as long as her music was still out.
7babyphat7 2 years ago
A my is beautiful
but i say sharon sharon sharon ...
more sharon sharon sharon and sharon
and million times say sharon
gallyokis 2 years ago
Amy is so pretty! but i like sharon's voice more.
Breathenomore1232 2 years ago
the song is Adiemus, from Enya.
one of the best melodies ever written.
grFreeCulture 2 years ago
What is the name of this song?
I loved the video!
I think Shraon and Amy are both
equally beautiful people with enchanting
voices. However, they are beautiful in their own way.
Thank you for making this.
(:
Neesalovesyou 2 years ago
EVANESCENCE!!!
sweetdeadlyvenom 2 years ago 2
Sharon Den Adel é a melhor.
Indrawtsharon 2 years ago
I wish Amy and Sharon would do a kick azz rock song together
jctcmc59 2 years ago
Yeah they're both beautiful and talented but REALLY on their own way. I like more Sharon's voice and WT's music but Ame is still very good (and Evanescence). :)
almafiina 2 years ago
I love Sharon and Amy but I have grown to love WT more than Evanescence
andrika1990 2 years ago
Comment removed
zeldagirl1234 2 years ago
Sharon Sharon
You're the best
icer82 2 years ago
sharon sharon and sharon
gallyokis 2 years ago
It's impossible to choose. They're both simply perfect for their styles and the music they make. Indescribable. Amazing.
CrimsonGrape 2 years ago
agree with you there! theyre both unique which is what i like about em XD
zeldagirl1234 2 years ago
they have different styles and voices so its not fair to compare... as far as im concerned...amy's style and sharon's voice
zouzoukini 2 years ago
AMY LEE,,love her,,soo much talent,,damn
jctcmc59 2 years ago
sharon x3
daniellebizarre 2 years ago
This song is really beautiful! I love it, what is it? <3
xfuckingstonerx 2 years ago
Its from Enya and the song is Adiemus or something like that.
demofrom 2 years ago
sharon is the best!!!! i dont mean to insult amy lee but sharon is way better!!!!!!!!!!!
xryxella 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
xryxella 2 years ago
Even though I love Sharon very much, Amy Lee is touching me more then Sharon. Sharons voice is more open, wich is really beautiful... But I love Amy more... ^^
BehindThisMusic 2 years ago
Sharon is a picture of pure beauty <3
D1FF3R3NC3 2 years ago
Still tarja's voice?OMG Tarja is a classic singeeeeeerrrr! why can't you understand? Sharon is an angel! that's the fact!
Readaphne 2 years ago 2
what is name this song
summerwine1608 2 years ago
Adiemus - Adiemus
brNNNbrNNN 2 years ago
lets all agree that the girls rock that being said for deep lyrics that touch the soul i like amy for symphonic elegant voice i pick sharon and for hard core mean bitch i pick emilie lets add them up and add in 100s more bands now you got it
TearisShatteredMoon 2 years ago
love this song<3
cangrylives 2 years ago
no me desagrada en lo absoluto Evanescence....pero indiscutible la música, y por supuesto la voz, de Sharon es mucho mejor...
daskane 2 years ago
I`ve found brilliant live performances from Sharon, Amy, Cristina Scabbia and Simone Simons but no matter how hard i`ve looked i can`t find a good one from Tarja but i`ll keep looking.
Bysectrix 2 years ago
what's the music plz?
takotak64 2 years ago
sharon isn't victorian, amy is but not sharon. im not sure exactly what sharon's style is, but i dont think it's victorian
singreadswimlove 2 years ago
i like evanescence more than within temptation... their music sounds more powerfull
alexecristiana17 2 years ago 3
i disagree, i think within temptations music is more powerful.
singreadswimlove 2 years ago 4
Song is Adiemus, originally by Adiemus but this version is Enya´s.
almafiina 2 years ago
:P Emilie Autumn is the best Victorian rock girl!
but Sharon has my vote!
Neona135 2 years ago
wats the name of the song u set this to? it sounds cool, ilike it!
lostndbrokenwithoutu 2 years ago
Here in my country I do not know who is Evanescence . Is this another Limp Bitzkit commercial crap ?
NSlave 2 years ago
beatiful...i love this video
icequeenwtevan9407 2 years ago
Sharon den adel and Amy lynn lee are the Godesses of th music!!!
icequeenwtevan9407 2 years ago 5
Sharonnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!!!!!!
You're the best!
cocoye33 2 years ago 4
amazing 5 stars
w amy and shar
what's name of this song?
30stmjohnnyavriljare 2 years ago
which is the real name of the song?
Tearjerker772 2 years ago
I personally do not think either one is better, because they ultimately sound different although they are similar in genre.
I do think it would be incredible if they did a duet!
alexatetris 2 years ago 3
It would be just amazing if they did a duet! I would love to hear it!! :-D
lanbo28 2 years ago
Sharon is by far, the best of both, and had such a long and good career before Amy. Sharon and Tarja are probably the best female vocale metal queens ever... but the list is bigger and, to my opinion, does not inlcude Amy.
axeldor 2 years ago
Tarja spen her career on partying thats why she got kicked out of nightwish i mean at least amy is on a goodpath and is doing her own thing i mean honestly theyare both good but i prefer amy and umm u dnt see many female vocalists like them these days
villeluv1 2 years ago 3
I guess that's the first time a rock/metal band one get's blamed by a fan 'cause of the party. I like more Sharon's because I find it to be more like goth metal than Amy. If you like to blame Tarja, it's ok, but she has the best goth metal voice ever, as she has a trained voice, and she can hit the tone she wants; and that's a fact, not an opinion. WHen you are a star, you always get mad; few starts have hit so high and haven't made mistakes. Tarja's voice it's the dark angel's voice on Earth.
axeldor 2 years ago
I think Robert Westerholt and Josh Hartzler are the luckiest bastards ever!
rosesxdaggers 2 years ago 5
Both are very interesting singers with unique voices. We don't really see a whole lot of unique singers. Anyone can sing, but few have true talent. Well, at least that's what one manga said. Either way, that statement is probably true. :D
danielledear1 2 years ago 2
amy scares me! Sharon for beauty, voice, songs, talent, costumes, and accent!
WithLoveAliceCullen 3 years ago 2
why she scares u?! 4 me she's not scary she's beautiful i just like her style, and most of her pics r not scary like 0:22, 0:31, 0:58, 1:25, 1:43, 2:17, 2:25, 2:56, 3:02, 3:18, 3:47...those r not scary, but i like every pics of hers ...and sharon's pics too ^_^
ZAshleyAngieZ 2 years ago
they are so amazing
benniskjaldbaka 3 years ago 2
A year ago I found this and it brought that amazing song to me again! Thank you!
almafiina 3 years ago 2
I choose both. Can't decide.
They both rock the rock/metal worlds.
Candy96969 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hmmmm,,lets,,no sound like evanescence,,Amy Lee voice is soo beautiful, to much talent,,Sharon,,not so much
jctcmc59 3 years ago
Amy Lee is younger than Sharon, and a little bit more pretty, but... Sharon is really beautiful and her voice is amazing. In score I give 8/10 to Sharon and 5/10 to Amy.
mralpro 3 years ago 2
Sharon is prettier than Amy. But they are both beautiful in there own way I guess.
andrika1990 2 years ago
I happy that women have finily got their due,,Amy rules
jctcmc59 3 years ago
Great video!!! :)))
Enangar 3 years ago
That was really cool, loved the song! :)
SpiritHawk7 3 years ago
both.
amy and sharon rock x]
xwithintemptationx 3 years ago
Sharon for the win. THey're both great, but I enjoy hearing Sharon more.
alissashape 3 years ago 2
that song is: adiemus - adiemus
bouno1986 3 years ago
what song is this?
RexyBX 3 years ago
I mean they'r both the best :P! surely
saneumesma 3 years ago
They are different styles so yes technically they can both be the best at what they do...
RandomMaggot 3 years ago 4
Amy :P she's the greatest
saneumesma 3 years ago
AMY!!!!
Victorian9322 3 years ago
they are both nice artists but amy is my love!!!!!!!!!!!!go amy i will always be with you11111111111111111
purpledeadfairy 3 years ago
at the pic of 36sec. Sharon looked like Julia roberts. not the faded pics in the background but the profile shot
soccerchik5592 3 years ago
they r the beeeeeeeeeesssssssssttt !
nepalas 3 years ago
I love Sharon. Her voice is so pure and angelic. I used to be an Amy Lee fan, but stopped listening to her after she released "Call me when you're sober." I am a huge Seether fan, and turned by back on Amy because she had no right to go out and make Shaun's private problems public. That was a very low thing she did.
BizenghastGhost 3 years ago
This slideshow with the song is great, when I watch it...i feel like the pictures tell a different story along with the song.Great work! Sharon and Amy are fantastic artists btw
Imabarbiegirlinabarn 3 years ago 2
even though i die for evanescence!
i love both girls!!they rock!
constantineofdarknes 3 years ago 2
I love Amy. She is my role model. She is brilliant and strong and independent. She has such a strong voice. Sharon is good too, and has a beautiful voice, but Amy wins in my book.
xxWolfgirl16xx 3 years ago 4
mine 2
Victorian9322 3 years ago
I love both, but Amy is so different than Sharon, you can't compare them. Also, for me, Sharon is..closer. She's dutch like me and I saw her live..amy lives on the other side of the ocean. But anyboth, both are GREAT. But very different..
SjoukJDB 3 years ago 2
I just wanna hear them sing together..Isn't that a thought
rowingfar 3 years ago 8
I love both Amy and Sharon...but I love Amy more..I think they are both amazing,have amazing voices and play with amazing bands... but I've loved Amy for years...and I find her to be in a differnt place than Sharon...
RandomMaggot 3 years ago 3
Amy lee!!!!
fahevans 3 years ago
I LOVE the both of them. There BRILLIANT! =)
They have FANTASTIC voices.
AzumaNinja01 3 years ago 3
I love amy and sharon a ton but amy lee can kick her butt anyday
mandyloveskittycats 3 years ago
mandyloveskittycats I dont think Amy will kick sharon cuz Sharon has more vocal skill than Amy
NOTE Im not soyin Amy isnt good, on the contrary she is really good at singing but Sharon is a soprano and Amy a mezzo soprano
the result is that both r good and they have inspired me a lot
kiotocitystories 3 years ago 2
I think amy is more alto. alhough she can hit soprano sometimes. sharon is more soprano but she can sing at a lower range too
andrika1990 2 years ago
and I love Amy for her power, creativity independence and I love Sharon for her voice and for her delicacy
kiotocitystories 3 years ago 4
Sharon is better:)
koalastephanie 3 years ago
I like Sharon better. It seems to me that she looks more natural with this look. On the other hand Amy looks like she's trying too hard to be (or look) goth-ish... she looks better with the rocker chick style, rather than that goth wannabe...
(I like their music and there was no offence intended in my long comment.)
saugac03 3 years ago 4
do you know the name of the band that singing this song please tell me thank you
fireprincess88 3 years ago
It's Enya, the song is Adiemus
MissingHelena 3 years ago
you luky one.i love them both, but ilisten mostly wt.iwant to see them but i think they dont came to cyprus.
ibluesky 3 years ago