As much as I love Les Paul and Mary Ford's original version, The Manhattan Transfer does a magnificant cover of this song. The original artists are most often very pleased when other artists cover their songs, and I'd risk a guess that Les Paul approved!
@TheFRiNgEguitars: Les Paul made a famous recording (1951), sure; but not the original: How High the Moon: Music by Morgan Lewis; Lyrics by Nancy Hamilton (1940).
@benjaminlhaines Yes, and it was first performed in the Braoadway show, "Two for the Show". Ella Fitzgerald also recorded a scat version of "How High the Moon". I accept a demerit for not crediting the songwriters. However, the first popularized version of any song will usually be recognized (arguably) as the "original version" (that many people know) which the artists are given full credit!
@TheFRiNgEguitars Fair enough. Speaking of Ella scatting, have you checked out that awesome [forgive tired, over used word] 6 1/2 minute clip on youtube of Ella scatting? Do! For all I know, you might have posted it.
@TheFRiNgEguitars Right you are, Steve. Who appreciates a really good song more than another musician? I don't think anybody does - because a musician knows what it takes to get the sound just right. They've made the song their own. To say one is better than the other is like saying, "Which child do you love most?" We just love them both. Les Paul/Mary Ford was unique. Manhattan Transfer is unique. We're the lucky ones because we get to hear both.
@mortygwhiz Yes, very much so. I'm slightly surprised they didn't go back to Benny Goodman's version instead for inspiration in making their own version. (Even his version wasn't the original; the song first appeared in a movie soundtrack, but it was the first hit version.) But the Les Paul and Mary Ford version is very well known.
They have a great vocal balance, but yah I find them to be a bit shallow.. wish there musical selection was a bit more obscure or even written for them.
Wow! I remember listening to the Les Paul and Mary Ford original over and over when I was a kid, but this is special. And the guitarist lays down some serious licks on that axe!
i think they should have 8 people instead of 4. it's funny they were on home improvement and said their names were Tim and Allen and whaddayaknow? It's true
its nice..but they completely shattered this song..ella fitz did such a nice job..and it was beautiful..i dont like this version as much..but to someone somewhere..this is there baby..so i have to say its ok..=]....
i think the words deserve a little more then a fast tempo a good band and good harmonies..thats all..the best part that i think did just was the girls solo in the middle..but its still too fast....
Five thumbs up!
jeweljgemini 1 month ago
i like les paul,s version better.
chrishibbs201012 4 months ago
Kinda hurts mah fingers...
50Emerald 5 months ago
ЭТО ГЕНИАЛЬНО!!!!
GuitarEUGENIA 6 months ago
háha_gÉbt_mâl_bëI_gÕoglë:_geldeasy_éÌñ_voll_kráss
tomchesanek 9 months ago 19
Incredible musicians! They use and control their voices like instruments!!! :-)
isimilkova1 10 months ago 2
amazing!!!!!
mandarin993 10 months ago
nerealu
mandarin993 10 months ago
SON ALUCINANTES Y LOS MUSICOS LOS MEJORES
rockitoblues 1 year ago
un resumen de toda la histia del jazz
rockitoblues 1 year ago
SOOOOO GREAT!!
trizzler 1 year ago
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
MartaBtrp 1 year ago
Encantadora versión de los ManTrans!!
Charmin' rendition with a plus!
.)
Magamaguitam 1 year ago
Now thats more like it.....some of these post's just destroy Les Paul and Mary Fords great hit.............
goffbum 1 year ago
great singing - who is the flute player? nice
EverythingProS 1 year ago
@EverythingProS She's the one playing the flute.
benjaminlhaines 1 year ago
Buddy Williams is a master drummer. He's on my 12 tune Cd that is being mixed now.
jazz1bro 1 year ago
good music can withstand many different interpretations ... and this is a good one.
. o O ( but I still like Les Paul and Mary Ford's better)...
louswire 1 year ago
@louswire their better version is on the cd Bop Do Wopp
Belchmaster41 1 year ago
Junto con Weather Report, los más escuchados por mí allá en los 80s, fantásticos!!!
Muy agradecida por haberla compartido conmigo, Leo, me trajo muy buenos recuerdos y vaya que si los necesitaba hoy!
;)
Magamaguitam 2 years ago
They aint no Les Paul and Mary Ford that's fuh shore.
Froggy19510 2 years ago
As much as I love Les Paul and Mary Ford's original version, The Manhattan Transfer does a magnificant cover of this song. The original artists are most often very pleased when other artists cover their songs, and I'd risk a guess that Les Paul approved!
TheFRiNgEguitars 2 years ago 9
@TheFRiNgEguitars: Les Paul made a famous recording (1951), sure; but not the original: How High the Moon: Music by Morgan Lewis; Lyrics by Nancy Hamilton (1940).
benjaminlhaines 1 year ago
@benjaminlhaines Yes, and it was first performed in the Braoadway show, "Two for the Show". Ella Fitzgerald also recorded a scat version of "How High the Moon". I accept a demerit for not crediting the songwriters. However, the first popularized version of any song will usually be recognized (arguably) as the "original version" (that many people know) which the artists are given full credit!
TheFRiNgEguitars 1 year ago
@TheFRiNgEguitars Fair enough. Speaking of Ella scatting, have you checked out that awesome [forgive tired, over used word] 6 1/2 minute clip on youtube of Ella scatting? Do! For all I know, you might have posted it.
benjaminlhaines 1 year ago
@TheFRiNgEguitars Right you are, Steve. Who appreciates a really good song more than another musician? I don't think anybody does - because a musician knows what it takes to get the sound just right. They've made the song their own. To say one is better than the other is like saying, "Which child do you love most?" We just love them both. Les Paul/Mary Ford was unique. Manhattan Transfer is unique. We're the lucky ones because we get to hear both.
nemo227 2 months ago
yeah man... people are crazy for thumbs downing that statement brother.
andrewguy768 2 years ago
Comment removed
Froggy19510 2 years ago
Que Guitarrista !
leoblack97 2 years ago
I like it. I like MT.
lindalds 2 years ago
Sounds like a tribute to Les Paul and Mary Ford.
mortygwhiz 2 years ago 3
@mortygwhiz Yes, very much so. I'm slightly surprised they didn't go back to Benny Goodman's version instead for inspiration in making their own version. (Even his version wasn't the original; the song first appeared in a movie soundtrack, but it was the first hit version.) But the Les Paul and Mary Ford version is very well known.
quadibloc 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no soul thay are shit!
markrobson 2 years ago
Lots of soul ! love it!
grenadian11 2 years ago
They have a great vocal balance, but yah I find them to be a bit shallow.. wish there musical selection was a bit more obscure or even written for them.
Skygerobrian 2 years ago
Wish granted! Look under your christmas tree.
unorgurlzball 2 years ago
@Skygerobrian I thought they wrote a lot of their own arrangements, no?
benjaminlhaines 1 year ago
gotta love the harmony...gives me chills
ena1490 2 years ago 2
this sounds like the arrangment by steve zegree....is it?
KelsosaurusRex 2 years ago
Wow! I remember listening to the Les Paul and Mary Ford original over and over when I was a kid, but this is special. And the guitarist lays down some serious licks on that axe!
rightousaussie 2 years ago
Wonderful way to Jazz.. Brillant harmony and the Band was awesome... go guitarist !!
dpunero 2 years ago 2
I am so happy for this. Manhattan Transfer were and are unique.
5023849465 2 years ago
Really dig Wayne Johnson's solo. Awesome!
wirmeth 2 years ago
ok... so they didn't have 14 track over-dub... it still sounds great!
louswire 3 years ago
i think they should have 8 people instead of 4. it's funny they were on home improvement and said their names were Tim and Allen and whaddayaknow? It's true
okonh0wp 3 years ago
its nice..but they completely shattered this song..ella fitz did such a nice job..and it was beautiful..i dont like this version as much..but to someone somewhere..this is there baby..so i have to say its ok..=]....
sidekickstupidco 3 years ago
Why did they shatter it? It´s just a standard, their close harmonies are nearly perfect, the band is great - so where´s the problem?
anonymusum 3 years ago
i think the words deserve a little more then a fast tempo a good band and good harmonies..thats all..the best part that i think did just was the girls solo in the middle..but its still too fast....
sidekickstupidco 3 years ago
do you know this is Manhattan Transfer right?
kububeach 3 years ago
very good. Guitar & musicans are awsome. Beautiful harmont..
hanker95 3 years ago
I love this song. Nice Harmony, Nice players!
ism023 4 years ago