@ KPKaccount: yeah, and also those people ca only go forward not backward. Because if you do there will be accident. In Vietnam if you go forward, people will avoid you.
@RichyDYupYup Actually, our country is developing on the other sides not traffic XD cuz this kind of traffic is sort of our "custom" no one can change that, even the gov't, so everyone accepts it :))
There are plenty of accidents, but they are usually small and people just get back on their bikes and limp home.
The real fun is when you need to cross the street... You have to walk into the street and wait till the bikes swarm around you back and front, then you do one step forward at a time, whilst allowing bikes to swerve around you as you walk. Quite a tourist experience!
they also drive this in indonesia,i think the reason is because theyre impatient and always wanna be in a hurry,they dont care about other drivers confinience,all they care is going fast,arriving at point B as quick as they can.
@robloxpwnmaster3 Because cars here are all imported, a car costs 3 to 4 times the original price. Not many people can afford that kind of price. Just imagine you have to pay 4 times as much for that car you're driving, would you buy it? No? And that's you're living in a developed coutry and make 10 times a month than us.
@zoophobe1 guess what would happen if each scooter is replaced by a car ? the same reason why the governments want us to pay 150% for cars which made cars not very affordable. ;)
There are 3.35 times as many fatal accidents in Vietnam than in Holland where there are rules and stoplights on these types of crossings. But it sure looks hilarious.
@s3xcr3w lmaoooooooooo. funny thing is when i first went back to vietnam i was waiting for a red light but found out that there were no lights lmao. so i wait and then ran across, stupid move cause the guy tried to avoid me but he moved in the direction that i was running in and almost hit me.
that's when i learned that all u had to do was walk across and people will avoid you lol
@lucirz yep, exactly how it is done. There is Vietnamese joke, the best way to cross busy Vietnamese road is to close your eye, and cross slowly, (no sudden movement)
The weather, the girls at the clubs n karaoke bars, n the best of all, the price!! Damn I'm making my self drool I think I'm gonna go tmr. Fuk my job, fuk my life, fuk Canada!!! I'm going to VIETNAM!!!! Lol
To anyone who haven't experience driving a scooter at nite in Saigon especially on a Friday n Saturday nites then u r missing out on a thrill of a life time!! It is one of the most fun things u can do, with ur girlfriend's (or hooker's) arms wrapped around ur waist zigzagging thru traffic with the wind blowing on a hot sexy nite is just paradise!! Can't wait to go back in a few months....... After u've been there u'll never want to leave or be anywhere else.....the food, the fruits, the weath
Yeah but here you don't have to worry. You are either hi by something big enough to instantaneously end your life, or you crash into someone else then climb back on your scooter.
tell you what, Vietnamese people are great at coordination overall, look at those people on 2 wheels no crashing, honking is for the purpose of letting others know your presence, not to invoke
it may look like chaos to most people but they understand the way traffic flows. i watched this a couple times and haven't seen any accidents. they have adapted to their environment unlike americans.
If you want to be trained for good driving skills and fast reaction , go there , you stupid Canadians . Just think that you are good drivers , huh ? . Dare you race in this kind of traffic ! .
Why are they using their horns all the time? After 10 years of intense traffic full of traffic jams, they still haven't understood that their horns won't solve the problem?
About 380 young monks and nuns who are followers of Buddhist leader Thich Nhat Hanh, have called on the French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, to grant them temporary asylum, after they were forced to flee Bat Nha monastery and repeatedly attacked by vigilantes allegedly hired by the Vietnamese authorities. They say the government regards their leader as a threat to its authority due to his fast-growing popularity among the youth.
i dont know how we did it back in the day ...but man it seems like it s gettin way worse since i was there..it is totally insane ..i would hate to work at the ER in saigon ?!!.
Ho chi Minh, Vietnam's communist leader, is a disguting TRAITOR & MURDERER! In exchange for chinese military aids in the war with France (1945-1954), he gave up Paracel & Spratly archipelagos with large oil resources to China. He even ordered to murder his own mistress named Nong thi Xuan when she threatened to disclose her sexual relationship with him since that would destroy his image as a "Father" of Vietnam who "sacrifices" his whole life for Vietnam revolution.
Prosperity only exists in big cities in Vietnam like Hanoi and Saigon, but 80% of Vietnamese population live in poor, underdeveloped rural areas. While corrupt communist leaders like Prime minister Nguyen tan Dung and President Nguyen minh Triet are multi-billionaires, a regular Vietnamese earns only $1 per day. More than 200,000 Vietnamese women from poor families, many as young as ten, are working as prostitutes and sex slaves in China, Cambodia, Thailand, Malaysia, Taiwan, and Korea.
I dunno. It's kinda chaos, but seems like everyone makes it through. If that intersection were orderly and had a traffic light, people would be waiting for hours to get through.
yeah u fucking pricks have sex with ur own moms and dont even give a fuck abt it.. stop shouting shit on the net.. go fuck some whore off the street over get urself fucked from the back with a big black dick.. fuckin douchebag..
@ KPKaccount: yeah, and also those people ca only go forward not backward. Because if you do there will be accident. In Vietnam if you go forward, people will avoid you.
anhho1997 3 weeks ago
Was that last guy turning left was he riding a Horse or Mule or was he on a slow bike.
AliensUTubedME 2 months ago
ฮ่า ๆๆ ออยน่ากลัว
wasana758 2 months ago
I would go cross-eyed! i dont think anyone gave anyone the finger either, hee, hee!
1707054 2 months ago
impossibru!! >.<
snejtueg 3 months ago
crazy undeveloped countries
RichyDYupYup 3 months ago
@RichyDYupYup Actually, our country is developing on the other sides not traffic XD cuz this kind of traffic is sort of our "custom" no one can change that, even the gov't, so everyone accepts it :))
peteredmade 3 months ago
@peteredmade lol ok :) just looks kinda lawless out there!
RichyDYupYup 3 months ago
@RichyDYupYup That's our law which is what you re watching now =)))
peteredmade 3 months ago
holy mother fucker shit pussy fuck!!!!!!!!!!!!!
usukker 4 months ago
There are plenty of accidents, but they are usually small and people just get back on their bikes and limp home.
The real fun is when you need to cross the street... You have to walk into the street and wait till the bikes swarm around you back and front, then you do one step forward at a time, whilst allowing bikes to swerve around you as you walk. Quite a tourist experience!
glytzhkof 4 months ago
was this filmed with a pepperoni roll?
wvBlackGun 4 months ago
AHAHHAHAHAAH PENCIL
ArmageddonArena 5 months ago
loooooooooooooooooooooool
MrGimmlie 5 months ago
put on some more traffic lights u gay bastard
GuardianDemonX 6 months ago in playlist Vietnam
I am in VietNam, and this traffic is very nomally, it can't have accidents...
tuhsome 6 months ago
It's not no accidents, it's just the people will just move the roadkill/human aside and continue!
DubCmusicTV 7 months ago
If i had one dollar for every pixel on this video, i would have one dollar
killeronthebeach 7 months ago 14
Sounds like a mass of bees.
av3ryx 7 months ago
they also drive this in indonesia,i think the reason is because theyre impatient and always wanna be in a hurry,they dont care about other drivers confinience,all they care is going fast,arriving at point B as quick as they can.
KPKaccountt 8 months ago
Ok my guestion is.
why the heck not?!?!?!?!?!?!?
Conway79 8 months ago
Now that's skill!!!
tsolorio3001 9 months ago
HOLy MUDA MARY .
UnstoppableGames 9 months ago
May I suggest.....traffic lights?
nottinghamization 9 months ago
Holy freakles what is this!?!?!? LOL!!
wzcefiro 9 months ago
wow,almost no cars!
adityayergolkar1995 9 months ago
Asians cant drive MY ASS!! asians drive too good for western traffic!
wizzzer1337 10 months ago
Ok my guestion is.
why the heck is everyone riding a modorcycle?!?!?!?!?!?
robloxpwnmaster3 10 months ago
@robloxpwnmaster3 cause its cheaper than a car...
shadowsofdream 10 months ago
@robloxpwnmaster3 Because cars here are all imported, a car costs 3 to 4 times the original price. Not many people can afford that kind of price. Just imagine you have to pay 4 times as much for that car you're driving, would you buy it? No? And that's you're living in a developed coutry and make 10 times a month than us.
phambaohoa 10 months ago
@phambaohoa O
robloxpwnmaster3 10 months ago
right,it" freedom" in Vietnam and i feel not to bad to be a citizens on the street.:D
kelvinjiro 11 months ago
what the heck there is no car?
zoophobe1 11 months ago
@zoophobe1 guess what would happen if each scooter is replaced by a car ? the same reason why the governments want us to pay 150% for cars which made cars not very affordable. ;)
blackknight1803 11 months ago
Begin to shut up about out "trafficjams"
Jarusuka1 1 year ago
MOTOCYCLE WORLD!!!!
XxJoelFCBarcaxX 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thơ của thằng VC tố hữu chém giết nhân dân và
nịnh bợ thằng ngọai bang:
.
Giết giết nữa bàn tay không ngừng nghỉ,
Cho ruộng đồng tươi tốt, thuế mau xong,
Giết giết nữa bàn tay không ngừng nghỉ,
Cho Đảng bền lau cùng rập bước chung lòng,
Thờ Mao chủ tịch, thờ Xit-ta-lin bất diệt..."
(bồi bút Tố Hữu)
TangTuyetMinh 1 year ago
And this is why it'll always be... a third world country.
thi711 1 year ago
man how munch is cost a stop lite this country have a big traffic problem they shout learn how respet trafic
Machodejalisco1 1 year ago
'
what city in VN,,,
how come no have traffic sign lights
bestamerica 1 year ago
Imagine what will happen when they introduce electricity to this country!
ThePhrenzy 1 year ago
@ThePhrenzy
Was it really necessary to say that? Have some respect for other people and countries.
Kinoru 1 year ago
WTF
cocuuco 1 year ago
Perfectly controlled chaos.
JulianoRamirez 1 year ago
Всем похуй!!
Pulsus142 1 year ago
haha what a bunch of fuckn gooks
inktoxicated 1 year ago 2
There are 3.35 times as many fatal accidents in Vietnam than in Holland where there are rules and stoplights on these types of crossings. But it sure looks hilarious.
MagicBoterham 1 year ago
there all going to a party at my place
AJFan1234 1 year ago
traffic in vietnam like ant colony
nhacviet2008 1 year ago
In Vietnam, road crosses you
IgnoredComment 1 year ago 7
@IgnoredComment LOL ROFLMFAO Ya Soviet Russia has nothing on this!
blva888 3 months ago
HOW DO THEY NOT WRECK THEY ARE EITHER CRAZY DRIVERS OR GREAT ONES !
Mr53562 1 year ago
@Mr53562
Oh, they wreck a lot, lot's of deadly accidents.
Been there several times in Vietnam.
UyLuy84 1 year ago
@UyLuy84 but for a population of 80 millions in a size of a large USA state, the accident rate is nothing compares to other countries
IgnoredComment 1 year ago
@IgnoredComment you got a point, I haven't studied the statistics but yeah you got a point.
UyLuy84 1 year ago
Asians are just pro at driving.
fugernut 1 year ago
@fugernut lol
Intosia 1 year ago
hahahaha incredible
pr5021 1 year ago
Comment removed
InsaneGoonRules 1 year ago
yeah ^^ i m proud to be a vietnamese
Vietnam has the most motorcycle in the world,
calculated by the land area per qm²
s3xcr3w 1 year ago
@s3xcr3w lmaoooooooooo. funny thing is when i first went back to vietnam i was waiting for a red light but found out that there were no lights lmao. so i wait and then ran across, stupid move cause the guy tried to avoid me but he moved in the direction that i was running in and almost hit me.
that's when i learned that all u had to do was walk across and people will avoid you lol
lucirz 1 year ago
@lucirz yep, exactly how it is done. There is Vietnamese joke, the best way to cross busy Vietnamese road is to close your eye, and cross slowly, (no sudden movement)
the traffic avoids you,
IgnoredComment 1 year ago
indeed, mansonly, indeed. i second that
KelthurChiang 1 year ago
The weather, the girls at the clubs n karaoke bars, n the best of all, the price!! Damn I'm making my self drool I think I'm gonna go tmr. Fuk my job, fuk my life, fuk Canada!!! I'm going to VIETNAM!!!! Lol
mansonly 1 year ago
To anyone who haven't experience driving a scooter at nite in Saigon especially on a Friday n Saturday nites then u r missing out on a thrill of a life time!! It is one of the most fun things u can do, with ur girlfriend's (or hooker's) arms wrapped around ur waist zigzagging thru traffic with the wind blowing on a hot sexy nite is just paradise!! Can't wait to go back in a few months....... After u've been there u'll never want to leave or be anywhere else.....the food, the fruits, the weath
mansonly 1 year ago
hahahahaha
TypowyPolak 1 year ago
theres always traffic in vietnam how do i no well i've been there :D and its so much fun!!
xlilygirlx 1 year ago
in other countries, beeping the horn has the top 5 most common sayings:
1. Fuck You!!
2. Hey, How Are Ya?
3. Get Off My Ass (Meaning Car)
4. Nice Car
5. Wake The Fuck Up!!!!
Indestructible229 1 year ago
wow look's like Ant
annie3204 1 year ago
Yeah but here you don't have to worry. You are either hi by something big enough to instantaneously end your life, or you crash into someone else then climb back on your scooter.
MrSemperFidelity 1 year ago
damn i still remember having to walk through this craze. almost got my foot ran over n_n
animeangel1441 1 year ago
ROFL i their bike test must be 5 times harder then ours.
j0rzeh 1 year ago
đánh cho Mỹ cút
đánh cho khúc ruột ngàn dặm nhào
SinhCung 1 year ago
tell you what, Vietnamese people are great at coordination overall, look at those people on 2 wheels no crashing, honking is for the purpose of letting others know your presence, not to invoke
phedoblue 1 year ago
=)))) cat de tareee
bebelinna 1 year ago
it may look like chaos to most people but they understand the way traffic flows. i watched this a couple times and haven't seen any accidents. they have adapted to their environment unlike americans.
yobuttin 1 year ago
lots of motorcycles dang
moldeecheese 1 year ago
Looks like the traffic in Beirut. They drive with their eyes not by their right! we could learn from that, here in the so called west!
trademark1874 1 year ago
Why bother buying a car there. It's just gonna get dented 'n scratched.
lesliekwan80 1 year ago
Get a giant lawn mower and run over the lot of them.
Kauwhaka 1 year ago
If you want to be trained for good driving skills and fast reaction , go there , you stupid Canadians . Just think that you are good drivers , huh ? . Dare you race in this kind of traffic ! .
fcukthecigarette 1 year ago
Comment removed
fcukthecigarette 1 year ago
Oh-My-God I can't believe this mess....
F3FisGoodforYou 1 year ago
The upside to this "jam" is that it's is still moving quickly. so unlike cars, you can get through intersections quickly.
Aspekitteh 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
TP HCM = Tội Phạm Hồ Chí Minh
MinhKhai1 2 years ago
Why are they using their horns all the time? After 10 years of intense traffic full of traffic jams, they still haven't understood that their horns won't solve the problem?
kamratframjandet 2 years ago
And they do it all day... with minimal accidents...!
quysweat 2 years ago 25
...and then one day, the Hell's Angels came to town...
DancingSpiderman 2 years ago
ill go play there
123animator123 2 years ago 2
Amazing traffic not crazy..(no accident)
sound horn to say im here not to say fuck u like other country
trido1986 2 years ago 64
@trido1986 y'r so funny ilu now
incrediablelove 1 year ago
@incrediablelove ilu 2 now and later although i donot know u
trido1986 1 year ago
@incrediablelove ilu 2 now and later although i donot know u but im not sure i'll know u,thanks
trido1986 1 year ago
@trido1986 no accident
aizemborg 1 year ago
@trido1986 its incredible driving in 3rd world countries....i'm frm india, i invite u here, bring ur helmet ;)
natureloverdude 1 year ago
@trido1986 nice!
antandant 11 months ago
damn that is amazing scary traffic..
samquan123 2 years ago
voll verrückt vorallem überall roller un dann bämm en bus der voll net durchkommt so geil^^
MultiFewer 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HELP BAT NHA MONASTERY!!!
(Vietnam) Dec 17, 2009
About 380 young monks and nuns who are followers of Buddhist leader Thich Nhat Hanh, have called on the French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, to grant them temporary asylum, after they were forced to flee Bat Nha monastery and repeatedly attacked by vigilantes allegedly hired by the Vietnamese authorities. They say the government regards their leader as a threat to its authority due to his fast-growing popularity among the youth.
TOMP66666 2 years ago
i dont know how we did it back in the day ...but man it seems like it s gettin way worse since i was there..it is totally insane ..i would hate to work at the ER in saigon ?!!.
57dragonball 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ho chi Minh, Vietnam's communist leader, is a disguting TRAITOR & MURDERER! In exchange for chinese military aids in the war with France (1945-1954), he gave up Paracel & Spratly archipelagos with large oil resources to China. He even ordered to murder his own mistress named Nong thi Xuan when she threatened to disclose her sexual relationship with him since that would destroy his image as a "Father" of Vietnam who "sacrifices" his whole life for Vietnam revolution.
TOMP66666 2 years ago
Prosperity only exists in big cities in Vietnam like Hanoi and Saigon, but 80% of Vietnamese population live in poor, underdeveloped rural areas. While corrupt communist leaders like Prime minister Nguyen tan Dung and President Nguyen minh Triet are multi-billionaires, a regular Vietnamese earns only $1 per day. More than 200,000 Vietnamese women from poor families, many as young as ten, are working as prostitutes and sex slaves in China, Cambodia, Thailand, Malaysia, Taiwan, and Korea.
TOMP66666 2 years ago
ma e un manicomio per caso??
luigidatorino 2 years ago
hahahahaa unbelievable
gpowersuprime 2 years ago
they're insane :D
ChainsmokingPothead 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bunch of stupid Viet ,we will sent you all out to the sea.
MAOTSETUNG2000 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tiên sư Hồ tặc thứ gian hùng
Giống chó to họng Nguyễn Sinh Cung
Chí Minh danh tiếng thằng bội bạc
Thị Xuân nó hiếp chảy máu hồng
Tao đái vào lăng bao giòng lệ
Mày nằm phơi xác mả gà đồng
Rắm tao từng tràng nhả thành tiếng
Bắt mày phải hửi hết kể công
SinhCung 2 years ago
Doesnt anyone ever crash? XD?
flamingpoodleofdoom 2 years ago
waw..this is unbelievable..
moriankoo 2 years ago
omg, i think this is the first time ive seen so many motocycles on a road
archucky 2 years ago
Awesome, you can see a guy crossing the road and he just keeps walking
sc841 2 years ago
LOL DAMN! That guys a beast.
shinfire13 2 years ago
nice poems, you cheaps!
rannero2 2 years ago
TP HCM = Tội Phạm Hồ Chí Minh
MinhKhai1 2 years ago
Thằng Minh thằng Duẩn thằng Đồng
Thằng nào cũng chỉ một lòng hại dân
Thằng Minh là đứa bất nhân
Hiếp xong rồi lại giết phăng là thường
Thằng Giáp là một thằng ngu
Đeo lon đại tướng bịt mu đàn bà
Thằng Chinh dại chợ khôn nhà
Tố cha, tố mẹ, ông bà tố luôn
MinhKhai1 2 years ago
are you poet? although I don't understand the content of this poem.
xiaoping1303 2 years ago
street filled with moto is scenery
,because only in vietnam you can see such moto rivers
gongdaweinan 2 years ago
the beaps will happen like every 3 secs
naruto199624 2 years ago
The beauty of controlled chaos ...
gobitz 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crazy people.
There are bunch of animals. lol
b8alumrock 2 years ago
Racism!
heavyrain2408 2 years ago
all of you are barbaric racists!!!
heavyrain2408 2 years ago
(O)____(O) W T F WAS THAT?..........
namas000 2 years ago
lol theyre a bunch of animals
Squashcooper 2 years ago
all farmers
thinkinrich 2 years ago
I dunno. It's kinda chaos, but seems like everyone makes it through. If that intersection were orderly and had a traffic light, people would be waiting for hours to get through.
fuzztubeyou 2 years ago
Interesting...
Yeah, people are quick to judge how a society should be run based on the standards that they encounter at home.
...but perhaps a roundabout might help their situation? =o
UnscriptId 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THis is one of the obvious reasons why we bomb and terrorize VIETNAM.......
fatdaleon 2 years ago
And when someone write something like this it's obvious that you are an idiot with very small brain and penis..
Kleppann 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You have no right to speak to me, a lowly slave of Allah.
fatdaleon 2 years ago
never thought i would say this..but im glad i live in jkt.
krahong 2 years ago
at least theyre in control unlike those lunatics in usa trying to race to put food on their table
sexking83 2 years ago
Im sooooo glad I live in the USA
DrPoon 2 years ago
You're kidding right. Except You don't live VietNam. I'm living in HCM and that is normal to me.
quainhankid14 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
vietnam is my country but this video is not true
thinkinrich 2 years ago
ahahahhahahahahhahahahahahha
sohardyeah 2 years ago
god.... chaos.....but no crash...im surprised.....:D..im lucky that i live in Slovakia xD i wouldn't like anything like this behind my house:D
OnnomonnomonnO 2 years ago
lmao...this shit is worst than LA!
geloyspirc 2 years ago
Perfectly organised! That's the way traffic should flow!
thamry721 2 years ago 28
lulz
GehUebenDuToy 2 years ago
@thamry721 here's the amazing thing....no traffic lights.
animelubbor432 1 year ago
@thamry721 : you don't know! I'm Vietnamese, that's crazy, not organized
cachia02 1 year ago
wanne hear a true fact? everyday, there would be more than 1 human brain pour all over the street, from whichever city
hsbinh1412 2 years ago
Holy shit!
ShaskaOcelot 2 years ago
This is how the traffic should be. LA, NY should learn from this to resolve their traffic problem.
vnRock 2 years ago
LMAO
NC403Firefighter 2 years ago
WOW that was organized:P
pjuske2 2 years ago
wow! cool
gsr205nighthawk 2 years ago
that is one of the most craziest traffic i have seen.. and i have been to vietnam.. it actually works lol.
rollinpace4lyf 2 years ago
it does indeed LOL !!
mikebenh 2 years ago
ce gramada dezordonata!
ursusivulpea 2 years ago
skills baby....
jamzchaos 2 years ago
LOL...asians reproduce so much they need motorbikes to reduce the traffic...FUCK WY DONT ASIANS JUST STOP HAVIN SEX
aneesbluezero 3 years ago
they got some cute looking girls though
rollinpace4lyf 2 years ago
no, why don't YOU just start have more sex?
iranjackheelson 2 years ago
yeah u fucking pricks have sex with ur own moms and dont even give a fuck abt it.. stop shouting shit on the net.. go fuck some whore off the street over get urself fucked from the back with a big black dick.. fuckin douchebag..
potterbond007 2 years ago
there was a lane of traffic that split another into 2!
maadgyal69 3 years ago
fuck :O
GoneDad 3 years ago
at the first look - they are insane...
but look again - no accidents so far :)
i guess they know how to drive
Plantum21 3 years ago
Crazy.
landgrader6 3 years ago
That is scary, cars in new york are one thing but it's gang mentality when you have a motorbike, what do old people do?
shadymatzoh 3 years ago
I think this effectively rules out the possibility of old people existing.
SilentServiceCode 3 years ago 3
Holy fuck! is right. damn!
Cod3Z3r0 3 years ago
OMG :O
marius620 3 years ago
holy fuck!
metale666 3 years ago
Ehm. Don't they have traffic lgihts? O.O
Yangie12 3 years ago
how'd u git it.!.? did u stalk on dem.,,,;omg watchin back at dat, ridin on dose is veri fun, especially if u dont git hit ! xDD
PhweshVietWeirdo 3 years ago
meh... guess the vid must be really shite quality to be that bad and make it seem like that..
jonnycy1 3 years ago
No coffee needed for this morning commute!
TN922 3 years ago
Holy crap, and it looked like no one was hit. Got to give it to them bikers.
HstufGottberg 3 years ago
OMG^^..xDD
Jushniykray 3 years ago
motorcycle rules.lol
2008dio 3 years ago
OMG ants. no ofence.
bestia89 3 years ago
jonnycy1, this video is 100% REAL!!!
I lived in VN. I know!
freefatherly 3 years ago
is it longdon or paris ?
thinkinrich 3 years ago