Added: 2 years ago
From: andylukk
Views: 101,268
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (156)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 都唔似- -

  • 攪到我意為沙龍係Mr.唱既TIM..

  • it seems like ah Paul singing....

  • 把聲唔好再似D...lol

  • @XBen91 佢地有d自己作既歌都幾好聽架..

    例如想太多..黑色狂迷戈d...

  • i think this is not mr

  • 像是只有聲帶, 少了感情和唱功的Eason.

  • 佢地把聲係似 但都係會有d分別..

  • honestly, he did a great job although eason sings this song better.

  • 真係Mr.?

  • @shirleysowy, i think it was alan that sang the demo of this song. eason's mentioned that once on a program that alan sang the demo of one of this songs. i forgot whcih song it was but it could be this one.

  • @mlsi 於心有愧

  • 每个人都有自己的风格,mr应该有自己的风格啦。

  • Mr. 唱的key低左, 但都有自己的風格!!!

    eason好好多!!!

  • @yiplee0912 it's the same key, are you tone deaf?

  • 歌詞唔錯。。。

  • 音樂係用黎交流,吾係用黎比較

  • @lookgoods

    like it!!!!

  • eason is better thaN ..........

  • Eason better !!

  • e神唱好聽好多..

  • 未夠火侯

  • TO:kevin2037

    嗱!要吋人呢就要揾齊証據噃小朋友!如果唔係就會好𤓓架啦...­...

  • demo?

  • 好似mr同陳奕迅都唔係

  • Mr.係903唱嫁,唔識野=.="

  • @Timmyjai

    thanks for that info! :)

  • Mr.黎架= =

  • 唔係mr黎

  • sounds like he is pooing

  • stop smoking

  • 歌詞都唱錯

    咩叫虛爛如電??

    唱都唱得認真d啦

  • 唱錯歌詞有幾咁唔閒呀-.-

  • 係mr. 黎既咩,,都唔似既

  • Comment removed

  • 其實我覺得佢把聲唔好似Eason. 唱腔都唔係好似。音唔係捉得好準。有D位唔夠氣,同breath­ing point 有關。No offense, just my humble opinion.

  • 呢個唔係MR。囉 -.-

  • how come there is no video?

  • 其實mr應該將首歌唱得rock d / 激動 d比較適合佢~~

    跟eason的唱法,佢會唱得好辛苦,就好像2.53,easo­n係feel到先唱上去,佢反而變咗硬要唱上去~~

  • 加油呀Mr

    人地冇講話好聽

    甘你地可以唔聽姐

    下面個nightXdark 講得岩,

  • I think so too, maybe they were trying to do something new :)

  • 一樣就等於好聽?都幾笑丫:D:D:D

    把聲係有小小似又點?聲是與生俱來 自己唔可以變 強硬變都唔好聽啦= =

    我反而覺得alan唱得唔錯啵:):):)

    或者可能係新人對歌唱仲未係好熟

    把聲仲有D未夠遠 有種再難小小就快走音既感覺!

    MISTER加油!:D

  • 用假音唔等於用唔到真音唱高音...

    唔鐘意acoustic version既去聽返原唱咪算囉... 咁多意見,,,

  • his voice similar to eason. but he dun have the magnetic feel like Eason. Shalong is one of my favourite song ever! GO EASON!!!

  • mr 應該發展自己的style

  • 感覺唱得有d唔穩= =n有d緊

    不過overall唔錯啦

  • 唔同style,

    同eason一模一樣=好聽?

    諗清楚啦:)

  • 講唱功同聲線

    係eason 唱得好過alan

    不過alan 唱有第種feel

    alan唔係唱得難聽..係eason唱得重好姐

    最好都係mr. =]

  • 呢隻唔係一開頭eason唱之前, alan幫手唱既demo咩?

  • '於心有愧' 先係=]

  • 無為比喇大家

    如果一隊新band 出黎

    可以好聽過香港公認最好果個之一

    咁新人洗咩進步

  • Eason's voice is stronger. still think he's better than Mr. though they are also quite gd

  • MR的確係一隊gd band~

  • 好聽a~~~~

    同Eason 又係唔同ge style

  • 好難聽?你去唱呀...

    eason好d就一定..原唱黎嫁人地..

    有幾多首歌..人地可以唱得好過原唱..

    點解你一定要比較呢??

  • Eason sings so much better...

  • 我覺得eason果把聲靚d...

  • 佢吾係專登扮咖..聽真d Mr有佢既風格咖 :)

  • 你一定係佢地fan屎, 洗唔洗喺每條mr.片都留同一句留言呀??

  • Mr. , Dear Jane, Rubberband, Kolor 我都有睇, 自己係夾band都會留意下本地band, 尤其是會留意下香港人會對呢d band有咩評價, 所以我有睇啲留言... 請繼續支持本地樂隊...

  • 咁你加油 :)

  • 仲有呀 唱歌係要同音樂夾架 唔係好似d人唱k咁狂嗌 自己有自已唱 音樂有音樂播囉

    呢個version後面d音樂咁smooth,alan用真音,­肯定會大聲過晒d音樂啦

  • 講真 臨尾果句唔係好高音,好多人用真音都唱到,想太多既"避開你是.­...捉不到最初"呢PART仲高音啦,ALAN唱到有突,只係­吒個VERSION 係acoustic,用真音爆太strong,所以用假音 係好正常囉 外國好多acoustic都係咁 好似daniel powter d歌咁 如果用真音爆,咪會好難聽囉@.@

  • good!

  • good!!!!

  • 無知的會員們,您知唔eason同mr 好fd架,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,mr係崇拜eason­先唱姐

  • 唔驶评咩似唔似,总之两个都唱得就系啦...

  • 點解甘鐘意將mr 同埋eason作比較呢?聲線似者嗎,都吾同style.而且我­都唔覺得MR唱得難聽啦,各有各好.兩個我都甘鐘意!

  • 我覺得唱得不錯

  • frankly speaking我唔覺得係MR唱.......

  • I think it is

  • Eason and Mr. has different style, just cause their voice is similar doesn't mean they are trying to pretend Eason. Why do you always have to compare it to Eason ???

    What if this is not Mr. but someone else with a totally different voice, will you still compare to Eason ??

    Different people sing differently, there's not a perfect way to sing !!!

  • 如果大家覺得唱得唔好而批評

    絕對可以

    但請尊重別人

    如果大家覺得Mr.似Eason而批評

    請搞清楚似o既原因

    唔好用主觀o既態度去睇客觀o既事情

  • 唱得唔錯=)

  • Mr.唱呢首歌個時係o係電台訪問個時唱架,咁唱得差左個dd你­地就o係度嘈,識唔識尊重架?試下你去唱丫,我肯定你唱得差過佢­10倍,什至100倍呀,好心你尊重下音樂啦

  • 仲有尊重下Mr.!!!!!!

  • not bad !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 一定要下下用真音爆上去先好聽架咩

  • 呢個應該係 live 版

    所以有差既地方係正常既

    雖然唔係話好似

    不過都唔錯吖

    如果太似 eason 反而會有 d 遜色

    因為會冇左mr既風格

  • 差=正常??????

  • 屌你班仆街

    唱得似eason又會抄人風格

    唱得唔似又話冇左神髓

    想點?

  • Comment removed

  • 幾好呀.....幾有自己風格呀....歌手最緊要有自己風格.­.....

  • 你地甘多位甘講又唔岩喇

    其實每個人唱歌都有自己既演釋方式

    如果你地要返之前果個feel

    你地返去聽返陳奕迅喇

    唱得唔同唔代表唔好聽

    若果有人覺得自己唱得比佢好既就post出黎

    如果唔係就唔好彈人地 應該用返欣賞既角度

    唔鍾意佢唱既大家可以唔聽唔留言

  • 用假音是種情緒舖陳

    mr成首歌都用左個較eason輕鬆既感覺去唱

    所以我覺得無問題

  • 有rock味的聲音

  • ok...

    但好似冇咩感情= =

    [的一秒]有點兒怪

    最尾果句用真音唱先有feel.

    某d音似eason

  • 佢咬字好似有D怪..

  • Comment removed

  • 似eason+黃貫中喎我覺得

  • 如果用耳仔細聽聽 就會很容易分別到了~"~

  • 人地都係唱demo姐=0=" 洗唔洗咁多批評呀?

  • 2:54~2:55 果個"的一秒"好似差少少喎

  • Seriously I don't understand why people claim they can't distinguish his singing from Eason. His voice may be a bit similar, but his techniques are at least two levels below.

  • 其實我覺得mr.  vocal 把聲真係好似..哈哈

  • only demo for eason, didn't aim for perfection.

  • 其實Alan同Eason係唔同風格,

    Alan的確唔係咁適合唱pop,

    佢只適合唱D重D rock味既歌

    所以冇話邊個好邊個唔好既

  • 係mr唱沙龍demo比eason聽...

  • 字既尾音做得未夠好..搞到好似冇乜感情噤

  • 哇~我反而覺得佢泥首歌唱得好似許志安

  • alan 唱得唔錯架啦..

    題外話, 如果覺得自己似另一個人而嘗試繼續去做個個人, 最後多數失敗, 反而繼續抬個被模仿個個

  • 我個人覺得alan巴聲好特別

  • 完全同意

    一開始都唔錯

    但到難既地方全部變晒假音

    好似"成為父母的一秒"同最尾"何來塵埃飛舞"

    呢兩句一定要用真音唱上去先好聽

    睇完eason live 完全明白點解eason咁紅

  • 假音=扣分?

    好明顯唔識音樂

    唔該你聽下個編曲,係全acoustic, unplugged既

    用真音會於這個version會過於激昂,失去左個more relaxed既feel, 相反用eason既studio version, 當然用返真音會比較適合

    真係無知

  • 果句唔係假音,輕真音,因為太輕聽落去似假音。如係識聽ge,應­該知道假音個底同真音個底ge分別。

    如果呢到有人係自認學過聲學又要堅持係純假音,我冇野好講。

  • 有學聲樂的人是叫「弱音(half voice)」吧。mr的vocal是可以爆上去,但聽得出他有­保留。

  • i agree!!

  • 有d似許志安

  • 虛爛如電 虛幻如霧 sosad

  • 手歌好難唱 ,最尾真係唱到冇氣!!

  • 唔明點解難唱,可能因為你唔學過聲樂。

  • 把聲係似...但係好明顯阿臣唱得好好多`

  • alan好耶a0a!

  • 第一次聽everyone仲以為係eason唱ge...

    真係好難分

  • 高下立見

  • alan把聲真係好似EASON!

  • 聽聽下似許志安多d-.-

  • 音好飄 音準有待改善

    雖然聲底似eason

    但唱功似乎差距明顯

    最後既高音上唔到 失望

    假音同真音個情緒差好遠

  • Mr.系叱吒樂壇唱呢首歌

    o既原意系覺得好聽系1首好歌~

    並不是要學Eason!!!!!!!!!!!

    你覺得似

    就話Mr.刻意學Eason

    咁對Mr.好唔公平喎!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Quite good, just feel a bit too strong.

  • 真系幾似eason~

  • Amazing Vocal...!

  • 可見沙龍真係唔易唱

  • His vocal performance is so gd!

  • Yes!! Alan's voice is so Amazing!! :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more