Added: 4 years ago
From: ruriel2
Views: 27,230
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (250)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • If you remember before a commercial break that night Seacrest kind of gave it away when he said "And Melinda goes home after the break" I mean I know he was talking about showing clips from her hometown visit but still

  • 1:53 I would like to shoot that girl in the back...

  • Honestly stopped watching after that. Should've at LEAST won 2nd cause Blake did nothing but beatbox if i remember correctly.

  • FOR ME, THE REAL WINNERS ARE: Season 1 - Kelly Clarkson Season 2 - Ruben Studdard Season 3 - Fantasia Barrino or LaToya London Season 4 - Carrie Underwood Season 5 - Chris Daughtry or Elliott Yamin Season 6 - Melinda Doolittle Season 7 - David Archuleta Season 8 - Adam Lambert Season 9 - Crystal Bowersox Season 10 - Pia Toscano
  • she lost because she didnt have the it factor. she shouldve never lost she was the best there but thats what america voted so ....

  • Melinda should have won. She was my favorite and she still is. No one in American Idol can be better than her.

  • This is a big American problem

  • who the hell is blake lewis and why did he make the final? lol he cant even sing a ballad

  • I loved Jordin since her audition. I'm so glad she won, she deserved it. But Melinda should have been in the finale with her. Nothing against Blake but Melinda was better than him. It's as simple as that

  • @pscanyc3 you can wаtϲh tv from аll οvеr the ԝοrld οո yοսr pϲ jսѕt by dοԝոloаding sοmе рrogram, it's ցοt tհoսѕaոdѕ of chaոոels on it. ϳսst ցo tο linevid com (рut а . beforе the сοm, it won't let mе poѕt lіnkѕ for sοme reason) іt's a bіt рriϲеy bսt іt'ѕ jսѕt οոe time аոd іt works rеаlly wеll

  • Melinda might be a great singer, but she doesn't connect to younger viewers.

  • IT WAS RIGGED.. DIDN"T HEAR HOW EVERYONE BOO'D WHEN SHE GOT ELIMINATED.

  • This WAS rigged!!!!

  • Adam Lambert, Melinda Doolitle, and Carrie Underwood are the three most flawless performers I have ever witnessed on American Idol(and maybe add David Archuleta to that group)! Melinda with no doubt in my mind was the best of Season 6 and should've won in a Landslide but yet Jordin was deserving as well.

  • jordin is very talented teen that time.. but if melinda made it into the final that year.. oh my god.. melinda will slaughter jordin.. in the highest form of slaughtering..

  • i love melinda!!! she should've won the AI6... it's really unfair for her.......... i've never had a dull moment watching her every week... This season 2010 is really boring, i thought it'l be gonna be a good season but they evicted those great singers with more potential on winning this season.......... melinda big fan here!!!!

  • If the best always won, it would have been like this:

    1. Kelly Clarkson

    2. Clay Aiken

    3. Jennifer Hudson

    4. Carrie Underwood

    5. Chris Daughtry

    6. Jordin Sparks

    7. Carly Smithson

    8. Kris Allen

  • u r wrong Adam Lambert should won season 8 and he is the best ever idol existed

  • Melinda and Jordin should've been the final 2. As much as I love Jordin, Melinda was simply the BEST.

  • @CoolTDIguy815 i love melinda!!! she should've won the AI6... it's really unfair for her.......... i've never had a dull moment watching her every week... This season 2010 is really boring, i thought it'l be gonna be a good season but they evicted those great singers with more potential on winning this season.......... melinda big fan here!!!!

  • this was when American Idol became useless

  • This was the moment when America became a joke, no way did Melinda deserved to get eliminated.

  • Melinda deserved this WAY more than blake. She and jordin would have made one heck of a finale.

  • Season 1 - Kelly Clarkson

    Season 2 - Clay Aiken

    Season 3 - Fantasia

    Season 4 - Carrie Underwood

    Season 5 - Chris Daughtry (no one cares about taylor hicks now)

    Season 6 - Melinda Doolittle

    Season 7 - DAVID COOK <3

    Season 8 - It should've been Danny or Allison or even Anoop!!!! As long as it isn't Kris Allen!!!!!

  • omg o cried

  • season 1 KELLY

    season 2 CLAY

    season 3 JENNIFER HUDSON OR FANTASIA

    season 4 CONSTANTINE OR BO OR CARRIE

    season 5 TAYLOR HICKS

    season 6 MELINDA DOOLITTLE

    season 7 MICHAEL JOHNS CARLY SMITHSON OR DAVID COOK

    season 8 ADAM LAMBERT

  • kris allen is great.. he deserves to win..

  • That was so wrong. Like Ryan said, she truly was one of the most amazing singers ever on AI.

  • Worst moment ever

  • Comment removed

  • yup i agree

  • damn jordin got no titties..melinda looks great

  • Randy is right..She's the most consistent contestant ever to step foot on the Idol stage.. If she won, she would be the best American Idol ever...AMERICA GOT THIS WROOOOOOONGGGGGGGGGG...

  • melinda isnt dull she's actually a better singer then blake will ever be and it's kinda a singing not a beatboxing competition

    and what did u mean sad but true???

  • In the end, I think that all three of them deserved to be there, but I do think that Melinda deserved it a little more than Blake. I do think Jordin would have cleaned her clock though.

  • sad but true

  • i sooo agree with Ajst1987

    americans got it wrong here

    but i hear that melinda is very happy now and has a wonderful career

    so take that BLAKE LEWIS :)

  • you can tell melinda was so relieved when ryan told her it was the end of the road. im sure she was happy to get over all the stress from AI.

  • Im sorry Melinda sings, Blake beatboxes

  • Okay it's simple. Whoever wanted Blake in the finale over Melinda is stupid! This woman has been consistant every week, delivered something different every week, never been in the bottom. Yet this stupid stuff happens? Sure, Jordin earned her right in the finale, but Melinda also did. This is officially when American idol became a popularity contest. Melinda is the real winner here.

  • some people prefer entertainment over singing. i voted for blake because i thought melinda was a little dull.

  • That's great for you then. Since this is a suppose to be an overall singing competition, I think differently.

  • you right and that's why he didnt win.

  • maybe they wanted to make it easier for jordin to win. this show is freakin rigged

  • lol maybe so

  • Comment removed

  • this was absurd,.,¡ melinda should have won idol that season..

  • whats the song at 2:46?

  • jordin was so skinny here

  • nicoako, she was always skinny!!!!!

    Tgis would be so hard, making it to the top 3! I feel so bad

  • america made the wrong decision! she should have won!

  • Even Blake's parents looked shocked.

  • 2 years later and I still cry when I see this! I LOVE YOU MELINDA!!! But I a happy because her CD is out and it's AMAZING!Buy it if you haven't already=D it's "Coming Back To You" ♥

  • Almost my whole family liked Melinda I used to like Blake just for his beat-boxing but now I realize Melinda should of went all the way to win.

  • I also like her smile and attitude

  • oh my gosh this was the wrong decision! DX

  • so wrong. blake SUCKS. and jordin is ok. but Melinda is awesome. im shocked.

  • even Simon thinks the decision is wrong.

  • this is soooo wrong!!!

  • season1: kelly clarkson

    season2: clay aiken

    season3: Fantasia

    season4: Carrie Underwood

    season5: Katherine McPhee

    Season6: blake lewis

    Season7: david archuleta or jason castro

  • Two years later and this is STILL the all time low point of American Idol....

  • melinda should win..

  • Don't agree with season 2 or 6

  • I love how Jordan looks like she's oging to puke at the results. I agree that Melinda is amazing but Im kind of glad she didnt win. It seem that over half of the diol winners knid of fade off but the fact that she didnt win made an uprisisng that keeps her even more alive. I mean Rubin, Fantasia, the person from season 5, cant even remeber their names without help. Only a few winners were able to keep their names known.

  • This was the last time I watched more than 2 minutes of any episode of AI.

  • Me too. Since that wrong elimination, American Idol was over for me.

    This TV show was supposed to be about singing talent. Instead, voters prefered to vote for superficial look. Stupid move that explain why USA voted twice for a mentaly challenged GWB for president. A dangerous irresponsable and narrow minded asshole who believes he can kill innocent poeple for the benefit of OIL companies.

  • i was sad she was awesome she had a street named after her...

  • Ridiculous results shows like this is one of the reasons that this show is a joke now. Too many people keep on finishing in the wrong places. Melinda should have won this season, absolutely no doubt about it. The fact that people like Blake Lewis and David Archuleta get this far is a joke. The only reason I kept watching last season is because of Carly, and the night she was eliminated was the night I quit watching, and will never watch again. And I know I'm not alone on that one.

  • jordin should be so thankful that melinda didnt made it into finale

    coz she will turned out very very very patheeeeethiiiic!

  • i agree

  • I know! You could see how relieved she looked when they told Melinda she was gone.

  • this proves that AI just like the Republican party is corrupt.

  • wow she smiled what a wonderful woman

  • nice joke blake

  • season1: kelly clarkson

    season2: clay aiken

    season3: Fantasia

    season4: Carrie Underwood

    season5: Katherine McPhee

    Season6: Melinda Doolittle

    Season7: David Archuleta

  • season1: kelly clarkson

    season2: clay aiken

    season3: Fantasia

    season4: Carrie Underwood

    season5: Katherine McPhee

    Season6: Melinda Doolittle

    Season7: David Cook

  • Season 1:Kelly Clarkson

    Season 2:ruben Studdard

    Season 3:Fantasia Barrino

    Season 4:Carrie Underwood

    Season 5:Taylor Hicks

    Season 6:Jordin Sparks

    season 6:David Cook

  • there bother better then black buy far.

    melinda is way better than jordin

    there for blake sucks dick and should have left. he has the gayest album out know that knowbody knows.

  • big mistake!

  • WHY's everyone being mean to JORDIN?

    they were both better than BLAKE xD

  • Season 1 Kelly Who Won

    Season 2 Clay

    Season 3 Fantasia Who Won

    Season 4 Carrie Who Won

    Season 5 Daughtry

    Season 6 Melinda

    Season 7 David Who Won

  • jordan sucks!!!

    MELINDA WAS THE BEST SINGER

    SHE WAS ROBBED!!

  • THAT WAS STUPID!!!! She so should have won!

    season 1: Tamyra Gray

    season 2: Rueben Studdard

    season 3: LaToya London

    season 4: Bo Bice

    season 5: Taylor Hicks

    season 6: Melinda Doolittle+ Lakisha Jones

    season 7: David Cook

  • it should have been her versus jordan

  • Daughtry wasn't robbed michael johns wasn't robbed did you vote first of all?????? if did good if not shut the fuck up.

  • Melinda was the best singer! Because in every audition she was always good, from beginning to end. Jordin at the beginning was not good enough, and although she improved a lot, she still wasn't as good as Melinda.

    Melinda, you rock! You have an awesome voice!

  • i think ppl take it too seriously, it doesn't really matter who wins, getting the exposure on this show will launch melinda's career to ..... i hope.... one of the biggest post-idol careers ever....and ppl get off jordin...jeez...she's very good friends with melinda and a sweet kid herself...

  • She should have won.. :[

  • I agree with everyone below: Melinda was by far the better singer than Jordin(no insult intended to Jordin). Problem is, the mass majority of voters in the US for AI ARE TEENAGERS!! So who do you think they're going to vote for?? So Jordin's win was no surprise. I think she can sing ok, is very sweet but even when I listen to her songs on iTunes, there is something lacking overall: her higher notes are just thin and tinny. But hey, she's young, hopefully she'll keep getting vocal training!

  • Yup your completely right.

    & thats why its a popularity contest.

  • I always thought Jordan should've gotten eliminated way before this and she ended up winning. Melinda was defintually the most talented and Blake stood out because of the beatboxing. I knew Blake was a lock on for the finale. I just didn't know who he would go up against. Never thought was gonna Jordan though.

  • I wanted to throw up and break my tv on this night on this night. Melinda was robbed! She was the only consistent singer that season. Blake is COMMON! He ALWAYS will be! The judges only liked him so much because they had to root for one guy and there no good guys in season 6. He hasn't made it in the music industry and he NEVER will. And Simon perfers him over Katharine McPhee Pulezze!

  • Season 1: Tamyra Grey

    Season 3: Jennifer Hudson + LaToya London

    Season 5: Chris Daughtry

    Season 6: Melinda Doolittle

    Season 7: Michael Johns

    When will the absurdity end!?!?

  • Season 1: Kelly Clarkson

    Season 2: Clay Aiken

    Season 3: John Stevens

    Season 4: Bo Bice

    Season 5: Taylor Hicks (Who did win)

    Season 6: Melinda Doolittle

    Season 7: David Cook (Who also won)

  • it was so absurd, putting blake against jordin?? oh my god, blake can't sing, he's just an entertainer, no offense but comparing these two to blake, blake is nothing... it would have been a great finale if jordin and melinda competing.... oh well.

  • where's jordin's tears? lol so fake, she was happy melinda would've wiped the floor with her...it's for a reason though, melinda has a voice that will never be replaced by anyone on AI

  • i hate that plastic look on Jordins face, she is probably happy her biggest threat got eliminated. HYPOCRIT

  • melinda SHOULD have made it to the finals!! if she made it she would have kicked jordins butt!! no offense but blake cant sing

  • If it was Melinda vs Jordin, Melinda wud win hands down...Jordin is no match... and wat the hell were they thinking putting blake against jordin???

  • lets see i hate blake he sucks and he has a hit record NOT at least melinda is comming out with a album ill buy it

  • jordins reaction is so fake

  • melinda>jordin

    anytime

  • so right on.

  • You did a very good job Melinda..look at simon at 1:48..he's like "nooooo..."

  • simon said himself melinda was the rightful idol.

  • I loved Melinda but I perosnally beliebe that things happen for a reason. At the time I wanted Melinda to win but looking back now, I'm glad Jordin won. She has such a great genuine personality and a gr8 voice to match! I am a huge fan of hers now...she is an inspiration to so many of her younger fans in particular who can relate to her...:D x

  • she is still very sweet. i really like her. Her cd will come out in JUNE? I would buy one

  • If american Idol is not fixed then i dont know what is... Melinda is BY FAR the most talented singer I have ever seen period! If no less Simon Cowell likes her then she must be good! For all those out there who feel this way, Melinda's CD is coming out in June, she is the best there.

  • Melinda is my best AI contestant 4ever! We love you Melinda, you are the best, that's true!

  • wow, simon finally found his favorite, and some beat boxing entertaintment jerk robbed her chances of winning

  • FUCK the best singer in american idol, voted off because of a preety blondie stupid with a funny talent of making stupid noises, bullshit!! she shouldve won, and everybody knows it

  • I totally agree - i still watch her songs now and I refuse to follow this year's american idol because it will just go to the prettiest, not the most talented probably.

  • EXACTALY! Did you HEAR the crown BOOING that?? Melinda shoulda won, Jorins dad paid to have it fixed, There was no way jordin would lose to blake but if melinda woulda made top 2 jordin woulda lost big time. Blake is a dumbass..."girl, girl machine duh der der"

  • Biggest con job in AI history

  • Dude!! the reactions! u could hear in the audience EVERYONE knew she was the best, EVERYONE!!! all the judges knew she was robbed and even Ryan was sympathetic to her. she has a much better voice than Jordin, anyone with a technical musical ear knows that.

  • idc what she looks like...ITS A SINGING COMPETITION!! NOT AMERICAS NEXT TOP MODEL...NOT DANCING WITH THE STARS...NTO A POPULARITY CONTEST...A SINGING COMPETITION...SAD TO SEE HER GO =/

  • Wow...Look at Simon's face...

  • ROBBED - SHE WAS THE BEST IDOL EVER!

  • Blake was so humble to melinda then and so was jordin.....

  • wow she smiled what a wonderful woman

  • wow blake, that "machine" joke sucked!

  • I WAS SOOOO PISSED! listen all three had talent, but like the finale was like nuthin. jordan blew blake away with ease. blake got thru cause he had talent more was hot. no one can deny it, the same goes for halie she got thru cause of her looks and chris aswell i mean like they were ok aswell but gina was 1,000 times better than halie and chris, but halie was a looker. i do feel bad 4 jordin tho simon ruined her moment right there lol wow i need to learn to shut up!

  • i prefer lakisha to melinda :D

  • No, Melinda was an is the best out of season 6. Lakisha is just pretty good.

  • "One of our best singers ever", said Ryan and he is 100% correct.

  • Do you see that dumb cunt in the background at 1:53? She obviously voted for Blake...

  • Hey I was rooting for blake as well. What's your point?

  • i think that is one of blake's friends that's why

  • Dial Idol voting results:

    1. Melinda-66%

    2. Jordin-64%-HANGING IN THERE, she needs LaKisha's votes to join Melinda in the Final 2.

    3. Blake-59%-the good ole boys are coming out in droves in honor of Jerry Falwell after tonight's performance.

  • I think so looks beautiful .

  • I always said from the top 24...what a finale Jordin, Melinda, and Lakisha would have been!! WOW!!

  • Melinda era la mejor lejos ,,Jordin y Blake dos muertos de hambres ,,Los yankees no entienden un carajo!

  • america was really stupid putting blake in the finale!

    melinda is one the best american idol has ever had!

  • probably the worst vote decision ever made the american public...

  • Agreed. I like Blake more than Melinda and Jordin but, to be honest, Melinda should have won American Idol.

  • I think that choosing Tylor Hicks was the worst!

  • im happy!!!! i wanted a jordin/blake finale every since the top 24!!!! yay! =]

  • It should have been a Jorlinda finale.

  • No it should have been melinda/blake finale.

  • yes i agree musicboy.Should be Melinda n Blake finale.Jordin is only the 3rd best.

  • america voting public = retards

  • sad :.(

  • Melinda was the best!!

  • american idol won't be a tv show if america keeps voting the way they are......and I can't lie Blake is an amazing entertainer but there was no way in hell he should've been in the finale with jordin.....melinda and jordin should have been in the finale together and melinda should have been our new american idol but that's ok because she will succeed over blake and probably over jordin

  • If Jordan is not stripping down to little or nothing she won't make it. She has a R&B sound and it's hard out there.

  • Hey,.,. blake's rendition of You give love a bad name,., totally deserved it,.,. This was a hard One,., and melinda is not comercial enough,., sorry,., but it's true,.,.

    I'm extasiated that blake made it to the Finally.,.,

    And this show hasn't been about talent,., since a long time ago,., remember.,., The Old dude,., wining over Katharine "Oh my god that rainbow" Mcphee

    The kids are both talented..,. I'm sad to see melinda go,., but not disappointed

  • The competition is about singing abilities until it gets to the point were the audience decides who stays... in this point everything comes into a very subject thing

  • You guys are out of order. It's not only about 'having a good voice'. yes, it's a singing competetion, but thats not what singing is all about. it's about your singing style, presence and personality. melinda has a great voice, bbut the other two are more unique. and she also does not have a stage personality. i love melinda, but i'm not very sad to see her go.

  • BOOOOOOOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOBBBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

    melinda shoulda stayed

  • This is the worst judgemtnt, this is American Idol someone to look up to...not a contest who to look at...that is the way people live today.

  • I also don't think the voting system is right. Only one vote per person should be allowed, even though I know it would be hard to track. I think the judges should make the final call, not people who vote for the hottest or the ones who only 'entertain' like sanjaya. It's a singing competition that's turned into a popularity contest.

  • America kicked Melinda's ass and voted for the weakest and most ridiculous finale in the history of this competition.

  • This only proves that looks, youth and presence, NOT TALENT, is required to be an Idol. This is such a disappointment....

  • disappointment.....this totally makes me not want to watch AI anymore

  • Clearly, American Idol is a popularity contest. Melinda SHOULD have been in the Top 2! Blake is a decent singer. Personally, I didn't want him in the final 2. I was looking forward to seeing the finale. After this round, I don't even think there is a point!

  • ditto my thoughts exactly. let alone assuming she'd be in the final two, i thought she'd WIN, as she SHOULD of. She's a true trained experienced singer and besides that, deserves it because she's humble and gracious and not arrogant at all. She didn't even look shocked when she was voted off, meaning she never assumed anything. I pray that she'll have the success of Chris Daughtry, the best singer last time, but also voted off. God bless Melinda.

  • For me, American Idol 6 season finally at this point. I´m from Brazil, and sorry the american audience.... but you´re all idiots and has a bad musical tast.

  • Actually, I'm American...but I couldn't agree more! People in this country have NO SENSE at all!

  • i want to kill the blaker girls!

  • hey come on just because you like Melinda or because Melinda is better doesn't mean you have to be like that. I like Melinda alot but my fave is blake

  • And here's me thinking there couldn't be as big a shock as Chris Daughtry's elimination last year, this showed me! I really don't think the final is even worth watching now and that saddens me as I've been a huge fan since the show was shown in Ireland from season 2. I really picked a bad season to try and get my husband interested in the show, he lost interest when Gina was eliminated before Phil, Haley and Sanjaya! It has been a very bad year for Idol!

  • jordin is so fake

  • jordin's catty nature is starting to show. i hate fake people.

  • melinda is a young tina turner no doubt. at least she can get a better contract than AI. predict her album outsells anyone elses

  • What a joke...my tongue belongs on Mel's A-hole. In a heartbeat...

  • I was hoping that it would be Jordin vs. Melinda because I can't stand Blake's beat-boxing so much. If Blake ends up winning American Idol 6, it would be the biggest upset in this show's history since last year when Taylor Hicks won.

  • vote jordin!!!!!!! i think she just got voted off because of her age which is sooooo stupid because 29 is still young!!!!!:'  (tear tear)

  • That "Going Home" video should have never, ever been aried featuring Melinda Doolittle..she was robbed

  • ok. who fixed the votes? I want a recount.

  • Blake and Jordin are pop "stars" and very commercial. Who the hell wants another Britney fucking Spears anyway?! I'm kind of glad she got voted off. She can start working on an album, with no pressure. She has the potential to become the modern Aretha Franklin, Dionne Warwick etc.... WAY TO GO, MELINDA!!!

  • hahahahaha :D This is hilarious!!! The best vocalist/performer in AI history, and she didn't even make it to the finale. She was way too good for AI anyway! AI lost its credibility. Melinda is all about the music. PURE music!

  • jordin can suck my u-know-what! faking reactions just to appear pleasing and adorable. mofo. i just wish blake will do what he did during the Bon Jovi week, i.e. picking the right songs and applying great beat boxing. jordin should be boxed off the stage, that's fo sho.