Added: 5 years ago
From: bryanjp
Views: 798,399
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,929)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 4 words 'To perfect for words'

  • Eel crrctgujokpl

  • A new recording by Becky has been uploaded. Please search YouTube for:

    “Becky Jane Taylor - Sailor 2011”

  • hahaha

  • what age is she? like, 12? shes amazing but she sings like a 30 or 40 year old but still AMAZING!!

  • beautiful... she has the the technical talent and the emotion to pull off this song.

  • haha my name is Becky too!!! I `m from Romania!!! ^^

  • magnifique ^^

  • angels r awsome

  • GOD HAS BLESSSED YOU!

  • Wonderfull voice,a litlle bit mature for her age, she sounds like Julie Andrews,as Justin said:)

  • she sounds a bit like julie andrews

  • beautyful song!

  • There is a new Becky video on You Tube. Search for:"Becky Jane Taylor - 6 Nations (Singing The Same Song)” I think it has some connection with the Rugby World Cup, something similar to Pavarotti singing Nessun Dorma a few years ago at the Football World Cup.

    

  • i think it sounds amazing, sounds like the one on anistasia, wait did she sing it on it.. err im confused.....

  • @PrincessJessyLou Actually Liz Callaway did Anastasia's singing voice.

  • that was fabulous i love her

    voice

  • what do you now about singing, she`s fabulous, her way of singing but perfect!!!

  • She is a little bit like Charlotta Church :-)

  • OMFG!! she's amazing! :D but how old is she? Is she young like 12? Cuz I cannot tell !

    But a fantastic job! Beautiful!!!! -3 :*]

  • To mark the tenth anniversary of 9/11 I have uploaded a video tribute to the fire fighters and others on rescue work in the twin towers disaster with pictures before and after the disaster. Search You Tube for: “Becky Jane Taylor In New York – 9/11 Heroes”

  • woaaa!!!!! Her voice is amaizing!!!!!!!! I sing this song to because is my favourite song!!!!! This girl is amaizing!!!

  • She has a good voice but it sounds like she should be singing opera....

  • great voice - but the biggest load of cheese i have ever seen.

  • great voice ) but :S british accent doesn't become to this song :S (

  • Very fantastic girl

    Becky you are prodigious

    by Georgian

  • You are, of course, entitled to your opinion, “It's just not one that goes with the song”. But having expressed your opinion you are not entitled to deny AMAIxKOKORO the right to his/her opinion, which you did in your previous mail.

  • @Bish29 They can think whatever they like about the song. If they'd like to think it's better than the original, I'm not stopping them.

    However, they didn't give the same coutesy to everyone else. They told people to stop critising her, and attacked people's singing voices. I'm just sticking up people AMAIxKOKORO attacked.

  • okay Im english and i think she sings wonderfully, people have different opinions but if he accent annys you this much go watch another video, its not hard to click somthing else. and Im guesssing she can sing much better than a majority of people commenting, stop Criticising this wonderful song. dont like it dont watch it.

  • @AMAIxKOKORO This is a brilliant song, and the girl has clearly got a lot of talent. However, the two aren't compatiable. Stuff like that happens. I'm sure she'd blow people away if she sang a song like Moonlight.

    Also, no reason to bash people's singing voices. For all you know, the people commenting have studied music with an emphisis on vocal training (aka know what they're talking about). Anyway, you don't need to be a carpenter to know when someone's built a rubbish table.

  • @TheMrOwlet You said “Also, no reason to bash people's singing voices”, having just done that yourself.

  • @Bish29 No, I didn't. I admited this girl has a really great voice. It's just not one that goes with the song.

    I could have a a gorgous dress, and a stunning pair of shoes, but when I put them together they don't work. Doesn't mean the shoes are hideous.

  • whattt? : DDD it is more amazing with this accent!!!!

  • Do the people who object to Becky’s accent really believe that Josh Groban should not sing “You Raise Me Up” because it’s not an American song? Should people whose first language is not English, never sing songs written in English because they would not have the right accent? Please try to enjoy listening to different singers and don’t expect them all to do an impersonation of the song’s first singer.

  • im british and accents dont bother me. well done<3

  • @TheMaskedstranger02 Because you're British.... it's originally an American made song so the accent throws us off, it's like us singing an old English song in an American accent. It just wouldn't sound right.

  • @redsoxfinatic77 Yes it would. As long as the person had a nice voice, it doesn't matter what the accent is. After all, they aren't that different

  • I think she's only singing it cuz of the camera, not because she actually knows the true meaning of the song.

  • I didnt even notice the accent. She sounds beautiful and amazing. She has a great voice for someone so young. People shouldnt criticize her, if you cant stand her dont listen to her k?

  • @thing2kk15 I totaly agree

  • her voice is pretty, but she doesn't sing it with the right emotion. :p its beautiful, but its like the words she's singing mean nothing to her. for someone who grew up with this song, its a little heart-breaking...

  • @Cutiepiespnz04 What are you talking about? How do you know if she knows the meaning of the song?

  • @LuisaPie

    not the ''meaning of the song'', but what significance it holds to her. The words she's singing seem like they don't have any value to her other than just ''words to sing."

  • @Cutiepiespnz04 Uh huh

  • i think the british accent is way better, way to go Becky wow ur amazing come to the USA

  • @mandygene22221 Thanks Mandy. Becky was in America ten years ago. She was in the Regis and Kelly show singing I Could Have Danced All Night. It’s on You Tube in ‘Bish29’ uploads.

  • @mandygene22221 Yeah

  • @IheartPercyPIgs

    I too am English. I don't like the fact that she's singing it in an English accent, it just isn't necessary.

  • @Carnage1235 “I too am English. I don't like the fact that she's singing it in an English accent, it just isn't necessary.” This reads as though you think she is not English and has gone to the trouble to learn an English accent in order to sing this song.

  • @Bish29

    I'm English. Trust me.

  • @Bish29 I don't understand. Are you saying that she shouldn't sing it in an english accent? I thought she was english, and if so how can she help it?

  • @LuisaPie You have misunderstood. In the first part of my message I was stating what @Carnage1235 had said. Please read it again and you will see what I meant.

  • sounds so good

  • how old is she here?

    wow, i just discovered her <3

  • @LORDNARCISSUS She would be 11 or 12. Now 23.

  • 221 people cant remember

  • ok like seriously people.. she's a kid and she did such an amazing job already... give her some credits aite.. i bet those who've been complaining about how her accent ruin this song.. *sigh can u actually sing like this???? i think the accent is just fine... and she did a good job! well at least she have talent to be proud of rather than criticizing others in youtube.. -____-

  • This songs is better than the original

  • @SomePinkGirl Yeah

  • I love the british accent =D It's so sweet. Not like the american so common and boring =/ It is just better XD

  • oh dear lord, I'm british and even i can't stand that bloody accent

  • @MrJamieb18 she was just a kid, give her some credit ._.

  • @MrJamieb18 i can't either.

    i am from yorkshire and i now live in ohio. I feel like an outcast when people look at me when i speak

  • @jackieevanchofan54 Here is part of what a Yorkshire paper said a few years ago. The Huddersfield Examiner Reported:

    "Becky Jane's voice, with its clarity, purity of tone and considerable power, was shown to far

    better advantage when singing not the crossover style, but the work for example of Handel in the aria Lascia ch'io pianga ."

  • @jackieevanchofan54 That's really sad. I live in California and every time someone who has an accent comes into my work I insist on talking to them. I love hearing different accents and finding out where people come from. Too bad some of us Americans can be too judgemental.

  • @MrJamieb18 agreed

  • it does make the song sound odd, but she has different ways of pronoucing words like mom mum

  • @xcutecupcakelala She is singing in English and I think most people in other countries will be used to hearing American English.

  • be singing this on my page soon. great job girl!

  • her accent makes the song sound odd. she does have talent and a remarkable voice, perhaps if she learns to fake accents it would have sounded better. She's also not using much emotion. This song is very very emotional and shouldn't be sung like an emotionless choral piece. with other songs it may sound well, but not with this i'm afraid. Still, she has talent and I congratulate her on that.

  • @onewingedraven here i agree with you

  • @onewingedraven I agree but if she was trained day after a day like most singers it makes a LOT of sense about how her accent fits into it

  • I thought this performance was ABSOLUTELY gorgeous! I LOVE her accent. Such a strong, clear voice. Wow. Love it. ^.^

  • so her voice doesn't work with the song. i'd like to see you sing like that. she has actual potential. so shhh!!!

  • you have never heard me sing you jerk face besides im ten

  • u stink AND YOU ARE A SUCKUP

  • gorgeous tone. she's been trained like nuts though; check the technical perfection. where's the expression? :/

  • good voice bad song for it

  • @TheBananaGirlsClub yes your right she does have a good voice, even great but the song she is singing i brilliant... i remember my mum telling me that she use to sing this to me when i was a little younger. this is and always will be my favorite song of all time, by the way my name is anastasia so it is very special song for me...

    and no i wasn't named after the movie a was named after my grandmother!

  • u stink

  • @bridget15223 so do you but we aren't complaining... keep your ugly comments to yourself you monster.

  • i prefer the Anastasia version

  • so far the best one ive heard . . . im a huge fan of this movie

  • amazing !! beautiful !!!

  • @Oraseyleythoss Definitely the most healthy way to sing, and have a career of longevity, because at this age, she's singing correctly. Becky's singing career will last longer than Charlotte Church's!!

  • Wrong accent? I think it suits the song perfectly. Elegant lyrics, elegant tongue.

  • She is sooo beautiful, and her voice is soooooooo lovely))))

  • wow how old is she?

    nice voice.

  • @joey20548 I know right (me to)

  • Tat had to be really hard to do to do the really high parts

  • T_T"

  • @Oraseyleythoss Please click on Bish29 at the bottom of this message and listen to Becky, now age 22, singing, Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again. You will notice she hasn't ruined her voice, and her parents didn't hate her after all.

  • hammma!

  • I'm British and her strong accent don't go with this song really shes got a good voice but still its her accent

  • oh god.... this made me want to barf :/

  • anastasia <3

  • In my opinion, the british accent has made it better and I'm not saying that because I'm british but simply because it sounds much more classical..amazing!

  • Like is not a strong enough word for how amazing this is.

  • Look I love this movie and know like every word to the movie and music. And have the dolls. Im sorry to say this is probably the worst version of this song Ive ever heard. I dont really like her voice in it. I love the song im just not a big fan of her singing it..sorry to people who like it.

  • Where did she go flat? I heard maybe a hint of a few but that's it other than that this song is amazing.

  • noooo the accent makes it sound even more pretty <3

  • i think she sings fabulous!

  • U are amazing don't u forget it!!!

  • I love this song! Theres nothing wrong with her accent.

  • If u could realy do better then that then post a utube vid nd lets see if u could other wise BITCH DON'T TALK ps becky u were asome hell yah

  • the video and voice both awesome (all the great artists aka MayaKobuladze and limalicious please keep your oppinion to yourselfs, much appreciated)

  • @BabiyyRevaeo95 shut up, AIDS infected bitch.

  • @BabiyyRevaeo95 BOO YOU WHORE

  • omg. And here I was , thinking this would be some kind of pop version of the song O_O this girl's awesome!!!!!!

  • she sounds so good! I´ve never imagined that a little girl can sing this song in such a great kind!

  • Wrong accent for this song and she keeps struggling on a bunch of notes to not go flat.

  • @limalicious I don't mean to sound rude or anything but could you do this at such young age? I'll admit there are a few flat notes but she was a child at the time... and she has achieved a momentous thng with her voice. its a haunting song and the accent gives it even more of an alluring sound

    The least you could do is be happy for her. Next time please atleast put a positive with your negative criticism?

  • I love this !!

    When I was little this was my favourite movie !! :) <3

  • holy crap!!!!!! how old is she??>???

  • Pure beauty, bravo. 

  • She has a gorgeous voice but her British accent is kind of ruining this song for me :(

  • @MayaKobuladze fuck up seriously, can you do better?

  • @littlelemon200 Not implying I can do better, it's a matter of personal taste. It's not my problem that you feel like a attacked rat as soon some one had a negative comment on a song.

  • @MayaKobuladze i don't feel like a rat nor do i feel attacked. I didn't say you were implying that you can do better, I was just saying. Besides, this song is good... and her British accent doesn't ruin the song, your comment did.

  • @MayaKobuladze TOTALLY AGREE AMEN!

  • @neytiri131 I take it that English is not your first language. There is nothing wrong with Becky's English accent, and the lyric is, in this version , in English.

  • @MayaKobuladze British accent is the most beautiful thing in the world!

  • @RybakAndEdenLover When it comes to this song . . . I disagree. And there are some accents that beat out the Brits.

  • @MayaKobuladze What's wrong with a British accent? I'm British too and I don't see how it can spoil a song. Personally, I think a British accent is just as good if not better than any other accent. If you agree, please click thumbs up.

  • @LuisaPie It's impossible to know what your own accent sounds like, so how can you say your accent is the best? And yes, I agree that this song sounds weird with a British accent. The song was originally done with an American accent, and I think it sounds better. LIkewise, there are British songs that sound better with that accent.

  • @sobefobik I know what my accent sounds like, because I'm not deaf and I hear myself and other people from where i am talk. You think the American accent is better for this sonfg because you first heard it that way, not because it is better. Same way I think the English accent is best for the song, because I first heard it in this version. I'm not saying this because I think my accent is better, because I'm not English.

  • @LuisaPie No one can understand what their accent sound like to others. Being deaf has nothing to do with it. In your last comment you said you were British. Now you're not?

  • @sobefobik Yes, I am still British. I didn't say I was not. I said I wasn't English. The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, where I am from, is made up of 4 different countries: England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. I am from Scotland; I am therefore both British and Scottish, not English. Perhaps in America this little titbit of information is ignored. That is not my problem. Goodbye. And, by the way, I agree with mommyslittlemonsta.

  • @LuisaPie Well if that is what you mean, I guess the term "English" is superfluous. You should know, then, that I am American, not English. Perhaps that's something you Brits don't pay attention to.

  • @sobefobik I never said you were English. In fact, I even implied that you were American, so I don't know what you're talking about. Read AMAIxKOKORO's message. Maybe he'll knock some sence into you.

  • @LuisaPie There is nothing wrong with a Brittish song, but I don't think it suits this song.

  • @MayaKobuladze Okay, look I don't care. If you son't like this version don't listen to it. That's all I have to say.

  • she sounds real posh

  • @xXxHurtsTheo: yea she really does!

  • She has a GREAT voice but this song is really not her chord type

  • I think she has a beautiful voice but I don't like it with this song. I feel like this song should be sung more gentler, while she has an extremely powerful voice. But I do love her voice.

  • she sounds a little bit like a young Julie Andrews :)

  • @AshChan19 I think you mean Beckii Cruel.

  • CANT BELIEVE I JUST DISCOVERED BECKY!! ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!! she is amazing. pure talent that i wish and would die for. she is my inspiration from now on. love her. she is also pretty

  • 208 people don't have pretty memories -__-

  • There is a very interesting new web site for Becky fans. Just search the web for ‘Becky Jane Taylor Fans’.

  • beautiful voice sounds like an angel.

  • That is a too good voice for such a young girl

  • Beznadzieja! :O Robi miny jak....

  • Beznadzieja! :O

  • Becky has just made a recording of the song, Was It Only Sunday. Fans can find this video by copying and pasting into You Tube search: TonyClaymanPromotions

  • @MadFannyLaBouche  Bleh. YOU suck! :P

  • is this the same girl that did the japanese dance? i didnt know she culd sing??

  • It looks like she's yawning when she goes aaaah .... :D But she has a great voice.

  • No doubt she's got a great voice but it sounds really different with a British accent¬!!!!!

  • This is in the movie Anastasia, right?

    I have to agree with lexidemon, it does remind me of Mary Poppins but voices are sometimes very simiular though they are different and unique in their own way. Very gorgeous.

    Thumbs up if you like this song and agree strongly with me. :)

  • oh my god, she sounds nothing like the actual song by anastasia. she sounds like my gradnmother. im serious. NOT kidding. she looks really young, but she sounds REALLY old.

  • @NarutoRules0198 Same here! Exactly like my grandmother, She British and shes 63!

  • I have uploaded a recent private recording of Becky singing Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again, from the musical Phantom of the Opera. To find this, please search You Tube for, Bish29

  • I can't believe they slowed the song down!!!!!!!!

  • What a superb voice. The best I have heard for a long time. She's a star.

  • she has great timbre, I would just like to hear her control the vibrato through all of the early verse lyrics...

  • I don't care what anyone says, that was awsome. Young or not.

  • im sorry to say, this is pretty creepy. her expressions are contrived and her voice doesn't seem to fit her body. she's talented, but ill-suited for this song. she has almost no childish innocence that i can see.

  • her face doesn't fit her voice. .i'm sorry to say this but i don't really like how she pronounces DACING and other words...it doesn't sound good...

  • This may sound mean but she shows no emotion in this song, and i am a ballerina and have been doing ballet since i was 4 and she was not good at ballet(but i have been doing it fo 10 years so im sorta biased)

  • BEAUTIFUL

    

  • well im 14 and professionaly trained singer (im still learning) and is bad she dosnt show emotion but if she acted like a kid the music industry wouldnt take her seriously as a singer. being muture dose not mean you shouldnt show emotion though. i kinda understand why she acted like this in the video. she wanted to look professional. i might be wrong the only person that could expain the video perfectly is becky her self.

  • wow she totally ruins this cbeautiful song

  • voice doesn't fit the song

  • shit!

  • @LadyDarija How can you call this shit? The song is amazing even tho i prefer Anastasia's version :)

  • @SmileyDari Yes, it is a very amazing song ...but the voice...

  • i think she is trying to be mature when all she needs is a fun video where she can act like a girl....not an adult, a video in which she has her hair down and curled and wearing a nice dress and just having fun like a kid!

  • Comment removed

  • she has such a georgous voice!!!

  • cool

  • How old is she??