Added: 5 years ago
From: noumayos
Views: 117,211
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (348)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love the phase "american life".

    this song is so emotional. this interpretation acoustic is so beautiful.

  • very nice song (':

  • am i the only one that cried ?

  • @yaboyteewon no, it's very beautiful and makes me cry too.

  • me like yes.

    i'd lick her sweet succulent pussy and make her sing acoustic hippy songs with guitar while i slide my juicy manhood into her geriatric poohole.

    yesssssss.

  • @CuntySurprise You fucking weirdo.. try redtube if you want to talk like that. Kids use youtube

  • @manxfaerie "DERE ARE KIDS ON DA YOUTUBES!!!!'

    yet you were quick to drop the f bomb, weren't you?

    yes, he's being weird, but c'mon...who HASN'T thought of pounding that old poon at least once or twice?

  • @TripToYourSin89 Ah but I didn't go on about wanting to slide my girth into someone did I? Get fucked knobhead...

  • please you motherf###ers get lost and stop criticize Madonna, if you don't ike her just listen to something else you loser!

  • FOUL!!!

  • sweet, she improved a lot on guitar. Kudos to her, i thought she'd get bored/frustrated and drop it after she learned her first 4 chords. But here she's playing barre chords and has great strumming and timing and everything. Of course she still can't rap though!

  • @areyouselling I don't think her goal here was to rap, actually.

  • @areyouselling THIS IS SHIT! Katy Perry plays better!

  • PLAYBACK, PORFAVOR PLAYBACK!

  • Queen!!!!!

  • People don't realize that when you combine dancing & singing together its very hard to do both! Madonna can sing she's not the greatest singer but she has been very successful these last 30 years! You put Mariah or Christina who are great singers to sing w/heavy choreographic routines and I bet they will sound like your choking a chicken! So people lighten up stop hating!

  • Love you, Madonna! =)

  • God, I love you so much Madonna!!!!!

  • Perfect song !!!

  • great video thanx for sharing...

  • That voice! WoW

  • I love wowow that's my queen I love I love to live the queen of pop and the universe

  • I love her.

  • God hase given us Madonna ...to show the people, what is real music

    God save Madonna

  • I believe that Madonna does an amazing job on this song, her voice is good and the lyrics are great. Madonna is a living legend!!!!

  • Wow.. her voice sounds GREAT here! Gotta love her! LOVE THIS SONG!

  • @DitRehab eh no they not just saying

  • Its weird, she sounds a lot better during other performances, and then two weeks later she sounds different again. You M fans know what I mean I bet ;) her voice always changes and seems to get husky fast. I prefer her live performances of Fever, Bad Girl and Sooner or Later (and the opera thing she did in her documentary once)

  • it's not how loud you sing is the ability to tune in with your true self a shine like a star ,music goes beyond how limited is your range if it can stroke a cord in your heart it will open it, cause truth is spoken

  • music goes beyond range if it can stroke a cord in your heart it will open it cause truth is spoken , it's not how loud you sing is the ability to tune in with your true self a shine like a star

  • She's an impressive talented songwriter, the best performer and I love her voice, I'm glad she's not the greatest vocalist on earth, I LOVE her "personal/unique" voice.

  • While she may not have the strongest voice. She's a much better musician, singer, and songwriter than she's given credit for... And she does have a limited range but the key to being a good singer is knowing your weaknesses and being able to work around them And Madonna does it very well I must say.

  • Finally, we're all just humans. No matter who we are or what we do.

    We all felt & still feel pain inside.

    Ι see no superstar in this but a woman who sings about what she lost.

  • @MrConstantineN I couldn't agree more.

  • Brava

  • I love her black hair

  • Después dicen que no sabe cantar... Esto demuestra y tapa todas las bocas...

    For all the people taht say she can´t sing!

  • schöner song 

  • this song touches on the weird simplicity of such a profound loss as a mother. "there was a time i prayed to jesus christ/ there was a time i had a mother/ it was nice" ...that really explains the loss of belief and safety i felt after i lost my mother at 9 years old. this song will all ways mean so much to me. i'm not a huge madonna fan, but nothing else has come so close to describing how that impacted me.

  • She so fucking should put out a unplugged album or EP!

  • love you madonna!!!

  • American Life is one of Madonna's greatest album. I love Madonna but I was not a fan of her last album Hard Candy. I would love for her new album to be as emotional and beautiful as American Life or Like A Prayer.

  • the best i have EVER heard her sing live ♥♥♥ Madonna

  • the best i have EVER heard her sing live (L)

  • wish she could still sing like this - even on You Must Love Me on the Sticky and Sweet Tour she was just sat there and her voice was poor :( its a shame she used to be a brilliant singer like this ^ ^ ^

  • @liob1611 I think she should just take some of her time for singing lessons like she did before Evita... that wouldn't be a bad idea, because it IS unfortunate that she has lost some of her singing techniques. :(

  • when she focuses on singing only,,,, this is what we will get.... AMAZING

  • She sounds very GOOD here. This is better than her cds and in her concerts she ususally doesnt sing that well casue she's dancing.

  • Comment removed

  • i can say that here she sounds better than in any of her studio albums

  • until today i thought madonna didn't have a nice voice! ( i'm her fan since i was 4 years old)

  • GOD ! she's amazing

  • this is so touching

  • Her voice is absolutely spectacular here. Period.

  • Madonna you're timeless! I don't care if people are like "Oh her arms are scary" what the fuck does that have to do with her amazing talent! This is the ORIGINAL Gaga people =]

  • Wow, amazing job there, Madonna.

  • omg. my life. is complete

  • Gran artista Madonna , la mejor !!

  • The very first time I heard this song, I cried for her. You can tell in this song why she is the way she is. Fearless, and Scarred. Love you Madonna :)

    <3

  • @xxbonex Lol. It's nice to see you supporting a rising star, but... keep dreaming! Hahaha.

  • @xxbonex Sorry but gaga is a fan of Madonna ... are words of gaga.

    gaga = cheap copycat

  • @MrShaoran2323 i'm not speaking about if gaga is a madona's fan, sorry. if you call lady gaga cheap, oh common madonnas is a cheap guitar player , she just plays C, F,Lm XD and is a cheap live singer.Gaga it's not a copy cat sorry, in the interviews never says that she is original or innovating , too says her work is an ispiration of alot of the pop culture's artist aka madonna, bowie , grace, britney . I'm just talking about talent , something that Madge hasn't :*

  • @xxbonex I disagree about madonna not having talent. This video proves that she can sing pretty well, if nothing else. and this song is very emotional and very well written lyrically. I love GaGa more than Madonna, but I love Madonna a lot too. I think they're both 'beautiful in their way' and that people should drop the insults depending on which they are or aren't a fan of. just leave it be, let their messages of peace and love shine through, and don't go commenting on videos hatred for some1.

  • Love her. Love her voice. I love all that she is. ♥

  • this sounds just absolutely beautifully!

  • Love This Version..and Love HER.!!

  • QUALITY IS TERRIBLE BUT THE VIDEO IS AWESOME!!!!!

  • SHE S THE BEST AND I LOVE HER REAL VOICE.QUEEN OF POP

  • @catneena

    Her voice is very smooth and female.. it is very nice to hear. In the evidence of her succes...

  • REALLY BEAUTIFUL !!!!!

  • This acoustic version is so lovely! :)

  • His mother was a beautiful Italian woman.

    A real mother for sure, I'm sorry Maria Luisa

    that you have lost your mother as a child

  • @Danielreds Her mother was french-canadian, just like me :) but her father was italian though :P everytime i think about it, i feel kinda weird, because it's pretty much like if i was connected to her : /

  • This song is a pray!

  • This was in 2003 I think. Her guitar playing has improved since. Anyway, she has always played the guitar! I don't know why it comes as a shock for you people. Even in the early eighties she played the guitar when she was in the band The Breakfast Club! And then re-learned in 1999. She has been playing the guitar in her tours ever since. She even said that being a Pop icon ruined her guitar playing and she regrets it. She even did a Pantera tribute in her latest tour! She is talented indeed!

  • Her voice here is like pure crystal, so beautiful. In her last tours and today she sounds like total crap.

    Why is that?

  • Comment removed

  • ^^adonna is gust aweso^^E. She knows her voice is li^^ited so she sing songs that fits her voice, and she does very well. That is a true professional.

  • God, her guitar playing is so fake. And I know, I'm a guitarist myself and what she does is like lysinching to music.

    Also, people call her their queen? Eeeek... sad!

  • @treg1980 I agree in many ways, but the rhythm at the beginning is her. and you can see she does have another melody guitarist that you know is there. I don't mind it much, a lot of good guitarists do that too. (not saying she's a good guitarist, but still) and in the 'I've got to give it up' part, you can hear her guitar and the melody guitar together.

  • @treg1980 You are a joke. You call yourself a "guitarist" and failed to perceive that there are two very clear guitars on this song: Madonna playing rhythm guitar and Monte doing the chord solos. I wonder how "good" you are as a guitar player, you failed to recognize that there are two different guitars doing two different things on this song. LOL Keep on hating troll. Or just get back to taking guitar lessons, maybe you'll learn a thing or two about guitar playing.

  • I never thought i i'd hear an acoustic of this song and love.

  • What voice!

    @letofcamb Did you see all the video? There's a man playing with her... --'

  • I like the song, the voice but it's a shame for the fake guitar, why she wants we believe that...

  • This video just took my breath away! I never knew she had this much talent! The words she sang about losing her mother at the age of 5 almost brought tears to my eyes, I lost my father recently.

  • Its so sad : (

  • I like this side of Madge

  • so beautiful so deep. what happened to this Madonna? I will always love her and admire her but she's slipped into the wrong things with the wrong sort of people.

  • she moves me a lot... i love you so much my queen..

  • "I made a vow that I would never need another person ever turned my hart into a cage a victim of a kind of rage" I can SO relate to that....

  • I LOVE THIS SONG IS MY FAVORITE MADONNA'S SONG EVER!

  • wonderful

    

  • She's amazing *-*

  • She is a great dancer, writer, singer, guitar player, designer.

    Her voice speaks for itself. She has beautiful vocals

  • People need to stop attacking her. To bring that amount of emotion for everyone to see is difficult as it is. Madonna has a beautiful heart and soul. Stop scrutinizing her.

  • So passionate and moving! Makes me wanna cry...

  • Madonna may have her detractors, but she seems to be proving them wrong. She continues to improve her voice and she is a brilliant songwriter and her stage presence is unmatched!!!

  • I'M PROUD TO SAY THAT I'M A MADONNA FAN! SHE'S TALENTED! AND MORE THAN THAT! GLAD TO SEE SHE'S DOING SOMETHING LIKE THIS.

  • such a good voice

  • This brings a huge tear to my eye. Beautiful!

  • It could have been perfect

    Pity Matt Lauer was there

  • bless old granny is still singing away in her little voice...

  • @mojopin70 I'd like to see all those other bitches sing in THEIR girly voices 20 years later

  • @mojopin70 ......and collecting more money than you'll ever see in a 100 lifetimes. Poor old RICH granny.......

  • @OrchidIslander ...lol only an angry homosexual would say something like youve just said- the only people that listen to her music are gay or old .

  • @mojopin70 Angry??? Where did you get that from? No anger here.. Gay? Damn str8, I am. Old? Probably by your standards. Hate on her all you like, but I can't imagine 1 million plus people paying to hear your brain farts. They have paid - and still are - to hear her...LOL....There are a lot of young people who would disagree with you about who "only" listens to her.

  • @OrchidIslander i dont hate her or a music i just think shes a pretentious bore, and the fact you replied to my first comment proves you feel the need to defend granny theres no doubt you are the type that hates, and you are laughing at yourself there too which is a true sign of " brain farting" .

  • Her voice is so unique and exquisite..

  • omg, who is this woman?! it is a rare thing to see Madonna this vulnerable; rare & exquisitely beautiful. omg.

  • here she reseambles the 17 years old girl who left Michigan looking for fame carring out her pain with her non dyed hair and her teenager voice, she has been the biggest diva on world but still is the same girl, she can buy a steinway piano for her living room but in terms of love hasn´t found a real suportive and strong man lover

  • @Cantantetecladista LOVE YOUR COMMENT... I ALWAYS WONDER HOW DID IT FEEL TO LIVE EVERY THING BEHIND AND THEN CHASE HER DREAMS

  • She really should do an MTV Unplugged album.

  • Her voice sounds great, rich and clear!!!

  • it's magic

  • Great lyrics, great vocals!!!

  • WOW! She sounds so good. It looks at one point like she could almost cry. I think that her mother's death forced her to be strong, and she felt that she could never allow herself to be weak, and this was all chanelled through everything that has made her the success she is Today, and always will be. So Beautiful Madonna.

  • religion sux, Darwin rulez.madonna sings well., facts of life

  • ı love you so much...

  • she is the greatest

  • american life, in my opinion, was one of the greatest Madonna's album!!!

  • she needs to do an unplugged album

  • @selmalover please can she

  • ah Madonna, se voce soubesse o quanto eu gosto de vc querida =D

  • Beautiful voice !

  • brilliant, its always going to be a mystery to why American life was panned back than and frankly i dont give a shit cause I lloooove this song and the album!!!!!!!!

  • Brilliant!!

  • Really well song, love this Madonna!

  • @XXBilliejoe

    me 2 !!!

    so touching, so simple !!!!

  • Oh crap...thing this album is taking over Ray of Light!

  • I've got to give it up u_ù

  • love This song and you Madonna how you singing .......it lovee you

  • I Love This Song!

  • for all the bad stuff that is written about her, I still like her

  • She is so beautiful. Her looks, her voice, she is flawless. Only a Goddess could be that gorgeous and talented.

  • Her voice is so beautiful... She is really The Queen of Pop :)))))

  • Comment removed

  • BRAVO

  • Madonna is brilliant. Her voice is so beautiful and she has so much talent.

    LOVE HER <3 !!!!!!!

  • She's so simple ! I like this moment. Now she's so...

  • eres genial eres la reina

    angel voice

    I love you

  • por que Madonna no ha grabado un desconectado con Mtv, estaria muy bien !!!!

    canta divino!!!!!

  • I love this version more than studio record.

  • wonderful!! I love this song and her Voice is so fantastic <3

  • My friend Kevin Jack Henry posted this video on Facebook, here is my response to him: Thanks for sharing that Kevin, this is one of my favorite Madonna songs, and I think I have new-found respect for her desire to know her craft (music.) She performed it with sincerity and arranged it perfectly for an unplugged set. I think it makes more sense this way than it does as the Mastered studio version on "American Life." THANKS again! oxox

  • I think the reason this album didn't go platinum is because Hollywood is a numb town scared of feeling and true art. i love you Madonna!!!! the Queen lives on!

  • who said that she can`t sing? the Queen is Madonna. she is not the best singer, but she have something very special. she put her emotions in all she do...is the best

  • @Alicess1 she IS the best solo singer

  • @Alicess1 I don't see how she's not consiered the queen of singing?

  • Por eso es la reina !!!!

  • Angel voice :)

  • No, this is not lip synching. And I think I know you Epic FAIL GUY!!!!!!!!! See you on IRC :P I can't believe you left a comment. cool

  • Elton John is so friggin stupid. This is NOT what I call lip-synching.

    "Since when lip-synching has been live?"

    EPIC FAIL :O

  • Without special effects in her vocie, no vocoder.. clear and soft wow, please Madonna come back.. stop dance pleaseeeeeeee!!!!!

  • great Job

  • I AM PISSED!!!!!!!!

    How did I manage to miss out on this??

  • WOAUUUUUUUUUU i love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu so much mady

  • I love You :'D

  • WOW! That REALLY Says A LOT!!! Deep deep deep...

    THANKS FOR POSTING and ENRICHING my LIFE with this ONE!

  • madonna i love you!!!!

  • Her singing is so good and so touching! And she's looking amazing, love her dark hair!

  • she's women of my life

  • love madonna dark hair!!

  • 100% MADONNA LOUISE CICCONE - her look is as natural as before Madonna, the blonde mega star. Great artist!

  • TRUE TRUE TRUE

  • madonna expressa toda sua dor nessa canção, madonna é uma artista inteligente e muito capaz, VIVA A RAINHA DO POP, PERTO DELA SÓ MICHAEL!!

  • Ela pode não ter uma voz deslumbrante como a da Whitney Houston ou Lauryn Hill mas ninguém canta as músicas dela tão bem quanto ela... já vi vários tributos à Madonna e ninguém canta as músicas dela como ela mesma.... ela é sensacional, a melhor artista de todos os tempos (dança/performance/música/suce­sso/vendas/shows/perfeição... enfim, o conjunto).

  • Concordo com você,sua voz realmente é linda e tem estilo proprio.Quando faz um acustico fica lindo,puro.

  • Não à toa esses tons agudos remetem à voz de uma criança, uma menininha orfã de mãe...

    Eis Madonna sem armaduras, totalmente vulnerável, aberta.

    Sensacional!