Cleveland Indians all-time batting order (MLB starting lineup)

[JHAce2k]

Catcher should be Victor Martinez or Sandy Alomar Jr.

[OpressionOffical]

Bobby Avila was a good player but Tris Speaker or Kenny Lofton have to play center and you forgot about Hal Trosky and NAP LOJOIE!! He's the whole reason why we have the Indians and that's why they were called the Naps (1903-1914) and he had 2046 hits, 919 RBI's and 200+ stolen bases for the Indians! Lineup: 1.Tris Speaker CF 2. Nap Lajoie 2B 3. Manny Ramirez RF 4. Albert Belle LF 5. Jim Thome DH 6. Hal Trosky 1B 7. Lou Boudreau SS (or Omar Vizquel) 8. Ken Keltner 3B 9. Sandy Alomar C

[Robbie91291]

Skye7713 - you are dumb, bob feller is the greatest pitcher in indians history and top 5 for all time

schlagar5o - Tris speaker is also one of the best players of all time.

Both of you need to learn a lot about baseball

[carlinrulez666]

I would have Thome bat cleanup and Belle hit 5th.

[Skye7713]

addie joss at pitcher and kenny lofton at center field

[Skye7713]

addie joss at pitcher and kenny lofton at cnter field

[Skye7713]

my pick at pitcher would have been addie joss though

[bizum82]

A tough lineup to argue against except for leaving Sandy Alomar off the list.

[schlagar5o]

dude....no sandy alomar? are you serious? no omar vizquel? are you serious? and i think i'd take either kenny lofton OR sizemore over that other dude you had playing center....especially lofton...