Brooke White - You must love me - American Idol 04/22/08

[jjemphoung]

she's struggling for the lyrics.

[faggyboy2]

bitch forgot a andrew loyd webber song? imma slap the cunt

[petunia0809]

She looks like Taylor Swift

[EgoGo85]

I think she has a great voice. no matter what.

But it´s a shame she hadn´t sang it with feeling, like Madonna in Evita.

[bella3987]

Man, when Paula was speaking. AWKWARD. lol

[BETTY5391]

Brooke White .... Excelente.....

[Laziness4]

Brooke deserved another chance after that. She performs from the heart. You guys should check out her new single.  I really like it.

[xXxRoCKnRoLLAxXx]

ha ha she messed up at 0:30, and she had to start over!!!!did you guys catch that?

[xxIdinaxx]

Gee, I don't know if anybody caught that. Thanks for pointing it out, big help.

[Laziness4]

LOL.

[SnehaRaoOfficial]

@xXxRoCKnRoLLAxXx um...... HOW CAN YOU NOT? that's the point of the video! how can you NOT catch that?

[Dramamagnet202]

its good she didnt spazz out but she shouldnt have restarted like tht, when i was watchin this live i didnt realize she forgot only after when they were rolling back so everyone could get the votes right AND SHE MADE IT THRU AFTER THIS ROUND oh well david cook deserved it and WON WOOOOT

[DancerProductionsx3]

bummmmmer

[Cblotnicky]

All singers make mistakes, but you have to be able to carry it off. She can't stop and restart songs like that.

[Rkc96]

Wasnt she on Idol 7..not 6? --description

[Vicarageroad1]

It says, American Idol TOP 6.

[Rkc96]

oh. k.

[Springsakura111]

BROOKE SUCKS!

[Differentation]

It's okay.. At least she didnt freak out~!!

[ezwaitloss]

ALL singers make mistakes, and she was nervous! I like Brooke! She has a very powerful voice! She has control over her voice and she is a very talented girl! I knew that it would be a guy this year, matter of fact, it would be between David and David, though I would have picked David A., not David C. America has enough "Savage Garden's" and "Dave Matthews Band"

[Randalina1]

nice girl but carly really deserved to stay over her and jason

[INDLIS]

I know.

[shaka055]

it upsets me that she made it through this week n carly didnt. no offense brooke is awesome but this should have sent her home. she got the sympathy vote; n carly fans got comforatble..

[ay0jay]

i found this performance really good .. she has the biggest fanbase out of all season 7 participants .. shes gonna be somthing .. ull see .. ULL ALL SEE ..

[Rkc96]

how does she having the biggest fanbase? im pretty sure david archuleta does - voted most fanatic fans.

[cbotten106]

This is the performance that bumped Carly Smithson off of American Idol?

OMG, is America kidding or is this some kind of hidden camera show where Carly is going to get Punked?

[TwinFatality]

Jason Castro should've been kicked off and not Brooke you idiot!

[themightyhun22]

maybe there's something going on in her life, and the song hit home...she sounded really emotional...

[KelliSedai]

the mess up was ok, its just that she failed the song. Madonna won it, but Brooke didn't quite understand what she was singing.

[ACTRESSLOVER1]

Ladies and Gentlemen! Don't blame her.please! She was tense and seemed to be frightened by something. Everyone have Failure. She sang with courage again. Finally she failed performance but was able to get big dream. Ladies and Gentlemen! Please don't dislike her. She is tender and splendid woman. Please praise her activity with an American idol. Everyone love her! As both a judge and an emcee seem to have liked her. （Simon seemed to have come to like her halfway)

[marcoaab8]

...ok

[ACTRESSLOVER1]

Anyone please blame her.

She was tense and seemed to be frightened by something. Failure is that even who has it. She sang with courage again. She was missing, but was able to grant a dream. Anyone please dislike her. She is tender, and it is a splendid woman. Please praise her activity with the American idol.

All, she love it.

Both a judge and the emcee seem to have liked her. （Simon seemed to have come to like her halfway.）

[fionaappleseed]

why is there a need to be cruel? there have been worse idols than brooke white, and the fact that she is such a sweet and genuine girl is reason enough to show some respect. theres no need for name calling, she did her best and thats all there is to it. carly was better, true, but its not brookes fault the way the public votes.

[zey105]

she did go home last night! she was crying like a baby!

[linkinparkdiehardfan]

i just dont like brooke.. she just too annoying to me... i need to laugh! who the hell sing and start the song again.. man! she cannot stay!

[sammariofan]

She sounded as if she was shaking

[Voros1993]

brooke white needs to go home!

[crazydany2u]

ha ha

[umbeans08]

she should have deff gone home.... not carly....jeez she is not good anymore!!!!!!

[cuteb25]

fucking biotch.

BROOKE = DRAMA

she just sux bad. her only good performance was Let it Be. after that she just screw ups.

[lali57]

I vote wrong This was poor, poor evita she is crying from the heaven, brooke doesn´t know anything about the respect, respect for history, history of this song...

[1americanidol11]

omg maybe she did cry!it kind of looked like she was going to cry!it was quiet.other than forgetting her lyric she did great!

[christentze]

poor darling. she looks like she wants to burst into tears.

[babydollxxx16]

america.... what were u thinking???

[Tributetycoon]

Man, it was quiet in there after she forgot.

[thinkmyli]

brooke,u're so fake n shit. u should ashame of urself.u're not better than carly.she's a big singer,so wad do u think u r by keep acting innocent to take people attention. shit!!

[roosevelt8283]

she's so attractive and skinny!!no wonder girls like she likes going to the dating site: _millionaireloves.c om_ to find their wealthy dreamer lover!! she has what it takes to win, anyway!!!!LOL

[yesqsucedeasi]

I don't like Brooke anymore...i used to like her now i find her annoying and boring....I don't like her attitude at all

[zanessa4yevah]

i have to admit..carly wasn't the one who was supposed to be voted out..but neither is brooke.she's just as good as she is...they're both amazing..so stop saying that brooke should be the one to get voted out...the person i want to leave is jason and syesha!!!

[ganga316]

i really thought brooke white shud ve gone home..altho she is a great singer..she just wasnt better than the other 2 girls.. was sad to see carly leave..love her attitude man! she took it like a champ!

[rdbsison09]

yattaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!­!!!

[ArmanValdar]

Very unprofessional, very poor--both Brooke and Jason were riding the same train that wrecked--and it seems that the American audience or 38 million voters were on the train with them. The worst week ever on Aİ with these two poor performances.

[ashleyluvspugs]

Paula - "what I loved about this performance is you didn't over act" - boy, she nailed her on her fake pouts throughout her other performances.

Paula was spot on for once in her comments, a singer (Randy & Simon aren't) does not start over 2 sentences in - you just try to correct your word or just begin with the next sentence.

She was really horrible on this, I am so upset Carly went home, and not this train wreck of a singer - seriously - this lady is one of America's top 5 new talents??? Bah

[gatekeeper04]

If this woman still doesn't get the boot next week, there's only one word to describe it - UNBELIEVABLE. Brooke is actually a smart girl. Smart enough that is to embody this image of being so sweet and innocent. Puuulllease! Oh and you should NEVER stop and restart. You're singing live. She should treat it like it's her concert. That was so unprofessional. She could have just continued and try to recover and make people forget about her mistake. That's what better singers do.

[ashleyluvspugs]

IDOL JUMPED THE SHARK!

to see the very mediocre boring off key sounds of this nice lady get to remain on the show when a powerful on key singer like Carly gets voted off, and Brooke isn't even in the bottom 2, is proof the show is a joke.

The Mormons really must have come out in force to vote for her, because Carly and Syesha were heads & shoulders above her and got less votes? Ridiculous. Seeing Jason stay on made sense, he has had 3 great performances (rainbow, hallelujah, travelin through)

[gatekeeper04]

Carly did not deserve to go home. Neither did Syesha. Brooke's got the looks I'd give her that. But she's no top12 singer. It's unfathomable! David Cook and David Archuleta will most likely be the finalists. No Brooke next week PLEASE!!! The nerve to have the orchestra restart. Ya it's difficult to sing in front of a live audience, the nerves kicking in and all, but why the hell would you ever think of restarting after already uttering a couple of lines?? What the hell?!

[islagirl84]

Even with this her screw-up, Brooke went on to sing a lot better than Jason did. Jason's performance was just painful. He sounded like a wounded animal. I still cannot believe he has made it this far in the competition. And Brooke has three great performances under her belt as well -- Let it Be, Love is a Battlefield and You're So Vain. Carly didn't deserve to go home -- Jason did.

[JSumpterluvr]

i would have to agree!

[136mcrrocksmysocks]

she looks like she was going to cry

[cogicva]

She needs to go home NOW!!!!

[MaximeMa]

it actually sounds like the band was not on cue at all... i think the AI band should be blamed for that one...

[Rangers4lf156]

wrong,

i voted for brooke about 25 times,

and jason around 100 times!

yeh. imma fan [=

[Hadeydeppio]

ur disgusting. vote for people that have actual talent u WHORE

[islagirl84]

Totally unnecessary. Grow up.

[easyfly]

Simon had every chance to slam Brooke but didn't. Even went as far to say he would have done the same thing. Brooke you are an amazing singer and from Nanny to Idol is what you will be remembered for. Keep singing girl we love you

[ImpmonLove]

my poor fellow arizonan... :(

[countrySTAR06]

thats so painful to watch

[tincode]

Paula was trying to say something that wouldn't hurt brooke's feelings too much. I thought it was well said. Took longer to say, but it would..she was finding the right words to let her down easy. People should really calm down about it.

[EstepaOnYou]

wow, is paula drugged? spit it out.. hurry up! its so annoying when she talks

[1Kaylor1]

I couldn't agree more with EstepaOnYou. Mrs. One Hit Wonder, shouldn't talk. Literally. Every time she opens her mouth I'm compelled to cram my ears with cotton balls. Damn is she annoying. Irrelevant ... and inarticulate.

[KatherineXIX]

Haha, Paula can't even insult her articulately...

[crazydany2u]

ha ha

[jerzeygirl63095]

i love brooke!!! who cares if she messed up? i would too if that many people were watching!!(I voted for her 55 times last night! lol!)

[VintageSunset]

You know it only counts as one vote, right? Its just a rumer that you can ovte hundreds of times:)

[christentze]

wow. :D 55 times is a lot! well, i personally think she handled it gracefully! she could've just been like, shit! and to start again, that must have been hard because i'd be scared i'd get to the same point and forget the lyrics again. everyone makes mistakes. im glad she has a loyal fan like you.

[zapjaste]

Terrible

[df1g]

You should not be talking crazyconffesion!!

Look at yourself in the mirror!!

[CrazyConfession]

Its time for you to be sent home country girl