Real Metal vs Fake Metal

[2009korte]

if you swap the first two photos the titles would be opposite. never judge by look.

[Mitchkilroy]

I thought this was awesome till it said GnR isnt metal. Guns clearly qualifies as metal.

[theKlaw]

Lost it at Limp Bizkit. I knew I should have pissed before watching this.

[andrews5879]

Meus parabens o video realmente é a realidade vc é oq chamamos um true headbanger mesmo abraço

[reptiles5522]

slipknot and avenged sevenfold is ten times better than those long faggot no-names you got on there

[antisciaf]

iron maiden, shit for faggots

[metaluke17]

Totally agree with the video except that Cradle of Filth is metal, and it's the only metal on the fake metal side

[xXDeadoraliveXx]

You're a stupid ignorant cunt...

[poshymon1989]

ass hole !

[brilligate]

What about steel Panther is theay a metal? ha-ha-ha-HA

[stijn291297]

Goddammit you are comparing alternative metal to original metal

you clearly don't now shit about metal

metallica = trash metal you bitch!!

marylin manson = industrial you fuck

limp bizkit = nu metal you seriously should have known that man

guns 'n roses = oh my god serious?!? that's rock man!!

and if that is anywhere close to metal it would be pop metal

please don't make more videos you are giving people a bad sight on the metalworld

[GuitarAimingOrNot]

you have to write in your heading: difference of old and and new metal styles

[GuitarAimingOrNot]

@GuitarAimingOrNot and the old metal bands are almost fuckin horrible now!!!

[andonakis10]

WTF??!! GUNS N ROSES IS A ROCK BAND!! WHY IS ON THIS VIDEO??!! WTF??!!!

[Slip7346]

Pera ai Metal pra vc tem q te cabelo grande e seo FDP . babaca

[Ciecho]

Personally.. i think u re the greatest metalhead all arround the world o.O

[tametaliczna666]

Fuck You :)



[HardMusicMenno]

Deicide is frigging awsome metal:D

[Baza45able]

Ok... who the hell said that Marilyn Manson is metal?Really now.The same goes for Limb Bizkit.No one said that they sing metal ffs.Avenged Sevenfold...... even they said that they are hardcore and not metal.Slipknot are metal :).You can't call them emo or that kind of shit so....they aren't hardrock or something so they are metal.Linkin Park never said that they are metal:).Papa Roach is Hard Rock.. .What I want to say it is that there is not "fake metal" or "true metal" ok?

[valdivianax]

Where is Exodus?? Where is Anthrax?? Where is Hirax?? Sucker!

[valdivianax]

Bitch Please!



[valdivianax]

Ooh Se nota que eres el Dios del metal!!

[666JpMayheM666]

Guns n roses are hardrock :P why are they mentioned

[colosalguitarist]

see..thing is what i hate about alot of metal heads is that theyr like ''we don't care bout our image coz we aint pussy n shit like hat '' yet if they see a band and they don't visually apeal to em theyr put off...hypocrit much/??? although i love metal but some of the people are worse than scene kids

[colosalguitarist]

sory but what aint metal about slipknot..i think alot of ..those ''i love pure metal'' hate them just coz alot of scene kids like them...

and that in itself is a scene thing to do....uhh i dont like this band coz look who listens to em...

guitars tuned down to drop B...blast beats on the drums..double bass pedal..potent snare drum..massive attitude...a fuck you persona..

[hellmaniac18]

Most of them are metal but you are just too stupid to realise that...

[colosalguitarist]

its your opinion on metal..and your entittled to it...but to me.personaly:

real metal:metallica,,korn,slipknot­,avenged sevenfold(i don't care..they just are metal)black sabbath,meshuggah,maiden,judas priest,children of bodom,sepultura etc

fake metal

bring me the horizon.and anyone who sounds like that

who ever was on at 2:48

..

[gore138]

champel of fuckin ghouls

[gore138]

MORBID FUCKIN ANGEL

[gore138]

MORBID FUCKIN ANGEL

[gore138]

hahha slayer you putted here MORBID FUCKING ANGEL?! NO FUCKIN COMPETITION! DEATH NILE CARCASS CRYPTOPSY THRASHING SLAYER MORBID ANGEL... DESTROYED

[gore138]

oh sorry slayer lol

[gore138]

oh sorry motherfucking Cryptopsy

[gore138]

sorry carcass

[gore138]

metal? ok ok DEATH AND NILE...

[MegaGuitarFreak123]

I disagree with a7x! They rule every fuckin band from that list.

[Bozvedjan]

You know a thing ? It's just diffrent Metal like Iron Maiden are Heavy Metal and Slipknot are like Death Metal. So why are you even bothering your self doing this fucking videos ? If you don't like other kind of Metal then go fuck your self instead of doing this videos !

[Hunntroll]

I disagree i like most of these bands (ou called metal and not too) You are very conservative but thats not a problem. Only one thing Cradle of Filth is the highest peak that metal can ever reach. Sorry its my Opinion but i do understand your's :)

[H4stein]

I agree with your video

[L1ST3Reda]

not all must be metal, its only rock, for WELCOME TO THE JUNGLE example

[jaakuutio]

So its about the lenght of hair?

[Cannedheat24]

Most of the comparisons in this video are absolute shit, this vid is badly made sorry!

[ROCKIT1960]

Scheiß Video. Es lügt andauernd.

[SINcereSmirk]

bro...,do your homework.

Guns n Roses is not a metal band, and MCR, I think those boys are meant to be emo punk rock or something. To call them fake metal is like calling a goose a fake duck.

[keaton223]

@SINcereSmirk lol a fake duck

[TheMouthBreaker]

Who said Linkin Park Is Metal ?

[Anka08111998]

Cradle If Filth is real black metal! It's not fake! I agree with you in everything exept this. :) \m/

[Bounzer88]

dude i like your thinkings bout metallica... but early Guns N' Roses is really near to Glam Metal... so dont call it Fake Metal.

Still i think that Slash is the most overrated Guitarplayer ever.

[LArsISmyNAme]

Haha, i enjoyed watching video and thank you for putting death in there too! :)

[Nekronatalenheten]

Funny how most of the bands you call "not metal" don't even claim to be metal. How can you waste your time on those stupid things? If you were real musicians or music lovers you would spend your time listening to music not telling other people what is "true" and what isn't. But well, it's the internet so... lol

[Fucklesticks]

LOL at the Metallica part, but it's the truth.

[saynotogmailforyoutu]

LoL'd at all the fake metal untill the one after slayer that one just pissed me off , whats the name of that band anyways , "fist filled fags ?"

[Drewer222]

Bro you are right in all of them but you forgot PANTERA but good video:)

[PrimeXDubstep]

G'n'R is rock faggot

[ZOMLUVER]

@PrimeXDubstep Get over it

[lulzlover59]

I love how for Slipknot you choose their most poppy song.

[d6rk3m0]

wtf why you think people think that deathcore is the same like metaland a scream is just way difrend

[Bleach182metal]

bad video.. aprende antes de criticar sos tremendo metalero poser..

aunq no me guste Limp bizkit no digo q no es metal.. Poser de mierd

El metalcore y el death melodico junto con el Power se comen en dos panes a cualquier mierd q vos digas q es Metal..

[ATTACK421]

MARLYN MANSON IS NOT METAL......and all of it is metal just different kinds of metal....except maralyn manson because he in my opnion is the worst vocalist of all time

[HaveSomeQuark]

is that tenacious d i hear lol???

[kingrichard2221]

Ye I agree slipknot and suicide silence!! They are metal!

[napalmpudding]

everything is agreed accept for Fuckin' Sliplnot and Suicide Silence

[PSNaj15]

@napalmpudding your opinion. i fucking love Slipknot

[Fribn]

Death in this video? Yeah. This guy knows what he is talking about.

[ThomasEtan]

Thanks ...

[The2Toilets]

jeeesus, my head is cracking becouse of your narrow taste of music and this shitty compare video

[1ceI3iamond]

I wouldnt call it Metal and no Metal

Ofc Marylin Manson and some other gay bands you showed that i dont even know are shit, but you divided what i would call old / trve Metal and newer Metal like Deathcore, Screamo, Nu Metal and so on..

But I'd call the newer Music also Metal, it's not the same anymore but it aint all shit.

I, for example, love Iron Maiden but I also like Trivium or Suicide Silence alot.

Stop hating, we Metalheads need to rise together against REAL shit like Pop music :)

[carloz1536]

@1ceI3iamond You so called "metalheads" are the reason look down upon metal. Deathcore is not metal. It's a bastardized hardcore genre that a lot of trendy fucks try to pass out as a metal subgenre, Ju-metal is wank ass alt-rock because it lacks metal elements (heavy riffs and generic vocals does not make one metal), and screamo... Hah you're joking right?! Pop music has been dead for years yet a lot of pop is better than that shit music trying so hard to be metal.

[Autumnal2]

So it's okay to jump from Sabbath -> Gorgoroth and still call it metal? It's just as huge leap as from Sodom -> Trivium.

[MrScreamingCamel]

Get fucked.

[JuanStradlin]

Guns n roses es Hard Rock, no metal .l.

[JuanStradlin]

La seunda banda no es metal!, el genero se llama Screamo! informate :B

[megadeth6660]

Im glad i know your opinion now.

[CrystalMethod16661]

This is all metal, just different subgenres. I don't like it most of your "Real Metal" but i don't call them FAKE, lol

[Buddimaaan]

sorry but GET A LIFE

Slipknot is metal, BMTH is metal,Metallica and also St.Anger is fucking metal!

it is ok if you dont like this bands, but nobody gives a fuck about your opinion!

I guess you are the ultimate goredomedeathfreak ever, but do you have any friends?

4chan-psycho

[Lefters666]

@Buddimaaan bmth is gay :))

[Julz333666]

You dirty bug



[sergiolo666]

Sure A7X IS NOT METAL?!!?!?!?! (facepalm)

[carloz1536]

@sergiolo666 Well they're not moron. 

[pippo139]

I think you don't get laid often do you?

[Sajotyn]

Sure, Guns'n'Roses isn't Metal...

[TimeayTerrorizesTofu]

@Mulchmann36 but another kind of metal...

[Mulchmann36]

Nu-Metal is also Metal-.-!

[TimeayTerrorizesTofu]

who said that these bands are metal? :D many of them are post hardcore or nu-metal...

[Fistler01]

trivium is not metal? ok

now i know who is a troll

[carloz1536]

@Fistler01 Shitty ass metchulcore is shitty. Metalcore is a hardcore subgenre that was once good, but posers like the morons in lame of god, trivium and killswitch engage try to pass it out as a metal genre only because they rip off shitty melodic death metal.

[ogiQQlele]

ofc guns arent metal ? who said they are?

[Kelzuzard]

linken park is not metal ... they are rockrap and/or Rock metal

[Kelzuzard]

just because you don't like som kind's of metal does not mean it's not metal

[KingTaargusVII]

@Kelzuzard true, but sorry, this guy is right. All of the shitty bands that were listed aren't metal.

[adicius10]

AHAHAHAHAH, dude, guns and fags is fucking fag, LIKE for sure.

[whiteorangatange]

you a bitch

[justyn3tears]

REAL Metal = Veil Of Maya, After The Burial, Born Of Osiris, Whitechapel, As I Lay Dying, Parkway Drive and any other Metal band that writes their own shit, has intelligent lyrics that actually have a meaning.

Fake Metal = Attack Attack, Asking Alexandria, Black Veil Brides and all the 80's glam Metal

[Renagade1325]

I personally cant stand Nile

[rrwwe]

this video is true but by the looks of it youre just another close minded elitist. youre list should have been more diverse than thrash and death. (sabbath and gorgoroth are exceptions)

[Dysaniclol]

a few of the "not metal" bands weren't even in the metal genre or close..but Slayer, Iron Maiden, and Black Sabbath are the shit..sad to see no Pantera :(

[Macerman2]

Music is music, end of discussion. segregating specific bands or genres and bashing them just shows that you are not a true music lover. If you were, you could at least appreciate the time and effort these people put into their careers as musicians, whether you like them or not.

[patitox4474]

hijo de tu gran puta no insultes a cradle of filth

[evildaemo]

praise metallica for being metal, then say theyre not...

its not metal vs non metal. its music written on drugs vs sober music

[xxraverxx1]

suicide silence ll the waay..obviously FUCK slipknot hahah.....seconds from the end,whats it gonna be,pull the trigger bitch-ss

[borderangels]

Hmmm Metal Dosent have brakedowns (x



[ItzBrennanYo]

Cradle of Filth is awesome

[ItzBrennanYo]

Oh shit, this guy doesn't know what the fuck metal is

[ItzBrennanYo]

Oh shit this nigger just dissed marilyn manson

[exerminator2000]

you call that constipated cookie monster taking a shit... music?

[moonharpz321]

lol who said marilyn manson was metal?

[MetalDeth777]

All you had to say was "Queer Masks" for shitknot. hahaha

[MetalDeth777]

Shitty bands are the reason for illegal downloading, so that no one would have to spend 10 bucks on a shitty CD

[dibi234]

Who gives a fuck!! they are both just soulless idiot noise, want real music?? Jimi Hendrix ftw!! Just sayin is all!!

[theGothic25]

Fuck yehhh!! dude i agree with u.. but cradle of filth - gothic romance its real metal, is all about the genres...

[terdball852]

thank god for fake metal o_O

[jimi7436]

i play in a british heavy metal band called shameful behaviour check us out on youtube

[MartinHansen97]

Then I would say fake metal !

[Ikkishimashi]

Congratulations! You've learned that deathcore, rapcore, industrial rock, rock, pop and more (i didn't want to continue watching it) aren't metal! You genius! How coult it be that these genres aren't metal!

[oly355]

I used to like metalheads. I though they were better people than the rap niggah fuckers,but the more I meet, the more they disgust me by the fact that they are may even be worst than the rappers fuckers. I think as long as an artist play with his heart, he's considered metal, but to put some band aside, that's just wrong. I like some of those you said were bad, and it's all a matter of self belief.

I also think, you did it wrong

[EsdrasMetallier]

My ass, Guns'n Roses never beem called metal!

[lucamonaco90]

but....Trivium Rulez!!!

[lucamonaco90]

Good lesson man

[Buhjachacka]

Calling Cradle of Filth "Not-Metal" is just another shortcut to hell. As for Slipknot, even though I don't really like them, they can considered Metal since their last few Albums.

Suicide Silence is Metal aswell.

[SkeleThorusRex]

this was obviously made by somebody who grew up in the 80's, however, they are NOT all metal. there are defining characteristics in music that place songs and artists in different categories, and this is true for a reason. you wouldnt call a squirrel a notebook, just like you wouldnt call manson or lp metal.

[fares57]

3:14 They get the chicks though...

[imperator166]

you are fuckin right \m/

[pwdfarky]

i hope u die slowly : DDDDDD idiot

[LukasPuk]

No dislike bar on this video, like this comment if you dislike this video.

[GTArichard]

who cares what you think is metal

[6Ikilledthepromqueen]

4:25 What the fuck is up with that middle guys finger?

[Domanat0r]

GnR not metal,... dude your an idiot,... thats fucking rock captain obvious... hahaa

[djfrank203]

Real and fake metal? since when was music FAKE? Its not up to you to decide, it's up to the listener!

[555TANATOS]

slipknot i think is metal!!!

[QuestionOfHeaven]

"I hope you learn what metal is"?? Dude, seriously, do you think you're some prophet or something? We have ears and brains ourselves, the fact that you label "metal" just according to your own opinion has nothing to do with other people. Just enjoy music people...

[Unkn0wnS0urc9]

=]] let listen rap or pop =]] ....

[smashead]

pathetic. Sad, and Pathetic.

[patto668]

so your an elitist twat that cant accept that all music evolves.

[Zadeify]

Fake metal consists usually themes like: "girlfriend left me, feels bad man" and all that kinda shit

[HeadBangar1030]

Not fake, just bad...

[SkullThirteen]

THIS IS TRUE... That is all

[Stoner69ification]

only a couple of yours are real metal, real metal started in the 1960's with bands like Alice Cooper, Black Sabbath, Lead zeppelin, Motorhead those are all real metal bands the original heavy metal learn your metal newfags.

As for slipknot they are fucking GOD! nu-metal but still amazing. and limp bizkit said themselves they were rock not metal so why are they even in here?

[BttrDanU64]

you cant have any room to talk we like what u like u cant compare metal because its all awsome we neeed to worry about gay pop and shit and i love slipknot

[denisborzenkov]

author of this shit video is complexed cocksucker comparing technical death and rapcore

[ThePhenix76]

And this video is usefull for what? You just spit on music you don't like... You seem like a rapper with this mind.... This is metal, this is not... If you don't like Linkin Park, Limp Bizkit, Slipknot, Monson, it's your choice... But don't say that's not metal... It's metal fusion or indus metal... Gorgoroth isn't metal anyway if I think like you... it's black metal... Nothing to do with true heavy metal

[DemoncKats]

Deicide, Nile, Gorgoroth(all black metal) is sick!

[nsschorty418]

Don't talk shit on Trivium.

[steinafl]

yeah you cant really put off marilyn manson and mip bizkit just cause they make a different style

[steinafl]

@steinafl ok after watching the whole thing i can say this really is more who do you think are the cool metal acts. (and yes alot of those NOT bands are really lame)

[YouAreDeath]

Lol putting suicide silence in a same video as Limp Bizkit? you must be new here.

[owneded56]

FUCK YOU GUNS N ROSES IS METAL hahaha i totally agree with everything else youve said though.

[ireternalexistence]

This is like when I go to the opticians to have an eye test. They say "Which is clearer, the red or the green".

[Sirrush87]

i think that the maker of this film loves trolling and wanna just have fun reading comments. if the taste of your music would be described by thoose bands you should go hide in a deep hole at the end of a world... dunno why u put screamo/rock vs metal bands ? and why the fuck you think numetal is not a genre of this beatiful music... even thou i like the whole idea of a troll film

[Arachnial]

and papa roach is more metal and more MUSIC, than this crap of gorgoroth will ever be

[maneggl]

@Arachnial Obvious troll is obvious.

[Arachnial]

@maneggl im a troll? just complaining about todays people who say music to SHIT

[Valhallaawaitsyou1]

@Arachnial and the last resort riff is stolen from iron maiden

[Lefters666]

@Arachnial go fuck your self and ass with papa asslicker!

[Arachnial]

@Lefters666 good argument you kid...

and i know that? the main riff is similar, but you cant say stolen. there is so fuckin' much music in the world, of course songs may sound similar. if you would have a working brain, you would understand that

go back to the hole wherever you came from

[Arachnial]

maneggl, your taste of good music partly sucks di**

gorgoroth for example is just bullsh**

maybe they see themselves as metal, but metal is a MUSIC genre...

[guitarlord1289]

Gorgoroth is gay the singer is gay

[guitarlord1289]

Dethklok and meshuggah is metal al that is crap

[poetwarrior13]

Trivium is definately metal. I call bullshit.

[ness6666666]

In many cases I accept terms of video, but M&M (we not take these video) not metal or bear step on your ear or you fuck yourself in it with your perfect musical mind. My mind on these video this is SHIT!!! (Sorry for my bad English)

[lalozz007]

slipknot = GAY!!!



[Afrolify]

THIS IS SHIIIIIIIIIIT!!

[MrBeeBool]

Congratulations! You have successfully fucked up this video! Limp Bizkit, Slipknot, Guns'n'roses, Metallica, (old) Linkin Park, Papa Roach, Craddle of Filth etc. ... I don't want to live on this planet anymore...

[MrBeeBool]

hey fuck off from limp bizkit! they're playing nu-metal or rapcore and they're playing it good -.-

[Headbanger6436]

es ist doch verfickt egal metal oder "nicht" hauptsache die musik !!!

[runescapeia]

How the fuck can someone say 'Fake' Metal? People who say that one genre of music is 'fake' and that one is 'real' are just fucking faggots. Listen to what ever the fuck you want to.

[ChimeraSeuchenmord]

''Real'' & ''fake'' Metal dosen't exist....

[RiesenBoHei]

I love Deathmetal and also Deathcore, but I hate this fucking emo shit

[erolllllllllllllllll]

oh guy you sucks very hard^^ it gives, death metal,black metal.power metal.speed metal.melo death metal.alternative metal. pagan metal. folk metal. e.t.c e.t.c metal its not all the same you faggot. yes the fucking deathcore,metalcore,screamo and the same fuck are not metal. but  its came from metal. it gives gäy metal and normal metal genres.

[heber97x]

hijo e la gran puta

[proHEADBANGER15]

you make me sick OLD metal isnt the ONLY metal you fucking retard