I love you sooooo much Take That, you're the greatest group ever, Oh my darling Gary Barlow; what a gorgeous singer love u so much & your lovely voice mwahhhhh
He's amazing live i just dont see why hes either not a solo act or why he doesnt let them actually sing in the song,, not just " ooooo" and "ahhhhh" throughout the song..
@Delokrat for the tour they're doing it so that the songs they did as a four piece will be performed as a four piece, then they'll have a set as all together and then robbie gets his own set. so this song won't be with robbie next to them!
These boys made my teen years very, very happy. I saw them live twice and it was awesome. I'm poorud they were my teen crush as they're still making good music and can still put on a damn good show :O)
Could somebody imagine Robbie's singing this song? I'm not too happy about Robbie rejoined Take That, now Robbie will try to lead almost all songs. I'm a Robbie's core fan, but they are just too different now. I like Gary's voice, when I want to listen to Take That, I want this, not Robbie.
@eeedwrds1 I am totally agree with you. It is just weird because Take That's style is ballad and soft rock while Robbie Williams' style is more to rock. You can also check on The Flood on X Factor. I realised that Robbie Williams cannot sing the background sound. He dont have the voice and long breathe.
How can anyone sound so perfect live! exactly like the irginal in every live performance of every song, dont get better than take that; musicians as well as vocalists, writing their own songs (especially gary)
@Thinkingjelle >> Donot agree..they both have own potentials as singer/songwriter (read: Robbie and Gary) so take time to be content my friend coz it is the MUSIC of the soul. btw it's great to see take that becomes the fab five again, let them take time to be friendly again...it brings happiness!!!
Sorry but Myrmianin if u don't know backstreet boys music - please don't write this stupid things about them. They also write own stuff and they're not only good looking u know :) listen to them acapella before u will judge them and also other artists. Anyway this TT show is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! love it so so much:-) thx
have seen thm at every concert as one daughter grew out of thm the younger 1 wood grew in2 thm so seen thm wiv Robbie.......till ths yr The Circus Im in2 heavy metal n ths concery was WOW....N ....FANTASTIC...IT blew me away n Mark blew a kiss to my daughter n she cried......brillant.
DONT READ THIS Cause It Really Works. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY
I don't know why do you think that Westlife are better that Take That.Only Mark and Shane can actually sing in Westlife-about Nicky and Kian->they can't sing(specially Nicky..can't stand him)...
Take That is amazng,not because I personally am their fan but..what they've done with the music after comeback..is just amazing..
one more thing...most of Westlife hits(80%) are just covers..on the other hand Take That make their own music!!!
And then people said that westlife are better...c'mon just compare Gary(TT) and Nicky(Westlife)....Nicky can't sing he is just pretty...Gary is amazing songwriter,singer,good looking and so one...everyone has their own opinion but is just the fact that-TAKE THAT RULE THE WORLD!!!!
They are my all time fave band ever am so happy they have reformed and been successfull where others like East 17,Boyzone and All Saints failed.I love Mark he is so cute
i AGREE WITH RIGMON. GARY HAS THE BEST VOCAL ABILITIES. i LIKE HOWARD TOO, BUT GARY IS DEFINITELY THE BEST. i´M SO HAPPY THEY´VE COME BACK!!!!!!!!I LOVE THEM! THANKS FOR THE VIDEO.
I've never heard a song in my life that so closely matched my life experiences .I love this song and every time I hear it I cry.I love my Linda because she has patience and understands me.
kisses & hugs to my cutest Gary ever in the world
MsRosy1983 3 weeks ago in playlist Take That
I love you sooooo much Take That, you're the greatest group ever, Oh my darling Gary Barlow; what a gorgeous singer love u so much & your lovely voice mwahhhhh
MsRosy1983 3 weeks ago in playlist Take That
love how his gestures to help concentrate on hitting the notes perfectly. the man has an awesome ear. so talented.
raylantigua 1 month ago
suuuper,ich liebe das Lied!!
DJAkira1989 1 month ago
i swear garys mic is the only one turned on
stompman101 2 months ago 2
@stompman101 because he has a great lovely voice :*
MsRosy1983 3 weeks ago in playlist Take That
Gary boys will win the x factor
jordanm679 3 months ago 2
que video,me encanta este grupo
JOHN2985694 3 months ago
Howard, I LOVE YOU!
cocosilk 3 months ago
i love the way gary flicks his hands about and, to be honest, i just love him, what a god.
poisonousremedy 5 months ago 7
@poisonousremedy i love him moreeeeeeee he's the best singer ever
MsRosy1983 3 weeks ago in playlist Take That
I'm not a huge fan of that kind of pop music
but damn they are kickin some balls right there
dammit!
ChillerKarnickel 5 months ago 3
Deutsch/German = Ich liebe dieses Lied.
English = I love this song.
Simone731441 5 months ago
He's amazing live i just dont see why hes either not a solo act or why he doesnt let them actually sing in the song,, not just " ooooo" and "ahhhhh" throughout the song..
LoraaCharlotte 5 months ago
thumbs up if you are watching this in 2011
mmhe01 5 months ago 32
@UltraVerySpecial He is leaving again to do a solo album, but I agree with you completely:)
abbbbdance09 5 months ago
i love you gary :)
ahyun617 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
you can hardly tell that this is live
billsemotional 6 months ago
howard's hair!!!!!!! <3
MsRumpelheinzchen 6 months ago
I have tried really hard to embrace the idea of Robbie being back in the band, but this reminds me how fantastic they are as a four piece!!
TheGillyfilly 6 months ago 3
jason is so amazing!
TheLYRICSBOSS 6 months ago
i need this type of song in this current situation. man im doomed.
dirtykitchen 7 months ago
sometimes i think , they were better like four-piece band.....
Sygi5 7 months ago 3
@Sygi5
I think that, too - not just sometimes.
MyNewSensation 1 month ago
Perfect.
l381t 7 months ago
Beautiful.
xliilmiissx 8 months ago
they never play instruments?
Juandiegodiverso 8 months ago
@Juandiegodiverso Watch the following video's on YT. You can see them play instruments.
Take That - «How Did It Come To This» [At Wembley / The Circus Live] [HD]
Take That - «Up All Night» [At Wembley / The Circus Live] [HD]
Take That - «Wooden Boat» [At Wembley / The Circus Live] [HD]
JouwBuisjeNL 8 months ago
thumbs up if you've loved take that from the beginning ,leather jockstraps,jelly,the lot!!
keanegazing 8 months ago
2:51 Alexa, you say you like punk but we can see you getting all excited with that falsetto!
abcchede 8 months ago
Nunca consideré demasiado a Gary Barlow, ¡¡impresionante sorpresa al escucharle en directo!! well done boys!!
basquegirl1 8 months ago
wow this doesn't seem long ago, about 5 years!!!
Mrazza11 9 months ago in playlist Take That
AWESOME BAND~ AWESOME SONG~ AWESOME GARY~
chongyaoxiang 9 months ago 2
it is realy great. Gary has so special and clean voice. So it is the best singer on the world :)
bajatela 10 months ago 3
Gary I just love you...!!!
cauac8 10 months ago
Take That - Germany loves you!!!
No other international band is so popular in Germany
Gary, Howard, Jason and Robbie you are awesome.
Dschland92 10 months ago
muy bonita cancion
JOHN2985694 10 months ago
Mum: turn that shit down
me: its take that
mum:turn that shit up
saltandpepper59 10 months ago 2
this sounds so bad live lolol. only the chorus though. the rest is alright.
MattKondrath 10 months ago
seeing robbie next to them would be extremely wrong
Delokrat 11 months ago 3
@Delokrat for the tour they're doing it so that the songs they did as a four piece will be performed as a four piece, then they'll have a set as all together and then robbie gets his own set. so this song won't be with robbie next to them!
west7689 10 months ago
Gary's the best singer/songwriter in my humble opinion....just sooo talented and such a nice guy!!!!!!
ErnestoAH 11 months ago 2
gary's voice is AMAZING.... so smooth and sexy
westlife4life 11 months ago 3
These boys made my teen years very, very happy. I saw them live twice and it was awesome. I'm poorud they were my teen crush as they're still making good music and can still put on a damn good show :O)
Elvinauk 11 months ago 2
he is the best live :)
joshlorenzen1 1 year ago
Gary is so amazing!
SoVerySpecial101 1 year ago 51
@SoVerySpecial101 yes!
Edunkaznh 3 months ago
Comment removed
SoVerySpecial101 1 year ago
Comment removed
SoVerySpecial101 1 year ago
MARK OWEN TAKE ME HERE AND NOW :D
antitainment 1 year ago
love your voice gary!!
valentinarog 1 year ago
i need tickets to see these live! :(
caattxo 1 year ago
I feel like running up to Gary Barlow and Pulling his cheeks!...x
Love Mark, Gary, Jason and Howard..xooh and Robbie...(almost forgot him then!)
lkjhg1098 1 year ago
I feel like running up to Gary Barlow and Pulling his cheeks!...x
Love Mark, Gary, Jason and Howard..x
lkjhg1098 1 year ago
Could somebody imagine Robbie's singing this song? I'm not too happy about Robbie rejoined Take That, now Robbie will try to lead almost all songs. I'm a Robbie's core fan, but they are just too different now. I like Gary's voice, when I want to listen to Take That, I want this, not Robbie.
eeedwrds1 1 year ago 3
@eeedwrds1 I am totally agree with you. It is just weird because Take That's style is ballad and soft rock while Robbie Williams' style is more to rock. You can also check on The Flood on X Factor. I realised that Robbie Williams cannot sing the background sound. He dont have the voice and long breathe.
derrick940930 9 months ago
Comment removed
eeedwrds1 1 year ago
How can anyone sound so perfect live! exactly like the irginal in every live performance of every song, dont get better than take that; musicians as well as vocalists, writing their own songs (especially gary)
astonJLSmarvin 1 year ago 2
0:51 and 0:54 how into the song howard and jason look! <3 loove gary!!
astonJLSmarvin 1 year ago
Gotta give the backing vocals their due, great harmonys
addey83 1 year ago
gary barlow is an awesome singer. but the others always doing just backround
abiiibiii 1 year ago
Take that are brilliant, robbie williams is a mistake.
keanuu 1 year ago 3
i will be seeing this live. i cannot wait! :D :D
MissLozza92 1 year ago
love Gary Barlow's
voice
mrmaniacobem 1 year ago 6
@mrmaniacob
em
yes garys voice is soooo nice and amazing.hes a wonderful man
with a wonderful voice.i love him!
sammy3473 1 year ago 3
Ich liebe dieses Lied. TT sind die Besten!!!!!!
kevinfan09 1 year ago
Gary Barlow is amazing. Period.
griffeyjrfan 1 year ago 2
@griffeyjrfan faggot. go fuck a monkey
edkes123 1 year ago
@edkes123 I'm a girl. Kind of impossible for me to be a faggot. But thanks for the thought anyway.
griffeyjrfan 1 year ago
@griffeyjrfan point taken, thanks for the feedback :)
edkes123 1 year ago
without robbie williams is take that nothing. robbie williams is really great. i know why he left take that
Thinkingjelle 1 year ago
@Thinkingjelle >> Donot agree..they both have own potentials as singer/songwriter (read: Robbie and Gary) so take time to be content my friend coz it is the MUSIC of the soul. btw it's great to see take that becomes the fab five again, let them take time to be friendly again...it brings happiness!!!
villebunch 1 year ago
@Thinkingjelle To become more famous and make more money.
Firstserger 1 year ago
I love this song. I love these sexxxy guys!
sexybuttcel 1 year ago
great 1 man!!!!mindblowing....
hitman12345100 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a bunch of cunts!
vikingmog 1 year ago
Westlife and Take That are awesome! :D don't compare cos there is no point of comparison! they are unique in their own way
patitoguapo85 1 year ago
celtic3342 well yea its better in studio and you dont have the pressure like u do in stage and he is way better then u sing >=(
Horseeriding411 1 year ago
i really like them they are amazing!!!!!
gdgdgd01 1 year ago
better in studio ...
celtic3342 1 year ago
I like Gary changes his beautifull voice to many ways. I gos a lot of emotions eith his voice.
tete3002 1 year ago 5
Sorry but Myrmianin if u don't know backstreet boys music - please don't write this stupid things about them. They also write own stuff and they're not only good looking u know :) listen to them acapella before u will judge them and also other artists. Anyway this TT show is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! love it so so much:-) thx
MrsAnGeLiKa1005 1 year ago 2
is this really live?
if it is, this is brilliant singing as it is really close to the recorded version!
Mstar82 1 year ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fake and gay
borgarvegur 1 year ago
@borgarvegur
you are an IDIOT !!!
ynossi65 1 year ago
oh i love gary and i love this song, i love also that german tv series bergdoktor
jockeyhanes 1 year ago 2
fantastic
Faith00007 1 year ago
the best boyband right now
mrmaniacobem 1 year ago 4
his falsetto ability is AMAZING! split second change!!!!!!
theironfreak 2 years ago 4
Yeah, when mark laughs it shows his boyish side.
ellenwispa 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Be The Change by Paper Plane Factory
Hear it !!! You will not regret it !!!
a dainsh band
Julemanden555 2 years ago
I like Mark face when his sing is cute.
adcrg 2 years ago
i agree, he is so cute
ktesuarez 2 years ago
once i saw TT live. years agow. I would like to see them again. Great live!!! Love them so much!!!
nathalieben1 2 years ago
join my FB group 'knight gary barlow'
VR462007 2 years ago 32
the best boy band ...
zarapato 2 years ago 6
gary barlow is amasing,
robbie is shit compared to him.!
greghead123 2 years ago 5
i luv gary, he cute, funny, fit and robbie is just gay, like u sed shit lol
LUV U GARY!!! XX
kissyjessy1995 2 years ago
nobody to touch the fab 4. what a fantastic show they never fail to impress
no other boyband can touch them thats why take that are a man band
ianhands1001 2 years ago 4
i love take that so much
they are the bestest band live!!!!
MARKOWENISSEXY 2 years ago 3
I love them soooo much *_*
Mark... no words to describe him <3
AlexisGinny 2 years ago 2
amazing performance !!!!
marivi2710 2 years ago 3
probably the best band live
discomaleriya 2 years ago 6
Highly agreed.
kimstarr28 2 years ago
How can you say that when you have bands like Queens of the Stoneage and Rage Against The Machine!!
crazywelshdood 2 years ago
have seen thm at every concert as one daughter grew out of thm the younger 1 wood grew in2 thm so seen thm wiv Robbie.......till ths yr The Circus Im in2 heavy metal n ths concery was WOW....N ....FANTASTIC...IT blew me away n Mark blew a kiss to my daughter n she cried......brillant.
LadyMacalla 2 years ago 2
Aww that's so sweet. I love Mark and i think i would have done the same :)
I have wished and wished for years to see Take That live one day...but that day hasn't come. My parents are abit short of cash right now.
xxx
TakeThatter95 2 years ago
I absolutely love Take That, I've seen them live twice now and every time they get better and better! =D
I LOVE GARY BARLOW SOOOOO MUCH!!
xxleeshxx 2 years ago 5
...the 4 fantastics
victorvicmech 2 years ago 2
gary looks soooo HOT!!!!
williamsnj 2 years ago 4
i love take that
sooooo much
there are the best and 4 ever
Entchen101 2 years ago
Awesome
aisis10 2 years ago
Take That Forever
I love you MARK.. i got to see them live at the circus concert woooot i'm sooooo happy, i'm in love all over agian hahaha
Gracefull24 2 years ago
You sound like me. Haha. That's the exact same thing i saod when i fell in love with him :)
xxx
TakeThatter95 2 years ago
love the hair gary and the bangle i have one the same love ya gary your the best and sexy
GaryBarlowisFIT 2 years ago
brilliant!!!!!
jezdrew 2 years ago
take that- rulez the world!!
jerinandrews 2 years ago 3
very good song
nikolasboy100 2 years ago 2
i luv this song very much
bt when i clicked on the vid that contains the lyrics of this osng it didn't work..
i want the lyrics
btw the last man on the left is sooo AWESOME
thaaaanx
LiLo0o085 2 years ago
lol at how cute mark is at the beginning, just stood there with his head down!
god, i love him <3
clewbe 2 years ago 2
Oh my goshhhh! what voiceeeeee, and he is cuteeeeeee... hehehehe
kalahari72 2 years ago 2
you can`t say TAKE THAT and other Bands name in the same words.
TAKE THAT FOR LIVE
takethat1979 2 years ago
Comment removed
rikiparra1 2 years ago
you are crazy,no other boy band is like take that
weslife,never heared ....
gerica82 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
rikiparra1 2 years ago
take that are on a completely different level.
they are up there with the beatles! only not quite :)
clewbe 2 years ago
Take that sounds much better than Westlife
AngelC4ever 2 years ago 6
0:50
xXxSmEgZxXx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DONT READ THIS Cause It Really Works. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY
potatoebrainedbarito 2 years ago
amazing song...i love it!
rikrdo0413 2 years ago
Westlife are useless compared with take that.I would never consider spending my hard earned money on westlife records or concerts.Gary rules ok
sloanprince 3 years ago 4
I don't know why do you think that Westlife are better that Take That.Only Mark and Shane can actually sing in Westlife-about Nicky and Kian->they can't sing(specially Nicky..can't stand him)...
Take That is amazng,not because I personally am their fan but..what they've done with the music after comeback..is just amazing..
one more thing...most of Westlife hits(80%) are just covers..on the other hand Take That make their own music!!!
TJASA3 3 years ago 38
Even thought i'm Westlife's fan. But i think Take that is better.
About ur comment: I've never anyone else of Take that sing, always only Gary sings.
And who care about cover??? WL cover it but make it better so they get more talent than who sung before.
WL and Take that is both great, so stop fighting. Love Westlife, like Take That =))
PS:Sorry about my English
shaneshama 3 years ago
@TJASA3 oiii i will have you know that nicky can sing ur jelouse cuz he is sexi yea""
fucking do one
manchestachick 1 year ago
@TJASA3 I couldn't have said it better!
bsbarg 1 year ago
well, obviously you're 10 years old and you weren't about when Take That ruled!!
By the way, where's Westlife now, haven't heard from those "nice" boys for a while.
glirvin 3 years ago 7
so right...TAKE THAT>westlife
TJASA3 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
take that can easily be compared to westlife there both good bands (westlife are sooooo much better and they can all sing)
Westlife have been amazing for the past 10 years!!! Unlike take that
But Take That are rellly good thou :D
1melonnn 3 years ago
Take That Rulez !!!
No place for fakers
Ama7aa 3 years ago 14
Amazing
Insanaty 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yor all a bunch of woosies. Who the hell cares!!!!!
bleaksplodge 3 years ago
Oh Jesus!!! Please DO NOT compare Take That with Westlife, or Boyzone, specially not Backstreet Boys!!! :(
That that are musicians, specially Gary, not pretty boys who can barely sing and don't even write they're own songs...
Myrmianin 3 years ago 57
LOL WELL SAID DUDE
watchyamouth90 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Your all a bunch of woosies. Who cares!!!!!!!!!!!!
bleaksplodge 3 years ago
@Myrmianin you know, i have to disagree because every song i just see one guy singing while in bsb they ALL sing in EVERY song
simplemellody 1 year ago
@simplemellody bsb so all sing, but who is still selling 30 millions albums 15 years later?
dingo79saddleclub 1 year ago
@simplemellody bsb do all sing, but who is still selling 30 millions albums 15 years later?
dingo79saddleclub 1 year ago
@simplemellody the bsb do all sing, but who is still selling 30 millions albums 15 years later?
dingo79saddleclub 1 year ago
@simplemellody Yeah, the one guy mainly sings cause he's called the LEAD singer... plus who are the ones selling 30 million albums 15 years later?
dingo79saddleclub 1 year ago
It's a beautiful song...
erikkitta22 3 years ago 7
take that are the best boyband ever gary i love you fantsatic voice
liannemullin 3 years ago 6
And then people said that westlife are better...c'mon just compare Gary(TT) and Nicky(Westlife)....Nicky can't sing he is just pretty...Gary is amazing songwriter,singer,good looking and so one...everyone has their own opinion but is just the fact that-TAKE THAT RULE THE WORLD!!!!
TJASA3 3 years ago 3
WESTLIFE!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Take That is 1000 % better!!!
Airbusmike 3 years ago 4
take that are the best boy band ever along with backstreet boys and westlife and dont forget boyzone GARY IS SEXY brilliant live gary i love you
liannemullin 3 years ago
lol..cant believe you compare them to westlife boyzone and backstreet boys what the fucks wrong with you mate!
neilmc06 3 years ago 3
Amazing!
towanda83 3 years ago 4
why did gary loose all that weight he looks fuckin amazin on this x x
kimsecker17 3 years ago
i agree with you,he is too skinny now,and i don't like that beard of his...
RIGMON 3 years ago
i can remember watchin this on tv wooo! i love take that!
xxsammiexx91 3 years ago 3
excellent comeback. nice song, good live vocals
noamdahan18 3 years ago 4
Who is Robbie Williams?
bulditan 3 years ago 4
you must be joking ???
RIGMON 3 years ago
They are my all time fave band ever am so happy they have reformed and been successfull where others like East 17,Boyzone and All Saints failed.I love Mark he is so cute
Hidden2808 3 years ago
it really is a great video i love them to pieces
jasongreenwooduk 3 years ago
i love him!
garybarlowissexy07 3 years ago 2
Love it. Jay really looks like he is enjoying and into the song :D
rachelsnape 3 years ago
Great performance, You can tell they are singing live and he is hiting every single note!!! Love It
AAlexM 3 years ago
im in love with them!!!! ♥ i know they are like 15 years older than me but who cares!!!!!
analizmot 3 years ago
TAKE THAT OBSESSED"
They're amazing!
Gemsypie 3 years ago
Now, I'm not the kind f person to like boy bands and such - but fuck me - TT are fabulous, and this song is is superb!
hurstryan15 3 years ago 4
i AGREE WITH RIGMON. GARY HAS THE BEST VOCAL ABILITIES. i LIKE HOWARD TOO, BUT GARY IS DEFINITELY THE BEST. i´M SO HAPPY THEY´VE COME BACK!!!!!!!!I LOVE THEM! THANKS FOR THE VIDEO.
dorianagreen 3 years ago 4
They sound really great live! For me Patience is the best Take That song ever. :)
More so since Matt Evers and Kristina Lenko made it even special for me in DOI! They did it justice for sure.
tatina3 3 years ago 3
one of the best song by take that i love othrs eswell bt love this one to much
zeesh108 3 years ago 2
Heard other people trying to sing this song and they kill it! Only Gary can sing this so everyone eles dont bother trying!!!!!! Take that fan forever
suzlil34 3 years ago 6
I've never heard a song in my life that so closely matched my life experiences .I love this song and every time I hear it I cry.I love my Linda because she has patience and understands me.
jennypoosuzyq 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh my god, these guys had won the "best live act" instead of muse, what a crime
MANCVSO 3 years ago
they won for the best reasons! live with it!
drewdrei24 3 years ago 4
Gary sounds perfect live!
lolor22 3 years ago 9