He already sang CHANGE that's what got the piece of shit voted in. But YOU Americans won't let that happen again right?? I said RIGHT??? Barrack Hussein Obama......WTF was the first clue
as our country nears a time of crisis, we need to remember that the privately owned Federal Reserve is our problem, not who our president will be or if Gay marriage should be approved or not. Our Federal Reserve is to blame for many of the problems that we are facing today, we are essentially paying a tax to the owners of the Federal Reserve although the owners may or may not be American Citizens!! Please Remind everyone what our real problem is, and that is Taxation without representation!!
His birth certificate has been proven fake. Think his certificate is real? Download it from whitehouse.gov then put the file into adobe illustrator. You can break it INTO LAYERS- proving it was digitally made. Typewriter written documents do NOT BREAK APART INTO LAYERS WHEN SCANNED INTO A COMPUTER.
Obama is supposed to be your president however he is playing you ignorant americans for fools, signing away your liberties and compromising your future. Laugh as he entertains you with his singing ability while people are SHOT in the street protesting against the corporate greed that he is paid to endorse. When are you stupid americans going to wake up? can you not see what is going on? It is in 'their' interests for you to love obama.
Watch the Obama deception and wake your stupid self up.
Shut up O B O M B M A , just shut up leave the White House don't let the door hit your ass on the way out. Do us this one last favor for the love of God. Just GTFO before the country decides to turn a blind eye to embarrassment and impeaches you which is what I would like to see by the way. Just GTFO!!
@johnnycmajor Sorry, it was late when I wrote that and I was a bit grumpy and that was clouding my vision. I just felt like Obama hadn't done anything wrong.
@63litenin1 Ya outta ya mind.. The NDAA act is not enough, killing little kids in libya is not enough, lying through his teeth before he got elected is not enough. The country is the worst off it has ever been , that is not enough, drones flying over America that is not enough, been kicked of the Georgia ballot because he is using false social securtiy number is not enough? Saying congress was not in session and putting neo con's in charge is not enough, lying about killing ole Bin?
Oh, Jesus Christ, onstageagain. Reading that comment was like stabbing my eyes out with bobby pins while hanging upside down by my toenails. I don't believe that you expect to be taken seriously when you type things like that on a YouTube video with so many grammatical errors. Get real.
Obama is a embarrassment , not good on his feet. A great speaker when the words are written out FOR him. He went to Harvard to be a attorney, but couldn't make it at that either. If he has to think about what he's saying on the spot, he's dead meat. He's going to have a problem unless he sticks to his talking points since that is basically a written out speech. Politicians & Preachers ! Two professions that take just a good sales pitch to get over on the masses.
DON'T READ THIS CUZ IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY FROM THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE, TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE; HOWEVER, IF YOU DON'T POST THIS TO OVER THREE VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN TWO DAYS. NOW THAT YOU STARTED READING THIS DON'T STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY! POST THIS OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES. WHEN YOU'RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSH'S NAME WILL APPEAR ON SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY BUT IT REALLY WORK
3 hours ago 24 seconds ago DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT REALLY WORKS,YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFETOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE,HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO OVER 3 VIDEOS OR YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS,NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP,THIS IS SO SCARY,POST THIS TO OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOU"RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS,THIS REALLY WORK
3 hours ago 24 seconds ago DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT REALLY WORKS,YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFETOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE,HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO OVER 3 VIDEOS OR YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS,NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP,THIS IS SO SCARY,POST THIS TO OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOU"RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS,THIS REALLY WORK
i DO NOT HATE PRESIDENT OBAMA!!!! QUITE TO THE CONTRARY. I AM AN UNABASHED FAN. I SUPPORT EVERYTHING HE STANDS FOR--HCR. RECOVERY AND REINVESTMENT ACT. WALL STREET REFORM, LGBT RIGHTS, IMMIGRATION REFORM.
WITH THE REPUBLICANS IN CONTROL OF THE HOUSE ALL THE GOOD OBAMA HAS DONE DURING THE LAST TWO YEARS IS THREATENED. THEY WILL REPEAL HCR , WALL STREET REFORM, LGBT RIGHTS AND THWART IMMIGRATION REFORM. AND MAINTAIN TAX BREAKS FOR THE WEALTHY, SOME THING PRESIDENT OBAMA OPPOSES.
Obama is my President, I am OFA ,Community Organizer. Obama makes me feel politically relevant for the first time since I was a young man, JFK was US President. I am eternally grateful to Obama for that feeling. I feel about Obama how i imagine you feel about the Prophet Mohammad.
@PDAYkivers so you hate him. bc thats what i feel. he is not my president and he never will. and for the mohammad remark, the nation of islam calls for infidels and non-believers to be killed or made to convert. not my kind of religion. killing innocent people just so you can rule and oppress the public and control them with fear is just what Stalin, Hitler, and Hussain did. Islam kills Jews, Christians, and anyone else who isnt a muslim. sorry, but that doesnt fly here in the U.S.A.
LEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARYBECAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKs
It's not a boston. Obama stands for the disestablishmentarianistic regime, and I will not stand and let him infect MY children with pneumeoultramicroscopicsiliconvolcaniconiosis.
us "Stupid Americans" don't blow each other up or strap bombs on each other for "religious reasons" and if were so stupid why do you all try to live here?
Obama world tour '09, box offices around the globe are sold out.
Obama performing in concert live singing his number one hit, " I Apologize," with his recent hit preformed with his old pal the Rev, " God D*** America!"
Get your tickets before he subsidizes them and the price goes through the roof!!!!!
Ron Paul 2012!!!!!
netttels 4 hours ago
0.16 and 0.29 LOOOOL
SuperJonaSabimbi 1 day ago
I do not understand how people can not like Obama, he seems to just wish everyone well :C
//Sweden
Haitakaz 2 weeks ago 3
We have an extremely racist country
princesskatrina23 1 week ago
@princesskatrina23 It's sad :/
Haitakaz 1 week ago
@princesskatrina23 We have an extremly racist world...
MixTapeHomez 3 days ago
OBAMA 2012 !!!
Michthemitch 2 weeks ago
He already sang CHANGE that's what got the piece of shit voted in. But YOU Americans won't let that happen again right?? I said RIGHT??? Barrack Hussein Obama......WTF was the first clue
whiskeygoggles 2 weeks ago
@whiskeygoggles *cough*TROLL!!!*cough**cough*
mariojacksonmoonwalk 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
as our country nears a time of crisis, we need to remember that the privately owned Federal Reserve is our problem, not who our president will be or if Gay marriage should be approved or not. Our Federal Reserve is to blame for many of the problems that we are facing today, we are essentially paying a tax to the owners of the Federal Reserve although the owners may or may not be American Citizens!! Please Remind everyone what our real problem is, and that is Taxation without representation!!
MrEndthefed2012 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He's going to need those singing skills when he's sitting in the Hague for war crimes.
altgeldrarities 2 weeks ago
Thanks for nothing, NIggerbama.
DaRyteJuan 2 weeks ago
AWSOME!!! OBAMA SUCKS!!! more like o bamy
vwbeetleowner 3 weeks ago
OBAMA 2012
rbanda1234 3 weeks ago
@rbanda1234
boooooooo whyyyyyyyy
Heinousness 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
His birth certificate has been proven fake. Think his certificate is real? Download it from whitehouse.gov then put the file into adobe illustrator. You can break it INTO LAYERS- proving it was digitally made. Typewriter written documents do NOT BREAK APART INTO LAYERS WHEN SCANNED INTO A COMPUTER.
AG3NTANTHRAX 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Obama is supposed to be your president however he is playing you ignorant americans for fools, signing away your liberties and compromising your future. Laugh as he entertains you with his singing ability while people are SHOT in the street protesting against the corporate greed that he is paid to endorse. When are you stupid americans going to wake up? can you not see what is going on? It is in 'their' interests for you to love obama.
Watch the Obama deception and wake your stupid self up.
rinseoutdrycleaner 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"Our individual salvation depends on our collective salvation." ~Barak Obama
Jesus saith unto him, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life: no one cometh unto the Father, but by me.".
paedagogus.ning.com
gte952r 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this mass murderer cant even sing
JagjeetMann 2 months ago
Comment removed
JagjeetMann 2 months ago
Obama can sing..:D
mikepousti 5 months ago
Shut up O B O M B M A , just shut up leave the White House don't let the door hit your ass on the way out. Do us this one last favor for the love of God. Just GTFO before the country decides to turn a blind eye to embarrassment and impeaches you which is what I would like to see by the way. Just GTFO!!
johnnycmajor 5 months ago
@johnnycmajor ...Are you a fucking idiot?
tle123rox 2 months ago
@tle123rox Why is that ?
johnnycmajor 2 months ago
@johnnycmajor Sorry, it was late when I wrote that and I was a bit grumpy and that was clouding my vision. I just felt like Obama hadn't done anything wrong.
tle123rox 2 months ago
@tle123rox No problem , however he has done enough wrong in the past, and I fear for the future if he stays in office. This however is funny.
johnnycmajor 2 months ago
@johnnycmajor list what he has done wrong? You fear? GWB had the whole nation fear. Not going to fly anymore.
63litenin1 3 weeks ago
@63litenin1 Ya outta ya mind.. The NDAA act is not enough, killing little kids in libya is not enough, lying through his teeth before he got elected is not enough. The country is the worst off it has ever been , that is not enough, drones flying over America that is not enough, been kicked of the Georgia ballot because he is using false social securtiy number is not enough? Saying congress was not in session and putting neo con's in charge is not enough, lying about killing ole Bin?
johnnycmajor 3 weeks ago
fuck the presiedent
OGmakaveli92 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
شى طبيعى إدانة حكام الدول العربية والنعى على سوء تدبيرهم وضيق افق رجالهم وقلة درايتهم بطبائع البشر وسوء استغلالهم للموارد البشرية
kdeed20 6 months ago
Obama is so tone deaf.
ProfoundComedyStudio 7 months ago
XDDD *s*
kekkinalover97 7 months ago
LMAO!!! David Bowie featuring Barack Obama!!!
KADiamante 8 months ago
LOL
OwhatOtheOfuckO 9 months ago
Oh, Jesus Christ, onstageagain. Reading that comment was like stabbing my eyes out with bobby pins while hanging upside down by my toenails. I don't believe that you expect to be taken seriously when you type things like that on a YouTube video with so many grammatical errors. Get real.
ledebin744 10 months ago
Obama is gonna steal all your change, sucka!
JakeBlakeProject 11 months ago
=^.^= lol
PUNKYxCHIX 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Obama is a embarrassment , not good on his feet. A great speaker when the words are written out FOR him. He went to Harvard to be a attorney, but couldn't make it at that either. If he has to think about what he's saying on the spot, he's dead meat. He's going to have a problem unless he sticks to his talking points since that is basically a written out speech. Politicians & Preachers ! Two professions that take just a good sales pitch to get over on the masses.
Meaning YOU!
onstageagain 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DON'T READ THIS CUZ IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY FROM THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE, TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE; HOWEVER, IF YOU DON'T POST THIS TO OVER THREE VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN TWO DAYS. NOW THAT YOU STARTED READING THIS DON'T STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY! POST THIS OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES. WHEN YOU'RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSH'S NAME WILL APPEAR ON SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY BUT IT REALLY WORK
imabem3 8 hours ago
desirae603 1 year ago
Thumbs up for schmoyoho
jmvmain 1 year ago
3 hours ago 24 seconds ago DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT REALLY WORKS,YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFETOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE,HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO OVER 3 VIDEOS OR YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS,NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP,THIS IS SO SCARY,POST THIS TO OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOU"RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS,THIS REALLY WORK
sergiomaya50 1 year ago
@sergiomaya50 shut up it does not work thats just a lie so shut up about it its not gonna happen, it doesn't work
isyluvsya 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3 hours ago 24 seconds ago DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT REALLY WORKS,YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFETOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE,HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO OVER 3 VIDEOS OR YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS,NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP,THIS IS SO SCARY,POST THIS TO OVER FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOU"RE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS,THIS REALLY WORK
sergiomaya50 1 year ago
i DO NOT HATE PRESIDENT OBAMA!!!! QUITE TO THE CONTRARY. I AM AN UNABASHED FAN. I SUPPORT EVERYTHING HE STANDS FOR--HCR. RECOVERY AND REINVESTMENT ACT. WALL STREET REFORM, LGBT RIGHTS, IMMIGRATION REFORM.
WITH THE REPUBLICANS IN CONTROL OF THE HOUSE ALL THE GOOD OBAMA HAS DONE DURING THE LAST TWO YEARS IS THREATENED. THEY WILL REPEAL HCR , WALL STREET REFORM, LGBT RIGHTS AND THWART IMMIGRATION REFORM. AND MAINTAIN TAX BREAKS FOR THE WEALTHY, SOME THING PRESIDENT OBAMA OPPOSES.
PDAYkivers 1 year ago
@PDAYkivers uh wtf im sorry i dont understand a word you just said
Etrain2010 1 year ago
strange change all right.
Txsray 1 year ago
Anyone know where to find Obama singing Billie Jean? The account it was uploaded by is gone.
thickterranarmor 1 year ago
I am so happy to see all these people who will soon be leaving America because they don;t like the President...then the rest of us can move in.
Hurry up and go already, idjiots
92384y23986432 1 year ago
Obama should "Change" his underwear. He stinks.
morrison1405 1 year ago
nice job but gay
chickmagnet12345671 1 year ago
This blows.....
3straightupAIR3 1 year ago
obama = bush : P
BadWithNames123 1 year ago
God, Obama is tone deaf.
oOAlannaOo 1 year ago 14
obama singing rick astley's never gonna give you up is better :)
AmandaMagg 1 year ago
GOD!
Americans KEEP believing... All STARRY EYED and childish. Jesus shit... It's so creepy!
andreaprodan 1 year ago
lol
pml795 1 year ago
Auto-Tune it!
What48 1 year ago
BOO THIS STINKS!
theChon100 1 year ago 4
Chchch change lol
XscXps3 1 year ago
@arthurdude21 lol ikr!!
baby22939 1 year ago
Obama is my President, I am OFA ,Community Organizer. Obama makes me feel politically relevant for the first time since I was a young man, JFK was US President. I am eternally grateful to Obama for that feeling. I feel about Obama how i imagine you feel about the Prophet Mohammad.
PDAYkivers 1 year ago
@PDAYkivers so you hate him. bc thats what i feel. he is not my president and he never will. and for the mohammad remark, the nation of islam calls for infidels and non-believers to be killed or made to convert. not my kind of religion. killing innocent people just so you can rule and oppress the public and control them with fear is just what Stalin, Hitler, and Hussain did. Islam kills Jews, Christians, and anyone else who isnt a muslim. sorry, but that doesnt fly here in the U.S.A.
darthmadeus 1 year ago
this must have taken FOREVER.
gsquarred13 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARYBECAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKs
desigirl9179 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Obama knew somebody cured of being gay! Call 1-888-264-0877 for a genuine homosexual cure!
Bestmanme08 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Bestmanme08 The book Obama:Why Black America Should Have Doubts(at amazon) shows this of him! Book partially by Martin Luther king's niece!
Bestmanme08 1 year ago
I LOVE IT!!
iloveeverybodycute 1 year ago
lol
tsotsc 1 year ago
This one's cooler, watch?v=DgLvT3yOF70&NR=1
Dymys200 1 year ago
Obama and Bowie...I can die happy now ;-) My two favorite men, seriously
raerae1281 1 year ago
lol
UpsideDownZ0ne 1 year ago
put ur hand on ur mouth
2.wish into ur hand
3.put ur hand in ur heart for five seconds
4.put this comment on three videos
5.tomorrow you will have the best day of your LIFE it real
DalleO3 1 year ago
@DalleO3
1.put ur hand on ur mouth
2.wish into ur hand
3.put ur hand in ur heart for five seconds
4.put this comment on three videos
5.tomorrow nothing happens!! woot!
legorok37 1 year ago
@legorok37 LOL hahahaha!
Nesninja85 1 year ago
@DalleO3
1.Put your hands inside your mouth
2. Stop breathing
3. Put your another hand on your heart.
4. Put this comment on fiftythousand other Videos
5. Hope you are alive tomorrow!
KingKong948 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DalleO3 1.Put your hands inside your mouth
2. Stop breathing
3. Put your another hand on your heart.
4. Put this comment on fiftythousand other Videos
5. Hope you are alive tomorrow!
keethepro 1 year ago
@DalleO3 it didn't work!
isyluvsya 1 year ago
this sucks.
MsLouCrow 1 year ago
With the dull monotone of his voice it actually makes it pretty funny x]
vvelvettearss 1 year ago
And does it MATTER if its autotuned? No, I like it how Obama sounds tonedeaf, it makes it better :P
Sarah98Ess 1 year ago
as much as I made this song and video, you did a nice job...
awesomemann1234 1 year ago
geil
leckers400 1 year ago
the only thig u changed is your moms panties
thunderclapper789 1 year ago
i thought this funny also.
chouavue2 1 year ago
this is gay watch obama sings replay?!?! its awesome
danuser98 1 year ago
bullshit
Sili96o 1 year ago
L to the ame
Psycho294Ware 1 year ago
This video is not fake. It's also not real.
It's not a boston. Obama stands for the disestablishmentarianistic regime, and I will not stand and let him infect MY children with pneumeoultramicroscopicsiliconvolcaniconiosis.
iCadaverNukes 2 years ago
lameeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Vanessa5513 2 years ago
why didnt they use auto tune??
sargeantcross 2 years ago
that was genius!!!
jenna0sftbal 2 years ago
bush singing sunday bloody sunday is way better
JAKIBA11 2 years ago 39
@Jakiba - If you liked that you might like
v=VafZic-UM_Q !
ksol1460 2 years ago
your right it was way better
codenem1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck the us
OGmakaveli92 2 years ago
no, fuck la.
AirForcedude5 2 years ago
haha we flamish did something good.
TheOuron 2 years ago
LMAO this is brilliant
santent68 2 years ago
us "Stupid Americans" don't blow each other up or strap bombs on each other for "religious reasons" and if were so stupid why do you all try to live here?
MY COLORS DONT RUN! I AM PROUD TO BE AN AMERICAN!
chihuahualover22 2 years ago
Obama world tour '09, box offices around the globe are sold out.
Obama performing in concert live singing his number one hit, " I Apologize," with his recent hit preformed with his old pal the Rev, " God D*** America!"
Get your tickets before he subsidizes them and the price goes through the roof!!!!!
LOL
timmunst 2 years ago
I'd pay to see that anyday. When can you get the tickets to see that? How much are they?
MegaTeacher25 2 years ago
wow. i'm american and you make us look bad.
stampcollectionfiera 2 years ago
you make your country look bad man!
killerbram40 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That retard should have never became president and ge doesnt deserve it and i refuse 2 call him my prezident! SO EAT THAT!
Richelle9595 3 years ago
then leave
VriffStari 3 years ago
yes, gtfo!
noahhk 3 years ago
I wouldn't some idiot who can't spell "president" calling me president either, so I'm sure he's happy..
therealblackcerberus 2 years ago
Bush never even won and I bet you call him the president.
You stupid American's love the way change sound but when it actually come down to changing you all pussy out.
themanfromthehouse 2 years ago
This "stupid American" can change, I can change the arrangement of your face with my fist.
Saggy315 2 years ago
That would be me changing. FAIL
themanfromthehouse 2 years ago
yes, i am changing. I am changing your jawline. lern2verb fail foreigner.
Saggy315 2 years ago
wow you stupid fag whered you get that stupid line a fucking cereal box
xT1NOx 2 years ago
learn your place you bottom feeding granual of self imposed shame. stay out of this.
Saggy315 2 years ago
Nice. Think you could piece it together for a whole song?
WonkoTheSane99 3 years ago 19
XD lol
ThePristsGirl 3 years ago
well done.
tonythecolorado 3 years ago