LIE TO ME - With Toby

[DemMajorLeagueChumps]

2nd one was a lie....he looked left to many times...looking left alot means your lyinig...FACT...i think

[108sMilez]

i like p.e.

[bignick123190]

i thought that the last one was a truth... i mean.... his dad is an assassin with a lazer gun

[cupcake10734]

The two true ones are the 1st one and the 2nd one

[FreelancerFlorida52]

The one where he said that he watched lie to me is the lie

[iITaLentzZz]

i ment 1st true 2nd lie 3rd true

[iITaLentzZz]

1st truth 2nd lie 3rd lie

[cousinsara]

I think the lie was when you said that two of the things are true :/

[KillingTheMoo]

1st truth, 2nd truth, third lie,

If you posted something other than this,

Watch his other video he posted about this.

Because you're all wrong.

[TheRaptorChild]

i feel like the third is a lie. i wasn't even listening to the story, but he started blinking a lot, and he was looking to the left a lot, which are both signs of lying. people look to their right when they're trying to remember something, and they look to their left when they're trying to make something up

[PikleJooce]

@TheRaptorChild He was looking to the right you idiot, the video makes it backwards. He was looking to YOUR left, but HIS right. And I didn't see him blink that much. It was just the most unbelievable story, you're just trying to act smart.

[aspirino67]

@TheRaptorChild ... you know that in a video right and left are the other way around right? sooo ... he was looking to his right not his left ... so now that means his story is true?

[jamcky13]

the 2nd story is nothing but a LIE!

[Amauri014]

#1 lie

#2 true

#3 lie

[Trisbuscus]

ALL TRUE

[neonMonsterxoxo]

The first one is true

So is the second

The 3rd is a lie..

My proof,

He made a video telling you which is which lol

[Kyuubikid909]

Maybe the third one because if his dad fled to canada to escape the mafia why would he post a video revealing his location and also they might try to say that his mom owes them money now so I dont think he would risk that

[22dragongirl22]

each lie is based on a kernel of truth. they are all half truths.

[bellaboop27]

3rd

[XxYODADDY125Xx]

lmao isnt the third one part of a scene from dumb and dumber?

[Chynaash]

1st lie the other 2nd truth and 3rd lie.

Bingo.

[babyfouche]

the 1st one is a lie and the other 2 are real

[NinjaYoshi64]

The two first ones are real but the last one fake..?

[MinnoLovesYou]

LIAR! All of them are LIESSSS

[freddytheshadowninja]

Not to be a troll or anything but... 1.)You'd scream bloody murder if anything touched your ear drum because it's pretty deep in your ear canal. 2.)A quack wouldn't obliterate his identity for something like that. 3.)A kid wouldn't fool two trained professionals and a mom by trying as little as he said he did. 4.)I saw you drive your dad to the airport during a lazyvlog (pretty mellow fellow btw).

[TurtleAteMySock]

@freddytheshadowninja theres a video where he proves the ones are true and the ones that are lies

[SexifoneMasta]

When I was 10, I fell of the monkey bars n a stick went into my ear n dislocated or what ever the ear drum, so #1 is true... There's a little stitchy thing behind my ear... I forgot exactly what it is they do tho... >~<

[AiBhai]

first of all i watched toby tells truths first so not exactly the least bias comment here but the third one was over twice as long as the other two LIE TELL

[KelsiTeaV]

Toobbyy. You should make videos like these again! :D And have people make video responses, and such. <3

[lilmac141]

the third, who goes  to canada to escape a mafia, they are rich beyond belief, they will find you fools

[TheFearofchicken13]

i think they are all true....

[me17241]

i put sub titles on and the first sentence is captioned as source tell did a lightening

[roguewolf18]

other signs of deception are scratching of back of neck or nose.a hand or shoulder shrug is an indication of a lie.asymmetrical expressions or no eyebrow reactions suggests faking.touching of forehead or looking away(lowered state)briefly is shame.arms crossed or a gesturial retreat is defensive.chin thrust,clenched fist are indications of aggression.

[BaguetteHD]

@roguewolf18 You have clearly just copy and pasted all 3 of those commens off of the wiki or something

[roguewolf18]

there's a study say if your right handed your more rational or logical,whereas if your left-handed your creative.that being said our hands and minds are cross-linked

ex. right handed people or more logical because they use their left side of the brain(the logical/rational half.left-handed people are more creative because they use the right side of the brain(imaginative half).

[roguewolf18]

eyes looking to the top right-fabrication of image

eyes looking to the middle right-fabrication of sound

eyes looking to the bottom right-accessing emotions

eyes looking to the top left-recollection of images

eyes looking to middle left-recollection of sound

eyes looking to bottom left-self talk

[2011JOnasFAN]

I Think They're All Lies LoL

[coreyf142]

on number 3 u looked to the left so yea.....

[TheLissie01]

#3 because why would his dad steal his car and drive it to canada

[1FallenAsh]

well i hate for this to be long,but first of all number 3 is a full lie unlike the other 2. Reason being when you talked about the first two your eyes glanced down and to the right, signifying you thinking about a past memory, in the 3rd you look straight at the camera most of the time trying to over convince whom ever you are talking to that its the truth but in reality, Its a lie. There is more haha but l'll leave it at that. Oh and uh you really didn't like P.E hahaha

[MegaTro11]

Its not the scratching your nose that signifies lying, it is the fact that you cover your mouth or face in anyway as if to stop the words from going out =P

[McNutty43]

they are all lies

[PSNteam501]

@McNutty43 I love how this was from 2009 and idiots lie you are still guessing

[elnegroable]

Lol obviously three... His dad is in some of his Vlogs. I don't need "LIE TO ME" to know that... I got logical evidence lol.

[PukeattackAK47]

You people have to be mentally retarded to not figure out that 3 is a lie. That would never fucking happen! Plus his eye twitched when he was telling it.

[lea3441]

1st

[Ahkuji]

1st

[ajc4327]

the lie is that two of your storys are true ;)

[Kemas42292]

eye movement detection: 3rd

[Sumbodey07]

lol this video was actually a advertisment for fox.

[nokkk9]

2nd Nobody HATES PE WERE NOT RETARDS!

[Chubbypuggiekids]

1st or 3rd

[scissorsistersrule]

All are lies :P

[raccoonfishgaming]

i haven't done this yet but at 3:49 he pauses and looks to the left as if he was reading script, just a guess

[JuuBaduu]

2nd is a lie.

[655Moosa]

3rd one.

[yoshifan9000]

all of them are lies! as he said an average person lies 3 times in a conversation

[IceColdChocolateMilk]

First story is a lie easily

[AugustGleek]

3 is the lie. It's obvious. And he has said that 3 is the lie now, check Toby tells Truth.

[skinspikes]

Last one is true... I'm sorry doll its not easy for people to run out on you. Have a good day and your brilliant! :D

[DuggieHouse]

Am I the only one who's bored?

[KamenRiderOnyx1]

3 is a lie Booz we have seen his mombuscus and dadbuscus

[Thurpsitix]

1 and 2 are true.

[MegaSmoshsmosh]

the doc pulling out your ear drum lie

[duecegorgon10]

thats where he got his L.A. noire game when he's asking questions when some of them is truth he goes ... LIER.

[CoolGamerPro]

I cant belive 1st is the truth

[CoolGamerPro]

1st is the truth

the rest are lies! lol

[TheBearsfan15434]

#'s 1and 2 r true

[dillydean]

lol toby is so normal in these old videos, hes so A.D.D now

[freeman3221]

Lol, I think the part where you said you were telling "!1!" lie was the lie XD

[Manimeluvr]

Did anyone else notice that he said "Let me tell you my next TRUE story...that might be a lie also." ALSO?!

[laughwhore47]

I think they're all lies.

[Scat495]

When he said 'I'm a Brony' was the lie.

Or am I just hearing things?

After all, I DID have my own ear drum clawed out after I took out Tobuscus' eardrum when he was a little kid...

Uh, I mean...

I used to think Tobuscus could be a brony....

but then I took an arrow to the...eardrum...yeah...

True story.

Forever alone.

[TheShadowRage]

i think toby was lying when he said 1 of them is a lye

[12dogu]

last 1 is a lie who does that i mean realy

[Chocolatebutterjelly]

The last one really is the lie I saw the answers

[iminclover]

They cancelled Lie to Me :(

[OmegacheeZ]

Haha Toby i think i have you, NO. 2 is a lie

I thought the blue cast thing was pretty cool so i looked it up on google images

There was a blue cast EXACTLY the same as the one that floated across the screen the only difference was that the man was darker skinned.

I think Toby, (or Steve) has edited the black out of that man's arm and turned it into white.

Got u there Toby ;)

[melovehalo7]

all of them are lies

[ToshiroFujimoto]

i have to say that #3 is the lie....you looked off to the left too many times :T

[Killermode01]

the 1st how could it be true ....... pulled out a ear drum WEW thats not true

the 2nd i think its true but when you put it that way in the nose scratch .... maybe

the 3rd it was too long to be true ..... and maybe its true but the way toby talks was like serious ....... and he didnt laugh at that time because it was funny said by toby

I THINK ALL OF IT IS A LIE BUT ITS REALLY HARD TO TELL IF ITS A LIE HOW CAN WE TELL AND

[LittleClarirra]

@Killermode01 The first one is a true story

[justthatdamnawesome]

lookin to tha left constantly in 3 easy way to tell its a lie

[KateDaGreat8]

3rd one

[sonicrider32]

#1 true

#2 true

#3 lie

[25marshmello]

1st

[mrpeppr1]

1st one

[salamicast]

3 is the lie by the way

[lucasklinkert]

they are all a lie!!

1: you were never 8

2:PE is awesome

3: parents are not funny

[SuperMegasmoshfan]

The third one is the lie. He has a scar on his ear to prove the first one. He says all of this in a video for proof

[3dgluv]

it was the one about your broken arm.

[gbatbart]

i think the gang one is the lie

[RhettRyler]

Toby, you should do more videos like this, it's a cool idea. :D

[Johnissogreat]

all of them are true

[alliwicious1]

All of them are lies. Cuz you a LIAR because you say LIAR all the time in la NOIRE. Why'd I caps the Noire you ask. because I FELT like it.

[2112Addyboy]

But.....

THERE ALL TRUE Dx

[SouthernSniperGa]

The 2nd one is true and you described a movie.

[TheMaschette21]

Him saying one of them is lie is the lie

[rpmmarch28]

"my parents..are hilarious" LIAR!!!

[TheConumdrum]

My computer mouse is being weird :(

[lifeiscrap103]

"My parents are hilarious"

LIAR!

[jakerz96able]

....those kind of all sounded like lies to me.  And the filth star to the left Toby? Well, back when this video came out, that would have been only 1 star. lol

[TwoStupidGirlsYT]

The lie was the last one. Its obvious! He says so in the mext video

[Joker1234343]

all lies

[nenny189]

You can tell that one and three are lies because of how the eyes are moving. When he tells the second one he looks toward the right (audience perspective), meaning he's recalling a memory. When he says one and three he looks to the left meaning that he's constructing a story that's false.

[clukeyjr]

The lie was the, "I'm going to tell you two truths and a lie!" Statement, duh!

[TheMastersnooze]

Canadian's don't mess around.

[lilyandalyssatv]

My science teacher did this one the first day of school, but it was 3 lies, 1 truth. He lost his leg in a shark attack, he lost his leg in a alligator attack, he lost his leg in a lawnmower accident, or he was born without the lower part of his left leg. He even showed us his metal leg. He lost it in a lawnmower accident, and the class laughed because h=of the way he described it. I love Mr. Boggs's 4th block class.

[doorfive]

The last one sounds similar to Tanya's story, maybe he borrowed it from her?

[silentshadow2828]

The first and the last one are both lies XD I havent seen the truth video I promise.

[MetroidMan347]

the cake is a lie

[Princessbilla100]

the first one

[scorch8833]

You lied two were lies and one was true

[skinspikes]

totally think # two is the truth you weren't so entertained when you enjoyed telling the story.. I think one was totally off the charts and three was believable yet you were entertained the entire time by telling it .. that is my opinion and I could be wrong but if you are a right handed person your eyes switched more left and right on the first and last more than the second.. I have no Psychology background I just LOVE that show.. lol. ;P

[KillerwithaHeart]

@skinspikes Huh......

[FiredragonSoftware]

@skinspikes ur 999999% right (i think that means ur more then right i dont know..)

[odd7de7la7robia]

@FiredragonSoftware 1 and 2 were truths 1 is a lie why would only 1 be the truth -.-

[Moonrisingoverwater]

The fisrt one. the eardrum is actully a thin sheet of tissue in your ear. impossible to take it out.

[TheDragon359]

@Moonrisingoverwater Wrong.

[pnppy]

i think the door behind you is a lie

[iheartudcriss]

It was obviously the last one! I mean you wouldn't confess to the Internet that your dad just did that! This was about a year ago if not more and I just watched it lol

[russianbeast23]

1st

[Conkermeister2011]

1st is a lie

[rwjsubscriber1]

1st and 3rd are lies

[RunnieGame]

1st one is a lie!

[werdghs]

3rd one is the lie

[UND3ADSAMURAI]

@werdghs Congrats on watching the Toby Tells Truth video

[ibetweetinonyou]

(1) truth

(2) lie

(3) truth

[Glameyes1]

The lesson is, Toby had incompetent DOCTORS! * strokes his hair* I feel for you, man....

[ghter05]

So that's why he says LIAR so much, and that's why he was good at guessing in LA Noire

[PurePlummet]

But which story can you tell backwards?

[psp3602]

the third one is a lie!!!!! we saw his father in a vid :PPP

[chalinaroses]

I love how he posted a video saying which one was a lie, but people are still debating which one it is XD

[SadDudeZ]

only the 2nd one is true xD

[MrNosrebor]

I think Toby implemented the "LIAR" line in his LA Noire gameplays

[duecegorgon10]

@MrNosrebor IKR :O THTS WERE IT CAME FROM >:D

[dylanthechameleon]

Third is a lie

[tdbopp]

they all lies

[InvaderPsych1]

it was the 3rd one that was a lie! you keep looking to the left (my right) so that means you are lying!

[123435r33]

anyone think of l.a. noire? when he sayd LIE i do

[Jdakx13]

I think the lie was that only one of the stories was a lie.

[TREEPUSHERBRAD]

1 is the lie



[MrFuck1006]

no. 1 is a lie

[smurfmaster90]

so this is the reason toby calls eeryone a liar in LA NOIRE....it all makes perfect sense

[uClicked]

@MoonGKOL He did, I think its called Toby Tells Truths.

[MoonGKOL]

First and third seemed grossly exaggerated...but possibly not entire lies.

So Toby, are you ever going to tell us the answer?

[falcon8621]

3rd one

[aifitz1207]

3rd because Russians love the cold so why would you escape to Canada

[Distort3dVisionz]

3rd one. Im not even going to read the comments. The lip bite. The Eye re-call. The increased blinking. The pause with hands clasped. Eye rub. lowered brows. Voice pitch change and when you explain the breakdown of the story you look directly implying that you are trying to convince the person into believing what you are saying is true. plus you have a fleeting shrug when you explain the million dollars which shows you dont even believe what you are saying.

[Distort3dVisionz]

plus when you say "mafia" your left eye twitches another subconcious sign of the ANS causing a reaction.

[wojitechintros]

@Distort3dVisionz nice! 

[tj007razor]

Worst news ever: Lie to Me cancelled by Fox.

[whatwhatbob101]

the third is a LIE!!

(i watched toby tells truth first ahaha)

[halenaredvance]

@whatwhatbob101 thanks for stuffing it for me before i watch toby tells truth :/

[Ilikegoodmusic02]

Its the 1st one no one goes to the doctor hahahahaha

[samspaino]

I think the lie was when he said two of them were true...

[Laughicosity]

u had some stupid doctors as a kid

[Sarahperkins78]

This video reminded me of Tobys L.A noire playthrough "LIAR!!"

[GetsugaGrimmjow]

Thus began the first badododododdodod DO SUBCRIBE~~~~

[Videowatcher1O1]

@GetsugaGrimmjow He does it in his first video haha

[GetsugaGrimmjow]

@Videowatcher1O1 DANG IT!!! :P

[Videowatcher1O1]

@GetsugaGrimmjow Never mind haha. I thought I was watching his first video but it was the first vid in a huge playlist. I was watching Fauxstralian

[GetsugaGrimmjow]

@Videowatcher1O1 -.-

[jonasdrejerjensen]

nr 3

[Antonmunnik15]

****spoileralert***** you can see its the third video because in All the others he loos down and right where as in the thrid he looks down LEFT right side logical left side emotional he feels bad for lying so he has an emotional response. Also he bites his lip in story 3 and when you interact with your lips you protect yourself (in this case from trying to hide that hes lying). So video 3 is the lie as is confirmed in the toby tells truth video

[spartanmc95]

@Antonmunnik15 no shit it was a lie, his dad and mom live together if u watch his later vids

[Turtleluver26]

"My parents are hilarious-"  LIE!!! O_O

[alaynawinchester]

This is kind of weird because I was loading all the literal trailers (to re-watch them all) and I just happen to be watching season two of Lie to Me on Netflix right now (no lie, I promise). I saw this video and had to watch it I thought it was so awesome. :)

[23yobby]

Dear retards who are still guessing which is a lie and which is truth incase you have noticed this video was made in 2009... its 2011... hes already made the other video which reveals the lies. You sincerly the people who dont have an IQ of a toaster.

[ilusions4]

The eardrum thing is a lie.

[CarlAxelBo]

Toby was ahead of south park. "Aaaand it's gone" - South Park season 15 I think, fucking hilarious episode

[amitlimbu]

so this is how he got the LIAR,he keeps saying that in tobygames

[MJFrodo]

God your mom's so stupid if the last one was true

[Thisismyusername1010]

The main guy on Lie to Me looks like the lead singer of OneRepublic. Just saying.

[BloodyRainvV]

all.

[icepods]

@tobuscus Bet u never thought anyone would reply to this old comment....

[The4Zigs]

first one

[rjmcaan]

the 3thed 1

[LilMissFlirty101]

the eardrum things and the cast thing is real

[Laoch121]

They're all so unbelievable. 

i really want the last one to be real lolol