this was really bad, ill tell you why, 0:43 got the lyrics wrong, she was pitchy, voice was shaky and she looked incredibly nervous for a song that requires power and demand, she should find something else to do
excuse me this is the best version i ever herd frm a tongan so just give her that i dont think another tongan kan sing like that so just leave it she has a great voice k
wrong best Version done on a singing Show is Still undisputed:
Vonzell Solomon, AI season 3!!!! She did the Whitney Key Change Full Voice!!!! this is good tone wise but she has a few pitch issues.. she reminds me of Jazmine Trias, and she failed the key change and was flat as well....this is my fav Whitney song
ummmmmmmmmmmmm im not talking about a black african im talking about a tongan k so get ur facts rite even though vonzell was so good im talking about this is the best version from a tongan and infact miss hudsons version was way better and shes has a stronger voice jennifer hudson
charice pempengco has any demond inside her, i prefer to listen this song with Jennifer Hudson she has style and she looks better than the ugly Charice, Indira u sing good, but u are not strong enough to sing this Big Song.
she can sing but compare to charice pempengco singing this song.......charice is way way better than this....anyway girl keep it up..u just need more practice to this song but u can sing..maybe this song is not suitable for ur voice range..goodluck..
she has a good voice but she cant hit the high notes...guys just check my fellow countrymen singing this son...her name is charice pempengco from philippines
hello. i would just like to make a comment. she sung the song with justice anyway but the strength and the emotions towards the song is not enough. many og the notes were not reached but the over-all performance was very well done.
I love indira!!!! but sometimes girl you sound like you're yodelling you shud push the notes from your throat and dont release just control. But so fink you shuda won i was voting for you girl =D =D
Hey I think you would kill this song if you didn't sound nervous.....You have a beautiful voice! Whatever people say they're just Intimidated by you....If you respond to this with hatred and negativity...Jesus Loves you! Why? Cause your words are just words...God BLess!!!!!
she sings too safe, and when she tries to make the song her own she sounds like she is trying too hard or just crappy....like in this song! Damn are the nz producers deaf?Not to mention a malfunction in the wardrobe department! Damn, who in the fickin heck dressed her? she looks hurt...push up those puppies youre are a disaster just waiting to get stomped on! My grandma has better coordination...you should have called her she would have hooked it up for you girl!
oh know im from New Zealand. this is a country of pride and honour.and we all know that the history lies deep in the american history. have you forgotten about Martin Luther king and what he did in standing up for not the rights of black people in america but for the right of every human being to be treated with respect and grace NO MATTER WHAT COLOUR YOU ARE. DONT GET ME STARTED. and yes we all have that racist history in our history but not to the extreme as america.
please....america was the first country to get over the racism issue. It holier than thou pricks like the euros and aussies who have problems with not just blacks, but any kind of immigrants. America is very tolerant towards immigrants unlike u guys.
sorry you are wrong. and you think that you guys are over racism. think again. although you have made huge strides since martin luther king it still exists much stronger deep within american culture. hey dont get me wrong i think that we all still have this problem in our own country but not to the extreme as america is now. i also think that having a black candiate to run for the white house is just a poltical divise that america is using to show that you guys can be divise and fair.
i think she did a really good version of this song some of the range was a bit much for her but it was still a very nice rendition of a classic if you wanna see some kiwi talent look up emily williams if you havnt already she was australias runner up she should have one but just check out how good she is and her sister lavina
she has a beautiful voice but this song wasn't for her voice......da song and her range are totally different....i apologize to diraz supporters but itz the truth...you can ask simon cowell and he'll say something harsher....!!!!
How could she possibily thinkk she cud take on a diva song like that. you aint got it!!! That song is one of the most powerful songs an onlii a few people can pull it off!! You just ruined it!!
WHEN U R READING THIS DONT STOP OR SOMETHING BAD WILL HAPPEN MY NAME IS SUMMER I AM 15 YEARS OLD i have BLONDE HAIR , SCARS no NOSE OR EARS I AM DEAD IF U DONT COPY THIS JUS LIKE FROM THE RING COPY N POST THIS ON 5 MORE SITES OR I WILL APPEAR ONE CREEPY NIGHT WEN UR NOT ExPECTING IT BY YOUR BED WITH A NIFE AND KILL U THIS IS NO JOKE SUMMET ING GOOD WILL HAPPEN TO U IF YOU POST THIS ON 5 MORE FLASH BOXES
Im sorry but there is no quality from any of the finalists especially the guy that WON OMG I cant believe that ANY of them got to the finals. I thought the most outstanding constestant was Bridget now she was fantastic
Marquise forget what Angela said, she's just deaf herself and absolutely clueless on what an outstanding performance should be and a great voice must be able to deliver. No disrespect to Indira but she needs desperate training. I'd like to think the quality of NZ Idol contestants has improved since Camelia - Obviously Not!
I think everyone that questioning her talent is more about questioning the race. I think she did a good job signing and shes very beautiful young lady. So for all the racist people out there if you want it that bad so get out there and do it your self. Sincerely. poly4life.
I can't deny she has talent, but I can't rule out this was terrible. So much to learn and so much to improve on. It's painful, highly ammateur, untrained and embarrasing for her but more embarrassing for those of you who have not a clue of REAL DIVASHIP which requires more than amateur voice control on all octaves. One shouldn't sing a song they aren't able to do justice to! Good luck to her but I am sure she lost! (Maori from Sydney Australia)
The worst version of this song on Idol ever! She completely butchered of my favorite songs of all time! She should never sing a big power ballad. Her voice is made for the small, simple melodies.
Go suck a dick you trifling hobitch! I just don't like her performance. Her voice is not powerful enough (she does not have enough range) to sing this song!
She is really good. Not only is her tone lovely, her pitch perfect and her voice controlled masterly; she also has fantastic timing. Fabulous!
astokkis 1 year ago
she has a similar voice like leona lewis
sprmodelmelove 1 year ago
shes really goood she can hold a high note~!
Reyna35Muniz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
open your eyes...
morneauj 1 year ago
escuse meh tankimlow..we awedi knows tat.buh tis is wat we call whitney houston par two...n dnt jealous...bitch
MrBabegal 1 year ago
this was really bad, ill tell you why, 0:43 got the lyrics wrong, she was pitchy, voice was shaky and she looked incredibly nervous for a song that requires power and demand, she should find something else to do
Prolife29 1 year ago
she is really pitchy and goes off key a bit. hard to listen too
coathangerblackout 1 year ago
Jessica Mauboy at 16 on Australian Idol sung this ay better!
LeeMarieC3 1 year ago
American Idol would have eaten her alive! lol
tdvaimoso 2 years ago 2
@tdvaimoso hahahahahahaha ain't that the truth!!!!!!!!!!!
lingimagz 1 year ago
@lingimagz ahahahaha i'm sorry. I better not comment like that seeing as my username is my real name ahahaha...May get jumped ahaha
tdvaimoso 1 year ago
@tdvaimoso fair enough lol..my bad then hehe
lingimagz 1 year ago
why it gotta be about what nationality she is? why cant it just be about the God given talent?? u worry about the wrong things...she did good!
iamdeidah 2 years ago 2
excuse me this is the best version i ever herd frm a tongan so just give her that i dont think another tongan kan sing like that so just leave it she has a great voice k
peace
hayMateyha 2 years ago
wrong best Version done on a singing Show is Still undisputed:
Vonzell Solomon, AI season 3!!!! She did the Whitney Key Change Full Voice!!!! this is good tone wise but she has a few pitch issues.. she reminds me of Jazmine Trias, and she failed the key change and was flat as well....this is my fav Whitney song
GRomance0804 2 years ago
ummmmmmmmmmmmm im not talking about a black african im talking about a tongan k so get ur facts rite even though vonzell was so good im talking about this is the best version from a tongan and infact miss hudsons version was way better and shes has a stronger voice jennifer hudson
hayMateyha 2 years ago
I am sticking to my opinion and I love J. Hudson, however She didnt do the keychange unlike Ms. Solomon...
GRomance0804 2 years ago
man. she is fckn gorgeouz
PHRESH1228 2 years ago
omg i love how u sing u sing really good guud luck
fyiqwrfgfdsy 2 years ago
This song is way too big, vocally, for her.
AndyArtichoke 2 years ago 2
this chick is mud shes flat and shaky and sounds like a goat
Shaquantaylaville 2 years ago
waaaaaaaaaaaa..
isa din e2..
MAGALING din :x
imyselfandme1 2 years ago
great voice
claudimaus91 2 years ago 2
Why is everyone comparing her to Charice? Or even saying that Charices better? Its Not about Charice they both have different voices and styles.
NiueanSistahsz 2 years ago
this gal is good but no one can hold competition against charice. She's like the greatest.
thediamondgoddess4L 2 years ago
No doubt Whitney is the best and no one can ever touch her ; )
tankimlow 2 years ago 13
I absolutely agree!!
I mean there are lot good versions of Whitney's songs,but Whitney is Whitney!!!Noone'll ever beat that!
TheNona2403 2 years ago
@tankimlow mariah carey was better
danieltongaww 1 year ago
shes good, she just doesn't sound right for this song
MissLoserrFace 2 years ago
charice is the best
slow2680 2 years ago
i agree besides whitney herself charice is the best ever
Day26isthebest09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
leona lewis is the best singer of this song
McJulia91 2 years ago
she went flat at the same note in half sharp tone.
but nice voice:)
GOD BLESS :)
Laileen 2 years ago 2
i think shes a brilliant singer. why does one have to compare? i say shes got a lot of talent
sweetboycalvin 2 years ago 2
wow great...! echt super
Leylahoney 2 years ago
this is sooo old skool..i'd rather watch some drunk singing it at a random pub
dissbee 2 years ago
CHARICE ROCKS!
nehatnehet 2 years ago
it's not bad at all but i agree charice is better
maximary777 2 years ago
Sister leave this to the other diva - Your voice is to weak for this You just soked all the feelin out of this
sexy912 2 years ago
nice... just a not very powerful... the song is simple, but meant for a powerful singer to impress with the voice
Zerjio 2 years ago
So-so.
yoursuperheroXx 2 years ago
ew. that was crap
imluvinit777 3 years ago
Carolina Soto sings better....and it's in Spanish!
xebecllc 3 years ago
charice pempengco has any demond inside her, i prefer to listen this song with Jennifer Hudson she has style and she looks better than the ugly Charice, Indira u sing good, but u are not strong enough to sing this Big Song.
ivanzion 3 years ago
she can sing but compare to charice pempengco singing this song.......charice is way way better than this....anyway girl keep it up..u just need more practice to this song but u can sing..maybe this song is not suitable for ur voice range..goodluck..
benabie 3 years ago
AWESOME!
21yOsUrEsH 3 years ago 7
she has a good voice but she cant hit the high notes...guys just check my fellow countrymen singing this son...her name is charice pempengco from philippines
arjae075 3 years ago 4
I just KNEW tht ws coming!!
Racocamoca 3 years ago 4
AMEN to CHARICE!!!
taumeasina 3 years ago 2
I heard your fellow country'men' singing this 'son'. She is NOT any better.
International singing sensation my arse.
bongadi 2 years ago 2
Great voice girl...Watching you from the UK..Wow! NEW ZEALAND definitely has talent..Keep singing Sweetheart. Godbless, love loads xx
sunsmile77 3 years ago 3
Listen to tarisai vushe from australian idol 07 to hear how this song should be sung, this is not even in the same league.
raff23 3 years ago
the only time i ever listen to this song is for the chorus
and she does that very well
ispitthetruth 3 years ago
too difficultz for her, although she pulled it off by not killing the tune, it was at that level a knock of the original singer.
need some exercise from the gut- she shakes the voice other guy was good, this ones ok
DragonToes13 3 years ago
hello. i would just like to make a comment. she sung the song with justice anyway but the strength and the emotions towards the song is not enough. many og the notes were not reached but the over-all performance was very well done.
rjsjrn 3 years ago 2
she needs to throw in more feeling in the song
philipthe1st 3 years ago 2
i thought that was just brilliant
softballnvolleyball 3 years ago
Some notes were quite abysmal...Nothing special about her...
blUdz18 3 years ago 2
I think Emily williams did better. Indira is... (no words can describe her) but she was a disaster throughout the competition. Thank god matt won
undacovaBrudah06 3 years ago
matt was a complete emo
all he did was go on about his family to make you feel bad for him
if you ask me they shouldn't of even had a newzealand idol because they all suck!
rustydevilll 3 years ago
lol so true
undacovaBrudah06 3 years ago
lol all matt went on about was his stupid family.
where the fuck is his cd LOL.
rustydevilll 3 years ago
BEAUTIFUL... gave me a chill on the high part hehe.
U rock gurl!!
jessandiese 3 years ago
ROSITA VAI SINGS IT BETTER!!!!
janesbabyboy 3 years ago
how do you prononce her last name?
mrsnickjonas56789 3 years ago
Moe a la
rustydevilll 3 years ago
maile:) u should'v won
PoLyGohYpHy 4 years ago
You can tell she hasn't had professional training. But imagine how good she would've been IF she had...
Jofishi 4 years ago 2
She was at the time studying performance at Auckland uni
deyonce79 3 years ago
She should have won....She has a great voice and she makes this song her own...Love her voice...
arkemais 4 years ago
she has a very nice voice
GLMJE 4 years ago
I love indira!!!! but sometimes girl you sound like you're yodelling you shud push the notes from your throat and dont release just control. But so fink you shuda won i was voting for you girl =D =D
mozfyne101 4 years ago
pitchyyyy :s
oliva321 4 years ago
stuf da haterz der jst jelouz coz dey hav a gorila voice lolz go indira
Piu27 4 years ago
Oh my <3 Love that song ^^
Stinalala 4 years ago
WHOO GIRL!! you got skillS! jus don't be nervous! OWN IT!!! No need ta be nervous Ya your awsome lady!
Jus be you!!!
MissClariceMarie 4 years ago
Hey I think you would kill this song if you didn't sound nervous.....You have a beautiful voice! Whatever people say they're just Intimidated by you....If you respond to this with hatred and negativity...Jesus Loves you! Why? Cause your words are just words...God BLess!!!!!
suimati 4 years ago
she sings too safe, and when she tries to make the song her own she sounds like she is trying too hard or just crappy....like in this song! Damn are the nz producers deaf?Not to mention a malfunction in the wardrobe department! Damn, who in the fickin heck dressed her? she looks hurt...push up those puppies youre are a disaster just waiting to get stomped on! My grandma has better coordination...you should have called her she would have hooked it up for you girl!
castrawberryflavah 4 years ago
wat a jelous even......
dazzian123 4 years ago
and why are you calling me an aussie. i am a new zealander. we accept all cultures of any backround and any religon.
vilisoni 4 years ago
Whitney Houston is better!
smudlicek 4 years ago
i didnt know they had black people in NZ....lol
jamal22066 4 years ago
fuck you she not black. you should know those comments are un called for. especally coming from america where all this crap started
vilisoni 4 years ago
what started? racism? Your part of the world (especially Australia) is notorious for being the bigest racist in the world.
jamal22066 4 years ago
oh know im from New Zealand. this is a country of pride and honour.and we all know that the history lies deep in the american history. have you forgotten about Martin Luther king and what he did in standing up for not the rights of black people in america but for the right of every human being to be treated with respect and grace NO MATTER WHAT COLOUR YOU ARE. DONT GET ME STARTED. and yes we all have that racist history in our history but not to the extreme as america.
vilisoni 4 years ago
please....america was the first country to get over the racism issue. It holier than thou pricks like the euros and aussies who have problems with not just blacks, but any kind of immigrants. America is very tolerant towards immigrants unlike u guys.
jamal22066 4 years ago
sorry you are wrong. and you think that you guys are over racism. think again. although you have made huge strides since martin luther king it still exists much stronger deep within american culture. hey dont get me wrong i think that we all still have this problem in our own country but not to the extreme as america is now. i also think that having a black candiate to run for the white house is just a poltical divise that america is using to show that you guys can be divise and fair.
vilisoni 4 years ago
not bad not bad iv herd better versions of this song by other contestants, the norwegian idol did it better, and so did lakisha jones
DonWon313 4 years ago
i think she did a really good version of this song some of the range was a bit much for her but it was still a very nice rendition of a classic if you wanna see some kiwi talent look up emily williams if you havnt already she was australias runner up she should have one but just check out how good she is and her sister lavina
nathanbrake 4 years ago
she has a beautiful voice but this song wasn't for her voice......da song and her range are totally different....i apologize to diraz supporters but itz the truth...you can ask simon cowell and he'll say something harsher....!!!!
tptBaby 4 years ago
fukk what dat dude under me said.... you did a good job!
EnvyDaSwag 4 years ago
Yuck that sounds like a cat dying!!!
How could she possibily thinkk she cud take on a diva song like that. you aint got it!!! That song is one of the most powerful songs an onlii a few people can pull it off!! You just ruined it!!
accordvtak 4 years ago
hey bitch so do u think u got it...so shut dah fucK up!...gurl u did a awsome job!!!
youngflipp310 4 years ago
Sorry white FOLKS the POLY RULES!
snaponya 4 years ago
Shit.
emmam1982 4 years ago
WHEN U R READING THIS DONT STOP OR SOMETHING BAD WILL HAPPEN MY NAME IS SUMMER I AM 15 YEARS OLD i have BLONDE HAIR , SCARS no NOSE OR EARS I AM DEAD IF U DONT COPY THIS JUS LIKE FROM THE RING COPY N POST THIS ON 5 MORE SITES OR I WILL APPEAR ONE CREEPY NIGHT WEN UR NOT ExPECTING IT BY YOUR BED WITH A NIFE AND KILL U THIS IS NO JOKE SUMMET ING GOOD WILL HAPPEN TO U IF YOU POST THIS ON 5 MORE FLASH BOXES
12345543216 4 years ago
Leave the girl alone, I'll like to see all you lot get up there and sing. Cut her some slack ay!
Louize19 4 years ago
hope you didnt win aow1
deazzaa 4 years ago
I really didn't think it was totally awful. Although I much preferred the opening to the middle and end.
MinsiKid 5 years ago
Im sorry but there is no quality from any of the finalists especially the guy that WON OMG I cant believe that ANY of them got to the finals. I thought the most outstanding constestant was Bridget now she was fantastic
silvea 5 years ago
She was alright although I liked others version beter.
shouayang 5 years ago
Marquise forget what Angela said, she's just deaf herself and absolutely clueless on what an outstanding performance should be and a great voice must be able to deliver. No disrespect to Indira but she needs desperate training. I'd like to think the quality of NZ Idol contestants has improved since Camelia - Obviously Not!
homebuddha 5 years ago
I think everyone that questioning her talent is more about questioning the race. I think she did a good job signing and shes very beautiful young lady. So for all the racist people out there if you want it that bad so get out there and do it your self. Sincerely. poly4life.
snaponya 4 years ago
I can't deny she has talent, but I can't rule out this was terrible. So much to learn and so much to improve on. It's painful, highly ammateur, untrained and embarrasing for her but more embarrassing for those of you who have not a clue of REAL DIVASHIP which requires more than amateur voice control on all octaves. One shouldn't sing a song they aren't able to do justice to! Good luck to her but I am sure she lost! (Maori from Sydney Australia)
homebuddha 5 years ago
vonzell is waaay betta then her singing this song
nigsdog 5 years ago
shes AWESOME!!!
hoolalaa 5 years ago
she reminds me of paulini
mjy0801 5 years ago
You got TALENNNTTT! Love this!!
mmafua 5 years ago
Imagine Whitney would perform that song today - hahahah ... this girl is good!
Maddien 5 years ago
The worst version of this song on Idol ever! She completely butchered of my favorite songs of all time! She should never sing a big power ballad. Her voice is made for the small, simple melodies.
marquise2005 5 years ago
Ummm there are soooooooooooooo many worse performances of this on idol, i just looked at all the ones on youtube - this is considered a good one.
MariahsBiatch 5 years ago
i agree i think she did good on this wasnt the best of course but it was good
newbkid456 5 years ago
you're so stupid, this is amazing. clean the wax out of your ears.
Angela1984 5 years ago
Fuck you bitch!! I have the right to state my opinion...I was not overly harsh like some jackasses on this shit..so fuck you stupid cunt!!!
marquise2005 5 years ago
fuck off you dumpy slut... why are you so grumpy anyway - fall out the wrong side of your caravan this morning?
MariahsBiatch 4 years ago
Go suck a dick you trifling hobitch! I just don't like her performance. Her voice is not powerful enough (she does not have enough range) to sing this song!
marquise2005 4 years ago
why dont u kum sucK my cocK bitch...dont be hatin...chooohooo!
youngflipp310 4 years ago
shes amazing!
scrubs023 5 years ago
i love her!
hoolalaa 5 years ago