Les sauts, l'élévation sont impressionnants mais les bras manque de fluidité et d'abandon surtout pour "Giselle" et particuliérement au 2ème acte,David Hallberg ne démerite pas du tout mais l'orchestre est limite flonflon, Adam n'est pas Tchaikovsky certes mais la partition de "Giselle" est loin d'être mauvaise
i'm happy to see natalia being offered chances to do roles such as giselle that are very emotional and graceful. this gives her a chance to work on things such as softer arms and capturing a tragic character. she could just be relegated to roles that spotlight her fantastic athletic ability and jumps but she's being given the chance to grow and mature as an artist. she'll only get better! bravo natalia! and mr. hallberg...wow!
David Hallberg is entirely revelatory. His phrasing is so nuanced! And this is just my opinion but I don't like Osipova's port de bras. She has a very particular brand of movement that is very athletic, but I just don't think it looks right for this role, she's almost too on top of the movement for the character to be convincing. I hope she finds a good coach/mentor who can soften her arms and hands...
theyre both technically brilliant... especially davids lines and feet... unfortunately it was a horrible giselle do to lack of dramaticism... like the mariinsky's galina mezentseva and konstantin zaklinsky were MUCH better than this... nothing can live up to natalia bessmertnovas.. idk it will never be the same. :( but i mean they were nice... but it wasnt too memorable... like i said both technically polished. dancers dont REALLY dive into the character... they just act sad or make sad faces.
@pediatrapaola You do not mention the greatest-Madame Galina Ulanova,she made this role her own.She is not as gymnastic as modern day ballerina's but she was a true dancer of the classic kind.
Osipova is definitely a youtube generation ballerina, the kind of tricks-driven dancer who excites in small doses but lacks technical and artistic polish. Tendency to sickle, problematic port de bras, etc., but no doubt amazing springing ability. Hallberg is a consummate artist with astonishingly refined technique, ballon, and a full understanding of the character. Bravo to David.
@merluzasfritas MrsSmith152 I've seen about 40 ballerinas in Giselle (in the title part) and I think Natalia (I saw her live too) is one of the best, very emotional and with so airy dancing. But it all is matter of taste: for many people Bessmertnova and Mezentzeva were the best, for me - the worst, sorry.
@pediatrapaola Because she is blind and doesn't have any taste. So stupid comments from that lady everywhere, it's not for the first time. She's just a fury.
What a wonderful segment! Hallberg looked fantastic. Liked the moment when Ivan Vasiliev congratulated him and Natalia. If only I understood Russian...
Hallberg is an absolute DREAM. He eats up EVERY inch of music given to him, in the most dramatic and languorous ways. What a star.
TenduYou 6 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
Они изумительны!
liveforballet96 2 weeks ago in playlist Natalia Osipova & David Hallberg - Giselle
Comment removed
liveforballet96 2 weeks ago in playlist Natalia Osipova & David Hallberg - Giselle
His feet! I'm really glad that Osipova and Hallberg are dancing together. Much better than Vasiliev
minitay12 2 weeks ago
Les sauts, l'élévation sont impressionnants mais les bras manque de fluidité et d'abandon surtout pour "Giselle" et particuliérement au 2ème acte,David Hallberg ne démerite pas du tout mais l'orchestre est limite flonflon, Adam n'est pas Tchaikovsky certes mais la partition de "Giselle" est loin d'être mauvaise
plumplumpudding 4 weeks ago
breathtaking!
omgsls 2 months ago
they are both amazing!
ondinedancer 2 months ago
USA USA! lol *dodges rocks*
nevroth 3 months ago
Comment removed
coxkatherine 3 months ago
omg his natural elevation. he seems to float~ at every jump!! *envious*
prettyeveryday93 4 months ago
omg,did I just see 24 entrechats royale???and he was already jumping at the start!!and the last jumps were even high!respect!!waaaauuuuw!!!!
vaganovafan 4 months ago
For a moment I forgot that this is the Vasiliev version. Which is why the Albrecht variation is different at the start.
oldoperafan 4 months ago
Where is the whole mad scene from the first act which was on Youtube???
ssszhsc 5 months ago
Does anybody want to sub this in english???
grimreepeer1 8 months ago 2
@grimreepeer1 yeaaaaaaaaaa plz!
MamzeilleLili 7 months ago
@grimreepeer1 pleaz pleaz pleaz!!! ^_^
marylutube 5 months ago
Comment removed
grimreepeer1 11 months ago
i'm happy to see natalia being offered chances to do roles such as giselle that are very emotional and graceful. this gives her a chance to work on things such as softer arms and capturing a tragic character. she could just be relegated to roles that spotlight her fantastic athletic ability and jumps but she's being given the chance to grow and mature as an artist. she'll only get better! bravo natalia! and mr. hallberg...wow!
jengirl2 1 year ago 7
2:15 vasiliev!!!
MrNocco 1 year ago 3
I didn't like Mezentzeva bexause of her awkward figure ans always exaggerated mimic play.
MrsSmith152 1 year ago
Великолепно!
TViP75 1 year ago
David Hallberg is entirely revelatory. His phrasing is so nuanced! And this is just my opinion but I don't like Osipova's port de bras. She has a very particular brand of movement that is very athletic, but I just don't think it looks right for this role, she's almost too on top of the movement for the character to be convincing. I hope she finds a good coach/mentor who can soften her arms and hands...
DanseusePassionne 1 year ago
Perfect baillerine
NubiaCarool 1 year ago 2
Perfect baillerine
NubiaCarool 1 year ago
Ahh there's Ivan Vasiliev haha...her boyfriend!! :)
flaviakonig 1 year ago 4
@flaviakonig yes he is very talented at throwing water bottles hahaha
SuperBalletgirl101 1 year ago 2
You don't see entre cha sixes like that everyday! WOW!!!!
onxmyxtoes 1 year ago 3
theyre both technically brilliant... especially davids lines and feet... unfortunately it was a horrible giselle do to lack of dramaticism... like the mariinsky's galina mezentseva and konstantin zaklinsky were MUCH better than this... nothing can live up to natalia bessmertnovas.. idk it will never be the same. :( but i mean they were nice... but it wasnt too memorable... like i said both technically polished. dancers dont REALLY dive into the character... they just act sad or make sad faces.
bolshoiboy8 1 year ago
@bolshoiboy8 surely divine mezentseva ws one of the top giselle of all times with fracci and alonso
pediatrapaola 1 year ago
@pediatrapaola You do not mention the greatest-Madame Galina Ulanova,she made this role her own.She is not as gymnastic as modern day ballerina's but she was a true dancer of the classic kind.
TZEITEL10 8 months ago
Osipova is definitely a youtube generation ballerina, the kind of tricks-driven dancer who excites in small doses but lacks technical and artistic polish. Tendency to sickle, problematic port de bras, etc., but no doubt amazing springing ability. Hallberg is a consummate artist with astonishingly refined technique, ballon, and a full understanding of the character. Bravo to David.
kdub10009 1 year ago
They are the best Giselle ever!
NoAngel1959 1 year ago
@NoAngel1959 really? how many Giselles have you seen?!!!
merluzasfritas 1 year ago
@merluzasfritas not so many l am afraid,but natalia is good.
pediatrapaola 1 year ago
@merluzasfritas may be 8
NoAngel1959 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrsSmith152 1 year ago
@merluzasfritas MrsSmith152 I've seen about 40 ballerinas in Giselle (in the title part) and I think Natalia (I saw her live too) is one of the best, very emotional and with so airy dancing. But it all is matter of taste: for many people Bessmertnova and Mezentzeva were the best, for me - the worst, sorry.
MrsSmith152 1 year ago
@MrsSmith152 PLEASE...NOT MEZENTSEVA ,WHY THIS LOW OPINION?
pediatrapaola 1 year ago
@pediatrapaola Because she is blind and doesn't have any taste. So stupid comments from that lady everywhere, it's not for the first time. She's just a fury.
magnumSuper 10 months ago
Thank you for this video!!!!!!!
elga1525 1 year ago
What a wonderful segment! Hallberg looked fantastic. Liked the moment when Ivan Vasiliev congratulated him and Natalia. If only I understood Russian...
rosacotton 1 year ago 18
they are just great
squinternet1 1 year ago
Amazing!!!!They're so good together!!
dansedu92 1 year ago 4
Natalia Osipova is the best ballerina in the world!!
cca1954 1 year ago 34
@cca1954 no she's not. She's the most exciting ballerina along with alina cojocaru. but marinela nunez is the best.
jglove988 2 months ago
@jglove988 lets say, she is the outstanding very best giselle of act 2 and the unreachable Kitri.
Leirix61 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
@jglove988 I love Marianela Nunez, too !! She is a marvelous ballerina !! Natalia is much better than Alina. But i respect your opinion. Best !
cca1954 1 month ago
Hes a wonderful Albrecht!
rgscballerina 1 year ago 3
@rgscballerina if you had seen volodia vasiliev at his time,
pediatrapaola 1 year ago 2