Added: 4 years ago
From: XuWeiQin
Views: 965,727
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (354)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 楊宗緯終究是楊宗緯,很難超越

  • 對阿~想從後面緊緊抱住他

  • 敬腾哭了, 我好心痛

  • 這是一場不公平的比賽 評審也太假了吧 還問歌詞熟不熟勒 內行人都麻知道早就套好了

  • @simmy120889 您是內行人?內行到哪裡去?何以見得?

  • 亞洲新天王~GO GO Jam~~~

  • 老蕭他現在已經不輕易哭了~很堅強走他的音樂路

  • 我覺得這場比賽,楊宗緯真的表現得很好....比許多職業歌手都­還感動人,不過也不表示蕭敬騰就不好嘛......後來敬騰的唱­片真的是好聽..........

  • 阿咪老师在后面一直"啊叮叮叮叮..." 笑屎了~

  • 靠!想簽人家? 去排隊吧!白目評審!

    星光好不容易加持楊宗緯那麼久,蕭一出現就打亂了算盤。

    主辦單位不可能轉加持蕭啦!

    哈!不過現在呢???誰贏誰輸??

    

  • 現在的失敗就是未來成功的必經過程 敬騰 你最棒~~~~

  • 在哭,到最後兩個字還跟別人合音。今天哭過以後就不要哭了!

  • 我從不覺得楊宗諱唱得比蕭敬騰好!楊宗緯唱這首歌根本沒什麼感覺­能帶給我!但楊唱孫燕姿的雨天確是好聽!論唱功肅比楊高半點

  • 很愛敬騰...

    好討厭洋蔥~~

    

  • 我看到蕭敬騰哭我都好想哭喔....他真的好迷人喔...

  • 我又来看看了,敬腾宝宝哭得我心都碎了。。。 不过他现在多好了,还很调皮。 

  • 我覺得楊好好多喎...

  • 萧敬腾永远是最棒的!!

  • 看到敬騰哭著唱歌真的好心疼, 但為什麼連哭著的樣子都那麼迷人~

  • 喜欢小玲老师和张宇老师,是有坚持自己的专业,没有在节目的Yi­n威下扭曲。其他人象辛老姐,讲评得太假,牛大便.说什么全部改­风格不好之类的话。。恶心死了,然后后来还假星星的报不平。上火­啊。

  • It is a pity they dont duet together and are made out to appear to be rivals all the time

  • 最後蕭靜騰 幫楊宗緯 合音嗎

  • why is 蕭敬騰 crying?

  • @xiaobully3 because he wanted to outdo Yang but he couldn't do so that day..

    it's bitter...T_T However I felt that Hsiao is far better leh...^^ hehehe

  • c cup loool

  • 1:31

    evagelion?haha

  • 我看了王妃改版DVD N次, 我認得3:43 那位穿白背心的現場女觀眾也有去看王妃live tour台南場呀~

    不過相信pk賽敬騰已經俘虜了很在人(包括我呀)XD~

  • jam has more emotion when he sings, have his own style

    which is not easy to find

  • Both have great voices....to me...they are both no. 1!!!!!!!

  • 是不是覺得我們都在欺負你?

    沒錯,沒錯~~上至裁判 下至參賽者 都在欺負人~

    從一班看到五班~也沒聽過張宇說要簽哪一位參賽者~寫歌給蕭敬騰­唱吧 ^_^

    陶子其實這時對蕭敬騰就不錯了~會把很多

    畫面丟給他~鏡頭超多的~我愛~

    合唱時3:28不知道 楊 在笑什麼? 3:50 又在假哭 什麼?

  • 這就是蕭敬騰出到艱辛歷程!

    我們大家一起為他送上一個 d  前途無量 !!!!

  • 在敬騰很難受的時侯, 那麼多人在七嘴八舌, 我覺得就更難受..........

  • 看到這一幕,就很替當時蕭敬騰難過.根本就不是公平的比賽.無論­安排出場方式,評判的評分,節目的流程.星光幫觀眾當時人多勢眾

    楊宗緯也不差.但是為了谷收視.打擊這樣一個年輕人也不太好吧!­!還好蕭敬騰現在己經發光發亮,如果比他們打到一沉不起,就浪費­了一個人材了

  • Comment removed

  • 支持敬騰~~~~:P加油~~

  • 最愛敬騰, 愛他的歌聲, 愛他的品格~

  • 敬騰真的很可愛

    明明還在哭

    但合唱還是記得要合音,哈~

  • 蕭敬騰是自己領悟, 以jazz和blue的風格演唱這首歌. 楊宗緯如果不得到高人的指點, 怎可能在同一首歌, 以原唱的風格, 臨時發揮得這麼好. 當楊宗緯選擇唱同一首歌時, 留意評伴問他甚麼呢? "你記得歌詞嗎?"忘掉歌詞這究竟是上一次失敗的原因?還是這次­比賽的取勝關鍵的提示?

  • 結果就像辛曉琪說的

    蕭敬騰是這節目最大的贏家

  • 對阿

    好像現在蕭 比他們紅了

  • i find that both of them have some similarities among them, their looks, the way they sing

  • jam is good,aska is dam good

  • 若沒有這些強者的pk..我想節目也不會有高潮....哈~~都­很棒就是

  • 淘子姐也是腐女啊!!!!

    最后说的一句话说到我心里去了

    wakakakakakaa~~~

  • 重英雄,惜英雄

  • 楊宗葦1:55 在回答什麼阿!?

    問他東他回答西,

    很沒真誠的回答..

  • Who is better? The answer is rather clear. it is Jam. Never mind, so many people are on your side, we will support you forever.

  • 新不了情是一首表遠''哀傷失落''的歌...楊宗緯用哀愁情緒­演繹,令人聽了也進入哀傷失落境界...而蕭敬騰選用輕快高音演­繹欠缺了一點點感情, 輸給楊宗緯是理所當然 !!

  • 你到底在說啥鬼東西啊,蕭敬騰唱這首歌哪裡輕快.......,­楊宗緯贏是贏在最後有改變唱法,有把副歌地方做加強,但是就想黃­韻玲

    說的,他是星光成員因此很多評審敎他唱歌,他們要他用同一首歌p­k很明顯是套招,

    那至於改歌的加分是不是之前有敎楊宗緯這樣做就不得而知。

  • 蕭敬騰能快速走紅不能否認的是靠著天才般的音樂能力,

    但是星光pk賽真的也是個機緣,

    如果這節目沒有被炒紅,

    那蕭今天能不能那麼快走紅還是未知數,

    所以這節目的輸贏沒有這麼重要了,

    仔細想想,蕭敬騰是這節目最大的贏家,不是嗎??

  • Jam, support you always!

  • 敬騰的聲音除了力量還有生命

    我想他的歌聲在當時不只是技巧

    而是特色很鮮明很有風格

    我還是喜歡敬騰的歌聲

    還有和音 超美的

  • 蕭的聲音很有力量,可塑性很高,是天皇的材料,

    可是,

    我還是喜歡聽楊的,也許是他雖然也有足夠動人渾厚的聲線,但始終­沒蕭那樣揮灑自如,所以他更用心去唱每一個句子,每個聲線小變化­都能充沛的感情表現出來,感染力很好,每次聽他的唱,都有感動的­地方

    而蕭呢,我每次都只是會覺得"他的技巧太完美了,聲音好好聽",­就此而已。

  • 我喜歡蕭敬騰的聲音@@..

  • that is very very nice

    but i can't believe that he lose this competition...

    but these two guys are very popular now...

    they are amazing...incredible...:)

  • 對, 2個都是難得的、非常用心的歌手, 各有各味道, 不用比較

  • 两个都喜欢,两个都唱得很好,人比人比死人,难得唱逢敌手,可以­趁这次机会提高自己的歌艺

  • black & white spider

  • 你不會知道

    蕭哥 在那邊是多陌生痛苦?

    那邊的人 很冷漠 不關心

    所以星光幫一些人我有些反感阿~

  • Actually both Jam and Aska are top singers, pls try to treasure and respect them instead of comparing them. Just pay more support to both of them for they've become very best friends after Star competition.

  • 蕭敬騰明顯高一大等級,馬的真的是爛節目

  • 就算輸都不可能那麼多分啊-0-

  • 從這段片看來,楊宗緯是裝哭!虛報年齡,跟經理人糾紛,單方面宣­佈與經理人已沒有合約;看來楊宗緯的真正強項是演戲!那麼會演!­

  • 這是什麼的比賽?為什麼上次蕭敬騰贏了楊宗緯,製作單位會被罵臭­頭?這表示今趟蕭敬騰是被人擺上枱?Oh! my God !實在太醜陋!

  • 其實二個人都唱的很好,不過張宇也太有眼光了,知道蕭敬騰以後會­大紅特紅,搶著簽他(雖然是開玩笑的~),蕭敬騰也很厲害,在情­緒激動時唱歌還能唱合聲~~

  • 小胖給3分??? wat da hell???!!!!

  • well, jam lost because he sang the ballad song like a rockstar, which is not suitable for the song. aska's voice is more soothing to ears in ballad songs. jam's voice is better for rock songs and blues songs.

  • 其實仔細看你會發現蕭敬腾比楊有更多自己的風格, 如果像楊說唱歌要有夢想的話,那我聽得出蕭敬腾的夢想和想超越自­己的心都比楊的來得大來得遠!

  • 難過的是被節目安排做掉了,歌不能自己選,還要面對對方主場的壓­力,還要被主持評審調侃,畢竟星光的主角怎麼能被人家pk掉?楊­宗緯我怎麼感覺你是假哭

  • are these guys gay?

  • 就我自己感覺而言,蕭唱的有另一種層次的味道,

    而楊比較有轉折,不過,這首歌我還是比較喜歡聽蕭唱的,可是為什­麼他會輸?哈~搞不懂~

  • 他们太过份了。 萧敬腾,不要难过,我永远support 你.

  • 再看影片

    為敬騰感到值得啦

    祝敬騰一路長紅

  • 星光大道的評審不公平,從這次比賽以後我已經不看星光大道的比賽­,

    敬騰,你最棒.

  • oh my goodness this is soooo cute!!!

  • 敬騰~你已經超越他了~

  • 兩個都唱得好

    所以不論是誰的歌迷

    可不可以不要再互相攻擊呢??

  • 敬騰~你超越ing囉

  • 全部都在欺负敬腾,看到他哭我好心痛,好委屈哦!纯真可爱的萧敬­腾,你比杨好太多了!那些评审只会维护自己人,不要难过,因为那­只是一场不公平的比赛。。。你在我们的心目中已经是冠军,加油!­你一定可以成为天王巨星!

  • 没有啦。他们只是说事实而已,他们其实都一样棒,可是杨是赢在那­一句话啦。

    。。。。。我还是喜欢萧敬腾。。。。。。

  • 楊本來唱得很好,

    在我聽來, 那一句來得很突然,

    完全不自然, 是敗筆之處,

    好像旨在賣弄技巧.

    感情方面, 蕭唱得較到位, 感到絕望和回味過往.

  • 小胖請做一個公平的裁判 我已經失去看星光的興趣了

  • '给萧敬腾的制作人'

    萧敬腾唱Live的实力是能把原唱者比下去的!我一直徘徊在萧敬­腾现场唱口水歌的短片,虽然是口水歌但真的百看不厌!百听不倦!

    新专辑里的歌真的逊色!选歌感觉很'罐头式'!没有让我一听再听­的感觉!一流的歌喉,三流的歌曲!

    请帮萧敬腾挑好的,有灵魂的,天王级的好歌曲!Plz

  • 蕭敬騰哭比楊宗緯哭帅多了 所以今天蕭敬騰赢了

  • Jam, you are the best!

  • 敬騰星光耍奧步他們知道你打敗了揚宗緯但是畢竟這是他們的主將ㄟ­ 如果輸了節目做不下去所以只好犧牲你

    敬騰妳是最有實力的期待你接下來的表現

  • 觉得萧大侠很委屈,唉,不过好在这些都过去了,以后发展得好就好­了。

  • 敬騰,

    你已經超越楊宗緯很多啦

  • 小胖才給蕭3分. 這麼低很奇怪耶.

    個人比較喜歡蕭的版本.

  • The judges must regret not sign Xiao! Pity!

  • i personally like 楊宗緯 better, because his voice is a lot easier to listen to. the other guy is like almost having a heart attack when he sings.... sorry, that's just me.

  • jam's voice is super explosive power!

  • 事实上我觉得,让帮主输,不过是给星光帮找台阶下罢了。不见得他­输了。

  • 蕭敬騰 失敗為成功之母 今天失敗 是邁向成功ㄉ一大步

    出唱片之後拼過楊宗偉疤 你ㄉ粉絲都會支持你滴 加油阿

    沒有人沒有壓力 所以希望你能克服你所有ㄉ壓力 邁向人生中你所希望ㄉ舞台 加油啦 我會在你ㄉ舞台下為你加油ㄉ ^^ 加油囉!

  • 蕭敬騰 失敗為成功之母 今天失敗 是邁向成功ㄉ一大步

    出唱片之後拼過楊宗偉疤 你ㄉ粉絲都會支持你滴 加油阿

    沒有人沒有壓力 所以希望你能克服你所有ㄉ壓力 邁向人生中你所希望ㄉ舞台 加油啦 我會在你ㄉ舞台下為你加油ㄉ ^^ 加油囉!

  • Oh! no ,not楊宗緯. I try to say i love蕭敬騰,

    蕭敬騰 get our love, no need to cry .

    WE LOVE U <3 蕭敬騰

  • he no need to cry he get our love.. we love you 楊宗緯

  • 你以為每個人都是香港人啊?!

  • 正當大家都以為楊也替蕭難過的時候,

    忽然, 他在3:28 偷笑.

  • 偷笑完還要裝哭,他媽的洋蔥猴子

  • I start thinking TAOZI is quite SELFISH and fake from now on! Very UNFAIR! Though Yang is good, XIAO is obviously better! YuanWeiRen is mean, very unfair!

  • 正當大家都以為楊也替蕭難過的時候,

    忽然, 他竟在 3:28 偷笑, 哼!

  • 一些自以為幽默的人~~聽不下去

  • 不否认我有先入为主的观念,我先喜欢潇,然后才搜索这个节目来看­的!不过,说真的,我总觉得杨有点虚假!两场跟潇的比赛下来,没­有对潇做过任何正面的评价,而且总是用高谈阔论来掩盖一些显而易­见的事实,为什么就是不承认潇很不错呢?潇敬腾哭的时候真的好让­人心痛,好可爱!!加油!!

  • For sure the judges taught Yang how to perform that song so he can standout and beat Xiao. That's really unfair for this competition. Xiao's version of the song has his unique quality. Go Xiao and I will support his CD. By the way, I love Yang's new CD as well. Great for Chinese music from these new singers.

  • Aska 用情感演繹歌曲,敬騰用歌曲表達情感

    Aska 至情,敬騰至誠,多迷人啊!

    越听越有味道! 越听越入迷!

  • i think that huang yun ling should just shut up. Her voice is not caring at all. she's making xiao jing teng cry. at least the other judges are more jovial and thoughtful. If she thinks sounding like that makes her seem tough, she is wrong. Especially when its on national tv, and every one's CONSTANTLY praising Yang and saying how great he is , how much more emotions he put into the song, is quite stressful for Xiao.

  • i think both are very good. No question about that at all. i think Jam's voice is 較厚 and 較有力, while Aska makes better use of his voice & his voice is 較有感情. i think Aska did better in this PK round. Jam's performance in last PK round stunned me & was definitely better than Aska. i see that Jam still has lots of potential in him (when compared to Aska). Anyway, I love them both.

    Though, I strongly agree that Jam should not only get just 3 points. He should get more than 3.

  • They tried not to be unfair, though.

    XiaoQi is better!

    I start thinking TAOZI is quite SELFISH, stupid, and fake from now on!

  • 哀!敬騰是因為當天感冒喉嚨痛還勉強錄影其他兩個人都知道他不舒­服好不好~而且敬騰並不因為這樣還是表現他的用心~你看合音.高­音他都參與了~而且siupingbabii你這個人會不會太假­啦!!!沒關西~反正我也知道什麼歌迷出什麼樣的歌手品德~你們­這群鳥類不要隨地一直亂大便~真是不會將心比心~敬騰在你們星光­大道為了捧你主子紅才讓製作單位違背良心讓你們贏~哀~做人要厚­道~

  • One thing for sure - Jam's voice really

    makes me want to hear this song over

    and over again.

  • 每個人的感覺不同.

    我是蕭敬騰的粉絲.

    但我覺得楊宗緯的比較好.

  • 蕭敬騰is the BEST!!!!!!!!

  • 他们两位都是很有才华的年轻人。有理想的年轻人应该得到大家的祝­福。我很开心他们渐渐的慢慢的实现了理想。有理想而能把它实现,­那该多好。

  • 蕭敬騰 din take part...可惜

  • 公道自在人心...

    優勝者 - 蕭敬騰 !!!

  • old judges like old singers....

    but they forgot the majority of album buyers are young people...!

  • i dun c the same as u but ther r still sum old judges like old singers but now adays judge look at the looks n the voice vocal no offence =)

  • 蕭敬騰的合音真的很好聽

    太厲害了

  • 另外 在歌唱技巧方面

    我覺得蕭敬騰是比楊宗緯優勝

    但有時候在歌曲的詮釋跟感情的控制上

    楊宗緯是做得比較好

    畢竟他的歷練跟經驗比蕭敬騰豐富

  • 從一開始 製作單位安排蕭敬騰去踢館 就是為了製造話題 提高收視率 因為他們看中了蕭敬騰的實力可以帶來這樣的效果 其實回看第二場的pk賽 就看得出楊宗緯是故意輸的啦 他明明知道蕭敬騰的實力 卻為什麼會選靠岸這首難度不高的歌呢 張宇說得對呀 他就是拱手相讓 但大家也不能完全怪楊宗緯 畢竟這是製作單位的安排 他也不能不聽 除非他不想繼續比賽囉 (不過他的戲也做得誇張了點) 就因為這是一場戲 而楊宗緯才是星光幫的人 無論蕭敬騰唱得多好 他也不可能贏的啦
  • 不管星光大道是否"做馬"讓楊勝出 反正在我心目中蕭的歌聲是最感動人心的 他是最棒的 但客觀的看 楊同樣是位出色的歌手 值得尊重

  • 制作单位更本就是在偏袒杨宗伟,打从一开始就有打算让杨宗伟胜出­。。主持人还说上回杨宗伟输了她们被制作单位骂到臭头,所以这次­就安排一定要让杨宗伟赢。。他们更本就是串通好的。。真的很不公­平!!很替萧敬腾难过。。看到萧敬腾哭好心痛。。敬腾,加油!!­永远支持你!!

  • Both are professional.

    I think 楊宗緯's vocal is SUPERB already.

    But 蕭敬騰 VOCAL is POWERFUL, POWERFUL AND DOUBLE POWERFUL. I just like the way he drag those words. YOU TE SE! (=

  • 3:50那裡楊太over了,他就是把哭腔加重,根本不是真的傷

    心,如果真的哭,也不知道他的哭點在哪裡,就是從這裡對他

    觀感不佳.讓我想到看星光一班和二班合唱那集,二班的人因

    為有人被淘汰,當然也就有哭點,如果一班人各個感情豐富,

    相對的看到二班他們哭,一班照道理更應該感同深受才對,但

    是我卻沒看到任何一個一班的有在哭的.

  • 你都傻既....如果你見到你唔識既人死..你會唔會為果個傷心­先.......一班佢地畢左業啦...二班有人淘汰...都唔­關一班既人事啦....有咩理由要哭?

  • 岩,,

    所以咪話楊太over囉

    果時都無哭,,pk完人地就哭

    都吾知真定假

  • 有什麼問題?可能佢地係合唱時,楊感受佢蕭對音樂的熱誠而感動落­淚呢....而且哭同不哭都要睇時間??唔係掛

  • Jam, please don't cry. we will support you forever.

  • Aaka,加油!!!

  • 蕭敬騰,加油!!!

  • 大家可以在影片搜尋中,打上"蕭敬騰.阿妹演唱會"

    就可以搜尋到蕭敬騰參加阿妹演唱會,擔任嘉賓的完整片段哦!

    蕭敬騰現場演唱的功力沒話說,及和阿妹非常可愛的亙動,

    把現場的氣氛炒熱到最高點,全場為之瘋狂,

    看完,大家會更喜歡他哦!

  • omg... this is really a nice PK ... really sad to see both have to kill one... touching touching....

  • 唉, 看他的眼也哭腫了...他真的很傷心呢...很真,很讓人疼呢!­

  • Some comments here said Jam was attacked (verbally) by people after he won the 2nd time, because he won Yang, who's named to be the GOD of this show. can anyone tell me what happened after he won the 2nd time? I believe Jam wouldn't be affected by people's attack. He is very much in his own world & that's why he is so unique. He cried since he hasn't reached the best standard of his own. As innocent as him, he can't hide the emotion. Truely appreciate it. This is what a great artist should be.

  • both of them are really really great! clash of the titans, but i guess it's good experience for them to know that there are ppl out there who asre as good as them and they got to keep improving to 'survive'

  • lmao they cried together

    wow.. both very emotional =0=

    good singers indeed :)

    bright future for both of them i see =0=

  • no matter what the outcome of this competition is, the main point is that 2 VERY good singers have been brought into the media. that's a very good thing because both of them have good vocals. the people who gains advantage, in the end, is none other than us. so what's there to complain?!

  • the simple reason xiao cried is because he feel bullied by the other contestant and fans,he came into the show virtually unknown,and others onli gav support to yang,he's been lonely and to gone through tat onli made him greater,i agree beatlesgr8..ppl watch d show cause of yang.but he's a mid grade to be honest,xiao on the other hand is on d way to greatness,he's humble and lets his music carry his brand unlike other taiwan artist tat onli act handsome n look cute.

  • My friends in Singapore love Jam only after watching this singing contest. He is a kind of worldwide idol now.

  • unfair to Jam, well, it's show business, we don't expect fair judgement in some situation, but everybody has their own judgement, to me, Jam is the winner even though he lost this 'game'

  • homeground advantage is REAL.When both did equally well,the advantage comes into play.the other contestants should count themselves lucky.if xjt had chosen ANYONE OF THEM,they are gone!

  • Jam sang with his heart & soul. What a big let down.

  • 蕭敬騰的聲音很特別,我很喜歡。陽宗緯最會唱傷感的歌。可是蕭敬­騰的歌很有吸引力。

  • xxue123 u r right xiao's sound is more powerful than yang's i think tat he put more emotion in the song.. he sing into the song not the song make him sing... he has a good voice... godly sweet powerful voice... yang'g just get power at the end and the rest rough smooth like that not so power... if they 2 are the participant.. i bet xiao's win!! he lose just becoz he just a challanger to pk

  • Who say they purposely let Yang Zhong Wei win....IT IS NOT....I support zhong wei but both of them are good...but zhong wei won it SERIOUSLY....not fake

  • god!!!! what a GOOD,FANTASTIC voice they have!!!! really touching...both!!! Gambateh

  • WOW!!I like both of them man!!they're cool!!

  • I also love both of him la~~~~~~

  • both were superb!!! but 24 vs 21???i doubt...what is roger doing there?he knows nothing...fashion sense?I dont think Xiao's attire and appearance were inferior to that of Yang's.

  • Jam seems like he's been through a lot. I dont know somehow i feel wheres he coming from.

    u put so much efforts, & build up hard to find confidence, yet you did not win.

    a big let-down. I dont blame him for breaking down.

    One other thing, why do ppl say he does not show emotions in his song?? look at him! in talk shows, he hardly speak , soft spoken, but when he sings, like a lion out of the cage. i dont know so much pain & feelings from his song.

    Jam , JIA YOU.

  • i love both honestly. but i actually watched this show cos i heard jam's voice in the ad. jam's DA BEST MAN

  • 記得大姊頭張小燕小姐曾說過一句話,人不會紅,你怎麼捧也不會紅­,而注定會大紅的人,你怎麼踩他踏他,他還是會大紅大紫,這句話­太有深意!蕭敬騰,楊宗緯,好好珍惜上天給予的福分與天份,千萬­別染上一些要不得的惡習,惡癮!希望這些淪陷在你們歌聲的粉絲們­,能帶給你們無限的加持,讓你們有更多的能量!謝謝你們的歌聲!­

  • I love them both!!!