Why doesn't HDGD use the Korean sword? KURIGATA and SAGEO for thrusting into a belt are the features of Japanese sword. It is the similar Japanese sword. I never find such the Korean old sword or Korean soldier's photograph.
The thing that "the martial arts" were born from the existence of the samurai of the feudal age.
A record is almost left about the origin of the martial arts and martial arts of Japan,
The Korean history document does not exist at all, and the opinion that 花郎 was organized militarily is completely denied.
Clothes and a sword and the manners that a modern Korean martial artist uses again are all the things which imitated the Japanese martial arts after Japan-Korea merger.
I find it amazing that the swords discovered last year at the Todaiji Temple in Nara called "Yohoken and "Inhoken" (These two names come at the top of a record of 100 swords donated by Empress Komyo 701-760) are IDENTICAL to Korean Hwandudaedo.
@1C431USAF Listen kid, you are looking at history in terms of the last 100 years not thousands of years as most of Asia does. Katana is only evolution of original Korean hwando (Hwandudaedo) that Koreans brought to Japan, Sword forging period was brought to Japan from Korea as well as Chinese characters and buddism. I can show you many sword methods from Muye Dobo Tongji used in HDGD that look nothing like any Japanese style.
HDGD is the combination of Gicheon And Shim Gumdo, as well as revived sword methods from theeMuye Dobo Tongji- All Korean and unrelated to Japanese styles. Sword differences include a bolt welded to the tang with the butt cap(kashira) being the nut. Korean swords are wider back to blade and thinner side to side(niku?)
본국검 本国劒 (Bon Guk Gum) From 무예도보통지(武藝圖譜通志): It appears Wubei Zhi ( 武備志) written by Mao Yuanyi (茅元儀) acquired the book of sword combat from Chosun considering he compared Chosun sword methods with Dang Un's. It is obvious Chosun Had already developed the manual of Bon Guk Gum ( 본국검 本国劒) as they were compared to Japanese Ssangsu.
It is the World Championships. The reason there are Korean signs is because they are held in Korea. They are the world championships because members from all over the world come to compete. And the reason the cultures are so similar are because Korea was occupied by Japan and as usual the dominant country forced their culture onto them, as happened with any occupation. The swords are similar because the Koreans obviously saw how the advantage of the curved blade and created their own martial art
If this demonstration is really "World" Championship as the title says, why the letters in the site were written only in Korean language? It proves that this video is completly nonesense. Koreans are imitating Japanese because Koreans yearn for Japanese.
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
Which kumdo are you talking about? Haidong Gumdo and Gumdo are actually seperate martial arts... Also the idea that an actual martial art can start from a movie is pretty out there, i mean i really dont think shit like gun fu would fly, why? because with a firearm there are basics you need to follow, same with martial arts. and think about this, how the hell are you to fight wars if you didn't know how to use weapons? bows are good, but how are you going to fight closer range?
@taihuu25go That is a big negative, this is a demonstrations competition, so they need to throw in the flashy moves for style, but haidong kumdo is definitely usable, and what you fail to realize it actually originated before the japanese style kendo, and kendo has a lot of its basis in it.
@TheMidnight5000 shame on u mate..... u r so pathatic idiot with little knowledge when it come to true martial arts. come and see me, i'll slice u up in pieces.
well seeing all the people that think they know what they are talking about kinda makes me laugh but it makes me angry at the same time. First off they are not using "Japanese Swords" they are what is called a Jing-Gumb. A Korean sword is different from your katanas. The bend of the blade is different and is much less pronounced than a Japanese one. Secondly swords dont weep as said before they rust and chip. Third doing this is a heck of a lot harder than you give credit.
gravity is not the only thing that is used here. the precision of the cuts in this clip are amazing. Go ahead make a video and send it to me showing you can do it i guarantee you cant. respect the people. 4th its just like the Olympics they go to demonstrate your skills. @ the fencer dude sure there may seem to be allot of wasted moves but really there arnt its just the difference in the styles a Jing-gumb is heavier than a rapier and the demos are parts of forms we do that simulate combat
the only person here i have any respect for is Zorzevic. Learn to understand this WAS for demonstration purposes. these people are there to earn there place in the ranks. they deserve respect for what they can do so dont act like your almighty. they didnt ask to be tapped these are all clips from onlookers
Practice of Sword Techniques should be learning of the logos which penetrate his physical and mental condition. The logos of the sword links to the way nature is. Respect for the sword is same as respect for the world where we live. So gravity is required in sword practice. It shouldn't be a show for the audience with useless and blinging action. Sword is not a cutting toy. Read the FIVE RINGS written by Musashi Miyamoto.
@TheMidnight5000 mate, learn the true history before u speek, cuz i agree with u on respecting the world but, anything that u believe about the japanese are whole lot of crap coming out of their asses.
why do you all keep on arguing about japanese vs korean sword styles? Your tone tends to indicate you master one of this martial art, but if you really did you wouldn't spill pointless reflections about that and just show some respect to others, and concentrate on your own technical and spiritual improvement.
It is true that killing another with a sword does not make one a swordsman, but a murderer. Living by a code of strong ethics and becoming master of oneself, among many other things are what make a Warrior. Any punk can kill. it is easy. What is not easy is to be prepared to die honorably while living justly. Also, my friend, swords do not weep, they rust unless they are polished. Please understand the meaning of this, humbly.
@TheMidnight5000 I agree, im not a katana wielder but I'm a fencing competitor and have been one for 7 years now, what I see in that show is useless moves only for the pleasure of watching stupid brats waving swords over the places. A true katana wielder, or any true swordman, would, first, not cut things on tv thinking they're good, second, finish this with one fearful and tactical blow at a precise spot. Completely disapprove this show
well to be fair.... after the japanese BURNED all of our martial arts archives, we took in a lot of their style, but you know... haidong gumdo is a revival of the old korean sword style...and the forms werent made by japanese btw, adapted by them and changed yes.... but originated in china
You don't have to take their style. The Korean ways can be revived. You just have to believe that all are in your bloodline. You and your ancestors' feet rest on the same, unique and extraordinary land. And your blood runs through the same veins.
What's it called when they swing and the straw mats don't fall until a few seconds after? Is that some form of speed cut that's special or is it just the way the mats are set up?
@FatalKnight actually... haidongkums are longer, heavier and thicker than katanas... but not by a lot, and the weight distribution is nearly identical.
actually its pretty easy. if you look you will notice he is using a sharpened sword. Its makes cutting easier. So you don't need the grain to be perfect only the angle of the sword. which is difficult in it self.
“There is no sword art which has continued without breaking off from ancient times in Korea.”
朝鮮王朝實録:The Annals of the Korean Dynasty
【June 11, 1480】矧惟國人不慣槍劍專業弓矢爲禦敵之備
The people are not accustomed to use of sword or spear, defended from enemies only by archery
【October 13, 1592】上敎政院曰我國絶無劒手
The king said “There is no swordman in our country at all”
【July 11, 1594】我國自古劍術不傳
The king said “Any sword art has not been passed down from ancient times in our country”
enushisama 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why doesn't HDGD use the Korean sword? KURIGATA and SAGEO for thrusting into a belt are the features of Japanese sword. It is the similar Japanese sword. I never find such the Korean old sword or Korean soldier's photograph.
enushisama 1 week ago
การตวัดดาบ การฟันมันของ Kendo ชัดๆ
whitewerlet 4 weeks ago
I don't care if they are Korean or Japanese, skill is skill and I am in awe.
1182tque 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
For 李氏朝鮮 Korea 500 years, I ruled the country in Confucianism.
Confucianism respected a civil officer and looked down upon a military officer.
The martial arts become outdated, and the military officer does only the role of the police.
Korea had neither the Japanese style sword of the 海東 gumdo nor the samurai style nor the kimono.
The Korea-style is different from Japanese style definitely if I examine the Korean history.
海東 gumdo is fraud.
wolfpack13000 2 months ago
The thing that "the martial arts" were born from the existence of the samurai of the feudal age.
A record is almost left about the origin of the martial arts and martial arts of Japan,
The Korean history document does not exist at all, and the opinion that 花郎 was organized militarily is completely denied.
Clothes and a sword and the manners that a modern Korean martial artist uses again are all the things which imitated the Japanese martial arts after Japan-Korea merger.
wolfpack13000 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I find it amazing that the swords discovered last year at the Todaiji Temple in Nara called "Yohoken and "Inhoken" (These two names come at the top of a record of 100 swords donated by Empress Komyo 701-760) are IDENTICAL to Korean Hwandudaedo.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 2 months ago
1:01 Someone show me how to do that!
micahcolister 3 months ago
does anyone know where the music comes from the sound track for this video is awsome and epic would like to know?
superdaddy25 3 months ago
@1C431USAF Listen kid, you are looking at history in terms of the last 100 years not thousands of years as most of Asia does. Katana is only evolution of original Korean hwando (Hwandudaedo) that Koreans brought to Japan, Sword forging period was brought to Japan from Korea as well as Chinese characters and buddism. I can show you many sword methods from Muye Dobo Tongji used in HDGD that look nothing like any Japanese style.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
HDGD is the combination of Gicheon And Shim Gumdo, as well as revived sword methods from theeMuye Dobo Tongji- All Korean and unrelated to Japanese styles. Sword differences include a bolt welded to the tang with the butt cap(kashira) being the nut. Korean swords are wider back to blade and thinner side to side(niku?)
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
본국검 本国劒 (Bon Guk Gum) From 무예도보통지(武藝圖譜通志): It appears Wubei Zhi ( 武備志) written by Mao Yuanyi (茅元儀) acquired the book of sword combat from Chosun considering he compared Chosun sword methods with Dang Un's. It is obvious Chosun Had already developed the manual of Bon Guk Gum ( 본국검 本国劒) as they were compared to Japanese Ssangsu.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
Korea is a surprising country. No coutries except Korea hold World championship to cheat people.
expedition60 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuckin korea!
do not copy JAPANESE culture!!!!
tetupop12 4 months ago
The base of Haidongumudo is Japanese samurai movie.
Therefore, in the world champion tournament of Haidongumudo, they only compete for the beauty of the pose.
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
taihuu25go 5 months ago
@taihuu25go
Basically.
The Korean traditional martial arts do not use Korean traditional clothes and Korean traditional tool.
The Korean spreads it around to the world.
We taught kendo to Japan.
The Japanese respects us and should thank us.
taihuu25go 5 months ago
Comment removed
taihuu25go 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please watch
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
enushisama 5 months ago
Comment removed
enushisama 5 months ago
Honestly wtf is going on here.
GoodRockinBrown 5 months ago
It is the World Championships. The reason there are Korean signs is because they are held in Korea. They are the world championships because members from all over the world come to compete. And the reason the cultures are so similar are because Korea was occupied by Japan and as usual the dominant country forced their culture onto them, as happened with any occupation. The swords are similar because the Koreans obviously saw how the advantage of the curved blade and created their own martial art
SamurangSparky 5 months ago
@SamurangSparky This is a World Championship of liars. Only Koreans can hold.
tellthetruth5475 5 months ago
kooldalt 5 months ago
If this demonstration is really "World" Championship as the title says, why the letters in the site were written only in Korean language? It proves that this video is completly nonesense. Koreans are imitating Japanese because Koreans yearn for Japanese.
expedition60 5 months ago
武藝圖譜通志Muye Dobo Tongji (1790) : Comprehensive Illustrated Manual of Martial Arts in Korea .
[It is an official document at a Korean Dynasty, written by The Korean King order in the 18th century]
國練兵之制三軍練于郊,衛士練于禁苑,其禁苑練兵盛自 光廟朝,然止弓矢一技而已如槍劍法技,既未之聞焉,
Archery was the only martial art that had been practiced by Korean soldiers. They have no skills of sword or spear fighting (17th).
購得戚繼光紀效新書遣訓局郎韓嶠遍質東來將士
Therefore, Koreans began learning sword skills and others from Chinese.
enushisama 5 months ago
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
It is monkey business to insist on the Korea samurai and martial arts without a Korean having existed.
It is a fact that Korea was a dependency of Chinese 明、清 for a long time in 李氏朝鮮 Korea.
There are not society background and the base which there is a samurai.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
The Korean martial arts and fencing are monkey business.
Because there is not the culture that there was a samurai in the Korean history.
The Korean uses a castle of Japan and the sculpture including the Asura by an image strategy in imitation of the style of the Japanese samurai in HP.
I understand it if I examine it, but, in the Korean Peninsula, culture and the castle of the samurai do not have the trace.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
Please watch those videos.
watch?v=hG6tqGGZW8Y
watch?v=iFBo-Zs_Dp8
enushisama 7 months ago
I turn and why am a kung fu movie?
Do these people think that martial arts are dramas?
Such a useless movement is not martial arts.
The axle of the body moves too much slightly.
Impurity do not hold traditional culture in Japan!
I think and force it to desire why there is bending to the sword whether I am thin.
koisan1000 9 months ago
発想がすごいわ。笑い死ぬ
sakura0jp0aikidodesu 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Korean has been trying to steal Chinese and Japanese traditional culture and make FAKE TRADITIONAL CULTURE in this era. and They try to be its origin.
I want all foreigners to know this crisis.
Korean think Bushido , Katana , Samurai and so many Japanese tradional culture and chinese culture is korean origin.
THERE IS NO HISTORICAL PROOF!!!
Their mimic of Kendo will come to Japan expo in this year.
watch this
v=bivg7cDHeyg
tasu9 9 months ago
Which kumdo are you talking about? Haidong Gumdo and Gumdo are actually seperate martial arts... Also the idea that an actual martial art can start from a movie is pretty out there, i mean i really dont think shit like gun fu would fly, why? because with a firearm there are basics you need to follow, same with martial arts. and think about this, how the hell are you to fight wars if you didn't know how to use weapons? bows are good, but how are you going to fight closer range?
Xiox047 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1 some educated people in the world
get interested in some japanese old culture
2 koreans make copy of that for money, and start spreading lies
" this is korean original! korea number 1 !!! "
3 poor, uneducated guys believe that shit
'cause they never know the difference between
real deal and fake shit
oirarnoknutgib 11 months ago
kumudo increased showy movement such as the fight scene of the movie to Japanese kendo.
Therefore actually there is the nonsense skill that is not usable.
For example, it is ...
It is a style of the fictions which a Japanese movie created to have Daito with underhand.
taihuu25go 1 year ago
@taihuu25go That is a big negative, this is a demonstrations competition, so they need to throw in the flashy moves for style, but haidong kumdo is definitely usable, and what you fail to realize it actually originated before the japanese style kendo, and kendo has a lot of its basis in it.
Xiox047 11 months ago
@Xiox047
Kumudo was founded in 1980's.
Because Kumudo became famous for a movie, Kumudo attaches great importance to a showy style.
watch?v=_Xz_6MUYHcM
taihuu25go 11 months ago
Does that mental focus work, or is it just to make it look cool ???
lenzzii 1 year ago
Very cool!
SullivanArtsStudio 1 year ago
Korean history=Fantasy
People all over the world except Korea know Koreans are totally liar and are laughed at very much. OK, you can play swinging around sword. Go on.
I never visit here. Bye bye. Have a fantastic day until you die.
TheMidnight5000 1 year ago
@TheMidnight5000 shame on u mate..... u r so pathatic idiot with little knowledge when it come to true martial arts. come and see me, i'll slice u up in pieces.
johnyoo71 1 year ago
well seeing all the people that think they know what they are talking about kinda makes me laugh but it makes me angry at the same time. First off they are not using "Japanese Swords" they are what is called a Jing-Gumb. A Korean sword is different from your katanas. The bend of the blade is different and is much less pronounced than a Japanese one. Secondly swords dont weep as said before they rust and chip. Third doing this is a heck of a lot harder than you give credit.
G1johndom 1 year ago
gravity is not the only thing that is used here. the precision of the cuts in this clip are amazing. Go ahead make a video and send it to me showing you can do it i guarantee you cant. respect the people. 4th its just like the Olympics they go to demonstrate your skills. @ the fencer dude sure there may seem to be allot of wasted moves but really there arnt its just the difference in the styles a Jing-gumb is heavier than a rapier and the demos are parts of forms we do that simulate combat
G1johndom 1 year ago
each of the straw mats is used as an equivalent to a body so each slice through the mates or bamboo can be seen as a 1 hit kill
G1johndom 1 year ago
the only person here i have any respect for is Zorzevic. Learn to understand this WAS for demonstration purposes. these people are there to earn there place in the ranks. they deserve respect for what they can do so dont act like your almighty. they didnt ask to be tapped these are all clips from onlookers
G1johndom 1 year ago
Andi i apologize for the rant
G1johndom 1 year ago
Practice of Sword Techniques should be learning of the logos which penetrate his physical and mental condition. The logos of the sword links to the way nature is. Respect for the sword is same as respect for the world where we live. So gravity is required in sword practice. It shouldn't be a show for the audience with useless and blinging action. Sword is not a cutting toy. Read the FIVE RINGS written by Musashi Miyamoto.
TheMidnight5000 1 year ago
@TheMidnight5000 mate, learn the true history before u speek, cuz i agree with u on respecting the world but, anything that u believe about the japanese are whole lot of crap coming out of their asses.
johnyoo71 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheMidnight5000 1 year ago
why do you all keep on arguing about japanese vs korean sword styles? Your tone tends to indicate you master one of this martial art, but if you really did you wouldn't spill pointless reflections about that and just show some respect to others, and concentrate on your own technical and spiritual improvement.
zorzevic 2 years ago
They have no respect for Japanese sword.
They are just self-absorbed. Japanese swordman never use Japanese sword in such a ridiculous show.
They are never swordmen because they just swing around Japanese sword.
Koreans take Japanese sword as just a cutting-tool.
I can hear the swords' weeping.
Look at Japanese period drama. They respectfully treat Japanese sword.
TheMidnight5000 2 years ago
@TheMidnight5000
The sword is first and foremost a killing tool and the swordman is a murderer no matter what pretty words you use to dress it up this is the truth.
Respect a sharp steel bar with a handle made for cutting people?Respect is not that cheap my friend...use it for something else.
jorgedalko 2 years ago
It is true that killing another with a sword does not make one a swordsman, but a murderer. Living by a code of strong ethics and becoming master of oneself, among many other things are what make a Warrior. Any punk can kill. it is easy. What is not easy is to be prepared to die honorably while living justly. Also, my friend, swords do not weep, they rust unless they are polished. Please understand the meaning of this, humbly.
CitizenNomad 2 years ago
@TheMidnight5000 I agree, im not a katana wielder but I'm a fencing competitor and have been one for 7 years now, what I see in that show is useless moves only for the pleasure of watching stupid brats waving swords over the places. A true katana wielder, or any true swordman, would, first, not cut things on tv thinking they're good, second, finish this with one fearful and tactical blow at a precise spot. Completely disapprove this show
StallioN0of0MeadoW 1 year ago
@StallioN0of0MeadoW than fencin must be for poofters.
johnyoo71 1 year ago
than you must be very fag to insult a natioanl sport on the internet, I said I disapprove this show but your just a rotted asshole my silly friend
StallioN0of0MeadoW 1 year ago
They took music from Pirates of the Caribbean, ha ha.
summonshire 2 years ago
What's the music at 8:30 ?
DarthDormas 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Japanese are spreading lies that Koreans copied Japanese style.
Chinese & Korean styles are focused to fight SEVERAL enemies in surrounding environment.
Japanese style is more focused on ONE on ONE.
Basic strategies of Korean & Japanese are DIFFERENT.
Europeans don't accuse other Europeans of copying their style of fencing, archery, etc.
Even the Chinese DON'T accuse Koreans of copying their style.
Only Japanese accuse Koreans of copying their style.
Chinese > Japanese
KimInLosAngeles 2 years ago
well to be fair.... after the japanese BURNED all of our martial arts archives, we took in a lot of their style, but you know... haidong gumdo is a revival of the old korean sword style...and the forms werent made by japanese btw, adapted by them and changed yes.... but originated in china
MellifluousChime 2 years ago
You don't have to take their style. The Korean ways can be revived. You just have to believe that all are in your bloodline. You and your ancestors' feet rest on the same, unique and extraordinary land. And your blood runs through the same veins.
summonshire 2 years ago
Bad copy of Japanese samurai.
wonderousjapan2009 2 years ago
they are actually pretty good in terms of technique wise.
newaza2boddha 2 years ago
i'm learning kendo because my university only provides kendo club, but honestly I think korean gumdo is superior
BabyEater9000 2 years ago
What's it called when they swing and the straw mats don't fall until a few seconds after? Is that some form of speed cut that's special or is it just the way the mats are set up?
Wakuzashi 2 years ago
Thats call a cut... a REAL cut, is one that simply passes through, there is no falling unless by another force, (something pushes it or gravity etc.)
MellifluousChime 2 years ago
@Wakuzashi It just shows that the cuts are perfect even more so if they don't fall
G1johndom 1 year ago
@G1johndom No it just shows their blades are much thinner than traditional katanas.
FatalKnight 1 year ago
@FatalKnight actually... haidongkums are longer, heavier and thicker than katanas... but not by a lot, and the weight distribution is nearly identical.
Xiox047 11 months ago
the katana cuts very much...but the "samurai" have not the control of its sword.
TE NO UCHI IS NOT OPTIONAL..
6silver9 2 years ago
wow! those are way more superior in sharpness than a katana!
icecrimson 3 years ago
best be trollin
lORDELO2 2 years ago
???
icecrimson 2 years ago
best be joking
lORDELO2 2 years ago
i love the way they cut, looks like the effect describe in the comic!! very nice!!
bangkaliliang 3 years ago
the swords they're wielding, they're not nihonto are they?
lORDELO2 3 years ago
What's the music at 5:45?
Thanks
jackchn 3 years ago
なんか馬鹿にされてる感じがする
sako2kai 3 years ago 8
Huh??
SamurangSparky 3 years ago
umm... may I ask why?
Priest105 3 years ago
Korean was learn Japanese "Kendo"and"Iaido" ,
but korean was mix to Korean martial art.
And Korean said that The Japanese martial art(Kendo and Iaido) was invent from Korea!
Arr~!Not just martial art!
Even Japanese food and Chinese culture were invent from Korea!!
So,韓国人は馬鹿ですね~
mjjlcy 3 years ago 9
@mjjlcy So what, imitation is the best form of flattery. Your foolish to think that means they don't have their own strengths
Neopersonageguy 1 month ago
@mjjlcy Maybe they feel like stealing japanese culture because japan destroyed korea's culture during the annexation. Everyone copies fuckface.
stupidichigo99 1 month ago
What's the name of the music?
DarthDormas 3 years ago
Honestly have no clue sorry. Have training 2mro will see if my master knows.
SamurangSparky 3 years ago
Its off of The Pirates of the Caribbean.
Master293 3 years ago
my mom wont let me do that after what happened last time rofl
jimmy4560 3 years ago
wtf was that guy with 2 swords doing xD
inferiuz 3 years ago
well it is a martial "art" that was a pre-choreographed sequence of attacks counters and movements to make the audience feel in the heat of a battle
BlazeingShadows 3 years ago
trust me cutting news paper is harder than it sappears cuz if u dont cut it quick enuf it moves with u
MoooMon 4 years ago 2
actually its pretty easy. if you look you will notice he is using a sharpened sword. Its makes cutting easier. So you don't need the grain to be perfect only the angle of the sword. which is difficult in it self.
XD4133 3 years ago
freakin amazing skill and focus! the fruit was cool enough but the candle at the end...holy crap! XD totally got me beat there...
DamienZshadow 4 years ago
great vid, but bad quality
Elcrian 4 years ago