LIE TO ME!!!

[JennyKav123]

woah he was fat

[jonasbrothers140498]

omg shay, you were so frickin faaatttt!!

[SarahTheWolfe]

shaycarl omg <3

[ChaseSaysHello]

oh my god. look how fat he was O_o

[PanPuszczyk]

I don't understant to much from your video, cause my english is fucked, but second story is a lie. Ameright?

[qwuvf]

2 is false. You never joined a skateboarding competition because you got injured and withdrew. But you are awesome at skateboarding and snowboarding:)

[JansProduction]

@qwuvf Well ofc you know that... He told it 6 days later xD

[OnlySticksAndStones]

Number 2 seems to be a lie. Repetition, justification, and no mention of any specific details (e.g in the first one he mentions meaningless things like the date etc) Very quick speech and no hesitation suggests that he has already practiced the lie. Im an expert.....lol joke

[PERAGR0]

Can't believe a Tom Waits video took me here

[loveactandrock]

Spaz attack much???

[sexymeclaudiu1]

YOU FAIL!

[jwb4291]

it got cancelled NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[legokingbaden22]

the second one is wrong you get your drivers lisents when you're 16 not 15

[PeacockFethaMasta]

@legokingbaden22 not in idaho

[Didgeridoozie]

@legokingbaden22

You mean story one, jeez pay attention

[Ridthydams]

what is the shaytards video called?

[azzmch]

I thin it's the first one! I just watched the ShayTards response video, and I was wrong, it was the second one!

[88beda]

I didn't understood very well what you said('cause i'm italian) but i think that your third story is the only true one!! ahahaha! bye bitch

[techdeck8489]

at 0:41 it looks like hes doing it

[Benjikj]

2 was a lie!!! when he said we made a ramp in the skate park he was shaking his head, meaning he didnt agree with whatt he was saying!

[losredon0001]

Hombre eres un gran idiota!!!! Saludos desde Argentina!

[ShatteredBladeXx]

@losredon0001 Porfavor, no le des mala reputacion a Argentina, el hecho de que haya estupidos infelices como vos en nuestro pais, no significa que todos seamos tan retrasados y mediocres, sin nada mejor que hacer que ver un video de 4 minutos, solo para dejar un comentario tan pelotudo. Buscate una vida, y suicidate. Ok :) ?

[losredon0001]

@ShatteredBladeXx

Siempre hay un negrito de mierda como vos dando vuelta, porque no te pegas vos el tiro pelotudito de mierda, que no servis mas que para ver lo que comentan los otros, y tanto que decis el videito te lo viste vos tambien pajero infernal que sos, anda a hacer canales en youtube pelotudo, vos si que estas al pedo, y despues matate, pero bien muerto, que no quede ni una esperanza de que quede un gran imbecil como vos en el mundo!!!!

[ShatteredBladeXx]

@losredon0001 u mad? :D

[Minecraftwizard1000]

3 is a lie, Shay is to awesome to be left

[eed78]

2 is a lie

[theweedreportFL]

288 people cant do a backflip

[Mrsplatinumgirl]

1is so a lei

[killstreak789]

I THINK 3 WAS A LIE

[SuperReaper125]

well number 3 you tried WAY to hard and were way to dramatic so its safe to say that it was true but i think you are full of it the first two are lies

[MrPlainsteel]

1:28

a lot of lunch...

[MrPlainsteel]

1.28

a lot of lunch....

[theaprilthing]

Why is he so wet? o-o

[BIGBIGBIRTHA]

Ummmm................. 

[yummy2003]

HOT!!!!!

[cupcake171000]

2 is yessss

[LeekGallade85]

Nalts like Ralts?

[aly8495]

all 3 are lies including the part of u sayin "im gunna tell 3 stories, and 3 r a lie"

[darc721]

Hey dude I know a great therapist!

[hasert10]

number 2

[sptfgpn]

He's got sensitive hands.

[ChocolateCraziii]

#2 NOT BECAUSE OF YOUR WEIGHT!!!

[IIIIIIIIIIHD]

lie

[darkpegasus16]

number 2

[719brinkman]

I JUST FARTED.......

[s2luvv]

number 2

[EurowomanPink]

Shay have lost aLOT of weight now.

[95lamp]

# 3 

[EmberVampire]

number 2 fer sure.

[ravenvocalfire]

number 2

[MsSignedUp]

number 3

[savannahb123456789]

number 2

[MelodyandNatty]

number 3



[ThePigmented]

erm number two

cos youve talked about number one before

and because katilette could never leave you <3

...unless your being funny....then number 3 could be the lie

jokester <3 lol

[SaschaHeylik]

#1 cant be a lie, because then #2 would be a lie too and only one is a lie. #3 is true. So #2 must be the lie.

[supitful]

lol the last one was a lie

[phoenix137100]

lol u sound like po from kung fu pada (kick ass film)

[JDSpiderman3]

You are awesome (wink)

[alexafhal]

lol

[breebreeisawesome]

I LUV U XD

[whiteravenofhope1]

I'm like a ninja sometimes! *flail * You're amazing <3

[MistyAngel85]

uhm.....story 2 ofc......how old can you be to get a drivers license? 15? nah...don't think so.....

[MistyAngel85]

@MistyAngel85 or whatever the number of that story was..... >.>

[pan159159]

story number one is lie...story 2 true...story 3 true..!! and i love you for who you are shay..!!

[GaryX10]

#3 is the only one im sure is true.

[katara323]

Will u tell us which one is fake?????

[MrFunnynate]

all true



[VasiliyMikhailov]

1) lie

2) true

3) acting without emotions - bad actor or distancing

[pupsi1542]

@VasiliyMikhailov eh..... you do know its on propouse right??...

are u familiar with the word... "ironic"

or... the word... "fuck your life"

jaja just kid

[lol828282]

you acted on the last story and the first one was a lie

[zoegrace45]

the first story



[zoegrace45]

the second story

[MsSignedUp]

all of them are true....wait......3 story is true.

[heffernjustinheffy]

thumbs up and fav for fat ninja

[WANGXENGTHAO]

number 2 because all the other stuff are wait all the other stuff sound real hey i believe all the other ones upset and i think she loves you hahahaha the last part was funny hahaha!!

[shunuki2]

i think number 2 is a lie



[shunuki2]

i think number 2 is a law

[EvilPhantomDude]

i think its story 3 =3

[jondan3127]

312

[haylie135]

ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm­mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm­mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm­mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm­mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm..­. numbeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr three or two or one or three no i mean two NO one wait no five or not three yep it is three

[brunovila100]

The first one is fake!

[brunovila100]

The first one!

[writerreaderfreak]

2 is fake dude

[MrAsianKING123]

story #1

[MegaCow12345]

story three story three three three three

[monicrazzy]

story #2 is fake.... i know that the first one is true... and i know mommytard loves you & wouldnt leave you soooo story #2

[ItsJennysVideos]

I think that story #3 is true

[jeraiceball]

I remember the days when Shay has the hugest crush for SXEPHIL's shirts.

[mmrpablo]

It's story one

[beefan090]

Story 2 is a lie.

[comadsco1]

FAT ROUND ROLLYBALLY. YOU LOOK STINKY

[wendiehhh]

its so awesome, being 15/16 and already drive a car, here in europe we need to be 18... :(

[suicide5389]

0:40 lmao the train is pulling out of the station choo choo!

[TheBadtigger]

Well I kno 2 is real erm I think 3 is right and 1 is lie

[xZarakiix]

1st

[TheNICKoroni]

Shay you are awesome and funny I want to be a shattered so bad

[boredoutofmymindify]

Oops I mention to write 2nd

[boredoutofmymindify]

3nd because his eyebrow shifted dramatically and in the other story they stayed the same

[Juliette2014]

story 2 is the lie

[harrypotterlvr08]

sorta like 3 truths and one lie, except 2 truths and 1 lie?

[00hollister74]

@ murphyhurtme they have way more subscribers now.. and yeah that's rude? what nerd would do all that when its other peoples personal business and just post that on YouTube?!

[Boom1000100]

2nd

[guitarsly111]

@murphyhurtme you forget about advertising . Do you think he can have such a beautiful house on 10 grand a year?

[tiffaniered7]

3rd



[sammydrumm]

1st

[singingirl818]

2nd

[coocoocookie1]

3rd is a lie because your wife will leave you with four kids. J.k.

[decalpha1]

The lie is the 3rd story

I saw a flash of contempt in story 2

I saw genuine fear at the end of story 3

[Msnicolesixx]

id say the first 1 is a lie

[captainmoliver]

3rd



[Lillith798]

@murphyhurtme ! GOD! Keep ur ugly comments to ur self! If you hate keep it to ur self! :(

[epiphaniclife]

@murphyhurtme haha you are SUCH an idiot. shay is making ALOT more money than you will ever make...have you seen his house and the stuff he owns? but its not even about money. most of us watch his videos because they are one of the few things that can make us smile after a hard day. he has a loving family and i think its amazing that not only can he make a living out of just being himself, but he can also brighten people's day and bring a smile to our faces. go comment on a bieber video please.

[murphyhurtme]

@epiphaniclife thats funny, i have the actual numbers right here if you would like to read them yourself.

8793 (shaycarl)

27227 (shaytards)

302 (shayloss)

1008 (katilette)

So that's $37,330 and that includes all the money he would've made if his channels were revenue enabled from the start. That's over 3 years, about $12,000 a year, more likely $10,000 a year after taking out the non-revenue views. so more than likely he lives off of relatives and welfare checks. youtube doesn't pay very well.

[iliveforGod19]

@murphyhurtme what a fuckin ass

[murphyhurtme]

@iliveforGod19 how am i an ass for pointing out the truth you ugly bitch

[caspergyrup]

-.-

[mattiasskroder]

your skinny!... I just lied to you.

[MultiTDIfan]

The james blunt CD ad came on BABYTARD!!!

[ilovecupcakesable]

he uploaded this on my birthday yay

[NwzInd]

#2 is the lie, he made it to the competition but injured himself before hand and was never able to compete. he explained this in the shaytards video when he was doing flips off the ramp where princesstard does cheerleading practise.

[EscapeNewJersey]

Is this Kevin Smith?

[lovestories4u]

@EscapeNewJersey no its SHAY FREAKING CARL!

[jksc1]

3 is the lie

[tntom1035]

number 2 is the lie he says so in a video in the shaytards channel (if you want proof just watch the least watched video on that channel)

[DaMuscleBen]

we all know it's #2 because we've seen him skate a few time in LA and he probably can't make it off a sidewalk curve, and even if he did, he'd break the cement so it's illegal for him to leave the ground for over 0.01s on a skateboard to ensure public safety.

[LiveAnSmile]

Number 1 is the lie

[taylorchavis1]

# 1

[JillBearcub]

LOL, MIDDLE FINGER. 0:53

[jimepage]

WHO CARES!!!!!!!

[kolahn1]

# 2

[DeividasCool1]

Shay gay :DDDDDDDDDDDDD

[Maiayea]

Adopt Me! I wanna be a part of the tard family ;D

[imabeninjahaha]

1 cause ur uncle got u a blue truck not a yellow truck duh

[Fall3nSk8ing]

#1 cuz u said u got ur license at age 15 and u get ure permit at 15 and ur license at age 16!!!

[VloginRyan]

@Fall3nSk8ing nope he lives in idao so u can there but it is still #1

[rmpinkcorp]

@Fall3nSk8ing wow your retarded

[MrSlimyslime]

number 3

[1988jgraves]

psh your a ninja... yeah right whatever. HEY WHERE THE HECK DID MY BURGER GO?

[samsterz98]

0:53 hahahah he flipped us off...

[pizzagood182930]

#1 is a lie? u cant get ur liscense at 15 years old? or was it different back then?

[bambihasteeth]

@pizzagood182930 I think its and idaho thing or something. He said in a more recent video that his brother has his license, but he's also fifteen. it confused the crap outta me.

[18kjones21]

@pizzagood182930 in idaho u can

[UpperDarbyFilms]

# 2

[marbleartfan101]

2 is a lie

[dumdoman]

numba twoooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oo >:O!!!!!! iy iy iyyyyyyyeeeeeeee...hey shaycarl if you read this will you mention me on one of your shows...no way mhm dang right :P...hi! :D

[AndrizzleFoShizzle]

Shay why u all wet

[N1ck1Sk123]

number 5

[MrBouctouche]

no.1 is a lie

no.2is a lie

no.3 is true

[RCAF16]

3rd one

[jjgillyful]

idk i think 3

[DYlanMYSTER08]

i hate lie to me

[clipcriticsfan3465]

two

[youareepicfailz]

this guy remins me of Hurley from Lost XD

[ThePsh07]

3 was a lie. He gets left at home with the kids all the time.

[anybody15721678]

Story number 4 .

[duncanismine4]

Lying about number 3

[Swedengirl4]

1. True

2. False

3. True

[mefistin]

trueeee of the story... *fingers moves* ,!,

[5hexa]

number 2 is so fake

[1leadsingersdisease]

hez lying about nuber 2

[FalloutTim]

Story nr1 TRUE

Nr2 TRUE

Nr3 W00T..?

[Xramas90]

i think ur lying on the 3rd and 2nd!

[HunterRoxXbox]

true true false

[imconfusedplz12help]

why are you yelling?

[imconfusedplz12help]

and mememolly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

[Bdiddly1]

when you were young?you still are its just th@ your obese as fuck man!

[BOOMHATGUY]

duuh 3 is a lie

[LuckyGirl931]

ur skin looks so clare and ur teeth look perfect!!!! and nice video!!!!

[ExternalDestinyHope]

The first one, I think was the lie.

[nani10261]

DUH the story that was a lie was that your wife won't leave u cuz your I'm not gonna say fat buy a little over weight. ( bye the way I'm not mean I love ur vids even though I just found out bout them yesterday and I litteraly spent the whole day watching them when it was time for bed I was still In my pajamas watching them ( p.s. I stood up till 2:30 hahah) well bye bye

[ANSKET]

The first two were the lie

[warflepie23]

Shay is the best you tuber of all time!

[thejacesterness]

It was the lie

[thejacesterness]

First one

[jio5465]

i feel sad for you u have over 203 videos ur a nerd and u dont have anything else to do i was looking up a song and i saw for u and i said that i need to say this get a life bro i feel bad for and go on diet

[supernaturalguru]

@jio5465 dude, he has 700,000 subscribers and makes money from youtube.

what the fuck dyu have?

you`ve more vids than subscribers yu sad cunt.

[paustin0]

@jio5465 you dont even make videos, you record cartoons.

whos the nerd? hes married and has kids, thats more then youll ever be able to say

[MysticBlanky]

@jio5465 Thats pretty sad. That your looking through his old videos and being a hypocrite saying he's a nerd when you make cartoon videos. Thats nerdy. And besides, his videos amuse people. Yours make me want to jump out of a plane with no parachute and then have some one sticks fire up my ass and shoot me in my eye. And he has been going on diets, and exercising. And he isnt even ugly, I mean, hes actually pretty handsome, and I would LOVE to marry a guy who treats my kids that way. Get a life.

[taytayfreak1]

@jio5465 Dude you shouldnt be feeling bad for him you should be feeling bad for yourself. first of all dont watch this video if your gonna say mean things. Second you have 7 subscribers so please be nice and back off.

[spacie82]

@jio5465 ...that's all you got? IF being a nerd means you have no debt but own your own house + car, have good close family and friends, a beautiful wife and 4 great kids, the ability to support your family well by staying at Home all by making videos and being involved in other production employment, then you need to re-educate yourself and learn more English because he appears to have a fullfilling life and one that is quite successful. It's unfortunate you have to be so rude!!!