Added: 4 years ago
From: Gish1973
Views: 141,546
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (265)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Billy's voice sucks live but it's because he's going up there, screaming the songs and enjoying it. He goes on stage to entertain himself and fucking credit to him.

  • Iha is a very underrated guitar player - at their peak this band was unbeatable.

  • fORGIVEN:))))>0. no billy you are trying to sell tickets and not helping?

  • fORGIVEN:))))>0.

  • I they were kind of bored with "Cherub Rock" by 96. They had played it a lot on stage for three years and most versions that I've heard on the mellon collie tour sounded half-hearted, as if they were going through the motions. I might be wrong, but that's the feeling I get. "Disarm" & "Mayonaise" sounded better on that tour IMO. Still - they played stellar shows in 96 I got to see them pre tragedy (Jimmy istill n the band, Melvoin alive, and before Dublin) and I'M STILL THERE. Fantastic show.

  • Anybody hear darc's moanings,very weird rsrsrs

  • man billy's vocals suck live..hahaha

  • I SAY CHERUB ROCK !

  • Yeah, Pumpkins let it rip

  • faster than light....

  • Billy is one of those guys who were amazingly crazy.

    Their head is fucked up, but their minds are creeply amazing.

  • his middle finger its saluting them :D!

    at the begining!

  • fuck yeah!

  • To all the dudes watching this: rank Ginger, D'arcy, and Paz on their hotness. I personally like Ginger,Paz, then D'arcy.

  • @GAdawgsfan93 Agreed, like down to the fuckin tee, agreed

  • @GAdawgsfan93 If your wondering why I included Paz, I basically consider Zwan as a side project of the Pumpkins since Corgan and Chamberlain were part of it.

  • @GAdawgsfan93 Oops, forgot about Melissa. I still prefer Ginger.

  • I think the best proof of just how great Iha and Corgan were at guitar together is how they got louder and louder at the beginning until it sounded like a bunch of machine guns goin off at 0:31.

  • cara acho os caras massa 

  • Es la mejor primera canción de un disco en toda la historia de la humanidad!!! (bueno y además acá estaban los 4 no como ahora que es Billy y su ego)

  • 9 people have just made themselves one very powerful enemy, a female teenaged australian pyro

  • the 90,s ruled! for the last ten years we,ve had to put up with medeocre shit like snow patrol,keane,coldplay,the feeling,kaiser chiefs,scouting for girls,bowling for soup.wow i cant believe how many wank noughties bands i can recall!

  • I wish I was d'Arcy's: a) Panties b) Tampon c) Maxi Pad d) Jeans e) Eye Snot f) Toilet Paper g) Toilet Bowl h) Pubic Hair i) Freckle j) Pantyhose k) Pap Smear l) Colon m) Bead of Sweat n) Recliner Chair o) Finger p) Crab Lice (if applicable) q) Toothbrush r) Floss s) Bra t) Spandex u) Nipple Ring (if applicable) v) Nipple w) Belly Button Lint x) Cigarette y) Make-Up z) Sugar Daddy Can you do any better? If so, no you can't.
  • @Bagelbutcher You are a creepy motherfucker. The fact that you put time into coming up with something like that disturbs me.

  • great band, just great, billy corgan is a legend

  • Billy Corgan is a bad ass.

    The 90's were awesome and every decade since then has sucked ass in comparison!

  • @hog1775 agreed

  • Comment removed

  • Live version is fucking insane.

  • @MrJoeybigz Ummm...Cool story?

  • 1996 EH'....im sooo sad i never saw SP in all their glory back then LIVE!!!..theyre NOTHING like they were...thos i am gonna see them(him) when they come down next month..WHY NOT!!!?

  • D'arcy's pants are epic.

  • I really like the smashing pumpkins but they play way too fast live they do sound good tho and Billy's voice is great

  • it's too fast!

  • Billy's voice is pretty good at this tone

  • I love Jimmy's voice. I don't know why. It's so unique and fits the music really well. The addition of D'arcy as a backup vocalist really gives it the dreamy sound Siamese Dream was known for. Pumpkins forever! :D

  • he must be on some crazy drug because his hands are fucking FLYING, i have a hard time playing this song at normal speed

  • pumpkins are funckin awesome. this songs awesome. but they should have slowed it down even a little...

  • chamberlain dude, you had it all. glad to see him. but :(

    i love this video

  • I love this song, but am i the only one that thinks this version sounds like one big noise?

  • wow way to fucking fast for me

  • he's not much of a singer

    i just dig the music as a whole

  • Heh, 1:44 Who wants some hoooooo....ney :L

  • billy really can't sing live :P

  • @louisalive  wtf?

    Get out of here.

  • @FroylanRuiz1 mate, I love them, and have seen them, he's a great songwriter, just a shame about his vocals live

  • @louisalive Oh, ok, sorry for being so mean lol.

  • cocaine speed haha, but it doesnt matter if the bands play their songs fast or faster live, when the crowds are rocking and the energy is flowin, thats what counts!

  • Band's not looking so happy.

  • @drumrnva Probs cos their exhausted from tourin and cba :P

  • i luv this live version, makes me wish i was alive or at least old enough to see them

  • Yes, I would certainly pay 100 shillings to be D'arcy's bicycle seat.

  • I think they're trying to make it sound more like 'Jellybelly.' P.S. D'arcy is hot in this vid.

  • Tough luck at 1:11

  • by far the best live performance of cherub rock ive seen . Fastest version

  • There's one faster from 1995.

  • wouldnt know where i could find it ?

  • thepumpkins (.net)

  • GRUNGE CHERUB ROCK

  • The singer: in spite of himself, so soft in studio

    and so distorted live!

    i really like that.

  • woah at 1:34 billy's singin to james... tense times

  • holy crap I just noticed that.

  • haha but if you notice..billy started laughing haha :]..so it be not tht tense :P

  • tbh it didnt really sound like a laugh though

  • the only circus of its kind in the world worked better for bullet with butterfly wings

  • Chamberman just kicks ass!!

    EPIC Band!

  • Awesome!

  • turn off darcy's mic

  • iha shouldn´t sing

  • Let me ououerghout!

  • I would love to have a few drum lessons with him

  • He suffered hair loss, and then shaved his head.

  • realy?

  • hahaha i just saw your other comment that said that on the other video

  • They spent a lot of time in Germany.

  • Billy is great guitar player

  • albeit one with a massive ego

  • did billy lose his hair naturaly or do it himself ........he is still bold so i take it he lost it lol but im just wondering

  • He did it himself to piss people off. Everyone said he didn't look enough like a rock star so he shaved his head and started to wear goofy clothes.

  • Ehh, that's sounds a pretty stupid, doesn't it?

    "Dude, you don't look nothing like a rockstar!"

    Corgan - "Well, wait till you see this!"

  • Not sure, but If I was told right, he shaved it off and donated it to Locks Of Love, but that doesn't explain why he doesn't have hair now.

  • his hair line was receding so he just shaved it

  • It was probably the person who recorded the video. XD

  • who is singing false at 3:55.its not billy...someone in the audience?besides that this was really an awsome gig.

    The pumpkins had their golden years in the 90's,they were still badass after that but i'm just saying that they really had their moment in the 90's

  • I bet you it was the rhythm guitarist, whatever his name is.

  • BILLY CORGAN KICKS ASS and I LOVE THE DRUMMER

  • no effects except a big muff for billy. james is clean in intro with a big muff in the corus/verse

  • What a fucking awesome tone off billy.

  • 0:54 looks like David Draiman!

  • This sucks.. Not one of their better performances!!

  • its just shitty video quality..

  • mr. corgan is a better player that you'd think by listening to the records

  • do you play guitar? being a good player is not about doing a bunch of crazy shit and showing off. Sure he is capable of playing faster than he does on the records, but his songs show an amazing guitar talent as they are in the records. He has a true sense of melody and puts his emotions into riffs beautifully. He has been in metal bands, if that is what you are basing your statement from, I am sorry but i think yout statement wasn't too well thought out, peksu82.

  • What kind of Fender Stratocaster is that? I'm guessing the 1979 Anniversery Fender Stratocaster? If it is, God dang it, it costs too much...

  • That chick jams on bass!!!! sorry, i don't know her name. :(

  • D'Arcy Wretzky

  • @smortg exactly

  • wow smashing pumpkins are awesome live!!

  • i cant get over how good a singer he is, normally with bands the singer is terrible live he sounds exactly like he does wen he sings on the album versions.

  • @ilovejamesevans are you joking?

  • @ilovejamesevans the hell? wat bands do u listen to? O.o

    ever hear of METALLICA? they sound exactly the same live as on the albums, even sumtimes better....or mudvayne, slipknot, korn...and those r just a few metal bands off the top of my head. I agree hes a good singer but most bands singers r the only thing that sounds good live lol

  • @LesPaul1482 Please be quiet, people watching this video like good music. Slipknot, Korn and Mudvayne are dire...

  • @ilovejamesevans i just wanned to say nirvana , faith no more genesis phil collins and a lot more , please dont say that ever again

  • @ilovejamesevans lol i jut thought that hes a great live singer because he doesnt sound anything like on the album but much more aggressive

  • luckily for us maybe you'll die

  • haha

  • haha

    great

  • i reckon this was them at their strongest, amazing band, amazing song

  • ahahah you made me laugh!!! go listen to bon jovi and shut the fuck up please :)

  • i think it sounds cool sped up

    his solo sounds wicked and his voice is dead on

  • u think this is fast, listen to them doing geek usa live :P

  • epic live

  • I know it's the Pumpkins' stuff to be messing about with, but to me most of their live stuff is just way too fast to capture the feel of the original songs.

  • billy is a true superstar everyone else was way off at the beginning and he brought it all together awesome.........

  • Shes gettin in to it there at 1:28

  • does anyone think besides me think it sounds worse sped up

    it sounds like hes rushing the song and just trying to get it over with

  • He probably is lol.

  • It's common to play songs faster when performing live. But you're right, it sounds a bit awkward rushed, hats off to the Pumpkins for being able to play a fast song even faster though.

  • Yeah dude I'm with you... It seems like they speed everything up live... Too bad, I love live versions but it's just too fast.

  • they sure know how to make a FUCKING awesome show.... god they are so fucking genious...

  • pinche pelon eres el amo

    d'arcy iha se les extraña de amadre

    vuelvan viejos Smashing pumpkins...

  • that is kind of like my band

  • electrifying!!

    i miss the halcyon days of siamese dream/MCIS

  • is it just me, or is this faster than normal?

  • Way Way Faster!

  • Trust me, SP speeds almost everything up live.

    As if they couldn't be happy just performing it perfectly, they had to rub it in our faces by playing it faster.

  • they dont speed up all the time. it depends on the era: in like the late adore/early machina era they played at normal speed or considerably slower(although they also played 2 steps down XP)

  • 2:32 is what a good band IS

  • great show!

  • i know right, hes like FTW!

  • cuz he's so pretty

  • Because he is mad at the Indie Rock Community.

  • he was mad at how indie rock abnds talk about staying indie and shit wen in reality its smarter to sign to a major label

  • Holy dicks they kicked ASS!

  • why is billy corgan bald. and who is that speaking in the beginning.

  • It's a recording over the PA I assume to introduce Bullet With Butterfly Wings ("the world...world...world/the world is a vampire). But I think the sound guy mixed it up with this song.

  • Actually, they used this for Cherub rock way before Meloncollie and then they used it for Bullet with Butterfly wings lol.

  • well... people sometimes like to cut their hair.. you know for a chance of looks.. and well.. he wanted to be bald.. thats normal dont worry... being bald is OK

  • Considering the uniqueness of Billy's voice, I actually think that they're like the perfect backing vocals for him, although i can see what you mean from this particular video, haha.

  • Wow...the backing vocals were appalling.

    James should be barred from setting foot within 15ft of a microphone.

  • all the vox were appauling, THATS WHY ITS INCREDIBLE!! love it

  • Somebody is aggressivee...anywaiz I play a bit of guitar and let me tell you if you check out the solos for Cherub Rock, Soma (from the same album, Rhinocerous and many others they are very very difficult...

  • Sure like it when Billy had fire in his belly.

  • billy is so into his music and expresses himself fully which is the great thing about him. he's also one of the most underestimated guitarists ever

  • i think your right.

    his guitar and song writing qualities are just awesome....

  • agreed

  • Billy Corgan is one of the most technically talented soloists of any guitarist...new and old...

  • If you're talking technical I gotta say you're talking out of your ass here. There are more metal guitarists than anyone can shake a dick at that technically speaking are about 4000 leagues above Corgan. The only thing is that about 20 of them make anything worth listening to.

  • best song by the smashing pumpkins

  • uh, nope.

  • wtf are you guys talking bout ou can totally tell james is singing

  • The Smashing Pumpkins aren't my favorite band but i never get tired of listening to them and this song, even if it is on rock band.

  • EXCELLENT!

  • D'Ary at 0:44 That was irrisistible

  • I'm putting it very frankly but, James sucks at singing.

  • DUDE! That's actually D'ARCY! HAHAHAHA!

  • James is singing as well. There's a part where it shows him and then your like, what? No, leave the mic alone.

  • I'm not sure who you're talking about... I know they both sometimes suck very hard at singing.

  • I know D'arcy's voice though... that was definitely her... you can barely even hear James.

  • At 2:16 you see James singing. But D'arcy's sure a cutie huh?

  • Yeah she's pretty hot. Ginger's hotter though.

    Yeah and she sucks at singing... except on the Vieuphoria Acoustic version of this... that one she sang really nice.

  • well who did u expect?

  • why is he bald now

  • He changed his hair because he was unhappy with his receeding hairline. I also heard he does it to seem more "vampiric" and to point out his ears more. If you look at :38 - :40 he's fitting it quite well.

    Also something to do with the reason why he sometimes wears "dresses" or long capes, to make him look vampiric and "god Like"

  • is it me or billy's laughing at 1:34 looking at james ahah?

  • at least James should come back, I don't think anyone knows what the hell D'arcy has been up to. The last time she was heard it was her trial when she got arrested for buying cocaine back in 2000 =[ Hopefully James and Billy will settle their differences eventually though.

  • carajo!!! qué chingón!!

  • I love how in like every video he puts a different spin on the solo.

  • check out james back up vocals towards the end of song when billy starts to lose his voice hahahah... it sounds kinda like myaki go karate from the karate kid lol... i love these guys... D'arcy and James please come back to the group!

  • preety cool

  • ..WOW