NDTV: India Better-off With Partition? -1/5

[SIXMIXFIXGIX]

Every Day I THANK Ali Jinnah the 'Gin' Drinker, Weed Smoker and Mujra Liker :)))

[workhardt2]

Jinnah, and his stupid "Two Nation Theroy" !

Jinnah really succeded in Dividing the sub continent !

[workhardt2]

Well, the idea or the first priority of any nation is to raise the living standards of its citizens. With an undivided India, i fear there would be too much stagnation, corruption, communal polizations, and the arab, muslim problems would be India's nemesis.

[irshaad86]

@workhardt2 I don't know what made you say that in undivided India, there would be too much stagnation, corruption becoz Pakistan raced ahead of India in 1950s and 60s in both economic terms and as well as in other terms. Even if you take a look right now, Pakistan fares better than India in certain sections even after being engulfed in war and political instability. Muslim problems? Don't you think there are hindu problems aswell. Communal polarization is still there and it won't go so easily.

[zolmaster100]

ppl say thnk god pak was seperated and it is in its worst condition ...! i not really think so if indai wasnt divided then pakistan also would had been developed

[MrSatyanveshi]

No Pakistani will say partition was a bad thing

No Pakistani will speak good about any hindus

So why are Indian people romanticizing that partition was bad and we that we are brothers? Can't you read and understand Pakistani view points? Don't be foolish Pakistanis are no brothers they are just hindu haters and india haters.

[sikhrocks]

Partition was the best thing which happened to INDIA.

[Phead128]

India doesn't even own the Indus Valley, the supposed source of Indian civilization...

Plus, Pakistan derives her sense of identity by her existential defiance relative to a hindu India....always having to "prove" sovereignty by posing herself as the "real" anti-Indian arch rival...

[idioticstuff]

if somebody says that we are better off with partition will always support more partitions happening in India. So this country does not exist.

Well I have one thing to say to them, fuck off u traitors !!

[TheEsotericDesi]

India's way better off divided than united... Imagine, those 180 milion asshole Sunni Muslims would've been part of India today, causing so much internal issues...

[idioticstuff]

@TheEsotericDesi if it wld not have been congress, India wld have been much better ...

A son who have fought for his mothers freedom cannot be called the father of that mother.

Son will always remain the son.

[Dizasta767]

Partition??? What fucking Partition??? Pakistan is an independent country which was carved out of the BRITISH OCCUPIED FORMER MUGHAL EMPIRE. There was no india to begin with, so it's pretty much clear that hindustanis are fuckin retarded!!!!

[MrLonelygoatherd]

the guy talking at 6:23 has no idea about our history!!

[freepretender]

Mark tully is same old british asshole. bullshit for putting this man on Panel. British dont really desereve what they are being given. They desreve a boot

[Nokapp23]

In Pakistan the word ‘ Hindu ‘ is used with utmost contempt. If one is to use word ‘ Nigger ‘ with such contempt in USA, he will be fired from his job (including president of USA). Hindu needs to defeat Pakistan over & over ( like 1971 war) to bring their senses at right place. And it can be done. Look at Israel.

In fact in Pakistan, you don’t need to do anything to be head of state, just keep cursing ‘ Hindu ‘ & you will be head of state.

[cillantro]

Defenitely but Pakistan should have been a country within a country or an enclave like Lesotho is within South Africa.They should have been landlocked.This piece of land should have been well within India the likes of UP or Madhya pradesh or Jharkhand.Instead our great Ghandi Ji gave away the most cultivable and fertile land with the indus river and our(Indian) civilizations' birthplace the Indus valley to the pakis.You don't give the land they ask to secessionists,only the ones you want to give

[TheEsotericDesi]

@cillantro Thanks to Gandhi and Nehru's post-Independence nonsense, we' Indians are still suffering...

[mjder]

partition to hona hi tha duniya ki tareekh ki doosri religious naion hain hum after medinah alhamdulillah warna aj hindu schools mien wande matram jaisa mushrikana qalma parhna parta hamien and jo halat 9/11 ke bad huwe hain use dekhte huwe msjid jat huwe bhi kafir checking karte so proud to be a muslim pakistani hope so k pakistan is hidden leader in ummah now and will be in front of the world soon inshahllah great workby quad e azad and allama iqbal allah o akbar.

[nawab58]

Racist Indian's in so called secular India. Glad that Jinnah did not accept the Gandhi and Nehru deceptive offer.

[roxor1080]

I'm Pakistani, but just have to say a thing to the ones talking of 'Muslim extremism' : if the Partition hadn't occured, there would be no Islamic extremism, as Pakistan, being an ideological based on religious denominations demands these developments. Personnaly, I've got a more cultural point of view, and I think that dividing the Punjab region was really, really bad.

[Critic224]

@roxor1080 and also Bengal my friend ...

[Citabria007]

The Bengali guy there...Mukherjee or whatever is so wrong. West Bengal should never have been partitioned. India would have been better off if the entire Bengal had gone to Pakistan/Bangla Desh/

The amount of trouble the Bengali's have created for India is unforgivable.

[heirofthenight]

@Citabria007 u have no idea what u r talkin abt .... please check the fact. If u do u will see that even the freedom struggle for freeing ur sorry ass started and took shape from bengal only. Other than the creation and development of modern india, indian industrial hub etc etc etc etc.

[Citabria007]

Wish, Partition had gone on without all the violence..but Partition was the best thing to happen to India,

Thank you Jinnah.

[htgajjar]

India is hundred times better off with Partition otherwise it would be a failed Islamic terrorist state like Pakistan.

I stongly believe that Muslims can never get along with any Non-Muslims be they Hindus, Jews, Christains or Parsis because Islam is all about Hate, Islamic Terrorism and to killing to Kafirs as per Koran.

Even Western nations and China are having problems with Muslims and Islamic Terrorism

[rsridhar]

Jinnah did India a great favor. But for JInnah, India today would be battling the taliban and would be the terrorist nation and not pakistan.

[DylaNxSurF]

we need one to partition Muslims are growing again..

[Vercene]

Yes they are better off because there are less muslims.

[punjabicheeta]

@Vercene Yes we are better off because there are less Hindus.

[satyvirjasra]

@Vercene Well...I dnt think its betr because there are less muslims in india....But yeh u do make a sense tho.....India took the right away from muslims aftr partition, the right to make riots, and control government as a dectator, like they were used to 1000 years ago...Now they cant say anything....Stupid ppl were gone...Even muslims in india are proud to be indians.... u shud knw that aye.... =) BTW I M A HINDU TOO....

[MrTheCorrupter]

@satyvirjasra India is a huge nation with a diverse population.I am a minority, and I can vouch for you that minorities dont feel unsafe in India.Yes,communal riots tend to happen.Think about it? Babri masjid was built by an invader right on top of the center point of Hindu civilization.How would a Muslim feel, if hindus built a temple over kabah,or just nuke it out?.And Gujarat does not represent Indian state policy.In time,people are getting educated and integrating more.

[itsmeeeeeeeeeee]

IF you aunt had a moustache you could have called her Uncle! Ifs and Buts' aside in the present situation, it would hurt India a lot if we were to re-united with Pakistan. Noone can change the past. Two wrongs dont make one right when history is written.

[PakPORKistan]

just look at pakistan do you really want to live with them!!!!!!! thanks to jinnah(who i personally think of as an idiot), we do not live with thse fanatics anymore

[PersonOfBook]

This shows that you are afraid of Muslims? Hindu Coward!

[gikiansage]

jinnah was a genius, i wish had ppl accepted jinnah's proposal we'd be in united india. after all most of his life was for it. it was only politics that led to partition not the two nation theory. anyways it can't be undone so lets be friends

[dignifiedflirt]

@PakPORKistan are you sure all the fanatics went to pakistan during partition??

[Dizasta767]

@PakPORKistan And you're Gandhi was a gaandoo faggot who got shot by your own people!!!! So shut your whore trap, fuckin hindu bitch!

[xizvw]

But  Partition should have been in better way

[Hinduismglance]

Is India Better-off With Partition.Definitely.

If there is a bad relationship,its better to keep it aside rather than drag the animosity.Even if two children do not get along...they do when they live in seperate cities.