i liked the 2004 version with gerard butler and emmy rossum, all time fav..gerard butler HOT phantom, and emmy rossum has the perfect voice for christine daae...i think she should've chosen him instead of Raoul
Nope. Michael Crawford or no one! I saw this over 20 years ago in L.A. a week before his last performance and no one else can touch him. I remember that performance like it was yesterday...
Sarah's voice really changed over the years, and that recording from 25 years before used for the high notes doesn't match. And how about how the orchestra really collapsed during the overture? This is sad...
I remember that I saw this show, at the London Palladium I think it was, back in 1989, and to this day, year 2011, I still do love recollecting the arrangements and lyrics, in my own mind. There have been countless of other versions I know, this one is the best.
I LOVED how they did the technical part of this. The organ and the lights at the beginning gave me chills, and how Antonio walked down those stairs.... holy cow.
Anyone else think the organist is miming? It could just be me, but that really doesn't sound like an actual organ, especially not considering the instrument they have in the Royal Albert Hall. I think the organ sound is coming from something electronic. He's pulling out stops in some rather unlikely places too, and it seems to make no difference. I suspect it's just for show
I don't really care for his singing. I much prefer the movie version with Gerry Butler as Erik the Phantom. They weren't bad, but I just couldn't get into it like I did with the soundtrack to the theatrical version.
Does anybody know why he was dropped from the film? Was is solely because Schumacher wanted young actors or was it something else? I can't find anything online about this casting decision.
@audiesgirl yeah Schumacher did want younger actors and Andrew Lloyd Webber agreed so long as they did their own singing. Their orginal idea was to do the film a couple of years after POTO first came out on stage and have Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman starring in it but it ended up, obviously, being made many years later so they couldn't use them because Schumacher thought it would be better for the film if the characters were younger rather than older :)
Both have good voices, both they don't sound good together. Don't get me wrong, I like Antonio Banderas and think he could play the phantom really well, but he'd have to lose the hispanic accent. It just doesn't fit the character. He does have a beatiful voice though.
I love their voices, just not together. Original Broadway Christine plus singer with a distinct accent is not the best thing I've ever heard, but it's still pretty good.
@FireSath he was a singer before his acting, and to be honest antonio makes a good phantom of the opera, that kind of italian prescence makes it interesting (Im sure hes italian or spanish,not sure)
there are many male singers who've played the phantom for the live performances that although they were professionally trained, etc., their voices weren't as powerful. atleast banderas put some "oomph" behind it! he had more passion and presence than steve harley (who sounded kind of wimpy). the phantom is a "villain"...he's supposed to be dominating and some of the performers over the years haven't delivered that. banderas did.
I agree, he would have been better than who they got, I feel like butler butchered the songs in a couple of spots (did he actually sing his parts or did they get someone else to do the singing?)
It's called the british linking "R". If you study accents usually this happens when a word ends with vowel and the next word starts with another vowel. In american accent it would have been a linking "Y" like "Opera-Yis-here" but for some british it will be "Opera-Ris-here"... So it's an accent issue, mate. hehehe
thumps up if antonio should have wearen a mask
dyanlololol 15 hours ago
@ imarockchick o ya it did i love both of their voices
rockenmom08 3 days ago
2:06 - if the guy on the organ wasn't Antonio Banderas...then who was he? D:
LowellBekker 1 week ago
my GOD he makes my heart stop!!!!!
marylk2657 1 week ago
yuuuuuuhhhhh gerrard and emmy FTW
GameMachine1000 2 weeks ago
i liked the 2004 version with gerard butler and emmy rossum, all time fav..gerard butler HOT phantom, and emmy rossum has the perfect voice for christine daae...i think she should've chosen him instead of Raoul
PhantomGirl1988 3 weeks ago 3
LOVE the song REALLY not doing the girl.....she makes the the song be all weird!!!! but dont get me wrong i love the guy!
sarahrocka10 1 month ago
24 bieber '-'
xiriu0 1 month ago
2:52 slightly pedo-like :L
1414Jade 1 month ago
Nope. Michael Crawford or no one! I saw this over 20 years ago in L.A. a week before his last performance and no one else can touch him. I remember that performance like it was yesterday...
pegster6 1 month ago
Sarah's voice really changed over the years, and that recording from 25 years before used for the high notes doesn't match. And how about how the orchestra really collapsed during the overture? This is sad...
simolionshane 1 month ago
1:50 "I should sing, ... no, better keep walking"
pksstr 1 month ago
@ 3:25 does he say Phamton?
stefengray 2 months ago 2
I'm sorry, but Emmy Rossum is no match for Sarah Brightman
funnyberry93 2 months ago
@MrBuch169169 "Why ya lookin at me like that?"
"Well for one, Antonio is Mexican. . . He's sexy. . . You want me to continue?"
"Your point?"
". . . Alright, go get him."
alanrickmanobsessor 2 months ago
CO DODAT.NADHRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
BĚHA MI MRÁZ PO ZÁDECH
Bejbin77 2 months ago
I'm sorry. I loved the more recent film but Mr. Butler was NOT suited for the singing parts in any way.
princesshyrule 3 months ago
just when I thought the Phantom couldn't get any greater...they bring in Antonio!
alyssheartsanime 3 months ago 4
Good but not as good as Emmy Rossum and Gerard Butler
themollydog2 3 months ago
omgggggggggggggg in love whit banderasss *.* ♥♥
neychayari 3 months ago
Oh, wow.
twiwonder 4 months ago
I can't quite tell what Antonio's voice placement is for those high G's. I want to say it's a mix, but I'm not 100% sure.
MrSean24601 4 months ago
Sarah is awesome..
motlovkaa 5 months ago
The play was written for her as she was married to Andrew Lloyd Webber at the time
she got it as a gift from him!!! She certainly deserved it didn't she???
1musicalfreak 5 months ago 3
dear good Antoni he look's so sexy and OMG he's voice!! :)
ChildrensJackson 5 months ago
I sometimes feel like the phantom was written about Sarah, she is the only Christine (although Emmy Rossum is beautiful and did a great job) :)
Livingetc25 5 months ago
@Livingetc25 Because the play was written for her voice
shyeyedyuki 5 months ago
@Livingetc25 It was.
shionxallen 5 months ago
I remember that I saw this show, at the London Palladium I think it was, back in 1989, and to this day, year 2011, I still do love recollecting the arrangements and lyrics, in my own mind. There have been countless of other versions I know, this one is the best.
natalie11034 6 months ago
lol i think Antonio makes this song really sexy!!! Gerard butler made the movie sexy too though..
melmelmax 6 months ago 7
wheres antonios mask O.O
nataliemm123 6 months ago
I LOVED how they did the technical part of this. The organ and the lights at the beginning gave me chills, and how Antonio walked down those stairs.... holy cow.
ABsensation 6 months ago
I think your all wrong, Antonio is a good singer. plus he looks pimp walking down the stairs.
cooman34 6 months ago 5
pause at 2:14 and look at the spotlight LOL
Roudidou666 6 months ago 6
I think Antonio's accent gives a little sultry and stranger hint to the Phantom's voice.
AishiteruUchiha 6 months ago
The Phantom just got a whole lot flipping sexier
Lotto15719 6 months ago 7
ok do not like her voice at all... but oh boy antonio... WOWSA!
queenofmen52383 7 months ago
Anyone else think the organist is miming? It could just be me, but that really doesn't sound like an actual organ, especially not considering the instrument they have in the Royal Albert Hall. I think the organ sound is coming from something electronic. He's pulling out stops in some rather unlikely places too, and it seems to make no difference. I suspect it's just for show
YKW2 7 months ago
What's the purpose for cutting this short???
jayseah32 7 months ago
which is year it?
lafinion2005 8 months ago
.....is it just me or did the phantom just become 1000000x sexier with a spanish accent? <33333
imarockchick 8 months ago 70
@imarockchick No...it's not you.... :'D
sasukesmyboy 8 months ago 3
@imarockchick How about infinite times?
superblahmanofdoom 3 months ago
@imarockchick what spanish accent? it can't even be noticed...
ferbe1776 4 weeks ago
@imarockchick hell yea
PhantomGirl1988 3 weeks ago
i didnt know antonio banderas could sing! appalause!
ElyTitaShow 8 months ago 5
Antonio is a demon!!! love him! :-)
Antarktida21 9 months ago 3
i like the way antonio banderas sings
melaina16 9 months ago 4
more than half of this was an obnoxiously long intro lol
deutschesmaedchen 9 months ago 3
Does anyone else think that Antonio Banderas looks a little like Raoul Julia? O:?
KristyxoxoAnime 9 months ago
Maravillosa música, Sarah Brightman maravillosa también.
nktu23 9 months ago
i love antonios accent!
moosedawg13 10 months ago
I prefer Lacrimosa Version
dcrow09 10 months ago
Did he say "the PHAMTON of the opera"???
MingDoll82 10 months ago
@MingDoll82 LMAO!! OMG!! I think he did!!! XDDD Wow...
xharleenxquinnzelx 10 months ago
@MingDoll82 yes and i thing i also heard "le phantom of the opera"
CheskaPalabrica 6 months ago
Sarah's still amazing...yet where on earth did they pick up Antonio? His voice is awful...
loverofmusicality 10 months ago
@loverofmusicality obviously a better place than the place you were put
smilesgonewild 9 months ago
I LOVE THESE TWO ! Antonio did amazing :)
DARKmirror70 11 months ago
im watching this video before bed...
letsshoutletsdance 11 months ago
how old is she?
nellas1111 11 months ago
SO AMAZING
i love that song omg.........
TombaLobos9 1 year ago
"Hmmmm, we need an actor to play a hideous, disfigured, French, musical genius and expert singer."
"Okay, how about Antonio Banderas?"
"..."
MrBuch169169 1 year ago 81
@MrBuch169169 Like whatttt??? Why? Just... why? It doesn't make any sense to me. Not bad just not... not quite right.
Talkie15 3 months ago
@MrBuch169169 "Why ya lookin at me like that?"
"Well for one, Antonio is Mexican. . . He's sexy. . . You want me to continue?"
"Your point?"
". . . Alright, go get him."
alanrickmanobsessor 2 months ago
:'D Antonio Banderas has got to be one of my favorite actors!!! :D As soon as I saw his name I went to Zorro... I'm a huge fan of him.
Angellbaby3426 1 year ago
Why does this have to be SO AMAZING?!? ♥ it!!
DelilahAmelia 1 year ago
this makes me want to learn the organ...so beautiful
jacci004 1 year ago
i laughed when he thrust the mic out just like that xD
animefreak3 1 year ago
I don't really care for his singing. I much prefer the movie version with Gerry Butler as Erik the Phantom. They weren't bad, but I just couldn't get into it like I did with the soundtrack to the theatrical version.
croweandcsi 1 year ago
Does anybody know why he was dropped from the film? Was is solely because Schumacher wanted young actors or was it something else? I can't find anything online about this casting decision.
audiesgirl 1 year ago
@audiesgirl yeah Schumacher did want younger actors and Andrew Lloyd Webber agreed so long as they did their own singing. Their orginal idea was to do the film a couple of years after POTO first came out on stage and have Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman starring in it but it ended up, obviously, being made many years later so they couldn't use them because Schumacher thought it would be better for the film if the characters were younger rather than older :)
xxxAliceMariexxx 1 year ago
2:03 - 2:09
The sexiest o face I've ever seen in any work of art!
TheJobyDick 1 year ago
@TheJobyDick I've always thought that too. And the way she moves her head so slightly and closes her eyes like the music is filing her up is amazing.
lasktguy 11 months ago
She has the best voice ever, and Antonio's is beautiful!!!!
Dragonista113 1 year ago
It's all in his stage presence. Those eyes would and do, chill you to the bone, and looking at Sarahs face, she could FEEL him behind her....SUPERB
Nimander76 1 year ago
I prefered Sarah when she was in the musical
tmccak 1 year ago
I want that suit.
Giustheangyone 1 year ago
i love his mexican accent. just his
mlluther00 1 year ago
@mlluther00 Spanish accent. He's not mexican
kiotocitystories 1 year ago
oh my gosh hes so good looking
luvskoolgeek 1 year ago
Ooh, Antonio, sex me up, big boy
SeahorseSalsaXxx 1 year ago 4
@SeahorseSalsaXxx bwa haahahahahhahaa! lol lol
nika4507 1 year ago
I like most of her dress. The bottom portion is lovely. I don't like the sleeves though.
hannah4colbert 1 year ago
i think antonio does great in this song, the phantom is now a spaniard, i love it haha
AidenZaine 1 year ago
hmmm... many have played the Phantom, but I dont think Antonio Banderas ever did. There has been many but no one is as great as Michael Crawford
multiz007 1 year ago
i like phantom of the oprea.
sly3832 1 year ago
que gran obra dicno de llamarse musica y obra de arte
nada como una buena opera para no olvidar lo que verdaderamente es arte
eskimalero 1 year ago
@eskimalero Dios que ironía XD
Dicno jeje
kiotocitystories 1 year ago
he's a great actor and singer. i love him singing oh what a circus in Evita
symoon123 1 year ago
no esta completo el video malo
fresa326 1 year ago
Que guapo Antonio Banderas en este video y que gran canción con la voz de Sarah Brightman solo Espectacular
fresa326 1 year ago
espectacular
javierchepe 1 year ago
Superb performance from both. Would like to see John Travolta perform this part.
voon100 1 year ago
Oh my god, the thunderous overture still gives me chills.
Phantom Forever <3
bassoonbuddy247 1 year ago 5
Both have good voices, both they don't sound good together. Don't get me wrong, I like Antonio Banderas and think he could play the phantom really well, but he'd have to lose the hispanic accent. It just doesn't fit the character. He does have a beatiful voice though.
jedilord88 1 year ago
I LOVE THE OVERTURE TO PHANTOM IM WALKING DOWN THE ISLE TO IT AT MY WEDDING AVID PHANTOM FAN LOL
phantomchick88 1 year ago
Pst...Antonio...I think you forgot something...
90DaysDelinquent 1 year ago 2
amazing!!! and breath taking!!!!!
zutarafan0909 1 year ago
I love their voices, just not together. Original Broadway Christine plus singer with a distinct accent is not the best thing I've ever heard, but it's still pretty good.
Aventura459 1 year ago
why does the phantom bloke wear a mask
thunderstormabbi 1 year ago
@thunderstormabbi ಠ_ಠ.... are you serious?
oxLtWolfxo 1 year ago 2
@oxLtWolfxo -LOL.
KaoriSan13 1 year ago
@thunderstormabbi lololol this made my day
brownosity 1 year ago
@thunderstormabbi ...........
Danscottonair 1 year ago
@thunderstormabbi -The Phantom shall now come to your house and strangle you. Be prepared.
KaoriSan13 1 year ago
@thunderstormabbi I cant remember what happened to it but what ever happened his face looks gross. it was probably a fire.
symoon123 1 year ago
@symoon123 it was a birth defect. he was born with it
ilovejobros312 1 year ago
Antonio would have been a great phantom in the movie!
wfwr 1 year ago
Sarah is awsome! She can sing opera just like tarja but better!(no offence) This is Beautiful!
xena1234100 1 year ago
did he just say Phamton @ 3:28??
stefengray 1 year ago
@stefengray Haha, he so did! I never noticed that before, but now that you mentioned it, it definitely sounded like that.
aarond53 1 year ago
does music get any better than this, maybe be just maybe kris and sophie
whittley90 1 year ago
Love opera.......Antonio and Serah beutiful couple..........
countcsaba 1 year ago 2
Love you All who likes good music............
countcsaba 1 year ago 2
love this song!!!
but i preffer the nigthwish version
the voice of tarja is better, speciality in the end. i like sahara but...my heart is of nigthwish :3
zuraretany 1 year ago
Impresionante!!!!
BibianaClaudiaBryson 2 years ago
I love Antonio's accent on this :D
holidayizon 2 years ago 5
i like the nightwish version.. is more rock.. but this worth to see if it really is antonio banderas...
sparklight39 2 years ago
Funny how he says the phamton of the opera
Gideon235 2 years ago 2
Sarah Brightman is still a superlative singer... and a total overactress!
NPChilla 2 years ago 56
@NPChilla Nothin' wrong with a little overactin'. ;-)
LadyAnneBoleyn1536 1 year ago
the organ player in this is absolutly amazing! <3
RedDeathsReturn 2 years ago 7
I love it.
Perfect
mbizinoto 2 years ago
Antonio is a good actor, and he sing really nice. But he's not singer, oh no.
FireSath 2 years ago 46
@FireSath he was a singer before his acting, and to be honest antonio makes a good phantom of the opera, that kind of italian prescence makes it interesting (Im sure hes italian or spanish,not sure)
cgsmitherine3 1 year ago
@FireSath but i don't think the phantom is really suppose to have a professional sounding voice. It's suppose to be kind of rough.
chiccaboom 1 year ago
@FireSath oh shut up yes he is! He is an amazing singer!
sweetheart1129 1 year ago
Go antonio!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
slytherinangel666 2 years ago 5
Łaaaa .. nie wiedziałam że Antonio tak śpiewa :D
Szefuncio13814 2 years ago
pinche antoño banderas si lo idolatraba ahora mas
es un a verga cantando
freskiboypcr 2 years ago
OMFG ITS ANTONIO BANDERAS!!
cgsmitherine3 2 years ago 3
I could so see Antonio Banderas as the phantom...it's weird but I think he would be good.
slytherinangel666 2 years ago 5
i didnt know antonio can sing... good on him. if the movie called for a spanish phantom hed be perfect. he has that edge..... phew x
Stripedinside 2 years ago 7
she's really pretty! :)
MJFan10151 2 years ago 3
Sexy Vampire(interview with the vampire), and Phantom! My favorite things! He's like the ultimate Fabio(romance novel sterotype)!
LolitaLexi 2 years ago 5
la~ la~
iluvsnoopy25 2 years ago
Mrs. Brightman uses too much vibrato ... less is often more
maskedhedgehog 2 years ago 7
Agree! This is tooo much!
MrSpartacus09 2 years ago
Scottish? He's Spanish. His accent is Spanish. Lol.
XMissNarcoticX 2 years ago 7
I did not mind AB as CHE. But this is a real singers role.
waltfrasier 2 years ago
there are many male singers who've played the phantom for the live performances that although they were professionally trained, etc., their voices weren't as powerful. atleast banderas put some "oomph" behind it! he had more passion and presence than steve harley (who sounded kind of wimpy). the phantom is a "villain"...he's supposed to be dominating and some of the performers over the years haven't delivered that. banderas did.
viciouscanadianvixen 2 years ago 3
villain? check out marco hietala dude!! thats pure brutality that a villain needsa!!
elliotaurellia8 2 years ago
For a Rock/Metal song, sure.
But the Phantom isn't a Brutal villain, he's a classy/refined one. Marco is a VIKING. Totally unsuited. =P
Foxhengeyokai 2 years ago
It's beautifull the dress she's wearing...i love it
DartiCia 2 years ago 3
Banderas was terrible, but Sarah is the reason I listen
gabrielevanhelsing 2 years ago
lol he was meant for roles with masks
McLongDong 2 years ago
If you look very closely you can see Sarah's skin crawl when Antonio sings! I know mine did!
Feetie39 2 years ago
Look at 2:14 and tell me what you see lol
RebelFounderOdogoo 2 years ago 3
scissors? xD
VenustasSomnium 2 years ago
lol
Xage85 2 years ago
I feel butler did a good job so far as the acting, but I didn't like how he sung some of the parts (if that is indeed him singing)
espnmarshall 2 years ago 3
It is indeed Butler singing in the movie :)
paulitaa05 2 years ago 2
I agree, he would have been better than who they got, I feel like butler butchered the songs in a couple of spots (did he actually sing his parts or did they get someone else to do the singing?)
espnmarshall 2 years ago
if they did... couldnt they get a better singer?
renogwapo 2 years ago
anyone else notice how she calls him the phantom of the 'operar' ?
njagala 2 years ago 2
It's called the british linking "R". If you study accents usually this happens when a word ends with vowel and the next word starts with another vowel. In american accent it would have been a linking "Y" like "Opera-Yis-here" but for some british it will be "Opera-Ris-here"... So it's an accent issue, mate. hehehe
zer0cool16 2 years ago
you have to see evita then! he's so sexy in evita oh man
njagala 2 years ago
i'm dutch too
:p eindelijk een belg
herryOrRobin 2 years ago
quee hermoso! pero no sabia ke antonio banderas cantaba me sorprendio n_n hasta ke tono alcanza la voz de sarah ?
HinaichigoPola 2 years ago
HOW DID THEY GET Antonio Banderas FROM THE TOP TO THE STAGE SO FAST
pogo506 2 years ago
I don't think it's him. The organist has lighter coloured curly hair and a fuller face.
*sigh* song feels rushed... :(
LittleCrowling 2 years ago
In search of the Holy God
Phantoms lurk
stalk
prey
Pray for them
my angels
Pray
Eveningwillow 2 years ago
hmm... I think Gerard Butler is the best PHANTOM. The next is Polish version. Damian Aleksander, Tomasz Steciuk and Edyta Krzemień, Paulina Janczak.
Broadway version is bad.. I think..
roxy116116 2 years ago 2
i never knew that he could sing this good..wow
kikyo10231 2 years ago 2
They should of had Michael Crawford singing this...the man who made this role legendary and sings it better then anyone on the face of the planet!
colinmcphan 2 years ago
antonio banderas can sing??!!!
what is this??!!!
oh man..and he sounds good too.
shewasnumber1 2 years ago
Ya. Go find the movie of Evita. He sings in that.
LittleCrowling 2 years ago
why Antonio Banderas why! he sound good i just dont like his accent
why not Colm! would have been better
but shes amazing!
Jiraiya1313 2 years ago
her dress is gorgeous and she's SUCH a talented singer!!!
antonio has a voice?? i actually kinda like it =]
carmuchita 2 years ago 3
God he is an actor - how could he sing like that!
prymadarya 2 years ago 6
Considering Sarah was a skimpy dancer in the past....
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago
this video is taken from?? dvd??
ikilie 3 years ago
well, i have this on tape.. it's a concert to honor andrew lloyd weber. :)
ferrisgrl9 2 years ago