I love the Guilty Ones, and I understand why this was cut. However, it is incredibly symbolic to the relationship between Melchior and Wendla. Wendla is the innocent madien searching for love, Melchior is the pirate who kept searching for knowledge and answers so much that he unwittingly had people hurt along the way.
Oh. Well, it has to do with their childhood. They used to play pirates and the conflict in the song has to do with what just happened. The song would have been were the Guilty Ones is now.
The 1st is Wendla, the 2nd is Melchior, 3rd is Wendla (then the girls join in), 4th is Melchior and the boys join. The 5th the boys sing (the girls kind of echo). You can find a recording around here from the off-Broadway version.
On the chalkboard on the set, with the song list, you see the name of a song crossed out, and I always wanted to know what song had ended with the word "pirate..." hahah. this must be it. I like it.
This song gives me shivers.
mewichigo10 1 month ago
love it! can anyone tell me te chords for it? anyone know how to play it?
senatorssweetheart 1 year ago
its good :) can anyone tell me what the chords are for this? i'd like to know how to play it
senatorssweetheart 1 year ago
I like the way Leah sang this song
OutOfTotalRandomness 1 year ago
I love the Guilty Ones, and I understand why this was cut. However, it is incredibly symbolic to the relationship between Melchior and Wendla. Wendla is the innocent madien searching for love, Melchior is the pirate who kept searching for knowledge and answers so much that he unwittingly had people hurt along the way.
AliaSparrow 1 year ago 11
@AliaSparrow wow...good call. i didnt really think about how deep and symbolic it is
TheDieselD13 1 year ago
I prefer this to Guilty ones. It's more haunting and symbolic (the pirates', the violets the willows)... TGO is more obvious in its meaning.
shellshockkked 2 years ago
*loves it*
omikronescence 2 years ago
This is excellent. It freaks me out but I love it.
animagusprincess 3 years ago
Love this song, but am getting a bit freaked out by the electronic noises zooming around in the background. Trippy.
benjywho 3 years ago 8
I really wish they hadn't cut this song. I do understand that many people wouldn't understand it though. But I love it still!
ernieislove 3 years ago
It was cut from the play, but its still on the cd... I listen to it all the time.
kyrakyramyra 3 years ago
What CD do you have?
GardenOfEros 3 years ago
the soundtrack on itunes has it..
magicmike96 3 years ago
Whoa, thanks. It's not on the physical CD I bought after the show.
GardenOfEros 3 years ago
hmm thats odd?
i wonder why not..?
magicmike96 3 years ago
@magicmike96 It was only available on albums downloaded through iTunes.
Jcthefluteman 1 year ago
I do not get it? Is it supposed to symbolize Melchior's and Wendla's relationship?
Compooky121 2 years ago
Oh. Well, it has to do with their childhood. They used to play pirates and the conflict in the song has to do with what just happened. The song would have been were the Guilty Ones is now.
ernieislove 2 years ago
i think the 1st verse is Melchi and Wendla.
and the 2nd verse is Moritz and Ilse.
idk idk, just me
GlassFrogProductions 2 years ago
The 1st is Wendla, the 2nd is Melchior, 3rd is Wendla (then the girls join in), 4th is Melchior and the boys join. The 5th the boys sing (the girls kind of echo). You can find a recording around here from the off-Broadway version.
lotrfan8 2 years ago 4
On the chalkboard on the set, with the song list, you see the name of a song crossed out, and I always wanted to know what song had ended with the word "pirate..." hahah. this must be it. I like it.
CCCHHHLLLOOEEE 3 years ago
Ooh this song is cool! Thank you for posting.
monorailblue 3 years ago