American Idol 7 Top 6 Elimination of Carly Smithson 04/23

[triamera28]

Carly is such a brilliant and great singer...

She is so pretty..

I LOVE YOU CARLY!!!

GO CARLY!!!!!

GO CARLY!!!!

[JBArchieFan101]

no offense but in my opinion syesha or brooke should have been the botton 2

[spashley16]

she was the best one on american idol 7... she is my idol... Is such a joke for her to be leaving so soon.. not fair at all...

[cbotten106]

Carly's going to get three songs on the tour so if you've got the money and the stomach to sit through a couple of hours of "the others" then it would be cool to see her sing live. Supposedly her set is going to be Come Together (Beatles cover), Crazy On You (Heart cover) and Bring Me To Live (an Evanescence cover). Sounds like a good set for Carly.

[shannihan]

I hope she sing "Alone" by Heart on the tour. If you go to the official myspace done by her family, she says "I'm gonna sing Alone. I never got to do it on the show, but hopefully I'll get to do it on the tour." when you play Alone on the top left-hand corner of the page. I know she sang it during Hollywood week, but I think she meant the finals. :)

[shannon372565784]

i was mortified when i heard she was going home, but the flip side is look how great jennifer hudson turned out once she went home! she was in dreamgirls! so shes gonna have a huge career ahead of her and this is not the last time you will here the name CARLY SMITHSON

[L00king4LOVE247]

She has the best personality and the best voice ever !!!! I still am trying 2 get over that moment. That shouldn't have been. I can't wait to buy Carly's album and see her on tour.

WAY TO GO CARLY !!!!! I <33 YA !!!

[cbotten106]

Carly is truly a special talent and I suspect in time a whole lot of people we come to this conclusion.

[irishsweethearttx]

2:42 she looks stunning. I miss those irish eyes, I will miss her in general. PLEASE COME BACK CARLY SMITHSON ! :D

[avrillabing]

is she pregnant?

[cbotten106]

No but Ryan's pause before announcing the "result" certain was.

[2magical2]

Who ever likes Carly and would like to support her, her Ultimate High album charted at #82 on top pop 100! It'll be great if we support her and buy the album.

[madhattertophat]

I really can't get why Syesha still there. She might be the next,after brooke and stuff. I mean, she and jason castro are not good, but jason at least has charisma and stuff. Please don't be mad at me for saying this, but,eventhought syesha is xtremely talented she has nothing that, I don't know, make people love her or something. I really don't get it :T

[ultimatejoeshmo]

the faggot with the dreadlocks has got to go

[scoopgirl0829]

Like Jennifer Hudson, like Chris Daughtry, like LaKisha, another amazing singer left the show.

This is ridiculous. She shouldn't have gone home. She should have stayed AT LEAST until the Top 3.

Something happened there. You can hear the audience, they did not like the results. I can't quite believe America voted to this.

I'm sure she'll do great, though. A girl with such a talent like her will not be forgotten that easily.

[iluvhotcheetos18]

I was so mad! Jason castro should have gone home A LONG TIME AGO! Hes pushing out alot of great singers out of the competition.

[hollynat]

which song is this?

Carly congrats anyway!

great job Irish eyes....

Greeetings from Argentina!!!

Goodbye my friend

[aamllover]

Que marmelada!I hope David Archuleta wins

[537etecsa]

Carly is out because she is white, and the other girl is black.

Fox is afraid about the black - american boicot...

[missingsimon]

those two DID not and DO not belong in the bottom two. =/

[Socatmeow]

carly was like the best

[livi40]

hey im 13 and im definately not voteing 4 jason i think hes a bit of a prick not even my sister liked him and shes in to that sort of crap i cant wait 4 carly 2 relese an album she n david cook r the only ones i would buy

[flx16]

buuuuh!! buuuh!!

[cbotten106]

Carly Smithson had a good run and be sure to look for her in the finale show because I'm guessing she will be one of the the stars.

[GoodDayBeatles]

I was so shocked when I found out that she left American Idol. Carly Smithson is a talented girl, who will most likely have a record deal anyways. Brooke or Jason should've left. It's not fair.

[e6e678910]

where is the sound?

[giganticgreen]

there's a sound. make sure your speakers are up.

[blahblahblah92695]

dang, i though brook or jason should've left. anyway, lol, david archuleta in the back is like "um i can't see..."

[inxsamy]

That crap is crazy. This girl has got talent. All I have to say though is look at Chris Daughtry. We will see her on the charts real soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Citabria007]

she already has a CD out..where the recording label spent over $3 Million and it sold less than 300.

She is lying here saying ....she never had a door open for her. The lying tramp that she is.

[inxsamy]

grow up

[Augustus1225]

well, let's see. There is the obvious respect of the judges and other contestants on the show... and then there' your opinion. Wonder who's will go further? maybe she just needed some exposure? At any rate, pea green envy is NOT your color.

[PinkFrostyDonut]

Citabria007-Looks like Carly was ripped off of $3 million by her marketers/agent who did nothing to market her CD. I never heard of Carly before so the agent she hired sucked so much that she had to join American Idol to gain popularity herself and not pay someone else $3 million to do it for her. SMART move, Carly. You finally got your name out there without costing you $3 million and all purely based on your hard work & talent that the judges (even Simon) said you could be at the top 3!

[irishsweetheatx]

You guys are saying America made a big mistake? You guys are the ones voting. She should still be there, all you 12-15 year olds, stop voting for Jason because of his looks! I love you Carly Smithson, I will keep my ears open for news about you!

[Citabria007]

My fav AI Moment was to see Carly Shitson Porky voted off.

In fact, its my fav all time TV Moment

[lico909]

how can you call her that take a look in the mirror first porky you damn shit if i were you i will shut my mouth you dick head

fuck you

[jaybellicks]

carly is a good sport, you'll have a bigger singing career this time. jason or brooke shoiuld have been voted out first. america use your good judgment goodness sake!

[101u]

Its about time she is gone. She screams too much while singing(well, sort of singing)

[UndercoverCracker]

...idiot...She is amazing and just plain fun!

[pukeface90210]

Carly: I remembered all the words! hahahahahahhahahahahah. bitch.

[punk2116]

Fuck this. AMERICA...so DISAPOINTING

[Ann0319]

Thats too bad se left :(...she realy has talent. :(

This is as bad as when Michael left. I wanted Carly or him to be in the second place, coz of course DAVID ARCHULETA deserves to win ;)

[moonstaff1234]

Sniff Sniff!!!!!! Carly was one of my favorites from the start! I can't believe she got voted off. She was only in the bottom 3 twice and this was her first bottom two! She sang great and she was happy how did she get voted off!! I was so sure she would be in the top three. Brooke hasn't been doing good lately and I thought she was definetly going then Jason and from there I was not sure. WUAH!

[thericketandoo]

wow. America...we is retarded. yup. 'yall can't see talent when it's right in front of you.

[Camillah]

I was really surprised when i saw carly got voted off, she was definitely in my top two.

does anyone know the name of the song playing in the background??

[rubiitvxqsuju]

Simon looked so sad :(

i'd be SO disspointed if BROOKE OR JASON manages to stay next week, unless if they pull of something amazing

[giganticgreen]

If the "popularity contest" as what Randy has mentioned continue next week, then Syesha might be the next cast-off.

[splashpower]

I agree! I'd be furious if Jason manages to stay in the competition. He sucks!

[SamIanFan08]

It's obvious that it's about popularity and CAMPAIGNING! HELLO! Brooke clearly has a bigger fanbase who are active. I just wish that more Smitson fans held back voting because Brooke messed up. Goes to show you have to keep it up no matter how good a performer.

Personally, I love both Davids who are most likely to face to face at the end.

[giganticgreen]

I agree that AI 7 would end up having the 2 Davids face to face. I can't wait for it to happen!

[splashpower]

I also see that...wahahhaa...I'm pro-David A.

[giganticgreen]

I'm pro-David C.

A is too young and has the same style over and over. It gets boring sometimes, though he's really good for his age.

[TheRealArchAngel]

Also remember that all Eliminated Contestants votes have to go somewhere.

Kristy Lee Voters likely migrated to Jason and Brooke

[knockedup13]

Carly had her chance as a singer and she sold a whole 300 albums. Ya, I am sure she would be better with a second contract.

[giganticgreen]

Yep, I think so. And as Paula said it "it's just the beginning..."

[coconnel51]

Wow. America must be a group of f$#@%^(! idiots. 13 year-olds must be deciding the vote. I'm ashamed for the taste of this country. Disturbing.

[splashpower]

I very much agree!

[crazedcapitalist52]

This sucks. Fuck you America with your fucking bias favoritism.

[splashpower]

Yeah! You're perfectly right!