This authority is merely Patriarchal because ITS AUTHORITY IS TERRITORIALLY AND PERSONALLY LIMITED to only those who profess to be Novus Ordo Catholics. But wait Lutherans and Anglicans and Orthodox can legitimately be members of the body of Christ! Right? Why does he not have authority over THEM? Because, by definition, his authority is not the authority of the Roman Pontiff; the Roman Pontiff has Universal and SUPREME jurisdiction over the Church which is the mystical body of Christ.
This NEW VATICAN ORGANIZATION is ONTOLOGICALLY DIFFERENT from the Traditional Catholic Church. Therefore, it cannot BE the Catholic Church. Therefore Its HEAD cannot be the Pope. The head of this Organization does not FUNCTION as a Pope, because he does NOT have jurisdiction over all its members! Insofar as Lumen Gentium and Gaudium et Spes and other documents admit to the Body of Christ Non-Catholic and heretical gruops and schismatics, the Pope has only a Patriarchal Authority.
The reason for this is that Lumen Gentium REDEFINED the NATURE of the Church by sating that the Mystical body of Christ SUBSISTS IN the Catholic church. For one thing to exist within another is to be distinct from it, and implies that it may be larger than it. That is because ABSOLUTE EQUIVOCAL IDENTITY (Catholic Church IS the Mystical body of Christ.) is not maintained as it was by Pope Pius XII in Mystici Corporis Christi. THEREFORE, PAUL VI defined INTO EXISTENCE a NEW Vatican Organization.
Now, let's think: Benny has called the Orthodox Churches particular and true churches. He has also called the Orthodox priests "True shepherds of the church of Christ." Okay, so he understands that the Orthodox are united to the Mystical body of Christ. But the POPE has JURISDICTION over ALL the visible members of the mystical body of Christ. Yet Benny has no jurisdiction over the Orthodox! Yet he calls them member sof the body of Christ! Therefore he is NOT aPope, not even in his own church!
May God bring a swift end to the "Reign" of Fr. Ratzinger, and may he grant us a true and holy Pope. May Fr. Ratzinger Convert before his death and so avoid damnation for his manifest apostasy and heresy.
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. There is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. There is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. THere is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
If sedevacantism is correct then this would mean that all priests ordained since Vatican II are heretics and as a result, cannot perform the transubstantiation necessary for the real presence in the Eucharist. Would Jesus allow the world to be deprived of His precious body and blood? I cannot and will not accept sedevacantism as truth. I see this as a brazen attack on the church. What right do they have to call anybody an "antichrist" especially John Paul II?
The maker of this video is himself a protestant heretic and schismatic. We dont protest Vatican 2. It is heretical schismatic and invalid. The Catholic Greek Byzantine rite Patriarch just excommunicated Ratzinger and the apostate Woytiwa who prayed to the devil in the meeting houses of heretics, pagans and Jews. He declared we are in a state of Sede Vacante.
Frankfurt Bavarian Iluminati was founded on May 1, 1776. This is the date of founding of all communist nations and the date of the Illuminati claiming to beatify the apostate Woytiwa brought to power by CIA and P2 lodge/operation GLADIO.
@aburke673 Pretty sure you don't get to decide what is heresy and who is condemned, dude. Anyway, cool story! Very convincing. I see my priest for my sins, not you. That is, my priest who possesses the authority handed down to him in an unbroken line from Jesus to Peter until this point and into the future. Not you.
@TheHardout2005 my wife Mrs John Stewart is correct. Only heretics would believe an apostate who goes into the meeting houses of jews, heretics and pagans to pray to the devil with them, is their pope. check out my channel on the excommunications of Ratzinger and Woytiwa by the Greek Byzantine rite Catholic Ukraine Patriarch.
@stewartburchardjohn Listen, I don't want to be your daddy, but your understanding of ecumenism is woeful. Why not check out Catholic vids, instead of sedevacantist vids?
@aburke673 I'm sorry. I didn't know I was dealing with an insane racist - as evidenced by the use of capital letters, overzealous listing, polar words, and language.
Do you know what heresy is? It is going against the teaching of Church. Thus the Church, by definition, cannot teach heresy, because She is what defines what heresy is. Thus it is illogical to conclude that Humanae VItae is heresy, as the Church teaches it. In fact, by being sedevacantist, you are living in heresy.
@aburke673 Firstly: name-calling is polarising and unhelpful. Secondly, I've performed no heresy. Tradition begins somewhere, does it not? I am making no claim to creating that tradition myself. You might consider that recent publications by popes, such as Humanae Vitae and Fides et Ratio, or Pope Benedict's books, will form part of our Tradition in the years to come. Perhaps it is your understanding of what I meant that went amiss?
Everything I have heard about Pope Pius XII confirms that he was a holy man and a very good Pope - that his writings served to sure up the defenses and strengthen the bulwarks, so to speak.
It seems to me that his invaluable contribution was God's Divine providence for the Church, coming just before the cataclysm.
Please reply and say what you consider to be the heresy taught under Pope Pius XII.
Sedevacantism is not a strange position, remember that the Catholich Church has had many anti-popes through its history; if there's a time when this is most evident, it is today, we've never witnessed so many heresies as today.
Although no doubt Freemasons had infiltrated the Church to its highest levels before the invalid "Vatican II" Robber Council, the primary responsibility for the loss of faith that followed lies solely with the head-bobbing clueless sheep in the pews, along with a lax clergy and a hierarchy composed primarily of craven sycophants, whose primary concern was advancing their own careers. They paid homage to the APOSTATE Paul VI and his unworthy successors, as the speaker in this video confirms.
How do you cope with the Pope's joint prayer day with the muslims in Turkey and his acceptance of Talmudic Judaism (satanism?) as a valid way for salvation. As a recent convert to Catholicism myself, I have done ext research into the history of the Church and doctrine. Don't you find, as I did, the Vatican II council to be a complete, radical and herectical break from the entire teachings and actions of the Saints, Popes and Martyrs up to that Council?
O YOU THAT SO EAGERLY CONDEM MY CHURCH, WILL SAY TO YOU CHRIST AT THE OUR OF JUDMENT: WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO BE PERFECT, SHOW ME WHAT YOU HAVE DONE FOR MY CHURCH. Did you instead pass your whole time to critisize her. Fool! Don't you know that he who critisize is loosing time to work? Satan the accusator, good of nothing. CATHOLIC CHURCH IS IN VATICAN AND ALL WHO SAYS OTHERWISE ARE HERESY PROPAGANDER, worth of Luther
Doing an assignment on "Christian Fundamentalism" at University as part of my theology degree. Basically Sedevacantism has the basic hallmarks of christian fundamentalism. They are a reactionary group to modernist liberalism, they are a small organised group who continue to condemn anybody who does not conform to their belief.
Basically they are a bunch of doomsday spooks who couldn't handle reform. Just pointing out that the dark ages were over 600 years ago dudes.
I do not believe in reform of the catholic church when it comes to many things. But I would not go beyond SSPX. They are not excommunicated anymore. Now Im not a member of SSPX, but I respect them. The best thing is of course to retake the Catholic Church from the followers of John XXIII. But this should be done from the inside of the church. Not creating this mad secteristic groups, like in USA. SSPX is a one of those groups that can change the Catholic back to its roots.
@Faith3Faith It's true; I'm afraid. I'm also afraid to debate L. Ron Hubbard, Benny Hinn, Benny Hana, Hare Krishnas, Jehovahs Witnesses & Mofmons. I'm afraid of wasting my time.
@Faith3Faith ^And the king of all nefarious sects has spoken.
So, how do you like belonging to the Protestant sect who believe that everything after Vatican II was false?
Stop being a Protestant already and come home to the True Faith and UNBROKEN AUTHORITY that is only found in the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Do it now ...
elcamaras, if you believe you have the TRUTH, then why don't you debate the Sedevacantist, brother Peter Dimond, one on one by phone and then upload that debate to YouTube ? Why are all of you V2 defenders so afraid of debating the Dimond brothers ?
Sedevacantists should hear St. Paul: "And in all seduction of iniquity to them that perish; because they receive not the love of the truth, that they might be saved. Therefore God shall send them the operation of error, to believe lying (2 Thes 2:10)."
Pope St Agatho III Council of Constantinople; "If any ecclesiastic or layman shall go into the synagogue of the Jews or the meeting houses of the heretics to join in prayers with them let them be deposed and deprived of communion."
Several Archbishops and Cardinals forewarned the Attending Bishops of the plot in the book published prior to the council, called THE PLOT AGAINST THE CHURCH by Maurice Pinay, a pen name of the consortium of those clerics.
A must read for any Catholic.
Its free online as well.
Changing Christ's Own Words in the Canon, should be reason enough for anyone with a brain to sort out, its Invalid.
@elcamaras just anothert lie of heretics. During the arian apostacy denying the divine incarnation of Christ, most bishops fell into the arian heresy after the Council of Nicea. Bishop saint Doctor Athanasius and saint doctor martyr Bishop Ecebuis all deposed arian bishops and consecrated catholic ones. there was no ordinary jurisdiction during this crisis only supplied jurisdiction. Saint Athanasius taught in his letter to his litte flock all heretics excommunicate themselves ipso facto
@elcamaras heretics are ex cathedra the gates of hell. it is ex cathedra all heretics are self condemned after 2 warnings. If you understood the church which you dont, being a heretic, you would know a catholic can not obey both Pope Gregory XVI and Mirari Vos and the evil heretical anti Pope Roncalli in his anti catholic encyclical Pacem en Terris where he heretically claims non catholics have religious liberty.
@nicholasvonfluh you clearly stated what place will lose the faith.
Is it Rome according to the vision or the Vatican? Remember Rome in the early church was faithless as well? Only the Church was there and the rest of the city itself was infested with pagans. Our Lady does not mention the Vatican or the Church.
Its also funny that Our Lady of Akita appeared after Vatican II, is her message a "modernist" message as well?
@huntinggods Pope saint Pius X and scriptures state anti christ will stand in the holy place of God the Catholic church. Mathew 24:15 makes this clear.
@nicholasvonfluh you should see all the prophecies of Catholic Prophets, not just La Salette. Remember also that the Virgin of Fatima was protecting the Pope John Paul II when he got shot. Anyways, if you read the prophecies, there will be an antipope, not sede vacantism, and not a bunch of antipopes either.
@gersoto you seek after false signs and revelations. with itching ears you deny catholic dogmas. try reading the bible heretic along with the divine magisterium
@gersoto you have followed anti pope Roncalli into heresy non catholics have relgious liberty. THEY DONT HAVE IT ONLY CATHOLICS HAVE IT/THE DIVINE INFALLIBLE RIGHT TO DEMAND FROM EVERY GOVERNMENT THE DIVINE RIGHT TO PRACTICE THE GOSPEL PRECEPTS TO FULL OVERFLOWING MEASURE. Pope Gregory XVI called non catholics having religious liberty smoke of satan. modernists morphed this heresy into implicit unconscious BOD without the catholic faith putting MAN'S PRIVATE CONSCIENCE IN THE HOLY PLACE OF GOD
@aburke673 you may want to improve your way of teaching, I recommend you G.K.Chesterton or st. Francis de Sales, other than I am not protestant, I'm catholic, and I have liberty, however, if you hear the gospel and beleive one thing and not another, you don't beleive in the gospel but in yourself. When I said prophets I meant catholic prophets; from, for example "Catholic Prophecy" of Tan books.
@gersoto I recommend you read the book an introduction to a devout life Saint Francis de Sales page 234-236 that states frustrating the primary end of marriage that is always procreation is always grave mortal sin heretic, and this dogma is taught by the unanimous consent of all the church fathers. I am sick of you arrogant heretics. GET OUT OF MY CATHOLIC BUILDINGS BEFORE WE HAVE A REDO OF THE MACCABEES
@gersoto YOU STUPID ARROGANT HERETIC OF SATAN AND THE APOCALYPSE. NON CATHOLICS DONT HAVE RELIGOUS LIBERTY AND YOUR ANTI POPE RONCALLI HERETICALLY PROCALIMED THE DO HAVE IT. YOU CAN NOT OBEY BOTH POPE GREGORY XVI AND THE EVIL APOSTATE FREEMASON ANTI POPE SMOKE OF SATAN RONCALLI. YOU ARE A NON CATHOLIC YOU SATANIC FOOL SINCE YOU FOLLOWED ANTI POPE RONCALLI INTO HERESY AND ANTI CHRIST PAUL VI INTO APOSTACY AND ABOMINATION OF DESOLATION
@gersoto You can not obey both Infallible Pope Gregory XVI papal encyclcical Mirari Vos and obey the anti pope Roncalli who claims as smoke of satan non catholics have religous liberty. You are on your way to hell heretic. wake up before you are in hell. Public warning number one. It is ex cathedra Pope Vigilus you will stand self condemned after 2 warnings and heretics are the gates of hell.
@aburke673 condemning others to hell is not the way to teach, but the ones that can excommunicate for example, do it as the last resource. Who put you as our teacher to tell us that? Didn't God put the priests and bishops? (Acts 20:17-30) And you think you are more catholic than the Pope? like protestants, you interpret wrong what someone says to say as if they were in favor of you, but you have no prophets but your own interpreetation to tell if something is true.
@gersoto THE CHURCH CONDEMNED YOU TO HELL BY PERPETUAL IRREFORMABLE SOLEMN BIBLICAL ANATHEMA. UPON DEATH ALL HERETICS WILL DESCEND INTO HELL UNDER PERPETUAL CURSE. You have to be catholic to be a bishop you stupid heretic. I dont interpret, Christ, the unanimous consent of all the church fathers from the apostles, safeguarded by papal infallbility in papal encylicals and lastly the sole ex cathedra dogmatic definition put you under your curses. you stand self condemned after 2 warnings
@gersoto you twist the scriptures and the words of our holy popes. we do not judge with the judgements of men but when a person manifests his heresy we judge using the infallbile judgements of the church he is a heretic plain and true. rot in hell heretic under your biblical curses. upon death all heretics descend immediately down into hell where they will curse under their curses for eternity as GATES OF HELL.
@gersoto since I am not the catholic magisterium. I do not teach. I profess my catholic faith always, everywhere and anathematize all the church in her perfect glory eternal divine majesty has ALWAYS EVERYWHERE ANATHEMATIZED UNDER PERPETUAL DIVINE CURSE OF BIBLICAL ANATHEMA. God is not mocked and all tht is happening has been fortold in the scriptures and by Tradition. Pope Paul IV spoke of the abomination of the desolation when he declared ex cathedra a hereitc can never be validly pope.
@gersoto it isnt my interpretation. the dogma has been defined infallbly in 2 stages you can not deny without being a non catholic heretic; 1. the dogma is the unanimous consent of all the church fathers/infallible tradition according to Denzingers, 2. it has been defined using papal infalliblitiy Pope Pius XI Casti Connubiss.
@gersoto the dogma non catholics having religous liberty is the smoke of satan has been defined 1. by the unanimous consent of all the church fathers/ infallible tradition according to Denzingers, 2. by papal infalliblity Pope Gregory XVI papal encyclical Mirari Vos. It is undeniable Roncalli is a satanic atni pope who taught heresy as de fide against this dogma Pope Paul IV ex Cathedra Cum ex and Pope Vigilus ex cathedra Council of Nicea.
@gersoto the dogma outside the church absolutely no salvation no remission of sins, all must be water baptised and be subjects of the roman Pontiffs is defined ex cathedra multiple times. the ex Cathedra sole dogmatic defeinition of the explicit sacramental unity of the church is defined ONE CHURCH, ONE FAITH ONE BAPTISM, THE SOLE FORM OF THE DIVINELY INSTITUTED SUBSTANCE IS REAL AND NATURAL WATER. THE CHURCH TAKES LIETERALLY THE GOSPEL UNLESS ONE IS BORN AGAIN OF WATER AND THE HOLY GHOST.
@gersoto you heretics are protest-ants. your new mass is invalid sacriligous blasphemy of satan and jews. it is spirit of anti christ who dissolveth Christ. the dogmatic canon has been defined ex Cathedra Council of Trent along with the dogmatic form of the consecration ex cathedra Council of Florence. de defectibus states ex cathedra to add or delete a single word is grave mortal sin. If you change the meaning of the words the entire sacrament is invalid.
@aburke673 is your own opinion as I said, you have no prophet or anything. The liturgy has not always been the same, but because of the abuses, that are not part of the Liturgy, Pope Benedict is making "the reform of the reform." The essence is not another, words change, they are not the same in latin and english many times, or are a little different in Revelations of different Bible versions. You may think more intelligent than the Popes and cardinals, but instead of repairing you condemn.
Yes, continue to follow Rome. We worship along side Muslims and Jews now. We are one with mother earth. We are one with Bhudda and the gods of witchcraft. It is wonderful that the windows of tolerance and understanding have opened in the Roman Catholic Church. Let us follow our beloved popes and sing praises along side the Jews and Muslims and all other religions. Then watch what happens as it did in Assisi Italy after the pope prayed with Hindus and Muslims and Jews.
Certainly, much has been said and the arguments have been refuted.
Sadly, these many, odd little sects of sedevacantists resemble the anatomy of of hydra-like creature whose tentacles may be withered by reasonable discourse and yet another new crop of tentacles crop right up to replace those which had been withered.
Many in these groups can only be moved by the Holy Spirit, they have cast their lots and come up short and still persist.
umm.. well i like the last 5 second ending.....
richr410 1 week ago
the first sentence in the second vatican council is a heresy
21scuderia 2 months ago
This authority is merely Patriarchal because ITS AUTHORITY IS TERRITORIALLY AND PERSONALLY LIMITED to only those who profess to be Novus Ordo Catholics. But wait Lutherans and Anglicans and Orthodox can legitimately be members of the body of Christ! Right? Why does he not have authority over THEM? Because, by definition, his authority is not the authority of the Roman Pontiff; the Roman Pontiff has Universal and SUPREME jurisdiction over the Church which is the mystical body of Christ.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
This NEW VATICAN ORGANIZATION is ONTOLOGICALLY DIFFERENT from the Traditional Catholic Church. Therefore, it cannot BE the Catholic Church. Therefore Its HEAD cannot be the Pope. The head of this Organization does not FUNCTION as a Pope, because he does NOT have jurisdiction over all its members! Insofar as Lumen Gentium and Gaudium et Spes and other documents admit to the Body of Christ Non-Catholic and heretical gruops and schismatics, the Pope has only a Patriarchal Authority.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
The reason for this is that Lumen Gentium REDEFINED the NATURE of the Church by sating that the Mystical body of Christ SUBSISTS IN the Catholic church. For one thing to exist within another is to be distinct from it, and implies that it may be larger than it. That is because ABSOLUTE EQUIVOCAL IDENTITY (Catholic Church IS the Mystical body of Christ.) is not maintained as it was by Pope Pius XII in Mystici Corporis Christi. THEREFORE, PAUL VI defined INTO EXISTENCE a NEW Vatican Organization.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
Now, let's think: Benny has called the Orthodox Churches particular and true churches. He has also called the Orthodox priests "True shepherds of the church of Christ." Okay, so he understands that the Orthodox are united to the Mystical body of Christ. But the POPE has JURISDICTION over ALL the visible members of the mystical body of Christ. Yet Benny has no jurisdiction over the Orthodox! Yet he calls them member sof the body of Christ! Therefore he is NOT aPope, not even in his own church!
aelwyn82 5 months ago 2
May God bring a swift end to the "Reign" of Fr. Ratzinger, and may he grant us a true and holy Pope. May Fr. Ratzinger Convert before his death and so avoid damnation for his manifest apostasy and heresy.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. There is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. There is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
Uh, it is evident that JPII was a manifest and notorious heretic. He called Greek Schismatics the other lung of the Church. Sorry, the Catholic Church is whole and entire IN HERSELF and has no need of such a calumny. Those who believe that the Orthodox churches are part of the church of Christ are heretics, for they deny the particular nature of the Catholic Church. The Mystical Body of Christ IS the Roman catholic Church. THere is no invisible extension of its boundaries.
aelwyn82 5 months ago
God bless Pope Benedict XVI
kpichett 7 months ago
If sedevacantism is correct then this would mean that all priests ordained since Vatican II are heretics and as a result, cannot perform the transubstantiation necessary for the real presence in the Eucharist. Would Jesus allow the world to be deprived of His precious body and blood? I cannot and will not accept sedevacantism as truth. I see this as a brazen attack on the church. What right do they have to call anybody an "antichrist" especially John Paul II?
angelamwatts 9 months ago
The maker of this video is himself a protestant heretic and schismatic. We dont protest Vatican 2. It is heretical schismatic and invalid. The Catholic Greek Byzantine rite Patriarch just excommunicated Ratzinger and the apostate Woytiwa who prayed to the devil in the meeting houses of heretics, pagans and Jews. He declared we are in a state of Sede Vacante.
stewartburchardjohn 9 months ago
@stewartburchardjohn Eat my novus ordo shorts!
elcamaras 9 months ago
Frankfurt Bavarian Iluminati was founded on May 1, 1776. This is the date of founding of all communist nations and the date of the Illuminati claiming to beatify the apostate Woytiwa brought to power by CIA and P2 lodge/operation GLADIO.
stewartburchardjohn 9 months ago
@aburke673 Pretty sure you don't get to decide what is heresy and who is condemned, dude. Anyway, cool story! Very convincing. I see my priest for my sins, not you. That is, my priest who possesses the authority handed down to him in an unbroken line from Jesus to Peter until this point and into the future. Not you.
TheHardout2005 9 months ago
@TheHardout2005 my wife Mrs John Stewart is correct. Only heretics would believe an apostate who goes into the meeting houses of jews, heretics and pagans to pray to the devil with them, is their pope. check out my channel on the excommunications of Ratzinger and Woytiwa by the Greek Byzantine rite Catholic Ukraine Patriarch.
stewartburchardjohn 9 months ago
@stewartburchardjohn Listen, I don't want to be your daddy, but your understanding of ecumenism is woeful. Why not check out Catholic vids, instead of sedevacantist vids?
TheHardout2005 9 months ago
@aburke673 I'm sorry. I didn't know I was dealing with an insane racist - as evidenced by the use of capital letters, overzealous listing, polar words, and language.
Do you know what heresy is? It is going against the teaching of Church. Thus the Church, by definition, cannot teach heresy, because She is what defines what heresy is. Thus it is illogical to conclude that Humanae VItae is heresy, as the Church teaches it. In fact, by being sedevacantist, you are living in heresy.
TheHardout2005 9 months ago
I have a video resposnse for you (SEDE VACANTE).If you have a point why don't you accept it? bcse the LIE is your v2 sect essence.
10WiseVirgins 9 months ago
@aburke673 Firstly: name-calling is polarising and unhelpful. Secondly, I've performed no heresy. Tradition begins somewhere, does it not? I am making no claim to creating that tradition myself. You might consider that recent publications by popes, such as Humanae Vitae and Fides et Ratio, or Pope Benedict's books, will form part of our Tradition in the years to come. Perhaps it is your understanding of what I meant that went amiss?
TheHardout2005 9 months ago
@aburke673
What heresy was taught under Pope Pius XII?
Everything I have heard about Pope Pius XII confirms that he was a holy man and a very good Pope - that his writings served to sure up the defenses and strengthen the bulwarks, so to speak.
It seems to me that his invaluable contribution was God's Divine providence for the Church, coming just before the cataclysm.
Please reply and say what you consider to be the heresy taught under Pope Pius XII.
Godbless.
sharbel23 9 months ago
Sedevacantism is not a strange position, remember that the Catholich Church has had many anti-popes through its history; if there's a time when this is most evident, it is today, we've never witnessed so many heresies as today.
garciadelacadena 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
/watch?v=UTzgaXV1w14
10WiseVirgins 10 months ago
/watch?v=UTzgaXV1w14
10WiseVirgins 10 months ago
Although no doubt Freemasons had infiltrated the Church to its highest levels before the invalid "Vatican II" Robber Council, the primary responsibility for the loss of faith that followed lies solely with the head-bobbing clueless sheep in the pews, along with a lax clergy and a hierarchy composed primarily of craven sycophants, whose primary concern was advancing their own careers. They paid homage to the APOSTATE Paul VI and his unworthy successors, as the speaker in this video confirms.
GasconyKid 10 months ago
your ordination is VOID, they REJECT CATHOLIC DOGMA.
Vatican II is a DEMONIC HERESY!
Instead of DEMANDING orthodoxy to be restored, you get the SEAL OF THE BEAST!!!!
woodyaan 1 year ago
If you acknowledge B16 as a pope, you should absolutely OBEY HIM!
Do you obey him when he worships demons of Muhammad and Buddah?
Heretics are EXCOMMUNICATED!
B16 is an APOSTATE, so are you, if you are in communion with heretics!
woodyaan 1 year ago
How do you cope with the Pope's joint prayer day with the muslims in Turkey and his acceptance of Talmudic Judaism (satanism?) as a valid way for salvation. As a recent convert to Catholicism myself, I have done ext research into the history of the Church and doctrine. Don't you find, as I did, the Vatican II council to be a complete, radical and herectical break from the entire teachings and actions of the Saints, Popes and Martyrs up to that Council?
thegreatfearblog 1 year ago
O YOU THAT SO EAGERLY CONDEM MY CHURCH, WILL SAY TO YOU CHRIST AT THE OUR OF JUDMENT: WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO BE PERFECT, SHOW ME WHAT YOU HAVE DONE FOR MY CHURCH. Did you instead pass your whole time to critisize her. Fool! Don't you know that he who critisize is loosing time to work? Satan the accusator, good of nothing. CATHOLIC CHURCH IS IN VATICAN AND ALL WHO SAYS OTHERWISE ARE HERESY PROPAGANDER, worth of Luther
TheSpiritualShow 1 year ago
Sedevacantism is a serious error, The Sedevacantists I have known are cult like closed minded people.
desertrat1111 1 year ago 2
Doing an assignment on "Christian Fundamentalism" at University as part of my theology degree. Basically Sedevacantism has the basic hallmarks of christian fundamentalism. They are a reactionary group to modernist liberalism, they are a small organised group who continue to condemn anybody who does not conform to their belief.
Basically they are a bunch of doomsday spooks who couldn't handle reform. Just pointing out that the dark ages were over 600 years ago dudes.
jodurproductions 1 year ago
@jodurproductions just because the times change, doesn't mean the Church does. Your comment about not living in the dark ages anymore is irrelevant.
TheSacredHeart2 11 months ago
1:41 such a good point
TheHardout2005 1 year ago
So Sedevantists think they're more Catholic than Catholics? wtf? Tradition doesn't just stop. We are continuing and creating it even now.
TheHardout2005 1 year ago
The Dimond Bro. do not represent Sedevecantist they are crazy and you need to look outside the youtube world to figure that out.
brazierdaddy 1 year ago
I do not believe in reform of the catholic church when it comes to many things. But I would not go beyond SSPX. They are not excommunicated anymore. Now Im not a member of SSPX, but I respect them. The best thing is of course to retake the Catholic Church from the followers of John XXIII. But this should be done from the inside of the church. Not creating this mad secteristic groups, like in USA. SSPX is a one of those groups that can change the Catholic back to its roots.
FreeDogdylan 1 year ago
elcamaras, all of you Vatican 2 sect supporters don't have the guts to debate the Dimond brothers. You are all cowards hiding behind a script
Faith3Faith 1 year ago
@Faith3Faith It's true; I'm afraid. I'm also afraid to debate L. Ron Hubbard, Benny Hinn, Benny Hana, Hare Krishnas, Jehovahs Witnesses & Mofmons. I'm afraid of wasting my time.
elcamaras 1 year ago 11
@Faith3Faith its funny how you rely on him to debate...
TheEcumenator 1 year ago
@Faith3Faith ^And the king of all nefarious sects has spoken.
So, how do you like belonging to the Protestant sect who believe that everything after Vatican II was false?
Stop being a Protestant already and come home to the True Faith and UNBROKEN AUTHORITY that is only found in the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Do it now ...
ChristianFirefighter 1 year ago
@Faith3Faith I'd happily respond to the Diamond Brothers! Good video.
fredflinstone1291029 1 year ago
@Faith3Faith Diamond Brothers. I have the tattoo of Diamond Brothers on my Dick. Want It.
eraser695 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
elcamaras, if you believe you have the TRUTH, then why don't you debate the Sedevacantist, brother Peter Dimond, one on one by phone and then upload that debate to YouTube ? Why are all of you V2 defenders so afraid of debating the Dimond brothers ?
HolyBeThyName 1 year ago
This video is another that is wrong from a katholick Novus Order know nothing who will not debate , Did the Gates of hell
win when the other anti popes sat ?
NO .....argument is thus moot .
SAYYOURROSARY 1 year ago
"This video is another that is wrong"
It's wrong to you because we are correct.
Stick to studying jet contrails.
mapollo 1 year ago
Sedevacantists should hear St. Paul: "And in all seduction of iniquity to them that perish; because they receive not the love of the truth, that they might be saved. Therefore God shall send them the operation of error, to believe lying (2 Thes 2:10)."
deliveringit 1 year ago
Good video!
SpanishWrangler 1 year ago
Sedevacantist is the new threath! IT IS WORST THAN THE PROTESTANTS HERESIES!!!!!! You are playing with fire Sedevacantinists!
SpanishWrangler 1 year ago
Our Lady of La Salette, Sept. 19 1846:"Rome will lose the Faith and become the seat ot the Anti-Christ...The Church will be in eclipse."
nicholasvonfluh 1 year ago
@nicholasvonfluh Sedevacantists = armchair bishops
elcamaras 1 year ago
Pope St Agatho III Council of Constantinople; "If any ecclesiastic or layman shall go into the synagogue of the Jews or the meeting houses of the heretics to join in prayers with them let them be deposed and deprived of communion."
StSimonMartyr 1 year ago
Vatican 2 was a Hijacking by Freemasons and Jews.
Several Archbishops and Cardinals forewarned the Attending Bishops of the plot in the book published prior to the council, called THE PLOT AGAINST THE CHURCH by Maurice Pinay, a pen name of the consortium of those clerics.
A must read for any Catholic.
Its free online as well.
Changing Christ's Own Words in the Canon, should be reason enough for anyone with a brain to sort out, its Invalid.
One cannot Change Christs words!
StSimonMartyr 1 year ago
@elcamaras just anothert lie of heretics. During the arian apostacy denying the divine incarnation of Christ, most bishops fell into the arian heresy after the Council of Nicea. Bishop saint Doctor Athanasius and saint doctor martyr Bishop Ecebuis all deposed arian bishops and consecrated catholic ones. there was no ordinary jurisdiction during this crisis only supplied jurisdiction. Saint Athanasius taught in his letter to his litte flock all heretics excommunicate themselves ipso facto
aburke673 9 months ago
@elcamaras heretics are ex cathedra the gates of hell. it is ex cathedra all heretics are self condemned after 2 warnings. If you understood the church which you dont, being a heretic, you would know a catholic can not obey both Pope Gregory XVI and Mirari Vos and the evil heretical anti Pope Roncalli in his anti catholic encyclical Pacem en Terris where he heretically claims non catholics have religious liberty.
aburke673 9 months ago
@nicholasvonfluh you clearly stated what place will lose the faith.
Is it Rome according to the vision or the Vatican? Remember Rome in the early church was faithless as well? Only the Church was there and the rest of the city itself was infested with pagans. Our Lady does not mention the Vatican or the Church.
Its also funny that Our Lady of Akita appeared after Vatican II, is her message a "modernist" message as well?
TheEcumenator 1 year ago
@TheEcumenator Our Lady just said Rome. As in the City. We are now seeing Italy let go of the Catholic Faith.
huntinggods 1 year ago
@huntinggods Pope saint Pius X and scriptures state anti christ will stand in the holy place of God the Catholic church. Mathew 24:15 makes this clear.
aburke673 9 months ago
@nicholasvonfluh you should see all the prophecies of Catholic Prophets, not just La Salette. Remember also that the Virgin of Fatima was protecting the Pope John Paul II when he got shot. Anyways, if you read the prophecies, there will be an antipope, not sede vacantism, and not a bunch of antipopes either.
gersoto 1 year ago
@gersoto you seek after false signs and revelations. with itching ears you deny catholic dogmas. try reading the bible heretic along with the divine magisterium
aburke673 9 months ago
@aburke673 what catholic dogmas am I denying?
gersoto 9 months ago
@gersoto you have followed anti pope Roncalli into heresy non catholics have relgious liberty. THEY DONT HAVE IT ONLY CATHOLICS HAVE IT/THE DIVINE INFALLIBLE RIGHT TO DEMAND FROM EVERY GOVERNMENT THE DIVINE RIGHT TO PRACTICE THE GOSPEL PRECEPTS TO FULL OVERFLOWING MEASURE. Pope Gregory XVI called non catholics having religious liberty smoke of satan. modernists morphed this heresy into implicit unconscious BOD without the catholic faith putting MAN'S PRIVATE CONSCIENCE IN THE HOLY PLACE OF GOD
aburke673 9 months ago
@aburke673 you may want to improve your way of teaching, I recommend you G.K.Chesterton or st. Francis de Sales, other than I am not protestant, I'm catholic, and I have liberty, however, if you hear the gospel and beleive one thing and not another, you don't beleive in the gospel but in yourself. When I said prophets I meant catholic prophets; from, for example "Catholic Prophecy" of Tan books.
gersoto 9 months ago
@gersoto I recommend you read the book an introduction to a devout life Saint Francis de Sales page 234-236 that states frustrating the primary end of marriage that is always procreation is always grave mortal sin heretic, and this dogma is taught by the unanimous consent of all the church fathers. I am sick of you arrogant heretics. GET OUT OF MY CATHOLIC BUILDINGS BEFORE WE HAVE A REDO OF THE MACCABEES
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto YOU STUPID ARROGANT HERETIC OF SATAN AND THE APOCALYPSE. NON CATHOLICS DONT HAVE RELIGOUS LIBERTY AND YOUR ANTI POPE RONCALLI HERETICALLY PROCALIMED THE DO HAVE IT. YOU CAN NOT OBEY BOTH POPE GREGORY XVI AND THE EVIL APOSTATE FREEMASON ANTI POPE SMOKE OF SATAN RONCALLI. YOU ARE A NON CATHOLIC YOU SATANIC FOOL SINCE YOU FOLLOWED ANTI POPE RONCALLI INTO HERESY AND ANTI CHRIST PAUL VI INTO APOSTACY AND ABOMINATION OF DESOLATION
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto You can not obey both Infallible Pope Gregory XVI papal encyclcical Mirari Vos and obey the anti pope Roncalli who claims as smoke of satan non catholics have religous liberty. You are on your way to hell heretic. wake up before you are in hell. Public warning number one. It is ex cathedra Pope Vigilus you will stand self condemned after 2 warnings and heretics are the gates of hell.
aburke673 9 months ago
@aburke673 condemning others to hell is not the way to teach, but the ones that can excommunicate for example, do it as the last resource. Who put you as our teacher to tell us that? Didn't God put the priests and bishops? (Acts 20:17-30) And you think you are more catholic than the Pope? like protestants, you interpret wrong what someone says to say as if they were in favor of you, but you have no prophets but your own interpreetation to tell if something is true.
gersoto 9 months ago
@gersoto THE CHURCH CONDEMNED YOU TO HELL BY PERPETUAL IRREFORMABLE SOLEMN BIBLICAL ANATHEMA. UPON DEATH ALL HERETICS WILL DESCEND INTO HELL UNDER PERPETUAL CURSE. You have to be catholic to be a bishop you stupid heretic. I dont interpret, Christ, the unanimous consent of all the church fathers from the apostles, safeguarded by papal infallbility in papal encylicals and lastly the sole ex cathedra dogmatic definition put you under your curses. you stand self condemned after 2 warnings
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto you twist the scriptures and the words of our holy popes. we do not judge with the judgements of men but when a person manifests his heresy we judge using the infallbile judgements of the church he is a heretic plain and true. rot in hell heretic under your biblical curses. upon death all heretics descend immediately down into hell where they will curse under their curses for eternity as GATES OF HELL.
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto since I am not the catholic magisterium. I do not teach. I profess my catholic faith always, everywhere and anathematize all the church in her perfect glory eternal divine majesty has ALWAYS EVERYWHERE ANATHEMATIZED UNDER PERPETUAL DIVINE CURSE OF BIBLICAL ANATHEMA. God is not mocked and all tht is happening has been fortold in the scriptures and by Tradition. Pope Paul IV spoke of the abomination of the desolation when he declared ex cathedra a hereitc can never be validly pope.
aburke673 9 months ago
@aburke673 I have been saying that your interpretation of the anathema is wrong, and sedevacantists have no prophet that can say is entirely right.
gersoto 9 months ago
@gersoto it isnt my interpretation. the dogma has been defined infallbly in 2 stages you can not deny without being a non catholic heretic; 1. the dogma is the unanimous consent of all the church fathers/infallible tradition according to Denzingers, 2. it has been defined using papal infalliblitiy Pope Pius XI Casti Connubiss.
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto the dogma non catholics having religous liberty is the smoke of satan has been defined 1. by the unanimous consent of all the church fathers/ infallible tradition according to Denzingers, 2. by papal infalliblity Pope Gregory XVI papal encyclical Mirari Vos. It is undeniable Roncalli is a satanic atni pope who taught heresy as de fide against this dogma Pope Paul IV ex Cathedra Cum ex and Pope Vigilus ex cathedra Council of Nicea.
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto the dogma outside the church absolutely no salvation no remission of sins, all must be water baptised and be subjects of the roman Pontiffs is defined ex cathedra multiple times. the ex Cathedra sole dogmatic defeinition of the explicit sacramental unity of the church is defined ONE CHURCH, ONE FAITH ONE BAPTISM, THE SOLE FORM OF THE DIVINELY INSTITUTED SUBSTANCE IS REAL AND NATURAL WATER. THE CHURCH TAKES LIETERALLY THE GOSPEL UNLESS ONE IS BORN AGAIN OF WATER AND THE HOLY GHOST.
aburke673 9 months ago
@gersoto you heretics are protest-ants. your new mass is invalid sacriligous blasphemy of satan and jews. it is spirit of anti christ who dissolveth Christ. the dogmatic canon has been defined ex Cathedra Council of Trent along with the dogmatic form of the consecration ex cathedra Council of Florence. de defectibus states ex cathedra to add or delete a single word is grave mortal sin. If you change the meaning of the words the entire sacrament is invalid.
aburke673 9 months ago
@aburke673 is your own opinion as I said, you have no prophet or anything. The liturgy has not always been the same, but because of the abuses, that are not part of the Liturgy, Pope Benedict is making "the reform of the reform." The essence is not another, words change, they are not the same in latin and english many times, or are a little different in Revelations of different Bible versions. You may think more intelligent than the Popes and cardinals, but instead of repairing you condemn.
gersoto 9 months ago
Yes, continue to follow Rome. We worship along side Muslims and Jews now. We are one with mother earth. We are one with Bhudda and the gods of witchcraft. It is wonderful that the windows of tolerance and understanding have opened in the Roman Catholic Church. Let us follow our beloved popes and sing praises along side the Jews and Muslims and all other religions. Then watch what happens as it did in Assisi Italy after the pope prayed with Hindus and Muslims and Jews.
robertiacomacci 1 year ago
Great comeback how long did it take you to think of that?
nicholasvonfluh 1 year ago
@nicholasvonfluh 3.5 hours
elcamaras 1 year ago
Comment removed
robertiacomacci 1 year ago
ha ha ha ahahahahahahaha!
SpanishWrangler 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing the truth
Fantastic video 5/5
God bless
katdanmo 1 year ago
great video thank you for sharing...GBU
TheVeiledCatholic 1 year ago
@elcamaras,
Thank you for this video.
Certainly, much has been said and the arguments have been refuted.
Sadly, these many, odd little sects of sedevacantists resemble the anatomy of of hydra-like creature whose tentacles may be withered by reasonable discourse and yet another new crop of tentacles crop right up to replace those which had been withered.
Many in these groups can only be moved by the Holy Spirit, they have cast their lots and come up short and still persist.
Time to move along.
ProdigalSonship 1 year ago