Emperor: Wait! You are picking me up. I don't want to be picked up. I want to zap Luke.
Luke: Yes. Darth Vader, my father, is a good guy now. I sense that he has let go of the hate.
Emperor: Put me down now Darth. No not in the pit! I didn't mean to put me in the pit. Let me just make that abundantly clear. I wasn't setting up a gag. (as he falls into the pit) I wanted to keep zapping Luuukkkeee!!!!
People just stop it. Lucas own these movies and can do whatever the hell he wants with them. Do I agree with all the changes he's made? No, but I can either bitch about it knowing it will change nothing or just go with the flow and see where it goes.
@merrimac291 He didn't say it that loud until he actually grabbed the Emporer, and honestly he was too focused on killing Luke to even notice, so he actually probably wouldn't have been able to predict his death
You know what? All of the Star Wars fans who claim they're "true" fans are being SO melodramatic, I find it amusing. I'm not too big on these alterations, but I don't waste my breath complaining about them, and how George Lucas "raped" my childhood when he really didn't.
The " NOOOOOOOOOOOO " in ROTJ is an echo of the other unpopular " NOOOOOOOOOOO " from Episode III as Anakin dies and becomes Vader because he killed Padme. Vader see's in his tortured son Shmee & Padme. We know that Anakin's pain from his failure's to save his Mother and his wife explode inside him. Finally Anakin screams free of the Emperor's Vader cage & saves his son.
honestly, i love the fact that George Lucas did this. it's extremely stupid, but so entertaining how terrible it is. i mean, it's not like there's any going back with these original trilogy re-releases. i just love laughing at his bad decisions. vader yelling NOOOOO will go down in history.
Guys, stop hating on George Lucas. Everyone knows the new editions of Star Wars is meant for comedy. Therefore, they have decided to make the movies a comedy. Respect George!
Why is everyone so pissed off? It's not like they didn't already piss all over Vaders image by showing him to be a little bitch with a short temper.
The beauty of this scene was the sudden redemption out of nowhere. Where you realise that he is infact human and not a machine like Obi Wan says. The slow, silent and calm destruction of everything you thought you knew about him no longer worked anyway because you know what and who is inside. The same bitch only with no limbs.
I'm watching the saga box set now and I had to take a break in the middle of episode 1 the fucking jar jar I mean phantom menace. I can tolerate the nooooo more than I can this jar jar stuff. Starwars should have been darker.
Also you people calling Lucas a loser dumb shit.... Yeah that ought a teach that 3.5 billionaire a lesson. Bet his quality of life was shaken when you refused to spend $90
I actually like it. It helps make the older films suck as much as the prequels. I just hope when Hayden Christensen gets older, they will digitally replace the other actor with Hayden when Luke takes Vader's helmet off. Then the films will be perfect. Also they need to replace the puppet Yoda with CGI version. Actually, Lucas should just re-film the entire original trilogy.
@jayce79 I still think the first one is better. Short, darker and deeper. Enough to clarify that he stopped being Darth and decided to turn back to the light. The second is like the one at the end of Episode III and it's pretty girly.
Actually the first one makes it so bad. The second if it was not as loud and under the breath might actually work. But as it is now, there both pretty shitty.
And now I'm going to watch good old Star Wars in original version without any shitty cumputer effects, without any new shitty actors on my VHS, the only good version. This scene, most important scene is now unwatchable!
Why? George I'm fu*king asking you why did you do that? With every newer version good old Star Wars are becoming crap. What next? Will you change great special effect which are bilion times better than in New trilogy into computer effects? You have lost your mind old guy, you should have go for retirement 15 years ago.
to actually see the original version without all these little new ads...
But then again the "oldschool" Star Wars fans have whined ever since Episode I and Jar Jar Binks and they propably never stop whining...and yes, I do understand why they whine about the new trilogy and about the little changes made to original trilogy, but in the end Star Wars is Lucas's own creating, he can do whatever the hell he likes with it....even if that means that he will piss of the "hard-core" fans in the process
@VenomShock Heh, you know that Star Wars fans are VERY sensitive to these kind of changes...altough I dont understand how this "NO!" thing is the end of the world for them, I have to agree that it was unnecessary or at least they should have done it better.
@Balnazzardi Oh for sure. IT's weird that George Lucas would go "I have to go back and add this to better the film!" it is really unecessary and one of the weirdest changes you could make to a film....
But yeah, I don't think it makes the scene any worse.
@VenomShock Ye, I agree with you on that....but there were fans who were mad about the original "NOOO!" from Episode III,and even I have to admit that scream sounded more like comical to me, something that just didnt suited in that moment and for Vader...for many people it ruined the moment..and I think that now many people feel like Lucas wanted to piss them off een more on purpose by adding this "NOOO! on here as well....no offense to SW fans, but I actually find that though quite hilarious xD
@VenomShock I actually remember how some of my class mates were talking about it right after they had seen the movie, and said that there was seriously something wrong in that, since some people actually bursted laughing in theater when they heard Vader screaming....
But overall I feel that Star Wars fans just whine too much about every bit of change that have been made to the movies over the years..sure this is not the best way to treat the fans, especially since there is no option in Blu-ray
The first SE in 97: GREAT! I do miss the older stuff, but the new music for Jabba's band works. The ending showing how all over the galaxy celebrates when the empire's defeated, quite interesting: Shows what a few people did as they lived their stories. It still kept shaw as Anakin and the music was SPLENDID!
DVD: Ruined: Hayden replacing Shaw as Anakin just ruined it. I get what Lucas was driving at but he would still age.
BLURAY: DESTROYED!!! Just this "NO" destroys it all.
lucas made starwars and as far as I'm concerned he has every right to make changes to it and i have actually liked most of the changes hes made and find them to improve the films. people get to hung up on little stuff like this noooo thing etc.if you don't like change you can always watch the 100% unchanged dvd version and then you will have nothing to cry about.
now i shall brace for the hater comments so "let the hate flow through you" and begin your angry typing now
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO .... its chuck testa :) .... no but seriously guys it is just a "NO" ... your childhood memories wouldnt change just for adding a : "NO" cmon dont be stupid
I don't see why people hate this it's just no , if you saw you're son getting fu$&ed up you'll won't say anything wow people now in days get a life !!
wow, thanks George Lucas... I was wondering why Darth did what he did in this scene... I wouldn't have understood what was going on in his head without the "NOOOOO!!!" dialogue...
You have no sense of subtlety and are perfectly happy to let Lucas stick his fat finger down in your ass-wallet. If anyone should shut up, it is you, you simpleton.
Congratulations George, you just ruined an epic and cathartic climax to the entire series. Thank god i don't have this version, even the 2004 Special Edition is better than this.
I don't know what the fuss is about. I mean, George Lucas is only trashing and dumbing down the climatic scene of the finale of the series, and making one of the greatest movie characters sound idiot in the moment of his redemption. So what? Let the man have some fun in his old age trolling the fans of his movies a little bit.
I wouldn't be surprised if some time later Lucas decides to add another NOOOOO in Empire Strikes Back when Luke let himself fall down just after Vader offered to have him join the dark side. Like this...Luke: -Lets himself drop down- and then Vader: NOOOOOOOOOO!!! o.o Maybe I shouldn't give him ideas.
It was more suspenful when Darth Vader never said anything as he watched how the Emperor tortured Luke. You didn't know whether he was going to save him or not. Now with the NOOOOOOOOO it's like...well there goes the suspense. It just makes it boring and predictable.
It was more suspenful when Darth Vader never said anything as he watched how the Emperor tortured Luke. You didn't know whether he was going to save him or not. Now with the NOOOOOOOOO it's like...well there goes the suspense. It just makes it boring and predictable.
i have to say, when i heard all the whining about it i thought it was going to be like him shouting NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! while carrying him and throwing him down the shaft, and i would have been mad..........but this?.........people are retarded sometimes.........
Hmmm. It's not too bad. But in my opinion the original scene was so good because he didn't need to say anything. Even you couldn't see his face you could sense the struggle going on inside himself. A triumph of how it was filmed combined with the amazing music. Adding the "no...noooo!" now kind of feels like they're dumbing it down, as if we can't already tell what Darth is thinking.
And it aint so bad ! Cheer up guys! Il give it 5 years! By that time Lucas will release again the Bluray version with more extras included the unaltered version in 1080p
Dear George, you're a fat fuck and everything decent you ever made was basically done by other people. Stop raping their hard work with your untalented childlike brain.
Ah, I get it. His first and last words are "NOOOO". It rhymes, it's... it's like poetry. OR Why isn't Palpatine like "You got something to say?!" when Vader goes "No".
0:27 Was when george lucas came up to james earl jones with a mic and asked him to do the lines 0:31 was when lucas smashed his door in demanding he do it.
not one,.... but TWO of the most RETARDED, imbecilic things a character could say on film. And not only does he say it in a whiney, fool kind of way, but it completely turns Vader into a little bitch in ALL 6 EPISODES. Wow. whoever owns these blu rays knowing of the edits is a GODAMM FOOL.
This is completely unnecessary, it's like: "C'mon guys, it's blu-ray! We have to make something new." Why not just go all the way and put a brief flashback of Padmé's face right before the first "No"?
I hear in the *next* incarnation of JEDI that the Emperor is going to be taking hits off a huge Bothan skull bong that will be digitally inserted next to his throne. And that Leia will go topless and sport a wicked tramp stamp.
do you guys realize something, mark zuckerberg is doing the same thing. Man i swear if we find you george lucas is his real father, it wouldnt be too surprising !
What made this scene so powerful was Darth Vader being the silent protagonist. But since George Lucas developed the reverse Midas touch, where everything he touches turns to shit, he decided to ruin it.
Huge star wars fan, don't like that Lucas changes his movies, but let's face it. I'm 23 and the version I grew up with isn't the same as the original. The VHS version had changes, the VHS special addition had more changes, and the DVD had even more. It's Lucas stupid genus plot to get every spare penny out of his fan boys. He's going to keep changing it and people will keep buying it. O well... I'm going to go watch star trek
Guys its lucas's movies he can do what he wants.personally i dont think its to bad it aint great either if you dont like it dont buy it and watch the terrible quality on vhs
@dhiz92 are they really HIS movies, or do they ALSO become a part of culture and history at some point? After 30+ years of undending support, the fans and history deserve a release of the ORIGINAL, UNTAINTED versions.
UGH. Why?!? George Lucas, how could you be so stupid...
There is no way in heck I'm buying these, and I hope hardly anybody does. I hope this whole scheme fails horribly and the backlash finally hits this guy in the head hard enough that he realizes what he's doing! Release the FRICKIN' originals properly on Blu-Ray. He'd sell way more.
@robynbirde A friend of mine thinks that that's just what he'll do... twenty or so years down the line, either before he dies, or when almost no-one's watching it anymore, for one last surge of sales.
Lucas keeps wanting to change the original trilogy to match the new one, when instead he should be changing the new trilogy to match the original.
Think about it, the new trilogy used a lot of CGI and green screens, so it would be easier to edit...
TheParanormal 3 months ago
Lets get ahead of the game here.
Darth Vader: No. NOOO!!!!
Emperor: Wait! You are picking me up. I don't want to be picked up. I want to zap Luke.
Luke: Yes. Darth Vader, my father, is a good guy now. I sense that he has let go of the hate.
Emperor: Put me down now Darth. No not in the pit! I didn't mean to put me in the pit. Let me just make that abundantly clear. I wasn't setting up a gag. (as he falls into the pit) I wanted to keep zapping Luuukkkeee!!!!
groupthinker1984 3 months ago
I actually prefer this with him saying NO rather than saying nothing and grabbing the emperor.
Plus George Lucas can do what he wants with the movies. Its his movies. If you want original just go watch it on VHS.
Gurimmjaw 3 months ago
i've heard this was the in the original but was edited out before its original release.
Cobracatcommander 3 months ago
People just stop it. Lucas own these movies and can do whatever the hell he wants with them. Do I agree with all the changes he's made? No, but I can either bitch about it knowing it will change nothing or just go with the flow and see where it goes.
Something for you to keep in your back pocket.
extremechampion00 4 months ago
You know Lucas, a little subtlety goes a long way. The scene was more powerful without Vader dialogue. Just sayin'.
NYG4LIFE123 4 months ago
NOOOOOO
fuck off george
skipunkrich 4 months ago
Now to find the original unedited version on VHS.
HLM190586 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LOL. Star Wars geeks that bought this SHIT should be ashamed of themselves.
LukeLovesRose 4 months ago
I lol'd at first "No" . Sounds like Emperor asks him "Hey, wanna try?"
Knightley5 4 months ago
Great video.
Cococrash11 4 months ago
*watch it on youtube* that is probably a joke *watch it on Blu-Ray* NOOOOOOO
matrixfan127 4 months ago
you'd expect the emperor to get suspicious when he hears "No".
merrimac291 4 months ago 7
@merrimac291 He didn't say it that loud until he actually grabbed the Emporer, and honestly he was too focused on killing Luke to even notice, so he actually probably wouldn't have been able to predict his death
havwulfkikboot 3 months ago
george lucas stop fucking with my childhood
BritishGamingNews 4 months ago
WHY!????????!?!?!?!?!? WHYYYYYYYY!?!?!?!?
bellatheliar 4 months ago
@SithLord666HD Tool!
MrPrice2U 4 months ago
Crap!
bmgsantos 4 months ago
watch?v=jTF8I8cHTqQ
kr1z23 4 months ago
You know what? All of the Star Wars fans who claim they're "true" fans are being SO melodramatic, I find it amusing. I'm not too big on these alterations, but I don't waste my breath complaining about them, and how George Lucas "raped" my childhood when he really didn't.
darthvalor07 4 months ago
why is this thumbs downed so much, i dont get it
kennykiller911 4 months ago
@kennykiller911
probably because it's one of the biggest embarrassments in cinematic history. i just don't understand Mr. Lucas...
Heliosphan15 4 months ago
Why can't Lucas fix the real problem..... the prequels
TheCrackerStacker 4 months ago
Vaders silent decision was more powerful.
1Beaker2 4 months ago
The " NOOOOOOOOOOOO " in ROTJ is an echo of the other unpopular " NOOOOOOOOOOO " from Episode III as Anakin dies and becomes Vader because he killed Padme. Vader see's in his tortured son Shmee & Padme. We know that Anakin's pain from his failure's to save his Mother and his wife explode inside him. Finally Anakin screams free of the Emperor's Vader cage & saves his son.
DippersandSmiles 4 months ago
WIN!! que bacan ahora
ADoGhOsT18 4 months ago
EPIC FAIL!
Ferret0418 4 months ago
Do I like this change? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
EssuSHI 4 months ago
It's amazing how such a short two-lettered word can piss off so many people.
wiimannoob 4 months ago
@wiimannoob
honestly, i love the fact that George Lucas did this. it's extremely stupid, but so entertaining how terrible it is. i mean, it's not like there's any going back with these original trilogy re-releases. i just love laughing at his bad decisions. vader yelling NOOOOO will go down in history.
Heliosphan15 4 months ago
Guys, stop hating on George Lucas. Everyone knows the new editions of Star Wars is meant for comedy. Therefore, they have decided to make the movies a comedy. Respect George!
Sincerelydamike 4 months ago
I don't want to live on this planet anymore.
PeanutCupProductions 4 months ago
I LIKE IT SO MUCH
PADAWAN688 4 months ago
"Know" what?
Darkwolf198821 4 months ago
Why is everyone so pissed off? It's not like they didn't already piss all over Vaders image by showing him to be a little bitch with a short temper.
The beauty of this scene was the sudden redemption out of nowhere. Where you realise that he is infact human and not a machine like Obi Wan says. The slow, silent and calm destruction of everything you thought you knew about him no longer worked anyway because you know what and who is inside. The same bitch only with no limbs.
darthkahn45 4 months ago
My reaction when I found out Mass Effect 3 had multiplayer, and what I wish to do to Bioware.
zxFearOfFallingxz 4 months ago
I'm watching the saga box set now and I had to take a break in the middle of episode 1 the fucking jar jar I mean phantom menace. I can tolerate the nooooo more than I can this jar jar stuff. Starwars should have been darker.
Also you people calling Lucas a loser dumb shit.... Yeah that ought a teach that 3.5 billionaire a lesson. Bet his quality of life was shaken when you refused to spend $90
Labzo441 4 months ago
One of the most dramatic , beautiful moments in cinema history ruined :(
sixfouimpala 4 months ago
No... Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
Wiliraughshai 4 months ago
What a disgrace. Cant believe what a fucking idiot George Lucas turned out to be. Loser!!!
TonyRod7 4 months ago
I have one thing to say to you, George Lucas: NO!
OctavioJames300 4 months ago
I actually like it. It helps make the older films suck as much as the prequels. I just hope when Hayden Christensen gets older, they will digitally replace the other actor with Hayden when Luke takes Vader's helmet off. Then the films will be perfect. Also they need to replace the puppet Yoda with CGI version. Actually, Lucas should just re-film the entire original trilogy.
Tikidew 5 months ago
@jayce79 I still think the first one is better. Short, darker and deeper. Enough to clarify that he stopped being Darth and decided to turn back to the light. The second is like the one at the end of Episode III and it's pretty girly.
Lorinion 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is that a red lightsaber under the view count, or are people just really really pissed?
LordMortis315 5 months ago
I can accept the first "No". The second one sounds like a joke.
Lorinion 5 months ago
@Lorinion
Actually the first one makes it so bad. The second if it was not as loud and under the breath might actually work. But as it is now, there both pretty shitty.
jayce79 5 months ago
Lucas: I'm the creator of the franchise. I can do whatever I want.
Vader: You are a greedy fool and a traitor! Take him away!
Jakeeey92 5 months ago 10
@Jakeeey92 Even better:
Lucas: Yo stevie, I've got a whole lot of crazy ideas for this year's Indian Jones special editions! Get ur ass over to Industrial Light & Magic!
Spielberg: But.. but... you said we'd leave Indy as it is! We had a deal! The fans had a deal!
L: I am altering the deal. Pray I don't alter it any further!
S: George Lucas... prepare to meet Kali... in HELL!
And so Steve ripped Lucas' heart out, threw him into a river of crocodiles, and the fans lived happily ever after.
neosoc 5 months ago
George Lucas is continuing to shit on his once legendary franchise?
NO.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!
0djin 5 months ago
HAHA i own the tapes! but i must admit, the first no was okay, but the second sucked.
PSNSMANIACALMIND1st 5 months ago
And now I'm going to watch good old Star Wars in original version without any shitty cumputer effects, without any new shitty actors on my VHS, the only good version. This scene, most important scene is now unwatchable!
Dulk9 5 months ago
Why? George I'm fu*king asking you why did you do that? With every newer version good old Star Wars are becoming crap. What next? Will you change great special effect which are bilion times better than in New trilogy into computer effects? You have lost your mind old guy, you should have go for retirement 15 years ago.
Dulk9 5 months ago
to actually see the original version without all these little new ads...
But then again the "oldschool" Star Wars fans have whined ever since Episode I and Jar Jar Binks and they propably never stop whining...and yes, I do understand why they whine about the new trilogy and about the little changes made to original trilogy, but in the end Star Wars is Lucas's own creating, he can do whatever the hell he likes with it....even if that means that he will piss of the "hard-core" fans in the process
Balnazzardi 5 months ago
Why is George Lucas doing things like that?! :O
Lincoln2000 5 months ago
Yeah, I don't understand the hatred for this.
VenomShock 5 months ago
@VenomShock Heh, you know that Star Wars fans are VERY sensitive to these kind of changes...altough I dont understand how this "NO!" thing is the end of the world for them, I have to agree that it was unnecessary or at least they should have done it better.
Balnazzardi 5 months ago
@Balnazzardi Oh for sure. IT's weird that George Lucas would go "I have to go back and add this to better the film!" it is really unecessary and one of the weirdest changes you could make to a film....
But yeah, I don't think it makes the scene any worse.
VenomShock 5 months ago
@VenomShock Ye, I agree with you on that....but there were fans who were mad about the original "NOOO!" from Episode III,and even I have to admit that scream sounded more like comical to me, something that just didnt suited in that moment and for Vader...for many people it ruined the moment..and I think that now many people feel like Lucas wanted to piss them off een more on purpose by adding this "NOOO! on here as well....no offense to SW fans, but I actually find that though quite hilarious xD
Balnazzardi 5 months ago
@Balnazzardi I had never thought about the original "No" until years later when people were getting angry about it, I always loved that bit.
But yeah, I think the idea of that is pretty freakin' hilarious. "I'll give you something you bitch about, you whiny little bastards!"
VenomShock 5 months ago
@VenomShock I actually remember how some of my class mates were talking about it right after they had seen the movie, and said that there was seriously something wrong in that, since some people actually bursted laughing in theater when they heard Vader screaming....
But overall I feel that Star Wars fans just whine too much about every bit of change that have been made to the movies over the years..sure this is not the best way to treat the fans, especially since there is no option in Blu-ray
Balnazzardi 5 months ago
Oh that is so dumb.
CathannahShowani 5 months ago
WHEN REBECCA BLACK IS THE NEXT FOLLOW UP VIDEO, YOU KNOW YOU'VE HIT ROCK BOTTOM. Star Wars is now a retarded mess and a joke. Congratulations Lucas.
John1386788 5 months ago
I don't get it. What's so god-awful about adding 'no' into a scene? o.o
P0int13lank138 5 months ago
Oh my god WHY!?
The first SE in 97: GREAT! I do miss the older stuff, but the new music for Jabba's band works. The ending showing how all over the galaxy celebrates when the empire's defeated, quite interesting: Shows what a few people did as they lived their stories. It still kept shaw as Anakin and the music was SPLENDID!
DVD: Ruined: Hayden replacing Shaw as Anakin just ruined it. I get what Lucas was driving at but he would still age.
BLURAY: DESTROYED!!! Just this "NO" destroys it all.
Aussieroth7 5 months ago
lucas made starwars and as far as I'm concerned he has every right to make changes to it and FUCK IT ALL UP. lol.
Sentidocomuncabron 5 months ago
The dislike bar looks like Vader's lightsaber... right?
DannyLaam 5 months ago
That's like painting a big stupid clown nose on the Mona Lisa.
kr1z23 5 months ago
lucas made starwars and as far as I'm concerned he has every right to make changes to it and i have actually liked most of the changes hes made and find them to improve the films. people get to hung up on little stuff like this noooo thing etc.if you don't like change you can always watch the 100% unchanged dvd version and then you will have nothing to cry about.
now i shall brace for the hater comments so "let the hate flow through you" and begin your angry typing now
onesickbastard 5 months ago
Why does George Lucas keep shitting on himself?
bumfree 5 months ago 2
Does he say Noooo incase anyone mistook his throwing his master to his death for a wookie handshake?
SteveJS1985 5 months ago
good thing i still have the dvd version
cinemalego 5 months ago
@cinemalego actually i only have the original unaltered versions..... on 1995 THX VHS edition lol
elcap22 5 months ago
why the hell would anybody buy this
deathlaser3000 5 months ago
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO .... its chuck testa :) .... no but seriously guys it is just a "NO" ... your childhood memories wouldnt change just for adding a : "NO" cmon dont be stupid
ifunny05 5 months ago
LUCAS, YOU'RE A HACK. GOODBYE.
Sentidocomuncabron 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
it does not matter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wtckcs 5 months ago
I don't see why people hate this it's just no , if you saw you're son getting fu$&ed up you'll won't say anything wow people now in days get a life !!
QsKxNaTiioN 5 months ago
In honor of George Lucas and the new blue ray release I am making a new episode of my web series about fanfic.
ATfanfic 5 months ago
rape my childhood why don't ya lucas?
KillingJoke43 5 months ago
Comment removed
KillingJoke43 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lucas... YOU ARE FUCKING IDIOT!!!!
tajniak4 5 months ago
George Lucas created 984 Youtube accounts.
hcox 5 months ago 40
This has been flagged as spam show
@hcox "George Lucas created 984 Youtube accounts."
Now it's 992
993
994
99...
Darkwolf198821 4 months ago
Could've been worse though
Labzo441 5 months ago
hate me if you want but i really dont mind this scene. i have the blu ray and this doesnt bother me.
Whatsyournumber1404 5 months ago
Yes, just what the fans need, Lucas: a reminder of one of the stupidest moments of the stupid prequels.
neosoc 5 months ago 2
wow, thanks George Lucas... I was wondering why Darth did what he did in this scene... I wouldn't have understood what was going on in his head without the "NOOOOO!!!" dialogue...
h2opolodan11 5 months ago 3
George Lucas...you fucking cunt.
RandomoVideos 5 months ago 8
What's REALLY sad is that ALL of these new changes are now CANON to the Star Wars universe.
comicbookfannumber1 5 months ago
NOT MY SON YOU BITCH!!!!
littlesurfdude 5 months ago 23
@littlesurfdude lol
FishOnTheFishscale 5 months ago
Jesus, why Hates everybody this Second No? This is the most waynest Scene EVER!!!, Shut up, and be happy, that Star Wars is now on Blu Ray!
HyperKnoedelDoedel 5 months ago
@HyperKnoedelDoedel
You have no sense of subtlety and are perfectly happy to let Lucas stick his fat finger down in your ass-wallet. If anyone should shut up, it is you, you simpleton.
EyeoftheU 5 months ago
@EyeoftheU
GIT YOUR HAND OUTTA MY ASS-WALLET
Heliosphan15 5 months ago
Where were you the day the war began?
NovembersTerra 5 months ago in playlist Stuff Phil Likes: Thursday Sep 1st, 2011
I CAN'T STOP LAUGHING.
CountryBredJedi 5 months ago
MUST KILL GEORGE LUCAS!!!!!
jp3813 5 months ago 2
i've buying the t-shirt of this on redbubble! lool search: DARTH VADER SAYS NOOOO! on redbubble xD
Alan919 5 months ago
Gandalf
yakudza1988 5 months ago
OMG that is horrible wtf.... i thought greedo shooting fist was bad enough but this is complete trash...... WHY GEORGE LUCAS WHAT ARE YOU DOING.
MDagrosa 5 months ago
i really dont know why people are butt hurt bout this, i barily noticed a difference
TheStaticIce 5 months ago
Wait, is this a new edition to the movie?
isetmfriendsofire 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why do people hate that so much?
isetmfriendsofire 5 months ago
Should you buy this? Noooooooooooo!
oppositeofdeath 5 months ago
Congratulations George, you just ruined an epic and cathartic climax to the entire series. Thank god i don't have this version, even the 2004 Special Edition is better than this.
Colbystrns 5 months ago
VHS Only man.. FUCK HD
LewisJones28 5 months ago 4
I don't know what the fuss is about. I mean, George Lucas is only trashing and dumbing down the climatic scene of the finale of the series, and making one of the greatest movie characters sound idiot in the moment of his redemption. So what? Let the man have some fun in his old age trolling the fans of his movies a little bit.
Grissha 5 months ago
Let's see what Plinkett has to say, eh?
darkjj25 5 months ago
Comment removed
ledawg1138 5 months ago
Yeah i prefer vader as the strong / silent type
gmcq27 5 months ago
WTF SUCH BULL SHIT I CALLED THIS!! I SAID THEY WOULD CHANGE SOMETHING THAT'S WHY I DIDN'T BUY THIS!!! not to go in an all caps rage thow
EllDudeRocks 5 months ago
Mark Zuckerberg and George Lucas have a little competition going on...who can make the most changes
rifer7794 5 months ago 5
I wouldn't be surprised if some time later Lucas decides to add another NOOOOO in Empire Strikes Back when Luke let himself fall down just after Vader offered to have him join the dark side. Like this...Luke: -Lets himself drop down- and then Vader: NOOOOOOOOOO!!! o.o Maybe I shouldn't give him ideas.
MissLadyL09 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It was more suspenful when Darth Vader never said anything as he watched how the Emperor tortured Luke. You didn't know whether he was going to save him or not. Now with the NOOOOOOOOO it's like...well there goes the suspense. It just makes it boring and predictable.
MissLadyL09 5 months ago
It was more suspenful when Darth Vader never said anything as he watched how the Emperor tortured Luke. You didn't know whether he was going to save him or not. Now with the NOOOOOOOOO it's like...well there goes the suspense. It just makes it boring and predictable.
MissLadyL09 5 months ago
i have to say, when i heard all the whining about it i thought it was going to be like him shouting NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! while carrying him and throwing him down the shaft, and i would have been mad..........but this?.........people are retarded sometimes.........
Johnnyboy4678 5 months ago
You guys are such babies.
rpsmith014 5 months ago
Hmmm. It's not too bad. But in my opinion the original scene was so good because he didn't need to say anything. Even you couldn't see his face you could sense the struggle going on inside himself. A triumph of how it was filmed combined with the amazing music. Adding the "no...noooo!" now kind of feels like they're dumbing it down, as if we can't already tell what Darth is thinking.
jpdoctor117 5 months ago 2
does it really matter?
wtckcs 5 months ago
@wtckcs Yes. YESSS!!!
ledawg1138 5 months ago
noooo
Stairmaster9068 5 months ago
Wow. I canNOT believe ALL THIS FUSS is because of THAT. Unreal.
Computer? Check!
TV? Check!
Internet? Check!
Life?.........................
ceomyers 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ceomyers Commenting on this video? Check!
squamish4244 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That wasn't as bad as i thought it was going to be.
MrA88buckshot 5 months ago
Mr Lucas, will you release the original unaltered trilogy on Blu-Ray?
Lucas: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ashworth6 5 months ago in playlist Star Wars Blu-ray
he's saying NOOO to you george lucas leave those films alone
Han solo shot first
FierceMundy 5 months ago
HEY!!! guys stop trolling this makes it more powerful which vader cares about his son it is a great change
MarioLuigi117 5 months ago
And it aint so bad ! Cheer up guys! Il give it 5 years! By that time Lucas will release again the Bluray version with more extras included the unaltered version in 1080p
Tim38004 5 months ago
This makes perfect sense! He was timing his atack move!
Now???
Now!!!
Tim38004 5 months ago
Dear George, you're a fat fuck and everything decent you ever made was basically done by other people. Stop raping their hard work with your untalented childlike brain.
Mikedagraaff 5 months ago
That's different...
And doesn't work, keep it as it was
jaffamaster 5 months ago
HOW THE FUCK COULD YOU DO THIS LUCAS, YOU BASTARD
megamuffin15 5 months ago
Ah, I get it. His first and last words are "NOOOO". It rhymes, it's... it's like poetry. OR Why isn't Palpatine like "You got something to say?!" when Vader goes "No".
IllusiveSheen 5 months ago
I hope in the hungarian dubbing, this will be missing.
bbenjoe 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pathetic. i just can't believe it. :((((((
zenmonkey666 5 months ago
i think people overreact... it's not that bad. The second "no" last literally three seconds. Get over yourselves...
xsonicx08 5 months ago
@xsonicx08 Yes, but it is enough to suck out all the tension in one of the greatest scenes of star wars
Lundiez 5 months ago
@Lundiez nope. just people overreacting.
xsonicx08 5 months ago
Lucas has taken my childhood dreams and shit on it and forced me too eat it again followed by vomiting, rape and incest.
Thats how much this is damaged my memories. FUCK YOU LUCAS and FUCK YOUR BEARD YOU PODGEY LITTLE FUCK
VinylSamuraisMusic 5 months ago
Lucas self said in the 90's that he would never want his original movies to be changed or edited by any way. But he did it now, 2011...
HyperGolem 5 months ago
My sentiment, exactly.
krakatoa0mikel 5 months ago
It's still not as bad as Anakin's "Yipee!" in Episode I, or anything Obi Wan says in Episode II.
GNRKLL69 5 months ago
sounds a bit gay to me
ddrmetal 5 months ago
So...Lucas thinks this is a good idea, but he's ashamed of the Star Wars Christmas Special? People are strange.
Leatherbubba 5 months ago
My reaction to seeing this clip.
spinalTapSoundGuy 5 months ago
0:27 Was when george lucas came up to james earl jones with a mic and asked him to do the lines 0:31 was when lucas smashed his door in demanding he do it.
TheDazro 5 months ago
not one,.... but TWO of the most RETARDED, imbecilic things a character could say on film. And not only does he say it in a whiney, fool kind of way, but it completely turns Vader into a little bitch in ALL 6 EPISODES. Wow. whoever owns these blu rays knowing of the edits is a GODAMM FOOL.
Sentidocomuncabron 5 months ago
0:28 find out Vaders reaction to the changed scenes.
MsCreepyChan 5 months ago
This is completely unnecessary, it's like: "C'mon guys, it's blu-ray! We have to make something new." Why not just go all the way and put a brief flashback of Padmé's face right before the first "No"?
kekekekekeked 5 months ago
@kekekekekeked Goddamnit, don't give Lucas any more ideas!
neosoc 5 months ago
@neosoc Let's just pray he didn't notice...
kekekekekeked 4 months ago
yep, no blu-ray for me...
KyleDrewAPicture 5 months ago
"hey, george lucas is changing something"
"NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"
joni909 5 months ago
and 1% is dopey.
John1386788 5 months ago
PIECE OF SHIT. 99% of Star Wars is now RETARDED.
John1386788 5 months ago
I hear in the *next* incarnation of JEDI that the Emperor is going to be taking hits off a huge Bothan skull bong that will be digitally inserted next to his throne. And that Leia will go topless and sport a wicked tramp stamp.
But don't quote me.
TheDarthEddie 5 months ago
Clever Lucas if I was him id be milking this money cow aswell
typomk2 5 months ago
"Hodor!"
theeponym 5 months ago
do you guys realize something, mark zuckerberg is doing the same thing. Man i swear if we find you george lucas is his real father, it wouldnt be too surprising !
khisrow456 5 months ago
I hate the change too.
MrReco12 5 months ago
george, you've studied Buddhism right? it's not the movies that change - you change
reefergladness 5 months ago
Comment removed
Nomer1Baller 5 months ago
Does Star Wars suck because of this modification? Hell no. But now this scene does, yes, sir!
Grissha 5 months ago
Why, George Lucas? Why? FUCKING WHY???
Grissha 5 months ago
The dislike bar looks like Vader's lightsaber... right?
DannyLaam 5 months ago 64
@DannyLaam Let's keep it that way.
StygianWhite 5 months ago
What made this scene so powerful was Darth Vader being the silent protagonist. But since George Lucas developed the reverse Midas touch, where everything he touches turns to shit, he decided to ruin it.
Fuck you, George Lucas!
DallasSkinnyPuppy 5 months ago 2
Huge star wars fan, don't like that Lucas changes his movies, but let's face it. I'm 23 and the version I grew up with isn't the same as the original. The VHS version had changes, the VHS special addition had more changes, and the DVD had even more. It's Lucas stupid genus plot to get every spare penny out of his fan boys. He's going to keep changing it and people will keep buying it. O well... I'm going to go watch star trek
PianoProdigy88 5 months ago
Guys its lucas's movies he can do what he wants.personally i dont think its to bad it aint great either if you dont like it dont buy it and watch the terrible quality on vhs
dhiz92 5 months ago
@dhiz92 are they really HIS movies, or do they ALSO become a part of culture and history at some point? After 30+ years of undending support, the fans and history deserve a release of the ORIGINAL, UNTAINTED versions.
ZakTheRipper18 5 months ago
UGH. Why?!? George Lucas, how could you be so stupid...
There is no way in heck I'm buying these, and I hope hardly anybody does. I hope this whole scheme fails horribly and the backlash finally hits this guy in the head hard enough that he realizes what he's doing! Release the FRICKIN' originals properly on Blu-Ray. He'd sell way more.
robynbirde 5 months ago
@robynbirde A friend of mine thinks that that's just what he'll do... twenty or so years down the line, either before he dies, or when almost no-one's watching it anymore, for one last surge of sales.
neosoc 5 months ago