Twilight Saga Recasting: Who else could play Jacob Black?

[TwilightApple02]

No one! I LOVE Taylor playing Jacob! he is PERFECT for him! No one could ever replace him! If they replaced him, I don't think I could sit through another Twilight movie EVER again. <3 Taylor Lautner as Jacob Black <3

[gsgmrscrawford]

Steven Strait Thank you : )

[TRIXHOMO]

Steven Strait!

[sassy77855]

They does look like brothers! 2:11

[scarlett3849]

Steven Strait, but needs to pack on the muscles too

[misstrudi1]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­NE ELSE COULD PLAY JACOB

[TheDrinkjuice]

Steven Straight. He was Stephenie Meyer's original choice to play Jacob in the movies. If you don't know who he is, he was the one who played "Warren Peace" in Sky High and "Caleb" in The Covenant.

[MsSodapoplover]

no no no jacob is better and cuter

[perfectcatastrophe]

Taylor Lautner isn't even Native American... But I gotta admit he looked like a real Native American HOTTIE in New Moon when he had long hair. He doesn't look Native American with short hair though.....

[R4ND0MIZATION]

i reckon the first 1.. i 4got his name

[KSRPfan]

That Jessie guy does play a werewolf now, in MTV's Teen Wolf show.

[nikkisaurous]

@KSRPfan Hmm? The only two I have seen are Tyler Posey (Scott) and Tyler Hoechlin (Derek). I can see the similarity though

[KSRPfan]

@nikkisaurous oh, whoops, lol he looked like him.

[Supermanfan44]

Steve Strait!!!!!!!



[chinio18]

Im  pretty sure if they put some pale skinny ass guy to play on of these dudes roles yall would b pissed right?..... well yeahh the bitch in this movie is uglyy and skinny so this movie dont interest me, fucking lameee

[ahmshereiam16]

Its Steven Strait of course!

[ahmshereiam16]

STEVENNNNN STRAITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!

[sssSaramikeyzzz]

hey, channing tantum for edward!!!!!!!!

[bevz2nikki]

anyone but taylor lautner!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! n yes michael coupon

[Adrenalinejunkie1222]

Steven Strait definatly. i wanted him 2 play Jake

[Adrenalinejunkie1222]

Steven Strait definatly. i eanted him 2 play Jake

[MasterSokka]

Steven Strait was actually the first choice for Twilight, Stephenie Meyer thought he was the perfect Jacob. Sure, Taylor Lautner had the "looks", but he didn't have Jacob's personality.

[njbdsk]

TAYLOR LAUTNER IS THE BEST JACOB !! no one else could ever replace him i'm so glad he put on the extra 30 pounds of muscle, he deserved the role and is perfect for it. x

[Music1uv3r279]

Steven Strait IS Jacob. The movies got fucked. =P

[tdkiinani]

STEVEN STRAIGHT IS H O T<3!!

[Roxieeablee]

THEY ARE AL UGLY FOR GOD SAKE!

[NasukaChan]

I imagined Steven Straight as Jacob, it actually fits really good. Plus he's hot. xD

[55cuTEz]

i think michel copon would be great but i would die if they replaced taylor!!!

[KDMisery]

Steven Strait was my Jacob.

[cillygirl1998]

i lovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv­vvvvve taylor but i think michael coupon would have been better. i like him a little more. no offense taylor fans or taylor.

[MidnightThief15]

I like Taylor Lautner, but Michael Coupon's pretty hot.

[fitzaethan]

kim kardashian

[Angels2Hun]

i honestly hope some producer decides to do a remake in 3 years time or something haaha

[morrowam]

I love Taylor Lautner....No one can replace him! It would've been impossible!

[chik417]

TAYLOR LAUTNER ES EL MEJOR!!! LO MEJOR DE LA SAGA <3

[98Kurd]

NO NO ONEE ! JACOB IS GOOOOOOOOOOOOD

DO NOT CHANGE HIM !!

[XmienekeX]

ieuw steven is so ugly no jackob

[XmienekeX]

Jackob is perfect for the role he can play it perfect just the emotions and all!!

[lsnkittie]

I think taylor is awesome and he's a great Jacob, the only thing that stops him from being perfect as Jacob is his height. He's supposed to be "closer to seven feet than six" Why they don't just like put lifts in his shoes or something, I don't know. What I do know is that he does a great job of making you feel what Jacob is feeling and that is what its all about for me.

[Lovelyonuoha]

Steven strait was the guy

[VRUSTY19]

no one can play jacob better than taylor. but if taylor wasn't re-cast as jacob my second pick would have to be steven strait all the way.

[EV1M0]

i always saw Steven Strait as both Jacob and Edward<3(: but i wanted steven strait to be Jacob. :D <3

[kamjc]

Taylor is good already

[babyruth23217]

NOOOOOOOOO. Taylor is prefect.

[JennyA2496]

taylor rocks and if i had to choose cause he couldnt id say channing or zac efron. just cut their hair dye it black and give them a fake tan just to get their skin a little darker for the whole indian thing and there you go

[yayyabbyy]

neeeeh TAYLOR is perfect! He's got the bod and skin color for Jacob! Those who want Steven Strait... As hot as he is... He's too PALE to be Jacob, in my opinion! I think he would be a good Emmett or something. :)

[crapwad17]

Steven Strait FTW. He's so hott, he could even be Edward!

[ZacBeroende]

Chris Riggi!

[rockmecrzy]

i thought he did a good job as jacob and i'm on the vamp side.

[Believetruth100]

no taylor lautner is just PERFECT for the role

[Stupidblonde100]

NOPE SORRY NO ONE ELSE! DONT EVEN JOKE OF SUCH A FORBIDDEN THING!!! >:(

[Fantage4815]

DON'T RECAST!!! -.- she said "lautner" wrong HES PERFECT STUPID!! DONT CHANGE!!!

[dancinggirl52]

YAY!! ZAC EFRON ALL THE WAY!!!!

[mymyaiscool12]

you guy wanna keep jacob but dich all the other characters

[tixon434]

steven strait! but taylor lautner is soo.... hot!!

[salwa9895]

i can't imagine twilight wothout kristen robert or taylor so plz stop making this stupid video

[TheUnpredictable88]

@salwa9895 maybe if you reed the books you would have some kind of imagination...................­.P.s. i love robert for the part he is epic

[WillowMayin]

he was the best and only choice for him sorry. i would never pic any one else

[vampiresstrina]

they r supposed to look native american-ish so non of the other guys would have done it

[iHaflingerTheFirst]

No. You can't replace him. Twilight would have to end.

[GlamourGirl162]

= )

[eimgurl1018]

taylor is perfect for jacob except for the height...

[1twilightfan1011]

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO TAYLOR CANNOT BE RECASTED HE IS PERFECT I LUV HIM!!!!

[lairoloko]

steven strait could successfully replace jacob or even kiowa gordan who plays embry

but i think taylor was the right choice

[bonkersblock]

Jacky Chan would be the hotest pick to Play Jacob Black!

[Mystrygal13]

@bonkersblock LOL

[tweetysweety3t]

taylor is just tooo hawt :D

[ambersunsetatdusk]

the cast is fine as it is leav it alone clevver

[alexatetris]

Taylor Lautner is an unbelievably shitty actor.

[LilMissCraziness]

Isaiah Mustafa. The Old Spice Guy. He is the man your man could smell like.

[babygirl76419]

NO NO NO NO! NO ONE CAN RE-CAST MY MAN!! XDDD HE IS PERFECT!

[Baronstone]

@babygirl76419 He is nowhere close to perfect. Jacob is supposed to be six foot five, not the 5'9 or so that Taylor is

[supermarcusphoenix]

micheal copon defiantly! 

[brave4not]

i think that if anyone is playing a role alongside chase crawford and still be noticed is hot.props to steven.

[KittyCrimeStoppers]

Taylor Lautner, for sure! he plays Jacob well.

[YUNGLEFTYBABii]

NOOO.! LOL NOBODY ELSE COULD PLAY JACOB.

i WOULD BE VERY MAD.

HAHA;;

SO i'M HAPPY HE PUT ON THE MUSCLES.!

BUT LiKE i LiKE THE DUDE THAT PLAYED PAUL,

-JUST THOUGHT i'D ADD THAT iN THERE. LOL

[PaleMoons]

NO they got something RIGHT!!!!!

[numberonebrat95249]

Forget Jacob...Paul is the hotter/better werewolf!

[brave4not]

@numberonebrat95249 thought i was the only one who thought that

[numberonebrat95249]

@brave4not nope not the only one! When the brought in Paul in New Moon I was like....OMG!!!

[xoxluvmehatemexox]

Even if he was ugly , Taylor would still be an awesome Jacob hands down  no one Is a better Jacob than him( abd I'm not judging from looks)

But I would replace Bella

[LilTwihard]

i like michael :) he's yummy

i also like steven he is hot :D ( in the 2nd pic) But Launter reins supreme :D

[NaomiToraful]

no one else can be jake.

[doglover52]

They look totally like brothers!!

[cavlikcavli]

TO be honest, I don't think I want anyone recasted. Taylor's great. I think all these dudes are cute but if I had to pick one it would be Steven Straight.

And I have to agree, I think they are brothers. Shoot, they look so alike!

[colovalgreen]

Taylor plays awesome as jacob i would never replace i would only replace bella

[Gemshopet]

Are u crazy no one else could ever play jacob better!!!!!

[waawasad]

taylor is the perfect jacob

[thekaitlin]

Before they casted ANYONE I thought that Steven Strait would be PERFECT! I saw him in "Sky High" and was like.. "That's Jacob. Without a doubt." But Taylor Lautner proved me wrong. He makes an incredible Jacob and I like how he portrays a teen when he's a teen himself. I'm happy to see this movie casts people the same age as the characters (for once)!

[genie300839]

but taylor is hotter than anyody else

[soccerchick155]

Taylor is PERFECT for jacob. for all of you that hate taylor, go someone else. taylor was the best choice!

[TheCrapService]

ANYONE EXEPT TAYLOR LAUTNER!!!!!!!!!!

[vampirelover649]

what is the point of thinking about it Taylor is a perfect Jacob no doubt :-)

[xbeth151x]

they got jacob perfect! that is exactly how i imagined him when i read new moon

[mariemiller07]

taylor will always be jacob!!!

[graciegirl247]

i hate taylor laugtner anyway!!!! Copian IS HOT i'd choose him probably! ya they all do kinda look alike! Channing wuldnt do it even tho i love him

[Ulziimaa]

Alex Meraz.

[nyrarox2008]

My number one is Steven Strait. He was my Jacob before the movies, and WHAT DO YOU KNOW?! Taylor looks like his little brother, lol!

[Thorsbride]

@nyrarox2008 I totally agree! When I was reading the books, I totally envisioned Steven Straight as Jacob Black. Taylor is a real close second though.

[crispsyumlolxxx]

No one can replace him!!!

[glitterbearlover]

Hmm...Akihiro Sato maybe? I honestly adore Taylor though, so it's hard to come up with a replacement.

[joduyt]

no one can replace Taylor!!...tehe hes perfect....!!^^

[sierrahater666]

OMIGAWD STEVEN I S JACOB

[cellina14]

I actually like taylor and the first two. I really liked steven because he is the on I imagined jacob as, especially after twilight, but I think taylor did his part well, which is not something I can say about rob and kristen

[lucyloves95]

uh, duh! TAYLOR is the PERFECT Jacob, the only jacob. There will never be another jacob. Ever.

[RadChic121]

steven strait!!!

[PakiDevani]

If you call the three of them identical you need Fucking glases, Taylor is sooo much more sexier than any of them, and even if he wasn't in the movie, I would never see another twi-saga film.

TEAM JACOB!!! THUMPS UP IF YOU AGREE!!!

[guamgirl1980]

steven strait is awesome!!! n he's so hott!!! but taylors doin a good job!

[mzroker10]

i guess maybe the first guy

[LoganX333]

no one can ever replace jacob!

[TaylorJacobFan2462]

When I thought they were going to replace Taylor I almost gave up twilight! Cuz he is Jacob and no one else could ever be!! I luv him....and he proved everyone wrong and buffed it out!! Oh yea goo Taylor

[TaylorJacobFan2462]

If Taylor got replaced I would ethier give up twilight ( which was the one I almost did cuz he almost got fired) or go to team Edward( not likely but still) Taylor is the best actor ever!! And super hot !! He is Jacob black and no one else could ever replace him!!'

[mdara23]

Michael would be good, but not good enough. Taylor is the best choice and he proved himself worthy of that, obviously. No doubt. Channing is hot, but he's not werewolf material and the rest can go sit in a rock.....I don't think so.

[xsanitiex]

Channing Tatum is hot, hotter than Taylor Lautner, but I could never he wouldn't be right as Jacob.

[twilight132435465761]

When I heard that they had been thinking about recasting Jacob, I told my friends that I would boycott the rest of the movies. Taylor is perfect and I'd told all my friends that from the beginning.

[MerlevanderSteen]

@twilight132435465761 Ohhh so nice to know, I wish I was your friend!

[risrismb]

TAYLOR IS JACOB!!! JACOB IS TAYLOR!!! NO CONTEST!!!!!!!!!

[ladypearlypink]

the guy who was in hte convenant would of been ngreat though kudo on jacob for bulking up but he still didnt look the part

[Live4TV22]

@ladypearlypink steven strait, yeah he's good

[Veela66]

i love taylor as jake. he is the only one i can see for the part. But copand is cute. :) and i liked steven strait as jacob before the movies came out but i like taylor.

[kanosgirl]

Wow...I don't know. Taylor's the only guy I could think of to be Jacob.

[87jordy]

they are all TOTALLY HOT....but Channing Tatum? really people....hes hot but i wouldnt want taylor to go away!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! >:D

[sango42]

There is only one person Jacob Black and that is TAYLOR NO ONE ELES WOULD DO !!!!!!

[juztine12345]

I'm a half-filipina. Filipinos are great. HAHAHA nothin' Mickael Copand is really Hot :D

[CNicole2014]

Taylor Lautner may be the only actor whom I picture every time I think of Jacob. He's just perfect for the role.

[yougogirlphinney28]

If Mickael Copand (or w/e) was cast I'd stop watching the movies. I don't like that guy at allll.

[Laydee1b2]

HAHAHA HELL NO

TAYLOR IS PERFECT FOR THE ROLL JACOB

so..

BUN YOU!!:)

[ashanlani]

first off, jacb has to be HOTTER than rob otherwise i wouldn't b on a twilight team cuz rob just isn't hot, but rob is WAY hotter than the guys in the vid!!

[HJS92]

say taylors last name right for pete sakes its freakn annoying

[mojican13gem]

I love Taylor but I think Steven Strait would be great!

[nejisbabe]

STEVEN STRAIT!!!

[BebeBatechona]

Ok im sorry but just the idea of replacing Taylor L is INSANEEEE CRAZYY and STUPIDDD, so the answer is no one cuz TL has that perfect Husky look goin on so he makes the perfect jacob even his voice is husky hes just IRREPLACABLE and thats all there is to it, and stop trying to cast famous pretty boys in twilight, yes they r hot but they dont fit the characters not to mention channing t is WHITE and Jacobs suppose to be from a native tribe JEZZ ppl b realistic here

[TheTwiHardChannel]

Steven Strait!

[Avrilrulesalot]

no we dont love him he is aslo a major major piece of POOP!

[seasondills]

I love Taylor as Jacob. He is perfect

[MissLisaWen]

Taylor Lautner is irreplacable. But if i had to choose, i could see Michael Copan as Jacob.

[willow138]

was the first guy in one tree hill as felix?

[SexxyTiger]

@willow138 yes he was

[fanofalotofthings]

The people listed weren't bad but Taylor Lautner is the best choice for the role. He is dedicated as you can see by his transformation for New Moon and is clearly the best choice!

Taylor Lautner IS Jacob Black!

[Dizzy2381]

YES STEVEN STRAIGHT I SEE HIM AS JAKE aside from Taylor

[xxdamagedrosesxx]

Michael Copon would probably be good :O

Steven is alsoo goood! He was amazing in the Covenant. channing tatum as jacob??? umm... no.

[sarahjo941]

michael copon is hot but Jacob is hotter with/withough long hair and is perfect for the role, but all 3 of them do look freakishly alike

[TheEdwardLovesBella]

Micheal Copon!!!!!! He would be soooo gooood!!!

[oxspidermonkeyxo]

steven stright

[JustinBieberfan572]

Taylor is a great actor he is the best Jacob there could ever be

[Irisxoxoxo]

Steven! <3 He would have been so much better!

[leoaddict]

michael copon all the way

[monicamocahbee1]

talor is hot

[herhazeleyescry4u]

If taylor wasnt Jacob I would want it to be Micheal Copen..He's sexy enough to be a werewolf lol

[lolitakiss21]

Michael Copon and Steven Strait this two would be perfect .I'm still wondering why they didn't change Taylor Lautner in first place.He just don't have the look for that role.

[95sweetalex]

NOOO TAYLER is PERFECT

[llinalle1632]

i want Taylor Lautner!!

[ganga895]

i honestly dont like taylor lautner i think hes fake in a way!!

they would of chose JESSE METCALFE!!!!!!!!!!!

:D

[tigerwoman188]

Those three do look like brothers. I know Taylor is good actor and vicious just watching new Moon and him been Sharkboy

[PinkFirefly14]

Jacob is supposed to be 7 ft LOL but Taylor is alright I guess

[TwilightRules33]

Taylor is PERFECT for Jacob! But if Taylor couldn't then I would have to say Steven.

[Wolfchick1234]

Micheal Copon he is so yummy

[HobieHandyTV]

i think that first guy could have pulled it iff

[arah1113]

Hmm i think Jacob is really good and hot but Michael could possibly pull it off. And maybe. They really do look alike Jesse sure dies Yummy LoL

[68candylover]

no one can replace him!!! he is perfect for it!

he so proved all those ppl who said he couldnt be jacob he did! he was awsome!

[cooldssd02]

i know they said he was not beefy and look at him now he has an eght pack from a no pack!!!!!!

ands hes so beyond cute and i cant imagen someone els jacob

[caitlinbeadlesfan11]

taylor lautner is jacob. period. everyone else isnt jake.

[hazeleyes3395]

steven strait is perfect i love him but i love taylor too

[Shelagpccjsxwyxvhkf]

If you can`t wait for relase of Twilight Eclipse just go to OnlineTwilightEclipse[dot]info There is leaked version of it in not bad quality .

[zeecrane]

@Shelagpccjsxwyxvhkf that is just one of those things where you have to do like a quiz or something.. it doesnt work.. unless there's a way to shut that thing off

[raccoon516]

STEVEN STRAIT would rock the role :D

It has nothing to do that i have a major crush on him ;)

[09emmz]

I mean im not a team jacob and in the books jacob actually does my head in...and i still think so in the films a lil bit..im more of the jasper person myself buttttt!!!! taylor is wayyy to perfect for the role of jacob...i mean he completley proved himself by 'buffing' up for new moon....and i dont like jacob i have to admit the whole jumping into bellas window using th tree then when he jumped out and landed a bit later on i was kinda wooed for a moment :)

[itcytackle07]

I feel sorry for Meyer cuz I know he preferred Steven but she probably don't wanna messed with fans who likes Tay..lol!..first Henry Cavill and now Steven..tsktsk..XDXD

[itcytackle07]

Steven/Caleb Danvers/Warren Peace/Jacob Black,,,he is the one of most gorgeous hollywood actor evah!!..taylor can do the younger version of jake but for the buffed up and aged up Jacob theres no other guy that can pull that off but STEVEN!..HE SCREAMS HOTNESS, FACE and BOD!..the only hot thing about that taylor is his body thats all..but I know his a sweet guy.XD

[shrsalonga]

taylor lautner is soooo hot!he really deserve to be jacob black!he is fun and energetic!and he is soooo coolll!

[babexify]

Taylor is the best Jacob ull ever find so keep serching but u wont find anything Taylor is hot hot hot hot

[1915RosalieHale1933]

I would've picked steven if taylor wasnt in it! there is some serious similarity between those two

[CRAZYVAMPIREGIRL100]

TAYLER LAUTNER is the BEST Jacob Black and I LOVE him he is SOO freaking HOT!!!!!! TEAM TAYLER!

[Nubifera]

I really wanted Steven Strait to be Jacob, but Lautner brings a certain sweetness to the character which I like. I think Strait would have bee more brooding and suffering Edward-style.

[cndygurl990]

ahh ohhh no, no, no, no!! i mean all of them are okay but Taylor is exactly perfect for Jacob!!:D lol

[Zeo27]

i dont know i like taylor but michael copon was a power ranger and (like me) is fillopino....... someone help me out!!

[ohsomisskiss]

HELLO Taylor is THE PERFECT JACOB & before they casted him as Jacob he was my Jacob.