Measurement of the LANGUAGE PIE (Proto-Indo-European)

[gold333]

Yet another Albanian nationalist video trying to convince the world everybody is wrong. Why do you guys have such a huge chip on your shoulders?

[gold333]

@gold333 Lol, I just finished watching it. The uploader does not ony dismiss years of study by people who have devoted their ENTIRE lives to linguistics, but also claims that English and many other languages stem from Albanian. Talk about self absorbed nationalism.

[inferidamus]

*facepalm* Chomsky propaganda

[RONSANDHU]

it looks more like a propaganda.

[countersubject889]

It is like if you had said that french derives from andalusian.... Open your eyes, guy. Vedic sanskrit is much older than albanian. (and how would you explain similarities with indo-iranian languages?)

[BBarNavi]

Your point being: Everything originated in Albania, da ze?

[lindwurm2]

So, what you're trying to say, is that Albanian is nothing more than a dialect of Greek? Right?

[Spinnendieb]

Wow... those 200 years of research... comparing vocabularies, phoneme systems, morphologic and syntactic systems of countless languages... all thoat progres in indo-european studies which was made and which i believed in... it has now been destroyed by this video which delivered overwhelming proof by examining this one single word "mas/mat" in a single language which has no written account before the 15th century AD.

This is true science (which actually a 6-year-old could have done better).

[NoirHammer]

@Spinnendieb Agreed. Talk about all that wasted time analyzing Sanskrit during the 19th century. I believe this is knowledge derived from a crystal ball.

[gehenna961]

mimnis erut garestades rotnem uvlin par tenus polem isairon tet sut trat nesi kruvis tenag trut ipiem rotnes lutuis θalu isperion vul tes rotem teu aiten tasur soter merpon kalatne

nis vilatos paten arn uis balestenag ands et sut lakut treten teletau nem polem tisu sotris eus

[fuckturks2223]

indo-european is gay

[vaguelyhumanoid]

After all, who needs science when you can have anti-intellectual nationalist bullshit?

[HABRADASHR]

but hungarian isnt indo-european,right shittard?

[sneighwena]

What a ridiculous video. It's a fact that over 80% of Albanian vocabulary was borrowed from Slavs, Greeks, and Latins.

[TheValmirZz]

@sneighwena The words that exist in Albanian language you cant find in any other language!

Albanian Language is Illyrian Language, but it changed alot in years but we still have some words that we saved from Prehistoric times!

[roman1akid]

Soundtrack in the beginning, what is it?

[xhemexx]

Since ultimately we all shared the same genes, therefore languages are in many ways like human genes and they bare some remnants with every other language and languages. So all languages can have some siliarities with any given other language and languages/dialects etc that existed and ever will exist. So languages/dalects etc could be put in almost infinite combinations with every single other one. What do you guys think about this theory and what I think and this comment of mine??

[xhemexx]

So in other words, any given languages and dialects can be grouped together or rather share similarities with any other language a dialect that ever existed. Again not necessarily genetically related, but by other means, like through isoglossis, Shprachbund and areal connections etc. This makes sense because I beleive that all languages ultimately came from the same language, and therefore all people, ethnicities,languages/dialects that ever existed have similarities in some way with all others

[Eopyk]

@xhemexx No this is bullshit. Proto-Indo-European is proven by the means of soundlaws and morphological corresponses being mathaticly corresponding one another. The basic vocabulary is very easy to find in daugter languages despite what nationalists want to belive. Proto-Indo-European most likely spread into Europe with the domestication of the horse from the stepp area of Russia. Also what this bullshit video fails to know is that not all European languages are claimed to be Indo-European

[Naiant]

@Eopyk Yeppers. Nicely put.

[xhemexx]

I for one feel that every single language and dialect, and any other form of verbal and no nverbal speech is unique in so many way, and that it has properties that it are uniwue to it. I also feel that any given two languages/dialects etc in the world's history can have some sort of similarities with one another. It doesn't have to be genetic in origin, but I beleive they do hold some common deatures no matter what family they are from and what group they are in.

[Naiant]

This might have been interesting, but I have a rule against watching a clips when the poster is too afraid to allow ratings.

[acxSS]

ti qeke tamom shqiptar..! se shumica verdall n'youtube jane ose kosovar ose arvanitas the cam. Po mu m'interesojn me shume shqiptaret tamom.Dhe do m'duhej shum mund edhe kohe (me mos thone fat) me gjet ca gjona qe msova ke vidiot e tuja, dhe prap do ja vlete.Shqiptaret jane the Truth, and the truth is Divine(not like religions which are the Lie).

[acxSS]

M'intereson edhe natyra dhe mentaliteti i te Lashteve, si prsh.krijimi i gjuhes dhe fjales uje qe ngjason me zhurmen gje ben uji ne pruall (ujujujuj.......)

[ComandanteCrus]

Si jan Shqiptaret TAMOM sipas teje?

[acxSS]

....jane si ata qe krijun dhe e majten Besen si gjen me t'shejnt, gje qe po ta menosh eshte shume e thelle me e kuptu.Dhe t'jashtmit e shifshin si naivitet dhe e perdorshin per mashtrim.

nje shembull...do tjer?

[ComandanteCrus]

Ktu thua per besen kurse te komenti me poshte fole per Kosoven e Camerine....ktu flet per meritat e njeriut kurse me poshte fole per gjeografin.

[acxSS]

Po. Shqiptaret e shqiperise i consideroj the real shqiptar.

[ComandanteCrus]

Mire qe sjeni shume ju qe besoni kte gje.

Dhe me sa po shikoj nga shkrimi jot (konsideroj me K)nuk me duket se jeton ne Shqiperi.

Tani te bej nje pyetje personale cfare te ben ty Shqiptar dhe mua jo?

[acxSS]

esht e pamundur te jetosh i lir nen dhunen e tjetrit.

Vetem po t'Vdesesh.

[ComandanteCrus]

Ore tjeter gje te pyeta...

Une e di qe eshte e pamundur po ti ke ss fotografi avatari,keshtu qe te pelqen dhuna.

Dhe mos harro dhunen qe kaluan Shqiptaret e Shqiperise.

[nottiimmortalate]

1."Kostantini e Garentina:Kuptimi i nalte i beses shqyptare ne rapsodin e vjeter",21 faqe('44)//2.Lucera nei Secoli, 68f.('66)//3.Contestazione Contestata:Parole di un Credente,197f.('71)//4.Gesù (..dal preambolo dell'opera "Elena"dello stesso autore)61f.('82)//5.Ideali,197­f.('83)//6.Thot Parlava Albanese,222f.('83)//7.Enver Hoxha,20f.('84)//8.Antichità della lingua abanese,30f.('88)//9.Shqiptarë­t:Popull i ndarë,465f.('96)///

[nottiimmortalate]

pa tjeter! shiko sa libra kam gjete neper internet tek adresat e bibliotekave neper itali!..po ta shkruaj te gjith koleksionin!...sa qejf me i be fotokopje te tereve ose me i be .pdf!!...ua...jane gati 1400 faqe!!!!....ahaha...

[2bilderberg]

Mrekulli!

Pasi ti besh fotokopje dhe ti konvertosh ne PDF do ishte mire ti vendosje ne rapidshare per shkarkim dhe githashtu po pate mundesi te besh nje video permbledhese me kto materjale.

[nottiimmortalate]

Mrekulli!...kur te keme ca dite pushime, kam qejf te iki ne Rome, te takoj nje shoke dhe tek biblioteka shtetrore, gjenden librat 2/3/6/8...librat 1 dhe pj.2 e 9, jan ne Firenze, dhe te kem mundesin eshte prap afer dhe bukur te dal nje gjiro me shoket, prap andej...por librat 4/7(Cosenza) dhe 5(Palermo), vetem po me derguan fotokopjat...se jan me larg se t'ikesh ne shqiperi!...ahaha...

[2bilderberg]

Besoj edhe keto te dyja mund ti gjesh ne Itali sepse ne vende te tjera perndimore s'besoj se gjenden. Ti kerko neper bibliotekat italiane dhe me thuaj nese i gjen, madje po pate mundesi beju fotokopje dhe dergomi materjalet pasi do me interesonte dhe mua ti lexoja se nese i ka shkruar Catapano jam i bindur se jane kryevepra. OK ?

;-)

[nottiimmortalate]

plako dua te bleje librin e Xhuzepe Catapanos...ku mund ta gjej? se pash tek nje koment qe i dhe NikVlores linket per ta gjetur...mund te me ndimosh!?...jam ne dizposicion edhe po qe ne biblioteke...s'eshte probleme edhe ta scanerizoj ne pdf....shum flm ciao ciao

[2bilderberg]

Librin ke mundesi ta gjesh ne biblioteken kombetare shqiptare ne Tirane ne gjuhen shqipe dhe gjithashtu ne Itali ne biblioteken kombetare ne Firenze, Rome dhe Kalabri.

Ne itali librin mund ta konsultosh direkt ne bibliotek pasi nuk ta japin hua jashte saj.

[albblessed]

great video,great job bro..,Thanks!

[MariglenD]

Bravo