Added: 2 years ago
From: 3DGAMEMAN
Views: 30,720
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (501)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ati card is klocked very hi,and nvidia cards usualy are not thet hi,try both cards to run at the same core klock,see what hepens.

  • Lol Nvidia sucked 5870's balls. + Ati is cheaper. Lol what retard a person has to be to get nvidia now ;D

  • @Bibazavr Whaha i readed: Nvidia sucked 5870 balls. XD

  • Remember that both crysis and far-cry are optimized for nvidia cards.

  • @Monoindeed so is san andreas? lol, but an ATI card can slay that

  • their is so many advances in the 5870 40 nm process compared 55, dx11 vs dx10, gddr5 vs gddr3.

  • gotta love that generic music...

  • @nelizmastr lol idd m8 xD

  • cool, i bought my gtx275 just because i don't need that much power and because the 5870 was costing 1.599 against 999 of the gtx 275 :)

  • a better comparison is the 5970 and the gtx 295

  • @SoCalyankeefan finally someone that agrees

    why does everyone compare a single gpu card to a dual gpu card

    its so annoying

  • clash f the titan HD5870 vs GTS295 vs HD4870 X2 (ignore HD5970)

    im prefer HD5870 because it use less wattage/high performance on higher resolution/cheaper than GTX295

  • today HD 5870 owns GTX 295 because the new drivers came out for the 5870

  • @xichtyyy2

    well, there are also new drivers for nvidia 256.xx drivers, that gives boost up to 30% in most games

  • you should give me that 5870 when ur done with ur tests =]

    I'd greatly appreciate it!! :)

  • NVIDIA = WIN

    When duel viewing (extend desktop) with ATI you have to have both monitors at the same resolution!!!!!!

    When duel viewing (extend desktop) with nvidia you can have different sizes!, and change individual settings in the CP for the individiual monitors like digital vibrance

    NVIDIA = WIN

  • looking at the price i go for ATI its a realy good card and much cheaper

  • @m0hawk1dwarf

    yeah...i got HD4850 CF and its pawn GTX280

    HD4850 dual card cheaper than single GTX280/285 :)

  • @skywalkmangefore

    That isn't true... i have a 24" Samsung LCD I run at 1920x1200 and an IBM 15" CRT I run at 1024@768 and they run fine in extended desktop with my Sapphire ATi Radeon 4850 512MB

  • I'm still asking myself if 2 5870's will beat 2 GTX295 cause of better scaling..

  • some people are saying that 2 5870s will not beat a single 5970 cuz 5970 works in a more optimised way than crossfire

  • @moonshiry 5970's run at 2x5850s speed. but better scaling .... perhaps

  • @riepdiep10 not beat.... rape

  • @tallandme13 Thanks ^^ took some time to get my answer xD I'n may i'll be upgrading my Geforce 9600GT to 2 of those 5870's.. can't wait

  • @riepdiep10 just a fyi- you can oc a msi 5850 to go faster than a 5870- gpu at over 1000ghz- just a way to save 200$ =P depends on what you want... im sure if you were to get two 5870 by msi you can overclock just as much and be way faster than a 5970. SO Manny options

  • @tallandme13 That would be great i was thinking about buying 2 5850 instead, but im kinda scared to overclock, so unless i can be sure of not breaking my video card by overclocking to 5870 clock's i will buy a 5870 and wait longer till i buy the second card for crossfire

  • @riepdiep10 5850's have been overclocked to over 1 ghz, when the 5870 is stock at .850ghz...ish

  • So i should buy a 5850 for 100 buck less and overclock it ( safely) ?

  • @riepdiep10 Thats what im going to do. You dont need to have much over the 5870's speeds to match it either

  • My 2 5870s just arrived yesterday and I have to say they are beast. 1 of them can run Crysis on max with relative ease. 2 of them...........Crysis is a joke. 2 5870s out perform a 5970 but which ever you chose, you can't go wrong with ATI.

  • What do you mean crysis is a joke? It is the most graphic demanding game ever, you can presure graphics like forever.

  • @BiPart lol oh no man, I worded that wrong. I meant to say that just 1 of my 5870 cards can run Crysis on max and looks beautiful so the point I was trying to make is that when I tried it out with 2 5870s crossfired together, Crysis was not even a challenge to run.

  • @Ludoweezer it stinks that laptops cant hav crossfireX

  • This "VS" battle is wrong. The GTX295 is a dual chip card, against a single one (5870). The ideal competitor should be the 5970!

  • The 5870 does perform well, considering its a single GPU card and cheaper than GTX295, also the drivers were not optimized back then.

    ATI wins here, time to sell my GTX260 xD.

  • on this world were we are atm we need card what dont use a power :D kids

  • hummm,as i suspected?

    my 295 gtx STILL dominates,look carefully at the graphs,the 5870 is ahead on the first irrelevant test,but compare it on games,it wins 9 out of 10 times,glad i didnt sell it now.

    yes,fermi is taking a little time,developing gpus this state of the art isnt like baking a cake,its a ton of trial and error.ATI has some decent new products but when FERMI is released(i know!when?)it will reign supreme.

    view any testing thus far and suck it up ati,sorry!!

    nvidia for the win!!!!

  • good logic there einstein lmao

  • geforce win1

  • I get my new comp next month!!! NO MORE 800x600! 5870, i7 920, 26" monitor ahahahahaha!!!!

  • These benchmarks were done using the very first drivers for the 5870, AKA, the performance is nowhere near full :)...and look at the results.

  • lol this is great... ati holds there cards till Nvidia is done then releases its last ones, they know if they released them Nvidia would make some card and give it a random ass name like gtx 295 super + or some shit. fanboys can fight all they want but when it comes down to it im not into a card that i have to pray for a fucking drivers update. inb4 reply

  • the 9.12 drivers make the 5870 faster than the 295, it was only a matter of time.

  • Lemme sum it up here.

    HD 5870 = 1 GPU

    GTX 295 = 2 GPU's on one board.

    If the 5870 came so close to the 295 being a SINGLE gpu unit, how do you think the 5970 performs? :)

    It's okay, you can wait a couple more monts for Fermi.

  • From what I read the GTX 295 is physically deep, meaning that a 4 slot motherboard can hold only two GTX 295 cards. A four slot motherboard could hold 4 5870 cards. Three 5870 cards is more than enough to take on the 2 GTX 295 cards. That'll last you till direct x12 and outdates all the cards out there like direct X 9= did.

  • 5870 anyway faster GTx295!

    5870 can 2times more overcloack than GTX295

  • @halfpol Stupid question but how do you overclock ati video cards? i know there is a tool for nvidia cards but i don't know if theres one similar for ati. i run on an nvidia gts 250 and am about to buy the ati 5870.

  • @KwickLockPicker its something called visual cc or something like that for ati and there u open that and then u go there at something called ati overdrive and there u can overclock ur gpu for ati atleast thats what i did

  • yeeee , you right dude, you righttt !!!

  • one question which is betterrrrrrrrrrrrrrr :S

  • Price/Quality = 5870HD

  • The HD5870 seems to perform on the same level as the GTX295. For a new generation of video card, this is about where you want it to perform. Double the speed of the top/near top of the line. Since the GTX295 is a pair of GTX275, that puts it right where it should be.

    I also can't wait for the Fermi Video cards. They will drop these prices like a rock. However, Fermi isn't competing with this card. Its competing with the HD6xxx now.

  • and 3dmark app's are and have always been tilted in the favor of nvidia, since the way nvidia archetecture works better for gpgpu functions and open gl, duh of course your going to see better results with nvidia. but you dont buy a card to run bench's, you buy a card to play games, real world tests are so much different.

  • notice though, that the drivers being used are still imature, for the ati card i mean. the cards work differently anyway, despite the fact that one is a dual gpu. its not sane to crossreference diff generations of cards, wait till nvidias fermi chips (gt300 series) come out, then compare them to this. plus there is a 5970 that is only slightly more expensive than a gtx295 that kicks ass.

  • the 5970 is $750,the 295 gtx is $350?

    were do you shop?

  • GTX 295 has more GPU, but only direct X 10.1 support, and shader model 4.0, as well as 2.1 GL support

    Ati 5870 has less GPU, but has shader model 5.0 and direct X 11 support, as well aas 3.2 open GL support

  • hah! ATI got owned again!

  • LOL, Nvidia beat the 5870 by no more than a few FPS. 3DMark vantage is build more for Nvidia. Also ATI does not have physx. Physx is not even used in many games so it does not matter but 3Dmark still tests it. The 5870 only has one processor and the GTX 295 has two. learn a few things than post

  • @SoleGFXTube rage more ati fanboy. lulz

  • lol, "ati fanboy" I cant wait for the gt300 and im an ati fanboy. why stick with one company

  • he's stating facts, unlike you

  • @SoleGFXTube Don't forget that the 5870 has DirectX 11 and the GTX 295 had DirectX 10.

  • @SoleGFXTube Then it was an awful sad thing if nVidia couldn't come up with a good enough dual-GPU card to beat a single GPU card... Whether it used DirectX 11 or not.

  • @SoleGFXTube

    Physx may not be used in games very often, but Physx processor isn't only set up for specifically it. It processes physics of all types. It doesn't pertain to any specific engine. Certain engines like Physx it is designed for, but others like Geomod2.0 I got way better frame rates on my 8800gtx then with my HD 5750.

  • @Wakkajakka The onboard Physx processor is basically a gts250, and it will only accelerate Physx based games and only if it allows hardware physx. It wont work in games that don't use hardware physx, there is no other way around it. Geomod 2.0 is purely cpu based for its physics and may run better on the 8800gtx than the Ati card simply because it was optimized for Nvidia cards or its a "the way its meant to be played" title. And Physx is dead, Nvidia is moving on to OpenCL.

  • owned? i only see 5870 losing by few fps. not bad considering its a 1 gpu card and gtx 295 is a dual gpu card. you really want to proudly announce that ATI got pwned? why not go search gtx 295 vs 5970? both are dual gpus.

    Then the next thing u will say is, Fermi Will PWN ATI!! then we are like DUH it took like forever to make. and ati is also annoucing its 6XXX series end of 2010. Its a time game. however releases later has the later technology and is better. simple

  • I've been buyign Nvidia for my last three builds, but I'm goign with ATI this time. Lower power cunsumption and Directx 11. given the benchmarks results I've been seeing here and elsewhere. And thsoe ATI drivers hadn;t had time to amture by then. If you did that test again nw, you'd see a godo increase on teh ATI side. Nvidia too, likely, but all i saw of the initial 5xxx drivers is that they were complete shit.

    But now that I'm back on the ATI train, I won;t get drivers every 2 weeks :(

  • I love good competition from 2 different brands. makes each brand make better cards to try and over take the other. good ole competition. good luck to both brands. may the better card win.

  • now the 5970 is the fastest, then nvidea will come out with the 300 series, then after that ati will have a better, then nvidea will be better and so on ...

  • How you can know that?

  • lol its simple common sense. its how to world progresses. otherwise technology would stagnate

  • Yay my incomming 5870's in tri-fire...

  • guess ill be picking up the 5870 then :P

  • Considering that the 295 is dual GPU and the 5870 is single GPU, this is incredible.

  • So .... The GTX 295 still owns the HD 5870 ??

  • I wouldn't personally say it owned it. The 295 has an extra 768 MB of memory to work with. I suppose that is why at higher resolutions the nvidia scores higher. I would recon if your running your games at 1080p on a monitor under 30" you wouldn't see a dramatic difference between the two.

  • Also the 295 scores higher because a lot of games work much better with nVidia architecture.

  • @owendyhouse i concure!! finaly someone who understands!! XD XP

  • @jumpingshadow1 Long from owning,

    Ati = single core card

    Nvidia = Dual core card

    Id say Nvidia got owned too bad.

  • Great Video^!!!!! Thanks a lot for the information dude

  • its not nvidia/intel u idiot and intel/ati will forever be best choice coz u can get 2 ati cards for price of one nvidia card.

  • ATI has best performance graphic card.....i can run and record crysis using natural mod...

  • gotta remember ati have early drivers for these cards at the momment the 295 is a year old ? and they probly have got the most performance they can get out their drivers with the 295 so im sure the 5870 will become alot better soon

  • What?! It's just USD 389?

  • well futuremark vantage is just a pile of crap using physx , dosent give a worthy result so^^...

  • I am not a fanboy I just got best performance for the money as far as I can tell the 5870 wins for best performance for the money. Seriously 295 costs 500 is the cheapest while 5870 goes for 389.. Can't wait to buy a xfire mobo and xfire this.

  • i think the same as you, but when i went in to trade my 4890 in for another card, i was going to get a 5870 but the gtx 295 just looked so pretty. Nvidia uses vodoo man, its eeeeeeeeevil.

  • Nvidia FTW!!

  • Dude, look how close it got to a dual GPU... that's kinda close from a single GPU. Gotta give em credit...

  • nvidia sux cant u see this this gpu when made in dual gpu solution outperforms the "gtx295"

  • cant you see this card is a year old, now ati comes up after almost a year with the 5870, whats next? 5870 x2? by then nvidia is already steamrolling with the GTX 3xx series, think twice before you talk so much crap, nvidia will win the battle always, its Intel/Nvidia vs AMD/Ati forever anyways, i dont see amd beat intel and that will be the same with nvidia beating ati :)

  • also hd 5870 is the BEST single gpu atm so yeah

  • lol dude the 295=295x2

  • Crysis "HIGH SETTINGS?" WHATAHELL! High settings for... a GTX 295 and a 5870?! Are you guys crazy?! This cards handle VERY HIGH setting... Are you testing on windows XP?

  • *checks prices*

    pisses self

    *buys 2 5870's for price of 1 295 and smiles*

  • what is the difference between an his hd 5870 and a sapphire or xfx radeon hd 5870?

  • its a battle which never ends, with always nvidia as winner in the end

  • How is NVIDIA winner in the end if it never ends?

  • there will be a end you know that :)

  • damn mathhenr just destroyed u

  • @SuperMasterTroll EEEH!?!?! u react to something i said here months ago.. months dude rofl, what do you wanna explain here? that you had a red bike instead of a green one? your mom didnt give popsicles when you were a kid? for christ sake

  • when i read tats when it hapened i dictate where an when life takes place bsides i just replied to stuf over a year ago in another vid lmao

  • btw sory to remember u had ben pwned a month ago i no u were trying to forget hahaha

  • @SuperMasterTroll pwnd? ehm i am now on sapphire HD5970 crossfire you nitwit, who is owned here now? you dont have enough money to spend for videocards? no !! you go try and own people on youtube

    i own you !!

  • @SuperMasterTroll so i still remember you to your red bike and missed popsicles

  • gota say that the gtx 295 is dual gpu and the ati 5870 is singlecore so the ati wins :P

  • HD 5870 is better, it has a less power comsumption, more cheaper than GTX 295 and it own DirectX 11. But GTX295 has Physics and CUDA, driver update frequently. But I prefer ATI driver and the less comsumption, low-cost comparated to GTX295 and DirectX 11 makes HD 5870 a better choice.

  • when ati gets the hd 5870x2 nvida will get owned :D

  • no, i don't think that is true. The new GTX 300 series is comming out, which will have the great nvidia drivers and will probably be cooler cause of the small dye.

  • lol? 2x295 will pwn 2x5870

  • @BigMete0r

    gtx295 is a dual gpu card.

    and when you take 2 of them (so you have 4gpus) the performance will suck. thats not efficiency.

    and also you will get very much microlags.

    2 gtx295 are just 30% faster then 1.

    and 2 hd5870 perform over 50% faster then 1.

  • @Skipan2

    Oh ok thanks!

    And.. one question

    I have a MSI gtx 275

    what if i buy a second one? How much % it will be faster? and will it be better than a gtx 295?

  • bigmete0r ur an idiot -_- the 295 is already x2 so yeah

  • why idiot? pff i ask because i heard that 295 = 2x260 also i heard 295 = 275x2 so i ask..

  • @BigMete0r

    the gtx 295 is practicly the same as 2 gtx260

    a gtx 275 is 16% faster than a gtx260 so yes

    2*gtx275 should be faster than a gtx295

    i don't know exactly how much faster.

    google for some benchmarks you should find enough

  • Wrong.

    Gtx 295 is 2x gtx 285 with lower clock gpu and memory,less ram per GPU and 448 bit memory interface but it has the same amount of SPs,TUs and ROPs as gtx 285

  • the shader,chip and ram clock of the gtx295 and gtx260 is the same.(1.242/576/999)

    the ram size is the same(896mb per gpu), the memory interface (448bit), the amount of rops(28 per gpu)

    only TMUs/TAUs and shader are identical with the gtx280/285. (80/80/240 per gpu)

    so 6 things are identical with the gtx260 and only 3 things with the gtx285.

    thats definitly more equal to an gtx260.

    only the gtx295 mars is made by 2 full-fledged gtx285 but it costs 1000€ and is limited by 1000.

  • nvidia has more and better updates though

  • Well I use NVIDIA now and last time and the drivers for me is and was crap, very drivers bug etc. I will get my ATI and check the drivers. But the drivers of NVIDIA I didn't like.

  • god you soooo dont know what your on about. just shuttup and let people have their input, even if its not your liking.

  • well directx 11 have new technology so thats why the games have to be progam in a diferent ways. don't be surprice that the games are been delayed .

    is no fear the comparation is a new videocard running a last generation game also crysis was designed to run on nvidia cards

  • Nvidia pwned ati by a long shot i have both his card and gtc 295 im uploading a video my first video of me crushing the fuck outa the His card shits garbege haha my friends friend o well hes a fag :)

  • nice vid man

  • you write so much in just 1 video..

  • haha luv the new ati.. finally a reason 2 get rid of my 2 8800gt's... if a single gpu does this to a duel gpu 295 i just cant wait to see the insanity of the 5870x2

  • imagine 5870 x2 power

  • The HD5870 totally wins cause 295 gtx has 2 cores,1.7 GB GDDR3 576MHz of core clock,2016MHz of memory clock,1246MHz of shader clock and 896 bit memory interface and it has 480 stream proccesors the HD 5870 has 2 cores,1GB DDR5,256 bit memory interface,850MHz of core clock,4800MHz of memory clock and it has 1600 stream processors

  • You have some serious tech anger dude... Take a chill pill. I will believe what I want and you can go on trying to convince someone else that DX11 doesn't matter at all...

  • not sure what is so stupid about saying the 5870 can do DX11 therefor making it better than the 295... but whatever it doesn't seem you are listening.

    Goodbye.

  • why are you talking about a 7900GT?

    What are you getting all worked up about?

  • i never said the 295 could do DX11...

    but it can do DX10 and if a game supports DX11 it will also support DX10...

    so you can compare them

  • I'm just saying that the 5870 is a better card because it supports DX11

    they both preform about the same in DX10 and that is with the 5870 on really early drivers. As the drivers get better the performance will get better.

  • if gtx 295 had a dx11 it will be a best card ,but i think without dx11 its a still a best card

  • If this card preforms better in a game because it has DX11 it is better...

  • when DX11 games start to come out is when the 5870 will start to shine

    if a game supports DX11 it will support DX10 so you can compare the two cards

    Are you sifting through the comments and replying to people who commented like two weeks ago?

  • i mean (fair) :P

  • thats not fare.. 5870(Win7) vs 295GTX(WinVista)

  • nvidia will never be in my good system's the failure rate is just horrific. There are more reman nvidias than originals for sale they has issues and they are not priced that good anyway ati is the better deal price vs performance just like amd is better price vs performance against intel. some company's just dont get it and cant get it right. I agree with latinsoldierb too!!!

  • also i forgot to put in that the 5870 are brand spanking new thus not giving it full performance. Give it a month or so and it will destroy the 295 hands down.

  • I agree

  • I will wait for 5870x2 or 5890, if that will be released

  • Well I didn't change my mind yet but I'm still thinking about it. I was planning on selling my GTX 295 for 200 ( I have a potential buyer) and buying this card for only 150 (assuming it costs 350). I'm comparing the two cards. I like eye-candy and I've heard (yes through comments) that this ATI card has superior Image Quality to the 295. Researching that when I get time. Yea I'm pretty much done with this conversation though.

  • I will buy your gtx 295 for 200, please contact me.

  • in my opinion that you should test games on nvidia and ati archieture to get more reliable benchmark

  • looks to be very good bang for the buck not impressed with asus mars twin gtx 285 soon you'll need a nuclear reactor to run it

  • Whats fast about benchmarks are showing GTX 295 is faster single.

  • Did you see the "Asus Mars" graphic card Nvidia is more faster then the ATI HD 5870.

  • lol i wonder how much better it is them my old 8800gs from xfx XD i wanna up grade

  • I don't understand what you think "Success" means. Since you say whether you buy or not buy isn't part of the equation then you'd probably not know what "success" means. Success means money. Jeez what are you in 3rd grade?

    Success = popularity = money or in other words

    Managing competition (keeping customer base, keeping up with Nvidia) = secure buyers (like Apple) = Successful Marketing (ADs) = Customers (cash flow)

    Thusly gaining confidence from investors = success. Ya understand yet?

  • Hell Yes the 5870 Is One GPU and 295 Dual GPU + 5870 suport EYEInfinity :) Love It Bravoo AMD - ATI Radeon Best Choice and Rullz :P 5 Stars Vot

  • remember the 5870 is a single gpu unlike the 295...

  • Ok lets face it. Nvidia guys will always get nvidia and ati guys will always get ati. In the end, each card gets about the same performance, of course prices vary.

  • Exactly, however I seem to keep going back ATI because they have better value for money. But Nvidia have always had better drivers. I guess it's one of those things where there is no right or wrong choice.

  • True, those 2 differences influence what people usually get, but even then i like nvidia control panel much better, and also there cards seem to be better built.

  • whats better 2 4870 in crossfire or a 5870 ??

    i know 5870 has ps 5.0 and support 4 dx11 but i just wanna know what will be better?

  • there nearly the same,but I think that the 5870 wins

  • Yeah, Well, I agree with that. Nvidia's GTX 295 has dual-GPU, I know, and 5870 has single. So, It's not really fair. But then if Nvidia launches its GTX 300 Series, It will still beat ATIs. Anyway, their battle is just great. Awesome, as well...

  • haha it seemed like you where not trying to sound bias. But your ending could conclude other wise.

  • Why are trubitars video benchs showing the opposite? lol?!

  • Its a gaming card jesus christ. So then if the 5870 is not a gaming card then my 4870 which is highly recommended for gaming is a workstation card too? they are gaming cards. And many technology websites put them up not in workstation cards but in Video gaming cards.

  • You have no Idea what your saying do you Chungman? They 4870 5870 5850 4850 all the 850s and 870s are gaming cards. The ati fireGls and firemv and pros are all workstation. Get your shit straight.

  • You could use them as workstation cards though ;O but then again that applies to everything in a matter of speaking lol

  • and i am always wondering how the workstations would do in the benchmarks.. even though they arent made for that kind of stuff.. it would be intresting

  • I wait ati use havok.

    knock out physx. :D

  • you guys have to remeber though... 5870 is a single gpu card.... now imagine the 5870 x2.......

  • lets see the 295 vs. 5870 in some DX11 games...

  • The Gtx 295 is barely better than the 5870. But the 5870 runs cooler with lower fan speeds than the Gtx 295. And the gtx 295 has more memory.

  • and the Gtx 295 is dual gpu