EXTREMELY NEW! 2011 - Air Crash Investigation - Deadly Reputation (FULL)

[ALBATTAAR]

All over the world I did not see this stupid like this country! , does it make sense to have an international airport and the rate of every 90 minutes there is a landing aircraft and the boarding , resides between the buildings and main streets and petrol station ? !

This is the large number of people around airport,the petrol station the reason for the increase set on fire , causing an increase in the number of dead,Is it possible to keep this airport like this place after the piece ???

[ludocrat]

30.22: That's a reversal of logical probability outcomes. 400 Billion hours of flight (if he really meant that number) makes such a failure much more likely, not less (even if it wasn't what caused this particular accident). You have a 14 million to one chance of ever being killed by a meteorite in your lifetime. If you live long enough, you will be hit by a meteorite! (Just after you won the lottery probably. That's called Sod's Law!!).

[Handiman544]

..."lacked a critical safety feature..." this sounds so familiar in the airline industry. It's all about the money...safety comes next, if at all.

[MidwayCastaway]

Airbus + Third world country = DISASTER.

[VERGIS92]

@MidwayCastaway the plane that made Hudson River Miracle landing possible was an Airbus, its automation flew the plane at minimum speed, without stall, so the pilot could ditch it at minimum impact, let's see how a Boeing could have done it

[KautsarRz]

05:16 seriously which dumbass would named his airliner company "BRA"??

[Pvjinflight]

@KautsarRz Who gives a shit, its not airline from English speaking world.

[Xterminator390]

I dont know why they didnt go around.

[syedilyas33]

avoid this runway...its evil...35 l evil

[chmodgirl777]

Thanks for the upload. You rock!

[qwerty35124]

Which IDIOT designed and constructed this airport and surroundings??....I guess they thought it would be "kool" to have an airport on a hill, in the middle of a city, with a gas station directly facing the run-way....... -___-

[paulo2008dias]

@qwerty35124 did you ever heard the therm City Expansion ??? , I mean when Congonhas was opened for ops there was almost no buildings and surroundings nearby the airport...hope this clarify your non sense comment.

[MrSausagefingers1]

@qwerty35124 No idiot 'designed' it that way. Its due urbanisation of the city surrounding the airport and other contributing localised logistical restraints you simple minded, slack-jawed fuckwit.

[lewfather]

@MrSausagefingers1 EASY BRO LOL ITS THE INTRERNET N00BZ EXIST

[MrSausagefingers1]

@lewfather lol For when a 'thumbs down' is not good enough. deep breaths..and I'm calm..

[azeem150]

@qwerty35124 AMAZING...I'm watching the video shaking my head at the hill, the apartment buildings, the embankment...but when I hear now there's a GAS STATION TOO!!!

[mrmeldrewstuntdouble]

qwerty35124 Considering the notourious reputation of RWY35Left & its immeadiate built up surroundings,you would certainly have expected it to at least have had some basic form of EMAS protection.

But i guess its all down to that awful four letter word again.

COST!!!!!.

Anyway I doubt that EMAS would have saved this flight due to Eng2 being at power & the high speed of the airplane.

EMAS would have certainly made RWY35Left just that little bit safer.

Madness to have a RWY built like that.

[slutingaround]

@qwerty35124 Congonhas dates from 1936, back then the city was not like it is today, so considering that it has been growing a lot, it seems to me that the problem is not the place where it was built, but how the city grew all these years.

[VERGIS92]

they could always install an automatically activated steel rope just before the edge, like navy carriers use

[mjiscool2345]

@VERGIS92 then ALL aircraft would need a drop hook lol

[lewfather]

@VERGIS92 would be hecka cost efficient too bro!!1

[VERGIS92]

what procedure, if you keep your mind on basic physics you need no special procedures

[FIFAflex1]

y didn't the pilot make a go around as soon as he realized they were running out of room?

[fortyninepages]

Damn you, 35L ! DAMN YOU !!

[borichica33mar]

Pilots are SO well trained they become almost "robotic" in re-acting to emergency's.(My personal opinion) In a situation where Most people would scream at the top of they're lungs, Pilots remain relatively calm! But by the same token this "Robotic" reaction seems to keep them from thinking logically, .."Decelerate!!"..."IT CAN'T!!"...Umm...perhaps 'cause it's still acelerating!...Dark cabin? Can't see throttle position?...FEEL FOR IT!...(it's what an untrained person would instintivly & SCREAM!

[mygem01]

RUNWAY 35 HELL

[fancysnake1]

@sertox12345 They couldn't use both air brakes because one was under repair, and you don't understand how much money they would lose keeping that queue closed. It was the pilots fault so make sure you've watched the full video before posting that comment.

[Pvjinflight]

@fancysnake1 They could not use other reversers because it was under repair, both brakes on wheels and speed brakes on wings were working normally.

[fancysnake1]

@Pvjinflight Yes, you've just repeated what I just said.

[MrGameStarr]

@fancysnake1 but the thing is id rather loose alot of money and save 199 peoples lives

[fancysnake1]

@MrGameStarr You're saying the mechanics should have fixed the problem right? I'm not really sure what you're trying to tell me.

[Pvjinflight]

@MrGameStarr Its not mechanics who choose if that kind of thing is fixed. Also flying with one reverse unoperable for some time is not dangerous really.

[sertox12345]

y would you fly a plane with out air brakes wow i am so sick of this report

[sertox12345]

so lets not fix the prob just let humans get killed wow close that run way till all repars are done fuck portugess i am surprised

[sertox12345]

see now you know it a bad run way shut it down or just let very small planes land i dont get it

[zerozhack]

Title should be the HUNTED RUNAWAY 35L/ The RUNAWAY OF DEATH/ THE RUNAWAY OF HELL :D

[Pvjinflight]

@zerozhack Naa that would be annoying dramatization.

[echoshane]

the title of this video should be 35L

[ChorltonBrook]

Who's daft idea was it to put a petrol station at the end of a runway?

[ColdClearNorth]

Does the FDR also contain thurst-control movements? Any hard facts for that? Or do the film makers just speculate that the pilot failed in operating them correctly? I remember it was said earlier in this report that the power of one engine INCREASES. This clearly rules out the estimated scenario.

[Pvjinflight]

@ColdClearNorth All ACI episodes are based on information that has been found in official investigation. And yes I think that FDR does indeed record thrust lever movements, after all its very important flight control.

[bodkins01]

how annoying this episode was to listen too ITS NOT 35L ITS 35LEFT FFS

[idaoutid]

It is the most irritating episode I' ve watched. Showing how they can make a plane company look not guilty.

1) In 33:25 they show what the pilot was thinking just before landing. For christ's sake.

2) In 30:40 they naivly exclude mechanical problem, by just studying one thruttle part (and that destroyed)

3) When the plane kept moving fast, even the stupidest person on earth would have immediately look back to the throttle and see he is doing something wrong. common sense,

[portair12]

just for knowledge, all the cockpit pictures (except thrust levers) are not from an AIRBUS. Also, rwy is called 35L, but it isnt pronounced that way. Its called 35 LEFT. Lots of airports in the world have two parallel rwys, Left and Right.

[ns5036]

@portair12 They just dont appreciate pilots and atc as well as how we do our "things"

[MW2SPECIALOPS]

Short runway, that's why and remember he mentioned buildings surrounding the airport.

[x86br]

@MW2SPECIALOPS I think its Plane fail design. Its extremily hard one pilot forget to back engines trottle to idle.

[EpicWafflezXD]

why don't they just abort the landing, speed up an take off.

[x86br]

@EpicWafflezXD Bcause the rnwy is short, and take long time to reverse roll back to idle, than power up. Better you turn to some side and slide on the grass to a better place.

[Laudan08]

It once happened to me as a virtual pilot on KLAX, instead of using reverse, i throttled both to maximum.

[sopantake]

Thanks syedN07 for sharing...



[sopantake]

There is no evidence that the pilot committed the mistake of not taking right engine to idle.

How can the investigation officers and the human factor engineer blame pilot just on guesses? He might have done this and that...

Its unbelievable.

[portair12]

@sopantake Yes, there is evidence. The black boxes have that info. The cockpit voice recorder (CVR) records all voices in the cockpit. The flight data recorder (FDR) records all flight parameters (ex: attitude, altitude, speed, engine sttings,etc, etc). So, that info is on the FDR.

[joebpw209]

The actor's acting is so fake ... THE RUNWAY IS WET!

[SuperRegal79]

@joebpw209 Cut the crap! It's not some over dramatic crappy special affect hollywood flick that we are forced to pay $15 for at a local theater.Its a documentary.

[djericknaka]

after seeing the comments about this disaster, being a brazilian guy ,I know why they don't do anything to change this dangerous situation at Congonhas Airport

this airport is at the heart of Sao Paulo city and people and businesses need it....the other airport is outside the city, at Garulhos, known as Cumbica International Airport

Also Congonhas doesn't have any space around in order to grow in size, it's surrounded by buildings, streets and stuff

and the most important, MONEY is the big issue

[JosephHua]

If the pilot does not pull back the thrust lever, why would the engine thrust increase on the 2nd engine?

[portair12]

@JosephHua Normal flight on A320 is with thrust levers in the Climb (CLB) position with autothrust (A/THR) ON. Here thrust is managed by a computer (FADEC). They had A/THR ON just until touching the runway (which is normal to do). Just before touch down pilot shall put levers back to IDLE (which disarms A/THR). But if just one is in IDLE and the other in CLB (whith A/THR OFF), the lever which is not in IDLE will accelerate to CLB thrust (A/THR OFF). Thats why engine 2 did accelerate.

[Bhasker100714]

the main issue here is why they permitted 1 thrust reverser to be deactivated hence it is a safety features in every aircraft.....pilots are only human & prone to every errors......

[Feckz1n]

It's such a ridiculous error from the pilot that is unbelievable he has done it.

Runway 35R is much smaller than 35L. 35L is a 1940 m runway and 35R only 1435 m.

Runway 17R is as dangerous as 35L is (are the same runway).

And syedN07 thank you for sharing this whit us.

[Captain9876543210]

I really love what your doing mate keep it up, but i prefer the other narrator not this one

[krazytyme]

@Captain9876543210 I prefer the other narrator too. His voice is kinda creepy, but I like it. It drives the seriousness home. Thnx so much for these uploads, love 'em :)

[CaptainAirline]

the runway should be closed. too much danger. r.i.p. to all who died

[CaptainAirline]

i hope that this runway 35l was arranged. it is easy to say what the pilots should have done but they had a lot of stress because of the 1 thrust reverser+the runway's reputation+bad weather combined a cain of errors leading to disaster. you should try the situation in a proper simulator using the captain's method to see what will you do.

[antwan37]

@CaptainAirline I understand what you say regarding the pilot, but the 1st officer, he says deccellerate, deccellerate repeatedly and doesn't take a glance at the lever position which is on full throttle. How is that possible? should be the first thing to look at.

[Henoik]

I SAW THAT THE RIGHT ENGINE WAS AT 100% IN THE THRUST CONTROLLER IN THE COCKPIT!!!!!!! I KNEW IT!

[Henoik]

I would've abort takeoff and request landing at an alternate airport, or at an other rwy!

[Henoik]

Can't they just close 35L and use the 35R (Well, it will be called 35, then)

[CaptainAirline]

@Henoik but if it is the same runway but a different name it would still pose the same dangers. for me the air port should be closed...

[Henoik]

@CaptainAirline jk

[Henoik]

Please keep publishing ACI videos!

[donnie4393]

incredeiable!!! man 35 L dont know why humans wait for accidents to happen where people die before they change things its ashame. All those people and could have been avoided. :-(

[Ashwin031298]

WHY CAN'T MAKE THEY PLANE OUT THE BLACK BOX MATERIAL?????!!!!!

[toptubz]

@Ashwin031298 it would be hard to get a box shaped plane off the ground.

[andrewreader1979]

@Ashwin031298 Because it would be too heavy to fly.

[AIKfanatik]

Vanessa Dias is verry HOT !!!

[AIKfanatik]

From where is this recorded ? This narator is different from the other seassons,this is almost the same which narrated the first season,if not the same...I know that the canadian original version used other narator than those which was aired in europe,is this the one used in original ? btw thanks a lot,love this show !

[thecrew20101]

i dont see how they can fully blame the pilots when one engine wasnt working properley, the runway wasnt right and was flooded and it was half the length it should be,and flying guidelines were changed, surely these should be factored in for half the blame

[jonvoltage1]

It's a shame that with accidents like this, the only way anyone ever notices the problem is when disaster strikes. The ACI boards are good but the people that inspect runways, aircraft, facilities and procedures are either lacking or just incompetent.

[2002mlanova]

thanks for uploading completely:)

[Alread211]

air crash investigation uses a lot of money to make a episode

[cc1sportingtorver]

About time to!... It took them more them more than 4 years, which, comparing to the Air France recent accident ACI video is a LONG time... still, thanks for uploading!... I'm sure we all remember this terrible accident, although many didn't know WHY - until now.

[bluesky747er]

Thank You for the upload.

[ying20000818]

They could just have gone around if the plane wasn't stopping

[zippyTRG]

@ying20000818 "In any case, if reverse thrust has been applied, a full stop landing must be completed." -Airbus A320 FCTM (Flight Crew Training Manual), Rejected Landing.

Your committed to stopping if you have selected Reverse during landing, as safe flight is no longer possible with the thrust reversers deployed.

[Spacek531]

@ying20000818 A touch and go landing couldn't have happened because they veered to the left

[Nneka1963]

Thanks a million for the upload!

[Bastavalentin]

35 hell!

[nuwaus]

Thanks for the upload.

[tocsa120ls]

First of all, when i was born, the doc did not shout 'Contact-landing', but it irks me to hear "35 ellll".

Shouldn't that be "35 LEFT"?

[MrJackanthony]

@tocsa120ls Haha. right because L could also mean... Lunch?

[MrTimAway]

Why would the old procedure of reverse-throttling only one engine be more efficient and thus stop the plane faster? Surely, airbus would have designed an engine with deactivated reverse-throttle to go into idle by default.

[Bhasker100714]

@MrTimAway agreed....

[iFlyFPV]

thanks for uploading these! YOur AWESOME!

[stonee206]

what's wrong with the narrator??

[benjamiy831]

@stonee206 Is there something wrong? He sounds fine to me.

[yizhakreizman]

thank u vary much kip up the good work and continue more please

[sharppointy1]

Glad I'm not flying to Congonhas in this lifetime....Thanks for the upload.

[Irina55333]

it is awful........................

[John94098]

@Irina55333, yes it is. Sad to.

[syedN07]

I am 1 of the only person who uploaded it full ;) Enjoy!

[orioncheung]

@syedN07 Damn boi!!! =D

[vith1995]

@syedN07 Thanx bro, keep em coming :)

[Orangebike666]

@syedN07 I hate you... How will I ever go back to work when I still have episodes to watch. LOL Thank you for the one stop shop for the episodes!

[krugerfuchs]

@syedN07 yhank you so much you're brilliant

[John94098]

@syedN07, thanks.

[1ELTIBURONN]

@syedN07 yeahhhhh u the best,,keep doing such a ggod job,,,!

[theblacksheep1000]

@syedN07 thats why I subbed to you too!! and will enjoy!

[edxx7]

@syedN07  thanks!!!

[myosat]

Thanks so much for the upload..

[4mymubi]

Thanks.. now we r talking :)