Added: 2 years ago
From: MariahCareyDotCom
Views: 671,562
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (892)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • never get tired of hearing her sing this she has such a lovely voice.

    great song what im wondering is how 313 ppl can dislike this!

    people never do change it is truly sad.

    my favorite song of his is earth song

  • Mariah did an amazing job, she sang very emotionally cuz she knew MJ, those who are hating on her is jelous Madonna stans

  • She was obv close with him so she has soo much emotion in her voice and everything so you can fuck right offf

  • she lost her voice in lyrics?path?

  • It has to be difficult, but she got through it. She didn't break. She's strong, and she's a beautiful person. Wonderful tribute.

  • She´s thinkin about her image even at our biggest legends evers funeral and wearing shit like that! Good Job Mariah!

  • Annotation says "Read the Sidebar >>" ... awww good memories <3

  • I LOVE HER HAIR AND I LOVE THIS SONG

  • ALL THE PPL TALKIN SHIT ABOUT MARIAH NEEDS TO STFU FOR REAL...I MEAN IF U BEST FRIEND DIED DO U THINK U COULD GET UP AND SING AT UR BEST BY HIS/HER BODY?? COME ON

  • Why is there nothing more than dislike?

  • Someone shoot this whale and put her out of her misery, this was a pathetic attempt. She is a defect of human kind.

  • @Jisseppe89 shut up her friend was in a coffin right in front of her! u try singing one of the most popular songs of all time when ur looking at ur friends casket! try and have some consideration and respect ....

  • @559ALTOSAX FIRST He was not her friend. They worked together in MJ and friends, and thats it. MJ compforted MC when she was with all the glitter/fathers death debacle. When MJ needed Mariah to support him when he was fighting against Sony she dissappeared.

    SECOND: Her voice is ruined due to the nodules. She sings like that when trying to reach higher notes now.

  • Mariah Carey WAS , IS & Will be the BEST female singer!

  • Michael fez parte da minha adolecencia e continuara fazendo parte do resto da minha vida, obrigado por tudo...!

  • She was amazing... incredible tone

  • i dont know wether to like this video or not. he passed away and i wouldnt like that. its sad!

  • It is ridiculous that she had to apologize to the people, that shows people are so judgemental and picky. It was a very sad moment. She deserves all the credit to go up there and sing. 100% of you cant even sing in your showers.

  • this song makes me cry

  • saudades do michael jackson :'(.... te amoooooooooooooooo michaeeeeeeel de mais (L)

  • As a huge Mariah fan this is hard to watch :(..it's hard to watch someone you idolize nearly in tears, but she makes it through the song and sounds incredible considering she was fighting back tears

  • SHE'S A MESS!

  • Mj did alot of things for Mimi. He was there for Mariah when she was going thru the hold Tommy thing. I think I think she him as a idol and a really good friend. Can't really blame her. I personally love this so emotional and soulful.

  • Huge kudos! You can see she could've burst into tears any moment. And she managed to finish the song <3 RIP MJ

  • HARD to watch this mimi. . .Love you tho

  • This was a beautiful performance! How can anyone call her out for a lil voice mishap? Id like to hear how well you would sing when you fight tears to sing at a friend's funeral:/

  • Comment removed

  • So beautiful! This was one of the saddest days in the world the day he died.. Along with when Princess Diana died! The two most insperational people in the world.. I love you MJ!

  • I LOVE YOU MARIAH AND TREY LORENZ IS SO AWESOME TOO.

  • PEACE & LOVE

  • I agree!...Celine Dion has too much going on with her nose when she sings and sounds like she's trying to blow some snots out!!!...Celine aka (nasal)...Ha ha ha ha

  • Mariah is one of the best vocalist of alltimes!

    people like her Beyonce, Rihanna, Chrstina,

    Kelly and many more female singer idolizes

    her career and sorry not Celine Nasal Dion,

    who is a fake lipsyncer since 1993 and was

    never really revelant for the music industry...

    such a shitty singer compared really haha

  • @zanoases You know before you slagged off Celine, you had a good point and actually had credibility from my perspective, now you are just a bitter and envious fan of mariahs.

  • ForeverComplaining sorry i talk about truth, celine

    is a not even close talented to mariah and her lol

    stans are bashin aulthough celine is the biggest

    lipsyncin artist in history after britney spears ^_^

  • @zanoases Don't diss Britney Spears bitch. She sings live now.

  • @zanoases 

  • @zanoases fuck you

  • @ChaseSouthpark1998 please biatch stfu, your not even my shit in toilet.

  • Honestly, people overreacted to this performance. Always thought so. Only the first line was bad. From there, it was fine. Sure, she wasn't at her peak level vocal, but it was still a good/fair vocal.

  • The performance wasn't that bad in all honesty. She hit all the notes perfectly and with resonance. Her voice was just a bit raspy.

  • mariah is da best...y'all haters cant do any better...so shut up

  • Wish I could sing with a sore throat! GREAT EMOTION, A+

  • I didn't think it was that bad.

  • Mariah has proved herself and doesn't need to do so anymore. She's an amazing vocalist. She had a bad moment as all singers do. Big woop.

  • I wanna cry

  • Mariah can't sing when it counts the most, she couldn't sing well either at the 9/11 telethon, however Celine Dion always delivers

  • @italo36 omg TWO occasions

  • italo lol oh please you retarded celine stan, please stop makin me laugh, celine is the biggest lipsync fake artist of allimes, there hundred videos on youtube that shows that she lipsyncs on concerts, shows since 1993!! and she had never close difficult songs like whitney and mariah. just shitty ameteur songs compared and lipsyncs 24/7 sorry celine isnt even half talented as mariah,nobody cares for such nasal untalented singer

  • This was beautiful n i was crying rite along w/her, no need for her to ever apologize.

  • @YungMunyBarbie87 she didn't cry

  • @iiAngelic she said she wanted to when she saw the casket.

  • this is edited... i can still remember she started really bad and her voice was so hoarse

  • @ikom35 she was crying at the start

  • @williamomahoney yah, i can still remember during the interview regarding her bad performance. she said it was so hard to sing that time in front of michael's coffin

  • silvester 2010/2011 hat meine tochter ein konzert von michael jackson gesehen auf 3 sat und sie war so begeißtert das sie immer von michael jackson gesprochen hat jetzt hat sie dvds sie hat bilder von 1 straßenkünstler sie liebt seine lieder sie liebt wie er tanzt so jetzt kommts sie is 3 jahre alt das nenn ich mal ein eindruck hinterlassen

  • "I'm sorry that I wasn't able to pull it together and really do it right, but I was literally choked up when I saw him there in front of me"..... *sigh*

    Carey you're voice has DETERIORATED, don't make up lame excuses to deny what's OBVIOUS, it's sounds very DUMB and PATHETIC.

  • kaiyno youre just fuckin christina strainlera stan LOL mariahs shit in

    toilet sounds better then floptina strainlera AKA 24/7 offkeylera, sorry

    that Christina Screamlera cant even sing two notes LIVE without LOL

    sounding like 67 years alcoholic. Just look at anthem WOW hahaha

    totally disaster, grammys and mj tribute! haha she looked like pig who

    yells some choked notes. Her career is so over like FLOP CDS, Vocals

    MARIAH IS ONE OF THE BEST SINGERS OF ALLTIMES AND OFFKEY

    WHORE LOOKIN XTINA NEVER

  • kaiyno what christina whoreleras excuse for yellin on every song?

    what is her excuse copy lady gaga and FLOP harder then any artist

    before her? WHEN SOMEONE VOICE IS DETERIORATED PUSSY

    THEN ITS FLOPTINA OFFKEYLERAS UGLY SCREAMING VOICE!!

    Nobody like that pathetic untalented ameteur whore who kissed lol

    mariah ass!!!!!!!!

  • @zanoases 0:42 "...to you you you you you..."

    ROFLMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO :]

  • @kaiyno i know its hard to now, that Christinas kissed

    Mariah ass, but she doesnt cared, because they many

    copycat asskissers like her. you should make some lol

    promo videos for floptina, her career is just embarresing

    she is called the 24/7 FLOP LOL sit in a TV Show cause

    nobody cares for shitty CD! she couldnt even sell 2 cds!

    LOL ^_^

  • What ashame she felt the need to apologize for true emotion and the overwhelming sadness she was enduring...she deserves gold stars for the bravery she had to come out and sing this song amongst not only the thousands of people present, but the millions around the world watching on T.V. such as myself. She is human!! If I could sing and sound as good as her "worst"...well, then...I'd be happy!! Those sitting in jugement, how about put your money where your singing voice is!!!

  • @catsrock5154 Yeah, I agree with you. I can't sing when I am in emotional pain very good, it's hard, because of the stress and stress causes your vocal chords to tighten up. Mariah did a wonderful job.

  • MARIAH ROCKS!SEX AND DRUGS! K. now i got all of your attention! This is not a concert!!Its a bloody memorial Damn it! People have emotions! Thus, people have times they can't sing properly! >:(

  • she sucks lol

  • @Therightone4u1 you're a spastic lol

  • guys pls check this live version of i'll be there the first girl can sing like mariah's..just search> SOP Tribute to Michael Jackson- I'll Be There

  • I even cried watching this, imagine what she was like singing this live with her idol in a casket below!

  • @TheCelebBubble try to search this...SOP Tribute to Michael Jackson- I'll Be There

  • Clearly was emotional. If you listen to the performance, she got a TON better as i went on. Jeez, give her a break.

  • Rip m.j

  • LEAVE HER ALONE

  • this was the day I cried again in my life, I love you Michael and would give anything to have at least one hi speak with you before you leave.

  • I miss you~Michael~I cried.

  • MARIAH EARNED THE RIGHT TO SING THIS HOW EVER SHE WANTS TO...you sounded good Mimi love you!!

  • She's the only one who can do this song justice.

  • pas mal a coté du maitre !!!

  • shit i cried while watching this!!!! OMG!!!! MIKE! i miss u so much mike!!!

  • I can't even sing that well on a GOOD day. She even apologized for this but her voice is so beautiful!

  • oh..she makes me cry ..

    RIP Michael...I miss you.

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE Stop searching for her videos then, You've commented on most of her youtube videos, which clearly you've searched for. How sad is it that you even talk to yourself with your multiple accounts. Sad, I tell you. Sad.

  • this makes me cry  :, (

  • given the fact that she was emotional, this is a proof of mariah's musicality cos she managed to do that ad lib at 3:40, which is lower than her usual belting vocals. now that's an artist! i still applaud her performance.

  • mj obviously inspired a generation so it's hardly surprising ppl got emotional

  • ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬

    SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC

    ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬

  • @hmmannym fuck u

  • the performance wasn't bad really. it was just sad that he died thats all

  • it must've been tough for mariah to sing this song.

  • @InevitableOpinion

    No I kno that. I mean that its not like this is the end of her career nd she just messed up but she's not bad at singing or anything

  • I'm crying!! I love you Mike. We miss you so much....We never can say goodbye to you Mike.....You stay in our hearts....I WILL BE THERE FOR YOU MJ!!

  • i love mariah .....

  • @MidnightPizzaOrder haha lol screww you

  • 291 ?? nice try bieber , R.I.P Michael we love you <3

  • HD ????????????????????

  • i'm sure it was hard for all of them to sing! knowing MICHAEL JACKSON was laying in a CASKET right in front of me would make me emotional too, and hard to sing.

  • Mariah's voice is amazing nd Idk Wat happened here but every singer has had that one time where they mess up a song.. that doesn't mean its gonna keep happening from there forward

  • she is a beached whale who's voice...like Whitney Houston's was taken for granted ..she can't sing her ass if she wanted too..put her out to the fields to pasture...thank god for trey singing..or this would have been a COMPLETE bust..and it has nothing to do with the funeral..she just can't sing anymore..WHALE.

  • @kosmoboi the voice of ignorance speaks its mind

  • @kosmoboi LMAO at that comment #DEAD

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE What a disgrace and then the bitch went on to say she was sorry hahahaha she can't be sorry i mean she didn't do anything wrong she just worked with what she has A FUCKED UP VOICE i'm sure she gave 100% is just that her voice is gone long gone. Let's just kiss and say goodbye to her let the real queens of the new millenium rule the world amazing how trey lorenz outsang this overrated cow such an amateur tbh

  • @lc0309 I actually felt really embarrassed for her, I remember watching this live and it was just, shockingly awful as you can hear, she was cracking, unable to sustain notes, her high notes were also cracked and off key, what a terrible tribute, I guess thats why they didint ask her back to the new Michael tribute *snaps* !!! and she had the CHEEK to blame her AWFUL STRAINED OFF KEY vocals on MJ's death, how low is that ? just disgusting tbh

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE Did you watch @cowriahslutarey new video?it is amazing

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE It's funny because even though this is probably Mariah's worst performance, it's still better than anything Christina Aguilera could do - ESPECIALLY with this song!

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE LOLOL Speaking of OFF KEY and CRACKED performances, did you see CHRISTINA'S awful 'tribute'?! She ruined two perfectly good songs! HAHA.

  • @kosmoboi haahahahahahahahahaha i love reading comments from idiots like you. and people wonder why american's are stereotyped as stupid blondes

  • @sanantonioboozers were ignorant darn it get it right!

  • @sanantonioboozers I have brown hair...I don't get it...lol..

  • She almost cried when Trey sang "Michael." The look on her face was so sad. It made me get emotional too, just watchin git 2 years later.

  • @Raimundo91 she almost cried cause she knew she BOTCHED that performance...she is a whale.

  • I will still never understand the "Thank you, Jesus."

  • REST IN PEACE michael Jackson

  • RIP Michael

    Never forget

  • I cried while watching this!! We will never forget you!! R.I.P The king!!!

  • Mariah Carey has Justin Bieber hairstyle here

  • @TheJan2988 WTF WHO CARES ?????

  • actually mimi's performance is not really bad, it was just not really good...

  • You know what? I think mariah proved here that she can still sing a full live performance. The first part has a little problem but the rest was a blast.

  • Michael....2 years ago i was watching this, devasted....

    I couldnt believe what the world was celebrating.....you were suposed to be here/there. With us....singing...bringing magic, love and your soul through the all the things you did.

    "i'll be there to protect you...and RESPECT you"

    No one has ever made this efect in my life and i know that nobody else will.

    You got my heart, forever.

    RIP - that's all for L.O.V.E. and love lives forever

  • she was crying dumbasses, stfu -__-

  • She is clearly emotional. And really, could anyone perform perfectly when their icon's CASKET is right in front of them? I know I sure couldn't. Usher didn't either. She had true emotion and that's better and more real than a "pitch-perfect" performance.

  • @musicbizgrl funny..the 12 yr old Shaheen did..and did a better job than she did..go figure..she is a whale who cant sing anymore..and THAT MY FRIENDS is a fact.

  • @kosmoboi And you, "my friend" have no way of knowing that he felt the same way that she did about Michael at that moment. His casket had JUST been brought out. She knew him. Shaheen, though he may have admired Michael, did not. I notice you said nothing of the others who cried through their performances either. And the immature comments about her weight just mean you have no other real argument to stand on, so I'm done here.

  • @musicbizgrl you are DONE is right..talk about having NO argument...you are the one assuming who is feeling what..just because she KNEW him she was MORE emotional..I LAUGH at you...millions who never knew him shed tears!..she lost her "real' voice years ago when she had that crash and burn movie and GLITTER..(I cringe)..my argument is not about her crying or NOT CRYING (which she didn't)..my argument t is that she has lost her voice and THIS performance SUCKED! please deal with it and MOVE ON.

  • @kosmoboi : I am SOOOOOOOOOOOO sorry but I have to disagree...I didn't hear anything wrong with her voice NOR did I see anything wrong with her performance BUT hey YOU are entitled to YOUR opinion...She still sounds the same to me and I've been a fan for YEARS...But to each its own...PEACE!

  • @DaPeaceSeeker she is fat.

  • @musicbizgrl thats bullshit she cant sing full stop ....stop making excuses for her

  • @zzDoyler shut up hater she probably sings better than u ever could

  • @IMuMussi no

  • Peace & Love...

    RIP Brother

  • I still think the Illuminati kill him :(

  • God I love her. If it wasn't for this performance, I wouldn't have known of this song's existence. Its a great song! Thanks Mariah and thanks Michael!

    Btw...this is not a bad performance

  • I truly don't see what she had to apologize for, she wasn't bad.....

  • dude i Criedd when i saw this lol

  • Shut up, you know she is an amazing singer. She has a five-octave vocal range you idiots. She was emotional that's why it wasn't her best.

  • This moment makes me so sad..not just because the king of pop died, but my mom was fighting cancer then and lost the battle 2 months later. It just brings back memories, sitting in the hospital with her while this is going on.

  • Its hard for everybody to sing great at a funeral..she was just emotional god give ha some slack...it was a funeral not an awards show...Mariah is One of the Best Female Vocalist and Singers in the World and <3 Her....

  • "Thank you, Jesus!" lololol xD That's so american and corny.

    Didn't perform well.. uh-oh, better call on Jesus so no one will get mad xD

  • @thomaserex It's a funeral, not an awards show. She said "Thank you Jesus" because she's Christian and believes Michael is in Heaven.

  • Ok, so Mariah did not hit those notes when needed, but she was not out of pitch.

  • It is hard to sing when you are fighting back sincere tears.

  • 2:35 AMAZING!!

  • I think she did a great job under the circumstances!

  • if you always listen to mariah .. you will know that she sounds good in this one..

  • It's not much bad. I prefer she sing BYe Bye... XD

  • What is everybody talking about? THAT GURL SUNG THAT SONG!!!!

  • ela relmente é sensacional possui uma belissima voz

  • :(

  • This performance was far from terrible...... Get a life people....

  • What spoil sports, thumbs down to all you people talking shit, making Mariah feel like she has to apologize for not being perfect doing a tribute song. For shame.

  • i like when she sings " thank ya jesus"

  • it was not a bad performance it was mj's funeral she did her best for him he would v been happy that so many ppl cared about him. my thoughts go to prince , paris and blanket for there loss of a father . almost 2 years ago x

  • When uve been crying or upset, it will alter ur vocal cords obv ... or if ur upset the tension will stay in ur throat ! ....... I think she sounded amazing ! She did a really diff thing, they were very good friends ...

  • who wouldnt be all choked up i mean if ya knew that she was cryin before she came out to sing she was an emotional wreck ..... and didint think she could sing ya need to stop judginfg so much cause ijm sure ya far from perfect..... and ya def far from mrs mimi

  • she brought it home in the end :)

  • i'm cryin!!!!! :(x michael u rock 4eva en alwayz!

  • god give her a brake shes full of emotion, it is a funneral

  • The KING Honored by the Queen.MJ and Mariah FORVER Ever!!! Two Legends!!!

  • This performance is not even close to bad considering the fact that she was on the verge of tears while she was singing.

  • id like to see anyone who truly loved Michael belt out a perfect performance of that song without a single crack. she was holding back tears for christ sakes. Give her a break. Thumbs up MC. RIP MJ i still miss you after all this time

  • i lost my mum in dec 08 and this song was playing in my head when i lost her and losing micheal that i thought i was going to died and watching this left me heart broken all over again

  • try to sing with heart broken and tears in the eye, I think her performance wasgreat and is irrelevant if it was not perfect

  • real emotion is a wonderful thing to see at moments like this... i think she recovered quite well... and to keep it together at such a disasterous heartbreaking time for any of these artists is something we should commend them on! Mariah... u have no reason to apologize for showing real emotion... ur a beautiful lady and the way u show emotion to start off the memorial was something everyone should appreciate... i dont think it couldve began in a better way!

  • im gonna play this song for my mom

  • first, If I were Mariah, I would be very nervous, because my performance will be the start up for the Memorial, because MJ was the biggest super star, the King of Pop of the world. And women can't control feelings very well like men and Mariah was inspired by MJ, so with his pass by, she's just can't keep it together, she was like falling apart

  • this video just makes me want to cry..i never paid any attention to michael jackson until he died,,i wish i got to go to one of his concerts..i remember the day he died and i was watching the news, i wanted to cry even tho i bearly knew who he was.. now everytime i watch this or anyother michael jackson video i just want to cry, he was a great and caring person who deserves all the love in the world for everything he has done.i will forever and always love him and never forget him..

  • Michael :'( the KING we love you

  • @fanMJthebest that's right. We love you more Michael.

  • Bless Mariah. 

  • The best is : 2:34-2:45

  • I was in holiday in curacao when this was broadcasted, i remember i sat in the restaurant of my hotel watching this and i had to hold my tears... it just so emotional....

  • MARIAH CAREY IS THE BEST

  • @jassi611  No michael jackson was the best

  • @TimDre agreed :)