Added: 1 year ago
From: mattrantcom
Views: 122,628
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (362)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • which playsport is it?

  • kodak beat the odds

  • lolol flip ultra hd users can suck a dick.

  • @HC32KING I used the flip ultra to shoot the music video on my page. Nothing spectacular but people swore it wasn't the flip. Check out the video that comes on. Some of the camera matters, but it a lot of the editing. These days with After Effects/Premiere, etc. A flip will get you far

  • to me the kodak was the better for outdoors and the flip was better for indoors.

  • Play sport is better I just ordered the Burton model for snowboarding

  • i think the kodak zi8 is better lol

    with this 2 about the same playsport looks better in daylight but is preety bad with night vision while flip hd doesent have priblem with night vision

    overall i think flips better because theyre preety even in quality but flips better in night and is easy to use

  • Flip:

    Shaky

    worse quality

    PlaySport:

    Bad Night Vision

  • What generation are both of these camcorders?

  • playsport wins..sharper picture Much beter image stabilization

  • kodak looses in low light enviroments

  • '

    kodak is better video than flip

  • Kodak just took a giant shit on Flip!

  • The white balance is off in the Kodak most of the time so that explains the "blue". Idk if that's adjustable. Also exposure indoors doesn't do a good job for the Kodak. All in all this is a dumb comparison because all we're comparing is the camcorders' auto detect features and not actually "quality". A low light test can probably be the best comparison to tell you which camcorder succeeds.

  • The videos on the Kodak are horrible when you put them on the computer!

  • although I noticed Flip Ultra's videos as I am watching this is little bright..I mean it catches the scene in brighther mode than Kodak's..but Kodak is more HD i think video quality wise

  • Flip Ultra's video is little shaky and not as clear as that of Kodak Playsport on the left...I think Playsport rocks!!!

  • wich playsport are you using? The zx3 or the zx5? I'm thinking of buying one myself. Thanks for a great comparison, liked it alot! :)

  • @888Henke I just ordered the zx5 a few days ago! should get here soon... I did alot of research as to which one would be better, and I concluded to buy the zx5!

  • WTF 0:32 see the differences?!

  • @BronzeGamer7 well, the kodak playsport is meant for outdoors :P

  • So which one is TRULY the better one?

  • I just bought the kodak playsport and i was having the same problem as JaredvaldezTV i have an older computer and a while back i bought an HD camrea and filmed in 720 60hp and also 1080 . i was wondering if the kodak playsport i just bought maybe an hour ago will work in just plain 720. let me know thank you

  • The video doesnt flow smoothly at all with this camera! If I am doing something wrong them please tell me but when i fimed in 1080 the video does not keep up with the sound and is not smooth AT ALL! I have it in 1080p and it plays ok on the recorder but not when on computer with any video player! You drove a car and the scenery moved by quick but with mine all i did was pan around the outside real slow but it doesnt play back like i recorded it! help me out please!

  • @panjok2 Many older computers aren't powerful enough to play HD video smoothly, especially 1080p. I picked up a refurbished Dell Latitude 620D laptop for $220 a while back. It's able to play 1080p videos perfectly, even without a dedicated graphics card.

  • @panjok2 wich camera do you have?

  • @madacomachine kodak playsport is the camera I have and if this is in response to my comment about it not playing smoothly I already found out the problem. My computer was working in overload so it wouldnt play the video smoothly at the time but now all is ok! I love the playsport now!

  • I received one of these at a kings of leon video shoot because i was a fan and they had 40 of us fans come to the making of the video and stand in as extras and they wanted us to film our view of the shoot so they could use it in the second video which was the making of the back down south video! I have one BIG problem with the recorder! When I ilmed in 1080p the video is un-watchable because it is not smooth at all! when u watch u hear the sounds but the video doesn't keep up with the sounds

  • @panjok2 Hey, could it be that your computer is not powerful enough to play back 1080p smoothly since it takes alot of processing power to play back high resolution HD videos. Have you tried connecting the Playsport to your TV which HDMI or whatever it has and testing it on there?

  • @Hivemind5747 Ya that was the problem! actually my computer plays it fine now! I had just download a bunch of stuff so i think my computer was working in overload so the video wouldn't play but now I love this video recorder! thanks for the help!

  • bought a zx3 on the basis of this vid...very pleased...

    ta

    and didnt need dodgy underwater vid of women in swimwear....

  • bought a zx3 on the basis of this vid...very pleased...

    ta

  • i use these kind of cameras in my car, at racetracks.

    i had Flip Ultra HD gen2 for 2 year last month, i was satisfied with it.

    this month i traded it in, got Kodak Zx3. it seems to be better, it has 1080p and 720p 60fps. it can also take pictures. but watching this vid, the only thing i dont like about the kodak is the light exposure at night. i wonder if i can turn off the light sensitivity..

  • The New Flip Ultra HD 3rd Gen is actually pretty impressive you guys be the judge but i'm verrryyyy satisfied with it :)

  • playsport is WAY BETTER

  • Why do I always buy stuff and THEN watch reviews on it? :) LOL... Anyway, looks like I made a good choice, I do have the Kodak Play Sport, and its awesome. The low light isnt the greatest (made for outdoor use so..) and no macro. I came to the exact same conclusions, but for only 130 bucks at Wal-mart...and its can go underwater 10 feet?!? You cant beat it. Its the best camera all around out there right now.

  • This is how a fly can see.

  • so i guess the only downside is lowlight. good to keep in mind. thanks

  • @tijsnl the video quality is very similar but the zi8 has macro focus and an external mic plugin. The playsport is waterproof (yes it really is I've tried it) but you lose the macro focus and external mic plug. Either is a great choice.

  • great comparison, usually these clips containt different. this is great, im looking for a good small camera, whats the difference between a zi-8 and a playsport? anyone? thanks!

  • Playsport kicks ass, i bought it on amazon and will be here this week hopefully i love it

  • Very useful, thanks a lot

  • I actually bought the Playsport 20 minutes ago. It's charging right now. Can't wait to plop it into my motorcycle helmet and film. :)

  • @dazzelya i'm in the 20 minutes buying zone too!

    Will recharge in 2 minutes!

  • @rush2death

    Sweet, I've used it nearly every day for 3 weeks now and I'm pretty pleased. I did however buy the little macro lens you can find online. I needed a slightly wider angle when in my helmet.

  • @dazzelya

    (Eh, it's called the mini wide angle/macro lens and it's magnetic.)

  • @dazzelya LOL I've bought it too!

    Can't wait to try it out, and i'm pretty pleased with my first day with My PSK ''Thats the name i gave her. LOL''

  • SO HELPFUL

  • Thanks so much for the comparison. I was torn between the two, but leaning towards the playsport because of the price ($108 vs $180), and now I know I want the Playsport.

  • is that quarter horse still there? cause we got one like that and it might him

  • yeah, I used to want the flip till my gf got the playsport and said it was amazing, then i watched this video and now my mind is definately set

  • This is an excellent comparison! I was looking to buy one of these two camcorders, and you've helped make the decision much easier. Thanks for doing this!

  • Very informative. Thanks!! I recently bought a Playsport, so I won't be shocked at low light issues. Outdoors and driving/motorcycling should be awesome. Blessings.

  • Screw this,I'm getting a cannon 550d :)

  • @alrightproductions11 Screw that, I'm getting a Panasonic HS900K. Filming on a DSLR? Seriously?

  • @3Z3K13L08 Hi, can you point me to a good quality comparison video that pits a camcorder against a dslr of the same price range? Ive been hearing what you say recently, that dslrs are fine but to shoot video (not pics) its better to get a camcorder, but, I have never seen the evidence...

  • @alrightproductions11 Yeah, thats what I did too... by adding $700 to my budget. Its obviously in another market. My 550D is great for adjusting focus, aperture and shutter speed, but I cant run with it or handle it with one hand, neither take it underwater.

  • @omgtkseth Well you already have a 550D so it's a moot point. For a potential buyer in the market for a pocket camcorder, than the Kodak ZX5 is the camera for them, not a DSLR with video function. The DSLR world is, and will always be about still photography. The video function is handy, and that's it. Noting will beat a dedicated video camera for filming. Just like nothing will beat a DLSR for shooting stills. My point? Buy a dedicated product for what you need, it will do it very well.

  • @alrightproductions11 yeh since they're in the same price range.. idiot

  • @alrightproductions11

    Try jumping into a lake with that canon 550d!

  • Kodak playsport is so much better! I own both cameras and I have grown to lov the playsport alot.

  • how good is the playsport for still photos and can you upgrade the memory by slotting in a bigger SD card? Thanks.

  • When I hook my playsport up to the T.V. with the cable connector to watch the recorded video, theres a time meter on the top of T.V. screen above the video. Is there a way to remove that? Thanks.

  • Which generation Flip Ultra is this?

  • kodak better

  • wow this helped me decide to get the playsport over Flip...

    Thank you so much!

  • Thank you so much for this comparison. This definitely just sealed the deal for me!

  • wow the playsport has a clearer image.

  • Kodak software auto loads when you first plug the PlaySport into your computer. It takes a bit of getting used to. Movies are created in .MOV format. The software will convert it to .AVI so it CAN be used in Windows Movie Maker. The file conversion is slow unless you have a newer, faster computer. At first I hated the Kodak software, but now I dig it. Very easy to use, puts together very viewable movies fast and easily. Finalizing the movies is slow but overall it's very acceptable.

  • @srfnff soundl like a load od crap to go through just to upload video to YT.

  • @srfnff So your computer will convert the .MOV format to .AVI by itself?

  • @srfnff How do you convert the video file to AVI ?

  • @srfnff does it automatically compress for youtube? If not, how do you with the software?

  • @BlogsbytheDay I can't specifically answer that, i.e. I don't really know if it compresses for utube. I've uploaded movies to utube with no problem. I primarily use vimeo now and there is no problem at all. The mov to avi conversion is actually done in the software. I also use wmm primarily now which is glitchy but free and full of basic features that allow for decent movie editing and production.

  • Great review and comparison. I've been doing lots of research on the PlaySport and my conclusion is that it is primarily an OUTDOOR camera. (Duh. PlaySPORT, like sports mostly done outside.) Your review and comp really confirmed that for me. I've got one I'm using now on a trial basis. I shoot mostly outdoors, in the surf of people surfing. The camera doesn't do well in low light early mornings or late evening. Still and video images are soft and grainy. But in brighter light it is tops. Thx

  • My question, which flip ultra hd is it? theres like 3

  • the way the playsport records at night really bothers me. i almost would consider flip's slightly lesser quality than playsport if it means you can see it better at night.

  • Got the Playsport and the video quality is better than my Lumix ZS3

  • kodak playsport wins hands down even though the flip get more light but it does not get the natural color playsport has so much better color

  • i bought a playsport a few months ago. its working well for me so far

  • i really want playsport now. but i wanna know if the playsport works on windows movie maker? i still had doubts on flip even with their video commercials on tv

  • @f5yeangel5 So, my play sport doesnt work on Windows Movie Maker, and the editing system it comes with is horrible!

  • Thanks, that was super helpful!

  • playsport it is, cheers.

  • flip sucks ass and its so cheap feeling

  • win Flip Ultra HD (for me)

  • @hazelhoff18 you are blind?

  • Somebody just slaped their mom becuase they saw this video and asked for a flip for christmas

  • did you film the playsport with 1080p or 720p?

  • STAND STILL

  • From what I've seen, the Flip washes most scenes out, and that's only kinda helpful in low light situations.

  • OMG OMG OMG, .... I didn't know where I was going with that, but I was definetly going for the playsport even b4 the video, the flip just sucks, don't believe me? I guess you didn't watch the video. Plus, Playsport can shoot 1080p, flip cannot, so it's up to you, just wastin like 100 bucks on nothin, no big d

  • OMG OMG OMG, .... I didn't know where I was going with that, but I was definetly going for the playsport even b4 the video, the flip just sucks, don't believe me? I guess you didn't watch the video. Plus, Playsport can shoot 1080p, flip cannnot, so it's up to you, just wastin like 100 bucks on nothin, no big d

  • I'm returning my Flip tomorrow so I can enjoy the higher (and more appreciated) versatility of the Playsport. The Flip may work better in some instances, but if this video is accurate, I'm certain the Playsport will serve me much better. 

  • Kodak Playsport is amazing i jsut got it. it can handle alot fo things even being roughhandeld and it has alot better low lighting :)

  • @MoRGnFX

    You got that the other way around. Flip has a lot better low light video capturing capability.

  • I wonder why they didn't try the under water test... Oppss I forgot the Flip would drowned if they do that... Kodak playsport...Another Best way to go if you like water sport or just to have fun @ places were water don't make u stop from having a nice video memory...

  • So i should buy the Playsport, if i want to film american football?

  • i have the flip ultra hd,

    i shuda got the playsport....

  • play sport kicks ass i got it and this vid convinced me between the 2

  • Playsport wins all tests

  • PlaySport WINS.

  • all flip camcorders are fitted with f2 lens...its the more expensive lens than f2.8 or f3.5.

  • play sport so good

  • The Flip is so 2008 The kodak playsport is so 2011.

  • kodak doesnt shot in 1080p, it does 1080i (interlaced). its like 720p boost. there is no way kodak will put a high quality 1080p cmos sensor in this little cam. the kodak has poor quality in 1080 setting, you have to use the 720 setting. the big feature of the kodak is its waterproofing. these cams has advanages and disadvanages but i think the flip is ez simple and it uses .mp4 unlike kodaks outdated .mov

  • Flip is the winner

  • kodak is better

    

  • @chriskaterful no its not, r u blind??

  • @300kike are you?!?

  • @AdamBombStudios Am I what?

  • Just got one got Xmas!! I'm using it A LOT!!

  • Txs mattrant, this helped me to ditch any flip aspirations.

    I did the obvious and got the kodak Playsport. :-)

    You made one of the clearest most versatile comparisons there are.

    I would donate any flip for scientific research Lol.

  • playsport is much beteer and stonger when you drop the flip of the strairs he is death as shit and when you drop your playsport he still not death so

  • @Hardstyle4love learn to talk

  • winner by knockout!KODAK!PLAAAAAYYYYYYYS­POOOOOOORRRT.

  • As I can see the Kodak is much better outdoors than indoors. I am glad I got a Kodak Playsport yesterday. You could just setup some lighting indoors and you will have an amazing result as well. I just uploaded a 1080 HD video to my youtube channel using the playsport and it looks pretty amazing when you watch it at 1080HD. I wish it was sunny today so I could do some recording outside but I will upload other video to my channel soon. Thanks Kodak for this great and inexpensive camera!!! =)

  • @goyamoon2006 it does not shoot it 1080p

  • I'm glad I ordered the ZX3 today :)

  • @kawaihui it sucks, the flip is way better

  • Split screen comparison is great.

    Low light for the Kodak is a challenge (u can compensate w/ video-edit software though). Outdoors or in good light: Kodak blows the Flip away. But, you can't use the Flip under water or in the rain, etc.

  • peace full town dude where is it

  • Kodak working it's image stabilization.. :D

  • WOW. What cool Informative comparison. This sums up hours of comparing numbers and ratings. A+ for effort.

  • do both have an attached light or something for night time?

  • How do you import kodak videos on to youtube?

  • @SplufySocks you upload them onto ur comp. then to youtube lol simple

  • @xxBuLLet4Metalxx but i cant edit it or anything and when i try and put it on youtube it has audio but no video?

  • I bought he flip. and went to BB to compare Flip with Playsport. Decided to return the Flip and purchase the Playsport. I hope that the low light ratings are not an issue for me. If in the house... guess just turn on more lights! The apples to apples comparisons of both Flip & Playsport, My observations : Playsport wins. If Kodak could only improve the low light situation I think they may have an almost perfect mini cam!

  • In a world that is covered in water I would go for... the Flip. Jk

  • Someone should show this to the Jon channel.

  • wow that just helped a lot!

  • Before I saw this video I thought the Flip looked better as far as quality. The Playsport is waterproof and is just cool looking overall, plus the Playsport is alot cheaper compared to others. Lowlight is the only dis-advantage.

  • @xfactoruk2004 put ur flip in water then see what hapens

  • it looks like the playsport has a wider view than the flip

  • The Playsport is a lot more crisp than the Flip

  • @Bigglysmalls Definetly

    

  • Btw r u able to edit the videos of the Playsport on the computer?? Some people r telling me u can't edit but I'm pretty sure u can.. :/ can u?

  • @RTSplayer7 yes

  • @RTSplayer7 Been wanting to no the same thing

  • Thanks very much for this comparison, (even though I dont own either one yet

  • i think on the blue sky part the flip ultra hd gets just for that point, but for over all useage and the fact you can upgrade the momory to 32gb sdhc card the playsport wins it for me

  • Just ordered my playsport oh yeah!!

  • playsport wins by a long shot!!!

  • KODakk!!!!

  • kodak looks a lot better, didnt do as good indoor, but every other situation the contrast and fram rate looked superior. I have the kodak playsport now, this video helped me make my decision. I use it for outdoors mainly anyway, climbing mountains is my main use for it and that includes the possibility of it being out in rain and snow so kodak is better for that respect too.

  • Thumbs up if Kodak is better!

  • I think the Kodak is better. One thing I noticed was the Flip was very shaky. Then again the Kodak also makes the sky seem more white then it is. I am going to get the Playsport.

  • Flip is still better... yay.

  • @mankasban dude its not

  • kodak is much better the flip looks faded, anybody with can see that

  • so which one would you say is good kodak playsport or flip ultra hd

  • 'Flip better with stereo sound!

  • Is this a 3rd Generation Flip?

  • How big is your memory card? How much video fits on memory card (I know it depends on video quality, but tell me what you've experienced)? How long does the battery last? Thanks!

  • kodak is more crisp

    you can always adjust the brightness

  • You forgot 2 'by-design' tests - drop in snow and toss in river.

    Playsport wins!

  • @jeffsprayer true but there is a flip waterproof case

  • @MrLaxdude89 I just checked... and the waterproof case is another $250.00+ not worth it.

  • @MrLaxdude89 but it's 250.00 dollars so playsport wins

  • @tjseid its 179.

  • @jeffsprayer lol that test is to advance for the flipHD

  • I've been looking into which camera was better of these two for months, and never saw something that could really show the difference.

    Thanks!

    I cant wait to get the Kodak Playsport!

  • nice horses

    oh yeah, really useful, thanks!

  • nice horses

  • I like the playsport looks like a clearer picture

  • @BasketballKaya1995 lol you know its true. Good question, whats the audio in comparison, would you mind doing a video for the audio quality? Great video, pretty much sealed the deal for which camera im going to buy. Thanks

  • ok..so we know now the kodak video is better in light..flip is better in dim light...what about AUDIO??? i saw a video of someone using a flip at a concert and the audio was great..hows the kodak in live music situations??

  • @shogunwarrior32 the kodak has much better audio

  • 1 person just got a flip before watchin this video

  • @BasketballKaya1995 return it

  • @BasketballKaya1995 i just did too :( gonna return it

  • flip is better in the dark

  • IS the flip ultra hd 3rd gen better than 2nd gen

  • @Emelec18 there about the same

  • What a great video!! You can't argue these results.. Wondering why big "review" companies don't do this like CNet?

    Kodak it is for me!