This song was one of the songs that cemented me as a Porcupine Tree/SW fan, forever...beyond beautiful...beyond anything else they had done previously...
@muraliavarma I think you have it backwards. I think this song is from the perspective of someone who actually had the chance to sell out but didnt and then regretted it. He says "I should have sold out when the devil came for me" which implies that he didn't actually sell out but turned it down. If you read the lyrics it seems to imply that hes waging his war with himself because of regret and waves at the dots on the shore that represents his possible fame if he had taken
@ajkfrty7 I seriously doubt it's a reference, they say 'Soul' in tons of their stuff. In Absentia is about serial killers, but this song is more about regret, etc.
co oni mi robią z głową ? to kolejny utwór porcupine tree który mną zawładnął i nie odpuszcza . jak już się w to wpadnie długo nie da spokoju , jak narkotyk . uzależnia i każe cały czas siebie słuchać.a ja pokornie poddaje się temu i z wyrazem głębokiego błogostanu na twarzy słucham . thanks :)
Put this on as you go to sleep, you will be dreaming in no time. When the music ends you will suddenly wake up and realise you were never asleep, hit restart!
Kind of surreal.A mix between trance and ballad.With that trancy organ intro,very beautiful, to sad lyrics sung very very sadly,the song is a classic irony when it talks about being optimistic(buying new soul) in THAT dejected fashion.A tribute to the hopeless and 'those who disappeared'
Some people have already talked about it here, but I want this to be upvoted so more people can see this. The song is probably about how an artist gets a writer's block and sells out to the devil (money) and "be happy". But he doesn't. He still wages and rages his little war. He is a shade and easy to ignore. That is why this is on the obscure Recordings album. If this song becomes famous, it would defeat the purpose of the entire piece. How sincere must they be to create something like this...
Had to privilege to see them in October 2009, House of Blues Boston MA. Quite possibly the greatest show I had ever witnessed. They played this Song and Russia on Ice and I was in a complete and humble trance.
The only thing wrong here is the photo, because it is not Gavin Harrison playing the drums in this song. I heard Gavins version of the song live and I must say... it fails compared to this original version. And I am a big admirer of his playing. The drum track makes a big point in this fantastic song. Being a drummer myself this drum track gives me shivers up and down my spine.
Sitting alone in my apartment, headphones blocking out random noise, lights dimmed and Ive just got my Porcupine tunes taking my mind places. Been a good night! Love this song, but I love the live version from In Absentia better.
I only just started to explore this band, a few weeks ago (although, i was aware of their existence), and with each 'new' track i find, i can't help but think that this is possibly the greatest band in the world, ever... \m/ (:o)
@peacelovehominy 2 dislikes...... probably whining kids who don't understand or appreciate true music and listen to the shit spewed out of the rectal-eternal radio
This is definitely the most beautiful song they've ever released, if not the best song. I can listen to this over an over again and it still sends chills down my spine.
This is one of my favorite PL'song. Just love the emotional landscape (can I say that) built all around the whole song.. They're pure genius ! I think PL is one of the best alive bands ! it's damn well tuned with the actual world'spirit Emotion'sickness..
@TheRythmestick What if the song is actually about the talented artists who don't go mainstream and thus so many good songs remain obscure? Maybe this song was made to prove the point that such a good song is not to be heard by everyone.
Ripoff of Burning My Soul.
MIKEPORTNOYING 9 hours ago
How to take picture for your album artwork:
Step 1 - Stand in a mysterious and vacant area of nature.
Step 2 - Look in a random direction so it seems like you're too cool to notice that you're on the cover of an album.
It's true!
bnanacheese2 4 days ago
wow!! just... I have a new favourite band!
XkpaxX 1 week ago
OMG...I got them now. It took me time to understand the lyrics but now..its indescribable!! So great!!
rakeshbhatia986 2 weeks ago
This song was one of the songs that cemented me as a Porcupine Tree/SW fan, forever...beyond beautiful...beyond anything else they had done previously...
fathomspace7 2 weeks ago
@PatFromHell lol i was listening to pink floyd before i came here :P
themanwithnobutt 3 weeks ago
anuff said
prayer912 1 month ago
escuchar esta canción es como abrir una puerta por donde entra la luz del sol, mi oscuridad se ilumina de nuevo!!!
Porcupine Tree en Chile!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hakwind100 1 month ago 2
The new Pink Floyd. Yes indeed.
PatFromHell 1 month ago 3
@PatFromHell They're themselves Porcupine Tree not the next anything else.
coolins112 6 days ago
taken it*
jesusjuice15 1 month ago
@muraliavarma I think you have it backwards. I think this song is from the perspective of someone who actually had the chance to sell out but didnt and then regretted it. He says "I should have sold out when the devil came for me" which implies that he didn't actually sell out but turned it down. If you read the lyrics it seems to imply that hes waging his war with himself because of regret and waves at the dots on the shore that represents his possible fame if he had taken
jesusjuice15 1 month ago
Class..!!
pnp8686 2 months ago
"woke up and I had a big idea
To buy a new soul at the start of every year
I paid up and it cost me pretty dear
Here's a hymn to those that disappear"
It sounds like a reference to human trafficking. he metions "soul" in this song and color flow in mind. might be a reference to strip the soul?
I hope I'm perceiving Porcupine tree's lyrics incorrectly.
Brilliant music.
ajkfrty7 2 months ago
@ajkfrty7 I seriously doubt it's a reference, they say 'Soul' in tons of their stuff. In Absentia is about serial killers, but this song is more about regret, etc.
uchihaitachi888 1 month ago
Easily the best song I've heard in years - he captures the dark emotion of Pink Floyd and adds greater musicianship.
andrewh817 2 months ago
Can't get the CD with this song, bummer!
Myanleader 3 months ago
co oni mi robią z głową ? to kolejny utwór porcupine tree który mną zawładnął i nie odpuszcza . jak już się w to wpadnie długo nie da spokoju , jak narkotyk . uzależnia i każe cały czas siebie słuchać.a ja pokornie poddaje się temu i z wyrazem głębokiego błogostanu na twarzy słucham . thanks :)
TheLynx2008 3 months ago 3
I think I'm possessed by this song. I keep coming back to listen to it o_O
pawsoned 3 months ago
I saving money to buy my brand new high end stereo equipament to listen songs like this one....awesome!!!
thealieninme 3 months ago 7
@thealieninme I'm glad you like it :-)
Kneipp 3 months ago
@thealieninme me too. and also buying genuine cd/vinyls for better sound :)
thats how real music should be listened.
You know what Roger Waters (Pink Floyd) said once? "Our music should only be listened on a stereo heavy enough only 2 men can lift it up"
something like that
Pintoleite3 3 weeks ago
great song to listen before sleep...
theAgnesita 4 months ago 4
My favorite song... ever!
PrickyKorv 4 months ago
how much new soul cost?
TheOsirix12 4 months ago
@TheOsirix12 Pretty dear :D
ClassicalGuitarRulez 3 months ago
the live version is much more sensual i find...
alfalex38 4 months ago
@alfalex38 Right... and Wesley's solo is such beautiful
ClassicalGuitarRulez 3 months ago
It reminds me, Im fuckin mess
jerikooxh 4 months ago
not only yours...Very Strong song
divinesalvia 5 months ago
these guys make the soundtrack of my life
MrsCellardoor 5 months ago 2
@MrsCellardoor not only yours...Very Strong song
divinesalvia 5 months ago
Put this on as you go to sleep, you will be dreaming in no time. When the music ends you will suddenly wake up and realise you were never asleep, hit restart!
Aus78Formula 5 months ago 4
Kind of surreal.A mix between trance and ballad.With that trancy organ intro,very beautiful, to sad lyrics sung very very sadly,the song is a classic irony when it talks about being optimistic(buying new soul) in THAT dejected fashion.A tribute to the hopeless and 'those who disappeared'
rakeshbhatia986 5 months ago
this is the most beautiful song ever.
DDevilized 6 months ago
Some people have already talked about it here, but I want this to be upvoted so more people can see this. The song is probably about how an artist gets a writer's block and sells out to the devil (money) and "be happy". But he doesn't. He still wages and rages his little war. He is a shade and easy to ignore. That is why this is on the obscure Recordings album. If this song becomes famous, it would defeat the purpose of the entire piece. How sincere must they be to create something like this...
muraliavarma 6 months ago 53
Whitch album please??
gegege38 7 months ago
@gegege38 Recordings from 2001
klobuc85 6 months ago
Had to privilege to see them in October 2009, House of Blues Boston MA. Quite possibly the greatest show I had ever witnessed. They played this Song and Russia on Ice and I was in a complete and humble trance.
Porcupine Tree Forever.
GhostxNote 7 months ago
here's a hymn to those who disappear.
OreillyORLY 8 months ago 22
love the intro organ riff
Zehydra106 8 months ago 4
I'm just listening to this for the first time, i'm continually getting chills..
supergenius123 8 months ago
The only thing wrong here is the photo, because it is not Gavin Harrison playing the drums in this song. I heard Gavins version of the song live and I must say... it fails compared to this original version. And I am a big admirer of his playing. The drum track makes a big point in this fantastic song. Being a drummer myself this drum track gives me shivers up and down my spine.
NeeIsKla 9 months ago
Sitting alone in my apartment, headphones blocking out random noise, lights dimmed and Ive just got my Porcupine tunes taking my mind places. Been a good night! Love this song, but I love the live version from In Absentia better.
KoreyKu 9 months ago
thumbs up if you think PT should do the soundtrack to the next Metroid game.
Porojukaha 9 months ago
I only just started to explore this band, a few weeks ago (although, i was aware of their existence), and with each 'new' track i find, i can't help but think that this is possibly the greatest band in the world, ever... \m/ (:o)
klistarf 10 months ago 4
@klistarf same was here.. after several songs I realised they are the best... can't listen to ordinary rock songs now.
pinkangelok 8 months ago
man u dont know how much i get high whenever i hear this song i think it is better than anyother drug
if u wanna be high jus smoke shesha and listen to them
112233mode 10 months ago
no dislikes proves the epicness of this song!
peacelovehominy 10 months ago 6
@peacelovehominy And less than 24000 views (most of which by the same guys, I guess) show that there's something wrong with this world...
emotivenextway 9 months ago 7
@peacelovehominy 2 dislikes...... probably whining kids who don't understand or appreciate true music and listen to the shit spewed out of the rectal-eternal radio
krizem 8 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
what a great era to be in to music
Porcupine Tree
Anathema
Opeth
I doubt we'll see times this good again,fingers crossed though :-)
ANDREWHALL28 11 months ago 27
@ANDREWHALL28 Katatonia has a pretty unique atmosphere as well in some of their albums.
PSNBloodraid 5 months ago
@PSNBloodraid amazing band I have to admit, sen them twice now, sadly only at festivals,so will have to make sure I get to see a headline tour :-)
ANDREWHALL28 5 months ago
@ANDREWHALL28 Nice :)
I love how their sound changes every album, but is able to maintain the same atmosphere.
PSNBloodraid 5 months ago 2
@ANDREWHALL28 You will!!! Check us out!! We are inspired by all the bands you just mentioned!
GanjaBAND 3 months ago
perfect!
zlecony 11 months ago
I love all of PT's work, but man this song just sends me places. This is an incredible tune! Thnx for sharing.
OpethAndDTRock 11 months ago
awesome song :) wilson is simply the best songwriters i know
STRIEZELno12 1 year ago
This is on my short list of favorite PT songs.
JonP1961 1 year ago
@rellax12 No, he isn't. This drummer is Chris Maitland. Harrison joined PT since the album In Absentia, I believe.
RobinKlaassen 1 year ago
better then floyd's "wish you were here" and not as half as famous!
veryintricated 1 year ago
favourite band ever.
one of my favourite of their songs. :)
CaptainUltimate27 1 year ago
I'm not sure Harrison is the drummer in this song
rellax12 1 year ago
I was just introduced to PT this past fall. This is by far THE best.I've heard yet.
Eddie Jr.
meillered 1 year ago
god dammit! im dying of shivers over here... oh oops i meant Steven Wilson dammit! im dying of shivers
Kummen 1 year ago
This has to be one of the best PT songs I've heard
w1090 1 year ago 2
2:27 Spectacular
joekelly101 1 year ago
Comment removed
joekelly101 1 year ago
Comment removed
joekelly101 1 year ago
It's not a sush a famous song but it's one of the better songs of PT!!!
tholey1990 1 year ago 3
Wow, I had never heard this before today. Amazing song.
honcho321 1 year ago
How can a song be so musically beautiful and profound at the same time?
Masterpiece..
Blackdwarf1989 1 year ago 2
they are so awesome! i never get bored of listening to this song.. all day.. over and over again..
TheChocolategirl7 1 year ago 2
This is a very special song. It takes me to a different realm where I can think of a beautiful girl named Zoe. What an amazing masterpiece!
khashayar44 1 year ago 2
Like it? I FUC*ING love this masterpiece...
mojrzesz2 1 year ago
This is definitely the most beautiful song they've ever released, if not the best song. I can listen to this over an over again and it still sends chills down my spine.
Peregrineeagle 1 year ago
Great video
LVnthelife 1 year ago
Ok, I'm dying now.. *O*
This is one of my favorite PL'song. Just love the emotional landscape (can I say that) built all around the whole song.. They're pure genius ! I think PL is one of the best alive bands ! it's damn well tuned with the actual world'spirit Emotion'sickness..
ManiacOperaV 1 year ago
This song is super beautiful! why it wasn't released on the album I've no idea :)
arronmetallica 1 year ago
this is one of the few bands i don't mind getting stuck in my head. in fact, there's always a space reserved for them ;).
iterativechaos 1 year ago
Harmony korine by steven wilson?
NathanielLouis 1 year ago
@NathanielLouis Took 3 Weeks, but it's uploaded now! Check out my channel or listen to it under: youtube.com/watch?v=U3N3uEmVA3s&hd=1
Kneipp 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Make a PorcupineTreeVEVO!
KristofferNipen 1 year ago
@KristofferNipen Yeah...
Kneipp 1 year ago 5
@KristofferNipen No, then we'd have to be bombarded with the idiotic commercials of todays society.
beefjirky 1 year ago
Why is it that all their best stuff. is unreleased or hard to find. i mean this song is fucking awsome
TheRythmestick 1 year ago
@TheRythmestick Yeah, the B-Sides qualify as SUPER awesome...
Kneipp 1 year ago
@TheRythmestick What if the song is actually about the talented artists who don't go mainstream and thus so many good songs remain obscure? Maybe this song was made to prove the point that such a good song is not to be heard by everyone.
kax0807 1 year ago 3
Grear song great band. You have any other steven wilson stuff? No man? I have is solo and blackfield. Also awesome
NathanielLouis 1 year ago
@NathanielLouis I have some No man and Blackfield up on my page.
howdyfeller 1 year ago
@NathanielLouis I got all there is to have of Steven Wilson, Blackfield, PT, No Man etc.. You can suggest a song if you want, I'll happily upload it.
Kneipp 1 year ago
@Kneipp this song called hydrahead is amazing. its by colin edwin bass player of PT.. i think you can find the song in the discography. :)
otto192 9 months ago
@Kneipp upload 'things i want to tell you' by no man plzplzplz!!!!!
kokorochris1 5 months ago
@Kneipp do you have the tape version of nine cats? the 9 min one? cheers
cerojase 5 months ago
Well, there's another treat - I uploaded two more Vids of my favorite PT Songs.
Cure for Optimism:
youtube.com/watch?v=KSCswqmyf9w
Stop Swimming:
youtube.com/watch?v=MQcNH_aD6Ds
Of course in HQ Studio Quality. Use the links or click on the video responses
Enjoy
Kneipp 1 year ago
listening almost daily for the last 6 months, not yet bored..
Thank you for uploading the album version, it totally rocks. \m/
otto192 1 year ago 40
@otto192
You're absolutely right. The song - heck - even the band is an evergreen!
Kneipp 1 year ago
@otto192 It makes great background music for studying.
RageSchism 5 months ago in playlist pork tree 2
@RageSchism and working..
otto192 5 months ago
I did not know about this group. Its little known here in Colombia, but Its very good.
OscarJLondonoA 1 year ago
@OscarJLondonoA
Yeah, I'm from Switzerland, nobody knows them here either.... what a shame =)
Kneipp 1 year ago 2
587 views. SHOULD BE MORE LIKE 587,000,000!
robertskarin23 1 year ago 3
@robertskarin23
I hear you...
Kneipp 1 year ago
@robertskarin23 AT LEAST!
KristofferNipen 1 year ago
@robertskarin23 you will be happy to know that that number has significantly increased :)
tristaNINchains 1 year ago
i still rage and wage my little warrrrr...
peacelovehominy 1 year ago 4
one word, AWESOME!
peacelovehominy 1 year ago 3
@peacelovehominy
It is an awesome song - That's why I uploaded it :D
Kneipp 1 year ago