To all you half wits who keep saying this isn't Guns N' Roses,have you even gone and seen this line up live? obviously not! this is a way better band than "the original" line up.they play better together and thats a fact.everyone wants to see the "original" band back together and love that version of the band but there is a lot of us out there that love this version of the band too.Why should Axl change the name of the band?
Well AC/DC should change theirs too,and heaps of other bands aswell!!!
You have to be on crack. What just played was god aweful and anyone who followed the band should have been appauld at what this sounds like. these guys have no feeling and the song sounded empty with no passion. it is the current rendition of whats being called Guns in Roses but its more like The Rose band. this was just bad point blank and if you think thats good your tone def or never heard the real line up that was truely guns and roses
SLASH MADE THAT BAND..... YEAH AXL ROSE HAD A GREAT VOICE BUT TODAY THAT IS GONE ALONG WITH GUNS AND ROSES....... BUT THE FACT REMAINS SLASH CAN STILL KICK BUT ON HIS GUITAR AND WHERE IS AXL TODAY????? NO WHERE CAUSE HE SUCKS!!!! HE'S A JOKE AND I WOULD BET HIS UP COMING TOUR WILL PROVE THAT..... SO GLAD I DIDNT PAY TO SEE THIS CRAP!!!!
What is wrong with you debbie apparently you never herd velvetrevolver!Slash plays one of the cleanest guitars you will ever here!And all the greats played clean!These new guitar players have 20 footboards a computer program an a guitar tech!BB KING EDDIE VANHALEN ZAK WILED all play clean!Clearly you dislike slash because all the leads in GNR currently play dirty!Don't judge talent if you don't know the styles!
Guns N' Roses wasn't famous until the infamous Slash, Izzy, Steven, Duff. and Axl were all in it together. Appetite made this band. Don't act like they've gotten any better since they "reformed" or whatever you want to call it.
you are obviously not a slash fanboy, but why did you tag his name in the video? you are just as ignorant as any of the people commenting about how this is crap.
Look at their skinny litlle limbs, those replacements ain't kicking anybodys ass. Back in 89' people didn't talk shit about GNR because theyd get their head bashed in by the fans. GNR created fear and it was pure magic. Now Axl is off on some solo gig calling it GNR. This is not GNR people, this is pure, unfiltered faggotry. Axl got a taste for it after blowing Elton John.
I dont remember Tracci Guns puting an album out with guns n roses they ware in the band for a mounth get it right slash izzy duff steven are all orginal they made the best rock album in Rock music
The original Guns N Roses were the best and will always be, this new line up of Guns n Roses is shit as hell!!! They split up cause of that bitch Axl, and if it wasn't for him they would be still together till today enjoying there selves writing songs etc..
LOL what is even funnier is that Axl needs 2 lead guitars to do what Slash did by himself. Like it or not GNR is Slash,Duff,Izzy, Steven Adler. Never heard of these guys before. Such a shame that this band has become a parody of itself with Axl the only original member.
@mattharrington123 Um, no. Hollywood Rose was a band formed in 83 by Axl, Izzy & Chris Weber.
The 3 of them, and Johnny Kreis recorded a demo in 84. They disbanded, then reunited. Axl, Izzy and Steve Darrow&Tracii Guns joined, replacing Weber. The group then changed their name to Guns n Roses, combining LA GUNS and Axl ROSE. The lineup changed except for Izzy. That's when Slash, Duff&Steve joined. They were all from the same band called Road Crew.
GUNS N ROSES IS THE SHIT WHETHER ITS THE OLD OR NEW LINEUP IT SEEMS FUNNY TO ME EVERYONE BASHES AXL BUT IZZY N DUFF BOTH HAVE PLAYED WITH THE NEW GUNS WITH NO ANGER TOWARDS AXL N DUFF SAID HE LOVES HIM LETS LOOK AT THE FACTS SLASH WAS IN GUNS AXL WANTS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIM VELVET REVOLVER N NOW SCOTT WANTS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIM MAKES YA THINK MAYBE ITS NOT ALL AXL N SLASH IS A SELL OUT JUST LOOK AT THE HALFTIME SHOW WITH THE BLACK EYED PEAS TO PROVE THAT N HE PLAYED WITH MICHEAL JACKSON POINT
Is Axls babysitter on here?! Live like a suicide had Slash and Duff,obviously not Matt Sorum. The best precursor to Appetite and Lies. As far as im concerned that was their first album/EP. Even if they werent in the band, the only 100% gnr was when duff,slash and co. were part of it,otherwise the name should be changed to Bows and Arrows.
Thank you for telling the truth JoeyNH. Frustrated haters are in pain with the actual line up because they are awesome! Some prefer to live in the past and bitch, i prefer to enjoy the present of this great band! Long life to GNR!!!
Guns N' Roses is Guns N' Roses and thats a fact. Steven Adler, Izzy Stradlin, Slash, and Duff Mckagan left. SO WHAT? THE REAL FACT IS THAT: “Axl Rose”, “Dizzy Reed”, “Richard Fortus”, “Tommy Sinston”, “Bumblefoot”, “Dj ASHBA”, “Chris Pitman”, and “Frank Ferrer” is Guns N' Roses.. get over it, AND IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE SHIT DON'T WATCHH IT... SIMPLE AS THAT!!
Guns N' Roses is Guns N' Roses and thats a fact. Steven Adler, Izzy Stradlin, Slash, and Duff Mckagan left. SO WHAT? THE REAL FACT IS THAT: “Axl Rose”, “Dizzy Reed”, “Richard Fortus”, “Tommy Sinston”, “Bumblefoot”, “Dj ASHBA”, “Chris Pitman”, and “Frank Ferrer” is Guns N' Roses.. get over it, AND IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE SHIT DON'T WATCHH IT... SIMPLE AS THAT!!
the original line up is always known as what goes onto the debut album therefore slash is an original member, u make ur first album when uv got the members u want, u dont call a line up that was together for a month or two the originals u idiot. And they are playing the original songs that slash was involved in aswell, tracy guns etc had nothing to do with those songs! Axl is a selfish prick and if u can't realise that then you really shouldn't be allowed to comment on the situation
well you can't argue that.. axl, slash, duff and steven is the classic line-up at least and a lot better than the cover band with axl today that call themselves guns n' roses.
who cares about definition of original, this is the line-up that released the first and best album and their biggest hits, and is considered the classic and best line-up by most fans.
@13macgirl Eh yeah thats when they were called hollywood rose! Just because Axl and Izzy were in that band does not make it guns n roses. Every musician has been in bands that weren't famous before they were in ones that were. Alter Bridge for example are nowhere near the same band as Creed even though they have 3 former Creed members, they are a different entity completely in Alter Bridge. Every band in history's original members are so called because they were on the 1st Album.
Just because in your OPINION u like the Slash/"Classic" Lineup better does not take away the FACT that the orginal lineup was Axl Rose (vocals) and Izzy Stradlin (rhythm guitar), and L.A. Guns members Tracii Guns (lead guitar), Ole Beich (bass) and Rob Gardner (drums) and the current lineup is the one stated above. FACTS>OPINIONS.
@joeynh Well put! Getting sick and tired of all these mental midgets who don't even know the exact history of the band, but nonetheless feel a need to constantly piss over the newest incarnations. It's all nostalgically challenged unfounded gibberish.
@joeynh within the first year of GN'R all the members of LA Guns were replaced because they weren't as good. If you have ever been in a band you should know that the first few months are mainly a trial period when you are trying to find what people are best suited for the music that you wanted to play. The reason that the "Slash" lineup is considered the classic one is because it was that lineup that shaped a new area rock music. SHAPING AN ERA OF MUSIC>TAKING PHRASES TO LITERALLY.
This isn't GnR, this is AnF - Axl and friends.
A guitarist named Bubblebutt? WHAT?!
leadingreel 22 hours ago
Comment removed
chook069 3 months ago
To all you half wits who keep saying this isn't Guns N' Roses,have you even gone and seen this line up live? obviously not! this is a way better band than "the original" line up.they play better together and thats a fact.everyone wants to see the "original" band back together and love that version of the band but there is a lot of us out there that love this version of the band too.Why should Axl change the name of the band?
Well AC/DC should change theirs too,and heaps of other bands aswell!!!
chook069 3 months ago
@chook069
You have to be on crack. What just played was god aweful and anyone who followed the band should have been appauld at what this sounds like. these guys have no feeling and the song sounded empty with no passion. it is the current rendition of whats being called Guns in Roses but its more like The Rose band. this was just bad point blank and if you think thats good your tone def or never heard the real line up that was truely guns and roses
FilthyFletch 1 month ago
SLASH MADE THAT BAND..... YEAH AXL ROSE HAD A GREAT VOICE BUT TODAY THAT IS GONE ALONG WITH GUNS AND ROSES....... BUT THE FACT REMAINS SLASH CAN STILL KICK BUT ON HIS GUITAR AND WHERE IS AXL TODAY????? NO WHERE CAUSE HE SUCKS!!!! HE'S A JOKE AND I WOULD BET HIS UP COMING TOUR WILL PROVE THAT..... SO GLAD I DIDNT PAY TO SEE THIS CRAP!!!!
nirib1111 5 months ago
What is wrong with you debbie apparently you never herd velvetrevolver!Slash plays one of the cleanest guitars you will ever here!And all the greats played clean!These new guitar players have 20 footboards a computer program an a guitar tech!BB KING EDDIE VANHALEN ZAK WILED all play clean!Clearly you dislike slash because all the leads in GNR currently play dirty!Don't judge talent if you don't know the styles!
TAMAMANMANTAMA 5 months ago
Yeah man he died
nailed31 6 months ago
Is Axl Rose dead??
tell me..
johndel161616 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The "Axl needs two lead guitarrists to poorly equal Slash's talent" thing is getting oh so old.
Axl needs two lead guitarrists to play the brilliant and more complicated material they're coming out with now that Slash couldn't play.
DebbyRose 7 months ago
Guns N' Roses wasn't famous until the infamous Slash, Izzy, Steven, Duff. and Axl were all in it together. Appetite made this band. Don't act like they've gotten any better since they "reformed" or whatever you want to call it.
mfreemanification 7 months ago
you are obviously not a slash fanboy, but why did you tag his name in the video? you are just as ignorant as any of the people commenting about how this is crap.
mfreemanification 7 months ago
shit, this is not guns n roses
davidmaxpower 7 months ago
@davidmaxpower This is Guns N' Roses ..I'm sorry for you
GiannGNR 7 months ago
Axl need two lead guitar to poorly equal Slash talent...
elbataquero 7 months ago
Look at their skinny litlle limbs, those replacements ain't kicking anybodys ass. Back in 89' people didn't talk shit about GNR because theyd get their head bashed in by the fans. GNR created fear and it was pure magic. Now Axl is off on some solo gig calling it GNR. This is not GNR people, this is pure, unfiltered faggotry. Axl got a taste for it after blowing Elton John.
bryanjones007 8 months ago
F&$k yes Axl
BABS95062 8 months ago
I dont remember Tracci Guns puting an album out with guns n roses they ware in the band for a mounth get it right slash izzy duff steven are all orginal they made the best rock album in Rock music
IzzysLoaded 9 months ago
The original Guns N Roses were the best and will always be, this new line up of Guns n Roses is shit as hell!!! They split up cause of that bitch Axl, and if it wasn't for him they would be still together till today enjoying there selves writing songs etc..
1996Dalli 9 months ago
1980's ORIGINAL G.N.R ALL THE WAY . 2011 G.N.R Suck
ocerna92 9 months ago
ORINGINAL G.N.R ALL THE WAY . 2011 G.N.R Suck
ocerna92 9 months ago
LOL what is even funnier is that Axl needs 2 lead guitars to do what Slash did by himself. Like it or not GNR is Slash,Duff,Izzy, Steven Adler. Never heard of these guys before. Such a shame that this band has become a parody of itself with Axl the only original member.
Sidewinder9877 10 months ago
@mattharrington123 Um, no. Hollywood Rose was a band formed in 83 by Axl, Izzy & Chris Weber.
The 3 of them, and Johnny Kreis recorded a demo in 84. They disbanded, then reunited. Axl, Izzy and Steve Darrow&Tracii Guns joined, replacing Weber. The group then changed their name to Guns n Roses, combining LA GUNS and Axl ROSE. The lineup changed except for Izzy. That's when Slash, Duff&Steve joined. They were all from the same band called Road Crew.
Get your facts straight before arguing.
13macgirl 10 months ago
Dizzy Reed deserves respect
Crumisodamis 11 months ago
thats not the real guns N roses in the 2010!!!
Multifish456 1 year ago
GUNS N ROSES IS THE SHIT WHETHER ITS THE OLD OR NEW LINEUP IT SEEMS FUNNY TO ME EVERYONE BASHES AXL BUT IZZY N DUFF BOTH HAVE PLAYED WITH THE NEW GUNS WITH NO ANGER TOWARDS AXL N DUFF SAID HE LOVES HIM LETS LOOK AT THE FACTS SLASH WAS IN GUNS AXL WANTS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIM VELVET REVOLVER N NOW SCOTT WANTS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIM MAKES YA THINK MAYBE ITS NOT ALL AXL N SLASH IS A SELL OUT JUST LOOK AT THE HALFTIME SHOW WITH THE BLACK EYED PEAS TO PROVE THAT N HE PLAYED WITH MICHEAL JACKSON POINT
hellbilly74 1 year ago
Is Axls babysitter on here?! Live like a suicide had Slash and Duff,obviously not Matt Sorum. The best precursor to Appetite and Lies. As far as im concerned that was their first album/EP. Even if they werent in the band, the only 100% gnr was when duff,slash and co. were part of it,otherwise the name should be changed to Bows and Arrows.
daymosafc 1 year ago
Thank you for telling the truth JoeyNH. Frustrated haters are in pain with the actual line up because they are awesome! Some prefer to live in the past and bitch, i prefer to enjoy the present of this great band! Long life to GNR!!!
centcinqtiretseize 1 year ago
why the fuck did you do this video?
sexyHEATLIEDAVID 1 year ago
The original band was Hollywood Rose, not GnR.
Baadger 1 year ago
GnR is dead now the old one was better :'( miss u old GnR
mamoshe999 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Guns N' Roses is Guns N' Roses and thats a fact. Steven Adler, Izzy Stradlin, Slash, and Duff Mckagan left. SO WHAT? THE REAL FACT IS THAT: “Axl Rose”, “Dizzy Reed”, “Richard Fortus”, “Tommy Sinston”, “Bumblefoot”, “Dj ASHBA”, “Chris Pitman”, and “Frank Ferrer” is Guns N' Roses.. get over it, AND IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE SHIT DON'T WATCHH IT... SIMPLE AS THAT!!
Estranged68 1 year ago
Guns N' Roses is Guns N' Roses and thats a fact. Steven Adler, Izzy Stradlin, Slash, and Duff Mckagan left. SO WHAT? THE REAL FACT IS THAT: “Axl Rose”, “Dizzy Reed”, “Richard Fortus”, “Tommy Sinston”, “Bumblefoot”, “Dj ASHBA”, “Chris Pitman”, and “Frank Ferrer” is Guns N' Roses.. get over it, AND IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE SHIT DON'T WATCHH IT... SIMPLE AS THAT!!
Estranged68 1 year ago 10
Comment removed
Estranged68 1 year ago
like duff would say this are not guns and roses this is axls band
robicagljivica 1 year ago
the original line up is always known as what goes onto the debut album therefore slash is an original member, u make ur first album when uv got the members u want, u dont call a line up that was together for a month or two the originals u idiot. And they are playing the original songs that slash was involved in aswell, tracy guns etc had nothing to do with those songs! Axl is a selfish prick and if u can't realise that then you really shouldn't be allowed to comment on the situation
clince121188 1 year ago
@clince121188 thats ur opinion of the situation.
that fact remains that Slash, Duff, and Steven we're not in the orginal lineup.
dont like it? fine. dont bother coming on to a new GNR video then u idiot.
joeynh 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@joeynh
well you can't argue that.. axl, slash, duff and steven is the classic line-up at least and a lot better than the cover band with axl today that call themselves guns n' roses.
who cares about definition of original, this is the line-up that released the first and best album and their biggest hits, and is considered the classic and best line-up by most fans.
cakestalker 1 year ago
Comment removed
cakestalker 1 year ago
@joeynh AMEN, FUCK THEM GUNS N' ROSES HATERS... GUNS N ROSES IS GUNS N' ROSES
Estranged68 1 year ago
@joeynh Dude your wrong. Go do your hw lmao
AustinGraggmusician 5 months ago
Comment removed
cakestalker 1 year ago
@clince121188 Slash is not an origional member !
Origional members were Axl, Izzy and Chris Weber. That was when the band was called Hollywood Rose. Yes, it's the same band.
13macgirl 10 months ago
@13macgirl Eh yeah thats when they were called hollywood rose! Just because Axl and Izzy were in that band does not make it guns n roses. Every musician has been in bands that weren't famous before they were in ones that were. Alter Bridge for example are nowhere near the same band as Creed even though they have 3 former Creed members, they are a different entity completely in Alter Bridge. Every band in history's original members are so called because they were on the 1st Album.
clince121188 10 months ago
para mim o slash foi cona em sair dos gnr quem estiver de acordo me envie uma menssagem.
Slash was for me to get out of pussy gnr whom you disagree send me a message
toino1998 1 year ago
that my friend is not guns n roses this is some kind of parody of the glorious band GUNS 'N' ROSES :))))
punk0metal0antito 1 year ago
@punk0metal0antito
Just because in your OPINION u like the Slash/"Classic" Lineup better does not take away the FACT that the orginal lineup was Axl Rose (vocals) and Izzy Stradlin (rhythm guitar), and L.A. Guns members Tracii Guns (lead guitar), Ole Beich (bass) and Rob Gardner (drums) and the current lineup is the one stated above. FACTS>OPINIONS.
joeynh 1 year ago 6
@joeynh Well put! Getting sick and tired of all these mental midgets who don't even know the exact history of the band, but nonetheless feel a need to constantly piss over the newest incarnations. It's all nostalgically challenged unfounded gibberish.
o0Slipdisc0o 1 year ago
@joeynh Whats the big deal?? Its the SAME music! Who gives a shit at whos playing it! also Dj Ashba is amazing FYI.
FORDDEVILRACER 1 year ago
@joeynh Your a dumbass,old lineup is EVERYONES OPINION
WhatsAscope 1 year ago
@joeynh THATS NOT THE ORIGINAL LINE UP DUMBASS
TrilogyPaintball 1 year ago
@joeynh within the first year of GN'R all the members of LA Guns were replaced because they weren't as good. If you have ever been in a band you should know that the first few months are mainly a trial period when you are trying to find what people are best suited for the music that you wanted to play. The reason that the "Slash" lineup is considered the classic one is because it was that lineup that shaped a new area rock music. SHAPING AN ERA OF MUSIC>TAKING PHRASES TO LITERALLY.
DannyPadial 4 months ago
@punk0metal0antito The line up of Guns N' Roses today are carrying the torch ! They are Guns N' Roses !
pinkpanther446 1 year ago
@pinkpanther446 completely!!!!
farelowsky33 1 year ago
@punk0metal0antito Its the best Gunners line up so far.
FORDDEVILRACER 1 year ago
@FORDDEVILRACER And they all get along too dude:)
Estranged68 1 year ago
Comment removed
shining4841 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@punk0metal0antito the current Guns N' Roses, is the best line up ever, you stupid idiot!!
shining4841 3 months ago