Please realize basic strategy, No Pakistani civilian is ready to pay their tax money to attack India or some other country. At the same time no Indian would allow. The Political Leaders fight for survival is collapsing both the countries. Nothing more than that. All Corrupted leaders are creating/helping/promoting etc for their survival.
thank you very much ! parvez sahab . i appreciate ur honest & bold acceptance of pakistan,s role in planning Mumbai attack. even Mr. rehman malik accepted before media in a press conference called by him. But still the lunatic gold medalist in jehadi activities, madarsa educated zaid hamid says Mumbai terror attack was a plan of RAW & MOSSAD. sent him to mental hospital soon otherwise he will claim that "agle saal se jumme ki namaz white house main".
this dumb ass anchor hamid mir ..... @2.26 mentions about the assasination of mahatma gandhi, indira gandhi and rajiv gandhi ...... ABE MADERCHOD, HUMNE KAB KAHAN KI UNKE KATAL MEIN PAKISTAN KAA HAATH THA??? ...... hum to sir unn cheezopar pakistan par ilzam lagaate hain jo ki prove ho chuki hai puri duniya ke saamne ki pakistan ne hi ki hai
Stupid Hoodhboy is saying that HINDUS suffered the most by Mumbai attacks so it is a game by Pakistan......so HoodBhoy ! when such incident takes place in Pakistan and MUSLIMS of Pakistan suffer ....why dont you blame Indian Hindus for that ????????????????????????????????????????????????
@drbilalqamar ..... you only looked at that one statement but you did not hear the entire conversation it appears ...... he said that extremists groups in india dont have as much leverage as the ones in pakistan ... but the difference between indian terrorism and pakistani terrorism is that these groups dont have suicide bombers ..... yes rajiv gandhi was killed by a suicide bomber but these groups came to light after that ..... indira gandhi was killed coz she opposed the formation of khalistan
Fucking betrays even Indian has not claimed or proved most of that $#@#. I am not saying there are not problems but they need to be fixed internally but they are selling there words. No patriotic public figure would have said that in history about there country. We need good relationship with India and all other countries. Pakistan Zindabad.
I'm Indian and I have a lot of Ismaili friends from India and Pakistan. I admire the genuine tolerance and sensibility Ismailies posses. They have mostly been very humble and honest, in my experience. I love my Sufi Muslim friends from my neighborhood in Hyderabad (India). I wish ALL Pakistani Muslims were tolerant of others (non-muslims? Kafirs? Cow-Piss Drinkers???).
For every Godhra, there's a Gojra. For every Mumbai riot, there is a Faisalabad chaos. Intolerance everywhere :(
Good video Kashif! Well as I understand from this video: There are problems in pakistan (made by themselves, with contribution of US etc). And the extremism (or Jihad) is even over taking Pak.But now it is really hard for them to confess this(moreover in front of their age old enemy-India).To all the big problems, there is a simple solution-confession.
i am a Indian but i am a big fan of parvej , pakistan desperately want his kind of people in country who can talk sensible and who can show the correct picture to the nation.
Pakistani Army General has been proved a lier as all of other army officials who have been lying to their country pakistani army, pakistan has accepted that Mumbai attackers where pakistani. Pakistani and International media were able to trace their families and places of living and now the lone surviving attacker "Muhammad Ajamal Kasab" is a proven pakistani!!
Yes, I find him to be an intelligent and articulate person...A very good representation of Pakistanis. As an Indian, I do NOT believe in false patriotism for my country. Hence, I am not saying that India has been an angel either....It just has been lesser of the two evils....Pakistani establishment brutally murdered 3 million fellow Muslims in Bangladesh. Absolutely unforgivable.
Its amazing to find the level of ignorance of Pakis like Hamid Mir who does not even know that Pakistan is World Center of Islamic Terrorism and Jihad against India and the World.
@drbilalqamar why he say about another country he care pakistan nt he did nt care about india, US. why u prefer zaid hamid he only blames another country, mr. hoodbhoy is the best man nd many more u have like najam sethi in pakistan.
@drbilalqamar true true.. we tell same thing to kashmiris who say if india is supporting terrorism in kashmir then leave kashmir and go to neighbouring country.. simple...
LOL !! The moment i finished watching this video i found a response to this video Titled (Traitor perviz hoodbhoy exposed ) posted by some pakistani LMAO ! This happens all the time ..anyone who tries to make sense in pakistan is a traitor..Truth is bitter eh ?? and who is their hero..let em decide . anyway thanx for the video @kashif.
Hoodbhoy is out of his bloody mind. Indian extremists are actually in power. Isn't Narinder Modi an extremist and a terrorist? Is he not the chief minister of Gujarat?
@karachishaher no he is not in NAMO's stat4e muslims's are ahead of hindis on socio/economic laddere.. muslims from all over india flock to gujarta for this rreason yes he is extremist for jihadist mofos for sure
"The abbreviation Paki acquired offensive connotations in the 1960s when used by British tabloids to refer to subjects of former colony states in a derogatory and racist manner. In modern British usage "Paki" is typically used in a derogatory way as a label for all South Asians, including Indians, Afghans and Bangladeshis. To a lesser extent, the term has been applied as a racial slur towards Arabs and other Middle Eastern-looking groups who may resemble South Asians"
@XAPYH It is not my intention to offend Pakistanis with use of the term "Paki" in the video title. I am myself a Pakistani, and despite serious issues with its state ideology and foreign policy, have nothing but respect for the common man... who struggles heroically everyday to makes ends meet. That being said, I had no choice but to use some form of abbreviation for "Pakistani" as YouTube's video title length restrictions were preventing display of the full title in channel playlists.
@XAPYH In deference to your objections to the unintended derogatory connotations of the term "Paki", I have change the video title from "Hoodbhoy: Honest Paki on Mumbai Attacks" to "Hoodbhoy: Truth About Mumbai Attacks." Thanks.
i Hope this true voice...lives ...after this debate is aired on pakistani channels!! pakistan needs honest people like mr Hoodbhoy !! .. and general sahab please contact rehman malik for proof !! :) ! if you really mean it!
I like the fact that he said Bharat and not Hindustan. It's not just Hindus that live in "bharat". A LOT of people from different religions reside in India. Pakis can't seem to get over this fact.
He was never treated like a dog. RSS and MNS keep targeting high profile people to make news and increase their popularity. Like a free advertisement for their organisation. But, it keeps backfiring and no one supports them today. They lost miserably in last year's elections. They have no power or control over anything. They just keep barking like stray dogs. Shahrukh Khan also knows that. That is why he never apologized. 95% India hates RSS/VHP/MNS. We don't give a fuck about the remaining 5%
man hatsoff to this hoodboy ... hes jst being worried abt ur won country man rather than allegation , counter allegation and ... i think wht he want to conway is both countries shud get rid of extremist org. and head towards progress and peace
He, Ardsher Cowsji like persons are assets of Pakistan. I do not find any thing wrong with him. I agreed 100% to him. So far there is no proof for their so called traitorship etc
Hoodbhoy is a honest man. There is small problem called Hindu extremism in India also. But i believe that is eradicating day by day. No civilian now wants to have any war with themselves. Only gundas and mawalis are doing that and they are treated like criminals anyway. BJP has also learned that and has changed his idealogy. Whatever past has happened it happened. No future incident (if happened like Gujrat) would not leavy any criminal unpunished in India.
i blv people on this show are are quite learned and talkin sense..ppl should avoid gettin brainwashed from fanatics on both side of border..indo pak unity matters
@view587 I am a Pakistani mate and all the names you mentioned here are very respectable to me. They just enlighten us by bringing reality in front of us. They are not trying to misuse you like most of the Mullahs and people like Zaid Hamid.
Kashif, Now I'm convinced you are a traitor of Pakistan. All you Qadianies and Ismailies are traitors and as such should be thrown out of Pakistan! I hate you people!
I completely agree with u. All pakis speaking and exposing the harsh truth about their country must be thrown out of pakistan immediately. Reason - pakistan is meant only and only for terrorists, cheaters, liars, beggars, back-stabbers, hypocrites, etc. In a nutshell - pakistan is meant only for inhuman beasts. Now since Kashif has exposed the reality of his cursed shit land by this video, he must be thrown out of pakistan immediately - right!!!!
@cavegirl448 : why u always blame USA for condition of pakistan ... did america .. spreading extreamisum ..? did america .. spreading wrong islam n extreamist idiology ? did america giving you money n arms without ur permission ? did america offered you terrorist camps ? why dont you accept your mistakes .. u loosers... always pointing out fingers towards others .. once ..at least once try to look at yourself n your country .. n then write your comment ?
PersonOfBook: Tum kaminey Randi ke Aulad ho. MIT Professor ka brain dekho bhenchod, he said it so accurately and the facts are out. Tum madharchod illiterate gadhe ho.
Kashif, don't be disheartened with comments from people like "PersonOfBook". You are doing a great service to the country in your capacity. Truth is always a bitter pill to swallow so you will get reactions like this from misguided people.
If u have a problem with this guy, send him over to India, we'll give him citizenship. There r few like him n we'd try to keep all of them on our soil. A country that doesn't respect it's intellectuals doesn't deserve to have them.
hahaha.everyone who opposes pakistan is an intellectual.one who wants to be popular starts to oppose pakistan.hoodbhoy is one of those popular people.he has only one good thing on his credit and that is his book musalman aur science.
how simply he has clearified singh privar of india that eats muslims thrice a day.
That fucking anchor. He himself mentions kashmir first then accuses that analyst of saying that its kashmiri terrorists that did the 26/11 attack. From what i have seen, voices like Hoodbhoy and Hassan Nisar are 2 few, and that the pakistani people choose to ignore these few sane voices, instead listening to clowns like Zaid Hamid, because he says things they want to hear, but never the truth.
@DharmRakshak2 Dude i hope that our youth is now understanding more clearly what our previous rulers did to us in the name of religion. We are becoming aware of people like Zaid Hamid and this stupid anchor Hamid Mir etc because minds like theirs are actually the biggest problems of our country. Personally we dont have any problems with India and America but people like Zaid Hamid tries to impress us against you using their unmatched intelligence lol
@DharmRakshak2 The main reason the debate on such forums as youtube fail due to the sue of bad language against each other. If you had not used this language, many more people would have agreed to you.
I like Hoodbhoy, he is honest and clear, he is a man of intellectual thinking. I agree if we have such people as politicians we will be all ok but the problem is such nice people dont wana come to politics and if they come stupid pakistani people will not vote him ....
After a long search I have found a pakistani person who is honest. There is need of such person's in pakistan to make pakistan a better place and help itself. I think he should run the country and then I dont think there will be any terrorism left in world. It was really a heart warming thing to listen to such a honest pakistani.
@sankalp, i would agree with first part of your comment. lekin, lets behave as good indians, no point cursing out ppl like this, just put forth good arguments.
every pakistan should blow them self up... this is jehad Way.. to heaven... wat else i can say to the people who wanna live after death... when they will die v will fuck there. dauthers and wifes.. good na..:)
Your intense hatred to Pakistan is a bread to Jihadis in Pakistan. Jihadis tell Pakistanis that we defend Pakistan from Indian possible attack. if you analyse common Pakistani opinion, they would say it is India who is committing terrorism in Pakistan. Further you people with extreme opinion solids common pakistani's belief
@MrGoodman45 I wonder why do Pakistanis - correction ! MOST pakistanis think that whatever they do is RIGHT and if someone else says/does something which they dont agree with, is wrong?
People with brains like Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy should take over the political reins in pakistan. Otherwise Pakistan will be disintegrated into pieces and taken over by Jihadis.
@Mutahir213 Really? Kashmir? Who cares about Kashmir .. why not worry about your own country i.e. Pakistan 1st before start fighting for a state thats not even worth it.
Listen to this man, he is an intelligent man who has won numerous awards for his devotion to studies, he is not anti-Pakistan, but actually a real nationalist. Pakistan is facing much trouble just yesterday there was a sucide bomb. Pakistan should wipe out these rogue elements present in Pakistan.
You deposed Mujib-ur Rehman, who was democratically elected to power and was the rightful PM of Pakistan. Because Punjabi and Sindhi power players in the Army and the PPP did not want the Awami league to form the government.
You broke up your own country because you were not united enough to begin with.
babur.u are named after a invader who raped ur amis mummy..u dumb arabized brainwashed paki filth..go lick ur arab masters feet.u scum from a cesspool called baltistan..hahaha
Pakistan needs to saves itself from itself. As an Indian I know India isnt always as pure as we would like to believe, but still Pakistan needs to forget Kashmir for the time being and focus on itself. One thing, India does not trust the Americans to form any kind of alliance, the Russians are still no 1 in our books. I hope Pakistan returns to a peaceful nation.
Hmm, I agree with you. Americans are messing around in our region. For right now, India is not really a threat to Pakistan but Talibans are.
Pervez Hoodbhoy is one of the prominent nuclear physicist in Pakistan but sadly his pointing out about real face of talibans; Pakistanis still believe that India and Americans are their enemies.
I dont know why Hamid invited this guy in political discussion even he is only Physic profesor inuniversity. Kashmir is core issue b/w pakistan and inda .. it should be solve in under UN resolution. if kahmir problem will not solve then no one can give the surtey for peace. Actually Pakistan was born only for Islam because muslim league got muslim's votes for the name of ISLAM. So pakistan gov. should implement ISLAMIC LAW (not only in judiciary as well as in MEDIA) as soon as possible.
Hamid invites Zaid Hamid too who is nothing but an engineer and can't form an unbiased view on geo-politics and engages in downright fear-mongering by plagiarizing Alex Jones' bullshit conspiracy-theories.
"So pakistan gov. should implement ISLAMIC LAW"
I don't think Quaid-e-Azam wanted an Islamic Pakistan. He knew of persecutions during Roman Catholic and Protestant periods in England caused by discrimination and championed secularism. However this topic is of much controversy today.
try safe guarding ur own borders...frget kashmir....look at waziristan,baluchistan,swat...u cant look after ur own country...ur economy is in shambles.....my dear dont u love ur people and ur country????think about ur future....
when pakistan was formed, more muslims stayed back in india then joined pakistan. are these muslims who chose to remain in india against islam. these ppl include maulana abdul kalam azad and the great pathan khan ghafar khan. dont u see the stupidity of dividing ppl on the lines of religion.
Sensible voice in Pakistan. Hope the number of such voices increase on both sides and everlasting peace prevails between the 2 siblings who got separated 62 years back.
Why do we Pakistanis have to label everyone who offers a different perspective from Establishment, a "non-Muslim" or a "traitor". Why can't we just listen to the person's arguments with an open mind as opposed to attacking his faith or casting aspersions on his integrity?
I hate judging people based on their faith or lack thereof. But if you can't live without it, then know that Dr. Hoodbhoy is an Ismaili Muslim and an extremely honest, intelligent, capable, caring, and patriotic man.
A great man, A MIT Graduate who decided to stay in pakistan and teach and transfer his knowledge to fellow pakistanis. and offcourse his brave fight aganst all wrongs at policy level a true human.... and yes for most a RAW/CIA agent..
looks like who ever admits the fact that pakistan has terrorists camps is branded a gaddar... lol.. i wonder how long pakistan can keep on denying these terrorists?
must be??... read the info he's from " MIT " and yes its easy to see the difference from zaid hamid ( who was probably spraying bullets in afganistan while this guy pervez was in mit )
that is the difference a proper education can make. If you listen carefully, Dr. Pervez never takes sides and is quite objective in his analysis. Unfortunately, this gentleman may very soon (or might have been already) get branded as a mossad or RAW agent.
Good to see the person with great clarity. It takes lot of guts to speak truth at taht level. And its his greatness that he wants to see the truth, beyond what the media or the politicians brainswahing people that Pakistan is good and India is a big villain. If more people like him come forward, pakistan will be back on track and earn respect of the world
It is good to know that someone like hoodbhoy has the courage to come to national tv and speak truth otherwise we know what all other pakistani analysts have to say
and secondly rss and shiv sena definitely r fundamentalist hindu organistn but they doesnt go to pakistan and blow up bombs so comparing lashkar to them is meaningless
My friend Pervez hoodhboy is speaking the feelings of educated classs of pakistan (atleast most of them). But the problem is that the policies are not controlled by them, they are done by the military and security establishments, and those who try to go against them e.g leaders selected by popular majority like Nawaz Sharif and Benazir... they are simply thrown out of the way.
RSS is not a terrorist organization, they have never indulged in terrorist activities,they have never killed Innocent people, never exploded bombs in market or religious places.comparing RSS with Laskar-e -Toiba etc is not fair.killing of Mahatma Gandhi by Nathu Ram Godse was an individuals extreme reaction..Such killings have been in America and Pakistan also.Killing of Benazeer Bhutto is the latest example.
I don't know RSS and and so can't comment on whether it has been engaged in terrorism in general. I would like to point out though that the current Gujarat minister in Modi government, Maya Kodnani, was a member of RSS' female wing and personally led an attack that killed at least 95 Muslims in Ahmedabad in 2002 during the infamous Gujarat Riots. This is stated in a government affidavit. It appears, therefore, that some RSS members are capable of large scale death and destruction.
It is breath of fresh air to hear Pakistani analysts such as Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy telling the truth about Mumbai attacks on national TV. I agree that Pakistan continues to harbor powerful Jihadi organizations (on account of its policy of fighting proxy wars in India) and that these outfits were involved in Mumbai attacks. I further agree that Jihadi groups have outgrown their military masters by becoming self-sufficient in funding and now also pose a serious threat to domestic security.
a lot of people back home have given folks like Dr Hoodbhoy and Asma Jahangir a LOT of stick. Mainly coming from Jamaati ullu k pathay, and a lot of Pakistanis prone to believe in conspiracy theories and denial.
asma's meeting with Bal Thackeray also was the last straw for these Jamaatis.
many idiots called it an "Ahmedi conspiracy and Ahmedis are all traitors and Israeli trained".
You have identified all the right parts of the puzzle "jamaati ullu k pathay": I do not agree with abusive language on youtube but frankly you have been soft with this fitna. Many in Pakistan are living in a delusion and denial and create false realities of conspiracy theories. Facts: we are upto our knees under militancy threat and fast sinking further closing our eyes will not take the problem away. It saddens me to see many countrymen not realising this. But good see people like you also.
Please realize basic strategy, No Pakistani civilian is ready to pay their tax money to attack India or some other country. At the same time no Indian would allow. The Political Leaders fight for survival is collapsing both the countries. Nothing more than that. All Corrupted leaders are creating/helping/promoting etc for their survival.
vijaybacholla1 5 months ago
thank you very much ! parvez sahab . i appreciate ur honest & bold acceptance of pakistan,s role in planning Mumbai attack. even Mr. rehman malik accepted before media in a press conference called by him. But still the lunatic gold medalist in jehadi activities, madarsa educated zaid hamid says Mumbai terror attack was a plan of RAW & MOSSAD. sent him to mental hospital soon otherwise he will claim that "agle saal se jumme ki namaz white house main".
gauravcurious 5 months ago
this dumb ass anchor hamid mir ..... @2.26 mentions about the assasination of mahatma gandhi, indira gandhi and rajiv gandhi ...... ABE MADERCHOD, HUMNE KAB KAHAN KI UNKE KATAL MEIN PAKISTAN KAA HAATH THA??? ...... hum to sir unn cheezopar pakistan par ilzam lagaate hain jo ki prove ho chuki hai puri duniya ke saamne ki pakistan ne hi ki hai
iluvdrewbrees 9 months ago
Stupid Hoodhboy is saying that HINDUS suffered the most by Mumbai attacks so it is a game by Pakistan......so HoodBhoy ! when such incident takes place in Pakistan and MUSLIMS of Pakistan suffer ....why dont you blame Indian Hindus for that ????????????????????????????????????????????????
drbilalqamar 10 months ago
@drbilalqamar ..... you only looked at that one statement but you did not hear the entire conversation it appears ...... he said that extremists groups in india dont have as much leverage as the ones in pakistan ... but the difference between indian terrorism and pakistani terrorism is that these groups dont have suicide bombers ..... yes rajiv gandhi was killed by a suicide bomber but these groups came to light after that ..... indira gandhi was killed coz she opposed the formation of khalistan
iluvdrewbrees 8 months ago
hindu and jewish agent pervez hoodboy lol.......
thescorpionking2020 11 months ago
Wow, Hoodbhoy better get the hell out of that country. You can either talk sense there or be safe. Not both.
tonymontana1965 11 months ago
Wow, you still have people like Hoodhboy, who can speak the truth in Pakistan, God keep him secure.
indianspartacus 1 year ago 2
MIT.
Really impressive !
SIDEOCRACY 1 year ago
bjp, bajrangdal, rss, shive sena is very powerfull in india can turn government .
mark12345678965 1 year ago
Fucking betrays even Indian has not claimed or proved most of that $#@#. I am not saying there are not problems but they need to be fixed internally but they are selling there words. No patriotic public figure would have said that in history about there country. We need good relationship with India and all other countries. Pakistan Zindabad.
niceuser1234 1 year ago
THE JEHADI ARE AGAINST INSANIYAT.
THEY WILL KILL PAKISTAN.
dollanil 1 year ago
Shame on Pakistan...
There is still time...please please...stop all this non-sense and work for the betterment of your country.
weedleafGOD 1 year ago
Pervaiz Hoodboy is a jew
Ovais5831 1 year ago
@Ovais5831 Any sane voice in Pakistan is either JEW, HINDU or CIA, you are right.
indianspartacus 1 year ago
After a long time a paki with sense.......
ksihkar 1 year ago 5
If we have pple like Pervez Hoodbhoy then we don't need any enemy.
AsadImran1 1 year ago
.Nice person with good thinking
1301pk 1 year ago 2
he thinks he is a very high class intellectual and so sophisticated
7346908 1 year ago 2
hamid mir jese chutiya jahil log mulk ka bera ghark karte hen
nqur 1 year ago
I'm Indian and I have a lot of Ismaili friends from India and Pakistan. I admire the genuine tolerance and sensibility Ismailies posses. They have mostly been very humble and honest, in my experience. I love my Sufi Muslim friends from my neighborhood in Hyderabad (India). I wish ALL Pakistani Muslims were tolerant of others (non-muslims? Kafirs? Cow-Piss Drinkers???).
For every Godhra, there's a Gojra. For every Mumbai riot, there is a Faisalabad chaos. Intolerance everywhere :(
pogularocky 1 year ago
Good video Kashif! Well as I understand from this video: There are problems in pakistan (made by themselves, with contribution of US etc). And the extremism (or Jihad) is even over taking Pak.But now it is really hard for them to confess this(moreover in front of their age old enemy-India).To all the big problems, there is a simple solution-confession.
jsgorana 1 year ago
i am a Indian but i am a big fan of parvej , pakistan desperately want his kind of people in country who can talk sensible and who can show the correct picture to the nation.
I want to see pakistan happy as well.
amitkasaria 1 year ago
Pakistani Army General has been proved a lier as all of other army officials who have been lying to their country pakistani army, pakistan has accepted that Mumbai attackers where pakistani. Pakistani and International media were able to trace their families and places of living and now the lone surviving attacker "Muhammad Ajamal Kasab" is a proven pakistani!!
tutu1234 1 year ago
Pervez Hoodboy is one of the few sensible and educated people in Pak, we need more of his kind and NOT the stupids Zaid Hamid and Hamid Gul
Faraz70 1 year ago
@Faraz70
Yes, I find him to be an intelligent and articulate person...A very good representation of Pakistanis. As an Indian, I do NOT believe in false patriotism for my country. Hence, I am not saying that India has been an angel either....It just has been lesser of the two evils....Pakistani establishment brutally murdered 3 million fellow Muslims in Bangladesh. Absolutely unforgivable.
kashurludka 1 year ago 2
@tayyab1400 same thing like shame on zahil zaleel hamid fans...
balbal36 1 year ago
Its amazing to find the level of ignorance of Pakis like Hamid Mir who does not even know that Pakistan is World Center of Islamic Terrorism and Jihad against India and the World.
htgajjar 1 year ago
Mr. HoodBhoy ! Why DONT you throw your EDUCATED light on terrorist link with India in Afghanistan?
Will you explain the USELESS presence of US in Afghanistan?
Why Israeli Army Chief visits Indian occcupied Kashmir?
Why DONT you say anything about FREEMASONS?
Why DONT you say anything about Hindu Zionists?
Are they all INNOCENT KIDS?
Mr. HoodBhoy ! Why do you always blame your own country? If you think Pakistan is supporting terrorism, then WHY DONT you leave this country.
drbilalqamar 1 year ago
@drbilalqamar why he say about another country he care pakistan nt he did nt care about india, US. why u prefer zaid hamid he only blames another country, mr. hoodbhoy is the best man nd many more u have like najam sethi in pakistan.
so support these people nt like zaid hamid.
SuperKnightranger 1 year ago
@drbilalqamar true true.. we tell same thing to kashmiris who say if india is supporting terrorism in kashmir then leave kashmir and go to neighbouring country.. simple...
balbal36 1 year ago
a very true man.i havent seen on screen.we do discuss these matters in our rooms but still fear ISI that they would kill us.God bless you
najeebullahkakar 1 year ago
LOL !! The moment i finished watching this video i found a response to this video Titled (Traitor perviz hoodbhoy exposed ) posted by some pakistani LMAO ! This happens all the time ..anyone who tries to make sense in pakistan is a traitor..Truth is bitter eh ?? and who is their hero..let em decide . anyway thanx for the video @kashif.
dangerousmind79 1 year ago
Hoodbhoy is out of his bloody mind. Indian extremists are actually in power. Isn't Narinder Modi an extremist and a terrorist? Is he not the chief minister of Gujarat?
karachishaher 1 year ago
@karachishaher no he is not in NAMO's stat4e muslims's are ahead of hindis on socio/economic laddere.. muslims from all over india flock to gujarta for this rreason yes he is extremist for jihadist mofos for sure
dadarocks 1 year ago
"The abbreviation Paki acquired offensive connotations in the 1960s when used by British tabloids to refer to subjects of former colony states in a derogatory and racist manner. In modern British usage "Paki" is typically used in a derogatory way as a label for all South Asians, including Indians, Afghans and Bangladeshis. To a lesser extent, the term has been applied as a racial slur towards Arabs and other Middle Eastern-looking groups who may resemble South Asians"
XAPYH 1 year ago
@XAPYH It is not my intention to offend Pakistanis with use of the term "Paki" in the video title. I am myself a Pakistani, and despite serious issues with its state ideology and foreign policy, have nothing but respect for the common man... who struggles heroically everyday to makes ends meet. That being said, I had no choice but to use some form of abbreviation for "Pakistani" as YouTube's video title length restrictions were preventing display of the full title in channel playlists.
KashifHKhan 1 year ago 11
@XAPYH In deference to your objections to the unintended derogatory connotations of the term "Paki", I have change the video title from "Hoodbhoy: Honest Paki on Mumbai Attacks" to "Hoodbhoy: Truth About Mumbai Attacks." Thanks.
KashifHKhan 1 year ago
@KashifHKhan pls dont solve the problem related to pakistan let them make suicide bomber or bomb and getting killed by their own bomb
and shut u r mouth we are happy to see like them only and dont upload this type of video ok pls
vairagijayesh 10 months ago
i Hope this true voice...lives ...after this debate is aired on pakistani channels!! pakistan needs honest people like mr Hoodbhoy !! .. and general sahab please contact rehman malik for proof !! :) ! if you really mean it!
dangerousmind79 1 year ago
ye india se mila howa he
supermarwat 1 year ago
Hoodbhoy...intellectual....?
actually a stupid and an ill informed person but a good actor!
mkhurramnadeem 1 year ago
hoodbhoy begairat hai..................media baghi hai,,,,in begairaton ko itna sar pe chara rakha hai........begairat ka bacha
fadiabc 1 year ago
finally. a sane voice from pakistan.
hashpuppy101 1 year ago
where can i get subtitled version?
killintymm 1 year ago
I like the fact that he said Bharat and not Hindustan. It's not just Hindus that live in "bharat". A LOT of people from different religions reside in India. Pakis can't seem to get over this fact.
Minotauraus 2 years ago 13
kashif H KHAN u claim to be pakistan from lahore residing in the united states but all your videos provotes negativity n hates towards pakistan
from army to jihadist
i doubt if ur real paki real muslim
Jaigandjeeki 2 years ago
Agree with You
bilal007007007 1 year ago
The line of Control is like the Berlin Wall.
Some day, it will come down and it will be brought down by an enlightened Kashmiri community and not by India or Pakistan.
It is high time we had a Referendum in Kashmir and settle this once and for all.
pogularocky 2 years ago
He was never treated like a dog. RSS and MNS keep targeting high profile people to make news and increase their popularity. Like a free advertisement for their organisation. But, it keeps backfiring and no one supports them today. They lost miserably in last year's elections. They have no power or control over anything. They just keep barking like stray dogs. Shahrukh Khan also knows that. That is why he never apologized. 95% India hates RSS/VHP/MNS. We don't give a fuck about the remaining 5%
pogularocky 2 years ago
this is so good
sahil156in 2 years ago
islam is evil to the core
thescorpionking2010 2 years ago
we bought an air ticket but the sob refuses to move his base to porkistan
matkakulfi 2 years ago
Yes Pakistanis did it....nothing to hide about it.
nangamujra 2 years ago
Thanx for accepting yet again. I seriously appreciate your honesty.
pogularocky 2 years ago
man hatsoff to this hoodboy ... hes jst being worried abt ur won country man rather than allegation , counter allegation and ... i think wht he want to conway is both countries shud get rid of extremist org. and head towards progress and peace
vaibhav1710 2 years ago 2
He, Ardsher Cowsji like persons are assets of Pakistan. I do not find any thing wrong with him. I agreed 100% to him. So far there is no proof for their so called traitorship etc
sheheryyar 2 years ago 3
All these people are non-muslims, so their hatred for Pakistan is natural!
PersonOfBook 2 years ago
Hoodbhoy is a honest man. There is small problem called Hindu extremism in India also. But i believe that is eradicating day by day. No civilian now wants to have any war with themselves. Only gundas and mawalis are doing that and they are treated like criminals anyway. BJP has also learned that and has changed his idealogy. Whatever past has happened it happened. No future incident (if happened like Gujrat) would not leavy any criminal unpunished in India.
pgoyal1981 2 years ago 4
i blv people on this show are are quite learned and talkin sense..ppl should avoid gettin brainwashed from fanatics on both side of border..indo pak unity matters
DUSTNDREAM 2 years ago
muslims are not capable of brotherhood with people of other religion and thats a fact.
matkakulfi 2 years ago 4
Hoodbhoy, Hasan Nisar and Ahmed Rashid are all liars in Pakistani's eyes because they expose Pakistan as a wretched ROGUE state!
view587 2 years ago
@view587 I am a Pakistani mate and all the names you mentioned here are very respectable to me. They just enlighten us by bringing reality in front of us. They are not trying to misuse you like most of the Mullahs and people like Zaid Hamid.
NawazTakla 1 year ago
Kashif, Now I'm convinced you are a traitor of Pakistan. All you Qadianies and Ismailies are traitors and as such should be thrown out of Pakistan! I hate you people!
PersonOfBook 2 years ago
I completely agree with u. All pakis speaking and exposing the harsh truth about their country must be thrown out of pakistan immediately. Reason - pakistan is meant only and only for terrorists, cheaters, liars, beggars, back-stabbers, hypocrites, etc. In a nutshell - pakistan is meant only for inhuman beasts. Now since Kashif has exposed the reality of his cursed shit land by this video, he must be thrown out of pakistan immediately - right!!!!
gaurav448 2 years ago
@gaurav448
India should not trust America....look at what they've done to Pakistan....all Indians beware of America....they'll fuck you over too.
cavegirl1985 2 years ago 2
@cavegirl448 : why u always blame USA for condition of pakistan ... did america .. spreading extreamisum ..? did america .. spreading wrong islam n extreamist idiology ? did america giving you money n arms without ur permission ? did america offered you terrorist camps ? why dont you accept your mistakes .. u loosers... always pointing out fingers towards others .. once ..at least once try to look at yourself n your country .. n then write your comment ?
holysmoker24 2 years ago
the evil is in the land--ooooooow
scare someone else with ur cheap OLD tricks.
Its always a pleasure laughing at you guys.
adnanahmad23 2 years ago
PersonOfBook: Tum kaminey Randi ke Aulad ho. MIT Professor ka brain dekho bhenchod, he said it so accurately and the facts are out. Tum madharchod illiterate gadhe ho.
ahmedhusseinny 2 years ago
Kashif, don't be disheartened with comments from people like "PersonOfBook". You are doing a great service to the country in your capacity. Truth is always a bitter pill to swallow so you will get reactions like this from misguided people.
canzt3 2 years ago
Actually you are right personofbook, Ismailies and Qadianies are the hidden enemies of muslims and Pakistan, no doubt in it.
supportbuster 2 years ago
If u have a problem with this guy, send him over to India, we'll give him citizenship. There r few like him n we'd try to keep all of them on our soil. A country that doesn't respect it's intellectuals doesn't deserve to have them.
bozrich 2 years ago 3
Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy u are a real person among pigs
MrRajaBihari 2 years ago
hahaha.everyone who opposes pakistan is an intellectual.one who wants to be popular starts to oppose pakistan.hoodbhoy is one of those popular people.he has only one good thing on his credit and that is his book musalman aur science.
how simply he has clearified singh privar of india that eats muslims thrice a day.
agrarian21 2 years ago
That fucking anchor. He himself mentions kashmir first then accuses that analyst of saying that its kashmiri terrorists that did the 26/11 attack. From what i have seen, voices like Hoodbhoy and Hassan Nisar are 2 few, and that the pakistani people choose to ignore these few sane voices, instead listening to clowns like Zaid Hamid, because he says things they want to hear, but never the truth.
DharmRakshak2 2 years ago 47
@DharmRakshak2 Dude i hope that our youth is now understanding more clearly what our previous rulers did to us in the name of religion. We are becoming aware of people like Zaid Hamid and this stupid anchor Hamid Mir etc because minds like theirs are actually the biggest problems of our country. Personally we dont have any problems with India and America but people like Zaid Hamid tries to impress us against you using their unmatched intelligence lol
NawazTakla 1 year ago
@DharmRakshak2 The main reason the debate on such forums as youtube fail due to the sue of bad language against each other. If you had not used this language, many more people would have agreed to you.
zizpong 1 year ago
I like Hoodbhoy, he is honest and clear, he is a man of intellectual thinking. I agree if we have such people as politicians we will be all ok but the problem is such nice people dont wana come to politics and if they come stupid pakistani people will not vote him ....
shakir995 2 years ago 33
After a long search I have found a pakistani person who is honest. There is need of such person's in pakistan to make pakistan a better place and help itself. I think he should run the country and then I dont think there will be any terrorism left in world. It was really a heart warming thing to listen to such a honest pakistani.
chaitu184 2 years ago 9
@sankalp, i would agree with first part of your comment. lekin, lets behave as good indians, no point cursing out ppl like this, just put forth good arguments.
hawakajhonka1 2 years ago 3
every pakistan should blow them self up... this is jehad Way.. to heaven... wat else i can say to the people who wanna live after death... when they will die v will fuck there. dauthers and wifes.. good na..:)
sankalp4499 2 years ago
Your intense hatred to Pakistan is a bread to Jihadis in Pakistan. Jihadis tell Pakistanis that we defend Pakistan from Indian possible attack. if you analyse common Pakistani opinion, they would say it is India who is committing terrorism in Pakistan. Further you people with extreme opinion solids common pakistani's belief
rhummayuna 2 years ago
sir plz avoid this type of comments !!!
pakistanzindabaddd 2 years ago
isko bechare ko goli maar denge ye mulle..jo akal ki baat kare vo kafir hai hahahahahaha
mullonkimaut 2 years ago
Islamic Terrorist State of Pakistan has been a failed state since its inception.
Why Pakistani Islamic Terror is exported and used in U.K, India, U.S and other parts of the world.?
Why Pakistan is world centre of Islamic Terror and Jihadi.?
Why Pakistan army leaders call Islamic Terror and Jihad groups as important Strategic Assets.?
htgajjar 2 years ago
Ye ghashti ka bacha Pervaizi Kafar hai......
Jo Indian Dala hota hai, Kunky Pakistan k Law k mutabiq ye Non Muslim hai..
ramz2245 2 years ago
He is a CIA and RAW agent and getting lots of dollers from them
MrGoodman45 2 years ago
@MrGoodman45 I wonder why do Pakistanis - correction ! MOST pakistanis think that whatever they do is RIGHT and if someone else says/does something which they dont agree with, is wrong?
frankistine20 2 years ago
First time a pakistani man with truth......kamal hai koi to brain rakhta hai pakistan me..
vijaymehla 2 years ago
@vijaymehla My parents come from Pakistan and I gotta say I could not agree more. This guy is such a refreshing change.
frankistine20 2 years ago
harami sala
gabbrujatt 2 years ago
bullshitter
kamikim1 2 years ago
People with brains like Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy should take over the political reins in pakistan. Otherwise Pakistan will be disintegrated into pieces and taken over by Jihadis.
mradamdavey 2 years ago 10
why da hell hez sayin lashkar ... that fukin talib supporter ... lashker e taiba are tryin free kashmir that piece ov shit ....
Mutahir213 2 years ago
@Mutahir213 Really? Kashmir? Who cares about Kashmir .. why not worry about your own country i.e. Pakistan 1st before start fighting for a state thats not even worth it.
frankistine20 2 years ago 2
Finally a paki with some brains!
badassdesi 2 years ago 5
Listen to this man, he is an intelligent man who has won numerous awards for his devotion to studies, he is not anti-Pakistan, but actually a real nationalist. Pakistan is facing much trouble just yesterday there was a sucide bomb. Pakistan should wipe out these rogue elements present in Pakistan.
eleven451 2 years ago
I DONT BELIEVE HES A PAKI
akshatwarm 2 years ago
God The only person in Pakistan who have the ability to think, and see he is still alive
shashank2361 2 years ago 4
U r right yaar... But I don't think he will be alive for long time in bureaucrat Pakistan where media has no freedom
JustMeAtYT 2 years ago
hoodbhoy is not patriot pakisani he speaks usally agianst pakistan and islam.
waqasayub22 2 years ago
1971 india crossed international border lines and took advantage of Pakistan's internal affair. Dirty Kafir hindus can never be trusted. Fuck them.
babur1231 2 years ago
You deposed Mujib-ur Rehman, who was democratically elected to power and was the rightful PM of Pakistan. Because Punjabi and Sindhi power players in the Army and the PPP did not want the Awami league to form the government.
You broke up your own country because you were not united enough to begin with.
ukbang2007 2 years ago
First see how your own country is being fucked. Pakistan has become a prostitute of the US. It is giving u money and fucking u hard.
ashutoshmikku 2 years ago
babur.u are named after a invader who raped ur amis mummy..u dumb arabized brainwashed paki filth..go lick ur arab masters feet.u scum from a cesspool called baltistan..hahaha
AgainstEvil1970 2 years ago 7
Hoodbhoy is a intelligent man. As a nuclear physicist, he knows how devastating a nuclear bomb can be.
Why can't we live in peace? Aren't we facing enough threats to humanity?
ironstealer87 2 years ago 8
speaking the truth
99300208 2 years ago
Pakistan needs to saves itself from itself. As an Indian I know India isnt always as pure as we would like to believe, but still Pakistan needs to forget Kashmir for the time being and focus on itself. One thing, India does not trust the Americans to form any kind of alliance, the Russians are still no 1 in our books. I hope Pakistan returns to a peaceful nation.
VikramRao75 2 years ago 6
Hmm, I agree with you. Americans are messing around in our region. For right now, India is not really a threat to Pakistan but Talibans are.
Pervez Hoodbhoy is one of the prominent nuclear physicist in Pakistan but sadly his pointing out about real face of talibans; Pakistanis still believe that India and Americans are their enemies.
ironstealer87 2 years ago 2
I dont know why Hamid invited this guy in political discussion even he is only Physic profesor inuniversity. Kashmir is core issue b/w pakistan and inda .. it should be solve in under UN resolution. if kahmir problem will not solve then no one can give the surtey for peace. Actually Pakistan was born only for Islam because muslim league got muslim's votes for the name of ISLAM. So pakistan gov. should implement ISLAMIC LAW (not only in judiciary as well as in MEDIA) as soon as possible.
tahir2K9 2 years ago
Hamid invites Zaid Hamid too who is nothing but an engineer and can't form an unbiased view on geo-politics and engages in downright fear-mongering by plagiarizing Alex Jones' bullshit conspiracy-theories.
"So pakistan gov. should implement ISLAMIC LAW"
I don't think Quaid-e-Azam wanted an Islamic Pakistan. He knew of persecutions during Roman Catholic and Protestant periods in England caused by discrimination and championed secularism. However this topic is of much controversy today.
SYLFan2008 2 years ago 3
try safe guarding ur own borders...frget kashmir....look at waziristan,baluchistan,swat...u cant look after ur own country...ur economy is in shambles.....my dear dont u love ur people and ur country????think about ur future....
karma10pa 2 years ago 2
when pakistan was formed, more muslims stayed back in india then joined pakistan. are these muslims who chose to remain in india against islam. these ppl include maulana abdul kalam azad and the great pathan khan ghafar khan. dont u see the stupidity of dividing ppl on the lines of religion.
shankyxyz 2 years ago 4
Brilliant... This whole division in the name of religion, was useless... Mulana Azad warned Jinnah about this.
eleven451 2 years ago 9
Sensible voice in Pakistan. Hope the number of such voices increase on both sides and everlasting peace prevails between the 2 siblings who got separated 62 years back.
krish1011kkr 2 years ago 2
by the way he is not a muslim
But we have tolerance for non muslims in 99% muslim pakistan
aliabdullahmujahid1 2 years ago
Why do we Pakistanis have to label everyone who offers a different perspective from Establishment, a "non-Muslim" or a "traitor". Why can't we just listen to the person's arguments with an open mind as opposed to attacking his faith or casting aspersions on his integrity?
I hate judging people based on their faith or lack thereof. But if you can't live without it, then know that Dr. Hoodbhoy is an Ismaili Muslim and an extremely honest, intelligent, capable, caring, and patriotic man.
-Kashif
KashifHKhan 2 years ago 3
Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy and meer both are Pakistan's enemies. Both should be killed by the gov of Pakistan.
CowEaterindicka 2 years ago
he is probably the only atheist celebrity of pakistan.
confusedimigrant 2 years ago 2
A great man, A MIT Graduate who decided to stay in pakistan and teach and transfer his knowledge to fellow pakistanis. and offcourse his brave fight aganst all wrongs at policy level a true human.... and yes for most a RAW/CIA agent..
BalochTawar 2 years ago 4
only sensible person like this can bring peace hard to believe that in porkistan this type of people exist ..........
bikashliju 2 years ago 2
Porkistan is only going to be saved by people like Hoodbuoy and
Porkistan is going to be killed / finished by people like Zaid Harami...
Insha Allah...
kingcobbra007 2 years ago
I am an Indian and a proud one. I still pray for the stability of Pakistan because a stable Pakistan is in the interest of my country.
Dr Hoodbuoy is an intelligent person no question about it. Pakistan needs such people.
There is a character Zaid Hamid who really needs to make Dr Hoodbuoy his mentor. He badly needs someone to put some sense in him.
rahulinhere2002 2 years ago 5
Though I am an Indian but i take my hat off to this person very brave person comes across as very well educated and sensible speaks very nicely too.
SDSen 2 years ago 6
He is a scientist ! He knows stuff. He is not a thief like AQK. Btw I am also indian :-)
asatsi 2 years ago 4
looks like who ever admits the fact that pakistan has terrorists camps is branded a gaddar... lol.. i wonder how long pakistan can keep on denying these terrorists?
bestofrohan 2 years ago 6
Pakistan needs more people like him.
amansharma06 2 years ago 3
well said. i wish more people in pakistan would stand up and accept the truth about their country.
milindpania 2 years ago 6
Hoodbhoy talks a lot of sense.
jamesmaxwell007 2 years ago 6
great man . hope more like him in pakistan
kashmirisindian 2 years ago 2
perves is a bloody ghaddar. He is the best example of Mir jaafar and mir sadiq
abidkoper 2 years ago
hindu sala..!!
leotakesleo 2 years ago
Mr. Pervez the living gentleman in pakisthan
picologupta 2 years ago 7
this man is a reallly brave man yar
i feel like giving a standing ovation to him
motilalji 2 years ago 12
This person is very matured and speaks sensible must be very edudated unlike zaid unmatured talks
nh77154 2 years ago 6
must be??... read the info he's from " MIT " and yes its easy to see the difference from zaid hamid ( who was probably spraying bullets in afganistan while this guy pervez was in mit )
sshheekkhh 2 years ago 4
some pakistanis do speak the truth
premsporty 2 years ago 7
that is the difference a proper education can make. If you listen carefully, Dr. Pervez never takes sides and is quite objective in his analysis. Unfortunately, this gentleman may very soon (or might have been already) get branded as a mossad or RAW agent.
oliverharddy 2 years ago 4
Good to see the person with great clarity. It takes lot of guts to speak truth at taht level. And its his greatness that he wants to see the truth, beyond what the media or the politicians brainswahing people that Pakistan is good and India is a big villain. If more people like him come forward, pakistan will be back on track and earn respect of the world
thread4to 2 years ago 5
It is good to know that someone like hoodbhoy has the courage to come to national tv and speak truth otherwise we know what all other pakistani analysts have to say
and secondly rss and shiv sena definitely r fundamentalist hindu organistn but they doesnt go to pakistan and blow up bombs so comparing lashkar to them is meaningless
motilalji 3 years ago 10
My friend Pervez hoodhboy is speaking the feelings of educated classs of pakistan (atleast most of them). But the problem is that the policies are not controlled by them, they are done by the military and security establishments, and those who try to go against them e.g leaders selected by popular majority like Nawaz Sharif and Benazir... they are simply thrown out of the way.
harisasghar 2 years ago 2
RSS is not a terrorist organization, they have never indulged in terrorist activities,they have never killed Innocent people, never exploded bombs in market or religious places.comparing RSS with Laskar-e -Toiba etc is not fair.killing of Mahatma Gandhi by Nathu Ram Godse was an individuals extreme reaction..Such killings have been in America and Pakistan also.Killing of Benazeer Bhutto is the latest example.
kuckudk 3 years ago
I don't know RSS and and so can't comment on whether it has been engaged in terrorism in general. I would like to point out though that the current Gujarat minister in Modi government, Maya Kodnani, was a member of RSS' female wing and personally led an attack that killed at least 95 Muslims in Ahmedabad in 2002 during the infamous Gujarat Riots. This is stated in a government affidavit. It appears, therefore, that some RSS members are capable of large scale death and destruction.
-Kashif
KashifHKhan 3 years ago
Nice upload.
but you know a little too much about Indian affairs.
btw it wasnt RSS which carried out the Gujurat riots.
Being an indian muslim, i find it very awkward to see pakistanis man up for indian muslims.
LoopInc 2 years ago 5
It is breath of fresh air to hear Pakistani analysts such as Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy telling the truth about Mumbai attacks on national TV. I agree that Pakistan continues to harbor powerful Jihadi organizations (on account of its policy of fighting proxy wars in India) and that these outfits were involved in Mumbai attacks. I further agree that Jihadi groups have outgrown their military masters by becoming self-sufficient in funding and now also pose a serious threat to domestic security.
-Kashif
KashifHKhan 3 years ago
a lot of people back home have given folks like Dr Hoodbhoy and Asma Jahangir a LOT of stick. Mainly coming from Jamaati ullu k pathay, and a lot of Pakistanis prone to believe in conspiracy theories and denial.
asma's meeting with Bal Thackeray also was the last straw for these Jamaatis.
many idiots called it an "Ahmedi conspiracy and Ahmedis are all traitors and Israeli trained".
AtheistPakistani 3 years ago
You have identified all the right parts of the puzzle "jamaati ullu k pathay": I do not agree with abusive language on youtube but frankly you have been soft with this fitna. Many in Pakistan are living in a delusion and denial and create false realities of conspiracy theories. Facts: we are upto our knees under militancy threat and fast sinking further closing our eyes will not take the problem away. It saddens me to see many countrymen not realising this. But good see people like you also.
Bareilykobans 3 years ago 3