I think that's not the real tune of his performance. It's the record problem. It's normal. I guess he must be pretty good at violin because he learn violin at very young age.
i totally agree with you. i totally lost respect for him after he ruined prelude & allegro. i mean i played it better when i was like, 12 years old. he should really know where his limit is and stick to that. don't "attempt" to show off and make a big mess... and all of you who thinks i'm being harsh, i am not, it's just putting things into perspective. like i play the piano but i would never perform rachmaninov piano concerto No3 in front of a big audience! that's what he did many times!
I totally agree with you. He is a terrible violinist. I really do not know why he insists on playing the violin at his concert.Maybe that is the only way which he can impress brainless girls.His Prelude and Allegro with Lang Lang was a big insult to Lang Lang and of course, the biggest insult to the professional music industry.
to be good or bad is a matter of oppinion...you're considered a good musician because there are many people who would adore your music
that's what I see as the basis for judging...
so if billions of people say he's good...are you saying that such a large percentage of people are wrong? Or are you going to counter this by whinning "But the Chinese are not properly educated"
cacalacapoo just shut up no one cares what you think of leehom cause he doesnt know how to "stand properly"? and what makes you the genius of standing?
haha very funny. we should put a necklace on this neck just like Arnie's movie "running man" and if he plays a wrong note he gets a electrical shock and after 5 wrong notes it explodes automatically.
Yes, only his fans that like his singing are giving me negatives. But anybody with any experience in music can tell you he should NOT play or better yet, just not PERFORM instruments.
It's okay, it doesn't show that chinese people don't now music, on the contrary we DO, there are many talented musicians, just not Jay Chou with instruments, I have to admit, some of his singing is decent. He should stick to that and stop showing his poor abilities with the dozen instruments, he thinks he knows how to play...
I think a lot of his fans are from malaysia or singapore. Fans are fans, and of course they will defend him, no matter how poor he is.
You reminded me last year I watched a vid with him playing part of (he can't do the whole thing) Kreisler's infamous "Praeludium and Allegro" with Lang Lang and I kindly said that he needs some improvement, and I got mountains of hate mails because of it, most of them were from malaysia. anyways it looks like you can read Chinese so I'll write in chinese.
王力宏的小提琴拉的實在是不怎樣.別的不說光是這影片裡他連簡單的第三把位 A 弦的 fa 音準都拉的似是而非,還企圖用很多不漂亮的抖音欲蓋彌彰.要是我羞也羞死了.我記得他剛出道時在台灣接受綜藝節目訪問時說到他本來是主修小提琴的後來才唱歌.怎麼才過沒幾年小提琴就從主修變成興趣實在是令人費解.流行音樂他愛怎麼拉我不想管,可是他把好好一首 praeludium and allegro 拉的亂七八糟我就非罵不可.這首易練不易精的曲子是幾乎所有"主修"小提琴的學生必學的而且為了練好只怕吃了不少苦頭.王在怎麼有天分也沒有像 heifetz or perlman 一樣,更不用說他沒有天分.王把這首經典名曲拉的鬼模鬼樣的讓人一聽就氣,簡直是在污辱 Kreisler. 令人更不能理解的是一個號稱有絕對音感的人怎麼會連自己拉的音準似是而非都聽不出來,還是這就是他的"絕對"音感, i.e.我拉的就一定是對 kind of pitch.我同意你的看法.這影片還是不要上傳的好免得讓人看了一肚子氣.
@zzfxxx 这首曲子的名字是 "cinema paradiso". 来自同名的电影,电影本身也是经典,喜爱电影的不可错过.
bananafong 1 year ago
it does not matter what he does like how he plays the violin. All the girls care is his looks and body. Are you all stupid? lol.
neonaction 1 year ago
I think that's not the real tune of his performance. It's the record problem. It's normal. I guess he must be pretty good at violin because he learn violin at very young age.
jinyu911 2 years ago
what's wrong with this?
this is pretty good at least its not out of tune and has feeling in it..its not call showing off..its call trying to make his supportive fans happy :)
how do you know he's proud?
c830124 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
要我做他還不要,讓無能和無知的人崇拜
讓正常人唾罵,我還不如死了算- -"
他小提琴is ok,but 只會用些"十歲的人已經嫌簡單的歌"來show off,搞那麼多樂器,沒一樣是能見人的,說觀眾是努力爭取,只是經紀人和公司幫他搞而已,為了被無知的渣滓崇拜,不顧一切貶低了自己值得嗎
CSOgodhand 2 years ago
去查一查王力宏的資料吧
他不光只有外型而已
而且啊 只會說那麼粗淺的英文 我想你還是省省吧
這樣只是更顯你的無知罷了
rikku7919 2 years ago 9
He shouldn't exploit his fame and status to such lvl... stick to what he does best..
That performance didn't entertain me one bit...
BratscheChen 2 years ago
但是不可否認的
他的確很優秀啊
louisezx11 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
之前他拉過prelude & allegro 我看了真的很失望 覺得他原本就不該選這曲子. 或許他是有實力 但是他ruined掉整個piece的經隨. 一開始的抖音很難聽 中間雙音跳弓的地方也跳過.. 後面根本是在亂拉... 拉完之後 大家還高興得說他很厲害...
jandychou 3 years ago
i totally agree with you. i totally lost respect for him after he ruined prelude & allegro. i mean i played it better when i was like, 12 years old. he should really know where his limit is and stick to that. don't "attempt" to show off and make a big mess... and all of you who thinks i'm being harsh, i am not, it's just putting things into perspective. like i play the piano but i would never perform rachmaninov piano concerto No3 in front of a big audience! that's what he did many times!
kcc135711 3 years ago
有些人是不是脑子有问题啊。也许你比较闲 可以把他拉过的一首曲子练得比他好。那就怎么了 就代表你超越王力宏了??他的观众是他自己努力争取来的 又不是天上掉的。
freedomhom 2 years ago 3
厄。。他的觀眾可不是靠他拉琴爭取來的。。
他要是只拉琴而不會唱歌,大概就消失在芸芸眾生裡了。 他小提琴的水平僅僅是一般般而已。
我的重點是,很多人不滿他可能是因為他搞這麼一個噱頭,有點嘩眾取寵的味道。 或是利用他的名氣、地位來實現那比較不足為人道的自我吧?
BratscheChen 2 years ago
你就算拉的比他好10倍 100倍 又怎样??那些人不会听你拉 他们只想听王力宏拉。是不是觉得你比王力宏拉的好
却还是个普通人 心里不平衡啊 。王力宏之所以是王力宏跟他小提琴拉的比你好没有关系。你比他拉的好(还不知道怎么回事呢)你也成不了王力宏。 闲着没事多学学专业知识 多思考思考自己的不足吧 别竟做一些想不开的事。
freedomhom 2 years ago 14
@freedomhom just shut the fuck up
neonaction 1 year ago
I totally agree with you. He is a terrible violinist. I really do not know why he insists on playing the violin at his concert.Maybe that is the only way which he can impress brainless girls.His Prelude and Allegro with Lang Lang was a big insult to Lang Lang and of course, the biggest insult to the professional music industry.
jameshoffnung 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah :-) but no matter how bad he is, some stupid and silly fans would think he is a great violinist anyway.
jandychou 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我個人是認為 這是一種盡業精神吧
既然要表演 就要把曲子練熟, 他給人家得感覺 像是在應付一些聽不懂小提琴的人. 不管如何 大家都還會說他很厲害.
jandychou 3 years ago
您和您教授程度應該都不是很好耶. 敢問您是哪間學校的? 說出來讓大家笑笑吧!
jandychou 3 years ago
其实Leehom小提琴真的不错,可以看看他其他solo,音色音准技巧处理在业余爱好者里都算很不错了
wulioppa 3 years ago
可是, 我覺得他的音色不美(就連拉空弦也不美). 抖音也沒感情.. 或許業餘的聽不出好壞吧.
jandychou 3 years ago
毕竟不能用专业标准要求他,业余的这样算可以了,没多少唱歌的像他一样什么都能懂一点。像上面说的,大家怎么可以把他和Heifetz 这种宗师级的放在一起呢?难道我们吃了8岁小孩炒的菜就一定要说和XXX酒店的师傅比厨艺太差?
wulioppa 3 years ago
他要娛樂歌迷我沒意見只要他拉他自己寫的芭樂歌就好. 可他偏偏要拉新天堂樂園,還把 Kreisler 的作品拉的鬼模鬼樣的我就要說了。我第一次 post 是很委婉的說他應該要加強一些細處結果一堆不懂音樂的歌迷突然通通變成音樂大師,叫人哭笑不得。我說的也不是吹毛求疵都是一些基本功你要是學過就會知道。我會講理只要回我的也是理性的回。結果呢?是阿他是個州有歌迷,不過三人成虎的故事我想你也是知道的了。他沒有自吹自擂? 你看他金馬獎結束後接受訪問時還敢大言不慚說只有一個音沒拉準? 他不準的音多了不勝枚舉,這不是自吹自擂是甚麼? 別跟著別人瞎起鬨有一點主見吧.
josephile 3 years ago 3
講的拾人牙慧了無新意. 你具體的說一下王好在哪吧.他持弓像雞爪音又拉不準還愛出來亂拉一通. 不然的話就回你媽的地下室打槍吧.
josephile 3 years ago
@josephile 你厲害你去當他阿,跟他一樣阿。不要沒實力就在跟球評一樣亂嗆人
RickyWith1992 1 year ago
我看你跟你的教授都是修到屁眼裡去了. 你主修大概就是像王這樣而已吧? 去 New England Convervatory 看看就知道甚麼是高手了.
多練點琴把長弓跟音階好好練一練吧.
josephile 3 years ago
freedomhom 3 years ago
不然你要 lang lang 怎麼說啊? 當然講場面話啊! 笨蛋舉不出王好在哪裡就乖乖的龜回你媽媽的地下室對著王打槍吧. 少在那裏廢話. 你也看到我之前 post 也知道王的真實背景. 怕被人罵就趕快改口說拉琴指是興趣他其他樂器也是奏個那麼兩首. 講難聽一點黔驢技窮. 他音感在哪啊? 我看你是耳朵被屎塞到聽不出來吧? 他就專門騙你這種 bimbo 你搞理工? 邏輯這麼差這麼不會客觀分析? 我看你還是乖乖在媽媽地下室裡打槍比較安全.
josephile 3 years ago
开始以为你只是有点心胸狭窄 rp差点罢了
现在算了 懒得管你了 你简直就是个人渣
好好跟你说话你就是满口污言秽语
你不上档次 不代表我要跟你一样 我不会再理你了
你不配跟我对话 你哪些恶心的脏话我很多都看不懂
还有 我奉劝你一句 骂人的时候不要提别人的妈妈
否则让我见到你 我不会让你好过的 别人也一样 不管男生女生
你乱吠人家的家人 总会有人让你遭报应的 不是不报 时候未到
劝你回头是岸 你要是会拉琴是小提琴的悲哀 你不配
freedomhom 3 years ago
那人家講我的祖宗就 ok? 你這是甚麼邏輯? 還念理工? 我叫他回他媽媽家的地下室也不行? 是你們先滿口汙言穢語的還惡人先告狀? 沒文化就別當狗亂吠省的人家把中國人看扁了。不會拉琴就東扯西拉的想要轉移焦點。你跟 troll0123 一起來美國吧我一起跟你們把事情解決了,我等不及你不給我好過了快來吧。我看你們根本是同一個人。沒種的就去當孬種少丟人現眼了。
我還是老話一句: 請說出他拉的好在哪裡,然後大家來討論技巧的問題。講不出來就不要講吧。
josephile 3 years ago
to be good or bad is a matter of oppinion...you're considered a good musician because there are many people who would adore your music
that's what I see as the basis for judging...
so if billions of people say he's good...are you saying that such a large percentage of people are wrong? Or are you going to counter this by whinning "But the Chinese are not properly educated"
XSilverDestinyChaos 3 years ago
Those people who don't know Leehom please shut up!!!
cassie3178 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
中華民鬼憲法草案」有關領土的規定(第四條)這樣說:
「中華民鬼領土為江蘇、浙江、安徽、江西、湖北、湖南、四川、西康、河北、山東、山西、河南、陝西、甘肅、 青海、福建、廣東、廣西、雲南、貴州、遼寧、吉林、黑龍江、熱河、察哈爾、綏遠、寧夏、新疆、蒙古、西藏等 固有疆域。」
從條文中,我們發現,台灣並沒有被列在其「固有疆域」中
逃難族群竊據台灣,原本只想暫留不想建設,數十年之後,還是無路可逃,才把台灣納入中華民鬼憲法的領土,
中華民鬼將台灣納入其領土,並未獲得 多數 臺灣人 同意。
gto1159 3 years ago
lmao, even in 4 comments, someone has to make a retarded downgrading comment...
wtf is wrong with you people
kaitamasaki 3 years ago
cacalacapoo just shut up no one cares what you think of leehom cause he doesnt know how to "stand properly"? and what makes you the genius of standing?
JOOFiiExD 4 years ago
probably you are the one who does not know how to play violin.
get a life and learn something real.
leehom sucks!
jandychou 3 years ago 3
He also can't play if his life depended on it.
cacalacapoo 3 years ago
haha very funny. we should put a necklace on this neck just like Arnie's movie "running man" and if he plays a wrong note he gets a electrical shock and after 5 wrong notes it explodes automatically.
josephile 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He doesn't know how to stand properly..what a shame..
cacalacapoo 4 years ago
站37步. 音色不美麗.. intonation很差.. he is no good at all.
whoever thinks he is good, they are all pathetic.
jandychou 3 years ago
Yes, only his fans that like his singing are giving me negatives. But anybody with any experience in music can tell you he should NOT play or better yet, just not PERFORM instruments.
cacalacapoo 3 years ago
it only shows to other youtubers around the world that we Chinese do not know much about music. this is so pathetic.
the uploader should remove this video.
jandychou 3 years ago
It's okay, it doesn't show that chinese people don't now music, on the contrary we DO, there are many talented musicians, just not Jay Chou with instruments, I have to admit, some of his singing is decent. He should stick to that and stop showing his poor abilities with the dozen instruments, he thinks he knows how to play...
cacalacapoo 3 years ago
agree with you. And i think the chinese audience need to be educated too.
Wong is no good at all, but WHY those stupid fans keep defending for him??? isn't that very pathetic?
jandychou 3 years ago
Please kindly do not use the term :"CHINESE audience",
though i agree with you of his weaknesses, but as a chinese, i really feel offended by your choice of words.
friends4ever11 3 years ago
you mean he sucks and you feel offended when you said he is one of us?
jandychou 3 years ago
i don't really care if he suck but i care that you said that "chinese audience need to be educated"
friends4ever11 3 years ago
I think a lot of his fans are from malaysia or singapore. Fans are fans, and of course they will defend him, no matter how poor he is.
You reminded me last year I watched a vid with him playing part of (he can't do the whole thing) Kreisler's infamous "Praeludium and Allegro" with Lang Lang and I kindly said that he needs some improvement, and I got mountains of hate mails because of it, most of them were from malaysia. anyways it looks like you can read Chinese so I'll write in chinese.
josephile 3 years ago
王力宏的小提琴拉的實在是不怎樣.別的不說光是這影片裡他連簡單的第三把位 A 弦的 fa 音準都拉的似是而非,還企圖用很多不漂亮的抖音欲蓋彌彰.要是我羞也羞死了.我記得他剛出道時在台灣接受綜藝節目訪問時說到他本來是主修小提琴的後來才唱歌.怎麼才過沒幾年小提琴就從主修變成興趣實在是令人費解.流行音樂他愛怎麼拉我不想管,可是他把好好一首 praeludium and allegro 拉的亂七八糟我就非罵不可.這首易練不易精的曲子是幾乎所有"主修"小提琴的學生必學的而且為了練好只怕吃了不少苦頭.王在怎麼有天分也沒有像 heifetz or perlman 一樣,更不用說他沒有天分.王把這首經典名曲拉的鬼模鬼樣的讓人一聽就氣,簡直是在污辱 Kreisler. 令人更不能理解的是一個號稱有絕對音感的人怎麼會連自己拉的音準似是而非都聽不出來,還是這就是他的"絕對"音感, i.e.我拉的就一定是對 kind of pitch.我同意你的看法.這影片還是不要上傳的好免得讓人看了一肚子氣.
josephile 3 years ago
prelude & allegro的精華他不敢拉(雙音跳弓的地方)..他還覺得台下的人聽不懂Kreisler的曲子, 蒙騙過去就可以了. 簡直說是自欺欺人...
但是最讓人覺得不爽的是, 那些不懂音樂的人, 批評王力宏拉得不好, 還好意思反駁~
jandychou 3 years ago
說的一點不錯.他連一開始的 prelude 都拉的讓人聽了快要吐血.毛手毛腳的沒一個音是準的,連 e 弦第一把位的 sharp fa 都可以拉不準他自己居然不覺得丟臉我真是無言了. lang lang 會氣死吧為這種水準的伴奏...
奇怪的是就是有人會被他騙.像他這樣平庸的音樂系裡隨便抓就一堆,我真是不懂怎麼會有人覺得他有才華.我怎麼看都看不出來.他的其他樂器不提也罷,比半調子還不如.他的那些歌迷也真是耳朵去塗了糞什麼都聽不出來.
josephile 3 years ago
so clear
castyteo 4 years ago
i was there..saw best leehom that night
lawlawrence 5 years ago