Added: 4 years ago
From: loginjonel
Views: 27,621
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (186)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Both the original and remake are terrific. Very different films. One doesn't have to be "better" than the other when they're so different in tone and treatment. The remake had the benefit of having Angela Bettis and Patricia Clarkson as Carrie and Margaret, who were both excellent. Without them, it wouldn't have had the same anchorage. Spacek and Laurie's performances were perfect for the original film and that style. People just close-mindedly bashing the remake is just stupid and ignorant.

  • The 1976 version may be more of a classic and Sissy Spacek was more memorable with her role as Carrie but the remake follows the book more and has Carrie live at the end.

  • i love both these movies but if you read the book, they actually include allot more in the remake. originial is still a little better thoough

  • Wow, how predictable. The top comment is "OMFG 1976 version is better!"

    -.- just appreciate both pieces of art, seriously.

  • 1976 version, obviously...

  • The original Carrie, all the way. The tv remake is pathetic and so fuckin stupid. They should do a real remake.

  • fuck music

    

  • I think that the BEST version of Carrie is the BOOK. Anyone else agree?

  • why wasn't there a clip for the remake?

  • If I was Suie I would had screamed Carrie look out

  • The best is the BOOK

  • @ThatMrBerd the character was more powerful than the book which makes the 1976 movie very watered down. I like how the remake somewhat covers the book more closely then again they had a little more to work with vs. the 1976 version. Suttle difference vs just leveling the high school and then just leveling the entire town. I connect more with the book with the remake a close second and just look back to the 1976 version as eye candy (gotta love the nude locker room scene:).

  • @shaithis80 oh yah

    

  • i like the 2002 version better idk why but it makes more sense plus Carrie lives a

  • I like carrie 2002 better cause it followed the book version there both good and classic to me though

  • I like both equally. As far as story goes the older one is more accurate, but I like the Carrie in the newer one better because she is more like what I imagined Carrie was like when I first read the book.

  • 1976 one is obviously better. it's more dramtic and more realistic than the remake. though the 2002 one followed the book more, the orginal will always be the best.

  • Neither. The book was better than any of them.

  • Tbh, the 1976 version was better. The 1976 version had that special originality in it that made it better. Also, in my opinion.... Sissy Spacek did a better job playing Carrie than Angela Bettis did(Don't get me wrong she's a great actress and so is Sissy Spacek). The 1976 version just made more sense and had better directing.

  • 1976 if one of my favourite (if not the favourite movie) movies ever, but the 2002 got a lot of potential in it. They could have went all High School Musical on us, but they didn't. It was a good movie, until the end, wich was a huge dissapointment. But that figures becouse it was supposed to be a pilot movie to a tv series, wich never started. Thank god, there's no way that would have worked. I wish I could do a long in-depth comparison but youtube comments have such limits...

  • @andsosmileysays Actually the 2002 one follows the book more than the 1976. But that doesn't mean it's the better movie. 

  • 1976 is better, but 2002 was more like the book.

  • 1976 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • I haven't seen the remake least I don't thinking did but I just got done watching the orignal. I love sissy spacek she's a amazing actress hope the remake is good I seen it had my Katherine Isabelle in it lol

  • whoa i didn't even know this movie was remade?

  • i've watched both and i think that the remake is kick ass

    of course its from the idea of the old one but its just better

    the 1976 one just isnt scary its nice but not scary

  • old version always r better than reamkes,but carrie 2:the rage is much better than the first one

  • los dos son muy buenos pero una version que sea exactamente igual como dice el libro fuera el ganador

  • the best version is 1976

    like halloween

    

  • GAHHHH COVER GAHHH!

    1976 is a better movie, 2002 is closer to the book.

    nuff said.

  • I feel the 1976 version doesn't do the book justice the way the 2002 version does. Sissy Spacek just didn't seem to fit Carrie for me after I read the book and neither did Betty Buckley (although she's amazing in the other stuff I've seen her in). Angella Bettis and Rena Sofer had a better chemistry I think. Not to mention the remake has a nicer ending.

  • CARRIE (2002) PLEASE THUMBS UP !

  • you should have used the original version of ballroom blitz, this one sucks

  • The 1976 version of Carrie is obviously better than the 2002 version 'cause it was made when the best of things was made + since the 2002 version is just a copy so what would you learn new from that?

  • @gtUndertakerMinistry And as everyone knows the 1976 version is just a copy of the book so therefore the same logic applies to it, of course

  • there's not even the carrie 2002 in this! but i still like the carrie 2002 better

  • nice vid

  • I like the 1976 version best.

    I still think the version from 2002 is good & don't like the end on that version.

  • the original one is better, sissy spacek rocked in that movie unlike the other actress in 2002 movie

  • 1976 version: it's better!!!

    2002 version: it looks like a telefilm...

  • the original carrie is better

  • The original is better than the 02 version.

  • Which is the Carrie that is more like the novel, the original or remake?

  • @VioletBoyTV is the remake, but the original version is better than it.

  • @VioletBoyTV

    The remake actually was closer to the novel; except for the end.

    But I find the original a little better.

  • u didnt even show 2002 in this!

  • my fav is CARRIE 2002

  • they're all gonna laugh @ you! !

  • i think the first carrie can kick the other carries ass!

  • 1976 i love that 1!

  • My vote goes for the 2002 version, mostly for the better accuracy to the orginial story.

    But, there is several inaccuracies in the 2002 version (including the alternate ending), but I'm able to look past them.

  • I love Carrie with sissy spacek, shes a great actress especially in carrie, screw the new one.

  • nvr seen the movie but think it is funny that a freaky possessed person shares my name hmmm mayb thats why my steven king obsessed english teacher hated me

  • Of course the BEST version is the original from 1976, but we CANNOT deny that Angela Bettis is an AMAZING actress and she ROCKED playing carrie, she took that role like nobody's business

  • @artemiscarrington Can you tell me is it ok if a 12-14 year old watches this movie (1976 version not 2002)

  • @nightwishfan06 I recommend you to watch both films and also read the book, to enter carrie's world! as a carrie die hard fan, must tell you, you'll enjoy it.

  • @nightwishfan06 yes i have the DVD and its rated 14A so its ok I'm 17 but I have seen both 1976 version is better in my opinion.

  • @artemiscarrington Have you ever read the source novel? There are far too many deviations in the 1976 Carrie for me to think of it as anywhere near as faithful as the 2002 version. Don't get me wrong though, I love it all the same. Nothing like getting revenge on the foul idiots in high school, yeah?

  • @DarkwolvenWarrior i have read it 27 fucking times :)) i'm the number one carrie fan.

  • I like the 1976 version better.

  • The best version is from 2002 with

    Angela Bettis

  • You're an idiot. Please do the world a favour and crash your car into a tree at full speed.

  • trash

  • The best version is from 1976

  • AMEN

  • @Ilharess84

    There is no best version. They're both bad&boring.

  • @CleverDjembe i think the remake was not boring but the 1976 one was really boring..pointless and yawnnn fest but to each his own

  • @animegirlino1 Yeah, and you're obviously not seeing the big picture because everyone knows the 1976 one is the better movie.The 1976 had better prom scene and better acting. Not even Angela Bettis could match Sissy Spacek's acting as Carrie in the 1976 version. Sorry to say, but the 2002 version gets a 5/10 while the 1976 version gets a 9/10.

  • @Ilharess84 Agreed.

  • @Ilharess84 Defenitely i love the old one

  • lol funny charmed101fan i thinnk all of themr great eeven though i havent seen carrie 2

  • in the ORIGINAL movie in '76 carrie got stabbed by her mom. then b4 her mom could kill her carrie essentially crucified her mom with knives(ironic much?) she then collapses the house on her and her mom,killing them both she didnt bleed to death in a parking lot you morons

  • the new one is better bcuz the acting and effects are better

  • I liked both the 76 and 02 versions. The 2002 version had lot more detail in the story line and a better ending. The only thing I didn't like about the 1976 version was the ending.

  • I like the first ever carrie

  • What is the name of the song?

  • poor Carrie... I feel sorry for her. She died beacouse her power... and hers fucking mom!!!! Sorry my launging

  • both were very good, but 1976 i think was better. 2002 was pretty good, but 1976 was the better

  • carrie 1976 is better, but 2002 wasn't absolutely horrible. But id have to say the original is always best. By the way, does anyone know what Carrie 2: The Rage is about? And is it any good? as far as im concerned, random sequels arent always the best, but ive always wondered what Carrie 2 was.

  • Carrie 1976 is the only Carrie. Sissy Spacek is simply amazing and DePalma did a great job. The 2002 one is a joke. NEVER under any circumstances let someone who have havent seen the 1976 version see them remake first.

  • carrie 1976

  • Comment removed

  • Carrie direct by De Palma wins

  • Carrie (1976) is better in my opinion then the remake. But the remake with Angela Bettis is a lot better than Carrie 2 (1999).

    I generally found Carrie (2002) to be a pretty good remake though it certainly is not as good as the original. Sissy Spacek was great.

  • 1976 carrie was better

    sissy spaceks was a great carrie and john travolta looked well auh-maz-ing

  • i think my favorite is Both

  • my favorite is carrie 2 the rage

  • i definitely thought the original carrie was much better ...... the remake is over the top ...... nothing like red lights and really low bass to enhance the creepy factor ...... the orchestrated soundtrack in the remake is just plain cheese ...... btw ..... whats with the ballroom blitz ..... this wouldve been a much better vs. video if the original soundtracks were there

  • idk man, id have to disagree with u. I think carrie remake was better coz the visuals had enhanced asnd the actor fitted into the part perfecly with the shaking and everything. when the first one got the blood she looked crazy while carrie remake she looked evil

  • well the score of the original Carrie is just amazing. The score of remake is forgettable.

  • i think the 2002 carrie was better but sissy spaceks looks creeepy and weird and well carrie. so i say if she was in the 2002 version it would be awsome. they should make the rage carrie 2 remake.

  • Carrie is better than Carrie 2  the carrie in carrie 1 looks really really creepy

  • OMG, I hate the 2002 version. It's like, a mockery. They should leave the classics, be classics. *sigh* I love, Carrie, though. :)

  • part 1 is definently better cause in a horror you want horror not drama

  • anyone notice how sissy spaceks carrie rubbe the blood all over herself?>.> i mean the big patch would coated half her face and dripped of her neck, and the other splattered the dress, but like...she spread it over her face and neck. o.o

  • yes

  • Las dos versiones son buenas, la de 1976 es un clasico y es una pelicula genial, y la de 2002 es mucho mas fiel al libro en muchos aspectos .

    En cuanto a lo que se ha comentado, efectivamente Sue tiene la regla justo después de la muerte de Carrie pero NO ES SU PRIMERA REGLA,. Y tampoco creo que desarrolle poderes mentales como Carrie; es sólo que Sue se vale del poder de Carrie para que ésta lea su mente y se de cuenta de que nounca tuvo intención de hacerle daño

  • Carrie 2002 was better, it followed the Stephen King book,thou the first one was good and scary, exspecially the last scene where Carrie's hand comes up out of the grave, very scary stuff!!!!!!!

  • yes i agree! i dislike the feel of the highschool in the 2002 version, but angela bettis is the perfect carrie, her and linzi from carrie the musical. they make me cry Dx

  • thi sdoesnt even show the second one

  • The original Carrie is the best movie ever. :)

  • Na carrie 1, a Sue foi ver ela no baile o q foi legal em relação ao 2, mas no 1 a prof e ela morrem e a Sue fica louca, eh chato.

  • i mean that the 1976 version was better.

  • The 2002 version is better. I know that the 2002 version followed the book a little more but it didn't end like in the book, neither did the 1976 version. Carrie's physical appearance is not accurate in either movie. Carrie is supposed to be a little fat and has some acne blemishes. She's pretty much a plain looking girl, but in the movies, the actresses are fairly attractive. Also, Sue Snell was supposed to have had her first period at the end of the story and developed psychic powers.

  • You are not correct about Sue. Though she did have her period at the end of the story, it was not her first one. Some people even speculate that what she had was a miscarriage, since earlier in the book she worried that she might be pregnant by Tommy Ross.

    As to what you said about Sue developing psychic powers, I have no idea where you would have gotten that idea.

  • because ahe was able to read Carrie's mind while Carrie was dying and she was able to see through her eyes. at some point in the story, it is mentioned that girls who have the tendency to be psychic develop their powers after they start their first period.

  • The reading of Carrie's mind and seeing her memories was the work of Carrie's powers, and had nothing to do with Sue. Carrie also read Sue's mind, which is where she learned that Sue was maybe her only classmate who didn't hate Carrie. Pity for her, yes, disgust for her, yes, but no hate for Carrie. The book was specific about that.

    As to the connection between psychic girls and their periods, Carrie had powers even when she was a child; remember how she called down the rocks?

  • Oh. Ok. I must have misunderstood something while reading the book. Thanks for clearing that up for me. :)

  • s'all good. glad I could help =)

  • Once I ate a pickle and my powers turned it into a shiny green banana.

  • I never read the book What was the ending?

  • In the book, Carries does not die because of her mother. She dies because her heart exploded after making Chris Hargenson's car explode. Sue Snell finds Carrie lying down on the road and she was able to see through Carrie's eyes. What she sees is that the world is getting dark as Carrie slips away. After Carrie dies, Sue leaves mortified. She then looks down at her pants and she sees that she's bleeding and she screams.

  • no she could probbaly just tell she was dying...

  • wait, i thought carrie bleeds to death in a parking lot and Sue Snell goes to her and lets carrie raid her mind. Carrie learns that Sue is innocent and lets her live but Carrie dies.

  • I don't know. It's been a long time since I've read that novel.

  • yea but if carries heart exploded, she wouldve died instantly. on wikipedia, it says that her mom stabbed her in the shoulder, she killed her mom, and carrie collapses in a parking lot fatally wounded. then sue goes to her and allows carrie to go through her mind and carrie learns that sue didnt hate her. then carrie dies. i never actually read the book.

  • no she didnt carrie and her mom die in the house after carrie collapses it on them then in a dream sue goes to the lot where the house was which is now just rubble and as she lays some flowers on carries grave carries hand reaches up and tries to pull her down there was no parking lot

  • I'm talking about the book, not the movie.

  • oh nvm then lol

  • lol

  • Later on, there are these people, from some sort of government agency, investigating the town to search for girls who have the psychic gene. These agents mention that when girls with this gene start their first period, they develop psychic powers. These agents plan to terminate these girls in case they develop dangerous abilities. That's one of the resons why Sue leaves town. She developed psychic abilites and she wanted to leave before the agents could run DNA tests on her.

  • I didn't really get that when I read it. Did you understand the letter at the end?

  • Everybody dies

  • the remake got most of the movie from the novel then the orginal EX: police intergratons,

    scenes of her as a little girl with her mom and neighbor getting into arguement,

    her causing havoic all round the town, but it did look like a made for tv movie. I liked the remake better

  • original 1 is best an just cause the 2002 had more effects dont make it gd sissy spacek is carrie no doubt

  • la mejor es la de 1976

  • La mejor es la original. El remake cuenta con más efectos especiales y fluidez en la trama, pero sin duda la original está mucho más buena, da más terror sin necesidad de los efectos por la intensidad de los personajes. :P

  • I think Carrie 2002 was better. Of course the 1976 one was good, but in 2002 they used more special effects. That was like wow like the scene with the car look at 1976 and 2002 and you tell me which was better.

  • just coz the special effects are gd doesnt mean their acting is gd tho, im sure when this film came out the sfx were really amazing

  • I surelly prefer 1976's one !

  • Have you people even read the book. It is so much better. But I do like the original best.

  • Fuck you all...Carrie 2002 was better.

    P.S Eat shit

  • yes, original

  • originalllll

  • The original carrie is my favorite.

  • i think the pig blood scene

    for 2002 was wayyyyyyyyyy

    too much!

  • wheres the carrie 2002 remake version? you should have the original scene then the remake straight after, the same parts of each. that would be kool lol

  • 1976 Carrie.

    They're all gonna laugh at you!

    THE BEST.

  • that was Piper Laurie's best saying in the movie!

    " They're all going to laugh at you!"

    Love the original and remake and sequal to 1976 version

  • haha that part made me laugh so hard. and got stuck in the heads of my friend and i. "they're all gonna laugh at you" haha we mimicked that for weeks. il have to bring that joke up again some time soon.

  • both have their good points

    i like the 2002 version better tbh tho im not realy sure ^^

  • the original carrie is the best!!!!

  • i like da 2002 version beta but datz cuz i neva saw da 1976 version lolz but i wanna c it 2 compare it

  • Who would win if Carrie was reborn and fought Jean Grey and they both obtained phoenix force

  • i have no idea

  • whats the name of this song

  • Ballroom Blitz by Tia Carerre

    It says at the start of the video

  • the first is better, but it could have been more violent when she owned every1 in the building, instead of just sprayin them with o hose, she should have exploded some people

  • like Rachel, in THE RAGE: CARRIE 2, how she cuts people up with glass, Spears one in the head, Explodes a girl's glasses into her eyes, guys balls get cut off, drowning, and crushing some girl with a giant pillar. AWESOME CARRIE 2002 part though

  • holy shit, i hafta watch that 1

  • I never seen the 2002 version but I saw the original and it was really good!

  • Wonder how she gets her eyes open that wide.

  • The 2 things I wish they would have also included in the 2002 remake that were in the book were 1. at the end where Sue Snell is standing over Carrie and she has her period in her pants and 2. when Carrie's mom stabs her with a butcher knife and it's in her back for the rest of the ook until she dies....but that would have made it hard for her to live and run off to Florida, which I love as an ending to the 2002 version.

  • how does this VS the 2 films? it only shows one?!

    but carrie 1976 is better

  • Of course the 1976 version is better, but I still think that Angela Bettis did a very good job! Carrie 2002 was much closer to the book. In the book, Carrie did not kill her mother with knives, and also Carrie destroyed her whole community while walking back from the prom. This was presented in the 2002 version.

  • Both movies were good in there own ways. The origanl will always be prefered by the majority of people because it is the origanl and it was so scary and the re-make was closer to the book and Carrie was creepier. I could see the girl from the re-make being an out cast but Sissy from the origanl didn't

  • I don't care if the 2002 Carrie had more from the book in it. The 1976 Carrie is soooo much better! At least the blood looks more realistic in the 1976 version!!

  • I thought both of them were good, though the ending of the 2002 was messed up because the people who didn't die were supposed to. Though I like the girl who played Sue better in 2002 more than the 1976 version. Billy looked alot creepier in the 2002 version, and I think Carrie looked too old in 2002 rather than she actually looked like a highschooler in 1976 version.

  • the original is always better i don't even know why they remade it it was fine the way i was.

  • 1976 is better!!!!!!

  • i like all three carrie movies( carrie, carrie 2: the rage, and carrie 2002 version) it just proves that muder and telekenis run in the family!!!!!! plus what goes around comes around(karma) dont mess with carrie and her sisters!!!!!!!!

  • Carrie 2002 is my vote. I love how she looked in the prom scene. and the gym coach survived.

  • Carrie 2002 is the bEST!!!!!!

  • ok!! hahahah.... XD

  • i loved it but you didn't use parts from 2002 though i think 1976

  • Bonnie's song fits in the scene ONlY when Carrie begins her revenge (the exactly next scene when Chris and Billy exit behind the stage)

  • HAHAHAHAHA???? Try and see.

  • HAHAHAHAH

  • Stupid video. Bonnie's Holding out for a hero fits better in the excellent prom scene. I have tried it and i was excited.