I'm stumped because I don't see my comments, and they were nothing, but compliments; especially, to the person who ever thought of this. I never heard anything like this before; an orchestra with these piece. BRILLIANT!
I really loved your performance Mr. Cherkin. I, myself, recently started to study piano, although it's an old passion that unfortunately I couldn't practice before. Just for you know, you are an amazing pianist (not that you need anyone telling you this!) and you conquered a fan in Brazil.
The playing is great, but the recording is on the poor side it is not very clean. I wouldn't give it a dislike but I can't give it a like either not for the execution but for the quality, the background noise it makes difficult to listen to.
I simply can't understand why there are so many dislikes on this video. I'm very glad to have found an orchestrated version of this beautiful piece. I think it's quite unique. Congratulations to the orchestra-composer, and many thanks for the 'remake'!
@BubbaZen10 my daughters middle name is also Elise after this piece! :) its my all time favorite I used to have a set of headphones and I would play it over and over again with the headphones on my belly :)
My little girl's middle name is Elise (after this piece) and i wanted an orchestrated version to go with the video i'm making of her. This is perfect! Thank you for posting this.
@DwiteTheSpriteKnight Ok, I can accept this as constructive critics, however since now there is no other orchestration of this piece to make a comparison with and I believe that it is more like a good product than a bad one :)
I think I might have encountered the definition of incomprehensible. Maybe a musician can explain to me why this performance is so bad it deserves more than 3 dislikes for every 1 like? Have all the dislikes come from people who are too adrenaline charged to be in a frame of mind where they can appreciate classical music? That's the only way I can explain it.
@DwiteTheSpriteKnight It is not the performance, it is the orchestration. It doesn't do the original justice. It is also so minimal that it begs the question, what is the point of it? Just to make the piece more dramatic? I think it fails at that, to the extent that it is almost comical in places (that triangle...).
Even if this were an exceptional orchestration, there will be a lot of classical musicians and pianists that will dislike it anyways (where I would not).
@LissieLupin It would seem that Mr. Cherkin has acquired his own personal troll. Someone who creates a bunch of different accounts to "dislike" all of his videos. Hate idiots like that, but, what are you gonna do? I'm just somewhat amazed that a classical musician has a troll!! Must be doing something right!!
who thinks that he can play this song better than the guy in the video then just go die! because you die while playing it but look at him,he is taking it like a bite of cake so shut up and listen :)
The one who disliked this thinks his/her version of Für Elise is better. Well, this is by far the most beautiful ever! A splendid performance! Now I can lie down and listen to this from my ipod.
Lovely orchestration, indeed. My gratulations for your having enhanced the world music library with this beautiful work. Perhaps there are other orchestrations of Fur Elize but I've never come across any of them.
AWESOME! You are a great person to learn from. I just recently finished memorizing this piece and am working on all the little details. You're fantastic, well done!!
oooh this orchestra version sound great .... good job
sany1303 1 week ago
I'm stumped because I don't see my comments, and they were nothing, but compliments; especially, to the person who ever thought of this. I never heard anything like this before; an orchestra with these piece. BRILLIANT!
OmgLoLw2gLuvUidkROFL 2 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
HOW CAN PEOPLE DISLIKE THIS???????? SHAME ON YOU
StijnBF2 3 weeks ago 2
now this is the ring tone in my phone -amazing song!!!!!!
VOULKANOS 1 month ago
I don't understand why so many people dislike this...
musiclover2636 1 month ago
this is one of my favorites and this is the best i've heard. I'm using it to study for my mid-terms!
MsOwl7 1 month ago
Simply beautiful! The original piece is excellent, but just because this orchestrated doesn't mean it's bad.
Wonderful!
Bomnus 1 month ago
this was really good
i really like it coz i heard lots of different instruments being played
who would ever dislike this?
jksgill99 1 month ago
I really loved your performance Mr. Cherkin. I, myself, recently started to study piano, although it's an old passion that unfortunately I couldn't practice before. Just for you know, you are an amazing pianist (not that you need anyone telling you this!) and you conquered a fan in Brazil.
vanvrs 2 months ago
I really love and play this opus. The main character is the piano I think.
Haveagoodfun 2 months ago
The playing is great, but the recording is on the poor side it is not very clean. I wouldn't give it a dislike but I can't give it a like either not for the execution but for the quality, the background noise it makes difficult to listen to.
papibuddy 2 months ago
i am honestly taken aback by the number of dislikes on this video...this video literally gave me goosebumps...it is so beautifully done...
shyan042688 2 months ago 2
HOW CAN THIS HAVE MORE DISLIKES?
DevelopersPortalX 2 months ago 2
@DevelopersPortalX - Slow perhaps?
ISuckAtPianoPlaying 2 weeks ago
I simply can't understand why there are so many dislikes on this video. I'm very glad to have found an orchestrated version of this beautiful piece. I think it's quite unique. Congratulations to the orchestra-composer, and many thanks for the 'remake'!
kiemc0 3 months ago
very good
ksiu56 3 months ago
@BubbaZen10 my daughters middle name is also Elise after this piece! :) its my all time favorite I used to have a set of headphones and I would play it over and over again with the headphones on my belly :)
amazeddreamer 3 months ago
how can 300 people dislike this.
kedub670 3 months ago
My little girl's middle name is Elise (after this piece) and i wanted an orchestrated version to go with the video i'm making of her. This is perfect! Thank you for posting this.
BubbaZen10 3 months ago
The pianist has THE best part in his hair.
buttdud1122 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've recently made a "cover" on this symphony, feel free to visit my channel, subscribe, like and share! Cheers.
kevinthepianist 3 months ago
i think the pianist needs more confidence
ImAGrateSpellr 3 months ago
this was amazing! you played it perfect
hufnagel15 3 months ago
@DwiteTheSpriteKnight Ok, I can accept this as constructive critics, however since now there is no other orchestration of this piece to make a comparison with and I believe that it is more like a good product than a bad one :)
tcherkin 3 months ago
I think I might have encountered the definition of incomprehensible. Maybe a musician can explain to me why this performance is so bad it deserves more than 3 dislikes for every 1 like? Have all the dislikes come from people who are too adrenaline charged to be in a frame of mind where they can appreciate classical music? That's the only way I can explain it.
DwiteTheSpriteKnight 3 months ago
@DwiteTheSpriteKnight It is not the performance, it is the orchestration. It doesn't do the original justice. It is also so minimal that it begs the question, what is the point of it? Just to make the piece more dramatic? I think it fails at that, to the extent that it is almost comical in places (that triangle...).
Even if this were an exceptional orchestration, there will be a lot of classical musicians and pianists that will dislike it anyways (where I would not).
polyopulis 3 months ago
how can people dislike this........... i bet they liked it so much that they turned the screen upside down and liked it again...
3gummygirl 3 months ago
Why do these videos have so many dislikes? I think these are amazing!
LissieLupin 3 months ago
@LissieLupin It would seem that Mr. Cherkin has acquired his own personal troll. Someone who creates a bunch of different accounts to "dislike" all of his videos. Hate idiots like that, but, what are you gonna do? I'm just somewhat amazed that a classical musician has a troll!! Must be doing something right!!
BubbaZen10 3 months ago
283 or may be more think they can play better than BEETHOVEN.
am16749 3 months ago
beautiful music lives for ever
69Gabe60 3 months ago
283 people are tone deaf.
MrTimJr 3 months ago
BRAVURA................Brilliant performance Dear.
am16749 3 months ago
I love very much this music! It's very good
Victorciko2 3 months ago
JUST WONDERFUL MUSIC. LISTENING AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN. CANT STOP IT
secularvoice 4 months ago
very good
SuperHondaFit 4 months ago
DAMN this is music! (to all of this dislikers)
2222nessness 4 months ago
who thinks that he can play this song better than the guy in the video then just go die! because you die while playing it but look at him,he is taking it like a bite of cake so shut up and listen :)
aqwwow 4 months ago
BElieve me, i can play better than this guy. That's why so many dislike. this suck
Junichicool 4 months ago
@Junichicool put up a video then, before that, shut your ass... anybody can talk big, go back up your actions noob
CaptainSrzBznz 4 months ago
why so many dislikes?
shaunkoko 4 months ago
1 person is jealous
2096megaman 5 months ago
Sorry to be so pedestrian but the piano soloist looks like a young Val Kilmer.
marktheshark12 5 months ago
I love it!
sandraleig 6 months ago
amazing performance. Thanks for playing the best music of the world.
Shamsuzzohan 6 months ago
What brand of piano was this?
Pianocarneseur12 6 months ago
i love this song when i was a child. but now i just can play it in right hand :(, left hand just with the beginning!
annasweetlady17 7 months ago
Delightful my friend a genial performance thank your for sharing your art
Marianofrv 7 months ago
The one who disliked this thinks his/her version of Für Elise is better. Well, this is by far the most beautiful ever! A splendid performance! Now I can lie down and listen to this from my ipod.
loneaxolotl 7 months ago
brilliant
geetarxist 7 months ago 2
Lovely orchestration, indeed. My gratulations for your having enhanced the world music library with this beautiful work. Perhaps there are other orchestrations of Fur Elize but I've never come across any of them.
Georgi200 7 months ago 2
AWESOME! You are a great person to learn from. I just recently finished memorizing this piece and am working on all the little details. You're fantastic, well done!!
piano1324 7 months ago 6
Well done :)
RskcrProductions 7 months ago 2
Nice to hear this played with a sense of tempo dictated by the spirit of the music. Sometimes people play it like a metronome on speed.
melc1949 7 months ago 10
oh I love this, this awesome thank you for uploading this.
Sabin06 7 months ago 2
bravo!!
jadeeslayton 7 months ago 2