Great song although the album was kind of hit and miss for me. I say this knowing that in a few months or weeks I will listen to The Sunset Tree and think "wow, this stuff is amazing". The Goats are great for always rediscovering old songs or albums. I often find myself playing an album that I got sick of or found not all that good and suddenly shouting the lyrics at my wall all night long along Mr. Darnielle.
it's such an intensely sad song...listen to the lyrics...he's talking about when he was younger and his step-father abused him...you have to respect that he's telling that story...it's not easy...
Well, uh, strictly speaking, like a lot of his other songs - every single one on All Hail West Texas, for instance - he's telling a story about someone else through their eyes.
@trallala Actually, most of The Sunset Tree was, in fact, written about his childhood with an abusive step-father. This theme runs throughout the album, ending in Pale Green Things with his sister delivering the news of his death.
BigBear, your comment is unfair and unfounded. If you're going to compare musicians, you must listen to them first. Then again, don't bother, it's pointless. Everyone sounds like someone else at times! "No Children" sounds a bit like TMBG. "Oceanographer's Choice" sounds a bit like the Flaming Lips. Big deal. What *really* unifies these musicians? They're all geniuses. Enjoy.
Yeah youre kinda right. I dont remember writing that at all, and now that I read it it was kind of unfounded since I havent heard that other band. I was pretty hiped at the time on TMG and John, so maybe at the time I just couldnt believe that any other band could be half as good.
@BigBear - Good man! I bet you'd like TMBG. You should give them a shot. They have tons of great tunes right here on YT.
@badmoviecridict101: I hear what you're saying, sometimes JD is more of a poet than a songwriter. But that's just one of his signature styles. Listen to Sax Rohmer #1 or No Children or Woke Up New - these songs are melodic, catchy, hummable, and all that. TMG can swing both ways ;-)
You know what I love about this kind of music? The music is simple but powerful and meaningful. The singer doesn't have to be Frank Sinatra or Tom Jones to sound great. Besides, because their vocal style is much more "casual" than professionally trained artists they sound the exact same in concert as they do on their albums! Man, these guys rock! I thought it was They Might Be Giants when I first heard this song on the radio. lol Very original stuff though; I love it! :D
i can see why you might think that. it does seem kind of similar to a few songs of tmbg, such as narrow your eyes or something. his lyrics are similar with quirkiness and originality and... you know... darkness and depth...
side note, tmbg = john linnell and john flansburgh, both johns, mountain goats lyricist = john darnielle
@AegisNeglector Uhh... Yeah. It's a genre. It's called Folk. Y'know; people that have a good message, that can't necessarily sing like the vapid air-heads on "American Idol". Bob Dylan? Simon and Garfunkel? Y'know, Folk, right? The Mountain Goats are totally folk. Super-folk...
Uhh... Thanks. It's a thanks. I appreciate the non-sarcastic, non-pretentious manner in which you replied to my post. Until you filled me in I was quite ignorant to this genre of which you speak. What did you call it: "F-fowlck...Foalc music"? Nice. Is this a new genre? I like it!
I move away from the mic to breathe
wolfandnightingale 4 months ago
Great song although the album was kind of hit and miss for me. I say this knowing that in a few months or weeks I will listen to The Sunset Tree and think "wow, this stuff is amazing". The Goats are great for always rediscovering old songs or albums. I often find myself playing an album that I got sick of or found not all that good and suddenly shouting the lyrics at my wall all night long along Mr. Darnielle.
obermegalutschoar 1 year ago
This song never ceases to put a smile on my face. Forever amazing.
notritard 1 year ago
God what a great lineup! JEALOUS.
Jst0Lve 1 year ago 2
Love the Mountain Goats, but he just doesn't seem that "into it."
undathebridge 1 year ago
'so this is what the volume nob is for' is such a beautiful line
mynamesjustMaddy 1 year ago 2
One of the happiest albums(IN MY OPIONION), even though it's mostly about how big of a dick his stepdad was.
jamesandjackproducts 1 year ago
The most brilliant part of this song is how joyful and bouncy the tune is compared to the "life is fucked up" message that's present in this song.
ScottfromBKLYN 1 year ago 2
John sure is sweaty.
burgabuns 1 year ago
I love this song. It's my current favorite. I like it way better live, though
GTK96 1 year ago
listening to his songs is like reading a book, and you kind of get obsessed with the story and/or meaning JD's lyrics as one would for Bob Dylan's.
supercoolsunday 2 years ago 3
@supercoolsunday Its like Shakespeare
stupidyoopers 1 year ago
TMG are beast
uzername91PUNx 2 years ago 3
holy shit this song is so intense.....so great!!!!
chinolofus 2 years ago 4
i didnt really like it
badmoviecridict101 2 years ago
Why? Just out of curiosity?
boiledhooker 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
im not the kinda person who likes acoustic mixed with lyrics that have no tune. but thats just me
badmoviecridict101 2 years ago
Funny, I think this song has a very clear melody. Even more so if you compare it to some other stuff, A lot of Dylan's songs are less melodic.
NINandNirvana 2 years ago 2
it's such an intensely sad song...listen to the lyrics...he's talking about when he was younger and his step-father abused him...you have to respect that he's telling that story...it's not easy...
clemep 2 years ago
Well, uh, strictly speaking, like a lot of his other songs - every single one on All Hail West Texas, for instance - he's telling a story about someone else through their eyes.
But yeah, the song is devastatingly sad.
trallala 1 year ago
@trallala Actually, most of The Sunset Tree was, in fact, written about his childhood with an abusive step-father. This theme runs throughout the album, ending in Pale Green Things with his sister delivering the news of his death.
EdgarWFlintlock 1 year ago 5
havent heard tmbg but john darnielle is probably waaaay better at both writing and singing then them. and hes super down to earth too.
BigBearfromthe206 2 years ago
BigBear, your comment is unfair and unfounded. If you're going to compare musicians, you must listen to them first. Then again, don't bother, it's pointless. Everyone sounds like someone else at times! "No Children" sounds a bit like TMBG. "Oceanographer's Choice" sounds a bit like the Flaming Lips. Big deal. What *really* unifies these musicians? They're all geniuses. Enjoy.
3stringovation 2 years ago
Yeah youre kinda right. I dont remember writing that at all, and now that I read it it was kind of unfounded since I havent heard that other band. I was pretty hiped at the time on TMG and John, so maybe at the time I just couldnt believe that any other band could be half as good.
BigBearfromthe206 2 years ago 2
@BigBear - Good man! I bet you'd like TMBG. You should give them a shot. They have tons of great tunes right here on YT.
@badmoviecridict101: I hear what you're saying, sometimes JD is more of a poet than a songwriter. But that's just one of his signature styles. Listen to Sax Rohmer #1 or No Children or Woke Up New - these songs are melodic, catchy, hummable, and all that. TMG can swing both ways ;-)
3stringovation 2 years ago
Greetings from San Luis Obispo, CA!
gitarisuto05 3 years ago 2
You know what I love about this kind of music? The music is simple but powerful and meaningful. The singer doesn't have to be Frank Sinatra or Tom Jones to sound great. Besides, because their vocal style is much more "casual" than professionally trained artists they sound the exact same in concert as they do on their albums! Man, these guys rock! I thought it was They Might Be Giants when I first heard this song on the radio. lol Very original stuff though; I love it! :D
AegisNeglector 3 years ago 30
i can see why you might think that. it does seem kind of similar to a few songs of tmbg, such as narrow your eyes or something. his lyrics are similar with quirkiness and originality and... you know... darkness and depth...
side note, tmbg = john linnell and john flansburgh, both johns, mountain goats lyricist = john darnielle
clcsqueejy04 2 years ago 2
That's stupid. He's nothing like They Might Be Giants.
DavidSplendor 2 years ago
I dunno... they both kind of carry that slightly sarcastic sense of humor with them...
mascbp10 2 years ago
yes, they most certainly do
clcsqueejy04 2 years ago
@AegisNeglector Uhh... Yeah. It's a genre. It's called Folk. Y'know; people that have a good message, that can't necessarily sing like the vapid air-heads on "American Idol". Bob Dylan? Simon and Garfunkel? Y'know, Folk, right? The Mountain Goats are totally folk. Super-folk...
RhythmGrizz 6 months ago
@RhythmGrizz
Uhh... Thanks. It's a thanks. I appreciate the non-sarcastic, non-pretentious manner in which you replied to my post. Until you filled me in I was quite ignorant to this genre of which you speak. What did you call it: "F-fowlck...Foalc music"? Nice. Is this a new genre? I like it!
AegisNeglector 6 months ago
His facial expressions when he sings "Dance" in the first chorus are amazing.
This video is amazing, The Mountain Goats are amazing.
sparklenight 3 years ago 5
possibly the best song ever written.
ACloudHangsOver 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
you should get outside more often
fyodos 3 years ago
you're an idiot, this song is excellent
make7me7a7cake 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
uhhhhhhhhhh no, i'm afraid you,young woman, are the Prince Myshkin. Write back when you're allowed to cross the street on your own.
fyodos 3 years ago
maybe.
MrGameface 3 years ago
i yelled Dance Music!!
candelina 4 years ago 2
me toooo !!!! yaaaaaaaay !!!!
fyodos 3 years ago
I hate you for being at that show...
...but i love you for posting this video...
RRRRRRRRGGGGGGGHHH!
spoiled Toronto brat!
LOL
todd8008 4 years ago 12