Added: 2 years ago
From: rebellerock
Views: 69,426
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (197)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he could shit in a bag and make money or bottle his sweat like Elvis..

  • Wow, profile looks just like Paul

  • Waste of Time

  • Comment removed

  • Самое главное что он -пытается ......

  • He sucks. Too bad he lost his hair. He looks like a giant penis with arms.

  • @xb5jb7 and you sound like a giant dick. So whats your point?

  • This sounds more like a rejected song from Valotte : )

    

  • ..except for Dhani Harrison, he's got talent !

  • Beatle kids.. Ugh..!

    i call them larvae..

  • Excellent song ...actually ....Way to go James!

  • shake that beatle bob boy like yer old lady i mean man

  • If it's any consolation to making comparisons he resembles Linda so there.

  • I think he has the twangy higher voice of his mum , but the style of his dad.

    P.S.I love Lin's singing

  • holy crap, sounds just like his father

  • It must be difficult for James to be the son of the genius PM because people use to expect James to be a Paul´s replica. But it won´t exist a new Paul McCartney again. I think James should forget this opinions and go firmly ahead because he´s also talented and the time can make him even better.

  • James tenta outra coisa meu filho, que como cantor não vai da certo.

  • @rnb183 Desculpe, mas um McCartney não precisa, não tem necessidade nem obrigação de dar certo. Ele como todos nós deveriamos, só tem que fazer o que gosta. E na minha modesta opinião o James é um excelente musico. E quem não gosta tambem não precisa gostar. Agora fazer um comentário negativo desses me desculpe v pisou na bola com uma pessoa tão bacana e talentosa como o James. Imagine o que ele deve sofrer com o peso de ser filho de um gênio name PM quando recebe comentários como o seu.

  • much respect!

  • He sings well. Don't care for the tune, but like his voice.

  • I like his voice

  • He's not starting from no where like Paul ,so people have expectations which would be unwanted pressure to be like his dad,but its a different world now and he has to do his own thing and that's what he's trying to do,and he sounds ok, he has natural talent in my opinion.;)

  • Comment removed

  • AT LEAST HES NOT TRYING TO SOUND EXACTLY LIKE HIS OLD MAN - UNLIKE LENNONS SON- THAT I GIVE HIM CREDIT FOR.

  • @MrFukitt I happen to like Julian. It's much too late for good-bye's from you...so fukitt.

  • @cawttu - shut up

  • @cawttu - Canu explain, in English please ? - :)

  • IVE GOT A ORIGINAL FOTO OF HIM AS A TODDLER BEING CARRIED BY HIS OLD MAN ON PENNY LANE - ANYONE WANNA BUY IT - ONLY £1.000.000 - NO OFFERS! - :)

  • Wow he looks like Paul (but not as cute as him:) He's a good musician.

  • James sounds more like Neil Finn or Phil Keaggy than he does his Dad.

  • hey...a beatles one off....all sons of beatles create an EP

  • He's a good little musician.

    He knows his way around piano and guitar

  • "Am i not Turtle-ly enough for your Turtle Club!" "Turtle Power!" "I Love Being a Turtle!!"

  • wow!!!!!!astig!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

  • me encanta lo concentrado que esta en su musica! hace que todos quedemos hipnotizados!

  • :) nice sound

  • Has anyone done a dna test on him and Paul Schaeffer? Just saying......

  • I wonder if he'll start taking credit for all of Julian Lennons songs?

  • Macca's son is sounding good and I'm liking it! Rock on James. Can already see you're gonna carve out your own path with your OWN music. Yeah we know who your father is, but it's quite apparent who JAMES McCARTNEY IS!

  • great musician, great musician

  • HEY GOOD SONG.

  • you know, it's weird---Julian, Sean, and James all have little-kid voices---they don't sound like men. Not good or bad--just an observation.

  • @SlappyFrankenstein you should try listening to Dhani Harrisons stuff.....if you like George's music you will love his. It's like a stronger newer version of george's music

  • too bad he didn't get the mop top gene like his old man. just another idle wealthy kid doing this instead of working...

  • @stratobagster people with that much money face the real possibility of having their kids abducted......in this day and age it probably is not safe for the child of a billionaire to be working anywhere

  • steven bayley what are you doing in this band what a waste please reform "the open" such an amazing band you don't need to be doing back up vocals for Paul McCartney's son your much better than this.

  • Fallen Angel is Lucifer

  • looks like a monster kkkkk

  • Interesting. very good

  • Excellent keyboard and great voice. Go James!

  • uncle festerlol

  • He looks like Syd Barrett looked in 1975.

  • is he about 40..

  • nice voice James, he resembles Dad <3

  • There is a support group for famous muscians' off spring who suck. It's called Wilson Phillips.

  • @bluecrabs08 LMAO!!!! So true. "If ya hoooold on!" Puke!

  • This is gorgeous! LOVE IT! Very Good and intriguiing! to me!!! Holy !!! He can play I think better than Paul!!!! Oh yes, he can !!!! If you're a keyboard player you know he is clean n light on it and quick!! I don't remember Paul playing keyboard much just Linda and no one showed that stuff off like That! .. I really think the Beatle boys should consider they are Beatles' boys and go ahead and tour .... this is the here and now no reason to stop appreciating love of music!!! the potentials!

  • trying very hard not to concentrate on his extremly hairy chest.......no failed.

  • OMG I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!JAMES IS GREAT1XO

  • The only thing James McCartney has going for himself in life is that he was born into the right gene pool.

  • This guy is trying to make it -while standing in the shadow of a legendary talent, and former Beatle? Tough job, got courage to try that, you critics? Good luck James, follow your dream.

  • i think he sounds like dad, and i think some of the issues are in the sound reproduction, not his voice. The sound is bouncing off the walls. can you imagine being Paul McCartney's kid?

  • Somewhere out there....Paul Mccartney is dragging his head...

  • interesting !

  • All you critics---Go fuck yourselves! What are you doing on Monday morning? Probably making your balogna and mustard sandwich's, packing your lunch boxes and heading off to your no-where jobs at the city dump! Losers! The guy is trying and doing well--so go choke on your vomit!

  • @fender4444 well I wouldn't have to eat baloney or go to a no-where job If my father was worth one billion dollars..........we are not losers,.we are as john lennon put it "working class heros". I really like the way James plays piano but his voice is not great......on another note....I have heard Dhani Harrisons stuff and am pretty impressed

  • He's really a pretty good musian, but as far as singing........naa

  • @ricadrew he's got the range... just needs a little work, but has a good singing voice !!!! LM

  • pinche panszon vale verga

    paul saco todo lo chafa que habia en el en ti jaja

  • @cacarizo1000 hahaha!

  • Certainly has his mother's talent for singing and music. lol

  • Not bad he's a bit of a chipper

  • He does resemble his mother more than his dad, ( facial features)

  • he sounds like tim finn.

  • he sounds a bit like the youngl finn brother

  • Looks like a bald Peter Lorre

  • he sounds a little like paul i guess. all the sons of the beatles should form to make a new beatles

  • Bersuit Vergarabat?

  • My god, he's a very good singer!

    His voice doesn't fit him. Why is he so ugly?

  • A fallen angel is a demon I see hes following in his fathers occult footsteps

  • @aaron3009 What do you mean? I have never read anything about Paul being into the occult? What makes you say this?

  • Just a few words from "the states"......Reading a lot of the posts in here I begin to understand young Mccartneys reluctance to enter into the world of entertainment.All the comparisons to his father would drive me insane.I guess he better grow some thick skin though because the critics can be real assholes.

  • is he bald or is it just shaved really short?

    maybe he is trying to look as far from his dad as possible

  • he's just at his begining!! in a few years he will command everything, just as his daddy!! but... if I was Paul, I would put James in a strict diet and dye his hair as daddy!! ;) so I would make another paul! =) James sings beautifullyyyyy!!!!!!!!!!

  • what was that at the end???

  • i thought Paul was a vegetarian?? this guy looks like he hasn't met a steak he didn't like!!!

  • rebellerock... Tnx for posting this... LM

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • He's not shy, he's up his own arse.

  • He was nervous and shy. Wait...he has talent

    and self-confidence can be built up!

    Beautiful song anyway. His voice has a good tune.

    Does he have a vocal coach?

  • Wow, he looks JUST LIKE Paul. But a bit chubbier and bald... though it's quite difficult to picture Paul bald.

    He looks really nervous. He seems to be way different from his father in personality, but he is great musically - like Paul.

  • wouu!!!excelent musician,you play really good James congratulation!!!!and keep on making music,and ignore people judgment about your art and your fhather art,thanks.

  • he looks exactly like paul but with no hair. the music is not too bad either.

  • He sings like his mom....god awful

  • is he having chemo?

  • Looks like Homer Simpson with a Mc Cartney mask.

  • Comment removed

  • @talanca64 BWAAAAAAAA ha ha ha!!!!!

  • @talanca64 you make me laugh :)

  • @talanca64 Awww... that's mean :'-(

  • Comment removed

  • I think someone has pasted Sir Paul's face on a baldy bloke. Spitting image (facially) or wot?

    Very average imo - much like any pub gig, and in fact a rather dreary song.

    You have to ask, would James have got this coverage and attention if his Dad had been a nonentity?

  • Comment removed

  • if you listen you can hear his dads voice but he has a completely different style

  • Great gig in newcastle last night, nice to have a chat with him after the show. James isn't great interacting with an audience just yet, but with experience he should do fine.

  • man he looks nervous, hes gotta smile more

  • YOU ARE A SHALLOW FUCK!!

  • My band's supporting this lad tonight... Get in!!!

  • thom stone???

  • He was shit.

  • All my best wishes to James and Light on their UK tour beginning Thurs 2/25. What I wouldn't give to be at the London show or either the 3/14 Cabaret Voltaire in Edinburgh or the St. Paddy's day show in Glasgow at King Tut's Wah Wah Hut!! Dave Matthews, another fav, will be in and about the same areas about the same time. You go guys!! Angel on James' website sounds infinitely better than on YT!

  • Great voice and song bravo 5***** by Julita

  • reminds me of Staind

  • well ive heard angel, denial and now this song, i think theyre great tunes and i want to hear more! I wish him well!!!

  • i think the next song is Fallen Denial.

  • Great voice and talent.

  • James have a nice voice, I love the song but on this the sound is terrible and it doesn't do good for him.

  • Wonder and love  your cat pofle picture!

  • Definitely not his dad, but, then again- no one is. Very novice songwriter and musician.

  • But at the same time he wrote this with his dad so to call him a novice song writer is hard to do , we dont know wich parts he wrote or what Paul wrote, but i agree no one is like Paul.

  • A very beautiful Song....

    Do you have still more from him?

  • está bem parecido com a voz do pai. tocou muito bem inclusive. manda vê james!

  • Hes got quite a high natural voice

  • good piano playing

  • I wish I could have been there, too. Thank you very much for the video.

    Me hubiese gustado estar allí también. Muchas gracias por el video.

  • Wish I was there :) I would have loved to see him perform this live.

  • Am I the only one who thinks that Paul's kids look absolutely nothing like him at all?

    That's not a knock on them, but I mean Julian and Sean look like John, Dhani IS George, and Ringo's kids look like him.

    I just find it interesting.

  • @NeilFraudstrong I think that James, looks a lot like Paul in the face, he's just always had different hair colouring and now he's lost his hair & he's put on a few kilos, he looks less like Paul but the resemberlance is still there. Stella, is definately a McCartney, & Mary looked much more like Paul when she was younger, but now looks more like Linda. Bea, is the spitting image of Stella at the same age, and therefore definately another McCartney. That's my opinion, & I know others share it.

  • Well, James has his fathers eyes but he is blond like his mom.

  • Comment removed

  • wow, everyone on Youtube is an asshole. That's you, LitmusPaperSnafu, Sirsimagoo and Quiznationrules. It's a good song. And it SHOULDN'T sound like Paul's stuff.  He's his own person. If his last name wasn't "McCartney" you wouldn't be so judgemental.

  • "When I get older losing my hair many years from now..."

  • p.s. Jame's outer is just a golden - whiter version of his dad...Paul never ' been bold...

  • Wow ! James is a great composer ! Just maybe arrangement ...could be more classy , but the recording is not professionally done...It is VALUABLE that he has his UNIQUE HARMONYES & STYLE !

  • He looks like an albino turtle, lol... just kidding :).

    He has to just be himself because he has his own unique talents and can't worry about measuring up to his dad.

  • Pity he didn't inherit his dad's good looks, but I wont be an A-hole. I think he has talent, having that last name definitely helps too.

  • Good song, i think he has a good potential....The voice may be improved a bit

  • I like the piano's sound

  • i agree with many of you, he needs a better sound. i know he has skill , but seems he is somewhat afraid to be compare with his dad and that might be the reason he is not giving in to what he really got.even the looks you can see that he is just trying to look different.

  • Why are you going around to all the James McCartney videos and posting this identical comment? Because the world must know, right? You must get the word out there that he sucks. And I wish you good luck on your noble mission.

  • This song sounds a little like Depeche Mode to me.  I don't know if that is what he was going for, but I think it has that kind of feel. It will be interesting to see how his overall sound develops over time.

  • I would expect no less of his piano playing skills. Pretty great. Although I agree with ravenpicks below me. He really needs to find a sound and I pray it isn't influenced by the nonsense music of today. He indeed has a nice voice, now its time to tune it. Hopefully more of his dad shines through, not in a comparative way, but in a musical way. It would be nice to have the bloodline continue with similar sounds.

  • He's got a nice voice, needs to find a sound. He looks nervous. Didn't he have long hair? It is a lot of pressure on you when Sir Paul is your Dad. I wish the kid luck. Maybe he should do one song with his dad, just to get himself out there.

  • I like the James stuff. I am sure that a real video of it instead of an audience video would be a bit better. But he has his own sound and it does grow on you.

  • It looks like he has leukemia. Don't give me thumbs down about it, because it does.

  • So beautiful and special!All the best James!

  • Comment removed

  • I like this music :D

  • I love this. Great voice!

    I would buy this.

    I hate to say it, but I would love to hear the Beatle kids sing and play together.. one cool disc. Man cool voice.

    check my video 13 kisses

    even country guys love the Beatle Kids.

    The ending kills me...he don't need the big fin.

  • Lovely voice!! Love it. Also, wow i used to live just 30 miles from Fairfield, IA down in Canton Missour lol. If i were still there, maybe i could've gone up to see this. Oh well. Best wishes James! And thanks for posting, filmer! 5*****

  • Awesome!

  • Comment removed

  • this has something of Sargent Pepper's phase

  • shut up!!!

  • @philylennon what do you know about The Beatles, retarded?

    I have been there, I got 100,000 T-shirts!

    You didn't even was alive....don't ever dare to tell me to shut up...

    moron!!!!

  • First off where the hell did you learn to write? Hahaha! And I cant believe you hunted my page down and give me a one star! Classic you feisty little tiger you! I apologise if I upset you with my comment, but I disagree with you strongly on yours. I dont feel that this song deserves to be compared with the greatest album ever made, but thats just my opinion! Also just because I wasnt around in the 60s doesnt mean I cant love and appreciate the Beatles.

  • my first language is Portuguese. I can speak English enough to be understood.

    Can you speak Portuguese?

  • They were the best band to ever walk the planet and always will be there music is eternal! I know everything there is to know about the Beatles! Also I kind of feel everyone is giving James more praise than his music deserves, just because he is Pauls son, but thats just my opinion I think his lyrics are terrible, not saying I could do any better like.

    P.S. With love from England who are going to win the world cup this year Phily Hartley

  • @philylennon nope....Brazil is gonna win the World Cup.......lol

    again and for the 7th time.

  • I was a Beatlemaniac and I still am.

  • not this time baby it's all ours this time! And I can't speak Portuguese but i'll be singing to yaz when we knock you out of that word cup! "England England England England NA NA" but in portuguese! x

  • @philylennon ....I am out of the Word Cup yet....as you said and I agreed, my English

    is not perfect...now...about the World Cup this year in Africa....hehehe let's see.

    In 2014 it will be here in Brazil. You are invited..

    xoxo

  • oh i'll be there! I bet it's class in Brazil! Nice hot weather, all the carnivals, Bikinis thats my kind of place !! x

  • we can trade....my kind of place is UK...anywhere in UK...but I prefer England...London...wanna trade? I hate all those Brazilians characteristics as hot weather, carnivals, bikinis...

  • Hahahahaha fair enough, didnt mean to stereotype. And Londons a shithole! If you move to England you should go north the home of the Beatles thats the place to be in England. London sucks ass!!!!!! x

  • But London is London and has a universal History!

    Liverpool is Liverpool...well....it has a huge history too...anywhere but here.