Added: 1 year ago
From: naty1013
Views: 1,361,992
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (3,846)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i don't understand, why everybody says she's bad, then i have question: WHY DO YOU BUY ALWAYS HER CDs????? WHY DOES SHE HAVE 7 NOMBER- 1 HITS IN AMERICA??? I HATE HER!!! SHE IS BAD!!!! SHE CAN'T SING!!!

  • @MrAlesJackson being sucessfull doesnt make you sing well...examples.. madonna, britney, rihanna....and the list continues.. seems america has a very mediocre ear... SORRY

  • Omg... NOW I HAVE A FUCKING HEADACHE!! thanks katy :z

  • Kids 10 mark Katty -1 XDDDD

  • haimeeee !!!

  • People need to understand not every can sound as they would when they're autotuned. If we first heard the song this way we would think she is a great singer.

  • some one should sing this song right :) maybe x factor

  • This is too much song for her. It makes me mad to know that she won best live.

  • This is why Adele won all the Grammys...

  • This is atrocious, I love Katy! But this performance always makes me laugh :P

  • HEY SHES NOT SO MUCH BAD AT ALL!!!

  • whats so bad about this?!...

  • I like her music, but she is more of a studio person rather than a live singer

  • There's nothing wrong with her mic and nobody manipulated the video. She simply cannot sing.

  • From the Money spend for this crap they could have Fed hundreds of childs in Africa/Asia - before doing crap like ACTA someone should stop this massive Waste of money

  • I love katy but ... Kids are better , much better that her ! vocally

  • That was bad...

  • omg this is terrible

  • She is amazing no matter what the say. She's the only artist can this song with the way she sing.

  • oh god, she's so bad..

  • The only problem with her mic is that it is turned on. Gave her a chance over and over again, but she's not even close to good. Awful.

  • She ruined those kid's performance!!!

  • I look at award show performances like, artist that you will see headline a show in Vegas, i think she would do well as a performer in Vegas cause of the theatrics.. vocally she is good vocally, but i think she would forget the words every now and then.

  • God, I really, really love Katy, but... She just can't sing live.

  • 1:10 FAIL KKKKKKKKKKKKK

  • LOL

  • FLOP!

  • O çocuklar o sesi nasıl çıkarıyor lan dslfşeerwgbfb

  • she's amazing :)

  • you all are retarded. whoever actually watched the AMA's would know that she didn't sing like this. someone fucked with the video.

  • her mic has some problem. isn't that really obvious? i'm not a fan and i can even tell -.-

  • Ooooooh ugly kids OMG

  • this is the best live of firework ever! w/ all those firework effect and the dress transformation. yet, i'm not that impressed w/ the vocals. her voice's really good in cds not live.

  • eca...

  • R.I.P Etta James... Wait! You won't rest in peace Etta if Katy keeps gettin' nº1s... It's so unfair that we are left with talentless girls like these...

  • That's embarrassing to watch.

  • she really can't sing..

  • @0222chloe She CANT sing. Her voice is strong. In live is hard, now sings it better in live.

  • @shineKatyPerry sorry, CAN.

  • *---------------*

  • I want the jessica rabbit dress

  • Sounds painful!

  • I like her but she can't sing

  • I like 2:15 - 3:50

  • 0:00 to 1:24 is her best performance EVER!!!!

  • She is not rubbish there was something wrong with the mike, so haters stfu watch her sing the one that got away live she sounds great.

  • she sounds like a breathless little fish lol omg

  • That was... terrible.

  • the only talented on the stage are the kids

  • At least she sings live not like other people who just fake it.

    

  • this bitch should not sing

  • they need to make her mic sound louder... she actually doesn't sound too bad

  • @writer1294U2 She sounded horrible. They should have turned her mic off and let the kids choir do the song. Still at least this gives people a chance to see what a crap singer she really is without autotune. Like a lot of "singers" in pop music today.

  • I like Katy, but here... KIDS ARE BETTER THAN KATE PERRY :O

  • @devastatinggirl Katy You dumb fuck.

  • That was reeeeally beautiful while the kids were singing... then comes Katy to destroy the song...

  • Live sucks her voice .

    But on the CD's it's amazing .

    Yeah Baby , autotune! ;)

  • 1:11- 1:14 FAIL.

  • Song is good, Her voice sucks and always has sucked.

  • lmao lawd beysus

  • SAYING ITS A HARD SONG IS NO EXCUSE! BEYONCE SINGS HARD SONGS AND AMAZES PEOPLE! HAVE A _/

  • Worst one i've seen I love the kids!!!

  • they should have let the CHILDREN Sing The DAMN SONG!!!!!!

    P.S: She fuck up the show

  • She´s so amazing! :) 

  • THE WORST FIREWORK !

  • I dont think is her fault is just that this particularly song is too much for her type of voice, im not her fan but, that's the reality, she is not as bad as she sounds in that performance

  • OMG she sounded horrible

    

  • This sounds like a raped horse...

  • Her mic is fucking broken WTH LOL.

  • i think her mic is broke

  • My ears are bleeding

    0:45 - 0:51 lol

  • the only reason she is famous is because she is hot! i can't hear all the performance, my ears were sufficiently damaged!

  • Her voice is shaking 2:53

  • yeah, until, she is fucking singin, not doin' syplinc, and if you dont like her, why you dont buy a life and get out of here?

  • @MKPKJANNIS who are you to tell us to leave videos on youtube? you aint the fucking owner bitch. she sucks at singing get over it!

  • @tatianadt82 sorry, i say what i think. and i think you s u c k s.

  • @MKPKJANNIS yes you say what you think, but you do not tell people what to do. and wow my feelings a hurt so badly cuz you said i suck! boo hoo! you know who sucks? KATY PERRY lmao!

  • @tatianadt82 i say what i want, if you doit or not. good for you. oh my god, katy perry sucks? i hope you know what is good, just one day in your life

  • @MKPKJANNIS Lol you make me laugh! you think im crying in a little corner! lmao so cute! but yes she sucks get over it bitch. and next time dont tell me what to do cuz i wont do it heffer

  • ella no canta mal

    esoty seguro que cuando vocaliza y se prepara lo puede lograr

    su voz tiene eso .. de no siempre estar al 100%

    lo que si tiene es un lindo timbre

    que aveces confunde entre desafinacion o que que es propio de ella

  • aww. firework is too high for her voice. she should stick to california gurls or last friday night.

  • just love her in mv but for live......no say of that

  • I love her, but her voice live make me wanna die.

  • Surprised I'm the only one who's able to work out why she sounds so shit. If you go to 1:24, what can you hear coming out of her mic? Barely anything, that's why in the beginning she had to scream over the music, because no one can hear her.

    I've witnessed her performing live first hand, not a bad note the entire night, and I can say that she definitely has talent, it's showcasing her talent she tends to sometimes have trouble with.

  • @Musicfan5ft8 Actually the performance for AMA tthis video, is okay but it's not the over - the top- head - blowing ones, it's okay, I don't get how they say it sucks lol

  • @Musicfan5ft8 definetly true, i went to her concert, and ok, sometimes,, eww but she's got talent, and it is when she has these important performance when she struggles.. but not all of this perfomrance is bad... not many people can move and sing those notes, like her!

  • @Musicfan5ft8 nerves too, she admits that she gets very nervous, bless her x

  • @Musicfan5ft8 You're delusional. I don't hate Katy Perry but I can't stand someone like you lying in everyone's face. Not even a single bad note, Katy Perry? C'mon you must deaf to say. I can't believe that there's one performance in which she sings all the song perfectly like in the music sheet.

  • @NausAllien lol, call me what you want, idc, I'm not lying at all. If you want other people's opinions, go on ticketmaster and read her reviews, there are 2000 of them, and out of 5 stars, her average rating is 4.7, and many of them comment on great singing. She sounds a lot better in concert, idk if it's that she's more at ease in her own show or whatever, but when I saw her she was great, was such a good show.

    And there are PLENTY of live performances where she sounds brilliant, need some?

  • @Musicfan5ft8 I don't need to go anywhere. Fans tend to be blind when they judge their singer, and even if she sounds terrible they will say that she's an angel from Heavens. Anyone with ears (n o fans, no haters) can tell that she's not good live, or at least in most of her performances. I've seen a lot of performances and she always has the same problems... So, if you like her, that's ok. But DON'T LIE and say that she sings good.

  • @NausAllien I'M NOT LYING, I didn't even to expect her to be that great vocally, I thought she would be great during the acoustic set, but amplified I thought she would be good with some but not great with others, but around halfway through the show I remember thinking 'shit, she actually sounds great' and also, quite a few of the reviews are by parents who took their kids to see the show, and even if they were just by fans, I really don't think they would be biased, Britney Spears' fans are (1)

  • @NausAllien HARDCORE and she has plenty of bad reviews on there. And Katy really does have a great voice, honestly, like I said there are plenty of really great performances on here by her. If she was just another manufactured popstar, I really would not like her, I don't listen to a lot of pop anymore but Katy Perry I love.

    And sorry about the two replies, over the top, I know, I just really didn't appreciate being called a liar there.

  • @Musicfan5ft8 That doesn't explain why she sounds out of tune and wobbly right from the beginning of the song when you can hear her very clearly, even on the easy parts. Having to project louder is no reason for being all over the place.

    You must be really gullible if you think she can sing. Using autotune in most of their performances does not make someone a good singer. You probably think Ke$ha, Britney, Rihanna, Justin Beiber et all are also great singers. Enough said.

  • @soundseeker63 Well I don't know, but she really can sing when she wants to, believe it or not, she is talented.

    And no, thank you, but no I don't like any of those 'artists' at all, I have taste.

  • @Musicfan5ft8 Well I guess its a real shame she "couldn't be bothered" to sing well for this very prestigious live show then isn't it. Funny, you'd think with millions of TV viewers she might have seen fit to make the effort. BTW not liking Ke$ha does not mean you have good taste.

  • KATY THE BEST!

  • People this is just a bad performance from an amazing artist. She has amazing live performances if you don`t belive check her performance on Mtv Unplugged, or Walmart, or Grammys 2011. It will change your opinion!

    Tumbs up for everyone can see!

  • i think katy perry is a great singer. I've seen some good preformances from her maybe this one just wasnt as good

  • And my friend said she had 'an amazing voice' ...she mutt be deaf!

  • Did anyone else at the end see a huge hair in her armpit.

  • She is on key I listened carefully.

  • @pug6666 her pitch is just horrible

  • the kids sing better.

  • Those kids can sing better than the "professional" singer.....

  • Lady Gaga is better live.

  • She is so pretty!

  • she has big boobs :) big boobs = good sales men

  • it's awkward lol

  • I'm so glad she's better now. I love you Katy Perry <3333

  • her live sucks!

    gaga is much better!

    LOL

  • She's a lot better now.. She was terrible last year

  • im not a hater , love her , shes practising n her live she's so much better now. but to be honest this was one of her worst lives

  • She is the best. You are all jealous, because she can sing, be nice, be pretty, and have the best fans. :)

  • the auto tune can't handle it. haha ^_^ 

  • <3

  • Katy the best!

  • Comment removed

  • LADY GAGA OR ADELE SHOULD HAVE WON THE BEST LIVE SINGER!

    THUMBS UP!!

  • HATERS GUNNA HATE.

    I think she did an amazing job <3

  • OH MY FUCKING INFINITE GOD..... This was too hard for my vagina, she can´t stop screaming!!!!!

  • shes amazing... that song is so hard to sing note perfect and atleast she doesnt mime ! <3

  • Every single artist is going to have some good, some bad, some worse, some better performances. I personally LOVE that she messed up in this one. It shows she's just a human, she makes mistakes, she's still developing and that she's singing live ALL THE TIME!

  • what a horrible singer.

  • @meingott717 LOL AGREE!

  • I find it sad the little kids can see better than her.

  • @VampireWeirdoFreak42 hahahahha

  • People think it's a good performance because it uses fireworks and dance routines to distract you from Katy Perry's voice

  • @musiclistenerliberal there's nothing wrong wif katy's voice. it's amazing jst the way it is.

  • @western7dogs did you not see the video!!

  • This is a pretty awesome performance. The kids sell it, and Katy Perry isn't TERRIBLE, it's just not as amazing as the album version. I still like it though.

  • there is always a black person left out of the group

  • likEeE thEeE fooooooooOourth of julyYyYy - LMFAO 

  • i love katy perry's performance..but she can' sing live...i was shattered after i heard her singing firewroks live :O

  • She is brilliant! I love this performance! <3

  • @dkwon98 at what awards show?

  • Folks did you ever hear Kanye West singing live? This is muchhhhh better than his performance!

    She CAN do it muchhhhhhhh muccchhhh better. <3 her

  • I know that she didn't sing this song well .. there's no denying it.

    But she got on the stage and she gave it her all. She had a bad performance guys.

    Look at her other live performances, they're full of lights, and she puts on an amazing show no matter what.

    She's a performer guys, and there's no denying it. She knows how to amaze her audience and never fails to impress me.

    All of you claimed "fans" criticizing this performance means that you don't know the performer Katy Perry is.

  • This performance should win SHITTIEST LIVE VOCALS EVER. Katy Perry makes Rebecca Black sound decent.

  • she is just shouting not singing...:(

  • @dkwon98 Best live isn't only for vocal performance, is all the live show and katy won it cause she is on her California Dreams tour and she stoles a lot of hearts <3... if this award goes to the vocal performance, sure that Adele or Jessie J could be nominated... But this award is for all the live show and the katy show is really good

  • Es increíble que cante esto es vivo... INCREÍBLE, la fuerza que hay que poner para cantar así Dios mio :) Solo ella puede hacerlo así, no soy seguidora de Katy Perry pero ame esta canción, tiene un gran significado, y ella cantando con tanta fuerza, da mucho aliento!! Y sin dudas es una canción muy emocionante =)

  • @GabiiGgVvCc55  como? no ma... canta horrible en vivo le falta aire, se le van las palabras, es muy buena cancion y la version de estudio esta genial pero ...

  • @babyvelludito Va en gustos! Me encanta como canta ella, pero odio la voz de Shakira por ejemplo.. Tal vez sea porque de canto no se nada! jaja, pero me encanta ame este video.. No digo que esta perfecto, parece como que se esfuerza demasiado para cantarla, yo intente hacerla mi propia versión en piano, pero se me hizo imposible cantarla XD jajaja La admiro por animarse a cantarla en vivo, yo no podría jamas!

  • 1:11 ??

  • this best live ? *LOOL*

  • Ohmy 1:10 . Is she a singer ? :))

  • At least she sings Live I give her Props

  • It's so heavy to her to sing...

    I'm sure she has a lot of talents, but not this one!

  • Such negative comments for an inspiring song!! You should appreciate someone who has the balls to get up onstage and sing to & for millions of people!!! Whoever makes statements like that should look at themselves first before they say anything at all.

  • is flat on some notes, can not hear!

  • cant believe she's getting paid in millions to do that to our ears....O_O

  • @ Musicfan5ft8 no its the other way round dear,they have crankd up the background music high so you cant hear her f**** shriek

  • @111whitepony111: she didn't "off key the whole song"... listen to the rest of the performances.. even Pink's performance didn't go well... IT'S BECAUSE OF THE MICROPHONE!! whatever "sound system" they had in this AMA night sucked!  learn to appreciate music and performances, dear.. it's not the artists' fault that they had to scream the words out for them to be heard. ----> @111 @aubreyfesalbon such a lame ass excuse. of course it's supposed to be DIFFERENT and LIVE. NOT OFF KEY THE WHOLE SONG.

  • :((( 

  • Lea Michelle sings this song better !!!! WTF whith this lady !!!

  • wow, she used little children in the beginning to hypnotize the audience into thinking that shes good

  • BEST LIVE BEYONCE OFCOURSE (L)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • She should perform at the emas after winning this award :D she sucks at singing. She looks good though.

  • hm wanna hear a joke? katy perry wins best live award. -.-

    wanna hear a joke? lady gaga can't sing

  • i liked the begining and than katy showd up....

    her voice sounded AMAZING in #3:51

  • I'm suing this bitch for making me go deaf

  • Comment removed

  • So what if you dont like the color of her voice, she still did okay. I wouldn't say she's sings better live than all the other nominees though. I admit that, but she won the category mostly because of her CALIFORNIA DREAMS TOUR and I must say its quite good. The category was best live ACT after all. She has this charismatic energy that makes her a performer worth seeing. PLUS she definitely has her moments where her singing is right on point. That's mostly acoustic though :) She deserves it.

  • YES, her voice is shaky as hell, but once she gets into it she does just fine. 2:20 and on. Poor girl gets too nervous :/

  • oh my god~ i just cant stop laughing at tht! best live huh hahah

  • So Katy won the best live...? are u srs?

  • She should learn to sing...OMG