Review: Maybelline Lash Stiletto Mascara "Black"

[KatyxNicole]

Use a eyelash curler first then coat your eyelashes with atleast two coats.(:

[ecnstar]

Could you do a review on 'Collection 2000 Extreme coloured lengthening mascara' You can buy it in black, purple, teal and something else XD

[Sirvinya]

@ecnstar Sure. I've added you to my list :) I've been meaning to buy that one at some point.

[DaisyTwinkleTunes]

if you do a ton of layers using stilleto it looks cute

[RandoriHyuuga]

I know what you mean about the smell, it smells do familiar but I can't place it, and it is unpleasant.

[bluetigressemoon]

I Love the Eyemakeup! really pretty colors!

[mscameron22]

luv the waY She says MAS-CARE-AHh

[Samanthakins]

Dont like the smell but it realy made my lashes long, but need a few coats!!

[elena1910]

i didnt know mascaras should smell nice.. it's ridiculous since isnt lip gloss, hello...

[Sirvinya]

@elena1910 it doesn't have to smell nice, it just shouldn't smell disgusting.

[xxautumnmariexx23]

I love this kind of mascara, it's the only thing that looks good, and works on my lashes. lol

[kinogodt]

To me it smells kinda like honey, and I can't stand it....

[kinogodt]

I absolutely HATE the smell of it, other than that I kinda like this mascara. It gives me that natural look while defining my lashes a little. :)

[ilovekevasmoothies]

i love this mascara!

[Jess236]

i agree with you on this mascara, especially the bit about it drying very slowly.

i was quite dissapointed by the mascara, i like max factor mascaras much more than maybelline (:

[easybakebrownie2]

I don't think your reviews are too long. They are thorough and you are honest and weigh the pros and cons. Thanks for the review! Have you tried Covergirl's Lash Blast? I like it a lot and it seems to be a favorite among others too.

[Sirvinya]

Thanks! Covergirl isn't sold in the UK.

[easybakebrownie2]

That stinks! It may be the same situation though, where it works for me and those who I have heard rave about it and doesn't for others. Still thanks for the review!

[thatkat31]

It smells like stinky roses to me. And I don't like the smell of roses.

[cutievanessa100]

to me it smells like apple

[TiaJadeX]

I love this mascara i have bought it 3 times! i dont normaly stick with the same mcara but this 1 i think its great! it made my eyelashes so long...everyone at school was commenting on how long my eyelashes were...my mate nadine even wen out and bought! maybe it worked well on me as my eyelashes naturally curl...my friend nadine's eyelashes are straight and it looked a vit wierd on her but her eyelashes were super long as well it probs works best on people with a natural curl to their lashes :)

[SundariArora]

I saw the advert for this and was wondering if it actually worked! I'm such a sucker for these adverts on tv.. thanks so much for the review! Which Elf mascara do you have? :)

[Sirvinya]

I have the ELF Studio Lengthening & Volumizing mascara.

[deb1701]

OH Becky I have exactly the same feeling that I have smelt it somewhere before but I haven't a clue what it is. I don't think it is totally useless as a mascara but nowhere near as good as the Boots No.7 360 mascara or the Chanel Exceptionale

[Brigita1618]

i didnt like it waste of money!

[emilysuzanne95]

my friend said it smells like a type of alcohol..and this mascara doesnt work for me really

[Purp1eHaze81]

are u gonna do a tutorial on the makeup u are wearing now?? its beautiful i love the colors

[Sirvinya]

I have done, it's already up.

[Purp1eHaze81]

i personally didint like the stilleto mascarai got it in waterproof i think and it dosent stay on my lashes, it tends to disappear after some hours of wearing it

[rubyloveXVI]

U.S. has waterproof version i havent tried it...

[TheChiliDragon]

FYI, this mascara does come in waterproof. :-)

I love this mascara, it works very well for me. It amuses me when people take these things personally though... My favorite mascara is someone else's disaster? So what? What do we care what others think, if a product works for us?

[KatrinaSmale]

@TheChiliDragon if you dont care, why watch the video?

tbh im gttin pissd off wif people watchin the videos then postin aload of shit like that on them, if u dnt like wt you see 1st off why watch the video?

[TheChiliDragon]

You didn't understand a word of my comment, did you? I simply said that I don't care if someone else dislikes something I like, and it amuses me to think that someone would take their own opinion that seriously. If that offends you to the point it pisses you off, that only puts you in the category of people taking their own opinion too seriously, and that makes you one of the more amusing ones. Chill.

[Sirvinya]

I think it's only in waterproof in the US.

You'd be suprised at the hate mail I get when I don't like someone elses favourite product. A lot do see it as a personal insult.

[TheChiliDragon]

"I think it's only in waterproof in the US."

Really? How incredibly lame. Strikes me as a bit unfair too, to be honest, since the vast majority of Maybelline's non-waterproof ones are pretty bad.

[BitterCakeLovesDepp]

this is one of my favourite mascaras...it makes my lashes super long...but i'v already long lashes...

[Nefertarisparkles]

I hated this mascara as well. Useless for me too. Thanks for the review :-)

[Sirvinya]

Yeah, disappointing.

[princessLouLee]

I'm so glad I watched ur review, I just bought a mascara and this one was on my list to try next...not any more!!! Still on the quest for a really good mascara that lengthens and volumizes at the same time that that's not too expensive, if you have a recommendation, I'd really appreciate it, thanks again!!!

[Sirvinya]

I really like L'Oreal Panoramic Curl. I think it's discontinued so I have to get it off ebay.

[monty12121]

So true. This mascara is really disappointing..

[ChixJulie14]

I have this mascara and i love it !!!

[mrsdcrossman]

Thank You so much for doing these reviews!!! I have been wondering about this mascara and I almost bought it today. Thank you so much for the review!

[NREnger]

I hated this mascara. Did not do anything for me.

[die9love]

this was the worst mascara i have ever used

[Sirvinya]

Not quite the worst I've ever used, but it's pretty bad.

[BellamyBlue]

I thought it smelled like Too Faced Lash Injection if you've ever tried that one?

[mizzworthy]

Totally agreed - I hated this mascara!

[fetishfairyfern]

haha i love that "do not like" hehe :)

[Sirvinya]

People complain I spend too much time rambling on my vids :)

[Sirvinya]

Thanks!

[ViAndOllie]

I found that it didn't work for, like most drugstore mascaras. The only one I've ever liked was Covergirl Lashblast however the curl only stayed when I used waterproof.

[Sirvinya]

I have got other drugstore mascaras that work really well. I just hated this one!

[HamOnMyHamSandwitch]

omg i loved this stuff it made my lashes even longer (my lashes can alredy touch my eye brows) it didn't smuge at all with me it's actully my fav mascara :P

shame you didn't like it :/

(p.s i think it smells like colossal)

[caylacleo]

I have it too. I like it it smells like nasonex lol

[Kay1994xx]

mine smells like nasal spray =/

[Sirvinya]

It does! That's the smell. It's the stuff I spray up my nose to stop hay fever.

[guitarrasara]

oh! you're 5'! so tiny :) nice review.

[ehagendijk]

Now I know not to buy this! Thanks!

[kuniochi101]

I havent tired this, but I hear that it doesnt lengthen much. My friend uses it, and she has lashes that stick straight out, and when she curls her lashes and uses it... it does crap. It just colors them black. It seems that drug store products aren't good quality, so they use gimmicks to reel people in. Like the whole Stiletto thing.

[Sirvinya]

There are good drugstore mascaras, I've got some to review. I've not had a huge amount of luck with expensive mascara.

[kuniochi101]

There are a couple, or maybe I'm just picky when it comes to mascaras. I dont think I'll be trying this one though, doesn't seem to be worth the money.

BTW - Thanks for the review!! :D I really do enjoy them!

[metoyoubbz]

i love this mascara it so good adds lots of lenth to my lashes i really like brush it

[saucymauve]

I love this mascara as well!!!

[streetglide10]

i personally hate lash stlletto - i found it didn't work out all & there was 0 "patent - leather shine"

[Sirvinya]

Exactly! No shine on me either.

[ljmxo]

LOVE THIS STUFF!!

[Sirvinya]

Haha, I know a lot of people do. Maybe I should put in a "mascaras work differently on everyone" before the haters attack me? hmmmm

[Fyuuuuuuu]

I agree, this mascara is shit.

Sorry to all you fans.

[jenGeeJushawshee]

@Sirvinya They do though, lasehes are just like hair and the same shampoos, conditioners, etc., don't work the same for everyone.

Some may hate one and others may love it!!