Added: 4 years ago
From: Samu
Views: 197,271
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (627)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Marty is a genius for putting the WTC in there!

  • Is it just me, but is that the Empire State Building standing blocks away from the

    Twin Towers? In Downtown?

  • As an American. I want this song played at my funeral.

  • In the end, all of the works of humans, all of our laws and societies and developments and technologies will be for nought, as all will, one day, be erased and there will be nothing to even remember it.

  • It's a spine-chilling ending. In it I see the future accelerateing away from the past, people fade and their graves are forgotten and crumble. Castles fall in the sand and we are lost. But our society marches on. In a way the whole film shows how removed from progress Bill and Vallon were, to the point that progress made their final battle irrelevent and they were ignored as our society powered forwards regardless.

  • @VainEldritch It's a nice thought, but are people getting better or, to paraphrase Edward G Robinson's character in Soylent Green, have people always been rotten and always will be?

    I heard that was Green-Wood Cemetary in Brooklyn.

    I'd like to see where an extension of this would go, what the skyline will look like late in this century. One thing is for certain, no one today will be able to conceptualize that period's architecture, try as they might.

  • @VainEldritch but they did have a big impact . did you see the movie? (rhetorical) they did have a lot to do with, but even tho your great and you run things now ,time will make it like you weren't , forgotten in time

  • the tower are still up in this is, even though this was made after 9-11 was becase the end meant what new york had built not what had was destroyed.

  • Comment removed

  • wtc....twin towers

    :'(

  • For me this is one of the best parts of the film....i dont know hot to describe it o_o

  • daniel day lewis was buried right next to the priest

  • Me encantó la película y este final me pone chinita la piel, impacta la entrada de la canción de U2, con ese saborcito irlandés, tomando en cuenta la temática de la historia.

  • The butcher was wrong as many of the imigrants were Irish told of a better place only to be unloaded from the ship in Boston and made to enlist and fight for your blasted union army would like to of seen you beat the CSA without immigrants

  • great movie...and ending

  • I would just like to say, the butcher wasn't wrong. You have millions of immigrants coming in and the were literally taking their jobs driving down the wages with the surplus labor. That just what the rich wanted and needed lots of cheap labor. 2011 is not 1960s nor was that time 1862.

  • If the Natives had won our Country may still be white and Christian, instead of brown and communist.

  • @TheBrewskiBaby your country is the furthest thing from Communist possible. Enjoy your unemployment rates and your medical bills : )

  • @TheBrewskiBaby You're an idiot.

  • @TheBrewskiBaby i'm white, with documents showing lineage back to the first pilgrim born on American soil. I take delight to be able to tell you that I'm christian, free mason, and I'm married to a South American Peruvian Latina with german, incan and spanish blood and we have a healthy, strong, intelligent son who will be replacing people like you as history takes us a long. you will be like the graves in this movie's ending.. forgotten and built over.

  • @PCSAWICK829 You have just won 5 Internets

  • ben laden incoming

  • Life is TOTALLY MEANINGLESS ..... fantastic movie, one of the best ever made.

  • @520LUNNY Life is NOT totally meaningless, life IS has a meaning and to me this movie showed me that people have spilled blood for the world of today, the people should take it more serious but also take small things less serious. Mtv and all this shit music and The hills and stuff should just fuck off, its so silly, do you get what im saying? we should be happy for living and do something of our lifes, thats the point with this movie to me!

  • I watched this movie and first and I said "hmmm . . . well that was ok . . . " then the ending came and it made it one of the best movie's ever! By far one of the best endings I have ever scene. It truly speaks to everyone

  • @oxMOVIELUVERxo ... come on man. An emotional ending can't (shouldn't) improve your opinion of any movie like that.

  • this was the worst movie i ever saw. i have no idea how people enjoy this movie. i could of ben great. the topic is great. the movie is so long and absolutely nothing happend till the ending, which really sucked. you know i tried to give it a chance because i really like leanardo dicapreo, but i think it just was the worst movie ever. i might give it another chance but i don't know

  • @xLyssaMooxx bill the butcher...thats all you needa focus on. he was the movie

  • @xLyssaMooxx The worst move ever? You obviously don't watch a lot of films. It looks as though the message was lost with you

  • Isn't it ironic that the Irish, who came to America, persecuted by nationalists would grow into nationalists themselves and persecute eastern Europeans coming to America in the 20's and 30's?

  • @tetrisclock and now they all work together to persecute people from the middle east

    thats they way Humanity goes.

  • Well the Muslims are doing enough to alienate the people of every country, demanding mosques be built everywhere and demanding special exceptions from laws.

  • @tetrisclock Like the Butcher Bill said, Fear, fear make people afraid of change, but like in this ending, no matter how you don't want change, time will force your surroundings.

    Also, every human have a notion of superiority,the fear just give the spark of ultra nationalism.

  • The best movie ending I've seen. It tells a whole story and sums up the previous movie with one time lapse shot. The results of mid-19th century feuds of a small neighborhood on Manhattan planted the seeds for the modern New York and America.

    (BTW, I can't help but think of Futurama when I see this scene. The next frame should be a UFO attack.)

  • "Thank God, I die a true American"

  • what would've been even better is if one last shot with the twin towers disappearing.

  • @ThinDiezel

    Personally I expected that.

    But if that was in movie there would be another scandal.

  • love the violin

  • so clever this part, brilliantly moving and touching. perfect way to end a film. :)

  • Love this part of the movie. Great movie.

  • You know, I usually hate hearing the word "epic", but if there's any appropriate word that would fit this ending "epic" is definitely it.

  • @Star16

    epic

  • This is the history of our country.

  • @CarlaLR74 yup from then to now...

  • I didn't know the irish played such a big part in how American evolved as a country.

  • Eh I thought this ending was terribly corny. That's just me.

  • @235T1NGR4Y23 I was moved by the ending, myself. The music really did it.

  • The story of New York is the story of America.

  • One of the most touching endings I've seen.

  • the best End which i've ever seen in a movie....just Epic.....with "Dances with Wolves", "Schindler's List" and "Braveheart" my favorite Movies

  • New York anthems are no joke, this is one of them. Empire State of Mind by Jay-Z Feat. Alicia Keys is a perfect fit!!!

  • @Malcolmthebeast I think one of the greatest anthems to New York is the song,NYC,from the musical Annie-especially the lines,"you crowd,you cramp.youre stiil,the champ. amen,for NYC !"

  • Awesome ending

  • haha i dont like this ending at all, it's too silly after

  • @Icix1 did you even watch it or did you just say this out of your ass like i think you did? No silliness here.

  • @TheSilentTyger

    Of course I watched it, that's why I think it shouldn't have such a cliche ending.

  • @Icix1 Cliche is different from silly. And I actually found the ending quite to my liking. I don't see the cliche in it, but maybe i'm missing something.

  • @Icix1 wow 

  • Comment removed

  • anybody who can guess the time setting of the shots? the first one with the smoky skyline is 1963 and the last one 2002, how about the ones in between anyone care for a guess ?

  • @GycuBrun I think you meant 1863 for the first one, second I'd say is 1880s-1890s, the third one would be 1920s or so, fourth would be 1940s or 1950s, and the last would actually be 2001 at the latest. Although the movie was released in 2002, much of the movie was short earlier.

  • @ChazzyJoe yeah man I meant 1863 :) pretty nice guesses :D

  • @GycuBrun The last one had to be 2000 or early 2001. The Twin Towers weren't there in 2002. And the first one is in the 1800s - like the setting in the movie. -__-"

  • @MaxxyandSeverus He left the towers in as a tribute to our great city.....

  • i want a cry

  • I find it fascinating how 'The Troubles' also occured on the other side of the atlantic.

  • Scorsese useually always has a greattaste in music.

  • That very last scene where you see new york changing over the next 100 years is prehaps what makes this the best dramanic ending. Seriously it gives that feeling when you watch it. "it'll be like if we were never even here..."

  • another brilliant performance by DDL. lousy ending. no way di caprio's character would have killed bill the butcher!

  • Evolution in 40 seconds

  • is that graveyard really there?

  • it must be...?

  • @KevinFromToronto Go do some digging...see what you come up with.

  • @KevinFromToronto dont know...but keep in mind, this film as great as it is...still pretty fictional

  • fucking awsome ending,and they havent built the "freedom" tower because this country hasent been fucking free in a long ass time.until the people of the united states take back this country and eradicate the patriot act we will never be free

  • the patriot act protects this country you stupid fuck! what do you have to hide, well if its nothing than you shouldnt worry because the us govt. doesnt give a shit about you! if they want to wiretap suspected terrorists phones they should be allowed too, if they want to search a piece of shit terrorist house without a warrant they should be allowed too! stupid idiot these things protect us and cutout the fucking aclu liberal middle men from doing their job!

  • @Gambino199 you do realize that our government armed and trained those "terrorists" to fight the soviet union.whom we once called freedom fighters.i would rather be free than be safe,fuck the government,its suppose to be a country run by the people

  • The Government use the "Suspected Terrorist" clause to abuse and harass anybody they see fit to. They're not protecting anybody's freedom when they're enforcing such stringent ruling. There's no such thing as freedom so long as somebody else has the power to abuse that freedom for their own ends.

  • @RightWingDarren and whoever dares to disagree with that, just keep in mind, the people who think they are free are even the most hopelessly enslaved

  • wow someone really downvoted my comment 11 times because what I said was the fucking truth. I called someone out on not knowing their shit about 9/11 and the freedom tower and he gets all butthurt cuz he is an ignorant fuck.

  • They need to rebuild the towers.  This is such BS... Almost 10 years later and nothing is being done.

  • I can't believe how many people are with me on this. The Empire State Building was built in 13 months during the Great Depression.

    every year something isn't built, is a another year we get laughed at. and honestly, why the skeleton-looking "freedom tower"? It's a slap in the memory of the Twin Towers, and most people want the Twin Towers anyway.

  • @h2opolodan11, there are a lot of people with you. Opinion polls show that 70% of people want the towers rebuilt.

    By rebuilding the towers, it would symbolize the resilience of America. There could be nothing more honorable for the victims of 9/11.

  • The Movie is so wtaht from professionel very very perfect scene Leonardo di Caprio is my favourite actorr and the music nicee

  • whats this piece of music called? i kno the hands that built america follows this but whats this particular piece called? cant find it

  • it is the Hands that built America, it's the film version which is not commercially available yet.

  • back then the Irish, the english, the Italians and others came to our country and worked their butts off to make it great. Now we have ones who climb over a wall or come in on some shitty home made boat and want equal freedom and rights. that sucks

  • Sorry but it was only the Irish and italians the english were too busy Invading countriies to try and build an "Empire"

  • @Xboxdude343 Go back to school, the so called natives in the movie would have had Western European and most likely British ancestors from Pilgrim times

  • @rylissnovaa Yes western europeans so that includes the other 24 countries within that catagory and as I previously stated a year ago was that during the time line this film was directed at I do believe that the english were in cairo and I believe they were slaughtering innocents in the Indian mutiny.

    Also considering that the American accent was most heavily influenced by the Northern Irish immigrants and Scots who settled in the Appalachian backcountry.

    So I don't think I need to go back

  • @Xboxdude343 The Northern Irish immigrants influenced the American accent? LOL how about you discuss how the English actually fucking made the US which is why you all speak English today. The vast majority of Americans after the revolution were of English ancestry. Sorry if this offends your anti-English stance. The English and (later) Germans built the US. The rest of you just jumped on the bandwagon. Deal with it.

  • @Cameronomics Do you understand that the nation isn't static. A nation doesn't stay the same for two hundred years. Few of the buildings that existed centuries ago still stand.  America is where it is today because of the British, German, Irish, Chinese (railroads), Italians, etc.

  • @deatharch The English were the founders. It's laughable how people seem to mention the contribution of EVERY other group except the most important.

  • @Cameronomics because they weren't , before you reply or something read this again...i never said they didnt 

  • @greenpredetor Speak English you moron. The English were the primary settlers.

  • Me encanta.

  • It also made sense that they didn't have a battle like in the beginning of the movie, and how the troops were called in to totally massacre a whole lot fo the citizenry (awesome scene by the way). It had to happen, because the city was way* too corrupted. For them to have another fight is to continue the madness they've created. It needed a good purging to clean away the anarchy.

  • Great ending. It's sorta like saying how no matter how dramatic your life is, what enemy you made out of another person, what beliefs you may have, or how messed up life was, everything moves on in the end.

  • Jup indeed + this music is perfect for it...

  • Ain't that the truth. Well Said.

  • @shoulderkolibri good comment, and that's exactly what Taoism teaches. Sometimes realizing how a small being I am in the universe, and knowing no real big change will be made no matter what I do makes me feel like doing nothing. Truly, we are stardusts.

  • @shoulderkolibri Also kind of means that everyone worries too much about making a legacy for themselves. haha

  • @shoulderkolibri couldnt say it any better my self

  • @shoulderkolibri wow that was lame

  • @crazyhorse1ck Wow your a bag of douche.

  • Tammany Hall still stands. Its the New York Film Academy now. It's located in Union Square. But it you walk to the north side of the building you will read the old inscription that reads "Columbian or Tammany order."

  • Nice ending, fits great with move, with cuttings grave there and stuff

  • worth an oscar

  • @Qahoa lmao it won 10 xD

  • Does anyone else feel the last shot is very haunting and depressing? I think they should of added an extra shot of New york without the towers, just to show the skyline is just as beautiful without the towers although obviously just as depressing.

  • The director responded to this point quite well... he wished to make a film about the men and women who built america and not those who attempted to destroy it.

  • Best movie ive ever seen.

  • Comment removed

  • Or Gangs of Saco Maine

  • The Towers.

    : (

  • Although I am not an American, I can't help but feel a sense of awe in these images. Something tragic, yet majestic at the same time. ANd the theme of U2 is perfect here.

  • What's the name of this theme!??!

    its not U2....

  • It is u2, it's called "The Hands That Built America" they are credited in the credits, and when the credits roll in Bono's vocal track comes in.

  • yehaa but if you hear the song of U2

    This part! isent their, and its the most beatiful part.... they changed it?

  • I agree with dapard that this is the most beautiful part. When I saw it in the theaters, it sent chills down my spine. And I agree with linkinknot91 that this is the instrumental track and they kicked it up. But you really have to listen hard to the song. I picked it up near the middle.

  • so weird to see the twin towers

  • maybe they will come out with an anniversary directors cut edition - and update the last scene of that montage... sans towers.

  • haha...and then they'll keep going afterwards, with the new towers, and then a bunch of sky homes like in the Jetson's cartoons!

  • best movie ending ever made. In my opinion!

  • I totally agree

  • the best no...i prefer the end of fellini's 'la dolce vita'.

  • are you idiot or what?

  • Yeah, it is.

  • amazing movie, this last scene was the perfect ending, very beautiful, also like this rendition of the U2 song

  • can you tell me whats the name of the song and who perfomed it ?????

  • it's called 'the hands that built america' by u2

  • "the hands that built america" by U2. it's the very end of the song in instrumentals.

  • yep but those retard have choose to make the version different

  • This was a pretty good movie, hard to believe that this scene and all the changes happened in approx. 100 years

  • forget all the bullshit comments... i find it amazing how manhattan island has developed over the past 250 years... think about this film, how it was then and how it is now thats amazing.

  • Great movie! Especially the last scene is very beautiful.

  • I wish they had rebuillt the towers. Why not? That was the most extraordinary part of the NY skyline.

  • i think you are right about that, but at the same time, the visual image of those towers not being there (while sad) unites New York . (IMO) Its a reminder. i know it sounds kinda cliche' or maybe insensitive, but thats what i think. i do agree with you however about it being the most extraordinary party of NY skyline!

  • Paradox, that would not be funny

  • Who's talking about humor?

  • Why would they make towers blown up?

  • Because that's what happened?

  • They really do need to remake the end having the World Trade center blown up.

  • Are you some kind of idiot? Did you not understand anything that DeCaprio said in the very last scene? The whole point of the movie was to tell the story of the people who built america, not the ones who tore it down. So sorry if it doesn't exactly fit the whole post 9/11 political correctness to show two buildings, but art isn't about going by societies standards of what's acceptable, and this movie is a work of art as sure as I'm sitting here.

  • So you're just going to suppress history, and let the terrorists win?

  • Okay, I'm not even going to get into the ancient idea that people still have about 9/11 being caused by terrorists. But regardless, someone did blow up the World Trade Center, and by acknowledging them you give them more power. It's not supressing history, it's sending a message. But I'm not going to try and explain it to you anymore because you obviously don't get symbolism.

  • So you're just going to ignore the fact that it happened and not bother changing history books? Not to mention a movie?

    Seems like a pretty pathetic thing to do.

  • Dude, I don't know how I can explain this to you any clearer. The movie is about the people who formed the foundation of new york, it is not a movie about the people who broke it down. Martin Scorsese didn't want to give those people power by acknowledging what they did, I don't think I could explain it anymore to you. If you're too thick to get it by now, then tough titty, I'm done with trying to make you understand.

  • Martin Scorsese is overrated.

  • Furthermore, I'm fucking astonished that you thought for even a second that I was serious.

    I'm thick headed? You're a dumbass.

  • Or could it be that I've lived long enough in this country to realize that there are people out there who really ARE that stupid. Good to see that you're not really one of them.

  • wtf bitch r u stupid that aint funny fagget

  • Actually it is.

    Besides, if you're going to throw insults at people directing at their stupidity, might want to use proper grammar, punctuation, and spell words correctly.

  • it doesn't fucking matter how i spell and how write a sentence...is this good bitch? still you don't make fun of something like that so many people died and the last thing a person can do is make a joke out of it. p.s. FUCK YOU!!

  • The best type of medicine is laughter, so whatever.

    If you can't laugh about something, whats the point of living?

  • I love the fact that you can see how New york grew into the great city it is. It was nice to see the World Trade Center in there too.

  • this ending is so cool. Next to Collateral, this is one of my favorite movies.

  • Goddamn , half of the comments in this video are made by annoying pricks who keep argueing over stupid reasons.

    Whoever said "Why can't people just comment this video is cool or that was nice" you are absolutely right.

  • and the tombstones stood there all that time, slowly fading away...

  • i loved that ending

  • can anyone tell mi whats the name of this song and artist..if it is a song..:S ,btw,greatest film i have ever seen..just watched it,and im gonna watch it again right now..hehe

  • u have in related videos...

    U2 - The hands that built America

  • I loved this film. The way it ended like that was cool.

  • The Irish Built America

  • if you liked that movie youll love in the name of the father at the end of it makes you want to kill the english

  • yeah well im irish and this movie deffo made me very angry and upset that the irish were killed in such brutal ways by a bunch of violent fuckers and i have no problem with the americans i just got so pissed off

  • That didn't stop us Irish folk from coming over though. ;) We are strong!

  • yeah true that