Added: 5 years ago
From: coulisnosaj
Views: 216,819
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (409)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • where'd you get the vo>

  • how can any prat think that will smith will give a realler portrayal than the original choi min sik,true some remakes are good but they only prove the paucity of ideas in hollywood.Sure they can chuck cash at it till the cows come home, but someones been putting acid in your beloved burgers if you seriously reckon Will Smith or Josh Brolin can bring half the intensity and power to the role than the original

  • This movie is based on the Japanese manga by Nobuaki Minegishi and Garon Tsuchiya! Give them some credits at least!!!

  • Remake cancelled? That is bad. Hollywood Films are much better than asian low-budget trash. Asian actors arent good, got no coolness. The actor from old boy is bad actor, got no style, is not real. Will would make it much better, more realstic feelings, not so trivial posing.

    Compare Ring asian version vs Ring American made. Asain ring is bad b-movie.

    Asians are good story writer. In Films they better stay in background. Are bad actor.

  • @hamburgerloyalts I suppose you're just trolling around? The Ring is like only one movie that isn't downright horrible compared to its Asian counterpart. Others are just.. meh.

    Or even if you truly think Asian movies are bad, there's still no reason for Hollywood to remake them for their own gains, especially when the director of the original movie doesn't allow it. Park Chan Wook already declined Hollywood's offer. So there you go...

  • oh no,dun remake this masterpiece!!!!!!!!!!Spielberg just stay with your crappy transforme D=

  • pls No Remake!..Instead..watch my 2010 best Korean Thriller Top 10 :)

  • Lesson learn here. Asian films are best left Asian. Don't bother trying to make it hollywood.

    And this film is a Masterpiece.

  • @iknowidie too late, Will Smith and Spielberg are remaking it!

  • @coulisnosaj  the remake is cancelled dont worry

  • @rodneytheincontinent So the Will Smith & Spielberg´s remake is cancelled? Thanks God these are really good news!!!!

  • @coulisnosaj so Will Smith is gonna f*ck his daughter?

  • @Furkan74s no, he's gonna fuck his son

  • @coulisnosaj NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOO!

  • @coulisnosaj They filed a lawsuit against it, so we are saved :)

  • @coulisnosaj Isn't it cancelled??

  • @coulisnosaj to ruin another loved movie

  • @coulisnosaj i only vote down because every other asian remake has never lived up to the original.

  • @coulisnosaj you better be trollin

  • @coulisnosaj Haha, now it's Spike Lee and Josh Brolin

  • @iknowidie Ring american version is much better than the asian version. Hollywood got better actors and style.

  • @iknowidie

    hey, i was wondering if you or someone could recommend any other quality films like this??

  • @demolicious1 I saw one that was release recently. "I Saw The Devil" Another Master work from Korea.

  • @demolicious1 I saw one that was release recently. "I Saw The Devil" Another Master work from Korea.

  • @demolicious1 Go check out "I Saw The Devil" another master work from Korea.

  • shit..i watched it in english.. should i watch it again in Korean?

  • @CuteSujoy Definitely, you should....

  • this is the best movie i have seen last decade. every frame is a worth it. a must, must watch movie.

  • this film is 10/10 top to bottom the type of acting hollywood should look upto.

  • this movie was remake in bollywood name zinda and it sucked box office

  • @shka003 I say we should together imprison those bollywood directors for 15 years.

    All they do is ripoff films from other countries. I mean why the hell did they remake it into a stupid film. It totally ruins the original work when its remade and specially when its remade very bad.

  • i love this movie

  • Shit ... watch it in Korean. This movie is a masterpiece, don't ruin it by watching it in English.

  • Oriental movies must be seen in original language.

  • if you're going to watch a korean film....watch it in korean.

  • typical american trailer, i don't like it, but the movie is godlike!!!

  • es la mejor pelicula que vi en mi vida

  • Oh god, I was afraid there was an American remake of this movie. Phew.

  • hollywood would KILL this movie

  • incest

  • I would love to see an English remake of this, not because I don't like watching foreign films, but I believe that many people do have that mindset and will never be able to enjoy this incredible film because of that.

  • @Krypto282 then too bad for them, if they cant watch foreign films, they dont deserve to watch this film. A remake of Oldboy would be highly unecessary and a waste of money, and time.

  • awesome movie a must to buy

  • awesome movie

  • where did you get the trailer voice from?

  • The difference is that Germany has a whole professional industry of A-grade voice dubbing actors and the people who work in the business really care about the results.

    In America they spend about 10 cents on untalented translators who can't translate and voice actors who can't act and nobody cares how crappy the results are.

    The exception would be the last couple of Miyazaki films. But I can't remember a single live action film successfully dubbed into English from any language.

  • This movie is AWESOME! Anyone knows where to find the painting that's in his room??? I've been searching for it a lot, and can't seem to find it.

  • what song is this it aint on the soundtrack cd

  • i just seen this movie 2 nights ago. what a great movie. great plot and the directing was great. i recommend just watch it in english subtitle.

  • God, the English dub is so bad in this movie.

  • @PrinceofNoir well in that case i wish i knew korean so i can watch this

  • @cage000100 You could do subtitles. It was just the version I was watching didn't have the subtitle option.

  • @cage000100 Im assuming you can read!!!!

  • there is a bollywood version of it also called "Zinda"

  • ZINDA is Bollywood Copy cat, Park chan wook sued the director , But INDIANS are corrupt so they managed it some how..

    Almost 90% of Indian movies are copy cats, if you do some research you could find it, but sadly INDIAN IQ is 70 on AVG

  • @razormanrambo Fail. The average IQ is always 100. Learn some Gaussian distribution. Besides, stop talking BS.

  • it's not a remake

  • This movie is only good in Korean. English takes the whole feel away.

  • Thumbs up X 1,000. Sooooooo glad that Will Smith/Spielberg shit remake got nixed.

  • It's actually pretty good in German, too^^

    just wanted to add that :)

    but yeah, I also definitely recommend watching the movie in Korean with Subtitles :O

  • @Imran500 totally agree

  • @Imran500 well, i watched it in german...

  • @Imran500 It's very good also in German

  • @Imran500 I prefer the originals as well, but I am glad the german dub is surprisingly good and exciting :D

    exceptions are proof of the rule , as we say.

  • terrible trailer did not do the movie justice at all

  • Where do I get this music?

  • I don't know why people have to give the dubbed version a hard time.

    The dubbed version of this film is really good, I've been able to watch it both ways very happily.

    now I understand giving dubbing in general a hard time (because there is some shit out there) but reading the whole damn thing tends to take alot away from the experience.

  • i cannot get away with this movie, 4 months went since I saw it but still cannot get rid of it.

  • Yeah dubbed movies feel a bit strange, like watching Forrest Gump with a chinese voice over.

  • use subtitles instead...

  • I realize this is a a voice over, but since the subject is being talked about, I cannot stand dubbed movies. I'd rather have subtitles, even if they have language barriers by not being able to properly convey some words. Dubbing is just too lame, kills the entire mood.

  • i totally agree with you

  • Totally agree, however I think that subtitles do not have any language barriers. The main problem with dubbing, even when done well it that they have to map the voice to mouth movements on screen. If the translation is a sentence, but the mouth only makes two shapes, what can you do?

    Subbing is so much better in every regard.

  • i dun like this way....i want eng sub!!! Korean movie supposed to sound like Korean plus if i cant hear actors sound wont b watching true movie...i want original sounds!!! but eng sub!!!

  • Look who's talking?.... that's the name of the song, The Oldboy OST

  • According to IMDB the remake will be with

    Director: Steven Spielberg

    Cast: Will Smith

    Anyone else find this insulting?

  • omg, i wanted to shoot myself when i heard that....im furious. steven spielberg isnt bad, but there is such a unique and intersting feel to park chan-wook's work that can not be mimicked. this is a master-piece and im dreading how spielbergs will present his version to the states

  • I didn't know Oldboy was a comedy =/

  • @Valormok

    Its canceled now anyway

  • SPOLIERS IN THIS COMMENTS SECTION

  • why does he only have 5 days?

  • watch the movie... most twisted plot i've ever seen in a film.. ever.. and one of the greatest films as well

  • Watch it with subtitles, it is much much better.

  • This is my favorite movie of all time. I've watched it more than ten times.

  • The English dub sounds okay, but I prefer the subtitles. Keeps it authenticity that way and I also won't seem like a lazy bastard >_>

  • i kind of didnt understand part of this movie... spoiler alert! only read if u saw it..

    so the guy who locked him up had sex with his sister knowingly and the dude got locked up because he saw them? then the guy who had sex with his sister tricked him into sleeping with his daughter?????

  • You are almost right, Daesu sees those two cuddling around after school and spreads a rumor that she is pregnent. Eventually she shows false pregnancy and believes the only way to solve the problem is suiside. And you've got the other part right.

  • actually. he didnt spread the rumor about her being pregnant. he just told his friend that they were doing things together. then that got around saying she's a whore and that turned into "oh she's pregnant." which led to her "suicide"

  • YES .

  • Yes, He saw and told people about it. Then he tricked him into having sex with his daughter without knowing it. Then at the end she does something to him again to make him think it never even happened.

  • SPOILER ALERTS

    he locked him up because he started a rumour, which led the sister to suicide. i give that the guy is creepy... but i think, if it takes such gigantic proportions in the sickness, it's because his payback to dae su is the only thing that keeps him alive. and after he got it, he shoots himself, crying for his sister. that's "le comte de montecristo" back word (a french novel about vengeance)

  • well...the guy who did it with his sister was mental...and his sister got pregnant and killed herself cause of that and cause everyone was talking about them, cause the guy who saw them told it to his friend who than again told it to everyone. So the mental guy couldnt handle the blame and blamed it on the guy who saw them and did whatever he thought would be the best revenge. In my opinion, he did a great job

  • basically yeah. the guy who saw the dude with his sister started a rumor about her that caused her to kill herself. so the incest guy blames his lover/sister's death on the main character and thus makes up that whole crazy revenge plan.

  • just downloaded with english subs, watching now..

  • It's because Americans can't read subtitles.

  • this movie would be ruined like too many american remakes. its already a masterpiece... why would you alter the mona lisa? or any other form of art. other countries should start remaking american films, cuz american films are the real trash ;)

  • its shit with the dubbing, watch it with the subtitles for more dramam and realism, which is what this film is all about

  • Comment removed

  • no remake... even tarantino would think that is completely inappropriate

  • Cool trailer! Best movie ever!!

    What is the music called wich plays after the voice says: "Now, he has 5 days to find out why..." ? Sounds really great (the music)

  • watch?v=jWCrbe67g6c

  • america isnt ready to see will smith fuck his own daughter.

    please dont do it.

    this movie is too brilliant for spielberg.

  • i'm in deep love with this movie. amazing, fucking amazing movie.

  • why would you see this movie in english

  • I really don't see why this film needs to be made again by Steven Spieldberg.

    Sure they said they'd follow the manga more than the movie but how different are they really going to be?

  • holivud amına koyim senin gül gibi filmin de içine sıç. ha yetmedi di mi doy amına koyim doy!

  • me and my buddies were talking about robert downey jr as well, he would be the perfect oh dae su, haha vote for downey : )

  • if will smith is doing it, he better be woo jin. i just don't see him as a dae su.

  • idk Will is a great actor. he may just surprise you... but he would be more fitting to woo-jin

  • I concur. I think he, Will Smith, would b a perfect woo jin, he has the whole; handsome, metrosexual, billionaire look about him already. He lacks the grit and mental instability to be dea su.

    I am more concerned with Steven Speilberg, I would have preferred David Fincher he has done "Zodiac, Fight Club, Seven, and Panic Room" all films similar to Old Boy's style.

  • I think if will smith does what he did in seven pounds he just might be able to pull off Woo jin.

    I know who would be Oh Dae-su. Robert downey Jr... I cant think who else would suit the weird hair and stuff.

  • i never thought of that! heres hoping

  • agree. hes too clean to play dae su

  • fuck! it is a spoiler not a trailer

  • No, seriously it's not. There's SUCH an epic twist at the end, that that it doesnt even matter that you know the beginning.

  • i know, i ve already seen the movie it was fantastic. but only thing is the trailer should not give any specific information about the movie... one, who has seen this trailer, will most probably know almost everything for the first 15 - 20 minutes of the movie. So totally it does not make any sense.

  • i was literally speechless after seeing this a year ago

    i remember just sitting there with my friend and saying "dude..."

  • Spielberg's Oldboy is going to be a lame super hero movie like HANCOCK. Oh how the great have fallen, I remember when Spielberg was one of the most respected directorsi n the world.

  • we'll see how that goes. so far the details aren't sufficient to say what the movie is going to be like. Anyway its Spielberg and Will Smith so I'm at least glad that the movie has risen to such high profile status. Like how Scorsese's Departed brought attention to Infernal Affairs, this will bring attention to the original Oldboy.

  • American Oldboy will be closer to the comic.

    Usually being closer to the comic is better...

    but when the original movie is better than the original comic?

    no.

    Will Smith would be good as the comic version's Oldboy.

    but Spielberg's film would never be as good as this work of art. Spielberg should just stick to the films he's good at, I want Jurassic Park 4, not stupid Oldboy remake!!!!

  • The film is one of the best I know. I´m just glad that I hadn´t seen the trailer, it tells already have the story. (But the other half is even better ;)

  • just finished watching this korean movie.. that was awesome.. a work of art..

  • best film ever no doubt

  • you are looking for 'silmido part1' in youtube

    silmido is korea masterpiece movie

    (english sub)

  • i think the creator of this video is trying to show you guys how lame.. an american remake of this show would be.

    hence the very lame trailer.. its so typical of hollywood.

  • Will smith is doing it

  • i hope the remake would be as good as the original, but i dont think will smith would be good for the lead actor!

  • if will smith is going to star in the movie, I hope he will be the antagonist

  • If Will Smith is going to star in this movie, I hope he gets put in a coma before it finishes, and the American version is never released.

  • hahaha good one.

  • the voice is so SHITTY

  • Such an awesome film

  • fucking americans, whats next, a remake?

  • I hate to say it, but I "am" American, and I agree. I fuckin hate how american movies are just nothing but remakes. That or if they boast that it's original, I guarantee it was already made in another country. Fuck America.

  • theres that movie QUARANTINE, the original is called REC'. its amazing, and not only 100% the same, but better in every way. remakes suck dick! and if your too dumb to read captions, dont bother!

  • I hate to break it to you, but the rights have already been sold to hollywood and the remake is in planning (if not production already... haven't cheked on that for a while)

    Remake = FAIL, only exception I know of being charlie and the chocolate factor. I actually enjoyed that one as much as the original.

  • man :( this days just few filmakers creates something new, today its all bout friggin remakes, videogames, comics and toys adaptations, thats so lame :(

  • lol... I hate to break THIS to you, too, bot OldBoy actually is a comic adaption. The original manga is "old boy" by Garon Tsuchiya and Nobuaki Minegishi.

    "History of Violence" is a comic adaption as well...

    anyhow, I agree with you on the rest ;D

  • :( so i guess i will remove park chan wook from my writerdirector's olympus

  • All " american style " shit , just sucks...!!!

  • You american realy distriod a biutful move.

    stopp blive you are the best.

  • right...death to America!!

  • Amen my bro...!!!

  • American is not 'you..'.

    realy->r eally

    distriod->destroyed

    biutful-> beautiful

    move-> movie

    stopp-> stop

    blive-> believe (you mean believing)

    that you are the best* (it's still not 'you')

    Were you drunk dude? It's just scary.

  • When you translate a movie from Korean to English will become exactly like my first komentar you did not take.

    This is no idea to check on a damaged movie.

    finally, I must say that I have nothing against people from USA. It was the only movie that was meant to be.

  • GOD FUCKING DAMNIT. just release the original in usa fucking dumb ass Hollywood

  • English dubs are so painful to listen to.

  • america have to destroy everything

  • haha amen bro

  • america have to destroy everything

  • one of the most brilliant movies ever

    and I don't understand why some Americans can't just enjoy a great foreign movie without making a remake

  • Dude, I'm American, and I totally agree.

    Our remakes usually suck, too. They use all the cool action and totally bastardize the meaning and depth of the movie.

  • Absolutely right. There are exceptions, though.

    I enjoyed Departed by Scorsese, for example. But still I am absolutely sure that the American Oldboy won't be as good as the Korean film.

  • :(((...nothing beats the original..

  • i hope this movie won't have a hollywood version

  • Yeah it does.. there u=is actually an upcoming american version

  • It is said Will Smith's gonna star in the American version/remake.

  • Not will smith, but Nicolas cage. And Oprah and Jack Black will be in a supporting role. I have reliable sources mind you.

  • lol serious? well at least its not will smith, i dont think he would have fit the role. cage is a little better, but why do i keep thinking of con air? i think gary oldman would have been awesome if there had to be a remake, but honestly i can't imagine anyone being able to replace choi min-sik perfectly.

  • Comment removed

  • ENG sucks

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GODDAMN IT YOU CANT REDUB IT Y GOD?!NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO and this tersiler misses the point its not a super actiony movie its a slower moving intulecttual aCTION MOVE and the korean helps it along watch the original!@!@!!!!!!

  • heard very good things about this movie

  • check this movie out..its fucking awesome

  • this movie is the greatest movie ever. if you watch it mae sure its with subtitles, because teh voice acting is intensely important and american dubbing ruins it! WATCH IT WITH SUBTITLES!!!

  • Why you deleted mcshady71´s comments and viirocks coments??? I think viirocks comments were more violent. See ya.

  • watching a dubbed movie is stupid, after all. u need to be able to hear the actors' voices with english subtitles to fully enjoy the movie even if u can't understand the language.

  • Wow, this sucks.

  • The film dubbed just isn't right it seems to i don't know ,make the film unexplainably lame. Should only be viewed with original korean and subtitles. I remember my friends watched it thought it was better with the dubbing but they are morons and no longer friends of mine.

  • it's a trailer not the entire movie...get over it!!!

  • lol I really hope your kidding about them not being friends anymore lol. but i saw it with dubbing, and i was like wow this is terrible!! until an hour in, i realized it was a really good movie but the dubbing made it seem so silly, and i really wish someone told me just to watch it with subtitles. great movie.

  • lol

  • Watch the korean audio with Englsh subs. They did a fucking terrible job with the dubbing and it makes even the best scenes in the movie completely stupid. That is, if you really want to experience the movie for what it is.

  • Totally agree. If you're going to watch a foreign movie that's in a language you're not familiar with, at least turn on the goddamn subtitles.

  • "what loser who has an asian girlfriend can actually be proud of that??"

    seriously, grow the fuck up.

  • omy trust hollywood to f**k up a good movie.