I couldn't agree more with the previous post [McElhinney65]. I have the Glenn Close version of this too on my iPod but I think this is just stunning. Both girls are fabulous harmonising together, my only sadness is that I wish they had done the whole song because if this short version is anything to go by, it would just be phenomenal. Sarah just pulls this off effortlessly like she was born to sing it and Rachel compliments her too. ENCORE!!! x
I keep watching this clip over and over again. What a fantastic rendition of the song by both girls. Shows like this illustrate what a joke Britain's Got Clowns really is. These girls are truly talented. Good luck for the future both of you if you read this.
Sarah was definatly best for Nancy, and im glad shes in the production as an u/s. Totally right for that part. Rachel was amazing however, and i really was all for her to win.
i think sarah is so talented but i think her diction is almost TOO good! i know that sounds stupid, but i think nancy needs to be more rough than clean-cut...
they are both absolutely sterling performers - and their voices sounded amazing with that song...sent shivers down my spine...but Sarah just couldn't be Nancy. Shes Glinda, she's Fantine, but she's not really Nancy. Rachel has that toughness about her, you could believe her as Nancy. She was never going to win though because she was a professional so ALW gave her the boot too early - just to hedge his bets!
actually, i hadnt thought of that, Sarah would be a lovely Glinda, I can just imagine her pracing round to popular :) and dont they sing well asa duet couple, can you imagine them doing "For Good?" ;:) xxxx
well you have to think its sort of a good thing they were in the sing off or one of the highlights of the seires as in this song wouldnt have hapened well it would have but you know what i mean it wouldnt have been as good
i've watched this so many times... it's quite sad. Sarah for me was the best singer in the show; totally pure and angelic voice, and that face; so cute.. Rachel was good, but not that good..
i couldnt decide about who i would have saved if i was ALW - cos Rachel was my overall favourite BUT sarah had the nicest voice which topped rachels voice - i was so sad she went :(
Ditto [; dya know if Jessie's got offered anything, I heard somewhere they wanted her for Truly in the touring Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. But I can't remember when I heard it so I dunno if it's true /: x
She's been offered Nancy understudy and Sally Bowles in the touring Cabaret. I think she is still in talks atm but she is doing a Shakespeare course with RADA so things may be put on hold until that is finished. It's good experience for her.
Cool, I just hope it all leads to even huger things for her, she's amazing + deserves a fantastic career, I read one of your comments on another vid, do youu have her address? x
I got it from her brothers bebo. I recently made some fan-ail and said that everyone on Youtube that were Jessie fans could send a message and then I put them all together and made a little booklet and then I sent it off, but I've had no reply yet :(
Wow, this is definitely my favourite sing-off. I didn't see it on the tv but both girls are truly amazing and this makes me tear up every time. Sarah wasn't my Nancy, but she was a true star and I wish her all the best. And as for Rachel - someone get her a part in Cabaret, now!
This has to be the best, most emotional sing off from the competion (although, I loved Rachel in the Memory sing off - sam should have gone then)
Watching this, how good would a Sarah/Rachel/Jodie final have been. That would have been my perfect final three and I would have been happy whoever won! I thought the final was quite bland this year compared with last years Joseph one.
aww i liked sarah :( she should never have left that early! this was the best sing off in my opinion (: to be honest though, i'm more interested in all of the olivers performances ahaa :]
Why do people think that being loud means that you're a better singer? This song isn't about shouting, and Rachel's more emotional, softer take is more appropriate here.
yea i totally agree being loud does not mean ur better. at my drama group the people who r cast r always loud at singing and shout thier lines and i think its better to have more emotion in it and vary the sound but is suppose it depends on what the director wants :D
To me this was the stand out performance of the entire series. They were both performed so very well, and the lyrics were perfect for the occasion, it just took it to another level completely.
I felt Rachel was better throughout the song, but Sarah singing the last line into the camera breaks my heart, especially since she went.
I'd have placed Sarah much higher than some who stayed.
Sarah should have won, she was unique, had an amazing voice and would have made a great Nancy. shouldnt have left this early spesh with Nieve and Ashley still in
Aw this was the best sing off which is kinda sad coz it meens that both of them were amazingly good. Im sad that sarah went but i didnt want rachel to go either. they both have an amazing future ahead of them hopefully coz i would love to see both of them on westend:)
This is the best sing off and, I think, two of the best vocals on the show so far. Rachel and Sarah are fantastic singers. Sarah should still be in the competition
omg i almost peed with laughter at that comment... its like shes thinking... am i meant to be happy?? oh sod it :)except it turned out more like this :S haha!! sarah was my favourite to win... but now... jodie!!! go jodie!!!
I think Rachel is a lovely person and a very good singer and performer. However I can't helo but think she looks a bit...evil singing this! It's the look in her eyes...
in sarah's exit interview she said she wanted niamh or samantha to win, and francesca said the same thing! so i think all the fans of sarah and fran should get behind these two girls!!!
I live in Barcelona and my only experience with the show is through youtube. This girl, Sarah is SO MUCH BETTER than the other one. A truly beautifull voice. I do NOT like the judges: both Dennise and Barrowman have MEDIOCRE voices and they judge with inconsistent criteria...
I think this was the best sing-off so far, though Ashley should have had to sing it instead of one of them, that way there would at least have been a chance of her finally going! I think she should have gone in week 4 instead of Francesca. My favourite Nancy is Samantha, and my top 3 Olivers are Chester, Gwion and Kwayedza. They are all great though :) x
i have watched this bout 50 times, i love wen rachel sings...'I've Come Home At Last' it is amazing.. rachel lives near me an my mum knows her daddy.. she has been singing with her daddy since she was young an her sister aswell they r jus amazing
OMG this is the performance of the whole series. I'm so sad to see Sarah go. I couldn't believe it when Denise voted her as the one who wouldn't be Nancy. I hope producers were watching her and snap her up for a West End musical.
I think this was the performance of the series not Jessie's performance!!!! These two are showing how to perform, i hope the other girls were taking notes!!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Rachels expression at 2:08-2:09 and 2:28 really bugs me! I just want to slap her, lol .. she is so smug and up herself! Can't believe Sarah has gone, she was fabulous!
please can people honestly vote for who they think was the best...don't just favour someone e.g cause they're from the isle of man!... this result was ridiculous and i've lost a lot of respect for ALW
thats such a nice song. didnt like sarah but didnt think she deserved to be in the bottom 2 - neither did rachel. when is ashley gonna leave! naimh 2 win
This song almost brought a tear to my eye, I'd never heard it before, it was just beautiful. Neither of them should've been in the bottom 2. I considered those 2 some of the safest in the competition, this was a shock to me...
I thought they were both pretty amazing, although, if I was in ALW's situation, I'd have made the same decision; because Rachel sang the song the way it is meant to be sung, Sarah didn't really, you could spot her flaws clearly.
Having said that, she SO should not have been in the bottom two.
I want Jessie out. She RUINED The Man That Got Away!!
Silly man lol ! Why did he save Rachel over Sarah !? I Loved Sarah, she has a brilliant talent, and a stunning personality as well as a beautiful voice, as for Rachel though I admit she is talented, she strikes me as arrogant, and not very nice. But definately the wrong decision here! By the sing off you can hear that Sarah is better! How could he not see that!?
Rachel is really not arrogant at all! She comes across as so bubbly and friendly and definitely does not have a cold expression on her face. she was so shocked that ALW saved her. They were both absolutely amazing in this performance, and if i had to choose between them i would have chosen Rachel, she is solid, just as he said. But im gutted for Sarah and im sure she has a bright future ahead of her!
I must be watching the wrong show then. Rachel is defo not cold. The both of them did not deserve to be in the sing off. The both have amazing voices. I'd like to see some of you get on stage and sing live and see how your nerves are. If ya haven't got anything nice to say about their talent then don't bother saying anything at all, and as for Jessie she has an amazing voice and puts on a great performance. In fact all the girls do. This is going to be one tough winner to pick
Not only was Sarah outstanding in this performance, consiering the panel talked so much about expressions and conveying emotion, Rachel always has the same cold expression on her face - Webber definitely made the wrong decision last night!
Rachel was the only one I had no strong feelings about either way. I just didn't care about her but I'm completely gutted Sarah went. I thought she was brilliant and I wanted to see more of her.
I hated Rachel in this programme. She came across as so arrogant. She's amazing as Elphaba though!
StephC6134 1 month ago
Rachel should've replaced Jessie in the final
ImABroadwayLuver 8 months ago 3
Rachel is definitely 'I'd Do anythings' version of 'Over the Rainbows' Lauren!
GoldenCrackers 1 year ago 3
Rachel is FANTASTIC! :DD
wicked0824 1 year ago 3
best sing off
RandomRandommer 1 year ago 4
These were my favourite 2 from the start, couldnt believe the public are so stupid.
Oh well, Rachel got the best role in the West End, so she's the winner.
To even imagine Jodie trying to sing ANY of the songs from Wicked makes me shudder.
unidan82 1 year ago 3
I will never tire of this. Best sing off ever. They were amazing.
LawrieMarlow 1 year ago 5
@LawrieMarlow agreed. x
pipermaru2006 1 year ago
even after two years this still gives me the shivers
justjackfan1 1 year ago 6
I think rachael got through as she didnt have 2 many breathes
SlasherXxX9408 1 year ago
I think rachael had a more not breathe voice
SlasherXxX9408 1 year ago
The world seems to be crowded with intuitions of people who can sing.
LASTMAN024 2 years ago
such great singers
madisoned 2 years ago 3
she got a good voice she do
noshoe4u 2 years ago
At 2.10 Rachel looks fucking DEMONIC!
NigelHawbankTheThird 2 years ago 11
Definately should have both been in the final 3 with the Jodster.
NigelHawbankTheThird 2 years ago
Nigel, strange observation as the Jodster was out-classed by Jessie in the actual final
mawsley9 2 years ago
easily the best two singers in the competition
xjosiebeanx 2 years ago 5
I so agree :D These two should have been in the final with Jodie
speidismurf118 2 years ago 4
wat show is this?
DeathNoteStalker 2 years ago
i'd do anything a competitionto find people to play the roles of nancy and oliver in the 2009 revival of the stage musical Oliver!
justjackfan1 2 years ago
Sarah was always my favourite
speidismurf118 2 years ago
The best part of the series for me. I'm on the brink of tears every time I watch it :(
speidismurf118 2 years ago 4
i wanted sarah to get it
naomilovingmathew 2 years ago
I couldn't agree more with the previous post [McElhinney65]. I have the Glenn Close version of this too on my iPod but I think this is just stunning. Both girls are fabulous harmonising together, my only sadness is that I wish they had done the whole song because if this short version is anything to go by, it would just be phenomenal. Sarah just pulls this off effortlessly like she was born to sing it and Rachel compliments her too. ENCORE!!! x
beccababbit 2 years ago
I keep watching this clip over and over again. What a fantastic rendition of the song by both girls. Shows like this illustrate what a joke Britain's Got Clowns really is. These girls are truly talented. Good luck for the future both of you if you read this.
McElhinney65 2 years ago 4
Sarah was definatly best for Nancy, and im glad shes in the production as an u/s. Totally right for that part. Rachel was amazing however, and i really was all for her to win.
Tris092 2 years ago
legends
and this is a tune!
BleakleyCutler 2 years ago
i love thiss!! i like the chic in the yellow dress especially =D
sab45g 2 years ago 3
do you mean Rachel!
lol, my name is Rachael aswell!!
xx
icklemegan 2 years ago
They were both awesome. This sing off blew me away, as did Francesca's exit song the week she went. She nailed it.
McElhinney65 2 years ago 3
i think sarah is so talented but i think her diction is almost TOO good! i know that sounds stupid, but i think nancy needs to be more rough than clean-cut...
appletiser89 2 years ago 5
ye well sarah been cast as nancy understudy
128saz 2 years ago 2
they are both absolutely sterling performers - and their voices sounded amazing with that song...sent shivers down my spine...but Sarah just couldn't be Nancy. Shes Glinda, she's Fantine, but she's not really Nancy. Rachel has that toughness about her, you could believe her as Nancy. She was never going to win though because she was a professional so ALW gave her the boot too early - just to hedge his bets!
mysteriousgoo 2 years ago 4
oh apparantly Sarah is the understudy so I stand corrected! lol
mysteriousgoo 2 years ago
actually, i hadnt thought of that, Sarah would be a lovely Glinda, I can just imagine her pracing round to popular :) and dont they sing well asa duet couple, can you imagine them doing "For Good?" ;:) xxxx
animalpals 2 years ago 3
completely beautiful
peprilen 3 years ago 3
This was the saddest sing off ... I loved both of these two.
KitKat1990 3 years ago 7
oh O.O hey! this part is really good O.o
2:10 ^^cool! but i like 30 seconds to mars moore...sry ^^
xXemocloudXx13 3 years ago
errr.....pretty voice but...er....its okay^^
the girl with black hear is pretty ^.^
xXemocloudXx13 3 years ago 3
thats one fucking song to choose jesus!!
i know they dont choose it, but jesus, make it hard haha
queenavril89 3 years ago 2
Both faultless performances.
lukelewisDOTnet 3 years ago 3
Jesus christ, they were both fantastic!
I really think rachel should have won, I was outraged when ALW picked samantha, when rachel was a better singer and actress.
Moomintroll123 3 years ago 34
This comment has received too many negative votes show
? that was a waste of my time!
but they have good voices...
HDA720 3 years ago
This is a gr8 sing off,you think Sarah is good until you hear RACHEL..Gr8 song too
ronroo 3 years ago 12
Rachel should have won, but hey now shes gonna be in the west end version of We Will Rock You as Meat, so good on her!!!
giageordiegal 3 years ago 12
@giageordiegal and now she's going to play elphaba in wicked so really she is the most successful of them all
itbejess 2 years ago 3
Too much arm waving and head shaking
tadzio999 3 years ago
rachel should have won
ExAxLxPx12 3 years ago 23
This was the best singoff's in the whole series omg How did them2 get on the bottom 2
niknaknonoo 3 years ago 11
well you have to think its sort of a good thing they were in the sing off or one of the highlights of the seires as in this song wouldnt have hapened well it would have but you know what i mean it wouldnt have been as good
justjackfan1 3 years ago 2
denise cried her eyes out!! :(:(
kazzy1313 3 years ago
I know, it was emotional but it wasn't a reducing me to tears moment, unlike Jessie's ALAHNM.
MissiCharli 3 years ago
i've watched this so many times... it's quite sad. Sarah for me was the best singer in the show; totally pure and angelic voice, and that face; so cute.. Rachel was good, but not that good..
Sarah, hopefully, will become a star.
davidrabone 3 years ago
i couldnt decide about who i would have saved if i was ALW - cos Rachel was my overall favourite BUT sarah had the nicest voice which topped rachels voice - i was so sad she went :(
peprilen 3 years ago 2
SARAH WAS THE BEST
CarlyAndJacob 3 years ago
Ok i have listened to this song way to much!
I never used to even know the song!
And now i know all the words!!!
Lol!
Love you Rachel!
You should have won!
You are still my winner!!!
cathybabe7733 3 years ago 5
this has to the most AMAZING sing off. Made me cry :(
xHiddenxx 3 years ago 4
this and also memory (Sam and Rachel!)
dolfie95 3 years ago
sarah certainly didnt get as far as she deserved, but i do think rachel was betta, it was 2 early for them both 2 be out :(
rachel and jodie were my favs xx
xmusicalmaniax 3 years ago
Sarah + Rachel both should have been in the final [:
-ox
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago 7
With Jessie, that would have been my perfect result.
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Yeah, they were my top three [: all amazing x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago 3
My order would have been
3. Sarah
2. Rachel
1. Jessie
MissiCharli 3 years ago 3
Omg mines the exact same lol, that was deffo Jessie's role [: her + Gwion singing truly scrumptious was absolutely priceless [; x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
Ha. I know, SOMEONE stole it :( If not Jessie, defo Rachel or Sarah. So happy for Rachel now though, I might go and see her, I'm saving up!
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Ditto [; dya know if Jessie's got offered anything, I heard somewhere they wanted her for Truly in the touring Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. But I can't remember when I heard it so I dunno if it's true /: x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
She's been offered Nancy understudy and Sally Bowles in the touring Cabaret. I think she is still in talks atm but she is doing a Shakespeare course with RADA so things may be put on hold until that is finished. It's good experience for her.
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Cool, I just hope it all leads to even huger things for her, she's amazing + deserves a fantastic career, I read one of your comments on another vid, do youu have her address? x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago 2
I'm sure it will do! Yep, I do have her address!
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Ohh cool, how did youu get it? I'd love to send her a message or something x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
I got it from her brothers bebo. I recently made some fan-ail and said that everyone on Youtube that were Jessie fans could send a message and then I put them all together and made a little booklet and then I sent it off, but I've had no reply yet :(
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Ohh, I didn't hear about that, I would have put something in, I'm sure she appreciated it + will hopefully reply soon x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
Hopefully!
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Please tell me if youu hear something back [: x
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
I will, I would say I'll tell you first but I seem to have said that to alot of people! :/
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Lol, well I'll settle for being told any time, to make things easier [; haa
BluueSkyyScape 3 years ago
Ha, thanks!
MissiCharli 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shut the fuck up
magicmystery01 3 years ago
Comment removed
holliepophehe 3 years ago
Oh yes I've seen. I'm a regular to the Jessie and Rachel fan blogs!
MissiCharli 3 years ago 3
those are my top 3 apart from mine go
1)Rachel
2)Jessie
3)Sarah
holliepophehe 3 years ago 12
i have offically watched this too many times i know like all the words now
justjackfan1 3 years ago 4
ALW should have made a much bigger fuss about this than Keisha
ILoveWangers18 3 years ago 7
Rachel's bits were amazing but even though i am a rachel fan, sarah is really good in this song!!!!!
fionnaredhead 3 years ago
both of them have pure talent.
:)
francescamusical 3 years ago 2
sarahs effing stunning (:
loved her so much,
was always my nancy.
but happy that jodie won.
sarah should'nt of left,
but at least she went,
on a fantastic sing off and goodbye.
danhbk8 3 years ago 4
Iv'e just noticed sarah's got some right hips on her there besutiful nice nd curvy awesome
luv da sig-off no-one shud of gone
niknaknonoo 3 years ago 3
The singoffs brought out some of the best performances of the series. Week 5, 6, and 8 were brilliant.
AmyAge14 3 years ago 6
Dont' forget Week 9 with Rachel and Sam
LetTheGreenGirlGo 3 years ago 2
oh yea week 9 sing off was amazing but this was still the best
justjackfan1 3 years ago
Yes, this is (unfortunately) the best Singoff!
LetTheGreenGirlGo 3 years ago
both of rachels sing offs are the best and most emotional! they both made me cry
she should have been in the final with sarah and sam
dolfie95 3 years ago 5
My ideal final would have been Jessie, Rachel and Sarah (in that order). This makes me cry, I haven't seen her others.
rockingdiva7755 3 years ago 4
Wow, this is definitely my favourite sing-off. I didn't see it on the tv but both girls are truly amazing and this makes me tear up every time. Sarah wasn't my Nancy, but she was a true star and I wish her all the best. And as for Rachel - someone get her a part in Cabaret, now!
rockingdiva7755 3 years ago 8
rachel got all the best bits but they are both amazing
dolfie95 3 years ago 5
The performance of both girls sent tingles down my spine, very well done.
McElhinney65 3 years ago 3
Sarah was my favourite, it was so upsetting when she went. Definitely the most emotional Sing Off in the competition. I cried. :(
Cams10Jovi 3 years ago 4
cry like a baby every time.....
walfordslilprincess 3 years ago 5
Absolutely amazing! beautiful rendition of this lovely song. and closet sing off. these girls are both stars. I was gutted Sarah left.
GabbyDee32 3 years ago 2
This has to be the best, most emotional sing off from the competion (although, I loved Rachel in the Memory sing off - sam should have gone then)
Watching this, how good would a Sarah/Rachel/Jodie final have been. That would have been my perfect final three and I would have been happy whoever won! I thought the final was quite bland this year compared with last years Joseph one.
LesMisNut 3 years ago 4
aww i liked sarah :( she should never have left that early! this was the best sing off in my opinion (: to be honest though, i'm more interested in all of the olivers performances ahaa :]
♥
hezzabubs93 3 years ago 2
sarah should of stayed in this one rachel should of went instead
naomilovingmathew 3 years ago
both the best actresses rach should have won!
becgreen35 3 years ago 4
Why do people think that being loud means that you're a better singer? This song isn't about shouting, and Rachel's more emotional, softer take is more appropriate here.
j4Rose 3 years ago 3
yea i totally agree being loud does not mean ur better. at my drama group the people who r cast r always loud at singing and shout thier lines and i think its better to have more emotion in it and vary the sound but is suppose it depends on what the director wants :D
Howdy66 3 years ago 3
To me this was the stand out performance of the entire series. They were both performed so very well, and the lyrics were perfect for the occasion, it just took it to another level completely.
I felt Rachel was better throughout the song, but Sarah singing the last line into the camera breaks my heart, especially since she went.
I'd have placed Sarah much higher than some who stayed.
ZdPhoenix 3 years ago 3
I thought this was the most emotional sing off
odamadillo 3 years ago
yer most probably hardest choice of the series- neither should have been in sing off
walfordslilprincess 3 years ago 4
I love how Racheal says "This worlds waited long enough; I've come home at last"
And how at the end they both say "Oh please, Dont ever ever make me say goodbye"
Amazing :)
dkazd 3 years ago
Sarah should have won, she was unique, had an amazing voice and would have made a great Nancy. shouldnt have left this early spesh with Nieve and Ashley still in
FinchN9 3 years ago
to be honest this had to of been the closest sing off in the entire competition
walfordslilprincess 3 years ago
Rachel was definetly the right desicion!! But sarah is still good.
Star12140 3 years ago 2
sarah was amazingg,
best sing off yet.
jodie to win! xD
danhbk8 3 years ago 2
i loved sarah-she sounded like kerry ellis! but samantha all the way!! SAM 4 NANCY!¬
cherryride12 3 years ago
Ooh, she sound like Kerry a bit!
Still prefer Rachel though.
elleruth 3 years ago 3
Aw this was the best sing off which is kinda sad coz it meens that both of them were amazingly good. Im sad that sarah went but i didnt want rachel to go either. they both have an amazing future ahead of them hopefully coz i would love to see both of them on westend:)
gabbymcdoodle 3 years ago 5
This is the best sing off and, I think, two of the best vocals on the show so far. Rachel and Sarah are fantastic singers. Sarah should still be in the competition
johnjigglypuff 3 years ago 4
I loved them both but i would swap sarah for Rachel. But now it go on jodie and rachel!
walfordslilprincess 3 years ago 3
whats with Rachels face at 2.10? Is that meant to b a smile? Can't believe Sarah's gone...Jodie to win now i think
gayledunnett 3 years ago
omg i almost peed with laughter at that comment... its like shes thinking... am i meant to be happy?? oh sod it :)except it turned out more like this :S haha!! sarah was my favourite to win... but now... jodie!!! go jodie!!!
achancetoflyisback 3 years ago
When Sarah Singss
"We'll Havee Magic In The Makingg"
Youu Really Feel The Magic =) x
=( Miss Her x
ILoveeYouuOx 3 years ago 2
Yeahh I Noticed That =P x
=( Miss Sarah ='( x Just Isn't The Samee =( ,, But To Be Fair Neither Of Them Deserved To Be In The Bottom 2 =( x
Definately Best Sing Off =) So Much Passion Makes Youu Go All Tingly Lol =S x
Now Sarahs Gonee x Im Behind Jodie && Niamh x
ILoveeYouuOx 3 years ago
and now Niamh's gone as wel :(
SugarKissed 3 years ago 2
I Noo :( x lol its all goin wrongg :( x Now Jodie has to win :D x
ILoveeYouuOx 3 years ago
Have You Noticed That Whoever Sings With The Olivers Is In The Bottom 2?
Sarah & Niamh Sang With Them And Then Went Into The Bottom 2? x
I Think In My Opinion It Was The Right Decision As I Want Rachel To Win...Still Sarah Was Amazing x
Daffy1803x 3 years ago 4
I think Rachel is a lovely person and a very good singer and performer. However I can't helo but think she looks a bit...evil singing this! It's the look in her eyes...
rochdale1 3 years ago 2
Rachel is definately the winner.... Sarah is good... but not a Nancy... more a Mary Poppins!
Conleth1984 3 years ago 5
i think sarah was the best out of these 2, i loved her voice
IJustWanaHaveFun 3 years ago
in sarah's exit interview she said she wanted niamh or samantha to win, and francesca said the same thing! so i think all the fans of sarah and fran should get behind these two girls!!!
spotlighted91 3 years ago
I live in Barcelona and my only experience with the show is through youtube. This girl, Sarah is SO MUCH BETTER than the other one. A truly beautifull voice. I do NOT like the judges: both Dennise and Barrowman have MEDIOCRE voices and they judge with inconsistent criteria...
provenzal 3 years ago
I miss Sarah so much. I wanted to see so much more of her.
Imiana 3 years ago
Its a F**king joke that Sarah went!!! That performance was basily just Sarah kicking Rachels ass so hat the hell happend??!
Alipops 3 years ago
stupid decision .. miss sarah sooo much :'( xxxx
ILoveeYouuOx 3 years ago 3
I loved Sarah!! She was fab, I wanted her or Jodie to win. Can't beieve she went over Rachel, fucking joke
Kagglepop 3 years ago 4
I also agree that Rachel should have gone out of the two - I feel gutted for the Olivers as they obviously liked Sarah...
cdlaing 3 years ago 4
Possibly the best sing-off ever...but I still felt more emotion from Sarah. I miss her so much, she should've made the final!
akasha5 3 years ago 3
I can't help disliking Rachel. She seems to smirk when she's singing....all the time. Sarah shouldn't have gone.
saintmerryweather45 3 years ago
I think this was the best sing-off so far, though Ashley should have had to sing it instead of one of them, that way there would at least have been a chance of her finally going! I think she should have gone in week 4 instead of Francesca. My favourite Nancy is Samantha, and my top 3 Olivers are Chester, Gwion and Kwayedza. They are all great though :) x
Frappucino94 3 years ago 2
My sis & I are a Rachel & Sarah. So, in my mind, I win LOL
Neither of them deserved to leave IMO
AngelskaSings 3 years ago
i have watched this bout 50 times, i love wen rachel sings...'I've Come Home At Last' it is amazing.. rachel lives near me an my mum knows her daddy.. she has been singing with her daddy since she was young an her sister aswell they r jus amazing
belfastfooty 3 years ago 3
OMG this is the performance of the whole series. I'm so sad to see Sarah go. I couldn't believe it when Denise voted her as the one who wouldn't be Nancy. I hope producers were watching her and snap her up for a West End musical.
serenophin 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
septum...yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Ddial 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rachel has such a weird nose...the spetum is so wide....its...just...so....unbelievely....lovely! :D
Ddial 3 years ago
I think this was the performance of the series not Jessie's performance!!!! These two are showing how to perform, i hope the other girls were taking notes!!!!!
singinciaran 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Rachels expression at 2:08-2:09 and 2:28 really bugs me! I just want to slap her, lol .. she is so smug and up herself! Can't believe Sarah has gone, she was fabulous!
LesMisNut 3 years ago
please can people honestly vote for who they think was the best...don't just favour someone e.g cause they're from the isle of man!... this result was ridiculous and i've lost a lot of respect for ALW
xxplumpuddingxx 3 years ago 3
This result was so wrong.
Sam really needs to go IMO. She can't sing and her 'emotion' is simply shouting the words louder, and her personality doesnt even make up for it.
ralphy137 3 years ago 3
thats such a nice song. didnt like sarah but didnt think she deserved to be in the bottom 2 - neither did rachel. when is ashley gonna leave! naimh 2 win
sassysteph1990 3 years ago 4
the bit where rachel sings 'i've come home at last' is stunning and i'm so glad she is still in the competition!
fionnaredhead 3 years ago 3
This song almost brought a tear to my eye, I'd never heard it before, it was just beautiful. Neither of them should've been in the bottom 2. I considered those 2 some of the safest in the competition, this was a shock to me...
HoliHallow 3 years ago 2
rachel is good but her voice is not memroble like sarahs! what was he thinking!
wickedissocool 3 years ago
I completely agree.
Love them both :)
So sad sarah left :(
faker0001 3 years ago
Neither of them should have been in the bottom 2... no offense to the public but they haven't got a clue!!
Beccalola 3 years ago 3
Ashley shoulda deffo been in the bottom two... she really annoys me.
Loving Sam and Rachel and ADORE Jessie and Niamh... really impossible to choose!
I liked Sarah but she didn't really fit the role... she'd be perfect for something a little sweeter... she went really gracefully aswell I think!
rachel1175 3 years ago
I thought they were both pretty amazing, although, if I was in ALW's situation, I'd have made the same decision; because Rachel sang the song the way it is meant to be sung, Sarah didn't really, you could spot her flaws clearly.
Having said that, she SO should not have been in the bottom two.
I want Jessie out. She RUINED The Man That Got Away!!
tiaratickles 3 years ago
Totally Agreed!
doctorwhofanatic18 3 years ago
Sarah was the best here and ALW made a big mistake
craftyapplepie 3 years ago 2
Sarah's voice is so much more powerful.
Although Rachel has her moments.
I'm completely gutted sarah went.
I live in Australia so i can't vote.
WickedHaydie98 3 years ago 3
Best sing off ever I think. Wonderful performances from both girls.
LawrieMarlow 3 years ago 5
i'm still reeling from this result...
i had such a bad day saturday... and this really topped it off. what a waste. sarah should've been around 3rd or 4th... not 7th!
rargh.
rachel to win tho
unidan82 3 years ago 2
neither of these girls deserved 2 go..i like both of them...i dont understand why ashley is still around :S
tezdahasbean 3 years ago 2
Silly man lol ! Why did he save Rachel over Sarah !? I Loved Sarah, she has a brilliant talent, and a stunning personality as well as a beautiful voice, as for Rachel though I admit she is talented, she strikes me as arrogant, and not very nice. But definately the wrong decision here! By the sing off you can hear that Sarah is better! How could he not see that!?
x
ILoveeYouuOx 3 years ago 2
Rachel is really not arrogant at all! She comes across as so bubbly and friendly and definitely does not have a cold expression on her face. she was so shocked that ALW saved her. They were both absolutely amazing in this performance, and if i had to choose between them i would have chosen Rachel, she is solid, just as he said. But im gutted for Sarah and im sure she has a bright future ahead of her!
Rosie6689 3 years ago 5
I must be watching the wrong show then. Rachel is defo not cold. The both of them did not deserve to be in the sing off. The both have amazing voices. I'd like to see some of you get on stage and sing live and see how your nerves are. If ya haven't got anything nice to say about their talent then don't bother saying anything at all, and as for Jessie she has an amazing voice and puts on a great performance. In fact all the girls do. This is going to be one tough winner to pick
cspb 3 years ago 3
Not only was Sarah outstanding in this performance, consiering the panel talked so much about expressions and conveying emotion, Rachel always has the same cold expression on her face - Webber definitely made the wrong decision last night!
broadwaylover125 3 years ago 2
:( gutted to see Sarah go. This was the best sing-off performance any of these shows have ever seen.
Someone needs to hire Sarah for a West End show like... right now. :)
Laurlikesgoats 3 years ago 4
Rachel was the only one I had no strong feelings about either way. I just didn't care about her but I'm completely gutted Sarah went. I thought she was brilliant and I wanted to see more of her.
Imiana